Những vấn đề lý luận về xã hội hóa trong giáo dục đại học và pháp luật điều chỉnh hoạt động xã hội hóa giáo dục đại học

rmuAmiuiJMi^ NHUTNG VAN DE LY LUAN VE XA HOI HOA TRONG GIAO DUC DAI HOC VA PHAP LUAT DIEU CHINH HOAT DONG XA HOI HOA GIAO DUC DAI HOC Phgm Thi Giang Thu' Nguyen Van Cu' Tdm tdt: Xd hgi hda gido due dgi hgc Id vdn de mdi dgt giai dogn hien nay, vi vay cdn cd nhieu y kien khac ve vdn de ndy, bao gam ca sd thue hien xd hgi hda vd ngi dung phdp lugt vi xd hgi hoa gido due dgi hgc Bdi viet cita tap the tdc gid de cap den ba noi dung chinh: (i) Nhitng vdn de ca bdn ve xa hoi hoa gido due dgi hgc; (ii) Cdc bg phan cdu thdnh phdp lugt vi xd hgi hoa gido due dgi hoe; (lii) Yeu cdu cdn ddm bdo dieu chinh bdng phdp lugt doi vdi hogt dgng xd hgi hda gido due dgi hoc tgi Viet Nam Tit khda: Xd hgi hda, gido due dgi hge, phdp lugt; Viet Nam Nhdn bdi; 28/11/2019; Hodn thdnh bien tap: 03/12/2019; Duyet ddng 19/12/2019 Abstract: Since socialization of higher education is a.new issue set out in the current period, there are different ideas about this issue including units which carry out the socialization and legal issue on the socialization of higher education The groupof authors mention three main contents: (i) Basic issues related to socialization of higher education; (ii) legal components on higher education; (iii) Requirements are needed when the legal adjustment is applied to the socialization of higher education in Vietnam Keywords: Socialization, higher education, law, Vietnam Date ofreeipt: 28/11/2019; Dale of revision: 03/12/2019 Date of approval: 19/12/2019 NhCrng van de cff ban ve xa hoi hoa va xa hoi hda giao due dai hpc Khi ndi den xa hdi hda, ban than nd da ham chiia npi dung mang mdt van de thuge yeu to rieng tu hoac dan nhat van de mang tinh chat cong cdng Nhieu cong trinh da nghien ciiu ve xa hdi bda nbu quan diem cua N K Gontscharov, theo dd, "xa hdi bda la qua trinh ca nhan hda nhap vao xa hgi hay vao mdt cac nbdm cua bp thdng qua qua trinh hpc eac chuan myc timg nhdm va cua xa hgi"' Ve quan diem xa hgi hda giao due dai hgc d Viet Nam, ciing ed y kien cho rang "xa hgi hda giao due la qua trinh ehuyen giao nhiing ngi dung, nhiem vu thuge ITnhvyc giao due ma Nha nude khdng nhat thiet phai lam, phai thyc hien cho ngudi dan va cac td chiic ngoai nha nude thyc hien tren co sd nhiing quy djnh, quy chuan eiia nha nude nham tap hgp nguon luc xa hgi de cung tbue hien myc lieu nang cao chat lugng giao due va xay dung xa hpi hpc ta.p"^ Neu hieu xa hgi hda giao due la nhu v|iy tbi xa hpi hda giao due dai hgc la mdt phan dd Vdi khai niem chung nhu da de cap, cd the chi rang, xa hgi hda la qua trinh hda nhap cua ca nhan, ciia mdt chu the don nhat vao cdng ddng hay nhdm cdng dong Nguge lai, xa ' Pho giao su, Tien sy, Truang Dai hpc Luat Ha Ngi - Thae sy, Van phong Bg Giao due Dao tao ^ Ngu6n: N K Gontscharov, Sowjetskaja pedagogika", Moskau, Nr 4, i 957 (Original title- perspektivnom plane razvitija narodnogo obrazovanija v SSSR na blizajsie 15-20 let) "Utschiteljskajagaseta", Moskau, 2fL April 1957 (Original title:Vsesojuznoe sovescanie rabotnikov skolintematov) " http://tailieu.ttbd.gov.vn:8080/indexphp/tin-tuc/tin-tuc-ho-tro-boi-duong/item/964-quan-diem-ve-xa-hoi-hoagiao-duc-o-viet-nam-hien-nay