B NGHIEN ClifU TRAO DOI DOI mdi C0 che quan ly tai ciiinii de thiic ddy va nang cao chat lugng nghien ciiu khoa hoc cua cac trudng dai lioc cOng ldp ThS TRAN PITC CAN TrUdng Dgi hgc Kinh te Ky thudt C[.]
B NGHIEN ClifU TRAO DOI DOI mdi C0 che quan ly tai ciiinii de thiic ddy va nang cao chat lugng nghien ciiu khoa hoc cua cac trudng dai lioc cOng ldp sinh viln tham gia NCKH eua cic trfldng khdi kinh te, QTKD binh TrUdng Dgi hgc Kinh te Ky thudt quin dat 5,64%; sd Iflpng cdng Cong nghiip trinh NCKH cua sinh viln giai doan 2006 2009 li 15.192, Thi/c tr^ng ve ho^t d f n g binh quan hing nam tang 36% NCKH cua cac tru'dng d^i Nim 1990 cd 18 trfldng vdi 62 cdng hpc cong If p Irinh dfl thi, din nam 2009 da c6 1.1 Kit qud: 107 trfldng vdi 631 edng trinh dfl Theo sd li|u khio sit, cic thi [7) trfldng dai hpc trflc thudc Bp Giio 1.2 Mdt so bdt cdp: dye vi Dio tao giai doan 2001Tiiu chi xlp hang, danh gia 2009, da ddng gdp nhilu cho sfl ning lfle khoa hpc cua mpt quoc nghiip khoa hpe vi phit tril'n cdng gia, eua mpt trfldng dai hpc dfldc nghl cua dit nflde, bao gdm: can efl trin sd Ifldng edng bd quoc Mgt Id, da tham gia nghiin t l vi sd trich dan khoa hpc eua cflu 1.060 nhilm vu elp nhi nflde, qude gia, cua trfldng dai hpc dd bao gdm 91 dl tii hdp tic thed Thfle tien cho thiy, sd cdng trinh Nghj djnh thfl; 89 nhilm vu thudc cdng bd, trich dan cua cac trfldng chfldng trinh trpng diem qudc gia; dai hpe cdng lap nflde ta cdn it vi 08 dl tii thudc chfldng trinh trpng dang chfla dflng nhilu bit cap ve diem giao cho cie Bd, nginh; 804 chit Iflpng: chfldng trinh nghiin cflu cd bin; Mgt Id, cic kit qua NCKH cdn 20 de tii thudc chfldng trinh khoa ngheo nin, il bii dflpc dang tai trin hpe xa hdi vi nhin vin; 38 d l tii vi eic tap ehi ed uy tin cua qudc te 10 dfl in dpc lip elp nhi nflde Da Thi du, hai Dai hpc qudc gia li ky kit dfldc hdn 10.250 hpp ddng trung tam dio tao ldn nhat eua ei sin xult kinh doanh vi ehuyen nflde, ndi cd nhieu cdng trinh khoa giao cdng ngh| vdi cac dja phfldng, hpc dflpc cdng bd, nhflng so vdi cac cic cd sd sin xult [7] trfldng dai hpc khu vfle Hai Id, cd 2.183 cdng trinh rit khiem tdn NCKH dflpc cdng bd trin eic tap Hai Id, cic cdng trinh dfldc cdng bd quoc tl, da sd cdn dfla Bang 1: So hiffng de tai khoa hoc cdng nghl da thfle hiin vio sfl hpp tie, tham gia dia nflde cua 11 trfldng dai hpc khoi kinh tl, QTKD giai doan 2006 - 2010 ngoii Chi khoang 33% cdng trinh ndi lfle tao ra, dd d N9m TT Ten tjii li^u dir^rc cdng bo TSng Thai Lan la 65%; Malaysia: 75% vi 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Trung Quoc: 80% Cic cdng bd De tai cap nha nirdc 10 38 npi Iflc tao chu yeu thudc nhflng nganh nghiin cflu khdng ein dau 148 164 De tai cap Bp 159 182 152 805 tfl ve ed sd vat chat, nhfl Toan va 1.209 294 327 229 187 De tai cap ca sa 172 Vat ly ly thuyet cac nflde khac 34 De tai hpp tac quoc te 13 thi ngfldc lai Thi du, Dai hpc Chulalongkom cac cdng bo qudc te 2.086 496 486 352 411 341 Tong cpng ndi lfle tao thfldng