Đang tải... (xem toàn văn)
Việc phân cấp quản lý giáo dục nước ta được bắt đầu từ những năm 90 thế kỷ XX. Cho đến nay, đã có khá nhiều văn bản quy định về vấn đề phân cấp quản lý đối với lĩnh vực giáo dục và đào tạo nói chung và đối với trường đại học nói riêng được ban hành. Mời các bạn tham khảo.
NGHIEN CL/U - TRAO DOI /f ^' UOT iO OaNH 6M UE HET OUH WU^C HIEN Pf/AIV CU 0(/ditf 1*1 cac uu^ciNc oai HOC d Nifdc HIEN NM ThS BUI THI NGOC MAI Viec phdn cap quan ly gido diic nude ta dugc bat ddu tir nhu'ng nam 90 theki XX Cho den nay, da cd kha nhiSu van ban quy dinh v6 vdn de phan cap qudn ly ddi vdi llnh vue giao due vd dao tao (GD&DT) ndi chung vd dd'i vdi trudng dai hge ndi rieng dugc ban hdnh Ludt Gido due nam 1998 da budc ddu the cbe hod quan diem ciia Dang ve phan cap qudn ly gido due Tiep den, Ludt Gido due nam 2005 tiep tuc de cap den van de theo hudng md rdng hon quy6n tu chii CLia cdc don vi GD&DT; dd, cd cdc trudng dai hge Di6u le trudng dai bgc nam 2003 cd mdt sd quy dinh kha cu the ve quy6n tU chu ciia cdc trudng dai hoc Dac biet, Nghi quyei sd 14/2005/NQ-CP eua Chfnh phii \6 ddi mdi can ban va toan dien gido due dai bgc Viet Nam giai doan 20062020 la van ban phdp ly cd tinh loan dien, triet de vd sau sde nhai tir trudc den ve ddi mdi gido due dai hge Viet Nam Nhieu ndi dung ciia van ban da neu len khd cu the va chi tiei van de giao quyen tu chii cbo cdc trudng dai bgc Rieng vdi llnh vue lai chfnh, thdng 012002, Nghi dinh sd 10/2002/ND-CP ciia Chinh phii ve ehe tai chfnh dp dung cho don vi su nghiep cd thu ddi Sau dd, ngdy 25-4-2006, Chfnh phii da ban hdnh Nghi dinh sd 43/2006/ND-CP ve viec quy dinh quyen tu chit, tu chiu trdch nhiem ve thuc hien nhiem vii, td chiic bd may, bien ehe va tai chfnh ddi vdi don vi sir nghiep cdng lap thay the cho Nghi dinh sd 10/2002/ND-CR Cho den thdng 10-2007, quy^n tu chii da dugc trao d nhi6u cap khde nhau: - Hai trudng Dai hge Qud'c gia (DHQG) dugc quyen tu chit hoan toan - Ba trudng dai hge khu vue dugc quyen tu chu tuong dd'i rdng - Cdc trudng dai hoc khde dugc quy6n tu chit mdt phdn Day la kei qua dugc ghi lai tir cudc hgp ban v6 cdc van de gido due giira Bg GD&DT va Nhdm cdng tdc Gido due ciia Dien dan doanh nghiep Viet Nam vao 24-10-2007 Nhu vay, den cudi nam 2007, viec giao quydn tu chu cho cac trudng dai hge da cd nhtrng kei qud budc ddu Hai trudng DHQG dugc tu chit hoan loan, dd la DHQG Ha Ndi (ra ddi nam 1993) vd DHQG TR Hd Chi Minh (ra ddi nam 1995) Chinh phii da ban hdnh mot quy cbe rieng cho hai trudng nay, ggi la quy ehe DHQG, hodn todn khde vdi Dieu le cdc trudng dai hoc ndi chung Cu the, ngdy 01-02-2001, Chinh phii ban hdnh Nghi dinh sd 07/2001/ND-CP vg DHQG Ngdy 12-02-2001, Tbii tudng Chfnh phii ki Quyei dinh sd 16/2001/QD-TTg ban hdnh Quy cbe ve td cbiic va hoat ddng ciia DHQG, khang dinh va tang cudng hon nufa quyen tu chu ciia cdc DHQG nhifiu llnh vue hoat ddng, dac biet Id dao lao, nghien ciai khoa hge vd cdng nghe, td ehirc cdn bd, ke hoach - tai chfnh va hgp tac qud'c te Quy cbe Id hanh lang phdp ly cho viec thitc hien tu chu d DHQG; dd, ndi rd trudng dugc lam nhiing gi, den dau, phan cap gitra DHQG vdi Bd GD&DT (noi quan ly nhd nude vi mat chuyen mdn) 30 TAP CHI QUAN LY NHA NUOC - SO 162 (7-2009) Hoc vi^n Hdnh chinh NGHIEN CL/U - TRAO DOI nhu the ndo Theo cdc van bdn nay, hai trudng DHQG hoat ddng theo co ehe tu chu, tu chiu trach nhiem cao, dudi su quan ly true tiep ciia Thu tudng Chfnh phu Cdc trudng dai hge vd cdc vien nghien cihi thude hai DHQG la cac co sd ddo tao, nghien euu khoa hge cd tu cdch phap nhdn vd quyen tu chii nhu cac trudng dai hge, vien nghien ciiu khde dugc quy dinh Ludt Gido due va Ludt Khoa hge - Cong nghe Gidm ddc kiem Chii tich Hdi ddng qudn tri vd cdc phd gidm ddc eua hai trudng DHQG Thii tudng Chfnh phu bd nhiem Cdc trudng cdn lai dugc phep tu cbii mdt phdn; dd la, quy6n tu chii ve tdi chfnh, ddng thdi, tu chit mdt sd khau ciia llnh vue tuyen sinh, chuong trinh gidng day va nhan sU Trong llnh vue tuyen sinh, Bd GD&DT dua diem san vd cung cap cdc quy dinh de giam sat viec tuyen sinh Cdc trudng tU quyei dinh mirc diem triing tuyen vao trudng minh mien Id khdng thap hon mufc diem san Bd quy dinh Viec quyei dinh ve hd so du thi, ngdy thi, de vdn Bd thuc hien Thii hai, cdc trudng dugc tu quyei dinh va van de nhan su Hieu trudng cd quy6n lap vd gidi the cdc td cbirc thude bd may ciia trudng; ban hdnh va bai bd cac ndi quy, quy dinh ndi bd trudng, quyei dinh bd nhiem vd miln nhiem cdc ehirc danh cdc td cbirc ciia trudng; td chiirc thi tuyen cdn bd, nhan vien, quyei dinh tiep nhan, chuyen ngaeh tir gidng vien chinh trd xudng; dugc uy quyen td cbirc thi nang ngaeh va bd nhiem vao ngaeh tir giang vien chinh trd xudng Thi( ba, ve chuong trinh gidng day, Bd GD&DT cung cap chuong trinh khung quy dinh Ciiu true chuong trinh va cdc mdn chfnh, chiem khoang 50% chuong trinh dao tao Phdn cdn lai trudng tu quyei dinh Trong tuong lai se giam bdt nhtrng mdn hge ft lien quan den chuong trinh, vf du mdn chfnh tri mdt sd chuong trinh TAP CHI QUAN LY NHA NUOC - SO 162 (7-2009) dao tao kl thuat Thit tu, ve tdi chfnh, cac trudng dugc quy6n tu chii tdi chfnh theo Nghi dinh sd 43 Tuy nhien, co ehe tu chii ve tai chinh cdc co sd gido due cdng lap chua phdt huy hieu qud tren thuc te Hien chi cd mdt yeu td dugc thuc hien, dd la viec cdc trudng dai bgc se nhan dugc cang it hon tien hd trg tir Nhd nude Nhin chung, ddi vdi da so cac trudng dai bgc tren cd nude, quydn tir chii dang dirng d miic tu chu vi tdi chfnh theo Nghi dinh sd 43, vd dugc tir chii viec thuc hien mdt sd ndi dung cdc llnh vue lien quan den ddo tao va id chiic nhan su Ba trudng dai hge khu vue cd quyen tU chu rdng hon, dd la Dai hge Hue, Dai hge Da Ndng, Dai hge Thai Nguyen Ve co bdn, cac trudng cd cdc quyen tu chii nhu cac trudng ndi tren, nhung rdng hon Cdc trudng dugc tu chu van de tuyen sinh, luyen dung nhan sir, cdp bang (cir nhan, thac si, lien si) Trong cac van de nay, Bd chi ddng vai trd giam sat Ngoai ra, cdn cd De an xoa bd cO ehe chii qudn ciia cdc trudng diii bgc, cao ddng, du kien hodn tiii viio thang 12-2008 Dieu dd cd kha nang md quyen tu chii rdng rai hon niia cho cdc trudng dai hge Tuy nhien, qua trinh phan cap cdn nhieu diem hiin ehe Thit nhdl, phcim vi phan cap hep, chua dap ling dugc yeu cau eua cdc