Xử lý đơn tố cáo về sai phạm trong quản lý hành chính và chuyên môn của hiệu trưởng trường THCS

BO GIRO DVC VA DAO TAO TRU6NG CAN BO QUAN LY GIAO DUC TP HO CHI MINH TIEU LUAN CUOI KHOA Lop B64 i dtrirng nghiep vu COng tat vien tra gião dyc Kh6a /2017 Tén tieu luan: XirlY thin to coo ye sai phym quan ly hanh chinh NIA chuyen mon dm Hien trutng truting THCS Tan Van A He \TA ten hoc viên: TrAn La Phtrang Nghia Dan vi tong tâc: PhOng Gião due ve DA° to pht) Quang Ngdi Thânh ph/5 Qudng Ned, duing nom 2017 PHAN I: MO DAU Khieu nai, to cao IA quyen cua cong dan &A dirge phdp lust quy dinh dm Day la quyén de cong dan bao ve hop ,phap quyen loi minh, lgi Nha nuOt nu& thOng qua viec tiép clan va giai guy& khiéu nai, to cao co the kiem tra, giam sat, viec chap hAnh phdp lust cila cac co quan, t8 chlre va ca nhan Thvc hien tot cOng the tiep dan va giai quyét khieu nai, to cao IA co SO quan tong de Dang ya Nha nuac to nhan dinh danh gia dUng tlnh hinh thire hien, thi hanh chinh skit, phap lust cUa the cap cde nganh Danh gia dung nang luc, pham chat cila can b0 cong chive viec thirc thi nhiem vu, cOng vu dirge giao, tir duo nhilng Men phap him lieu viec dive Men chinh skit, phap lust qua trinh thve hien chlre nang quart 13? NM nuac Trong thai dai mai dat nutc tang phat trien, quyén dan chu tang dirge ma rOng thi guy& khieu nai, to cao cua cOng clan tang ma rOng va phat huy Giai quy& khieu nai, to cao nham bao ye, khOi phut the quyen va lgi ich hop phap cua cOng clan; ben canh xir lY kip tiled, nghiem minh cac hanh vi vi pham phap lust; vi pham quy dinh ve cOng the quan 15, nanh chuy'en mOn Nhan thirc dirge tam quan cua cOng tic giai guy& khieu nai, to cao va qua lop bOi dua'ng nghiep vu cong the vien tra, dOi chieu,vai thvc den cong tat tai dia phuong, tOi chon tieu luan: "Mr If don to cao ye sai pham wain If hank chinh viz chuyén men ciia Hieu trwang trailing THCS Tran Van A" Do then gian hoc tap ngan nen tieu luan chic than IchOng trânh khei nhang sai sot, kinh mong sir quan tam dOng y kién cua quy thay co gido de tieu luan hoan thien hon Xin clan cam cm Ban giam hieu, gido vién, nhan vién Truing Can b0 Quail 15T gido due phO HO Chi Minh da tan tinh ginp da, tao dieu kien de tOi hoan Chuang trinh hoc nay./ A PHAN II: NQI DUNG MO ti tinh Nay 25/4/2015, PhOng GD&DT pha Ycó nhan don t6 cao cac Ong, ba: DO Ngoc B — Gido vién truemg THCS Trail Van A, pha Y; to cao dai vai Ong LY Trieu C — Hieu truemg THCS Tit Van A, phi) Y ve mot so not dung sau: KhOng day du tit quy dinh nhung van huemg phi cap 30% luting Sai pham ve quy the chuyên mon BuOng lOng cOng tac quan 11 Tien hanh to chile day them sai quy dinh Tril dap ca nhan Lgi dung chirc quyen cho gido vien nghi sai nguyen tac Xfic dinh muc tieu xii 1Sr tinh fluting Tren nguyen tic viec giai quyat to cao phai &rot thuc hien theo dung quy dinh cua phat