quan diem vl xS hgi hoa giao due a Viat Nam hien nay, tmy cap 25.10.2019 am ihiJ Mucfi bon hdi hda giao due cung duge hieu la viec cac chii the khac xa hgi dau tu toan dien eho he thdng giao dye dai hge Ndi khae di, xa hgi hda giao due dai hgc cd hai npi dung co ban: - O goc sy tac ddng, hd trg tir cdng ddng ddi vdi boat dgng giao due dai hge, dd la eac bien phap can thiet de dua ngudn lye loan dien vao ITnh vuc giao due dai hgc mot each tich cue va hieu qua - O gde hda nhap cua mgt chii the/nhdm the cu the vao edng dong xa hgi hoac mgt phan eong ddng xa hgi, xa hpi hda giao dye dai bgc la viec thuc hien cac bien phap can thiet de tao va ehuyen giao nhtrng san pham hieu qua, chat lugng tdt San pham cd the la ngudi cd trinh eao hoac cac san pham khoa hpc duge ap dung vao thue te Tir each hieu ve xa hgi bda giao due dai hgc, cd the ebi nhirng dac diem eo ban ve van de nhu sau: Mgt la, xa hgi hda giao due dai hge la hien tuang xa hgi chi xuat hien dieu kien ehinh trj, kinh te nhat djnh Giao dye dai hgc la boat dgng khdng tao san pham dugc dinh gia mgt each tryc tiep, ehinh xac ve gia tri nen kha nang tiiu hdi tii nhiing ehi phi da tra eho boat dpng dao tao duge tinh loan tren nhimg ylu td f^at tridn kinh te xa hdi khac Nhu the cac ylu l6 "dSu tij'' ciing nhu "chi phi dau vao" cua boat dgng dao tao dai bpc Idn nhung lai khdng cd kha nang bii dap dSy du Ph£in bit dap mdt phkn dugc thyc hien tren co sd '"hpc phi" cua ngudi hgc, nhien day ehi la phan nhd tdng nhu cau cho boat dgng dao tao, dieu dd ly giai nhilu cac nha dau tu khdng "man ma" vdi giao due dai hgc Them nua, cung ehinh tu ly "khdng ed kha naiig thu hdi tryc tilp" nen Nha nude la chii thi ehu yeu va thudng xuyen ddu tu cho giao due dai hgc Tat ca eac kit qua dau tu eho giao due dai hgc d cac qudc gia phat triln nbu^Hoa Ky d chau My, Vucmg qudc Anh chau Au hay Singapore d Ddng Nam A, ty le v6n Nha nude dau tu cho giao due ludn ddng vai trd quyet djnh Tuy nhien, ngudn ngan saeh nha nude eang ban hep so vdi nhu cau chi lieu, viec chia se trach nhiem vdi cac chu the cd nang lyc va cd tiem nang xa hgi la dieu phii hgp Ben canh nhu cau chia se traeh nhiem dau tu la nbu eau ly than cua eae ehii the mong muon tham gia vao boat dao tao dai hoc vdi nhieu tu each khac nhau, ma trudc bet la phat huy nang lyc, kinh nghiem cua cae nha khoa hgc, doanh nhan tam huyet va ban than doanh nghiep mudn cd san pham cho chinh ITnh vyc eua minh Nhtmg ket qua "dau ra" cua dao tao dai hgc ndi ehung d ehimg myc nhat djnh chua dap ling dugc nhu eau eua doanh nghiep, vi vay nhdm chit the quyet djnh dao lao cho chinh minh va phuc vu nhu cau xa hdi Hai la xa hgi hda giao dye dai hgc ludn dat gidi ban hay nguong ciia "xa hgi hda", nham hudng tdi CO bdi budng lgi eho cae chii the thy hudng Viee tham gia ciia cae ehii the xa hgi ITnh vyc giao due dai hpc anh hudng den nhieu mye tieu, dd van de muc tieu Igi nhuan hoac van de ganh nang ehi phi cho ngudi hge ludn la ndi dung can dugc dac biet quan tam Mire dp lgi nhuan den dau la cd the ehap nhan dugc, miie chi tra the nao de cd tbi thu but dugc ngudi hgc luon la ndi dung dugc dac biet quan tam Khi muc tieu va yeu ciu cua ehu the dau tu