Đang tải... (xem toàn văn)
sir DUNG AN LE TRONG DAO TAO CU* NHAN LUAT 0 VIET NAM HIEN NAY THU''''C TRANG VA GIAI PHAP HOANG VAN T O A N " T6m tdt Mot trong nhSng biin phdp di hodn tkiin phdp ludt trong boi cdnh Viit Nam dang ngkie[.]
sir DUNG AN LE TRONG DAO TAO CU* NHAN LUAT VIET NAM HIEN NAY - THU'C TRANG VA GIAI PHAP HOANG VAN T O A N " T6m tdt: Mot nhSng biin phdp di hodn tkiin phdp ludt boi cdnh Viit Nam dang ngkien cOu xdy diing md kinh tdtung trank tung ckink Id phUdng dn sie dung dn l^ nkii mdt nguSn luat bSsung khodng trdng pkap ludt vdn bdn phdp luat diiu chinh cbn thiiu quy dinh Hoat ddng ddo tg.0 lu^t cdn don ddu xu kiidng xdy diing, dp dung dn / | thiic tien xet xil, tiip cdn tink chdt dng dung tkiic kdnh, ddo tgo cie nhdn tkeo ckiidng trinh chdt lUgng cao Trin cd sd dank gid tkiic trang si dung dn le ddo tgo ludt d Viit Nam kiin nay, bdi viit di xudt m^t sdgidi pkdp sil dung dn li ddo tgo ludt nham gop phdn ndng cao chdt liidng ddo tao ludt thdi gian tdi Ta khoa: An li; sd dung dn li ddo tgo; thUc trgng; giai phdp Abstract: One of the ways to improve the legal system in Vietnam is using legal precedents as a complement to existing gaps in legal documents Law education needs to catch tke trend and uses legal precedents in training law undergraduates Basing on an analysis of kow legal precedents are currently used in Vietnam, the author provided suggestions to the use of legal precedents in law education in the upcoming time Keywords: Legal precedent; training; situation; solution Ngdy nhdn bdi:2116/2017;Ngdy siea bdi: 0117/2017;Ngdy duyit dang bdi:29/712017 Dat van de Vdi vai trd quan trpng eua dn If ciing nhu ySu cdu ddi hdi cua thflc tien phap luat d Vift Nam hifn nay, vifc ban hfinh vfifipdungfinIf la rfi't cdn thilt vifc xfiy dung nln kinh t l thi trfldng dinh hudng xa hfii ehu nghia vfi xfiy diing Nhfi nude phap quyin xa hfii chu nghia d Vift Nam Trflde hit, de triln khai phd bien vfi ap dyng dn If thye tiln rapt each hifu qua thi edn dfio tao eho dfldc mdt dpi ngu chuySn gia vl fin If Nhifm vu dd ehi cd thi dfldc thi^c hifn thdng qua vai trd cua giao dye dai hpe ndi chung, dfio tao lufit ndi riSng 1, ThUc trang sit dung an le dao tao luat df Vift Nam hifn stf 7-2017 Tfl nfim 2004 cho de'n nay, Tda an nhan dfin Tdi cao (TANDTC) thfldng xuySn cfing bd nhflng quylt djnh gifim do'c thdm eua Hfi ddng thdm phfin (HDT?) cua TANDTC Dfiy lfi rapt nhflng bflde chudn bj cdn thilt eho sfl thfla nhfin va phfit trien an IS d Viet Nam Nghj djnh 49/ND-TW ngfiy 02 thang 06 nfim 2005 ciia Bfi Chinh trj vi Chiin lUOc cdi cdch tUphdp din ndm 2020 khdng dinh 'Tda fin nhan dan tfii eao ed nhifm vu tdng kit kinh nghifm xet xfl, hfldng dfin ap dyng thdng nhfi't phap lufit, phfit triln an If vfi xlt xfl gifim dde thdm, tai thdm" ViSc nghiSn eflu vefinIf d Vift Nam hifn la ^ ThS, GiSng viSn Hoc vi§n T6a &n NHAN LUC KHOA HQC XA HQI [ Q stjr DVNG AN LE TRONG DAO T ^ O ctir NHAN LUAT vfin d l edp bach Do vay, de fin IS dfldc vifc cd tinh tilt, sfl kifn phdp IS nhfl t r i l