lust, dam bao khach quan, cong khai, dan chu va kip thai Ved nhung kik thirc tier, thu qua lap bai dual-1g nghiep vu cong tac viên tra va 9ua trinh nghien cfru cac van ban phap 1uSt, tOi xac dinh mac tieu xir ly tinh huOng nhu sau: Xac minh tinh chinh xac cua nOi dung t6 cao ved yeu cau trung Uwe, dan chit, cong khai \fa Ichach quan Dam bao viec giai qnyet t6 cao duce thuc hien theo dung cac quy dinh cua Oat it* ve giai quyet to cao Dam bao quyen Ara Igi ich hop phap cua cOng dan, ben canh kip thai xfr lyr cac hanh vi sai pham (neu co) GOp phan cling co niem tin dm can b0, gido vien vao duang 16i, chil tnrcmg cua Wang, chinh sach, phap lust dm Nha nuac Phin tich tinh tiding (phin tich nguyen nhin va hiu qui) 3.1 Nguyen nhin tinh hutmg Trong qua trinh cOng tic tai truemg THCS TrAnVan A, ban than thay DO Ngoc B da chiu ap lye; Ink 'dm cong tac; dOng thai theo dOi tinh hinh ne nep h9c sinh nha true:mg va chat luting hoc tap, cling nhu cac phong tat) cua nha truemg cang sa slat Chinh vi the, thay Da Ngoc B da viat don t6 cao nhitng hanh vi sai pham dm Ong Ly Trieu C — Hieu tnremg THCS Tran Van A gei den PhOng GD&DT phi; Y Ho 3.2 114u qua tinh huOng Nhihrg viec lam tren caa 6ng Ly Trieu C — Hieu trueng THCS Tran Van A, phO Y co the gay nhfing birc xfic, mat doan ket nOi b0 nha truing ding nhu anh huOng den chat ltrong hoc tap hoc sinh DOng thai anh hueng den uy tin dm nha truang nOi rieng cling nhu town nganh Gido dye va Dao tao phO Y nOi chung De xuat nhfing giai phip \Teri nOi don , t6 cart tren tai de xuat phtrong , an giai quy& la: PhOng GD&DT, phO tham 1111R1 vai UBND phO Y thy 132 giai quyét don to cao dm Ong DO Ngoc B TO chat thyc hit'n Oaf phi') a dat dtryt myc tieu de De giai quy& don t6 cao cfra Ong D6 Ngoc B — giao vien truing THCS Tran Van A, chung to can thuc hien ding quy trinh theo Luat to cao so 03/2011/QH13 11/11/2011; Nghi dinh so 76/2012/ND-CP 03/10/2012 dm Chinh phi quy dinh chi tiét mot so dieu cna Luat t6 cao; Th'Ong tu sO 06/2013/TT-TTCP 31/10/2013 quy dinh quy trinh giai quyet to cao;‘ Nghi dinh so 42/2013/ND-CP 09 thing tram 2013 dm Chinh ve to chirc va hoat dOng cia Thanh tra gido dyc, cac bu&c tien hanh nhu sau: Bute 1: Tip than, VI' ly thOng tin t6 cao Ngubi t6 cao: Ong D6 Ngoc B — Gido vien truing THCS Trail Van A NOi dung dun la to cao: Vi pham quail ly hanh chinh va chuyen man cfra thu tnrOng don vi (Hieu truemg truing THCS Tran Van A) Nguti bi to cao: Ong Ly Trieu C — Hieu tnrOng THCS Tran Van A, la ngueri thuOc UBND ph0 Y quail ly, vi vay PhOng GD&DT phO Y khOng di tham quyen xi ly nen phai thuc hien viec chuyén don to cao den UBND ph0 Y - UBND phi) Y kiem tra, xem xet don di dieu kien thy ly giai quyet thi se guy& dinh ye viec thy ly giai quyét to cao va lap Doan xac minh to cao (thuc hien theo Mau so 05-TC ban hanh kern theo Thong tu so 06/2013/TT-TTCP 31/10/2013) Sau