va ngudi hudng Igi khdng dong nhat thi can cd "gidi han" hay "nguong" ma ea hai ben can phai chap nhan Ba la xa hgi hda giao due dai hpc ehi dat nang lyc ciia Nha nude va ciia xa hdi dat yeu cau can sy tiep siic ddng bg va yeu eau ve san phkm giao due dai hgc phye vu dugc nbu cm thilt ylu ciia ca xa hgi ma khdng ehi dap ling eho mpt nhdm chu the nhat dinh, cho dii chu thi dd la cbii the quyen lyc nhu Nha nude cam quyen Giao due dai hge budng tdi viec lao nbii-ng san pht^m ed chat lugng tri thire nhat djnh eho xa hoi Nha nude la ehii the thy hudng ca d gde tryc tiep va gian tiep Dilu ly giai vi Nha nude ludn dau tu cho giao due, nhien lai ludn gap phai trd ngai vl kha nang dku lu Dau tu cho giao due dai hgc ik quan trgng, can cd ngudn vdn tir Nha nude o fcssmzsi ma cu the tir ngan saeh nha nude, nhung ngudn kinh phi cang ban hep so vdi nhu cau su dung Vi vay, viee Nha nude san se trach nhiem dau tu eho eae chu the ed nang lyc tai chinb va ed nhu cau dau tu de tao nhting san pham ed gia trj cho xa hgi la cd the ly giai dugc Bon la, xa hdi hda giao due dai hge ludn gan vdi yeu cau quan ly nha nude, eho dii each thiic va phuong phap quan ly d cae quoe gia cd the la khac De phat trien giao due dai hge diing hudng va thong nhat, pbii bgp vdi chien luge phat trien kinh te xa hpi timg thdi ky, khong trai vdi nhiing nguyen tac ve chinh trj xa hgi ma quoc gia ed ehii quyen dang xay dung, nhat thiet ean tdi sy can thiep tir ca quan nha nude cd tham quyen Tuy nhien, each thirc va mire can thiep cd the khac nhau: bang dudng quan ly hanh ehinh nha nude hoac bang dudng xay dung quan ly gian tiep Cau phap luat dieu chinh hoat dong xa hoi hoa giao due dai hoc Xuat phat tir viee xae djnh ngi ham eua xa hgi bda giao due dai hge, ed the nhan djnh phap luat dieu chinb nhting van de cd lien quan den xa hgi hda giao due dai bgc cd bdn nhdm quy dinh phap luat sau day: Nhdm 1, xac djnh eac thuat ngii phap ly de giai thich duge nhtrng ngi dung ehii yeu hen quan den xa hgi hda giao due dai hge cting nhu eac nguyen tac phap ly can tuan thu qua trinh thuc tbi boat ddng giao dye dai hpc Xa hdi hda giao dye dai hpe thyc te dien d Viet Nam khoang thdi gian chua lau va edn nhieu each bieu khac ve npi dung cita xa hgi bda giao due dai bgc cimg vdi nhiing yeu cau ciia nd Vi vay, can cd each hieu thdng nhat de cd the thye hien day dii, ed hieu qua va dung hudng ITnh vyc Nhiing thuat ngu phap iy duge ghi nhan tai cae van ban phap luat se la co sd de danh gia viec thye thi va tinh tuan thu phap luat Nhom quy dinh phap luat dieu chinh viec tham gia tir cae ehu the ngoai Nha nude vao boat dgng giao due dai hge Nhdm quy djnh cd the bao gdm nhung ndi dung nhu xac dinh loai ehu the cd the tham gia, dieu kien de tham gia, phuang tbirc thye bien hoat dgng dau lu hoac md hinh thye hien, nguyen tac dau tu Day la ITnh vyc quan trpng, thudng dugc quy djnh nhilu van ban phap lual khac ma khdng nhat thiet phai the hien mgt van ban don hanh Nhom 3, quy djnh phap lual dieu chinh boat dgng eua eae co sd dai bgc vdi tu each la mpt chii the eung cap san pbam dae biet cho xa hpi, cd ngudn nhan lyc ehat lugng cao ed kha nang tham gia phuc vu xa hdi cua cac nha khoa hpc Nhdm quy djnh phap luat bao gom: - Quy djnh