n khai vfi phfit trien d Viet Nam thi thi phai dUde giai q u y l t nhU nhau*^ trudc he't nd phai dUde thfla nhfin va fip Su phat t r i l n eua a n IS la mdt dung phu hdp vdi efie dilu kifn eua hf nhiing yS'u tfi' khfic phyc nhflng b a n c h l thong phfip lufit Vift Nam Vfiy, Ifim the he thdng phap lu$t Vift Nam An If nfio de cd dUde nhiJng h i i u bilt ve fin If ndi se chi t i l t hda p h a p luat va vifc thfla ehung d ea gde dp v l ly lufin va thue tiln n h ^ n dp dung nd se l a m cho phap luat dang thUe sfl lfi mfit vfin di cdn d U ^ dflde a p dyng thong nhdt Hdn nfla, nghien eiiu d Vift Nam hifn Tai Dilu 1, Nghj quylt sd 03/2015 cua phat t r i l n dao tao lufit t h i cac b a n a n se cd vai trd la phfldng tifn quan trpng Hpi ddng Thira phan Tda fin nhfin dfin Tdi dao tao luat theo xu hfldng thUe t i i n d eao dinh nghia: "fin IS la nhflng Ifip luan, Vift Nam An IS se khfing t h i phat triln phan quylt b a n dn, q u y l t dinh da cd dUde n l u nd khdng dUdc Tda a n dja hifu lflc phap luat ciia Tda fin ve mdt vy phUdng eung nhU cdng ehflng biet din Vi vifc cu thi "'** Vdi djnh nghia nfiy, khai vfiy, ngofii vifc cfing b l cfic quyet djnh nifm an If da dflde nhfin difn nhflng ehUa gifim dde thdm (cua Hdi ddng thdm phan du ro v l m a t npi dung Bdi le, da sd cung nhfl cua Tda ehuyen trfich) thi vifc eae ban an, quylt dinh, t h i Tda a n thudng sfl dung fin If dao tao lufit d Vift ed n h i l u lap lu^n v l nhiing van d l cdn Nam hifn la rfi't cdn t h i l t giai quyS't cua vy vifc, dd cd t h i la lap T r l n t h e gidi, a n If ditcfc sxi dung rdt luan v l cfic tinh t i l t khfich quan cua vu phd bien Cfic trUdng lulit d My sfl dung fin viec, tinh hdp phfip, tinh hSn quan cua IS Ifim tfii h f u giang day lufit chu ylu chflng efl dUdng sii xufi't trinh, cimg cfi'p hofic lf.p lului v l vifc a p dung quy dinh eu the cua phfip luat Vi v^ly, vdi dinh nghia nSu trSn, cd t h i ddn tdi each h i i u ehUa dflng v l a n IS; dd, Khoan 1, Dilu 2, Nghj quylt s i 03/2015 da t i l p tuc eu t h i hda: "An If dupe lua ehpn phai dap flng dfldc efie tiSu ehi sau dfiy: 1) Chfla dflng Ifip lufin d l Ifim ro quy dinh cua phap l u p edn cd cfieh h i i u khfic nhau; phdn tieh, giai thich cac v&i de, sfl kifn phfip ly vfi Trong efie nUdc thufie h f thfl'ng dan lufit thfinh van, vai trd cua a n If dao tao luat cang dfldc nfing cao, day lfi xu hfldng bi a n h hfldng bdi phfldng phfip dao t^o lufit theo eae trfldng lufit cua My Tfl nfira 2004, cfic trfldng lufit eua Nhfit Ban hdu nhfl d a ehdp n h ^ phfldng phap giang day lufit theo phUdng phap vu vifc nhU cac trudng lufit cua My dang ap dung Cdn d nUdc Dflc, h d u he^ eae mdn hoc lu^t dfldc chi r a nguySn tfic, dfldng IcS xxt ly, quy pham phap lufit cdn a p dyng mft vu vifc cu t h i ; 2) Cd tinh chuan raiic; 3) Cd gifi trj hfldng dan fip dung thohg nhdt phap lufit x l t xxt, bao dam nhflng vu Q] NHANLQC KHOA HQC XAHtfl "' Hdi dong T h ^ p h ^ Toa &a nhan dfin T^i cao, (2015), Ngkf quyit si 03/2015/NQ-HBTP Vi quy trink Ifta ckpn, cdng bivd dp dung