do, UBND ph0 Y gOi thong bao bang van ban cho ngueri t6 cap — Ong D6 Ngoc B ve thai diem thy UT to cao va cac nOi dung to cao dupe thy 151 (time hien theo Mau so 08-TC ban hanh kern theo ThOng tu sO 06/2013/TT-TTCP 31/10/2013) Bute 2: Xdc minh t6 cao Ke hoach xac minh nOi dung to cao T8 trueng Doan xac minh lap va trinh ngtrairi quyétdinh lap TO xac minh phe duyet g6m the nOi dung: Can cu phap 132 de tien hanh xac minh; muc dich, yêu cau cia viec xac minh; 1\11:5i dung xac mirth; co quan, t6 chIrc, don vi, ca nhan phai lam viec de thu thap, xac minh cac thOng tin, tai lieu; bang thing; cac dieu kien, phtrcmg fien phut vu cho viec xac minh; du kien thai gian thuc hien -ding cong viec; nhiem vu cu the en a tong vién; thti gian du phOng de xi 1y cac cong viec phat sinh; viec bao cao tiên dO thuc hien; cac nOi dung khdc (nett co) To truang Doan xac minh co trdch nhiem giao guy& dinh lap to xac minh cho nguti bi to cao la Ong 14 Trieu C — Hieu trueng truCmg THCS Tran Van A Viec giao quyat dinh phai lap bién ban co chit k dm To trueng To xac minh, Ong 14 Trieu C — Hieu tnremg THCS Tran Van A Bien ban dugc lap it that hai bin, giao mOt ban cho Ong 14 Trieu C, nguei dai dien trutng THCS Tran Van A va luu ho so giai guy& to cao Bulk 3: Lam viec true Wei) v6i ngtrei t6 cao - Doan xac minh lam viec true tiep vti 'Ong D6 Ng9c B yeu cau nguti to cao cung cap thOng tin, tai lieu, bang thing de lam rO nOi dung tO cao NOi dung lam viec vai Ong DO Ng9c B phai lap bien ban (thuc hien theo Mau se, 09-TC ban hanh kern theo ThOng to so 06/2013/TT-TTCP 31/10/2013), co chit 14 cila Ong D6 Ng9c B Bien ban lap it nhat hai ban, giao mot ban cho Ong D6 Nggc B, nett ba B co yéu eau ye luu ho so giai guy& tO cao BuOc 4: Lam viec true tiep vol ngtresi bi t6 cao - Doan xac minh lam viec true tier, vai Ong 14 Trieu C; yeu cau Ong 14 Trieu C giai trinh bang van ban ye nhang nOi dung bi to cao, cung cap thong tin, tai lieu, bang chimg lien quan den nOi dung to cao, nOi dung giai trinh - NOi dung lam viec vei Ong 14 Trieu C phai doge lap bién ban (dare hien theo Mau so 09-TC ban hanh kern theo ThOng to so 06/2013/TTTTCP 31/10/2013) Bien ban phai co chit 14 &la Ong 14 Trieu C, nguiri tri lam viec yeti Ong C \fa lap it nhat hai, ban, giao mOt ban 'Ong Ly Trieu C nett c6 yeu cau Ara luu ho so giai quyêt to cao Buck 5: Thu thap, xir 15T thong tin, tai lieu, bang chimg lien quan den nOi dung to cao Doan xac minh yeti eau cung cap thong tin, tai lieu, bang thing lien quan den nOi dung to cao phai can cif vao ke hoach xac minh da dugc phê duyet, yeu eau cua viec giai quyat to cao Khi tiep nhan thOng tin, tai lieu, bang thing ngueri to cao, nguti bi to cao, co quan, to chit?, don vi, ca nhan lien quan cung cap true tiep thi To xac minh phai lap Giay biên nhan (thuc hien theo Mau so 11-TC ban hanh kern theo Th6ng to so 