trudng dai bgc Nhin vao nhu'ng kei qua da dat dugc, cd the de dang nhan thay cdc trudng dugc thuc hien quyen tu ehu tren ca nude la rdt ft Hien viec giao quyen tu chii cho cac trudng dai bgc ihuc te mdi chi dien d hai trudng DHQG (miic tir chu cao, khdng cd bd chii qudn), ba trudng dai hge khu vue (tir ciiii tren mdt sd mat), cdn lai cdc trudng khac chii yeu chi tu chii ve mat tai chfnh Neu de an trao quyen tir chu cho 14 trudng dai hge trgng diem thuc hien cd kei qua, thi sd cdc trudng dugc quyen tu chii cting mdi chi dirng lai d sd 14 31 NGHIEN CL/U - TRAO DOI Trong sd cdc trudng dai hge cdng lap tren ca nude len tdi sd xap xi 100 trudng, cd the ddnh gid pham vi phan cap nhu vay la qud hep Thuc te, hdu hei cdc trudng deu btic xuc trudc sir qudn ly qud chat cbe ciia Bd va mong mudn dugc cd quyen tu chii rdng rai Nhieu y kien cho rdng, viec trao quyln tu chu cho cdc trudng cdn thuc hien mdt cdch than trgn^ De trdnh nhting hdu qua ddng tie'e cd the xdy ra, nen tiing budc thuc hien thf diem d mdt sd trudng Idn, cd tiem luc tdt, sau dd mdi md rdng quyen tu chit cho cdc trudng khde Tuy nhien, thuc te' dang dat nhieu dp lire budc co quan qudn ly khdng the tri hoan viec phan cap rdng rai cho tat cd cdc trudng Viet Nam da gia nhap WTO, theo dd, cdc CO sd gido due dai bgc nude ngodi cd quyen lap dai hge lien doanh d Viet Nam Tir thang 01-2009, cac co sd gido due dai hge nude ngodi se cd quyen lap dai hge 100% vd'n nude ngoai vdi quyen tu chii dai hge rat cao Nhu vay, neu khdng cd quyen tu chu dai bgc nhu cdc co sd gido due dai bgc nude ngoai thi cdc trudng dai hge Viet Nam khd ldng canh tranh vdi cung nhu canh tranh vdi cdc dai bgc cd yeu id nude ngodi de phat trien Nghia la van de dang rat cap bdeb vi vdi mirc tir cbii thap vd mdi dugc thuc hien tren pham vi hep nhu tren, thi cdc trudng dai bgc Viet Nam cd the bi mat binh ddng Thii hai, phan ca'p khdng ddng bd Cung nhu tren da phan tich, chi cd bai trudng DHQG cd nhieu quyen tu chii hon, mdt so trudng trgng diem dugc tu chii van de nhan su Cdn lai, hdu hei cdc trudng chi dugc tu cbii ve tai chinh (tuy cdn gap nhieu khd khan qud trinh thuc hien), cdn lai, chua dugc tu quyet dinh chuong trinh ddo tao, chi tieu tuyen sinh, hge phi, qudn ly cdn bd, hgp tdc qude te, bang cap Ngay trudng DHQG cd quyen tu cbii rat cao nhung vdn phdi phu thude vao Bd GD&DT ve chi tieu tuyen sinh, td cbirc tuyen sinh khung chuong trinh ddo tao, quy dinh thu va sir dung bgc phi Nhu 32 vay, sir phan cap diin khdng hodn loan tren tat ca cdc llnh vue, cd vdi trudng dugc trao quyen tu chu cao nhat Nhieu nha nghien ciiu ggi dd la su tir cbii "nira vdi" Dieu dd gay nhieu kbd khan cho cac trudng qud trinh thuc hien nhiem vii Thir ba, co quan qudn ly vdn "ndm" nhu'ng viec cd the giao cho cdc trudng dai bgc Hien tai, cd mdt so khau, mdt sd cdng viec Bd GD&DT van dang thuc hien ma tren thuc te, vdi yeu cau phan cdp, thi nhiing khau, nhung viec dd hoan todn cd the giao cho cdc trudng thuc hien Cu the, dd la nhiing ndi dung vi llnh virc tuyen sinh, ve chuong trinh ddo tao, ve van de bgc phi Chiing tdi xin phan tfch mdt vf du ve llnh virc tuyen sinh Llnh vue tuyen sinh vdo