ve khung chuong trinh dao lao; - Quy djnh ve dieu kien md nganh dao tao mdi; - Quy djnh ve ve tieu chuan dau ddi vdi ngudi hpc cho timg chuang tinh dao tao Nhom 4, quy djnh phap luat xac djnh gidi ban cac each thiic, phuong phap va miic dp xa hgi bda giao due dai hoe Do ea yeu to tham gia cua eac ehu the tham gia vao giao due dai hgc eung nhu yeu cau ddi vdi cac san pham he thdng ea sd dai hpc tao can phai dat lieu chuan nhat djnh; tinh lan tda, anh hudng cua xa hpi bda giao dye dai bgc nen phap luat can phai tien lugng trude gidi ban va dieu kien thyc hien hoat dgng dae biet Nhiing gidi ban cd the bao gdm: gidi han muc lieu tham gia vao boat ddng giao due dai hpc, cac chu the khdng duge phep tham gia, ty le va muc dp tbam gia vao mgt co sd dai hgc hien bun, gidi han viec eung cap cae san pham Nhom 5, quy djnh phap lual ve quan ly va danh gia boat ddng giao due dai bgc nham dam bao boat dgng xa bdi hda duge thuc hien co hieu qua Nhung ijuy djnh cd the bao gom: - Quy djnh ve quan ly nha nude doi vdi hoat dgng xa hgi hda giao due dai hgc; - Quy djnh ve boat dgng tham djnh, danh gia chat luong giao due dai hpc, la co sd de xac dinh chat lugng san pbam ciia xa bdi bda giao due dai bpc; - Quy djnh ve su tham gia eua eac td chirc phi nha nude boat dpng vi mue tieu phi Igi nhuan gan vdi ket qua hoat dpng ciia Id chirc giao due dai hpc; So 7/2019 - Nam \M Mufli bon Oinlic Uunt Yeu cau can dam bao di^u chinh Can ed dai dien phan von sd hiiu ciia Nha bang phap Iuat doi vdi hoat dpng xa hgi hoa nude tai eo sd dai hgc edng lap Dilu giao due dai hoc tai Viet Nam khdng lam mat di nguyen vgng "bd ca quan De thyc bien dugc nhiem vu xa hdi hda chii quan ddi vdi ca sd dai hge cdng lap" giao due dai hge, theo chiing tdi, can quan triet nhung van dam bao yeu cau bao loan vdn Nha nude tai co sd dai bgc eong lap Ngudi dai dien nhan thiie va mgt sd yeu cau sau day: Mgt Id, xdc dinh truang dgi hoc la logi mo phan vdn nha nude khdng ddng nghTa vdi hinh dgc biet (lien quan den vdn de huy dgng ngudi dai dien ea quan quan ly nha nude tai co nguon vd tinh chiu trdch nhiem ve viec sic sd dai hge va khdng lam anh hudng den nhtmg dung, hodn trd nguon vdn) Hien nay, md hinh muc lieu dao lao dugc the bien cac quyet dai hpc hay trudng dai hgc deu xae djnh la djnh cua Hgi ddng Trudng phap nhan day dii Dieu khdng ehi dugc Cd ea cbe lai ehinh thicb hgp de quan ly va quy djnh d Viet Nam ma cdn phd bien tren thye hien ddi vdi nhtrng khoan vdn ma dai hpc pham vi toan eau Cd the dan den eac irudng bay Irudng dai hge nhan dugc dau tu, hay lien eong lap cd chat lugng eao eiia bang California ket, hay cac ngudn tai trg, bay vay cua cac chu nhu Dai hgc California (UC) San Diego, Dai the kinh te khac Ddng thdi vdi viec quy djnh hge California tai Davis, Dai hgc San Jose CO ehe lai chinh la quy djnh trach nhiem eua Stale University^ Tuy nhien, Viet Nam, ddi vdi cac ea nhan ed tham quyen quyet djnh, quan ly eae Dai hge cdng lap hay Trudng dai bgc cdng va sir dung cae ngudn vdn lap, day deu la eae don vi su nghiep ed thu Can cd co che xac djnh "gia trj" ddi vdi co Diem can nhan manb rang, neu quy djnh dai sd dai bgc cac chii the tbam gia vao eae hgc edng lap la don vj sy nghiep, eho dii ed giao djch