06/2013/TTTTCP 31/10/2013) - Ck thong tin, tai lieu, bang chUng dugc thu thap true tiep phai the hien r'O nguan gac Khi thu thap ban sao, Doan xac minh phi clOi chiêu vol ban chinh; tnrâng hop khOng co ban chinh thi phai ghi giay bién nhan Cdc thOng tin, tai lieu, bang chi:mg co quan, t6 chtic, don vi cung cap phai xac nhan dm co quan, to chdc, don cung cap ThOng tin, tai lieu, bang cluing ca nhan cung cap phai co xac nhan cua nguari cung cap - Doan xac minh phai ham tra tinh xac thuc cua thong tin, tai lieu, bang chang da thu thap duce, cha tong nhung thing tin, tai lieu, bang chirng nguati to cao cung cap a to cao hank vi vi pham va thong tin, tai lieu, bang cluing nguad bi t8 cao cung cap de giai trinh, cht'mg minh tinh dung, sai elm nOi dung to cao Buck 6: Xac minh Uwe to - Doan xac minh Wan hanh xac minh thuc tea tai truamg THCS Trail Van A de thu thap, kiem tra, xac dinh filth chinh xac, hop phap cua cac thOng tin, tai lieu, bang Chung lien quan den nOi dung to cao - Viec xac minh thuc to phai lap Nen ban ghi day du kat qua xac minh, y kien cna nhung nguad tham gia xac minh va nhung nguad kit CO lien quan Bien ban phai‘ CO cha 102 nguad xac minh, nhung nguad co lien quan Ira phai luu h8 so giai quyet t8 cao Buck 7: Bao cao kat qua xac minh nOi dung to cao Doan xac minh bac) cao ket qua xac minh nhu sau: Tir 06/05/2015 den 29/05/2015, Doan xac minh da tian hanh lam viec veri Ban giam hieu nha twang, ket qua cu the nhu sau: * NOi dung 1: IChOng day du ti6t quy dinh nhung van hthang phv cap 30% luong - Qua lam viec Ong L)2 Trieu C giai trinh nhu saw Nam hoc 2012 — 2013 sau ye nhan nhiem vu tai twang THCS Than Van A ban than Ong da day huang nghiep lap 9' va lOp va met so chuyen de gido due nha tnrang Nam hoc 2013 — 2014 Ong day mon GDCD lap 7A va day huang nghiep lOp 9A, 9B Nam hoc 2014 — 2014 HQC ki I Ong day mon GDCD lap 7A va hoc kST II day mon GDCD lOp 7A , 7B - Doan xac mirth da lam viec vari BGH nha twang va da duce cung cac bang phan cong chuyen mon, thai khOa bieu cac nam hoc 2012 — 2013; 2013 — 2014; 2014 — 2015 dO au c6 the Men viec phan cong chuyén mon , thai kh6a Neu day cho Ong Them Trong cac thai kh6a Neu a cac nam hoc 2013 — 2014; 2014 — 2015 mon GDCD Ong C day co the thien thai khOa biau cu the et& Arai cong tae day huang nghiep cho hoc sinh ,khOng dua nha truarng ma chi day vao thu hang tuan ye tiét vao thin khOa ,bien cua mot so buOi tuan *NOi dung 2: Sai pham ve quy the chuyén mon Qua lam viec Ong LY Trieu C gidi trinh nhu sau: Sau ket thfic nam hoc 2012 — 2013 Ong co kiem tra so goi ten, ghi diem dm cac 16p nhan they co nhieu so diem viec ste diem chua dUng quy dinh, co tay xOa nen khOng them ml va khOng dung quy dinh nen da chi dao nam hoc 2013 — 2014, 2014 — 2015 gido vien vao culei hoc ky meri vao diem s6 nham moc dich de tranh nheing sai sot teen va gilt so goi ten