cdc trudng dai bgc hien cd rdt nhieu bat cap Ve van de nay, hien Bd vdn la co quan dau mdi quyei dinh chi tieu tuyen sinh cho cdc trudng, quy dinh ve hd so tuyen sinh, thi, dirng td chiic kl thi tuyen sinh chung cho tai cd cdc trudng dai hge, quy dinh diem sdn xet tuyen Cd nghia la, Bd van chua phan cap cbo cdc trudng thuc hien cdng viec lien quan den llnh vue Dilu ndy ldm ndy sinh rat nhieu bdt cap, cu the la su kem chu ddng ciia cdc trudng va sir nang nl cho chfnh co quan qudn ly Don cir nhu vl cdch thiic tuyen sinh Hien chiing ta sir dung mdt ki thi dai bgc chung cho tat cd cdc trudng, theo md hinh chung: chung dgt, chung dl, chung kei qua xet tuyen Bd GD&DT thuc hien rat nhilu cdng viec nhu: dl thi, td chiic tra, kiem tra dam bdo cho ki thi diin an loan, de' viec cham thi khdng ndy sinh tieu cue Cdc trudng hdu nhu chi thirc hien khdu xet tuyen Viec Bd GD&DT dirng td chiirc thuc hien ki thi dai hge chung cho tat ca cac trudng dai hge cd rat nhilu ban ehe Ddi vdi thf sinh, ki thi gay nen tam ly cang thdng va ton kem Dd'i vdi co quan qudn ly, dd la mdt ganh nang ca vl cdng viec, ca vl chi phi Rieng viec dam bdo cho ki thi dugc TAP CHI QUAN LY NHA NUOC - SO 162 (7-2009) NGHIEN CL/U - TRAO DOI an loan, Bd phdi huy ddng bd mdy nhan sir rai Idn de di bdo ve, lam giam thi coi thi, huy ddng bd mdy tra, kilm tra Nhtrng dieu dd gay mdt dp lire nang nl cho loan xa bdi Diic biet, dd'i vdi cac trudng, viec sir dung chung ket qud cho tat cd cdc trudng cd nghia la yeu edu vl tinh dac thu vl nang lire cho lirng chuyen nganh ciia mdi trudng khdng dugc tfnh den Chuyen nganh ddo lao ciia cac trudng hei sire da dang, nhu vay, nhtrng yeu edu ddi vdi ngudi hge cung da dang Nhung hien Bd chi phan chia cdc khdi thi nhu A, B, C de dp dung chung cbo cdc trudng Nhu vay, dp diing mdt cdi "chung" de ddp ling cdc ddi hdi rat "rieng" vl nang luc CLia thf sinh cac trudng cd le la bat hgp ly Vf du, thf sinh thi vdo Trudng Dai hge Ngoai ngtr thi khdng cdn phai bgc toan hay nhu mdt so trudng thi ddu vdo ca khdi A va C, hoac A va D, thi su luyen sinh ddu vao dd dua tren tieu chi gi la chua rd rang Nhu vay, cd the tha'y, "ba chung" da khien cdc trudng, bat ke llnh vue, muc dich dao tao \'di cdc yeu cau chuyen mdn khac diu chung mdt "barem" luyen sinh dau vao gidng Va nhu the, vdi "ba chung", cdc trudng da khdng the tu chii, tu chiu trdch nhiem, khdng dugc tu xet tuyen sinh vien phu hgp vdi nhu edu va dieu kien dao tao cu the ciia minh Md hinh td chiic mdt ki thi dai bgc sau kl thi tdt nghiep PTTH bien cdn rat ft qud'c gia dp dung Hien tiii, Viet Nam ndrn khoang 10% sd nudc tren the gidi td chire ki thi PTTH vd dai hge, cao ddng rieng biet Trong dd, da sd cdc nudc tren the gidi thirc hien tbi tuyen vao diii hge hei su:c don gian Cdc trudng diii hge tir lam cdng tdc tuyen sinh ciia trudng minh bdng each xem xet hd so ciia cac thi sinh da cd bdng trung bgc phd thdng va ggi den kiem tra them hoac thi kiem tra mdt hoac hai mdn luy theo yeu cau eua lirng trudng Nhu x'iiy, cac CO quan quan ly nha nude Bd GD&DT khdng ciin thiep vdo qua trinh luyen sinh ciia cdc trudng TAP CHi QUAN LY NHA NUOC - SO 162 (7-2009) (J nudc