tin dyng hay lien ket tai ehinh de tbue ngudn thu tai don vj hay khong, tbi eo ehe hien dao tao hoae thyc bien cac boat dgng nhan ngudn lyc tai chinh ttr cae nguon ngoai nghien eiiu khoa hge ma san pham cua qua ngudn "tai chinb cdng" hoan loan khdng dan trinh ed the la hang hda cd gia trj thuong gian Ben canh co che khd khan viec tim mai eao Van de dudng nhu qua thien ve kiem ngudn thu thi viee xae dinh cac loai tai lgi ich kinh te, luy nhien lai la nhirng yeu td san va su dyng nguon lai chinh ngoai ngan quan trpng co sd dai hge cd nhu cau thiet saeh ludn cd ap lyc ve dieu kien chi ngat ngheo lap quan he vay vdn tai td cbiic tin dung hoac giao ket cac boat ddng nghien eim khoa hpc cd hon so vdi cac ehu the la doanh nghiep Van de tiep theo can giai quyet, la md phan chia ket qua boat ddng Hinh anh cua cac hinh dac biet d day can dugc hieu the nao cho CO sd dai hpe ed uy tin, ed chat lugng ve giao dung Chung tdi cho rang, tinh dac biet ciia md due va san pham cua giao due khdng khae gi so hinh gan vdi yeu eau xa hgi bda (la chii de vdi hinh anh nhan dien cua cac doanh nghiep chinh dugc dl cap bai viet nay) duoi goc ed uy tin thyc hien cac giao dieh thuong mai hay phi thuang mai kinh tl tai chinh, vi the, eo mdt yeu to can Can cd sy luong ddng ve phan bd Igi ich tao eho cac dai hge hay trudng dai hge: can coi loai ehu Ihl la doanh nghiep tai chinh (neu cd) ddi vdi ngudn vdn ty buy cd quyen tao lap vdn va sir dung vdn Nhu vay dgng, lien kel so vdi cac ca sd dai hpc tu thuc nlu dl xudt dugc cbSp thuan, vi quy djnh hoae dai hge ed ngudn vdn dau tu nude ngoai tai loai van ban i)hap luat cy the nao se edn tilp Chi cd sy tuong ddng nhu the mdi tao ddng lue duge can nhie tinh loan Tuy nhien, chung lyc va linh cdng bang tuong ddi giiia cac ca sd tdi nhan djnh viec quy djnh tai Luat doanh dai bpc cung mue tieu giao due dao tao tren lanh thd Viet Nam nghiep khdng phai la sy lua chgn • fiao cao dot c6ng tac Lien bang Hoa Ky ctia Doan cong tac ciia Truong Dai hgc Luat Ha Ngi 8.20J9 vg he th6ng III ^,x- truong dai hgc cong lap tao Bang California I.IJI1IJ)IJIIJ!MA Can tao ca che sir dung htiu ieh nhat ngudn nhan luc ciia eae ca sd dai hge ben eanh viee nang eao yeu cau ve tieu chuan "dau ra" cua dai hgc hay trudng dai hgc cdng lap Co ehe sir dung biiu ieh ngudn lyc tao cho co sd dai hge ndi ehung va dai hge edng lap ndi rieng eo hdi cdng hien va trao eho xa hgi nhting san pbam cd gia trj cao, dong thdi don vi dao tao va ngudn nhan lye eiia cac don vj ciing tiep can nhanh chdng, chinb xac va thu lai lgi ieh vat chat, lgi ieh phi vat ehat tir qua trinh eung cap san pham Hai Id, iri ho trg tdi chinh tic Ngdn sdch Nhd nude vd cdc hd trg khde tic Nhd nuac Can khang djnh viee tiep tyc hd trg tai chinb tu ngan saeh (thdng qua che chi dau tu theo Luat ngan saeh nha nude hoac giao vdn theo Luat quan ly va sii dung vdn nha nude, chi hd trg cd muc tieu tir ngan saeh trung uong eho ngan saeh dja phuong, chi dau lu ciia eae bp nganh cho eae ITnh vue giao due dai hge ma bg nganh quan ly Bat ky quoe gia nao eiing hudng den dau tu eho giao due, dd cd giao due dai hgc Paul T.Hill cudn "So luge ve cac trudng hpe Hoa Ky" Terry M.Moe ehii bien da nhan djnh rang "Giao due cdng la mpt dieu gi