ghi diem dm lop dugc sach se BGH nha truing co b6 sung them: Viec chi dao nhu teen nham moc dich tap dieu lcien cho mot so hoc sinh yeu kern kiem tra thueng xuyen bi diem th ei f) co co hOi guy& tam hoc tap cai thien diem so nham du dieu kien len 16p; hoac nhang em bel thi, thi hoc ky bi diem thap co co hOi thi lai nham cal thien diem hoc tap a * NOi dung 3: BuOng lOng cling tic quail li NOi dung dun co the hien co the: "Ghia vien toy clef giel, len lOp khOng co giao an ma ban giam hi'Ou khOng Net (qua ket qua kiém tra clot xucit 28/11/2014 caa Se) GD&DT Z)" - Doan xac minh TA' lam viec vOi Ong Truang Van D — Ph6 Hieu truing nha truing, Ong D giai trinh nhu sau: Ngay 28/11/2014 cila Ser GD&DT Z co kiem tra dot xuet twang THCS Tren Van A lire BGH nha truing chi co minh d6ng chi Truing Van D vi d6ng chi Lyr Trieu C xin nghi di kham berth tai Da Nang Tai buOi lam viec Thanh tra ser co gier tiet day dm cO Diep Thi My My, nhien hOm die cO My da d6i gi6 cho ere Pham Nir Vy Vy Thanh tra Set GD&DT co ket Gido vien to y bo gier, taking phai cap nhat s6 diem hang Trén ca ca co so ket luan cua Thanh tra SO BGH nha truing de tian hanh kiem diem d6i vai co My, co Vy vao cu6i hoc Icy nam hoc 2014-2015 va cat danh hieu LDTT hoc Id ded yea cO Vy * Ntli dung 4: Tien hanh to chirc day them sai quy dinh NOi dung Ong L5r Trieu C giai Trinh nhu sau: BGH nha truing tir d'Au da thgc hien theo ding ThOng to 17 dm BO GD&DT, co the co phan loai theo d6i tuong ,hoc sinh yéu, kern, kith, gied nhung viec chi thoc hien thai gian ngan vi hoc sinh khOng den lOp hoc do viec day them theo phan loai hoc sinh khOng tri dugc Tiz tinh hinh thgc to teen BGH nha truing da tochire day them theo cdc lOp chinh kh6a, khOng phan loai hoc sinh Viec to chIrc day them nhu ten da ducc Ong Ly Trieu C dua hop vi xin y 'den cua HOi dang su pham nha truing * NOi dung 5: TrU dap ca than Qua lam viec veri cdc Ong D'6" Ngoc B ya cdc vien khac H'Oi ding six pham; BCH COng Doan, kheing cung cap bang chOng chimg to Ong LY Trieu C co hanh vi trir dap ca When ded vai Ong DO Ngoc B * Ni dung 6: Lai dung chirc quyen cho gido vien nghi sai nguyen Qua xac mirth down nhan thay dOi veri nOi dung BGH nha tnrang da lam dung nguyén tac &Mg y cho co Quang Thi Linh co don xin nghi day vi hO san nu& nhO va da yeti cau co Linh cac giay tä de giai quyet nghi theo the thai san Trong bien ban hop BGH nha truemg 26/9/2013 a neu it "Co Linh cla lam xong thlt tuc la sinh nhung nOi dung chwa r'd nen cO kheing nghi hO san day binh thtfang thus hien tic wan thong 10" VA bien bin Hop hOi dOngr 3/10/2013 co nOi dung "Viet nghi 110 Asian vita co Yen neu kheing co gidy ter hop le thi phai day vao &hi thong 10 (day tie 07/10/2013)" Nhu vay, viec khOng phai Ong LY Trieu C dung chirc quyén cho c8 Linh nghi ma da co su than luan, ban bac BGH va dua HOi dOng su pham nha trui;mg