9ҩQÿӅQJKLrQFӭX 3KѭѫQJWKӭc thӵc hiӋn dӵ iQÿѭӧc nhұn thӭc tӯ rҩt sӟPOjJLҧLSKiSFKRPӝt dӵ iQWKjQKF{QJ0ӛLSKѭѫQJWKӭFFyQKӳng lӧi thӃ YjQKѭӧFÿLӇPULrQJ&Kӫ ÿҫXWѭphҧLÿiQKJLiYjÿѭDUDOӵa chӑQSKѭѫQJWK
amp;+ѬѪ1* ĈҺ79Ҩ1Ĉӄ
ĈyQJJySFӫDQJKLrQFӭX
3KiW WULӇQ TXi WUuQK ÿiQK JLi FiF WLrX FKt TXDQ WUӑng cho viӋc lӵa chӑn SKѭѫQJWKӭc thӵc hiӋn dӵ iQ[k\GӵQJGkQGөQJYjF{QJQJKLӋp tҥi ViӋt Nam, tӯ ÿyJL~SQKjÿҫXWѭFyPӝWFiLQKuQWәQJTXiWYӅ FiFYҩQÿӅ cҫQTXDQWkPWUѭӟc khi ra quyӃWÿӏnh lӵa chӑQSKѭѫQJWKӭc triӇn khai dӵ iQ ĈӅ xuҩt mӝWSKѭѫQJSKiSSKkQWtFKÿӏQKOѭӧng hiӋu quҧ, vӟi viӋFÿROѭӡng Yj thӵc hiӋn xӃp hҥQJFiFSKѭѫQJiQKӛ trӧ QKjÿҫXWѭÿѭDUDTX\ӃWÿӏnh mӝWFiFK ViQJVXӕWYjKӧSOê
1.5.2 9͉P̿WK͕FWKX̵W ĈӅ WjLÿmQJKLrQFӭXYj[iFÿӏQKFiFWLrXFKtҧQKKѭӣQJTXiWUuQKTX\ӃWÿӏnh lӵa chӑQSKѭѫQJWKӭc thӵc hiӋn dӵ iQNӃt quҧ Qj\FyWKӇ ÿѭӧc ӭng dөQJOjPQӅn tҧQJSKiWWULӇQYjWuPKLӇu cho tӯng dӵ iQULrQJbiӋt thuӝFOƭQKYӵF[k\GӵQJGkQ dөQJYjF{QJQJKLӋp tҥi ViӋt Nam ĈӅ WjLFyWKӇ ÿѭӧFGQJWKDPNKҧo cho nhӳQJQJKLrQFӭu tiӃQKjQKYӅ sau OLrQTXDQÿӃQFiFSKѭѫQJWKӭc thӵc hiӋn dӵ iQNKLFiFKuQKWKӭc tҥi ViӋt Nam trӣ QrQÿDGҥQJYjSKӭc tҥp.