dd sau xa, mgt cam ket lau dai cua nude My vdi viec giao due tre em bang bat eu phuong tien hieu qua nao" Vi the nhtrng van de lien quan den "ke hoach ngan saeh ro rang, tinh vien ehiie eiia cae giao vien, bay sy doe quyen eiia chinh quyen" eiing duge de cap tdi*^ Vdi lap luan nay, eac qudc gia dac biet coi trgng giao due dai hgc da ed nhtmg quan diem cu the ve dau tu eho giao due dai bgc Tai Hoa Ky, Chinh phii Hoa Ky cung cap lai chinh cho ca dai hgc cdng va tu' Ngan saeh ciia ehinh quyen lien bang dd vao giao due dai hpe chu yeu la de bd trg tai chinh cho eac sinh vien xuat sae Ngan saeh bang ehu yeu vao viec van hanh boat dgng eua trudng dai hgc (lien lucmg, quan tri, mua sam eua dai hgc) Vdi Australia, Chinh phii Uc cd trach nhiem chinb viee tai trg cho giao dye dai hgc Chinb phu Uc tai trg kinh phi eho giao due dai hgc thdng qua eae chuang trinh: chuang trinh trg cap cua Chinb pbii Lien bang cho mpt sd lugng nhat dinh hang nam; chuang trinh cho vay va hd trg tai chinb cho sinh vien; cac ehyong trinh hpe bdng cua Nha nude; va cac khoan tai tro eho cae myc dich cu the bao gdm chat lugng, hpc tap va giang day, nghien ciiu va eac chuong trinh dao tao nghien eiru Bo Giao due va Dao tao cd trach nhiem quan ly khoan tai trg nham thiic day va phat trien giao due dai hgc Hoac ddi vdi Lien bang Diic He thdng giao dye dai hgc eua Dire dugc Nha nude bao cap, sinh vien di hgc chi ddng mgt phan hgc phi rat thap, ke ca sinh vien nude ngoai Chinh phii lien bang ddng mdt vai trd rat ban che viec quan ly va phat trien giao due Chinh phu eae bang quyet djnh chinh saeh phat trien giao dye theo each thiic rieng Vdi nude chau A nhu Nhat Ban thi ea cau tai chinh cho giao due dai hge cdng (trimg uong va dja phuang) bao gdm khoang cap ttr ngan sacb nha nude theo hinh thiie trpn gdi Nhu the, cd the ehi rang, viec dau tu cho giao dye dai hgc la yeu cau thiet yeu de xay dyng ngudn nhan lue cho moi quoe gia, luon phan bo nguon kinh phi dang ke eho dau lit giao due ndi ehung va dau lu eho giao due dai hge ndi rieng Ddi vdi Viet Nam, quan diem ve dau tir eho giao dye dai hgc tir phia Nha nude da la truyen thdng ngan ddi Vi du lieu bieu nhat co the ehi ehinh la sy ddi cua dai hgc dau tien eua nha nude phong kien Van MieuQuoc Tir Giam Ben canh dd, viec tri hoat dgng cae trudng dai hgc da lap tir truoc 1945 d miln Bac (nhu dai hge Y Ha Ngi, Dai bgc Duge, D a i h p c M y tbual ) va trudc 1975 d miln trung va mien Nam (nhu Vien Dai bpc Sai Gdn), lap nhieu trudng Dai hoc cdng lap cd uy lin Viee tri boat dgng ciia cae Irudng dai bpc cdng lap chilm ty trpng * Sa luge ve cac truong hgc Hoa Ky, Terry M Moe chii bien, Nxb chinh trj quoc g ' Higher education act of 1965 So 7/201 y - Nam ihil MifSi bon kinh phi nhat djnh long chi ngan saeh tao quyen binh dang khong cd nghTa Nha nha nude, nhung luon la ngudn tai ehinh nude xda bd mgi rao can ddi vdi cac chu the ed khdng the thieu cho diu tu phat triln ngudn the tham gia giao due dai hge, nhung dd phai la nhan Iue^ Ben canh sy hd trg bang nguon nhung rao can ehung, ap dung cho rat ea eac md kinh phi, Nha nude ed the ho trg bang nhilu binh giao due dai hgc ma khdng phai la nhting ngudn khac ma chi Nha nude mdi cd nang lyc rao can lien quan den