thOng boo yeu eau Linh ter lai truing day co ho so thu tuc de nghi thai san theo quy dinh Nha trueng dal khOng dux hien viec phe binhkiem diém co Linh nghi viec sai quy dinh Theo Thong to 02/2011/TT-BNV 11/1/2011 thi ba Linh duce xat tang danh hieu Lao dOng Tien tian vi da nghi qua 40 lam viec (do khOng co du ho so thu tuc de nghi thai san theo quy dinh) nen HOi dicing thi dua — khen thlräng nhA truOng de nghi citing than danh hieu Lao dOng Tien tien la sai Viec Ong LY Trieu C ,bO tri cOng tat kiem nhiem thu vin cho be Linh vOi se, tiét kiem nhiem 10 tiet/tuan la khOng ding quy dinh Buck 8: Kat luan nOi dung t6 cao Can cu bac) cao kat qua xac minh nOi dung t6 cao, cac thOng tin, tai lieu, thongcó lien quan, , chieu yeti cac quy dinh cUa phap luat, Chit tich UBND nth phO Y ban hanh két luan nOi dung 63 cao Van ban kat luan nOi dung t6 can thuc hien theo Mau so 16-TC ban hanh kern theo Thing to so 06/2013/TT-TTCP 31/10/2013 Bulk 9: Ong khai kat luan nOi dung t6 cao, quy gt dinh xir ly hanh vi vi pham bi to cao va thOng boo kat qua giai guy& -CO cao cho ngued to cao UBND phO Y có trâch nhiem citing khai kat luan nOi dung t6 cao, quyét dinh xir ly hanh vi vi pham bi to cao theo quy dinh tai Dieu 11 Nghi dinh so 76/2012/ND-CP 03/10/2012 dia Chinh Buck 10: Lap, quail ly ho so giai quyat t6 cao Tnreyng Doan xac minh co troth nhiem ginp UBND ph6 Y lap hi\ so giai quyat to ea() theo ding quy dinh tai dieu 26 ThOng to so 06/2013/TTTTCP 31/10/2013 Kien nghi, de xuat Qua kat qua )(de minh the nOi dung t6 cep, Doan )(de minh kin nghi Chit tier' UBND thO Y xirb? nhu sau: I LM 6.1 D61 Wri ngvai t6 cao Co tinh than dau tranh xay dung, phOng chOng tham nhung Tuy nhien, viec dau tranh chin kip thai, can manh dan g6p y cho BGH nha twang mOt so tong tat ye chuyen mOn, ye quan ly ;Chua co tinh than xay dung khOi down két truemg cling nhu xay dung mOi twang gido due nha truemg yang math MOt so ca than to cao ban rinh chua vims yang de bi kich dOng, lOi kao chua nam duce vu \dee gay mat down kat nOi b0, anh ' huOng uy tin cna Nha twang Trong cac nOi dung to cao mOt nOi dung ding, phan lem nOi dung khac nguOi to cao chua näm chk cac quy dinh, khOng co bang chimg, mOt so nOi dung da duce thong qua HOi dOng su pham nha twang, da duce thuc hien nhieu ndm hoc nen CO cao khOng dung, khOng co co sa 6.2 Dt yOi nguiri bi t6 cao Trong qua trinh thuc hien nhiem vu lath dao, quan lY can phai thuc hien tot hon nua nhang nhiem vu sau: Xay dung khOi doan kat thong nhat that su don vi da xay dung nha twang cang phât trien ye m9i mat Tang cueing chi dao ding tee nha truemg thuc hien theo dUng cac quy dinh cua cac cap Can cong khai nen cac nOi dung, cac boat dOng nha twang sau da thong qua Lien tich, HOi Ong su pham nha truang BGH nha twang phan cling CB, GV, NV thuc hien nhiem vu, cong viec cu the can co minh chimg viec thuc