ta chua the thuc hien hinh thiic tuyln sinh nhe nhang vd don gian nhu vay Bdi xuai phat diem eua each thiic tuyen sinh nhu hien nudc ta dang dp dung la d Viet Nam nhu cau bgc dai bgc qud Idn, cdc trudng dai hge cdn it vl sd lugng x'd yeu vl nang luc dap ting, dd, Nha nudc phdi diing den ki thi dl ban cbe so lugng ddu vao Tuy nhien, khdng the vi ly dd ma khdng xay dung mgt hinh thirc tuyen sinh khac hieu qud hon, theo dd can hudng tdi yeu cau gidm bdt su can thiep true tie'p eua Bd GD&DT, de cdc trudng tu thuc hien cdc cdng x iec tuyen sinh theo tieu chi vd mong mudn ciia minh Hien nay, Bd GD&DT cung dang xay dung mdt dl an ddi mdi hinh thirc thi tuyen dai bgc theo hudng bd ki thi Hien Bd dang tien hanh lay y kien lan cudi cung trudc trinh Chinh phii dl an mdt ki thi PTTH qud'c gia va sir dung kit qua ciia ki thi de cac trudng dai bgc xet tuyen vao trudng Theo tinh than ciia dl an nay, thi viec tuyln sinh vao cac trudng dai hge se cd sir thay ddi co ban chuyen tir viec Bd Id cbirc ki thi tuyen sinh diii hge sang viec cac trudng dai bgc dugc tu tuyen sinh can cir vao kei qua ki thi phd thong trung hge qud'c gia Bd GD&DT td chire trudc dd Dilu dd ddng nghia vdi viec tang quyIn tu chu ciia cdc trudng d;ii bgc van dl tuyen sinh Cd nhilu y kiln iing hd cung nhu phdn ddi de an Y kiln iing hd cho rang dl an ldi d ehd bd dugc mdt ki thi, dd la ki thi dai hge, vdn la mdt ki thi gay nhilu tdn kem va dp luc cho cd thi sinh, co quan quan ly va loan xa hdi Tuy nhien, theo y kiln CLia nhilu nha nghien ciiu vl gido due, thuc hien mdt ki tbi qud'c gia nhu dl dn dl cd nhilu diem ban ehe Thit nhdt, muc tieu ciia hai ki thi la khac hdn vd vl nguyen tac thi khdng the nhap lam mdt Ki thi trung bgc phd thdng la dl cap bdng tdi nghiep, nham kiem tra xem cdc thi sinh cd dat dugc yeu edu tdi thilu da dl cho nam phd thdng trung 33 NGHIEN CL/U - TRAO DOI hge hay khdng, neu dat thi cap bdng tdt nghiep Cdn ki thi tuyen dai hge Id nhdm lira chgn nhu'ng ngudi cd nang luc hon ngudi khde vl nhung mat ndo dd de tiep tuc hge lap cao hon Nhu vay thi miic khd de CLia cdc d l thi Id rat khde nhau, vdn chi ndm pham vi kien thiic ciia chuong trinh phd thdng Ve mat kl thuat vd hge thuat, khd Idng tim dugc mdt d l thi chung cho cd hai mirc nhu vay Thit hai, mdt ki thi nhu vay de lam can cii cho cac trudng dai bgc tuyen chgn sinh vien vdo hge thi tin cay Id rdt thdp Do tin cay ciia mdt ki thi pbii thude vdo mgi cdng doan ciia ki thi, tir viec d l cho phu hgp, bao mat dl, td cbiic coi thi, cham thi Tuy nhien, thuc te nhiing nam qua cho thay, ki thi tdt nghiep phd thdng trung bgc cd tin cay thdp hon nhieu so vdi ki tbi dai hge vd cao dang, dac biet Id d khau coi thi vd cham thi Chiing ta da biet nhtrng tieu circ cdc ki thi tdt nghiep hau nhu Id phd bien vd nghiem trgng Cdn d cdc kl tbi dai bgc va cao ddng thi ft hon Mdt nhtrng nguyen nhan phai ke den la dia diem thi: thi tdt nghiep phd thdng trung bgc dugc td chiic d dia phuong sd tai d xa, huyen khdp noi tren loan qud'c, cdn thi dai hge thi chi d phd Idn Nhu vay, nhap hai ki thi ldm mdt va dugc td ehirc d dia phuong thi lieu cue se tang len Thii ba, neu nhu ki thi dugc