gan vdi Hnh Nguon: Bdo cdo tong kit hogt dpng khoa hgc vd cong nghi giai dogn 2006-2010 vd dinh vfle cdng nghl, y dfl(?c ThS TRAN PITC CAN chi qudc tl v.i hdn 5.000 edng Irinh dflpc dang Iren cae lap ehi chuyin nginh nflde [7] Dien hinh, Irong 10 nam, Dai hpc Qude gia Hi Npi da cdng bd dflpc 86 bii bio va 180 bai tham luan lai cic hoi Ihao qudc te, dang 42 bii trin tap chi khoa hpc va 124 bii tham luin tai eac hpi thio nflde [2] 11 trfldng dai hpe klidi kinh tl, quin irj kinh doanh (QTKD) giai doan 2006-2010 da edng bd 6.358 In pha'm; gdm 07 sich, 325 bai dang trin tap chi vi ky ylu hpi thio qude tl; 5.495 bii ding trin lap chi khoa hpe vi ky ylu hdi thio nflde; xult bin 531 giio trinh, bii giing vi sich tham khio, chuyin khio ILifle hien 38 dl tii clp nhi nflde; 805 dl tii elp Bp; 1.209 d l tii clp ed sd vi 34 dl lai hdp tic qude le Vdi tdng kinh phi dau lfl li 127.612 trilu ddng [8, tr.i2] Ba Id, eae NCKH, da sd deu gin vdi hoat dpng dio tao cua nhi trfldng, die bilt li dio tao tien si (nhilu luan an gin vdi dl lii khoa hpc eae elp) NCKH da dflpc trien khai tdi sinh viln vdi qui md, chit Iflpng ngiy eing tang (nam sau eao hdn nam trflde) Thf dy, ty le hudng phdt trien nam 2011-2015 ciia cdc trudng DH khSi kinh ti QTKD [8, tr.7] 20 C6NG N G H I £ P » Ky 1, thing 03/2012 -Website: ww.tapchicongnghiep.vn fmm TRAODAI trii Thi du, kinh phi ehi eho NCKH eua nhilu trfldng dai hpe khdi kinh te, QTKD ehi dat vii ty ddng/nam, TT Ten truang D?ii hpc So bii viet Quoc gia so vdi cie trfldng dai hpe trin thi D^ii hpc Qu6c gia Vi?t Nam (Ha Npi 52 Vi?t Nam gidi li qui nhd, nhfl Dai hpc Bie va ph6 HCM) CaroHna 350 trilu USD/nam; Dai Dai hpc Tong hpp Philippines 220 Philippines hpe Texas 300 trilu USD/nam [3] 504 Dai hpc Tong hpp Malaya Malaysia Do kinh phi it nen hau nhfl cac dl tii deu khdng mdi, khdng thul cic 822 D^i hpc Tong hpp Chulalongkom Thii Lan chuyin gia, nhi khoa hpc nflde 950 Thdi Lan Dai hpc Tong hpp Mahidol ngoii eung thfle hien Trung Quoc 2.343 D^i hpc Tong hpp Phiic Dan Hai Id, Nhi nflde chfla ed cd chl tii chinh riing Cy the, cd chl 3.219 Trung Quoc D^i hpc Tong hpp Bac Kinh phan bd ngin sach khdng cd phan 3.598 Singapore D?i hpc Tong hpp Quoc gia Singapore chi trflc tilp eho nhilm vu NCKH 5.060 Han Qutk D^i hpc Tong hpp Quoc gia Seoul cua cie trfldng, dd, phan NSNN ehi cho NCKH thdng qua Nguon: Science Citation Index Expanded, Thomson Reuters [!} cic Bp, nginh ehu quin boat ddng Ba Id, kit qui nghiin cflu cua lap Quy phit tril'n khoa hpe vi theo cd chl canh tranh cdn nhd vl nhilu trfldng chfla ed sfle hip cdng nghl qude gia (nam 2003, qui md, han chl ve pham vi vi Hnh dan ddi vdi ngfldi sfl dung, nhit li Chinh phu da cho phep thinh lap vfle nghiin cflu Mat khic, Nhi nflde cung doanh nghi|p Ngudn thu tfl boat Quy, nhflng din nam 2008, Quy chfla tao sfl tfl chu vl quyIn ddng NCKH cua cic trfldng rit niy mdi dfldc mit) Vi mai den thip, chfla dat tiiu chi qui djnh ngiy 05/8/2011, Thu tfldng Chinh sd hflu, quyIn sfl dung