van de sd hiiu thue hien nhu eo hdi dugc sir dung d§t hay Tren day la mgt sd y kien ban dau eiia thue dat ehiing tdi gan vdi ehu de ly luan ve xa hgi hda Ba Id ddm bdo quyen binh ddng vieetrong giao due dai hpe va phap luat dieu ehinh tiep can ngudn xd hgi hda cua ldt cd cdc ca sd boat dgng xa hgi hda giao due dai hgc, xin chia dgi hgc Neu xac djnh xa hgi hda giao dye dai se eiing ban dgc./ hpc la sy ehia se eiia cac chii the phi nha nude TAI LIEU THAM KHAO boat ddng giao dye dai hge Ihi yeu cau So luge ve cac trudng hge Hoa Ky, Terry binh dang ve co hditiepcan cac nguon luc cung M.Moe ehu bien, Nha xuat ban chinh tri qudc nhu ca hgi thyc hien eac boat dgng dao tao ciia gia 2005, trang 428 tat ca cac chu the cd nhu cau la can thiet Viec Higher education act of 1965 ' Xem Quyet toan Ngan saeh Nha nuPc 2001-2017, phan chi cho giao due (bao gom ca chi thuang xuyen va chi dau tu phat trien) Nguon: https://mof.gov vn/webcenter/portal/btc/r/lvtc/slnsnn/sltn/quyettoan''_afrLoop=8521459 2679232437#!%40%40%3F_afrLoop%3D852[4592679232437%26centerWidth%3D100%2525%261eftWidth% 3DO%2525%26rightWidth%3DO%2525%26showFooteryo3Dfalse%26showHeader%3Dfalse%26_adf.ctrl-state% 3D7c38ypiy_i55,truy cap 20.11.2019 MOT SO KHO KHAN, VUdNG MAC CUA PHAP LUAT VE HOAN THI HANH QUYET DjNH PHAT T I I N , GIAM, M I I N T I I N PHAT VI PHAM HANH CHINH VA DE XUAT, KIEN NGH| (Tiep theo trang 59) Theo dd, cac Bd, nganh, dia phuang theo hien cdc gidi phdp ndng cao hieu qud thi hdnh chiic nang, nhiem vy duge giao kjp thdi phan phdp ludt vd hodn thien he thong phdp litgt''''-^ Thir tu; tang cudng, nang cao ehat lugng, anh, kien nghj phat hien eac quy djnh ve XLVPHC ed ndi dung ehua ro, khd hieu, khong hieu qua cdng lae lap huan, bdi dudng ve kha thi, khdng phii hgp vdi thye lien hoae chong XLVPHC, theo do, tap trung tap huan, bdi dudng cheo, mau thuan de ea quan, ngudi ed tham ve nhiing ky nang chuyen sau ve XLVPHC quyen nghien cim, xir ly theo quy djnh " neu (trong dd cd ngi dung ve hoan thi hanh quyet phdt hien cdc quy dinh ve XLVPHC khong khddinh phat lien, giam, mien lien phat), bao dam thi khong phii hgp vdi thuc tien hoae ehdng tinh ehinh xac, thong nhat hudng dan ap cheo, mdu thuan thi kien nghi ca quan ehii tri dung phap luat va ap dung phap luat eua sogn thao hoac Bg Tu phdp de nghien cicu, xicCO quan, ngudi ed tham quyen, tranb mdt quy ly"^^, hudng den muc dich "nhdm xem xet, ddnhdjnh dan din nliieu each iiieu va ap dung phap luat khac nhau./ gid thuc trgng thi hdnh phdp ludt, kien nghi thuc ^^ Xem khoan Di^u 30 Nghi dinh s6 81/2013/ND-CP 19/7/2013 ciia Chinh phu quy dinh chi tiet mpt so dieu va bien phap thi hanh Luat XLVPHC (dugc siia d6i, b6 sung bai Nghi djnh s6 97/2017/ND-CP 18/8/2017) ^' Xem: DiSu Nghj dinh s6 59/2012/ND-CP 23/7/2012 ciia Chinh phu vg theo doi tinh hinh thi hanh phap luat  ... eiia thue dat ehiing tdi gan vdi ehu de ly luan ve xa hgi hda Ba Id ddm bdo quyen binh ddng vieetrong giao due dai hpe va phap luat dieu ehinh tiep can ngudn xd hgi hda cua ldt cd cdc ca sd boat... ngudi ed tham ve nhiing ky nang chuyen sau ve XLVPHC quyen nghien cim, xir ly theo quy djnh " neu (trong dd cd ngi dung ve hoan thi hanh quyet phdt hien cdc quy dinh ve XLVPHC khong khddinh phat