CЙ trù luН vÊn
HVTH: Trҫn Kim Anh MSHV: 7140090
&KѭѫQJ4X\WUuQKOӵa chӑQSKѭѫQJWKӭc thӵc hiӋn dӵ iQ [k\Gӵng DD&CN tҥi ViӋt Nam
- 3KkQWtFKWKѭYLӋQFiFWLrXFKt - &iFWLrXFKtFӫDTX\WUuQKOӵa chӑn
&KѭѫQJӬng dөQJTX\WUuQKOӵa chӑQSKѭѫQJWKӭc thӵc hiӋn dӵ iQ[k\Gӵng DD&CN tҥi ViӋt Nam
- Ӭng dөQJTX\WUuQKOӵa chӑQYjRFiFGӵ iQWKӵc tӃ
- XӃp hҥQJSKѭѫQJiQYjUDTX\ӃWÿӏnh
- ĈӏQKKѭӟng cҧi tiӃQTX\WUuQK
HVTH: Trҫn Kim Anh MSHV: 7140090
amp;+ѬѪ1* 7Ә1*48$1
T͝ng hͫp s͙ QăPNLQKQJKL͏m cͯDQKyPFKX\rQJLD thͱ 1
Bҧng 3.2 ± T͝ng hͫSWUuQKÿ͡ h͕c v̭n cͯDQKyPFKX\rQJLD thͱ 1
T͝ng hͫp chͱc vͭ cͯDQKyPFKX\rQJLD thͱ 1
HVTH: Trҫn Kim Anh MSHV: 7140090
T͝ng hͫSYDLWUzFͯDQKyPFKX\rQJLDWURQJG iQ thͱ 1
Bҧng 3.5 ± T͝ng hͫp lo̩i ngu͛n v͙n d iQQKyPFKX\rQJLDWKc hi n thͱ 1
Bҧng 3.6 ± T͝ng hͫSTX\P{Y͙n lͣn nh̭WQKyPFKX\rQJLDthͱ 1 ÿmWKc hi n
Bҧng 3.7 ± T͝ng hͫp lo̩LKuQKG iQQKyPFKX\rQJLDthͱ 1 ÿmWKc hi n
LoҥLKuQKGӵ iQ Sӕ Oѭӧng Tӹ lӋ
HVTH: Trҫn Kim Anh MSHV: 7140090
3.3.2.2 7LrXFKt ̫QKK˱ͧQJTX\͇Wÿ͓QKODFK͕QSK˱˯QJWKͱF
MӝWGDQKViFKEDQ ÿҫu bao gӗPFiF WLrXFKt tiӅPQăQJҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃn TXi WUuQK Oӵa chӑQ SKѭѫQJ WKӭc thӵc hiӋn dӵ iQ ÿѭӧc tұp hӧp sau thӡi gian QJKLrQFӭXWRjQGLӋQFiFÿӅ WjLÿmF{QJEӕ OLrQTXDQÿӃn vҩQÿӅ Qj\'DQKViFK FiF WLrX FKt ÿѭӧF SKkQ WtFK Nӻ Oѭӥng nhҵm kӃt hӧp nhӳng WLrX FKt WѭѫQJ Wӵ, chӗng lҳp hoһc WLrXFKt NK{QJSKKӧp vӟi bӕi cҧnh ViӋW1DPYjQKӳng WLrXFKt OLrQ TXDQ ÿӃQ FiF SKѭѫQJ WKӭF NK{QJ ÿѭӧc sӱ dөng tҥi ViӋt Nam +uQK WKӭc phӓng vҩQFKX\rQVkXYӟi tӯQJFKX\rQJLD hoһFQKyPÿӃQFKX\rQJLDWKHR tӯng thӡLÿLӇm BҧQJFiFWLrXFKt ÿѭӧc giҧLWKtFKFKLWLӃt cho tӯng FKX\rQJLD, sau thӡi gian thҧo luұQ Yj [HP [pW QKӳQJ NKtD FҥQK NKiF WҥL QJjQK [k\ Gӵng Qѭӟc ta, bҧng tәng hӧp 35 WLrXFKt ÿѭӧFSKiWWULӇn vӟi 3 WLrXFKt ÿѭӧc bә sung SKKӧp vӟLWuQKKuQKWKӵc tӃ QJjQK[k\Gӵng ViӋW1DPQKѭVDX
(1) Nguӗn vӕQÿӇ ÿҫXWѭ[k\Gӵng dӵ iQ (2) TұSTXiQYjWkPOê