hien nhfing nhiem vu, cling viec ten Nghiem tut rut kinh nghiem viec day dUng so tiat theo quy dinh; Chi dao,chuyén mOn tinic hien dung viec cho diem hoac nhan xat yao goi ten ghi diem theo dung quy dinh PHAN III: 'CET LUAN Voi viec thpc hien giai quyet don t6 cao ve viec sai pham cong tac quart ly hanh chinh va chuyen mOn cua Hieu truang THCS Tran Van A la mot cau chuyen co that nganh Gido duc va DAD tao phO Y Qua cau chuyen teen co the rut nhien kat Juan va bai hoc quy ban cong tac quart ly cua Hieu frac:king tai the trueng hoc, cu the: - Can xac dinh day at trach nhiem t6 chirc, quart ly cdc hoat dOng cita nit& trueng theo quy dinh cna phap luat Ara Dieu le TrtrOng Trung hoc ca ser (ban hanh kern theo ThOng to s612/2011/TT-BGDT 28/3/2011 cila BO Giao dpc va Dap tao): - Hieu tnrOng, Ph6 hieu truang trueng ph6 thOng co nhiem vu giang day mot s6 tiét de ndm duce nOi dung, chtrong trinh gido dye va tinh hinh hoc tap cua hoc sinh nham nang cao hieu qua cong tac quart ly ( theo ThOng to so 28 /2009/TT-BGDDT 21 thcing 10 niim 2009 cita Bo 1r:thing BO Gicio dyc va Dao too) - BGH nha trueng can phai xac dinh r6 viec php dao hyc sinh yéu kern va viec to chdc day them hoc them (Chap hanh nghiem titc ck quy dinh ye day them hoc them tai ThOng to s6 17/2012/TT-BGDDT 16/5/2012 dm BO Giao dye va Dao tao) - H'Oi &Ong su pham; BCH COng down can xay dung kh6i doan ket nOi b0, k6 try gilip da va dOng vien CB-GV thpc hien tot nhiem vu cua ca nhan; thpc hien clang quy the va quy dinh cua nganh PHAN IV: 'Lk! LIEU THAM KHAO LuSt TQ cao so 03/2011/QH 11/11/2011; Nghi dinh s4 76/2012/ND-CP 03/10/2012 cila Chinh phit quy dinh chi tiet mot so diéu dm Lust to cao; ThOng tu s6 06/2013/TT-TTCP 31/10/2013 dm Thanh tra chinh ph6 quy dinh quy trinh giai quyet to cao Th6ng tu so 07/2014/TT-TTCP 31/10/2014 cila Thanh tra chinh phi" quy dinh quy trinh xir ly don khiêu nal, don to cao, don kién nghi, phan anh; Tai lieu bOi duong Nghiep vu cOng tac vien tra giao dvc BQ GD&DT biên soan Th6ng tu sQ12/2011/TT-BGDT 28/3/2011 dm BO Geo dvc va Ddo tao ThOng tu s6 28 /2009/TT-BGDDT 21 thâng 10 nam 2009 dm BO tnräng BQ GA.° dvc vd Dao tao Th6ng tu s6 17/2012/TT-BGDDT 16/5/2012 cila BO Gide, dvc Ira Da° tao ThOng tu 02/TT-BNV 24/01/2011 dm BO NOi Vv 10 ... If don to cao ye sai pham wain If hank chinh viz chuyén men ciia Hieu trwang trailing THCS Tran Van A" Do then gian hoc tap ngan nen tieu luan chic than IchOng trânh khei nhang sai sot, kinh mong... truemg THCS Trail Van A, pha Y; to cao dai vai Ong LY Trieu C — Hieu truemg THCS Tit Van A, phi) Y ve mot so not dung sau: KhOng day du tit quy dinh nhung van huemg phi cap 30% luting Sai pham... luting Sai pham ve quy the chuyên mon BuOng lOng cOng tac quan 11 Tien hanh to chile day them sai quy dinh Tril dap ca nhan Lgi dung chirc quyen cho gido vien nghi sai nguyen tac Xfic dinh muc