ddi vdi eua Chinh phu li ngudn thu tfl cic phu mdi cd Quylt djnh thinh lap eac tii sin tri tul ed ngudn gdc quy ddi mdi cdng nghl qude gia d l tfl ngin sich nha nflde giing hoat ddng khoa hpc edng nghl, sin xult dich vu dat tdi thieu 15% tong thfle hi|n cie hinh thfle bio lanh, viln li tie gii eua kit qui nghiin ngudn thu cua cic trfldng vao nam hd trp lai suit, cho vay flu dai Thfle cflu Dan tdi thu nhap cua giing t l nhilu trfldng dai hpc chfla dflpc viln cdn thip, khdng du sdng de 2010 vi 25% vio nam 2020 lim NCKH mdt cich trung thfle tilp can eac quy trin Nguyen nhan cua cac Mfldi nam qua (2001 2010), v i hilu qui, nhilu giing viln lim bat cap mflc dau tfl cho khoa hpe vi cdng NCKH ehi de du nhilm vu hole Mdt Id, ca chi quin ly vi thfle nghe hing nam cua nflde ta ehi de ed kinh phi hoat ddng thi chinh sich cua Nha nflde, eua dat 2% tdng ehi ngin sich (tfldng Ba Id, chfla ed sfl phin loai cie trfldng dai hpc edng lap chfla dfldng 0,3 - 0,5% GDP) [4], dl tii vi vile lap dfl toin chfla ed flu tiin vl tii ehinh eho hoat ddng dd, nam 2010, mflc diu tfl cua khoin tiin chi eho kil'm tra, kiem NCKH Nd dflpc the hien: Trung Qude li 2,2% GDP; Hin soit, xult bin, edng bd vi dfla cdng trinh vio sfl dung Lam eho cic - Cic trfldng dai hpe li ndi tap Qudc 114,5% [6] kit qui nghiin cflu khdng dflpc trung sd Ifldng ldn cin bd khoa hpc cic trfldng dai hpe, nhilu edng bd, khdng dfldc flng dung vio trinh dp eao, nhflng dfldc giao biln trfldng chfla nhin nhan vi coi trpng chl NCKH rit it, ehi mang tinh dflng mflc nhi|m vy NCKH, dan thfle tien chit kilm nhilm Bdn Id, che dp nghiim thu, chi tdi sfl phan bd thdi gian, kinh phi Cham tre vile eho hoat ddng NCKH cdn it vi din tiiu vi thu tue tam flng, quylt toin kinh phi de tii sfl dung Bang 3: Mflc chi binh quan cho de tai NCKH cua 11 trfldng dai hoc vdn ngin sich cdn phfle tap, nang khoi kinh tl, QTKD giai doan 2006 - 2010 vl thu tue hinh ehinh, khdng tinh din hi|u qui, him Ifldng khoa Mii-c chi binh quin (trifu ddng) TT Loai de tki hpc Thi du, mdt chuyin dl gii tri 12 trilu ddng, ylu eau phii viit 35 5,2 D l tai cap co sd trang, cd chfl 14 [10] hole thdi gian 46,6 De tai cap Bp lim chflng tfl quylt toan dii vi mit rit nhilu cdng sfle 548,0 D l tii clp iiiha nudc Ndm Id, hiu hit cic trfldng 3.127,6 D l tai hpp tac qudc ti chfla thinh lap riing quy phit trien NCKH Dan tdi mflc ehi eho cic NguSn: Tdc gid tutlnh todn theo cdc so lieu bdo cdo cua 11 trudng dgi hgc kinh te, QTKD de tii thap, hoat ddng NCKH chfla Bang 2: So sanh so Ifldng bai viet dfldc xuat ban tren tap chi khoa hoc cua dai hoc quoc gia Viet Nam nam 2007 [8,tr.8,12] Website: ww.tapchicongnghiep.vn ã Ky 1, thang 03/2012 ô C N G N G H I £ P 21 UNGHIENCUHI TRAO Bdi chu ddng Dpi ngu giing viln cic trfldng mdi dflpc thinh lap, nang clp cdn thieu tinh cd bin, linh cap nhat, tinh ddng bp va da ,sd chfla hii'u, chfla dfldc liep can v(Vi cac cdng trinh NCKH Nliicu giing vien chfla co ed hdi eung lam vice vdi cie chuyen gia, nha khoa hpc ed kinh