(3) KXQJSKiSOêFKѭDKӛ trӧ SKѭѫQJWKӭc ThiӃt kӃ7KLF{QJ Ĉk\ Oj FiF WLrX FKt ÿһF WK WURQJ ÿLӅu kiӋQ QJjQK [k\ Gӵng ViӋt Nam
7KHRFiFFKX\rQJLDÿӃn thӡLÿLӇm hiӋn tҥi viӋc triӇQNKDLFiFGӵ iQFyYӕQQKj Qѭӟc vүQFzQ NKi SKӭc tҥp do nhiӅXWK{QJWѭYj QJKӏ ÿӏQKEDQ KjQK[HQ Oүn, thұPFKtWkPOêFKӫ ÿҫXWѭVӧ OjPVDLNKLYLӋc thanh tra quyӃWWRiQFiFGӵ iQFy vӕQQJkQViFKQKjQѭӟFYjYӕQQKjQѭӟFQJRjLQJkQViFKYүn FKѭDÿѭӧc hiӇu thӕng nhҩt trong nhiӅu vҩQÿӅĈLӅXQj\ҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃn cҧ KDLSKѭѫQJWKӭc thӵc hiӋQ Oj 7KLӃt kӃĈҩu thҫX7KL F{QJ Yj 7KLӃt kӃ7KL F{QJ QKѭQJ SKѭѫQJ WKӭc ThiӃt kӃ7KLF{QJFyÿӝ rӫLURFDRKѫQQrQWkPOêHGqKѫQ1JRjLUDNKLGӵ iQ Fy QJXӗn vӕQOLrQTXDQÿӃQQKj QѭӟF KD\ OLrQ GRDQK U}UjQJ quyӃWÿӏnh thӵc hiӋn hay chӑn lӵa SKѭѫQJWKӭFOjSKӭc tҥSKѫQQKLӅu so vӟi loҥLKuQKQJXӗn vӕn WѭQKkQYӟi chӍ mӝWKD\KDLQJѭӡi quyӃWÿӏnh
3KѭѫQJWKӭc ThiӃt kӃ7KLF{QJWURQJQKӳQJQăPJҫQÿk\OҥLÿѭӧc nhҳc ÿӃn nhiӅX KѫQ ÿһc biӋW WURQJ QJjQK [k\ GӵQJ GkQ GөQJ G WKӵc chҩW SKѭѫQJ
HVTH: Trҫn Kim Anh MSHV: 7140090 thӭF Qj\ ÿm xuҩt hiӋn Yj ÿѭӧF iS Gөng tӯ OkXTuy vұ\ SKѭѫQJ WKӭc ThiӃt kӃ/Ĉҩu thҫu/7KL F{QJ Yүn chiӃm tӹ trӑng lӟn nhҩW WURQJ QJjQK [k\ Gӵng DD&CN QѭӟFWDĈLӅXQj\GүQÿӃQ³TұSTXiQYjWkPOê´WKHRYQJPLӅQFy thӇ ҧQKKѭӣng khi chӑn lӵDSKѭѫQJWKӭc cho dӵ iQĈk\FKtQKOjWLrXFKt thӭ 2 ÿmÿѭӧFFiFFKX\rQJLDWKӕng nhҩt bә VXQJYjRQKyPFiFWLrXFKt7URQJTXi WUuQKSKӓng vҩQFyPӝt sӕ FKX\rQJLDFzQÿҳQÿRNKLFiFFKX\rQJLDWUѭӟFÿy bә VXQJ WKrP WLrX FKt Qj\ QKѭQJ FXӕL FQJ NKL ÿѭӧc giҧL WKtFK WӍ mӍ nhӳng FKX\rQJLDQj\ÿӗQJêbә VXQJ³TұSTXiQYjWkPOê´
7LrX FKt bә sung cuӕL FQJ Oj³.KXQJ SKiS Oê FKѭD Kӛ trӧ SKѭѫQJ thӭc ThiӃt kӃ/7KLF{QJ´Ĉk\OjWLrXFKt ÿѭӧFFiFFKX\rQJLDQKuQQKұQYjÿӅ nghӏ bә VXQJU}UjQJQKҩW3KѭѫQJWKӭc ThiӃt kӃ/7KLF{QJYӟi bҧn chҩWѭXYLӋt vӕQFyOjWK~Fÿҭ\FiFF{QJWiFGRFyWKӇ chӗng lҳp giӳa thiӃt kӃ vӟLWKLF{QJ hoһc gӕL ÿҫu giӳa thiӃt kӃ hoһc tKL F{QJ WURQJ FiF JLDL ÿRҥn thiӃt kӃ hoһc thi F{QJQKѭQJKLӋn tҥLNKXQJSKiSOêYүQFKѭDKӛ trӧ cho vҩQÿӅ Qj\*ҫQQKѭWҩt