id chiic mdt each nghiem tiic khdng lieu cue thi lin cay vdn la van dl dat ra, Bd dung hinh thiic tbi trdc nghiem Theo GS Van Nhu Cuong: gid sir mdt trudng dai bgc nhu Trudng Dai bgc Ngoai ngtr cdn tuyen nhiing bgc sinh khd mdt ngoai ngtr Hg mudn kiem tra xem kl nang nghe, ndi, viet, dgc eua thi sinh dd nhu the nao Trong trudng hgp dd thi theo hinh thiic van ddp la tdt nhdt va dang tin cdy nhai Nhung vi dieu kien khd khan nen trudc day ddnh phai chdp nhan hinh ihiic dl thi tir luan Tuy nhien neu dp dung theo dl an mdi chi nhat mdt bai trac nghiem khdch quan thi cdc thi sinh cd bdi trdc nghiem tieng Anh dat diim cao tham chi la diim tuyet 34 ddi thi ngoai kl nang dgc hieu, ta khd cd the ndi gi thdm vl cdc kl nang khac ciia hg Vdi nbilu ban cbe Idn nhu vay, dl an vl ki thi phd thdng trung bgc qude gia, mdt dl an dugc xem nhu mdt each thiic nhdm ddi mdi hinh thiic td chiic thi tuyen dai hge vdn ciing cd nhilu ban cbe' sudt nhilu nam qua cdn chua dugc dp dung kl thi tuyen sinh dai hge nam 2009 va 2010 De dl dn trd hien thuc cdn phdi xem xet, nghien ciru tir nhieu gde khac Nhu vay, cd the thay, thuc hien cdch tuyen sinh theo phuong phdp chung hien nay, hay thuc hien theo d l dn td cbirc mdt kl thi phd thdng trung bgc qud'c gia va tren CO sd dd cdc trudng dai hge tuyen sinh cho trudng minh, hai each ldm dd diu cd nhtrng diem ban ehe nhu da phan tich d tren Ca hai cdch deu the hien su can thiep ciia Bg vao cdng tdc tuyen sinh ciia cdc trudng dai bgc d miic bay miic khde Va cdc trudng vdn chua the cbii ddng dugc vl ngudn thf sinh ddu vao cho trudng minh Dilu cung cd nghia la cac trudng vdn khdng cd quyIn tu cbii luyen sinh theo nhu edu vd yeu edu rieng ciia tirng trudng Tdm lai, thirc hien phan cdp qudn ly cac trudng dai bgc tren thuc te da dat dugc mdt sd kei qud the hien d quyIn tu chu cao ciia hai trudng DHQG, ba trudng DH khu vuc vd quyen tu chii ciia cdc trudng tren mdt sd mat Tuy nhien, qua trinh thuc hien cung bgc Id mgt sd han cbe co ban nhu pham vi phan cap cdn hep, khdng ddng bd, ddng thdi CO quan qudn ly md cu the la Bd Giao due va Dao tao vdn "ndm" mdt sd cdng viec ma tren thirc te cd the giao cho cac trudng thuc hien, nhu llnh vuc luyen sinh Nhtrng kit qud da dat dugc la tiln dl thuan Igi de qud trinh phan cdp qudn ly nude ta tiep luc dugc thuc hien theo chieu hudng tang quyen tu chii cho cdc trudng dai bgc Tuy nhien, nhtrng ban cbe nhu da phan Itch d tren lai la luc cdn khien qua trinh dd chua dat dugc kei qua nhu mong mudnG TAP C H I Q U A N LY NHA NU6C - SO 162 (7-2009) ... trudng TAP CHi QUAN LY NHA NUOC - SO 162 ( 7-2 009) (J nudc ta chua the thuc hien hinh thiic tuyln sinh nhe nhang vd don gian nhu vay Bdi xuai phat diem eua each thiic tuyen sinh nhu hien nudc ta dang... nang ca vl cdng viec, ca vl chi phi Rieng viec dam bdo cho ki thi dugc TAP CHI QUAN LY NHA NUOC - SO 162 ( 7-2 009) NGHIEN CL/U - TRAO DOI an loan, Bd phdi huy ddng bd mdy nhan sir rai Idn de di bdo... dao tao Phdn cdn lai trudng tu quyei dinh Trong tuong lai se giam bdt nhtrng mdn hge ft lien quan den chuong trinh, vf du mdn chfnh tri mdt sd chuong trinh TAP CHI QUAN LY NHA NUOC - SO 162 ( 7-2 009)