nghiem de hpc hdi phfldng phip va kinh nghi|m nghien cuu, nin cic kel qui nghien cflu cdn thien ve djnh tinh hdn la djnh Iflpng Do vay, gap rat nhieu khd khan viec cdng bo cdng Irinh nghiin cflu tren cic tap chi khoa hpc uy tin va ngoii nflde Cac giai phap 3.1 Nhom gidi phdp ddi vdi Nhd nUdc, cdc bg, ttgdnh lien quan Hoat ddng NCKH cua cic trfldng dai hpc edng lap dflpc tri vi nlng eao chit Iflpng cP chl quan ly tii chinh cua Nha nflde, eua cie bd, nginh Iiln quan dflpc ddi mdi vi giii quylt tri|t dl cie vin dl sau: Mgt Id, nlng mflc ehi eho nhilm vy NCKH vi cd chl phin bd ngin sich, nin cd riing mdt phin kinh phi clp trflc tilp eho eic trfldng gidng nhfl vile elp kinh phi ehi hoat ddng thfldng xuyin Cd chl niy, nham xic djnh rd nhilm vy eua cac trfldng vi|c ddng gdp eho qui trinh phit trien kinh tl - xa hpi eua dit nflde Ddng thdi bit bude cic trfldng phii thfle hi|n vi day manh boat dpng NCKH ddng hinh vdi hoat dpng dio tao Hai Id, Lull Thul, Nhi nflde nin qui dinh bit bupc cic doanh nghi|p phii trich tdi thieu 10% ldi nhuan trflde thul d l diu tfl ddi mdi cdng nghl, nham trinh rui ro eho cic doanh nghiip mdi trfldng khoa hpe cdng nghl ludn thay ddi Ddng thdi eiing nham tao thi trfldng khoa hpe edng ngh| de cac trfldng dai hpc cd ed hdi tham gia vi nlng eao chat Iflgfng NCKH cua minh Ba Id, Nhi nflde nin giao quyIn tfl ehu vi tang lpi ich cho giang viln Cu the li, eae tai san tri tul cd ngudn gdc tfl ngan sach ma giang 22 CONG N G H I | P » Ky 1, thing 03/2012 vien la lac gia cua kit qui nghiin cflu thi Nhi luidc cho phep giing viln di/p'c quyen dem tai san tri l u | tie c'liuyl'n nhflpng hoic gdp vdn vio iloanh nghiep trin cd sd cd Id Irinh ho.in vdn dau lfl ban diu cho Nhi nflde Sau hoin vdn thi giang vien dflpc hfldng loin bo lpi nhuan thu dflpc tfl kit qua nghien cflu [6, lr.50] Bon Id, day manh viec tuyIn chpn cic lii theo nguyin tic canh tranh vi thfle hien cd che khoin quin ly, chi lieu cua cic de tii Bdi vi, san pha'm dau li thudc hieu qua quan trpng nhal cua cdng trinh khoa hpc Do dd, eic de lii nen thfle hien theo ed chl ky hpp ddng thda thuan, Nhi nflde flng lien trflde de mua sin pham khoa hpc, khdng ddi hdi phii lim dung nhfl dfl toin da lap Cd cic mflc phat cung nhfl thu hdi vdn diu tfl vdi nhflng trfldng hpp khdng hoin thinh hoac sin pham dit hing khdng dat ylu cau Vile thfle hi|n cd chl khoin se lim eho cic giing viln khdng bi gd bd chay theo chflng tfl vi dfl toin chi tilt mi giinh thdi gian, cdng sfle vi tri tul cho vile nang cao chat Iflpng, kit qui nghiin cflu eua de tai Ndm Id, ddi mdi cd chl lip dfl toin eua cic Ai tii nghiin cflu Cin cd sfl phin loai vile lip dfl toin eua cic dl tii Cy the, cic At lii nghiin cflu ly thuyet, huy ddng chit xim li chu ylu thi dfl toin khdng cin ed phan dfl phdng Cdn cic dl tii Iiln quan din diiu tra, khio sit hay thi nghi|m, thfle hinh thi dfl toin can dflpc ehia thinh phin li cie khoan ehi va khoan dfl phdng [5, tr.38] Khoan dfl phdng dfla nhim dim bio eho cic thi