cҧ FiFFiFGӵ iQSKҧLÿL theo WUuQKWӵ tӯ quy hoҥch EDQÿҫu ÿӃn ThiӃt KӃ &ѫ6ӣ, ThiӃt KӃ Kӻ Thuұt YjFXӕLFQJThiӃt KӃ Bҧn VӁ Kӻ ThuұW7KL&{QJ.KLFKѭD Fy *Lҩ\ 3KpS ;k\ 'ӵng WKu FKѭD ÿѭӧc triӇQ NKDL WKL F{QJ Yj PXӕQ [LQ ÿѭӧc Giҩ\3KpS;k\'ӵng WKuphҧLKRjQWҩt ThiӃt KӃ Kӻ Thuұt YjWUѭӟFÿyOjThiӃt KӃ &ѫ6ӣ Tuy mӝWYjLÿӏDSKѭѫQJWURQJWӯQJWUѭӡng hӧp cө thӇ FKRSKpSWKL F{QJSKҫn ngҫm sau khi ThiӃt KӃ &ѫ6ӣ ÿѭӧc thҭPÿӏQKYjSKrGX\ӋWQKѭQJYӅ KjQK ODQJ SKiS Oê WKu FKѭD U} UjQJ Yj QKuQ FKXQJ YүQ FKѭD hӛ trӧ tӕL ÿD FKR SKѭѫQJWKӭc ThiӃt kӃ/7KLF{QJ
Bҧng 3.8 ± B̫ng t͝ng hͫp 35 WLrXFKt WiFÿ͡QJÿ͇n la ch͕QSK˱˯QJWKͱc
1 MӭFÿӝ [iFÿӏnh phҥPYLF{QJ viӋc dӵ iQ
Khalil (2002); Mahdi Yj Alreshaid (2005); Oyentunji Yj Anderson (2003);
Zhang Yj Wang (2009); Chen vcs, (2011); Popic vj Moselhi (2014)
HVTH: Trҫn Kim Anh MSHV: 7140090
Bҧng 3.8 ± B̫ng t͝ng hͫp 35 WLrXFKt WiFÿ͡QJÿ͇n la ch͕QSK˱˯QJWKͱc
Khalil (2002); Mahdi Yj Alreshaid (2005); Oyentunji Yj Anderson (2003);
Mafakheri vcs, (2007); Chen vcs, (2011); Zhang Yj Wang (2009); Popic Yj Moselhi (2014)
Khalil (2002); Mahdi Yj Alreshaid (2005); Oyentunji Yj Anderson (2003);
Zhang Yj Wang (2009); Chen vcs,
(2011); Mafakheri vcs, (2007); Qiang vcs, (2015); Popic Yj Moselhi (2014)
4 +uQKWKӭFJLiKӧSÿӗng Khalil (2002); Mahdi Yj Alreshaid
5 1JkQViFKGӵ iQ Khalil (2002); Mahdi Yj Alreshaid
Chen vcs, (2011); Oyentunji Yj Anderson (2003)
7 ChҩWOѭӧQJWKLF{QJ Mahdi Yj Alreshaid (2005); Popic Yj
8 Nguӗn vӕn sӱ dөQJÿӇ ÿҫXWѭ[k\ dӵng dӵ iQ (*)
9 1JX\FѫWKD\ÿәi thiӃt kӃ trong suӕWTXiWUuQKWKLF{QJ Mahdi Yj Alreshaid (2005)
MӭFÿӝ linh hoҥWÿӕi vӟi viӋc thiӃt kӃ lҥLVDXNKLÿmWKӕng nhҩWJLiWKL F{QJ
Mahdi Yj Alreshaid (2005); Chen vcs, (2011); Qiang vcs, (2015); Oyentunji Yj Anderson (2003);
11 7tQKNKҧ WKLYjKLӋu quҧ cӫa thiӃt kӃ WURQJWKLF{QJ Mahdi Yj Alreshaid (2005); Mafakheri vcs, (2007)
12 ChҩWOѭӧng thiӃt kӃ Mahdi Yj Alreshaid (2005); Chen vcs,
13