nghiim, thfle hanh eua dl tii dflpc thfle hien dly du, nghiim tue ke ca thj trfldng ed biln dpng vl gii Trong dfl toin, ein bd tri khoin tiin ehi eho kil'm tra, kiem soat, xuat bin, cdng bd, dfla edng trinh vio flng dung Vile edng khai bo tri phin kinh phi se nang eao chat Ifldng hoat ddng cua eic Hdi ddng kiem tra, kilm soat va Hpi ddng nghi|m thu Budc ed quan quan ly phii cd trich nhi|m hdn ddi vdi npi dung, tiin dp vi chit Ifldng eua kit qui nghiin cflu da giao cho chu nhi|m dl lii Ngoii ra, nd edn gdp phan nang cao trich nhiem cung nhfl giim bdt khd khin cho chu nhi|m de tii vile edng bd kit qua nghiin cflu trin cic tap chi nflde vi qude tl Bdi vi, vile dang bii d mdt sd tap chi chuyin nganh cd uy tin qude tiddi hdi phii ddng phi Trfldng hpp de tii khdng dang bii trin eic tap ehi qui djnh thi khoin lien niy se bj thu hdi Siu li, Nhi nflde cin thfle hien ehinh sich md cfla hdn nfla, cho phep cie trfldng vay tiin tfl nflde ngoii cho boat dpng NCKH khdng lien quan den eic vin dl nhay cam vl xa hdi, ehinh trj, tdn giio hayed him chfla bi mat qudc gia theo cd chl ban dau ed bio lanh cua Nhi nflde, sau mdt thdi gian se thfle hien theo cd che tfl ehu tii ehinh, vay tiin theo kieu thfldng mai 3.2 Nhom gidi phdp dot vdi cac trUdng dgi hgc cdng l&p Y)i thu hflt vi hap dan giang viln tieh cfle tham gia NCKH thi cd chl quin Iy, quan ly tii chinh cua eic trfldng phai ddi mdi theo cie hfldng sau: Mot Id, xie djnh rd nhilm vu NCKH li trich nhilm, nghia vu bit bupc ddi vdi giang viln Giam bdt tinh trang qui tai vl giang day eua giang viln Gin nhi|m vu giang day vdi NCKH Kiln quylt khdng thfle hi|n phip chuyen ddi liy khdi Iflpng giang day bu trfl cho khoi Iflpng NCKH khdng hoan thinh, cdn thieu eua giang viln Hai Id, tang cfldng dfla sinh viln, hpc vien, nghiin cflu sinh cung tham gia, thfle hien eac de tai NCKH bang each tinh he sd de flu tiin ve kinh phi thfle hien Ba Id, cae trfldng can lap riing quy phat triln khoa hpc cdng nghl vi gianh mpt khoan kinh phi hing nam de to chfle cac ldp boi dfldng, dio tao ve NCKH cho giang viln, dac bilt la cac giang A^ln tre Lfla chpn va tap trung kinh phi cho mpt vai Ai tai de mdi cac chuyin -Website: ww.tapchicongnghiep.vn lIMIINII^iil TRAO Ddi gia ed kinh nghiim eung thfle hien, nham tao dieu kiln cho giing viln cd ep hdi cung lam vile, giao Iflu, hpe hdi, tieh luy kinh nghiim NCKH mdt cich bii bin, cd h i thdng, dim bio tinh chuyin nghiip, cd nang hdi nhap qudc tl Bon Id, cic trfldng cin nlng dan ty trpng phin bd ngudn thu sfl nghiip, thu khic cho nhilm vu NCKH Day manh sfl Iiln kit vdi cic doanh nghi|p ldn Vi, chi nhflng doanh nghiip niy mdi cd nang diu tfl eho nghiin cflu phit tril'n Do vay, cie trfldng ein thfldng mai hda dflpc cic an pham, edng trinh nghiin cflu; cd nhfl viy, mdi ed ich tfl vin giup doanh nghiip ddi mdi cdng ngh|, nlng eao nang lfle eanh tranh, ddng thdi cung cd ngudn tii ehinh de dau tfl cho NCKH cua nhi trfldng Mat khie, cie trfldng nin khai thdng vi md rdng hoat ddng tin dyng hd trp eho NCKH Ngan hing chinh sich xa hdi quin ly Dly manh vile tao lap vj the, quan he, uy tin vi thfle hien tdt vile tilp thi, quing cio thfldng hilu cua nhi trfldng de khai thic ngudn vdn tfl hpp tie qudc tl, tfl sfl ung hd cua cic ei nhin, td chfle chinh phu, phi ehinh phu ddi vdi hoat ddng khoa hpc edng nghl Dae bilt li tfl cie kilu bio, cie "doanh nhin thinh dat", vi|c Iiln doanh Hin kit, hdp tic dau tfl Trong bdi cinh hien nay, vile tim kilm ngudn vdn eho NCKH cua cic trfldng dai hpe edng lap li mdt vin de khd, nhflng khdng phii la khdng cd giii phip Van dl ca bin li Nha nflde vi tflng trfldng phii thay ddi cd chl tai chinh theo hfldng phan quyIn, lim rd quyIn ldi vi trich nhilm, nghia vy de tao sfl ehu ddng cho tflng ca nhan, tflng bp phan qui trinh khai thie ngudn thu va sfl dung ngudn tii chinh mdt cich hi|u qui, gdp phan thue day vi nang eao chit Iflpng NCKH cua nhi trfldng.• Tai lieu tham khao ve mo hinh ddu tUcho hogt dpng NCKH xd hpi diiu kien tUchCi tdi chinh cda cdc ddn vi sU nghiep KH&CN cong lap", Tgp chl Nghien cdu tdi chi'nh ke todn Hgc vien Tdi chinh, so 10 (99), tr.35-38 6- Ths Nguyin Quang Thdnh (2011)"D6i mdi ca che, chinh sach tdi chinh cho phdt trien KH, cong nghe d Viet Nam" Tgp chlTdi chinh, so 10 (564), tr 4850,55 7- Bdo cdo s6 34/BC-CP, ngdy 14/4/2010 cua Thu tddng Chinh phu ve viec thuc hien chinh sdeh, phdp ludt ve thdnh lap trUdng, dau tu vd ddm bdo chdt luong ddo tgo GDDH gdi Oy Ban thudng vu Quoc Hpi 8- "Bdo cdo tong kit hogt dpng khoa hgc vd cong nghe giai dogn 2006-2010 vd dinh hudng phdt trien ndm 2011-2015 cua cdc trudng DH khoi kinh te, QTKD" Ky yeu Hpi nghi tong kit hogt dpng NCKH vd 2- GS Phgm Duy Hien (2009), "Bp cong nghe giai dogn 2006-2010 vd dinh mat mdi cua dgi hgc Viet Nam?" Tgp hudng phdt trien ndm 2011-2015, cua chi Tia sdng, truy cap ngdy 05/10/2009, cdc trudng DH khoi kinh te, QTKD (2010), nxb Trudng DH Kinh teQuoc ddn, Hd Npi, 3- GS TSKH Vu Minh Giang (2009), "Kettr 1-17 hop ddo tgo vdi NCKH: Kinh nghiem tif mpt 9- "Bdo cdo tong kit hogt dpng NCKH tradng dgi hgc", truy cap ngdy 26/8/2009, sinh vien cdc tradng DH khoi kinh te vd QTKD giai dogn 2006-2010", K^yiu Hpi 1- Dgi An dich, "Harvard bdn vi khung hodng gido due dgi hgc VN", truy cap ngdy 10/9/2009 4- Nguyen Quan Bp Khoa hgc vd Cong nghe (2008) "Chi nghien cCtu chl chiem mpt phdn nho", Trung tdm tiet kiem ndng luong vd tu van chuyen giao cPng nghe Dd Nang - Sd khoa hgc vd cPng nghe thdnh Dd Ndng, truy cap ngdy 04/11/2008, 5- PGS TS Bdi Thien Sdn (2011), "Bdn nghi tong kit hogt dpng NCKH cua sinh vien cdc tradng DH khoi kinh te, QTKD giai dogn 2006-2010 (thdng 12/2010), nxb Tradng DH Kinh teQuoc ddn, Hd Npi, tr3-21 10- Theo dat Viet "Khoa hgc khong CO khd ndng hdp thu?" tmy cap ngdy 06/6/2011, Cdng bo Quy hoach phat trien nganh Than den nam 2020 Ngiy 23/2/2012, Bd Cdng Thfldng da td chfle hpp bio cdng bd Quy hoaeh phit tril'n nginh Than din nam 2020, ed xet trien vpng din nam 2030 Tdng cue trfldng Tdng cue Nang lfl