dn 1$, Di^u 1,2 f*' HOi d6ng ThSm phan Toa iin nhan dSn Ttfi cao, (2015) Nghi quyit si 03/2Q15/NQ-HBTP Vi^ quy trink lySa chon, cdng bivd dp dung dn 14, Khoan 1, Dilu stf 7-2017 HOANG VAN TOAN giang day vdi sU hd trd cua cac gifio trinh cd hf thfing an If Cho dS'n nay, nhflng t h a n h t y u ma dao tEio luat tai cae ed sd dao tao luat eua Vift mye "Binh luan b a n fin", dd cd ban an dfldc cong bfi' kdm theo ldi binh lufin; V l giao trinh phuc vu giang day thi hdu nhfl khfing cd an IS eua TANDTC Nam t h u dflde la rdt d a n g khich If Cae Nhfl vfiy, da cd viee khai thae fin If d trfldng luat cua Viet N a m da vfi dang p h a t Vift Nam dfio tao lufit nhflng vifc trien khong ngiing d l theo kjp nhflng ddi nfiy cdn rdt b a n ehS' N l u an If da trd hdi cua nhflng t h a y ddi v l kinh tS', xa hpi t h a n h mpt bp phfin khfing t h i thieu cua dat nfldc Tuy nhiSn, tii thfle t i l n dao dfio tao lufit tai P h a p thi d Vift Nam vifc tao tai eae trfldng lufit d Vift N a m hien dfla fin If vfio dfio tao lufit d bae dai hoc va eho thay, dao tao lufit vfin gan vdi sau dai hpc edn la "ngoai IS" Da phdn sinh phfldng phfip giang Iy thuyet t r u y i n thd'ng viSn dai hoe khdng dUde dao tao gfin liln thay vi tfing efldng xu hudng thUe t i i n Vi vdi an IS cua TANDTC De boat dpng vay, dao tg.o lug.t d Viet N a m nSn thay ddi dat hifu qua cao, tac gia de xudt mot sd theo hudng thUe tiSn hdn nfla de t r a n h bi giai phap n h a m tang cUdng sfl dyng an If t u t b a n xa so vdi xu hfldng dao tsto d qua trinh dao tao cfl n h a n lufit d nhflng nfldc phfit t r i l n Vift Nam Cd t h i k h a n g djnh, ddi mdi dfio tao luat d Vift Nam theo xu hfldng gfin vdi thfle t i l n xet xfl la each td't nhdt de tflng bflde Mot so' g i a i p h a p suf d u n g a n le t r o n g d a o t a o lufit Tha nhdt, cdn co mdt ddi ngd chuyin t h a y dfi'i t h a i dp cua cac luat gia Vift Nam gia, gidng viin ludt hiiu biii thUc sU ddy ddi vdifinIS du vi ly ludn vd thUc tiin dn le Trong boi eanh vfi d i l u kifn dao tao YSu cdu quan trpng ddi vdi dfii ngu luat cua Vift N a m hifn nay, da ed vifc sfl chuySn gia, giang viSn lufit lfi sU hieu bie't dung an If dfio tao luat Tuy nhiSn, ddy du v l khfii nifm an If theo nghia an If thflc tien cho tha'y, hosit ddng nfiy cdn rdt cdn phai dUdc hinh t h a n h bdi edc quylt h ^ c h l d bae dai hpc cung nhfl d bae sau dinh eua tda an mfit vu viec cu the dai hoe: Rdt hilra giang viSn dfla a n If vfio vfin tdn tai d Vift Nara D i l u dfin dS'n giang day mfit each hf thfing theo phfldng viee n h i l u ngUdi sai ldm cho rfing chinh phap vy vifc Hdn nfla, dfio tao lufit hifn cac bfio cfio hfing n a m cua TANDTC ve d Viet Nam ndi chung cdn b a n ehS', tdng k i t kinh nghifm xet xfl lfi radt hinh chfla chu trpng d i n truyen t a i k i l n thflc thfle an If hf thd'ng phfip luat Vift thflc tien cho sinh viSn lufit qufi Nam Day la mdt quan nifm chfla thfle sfl trinh dfio tao, bdi vi rdt n h i l u mfin hpc chinh xac Cdn n h a n thflc rang, fin IS bao dfldc giang day mfi chfla cd nhieu sfl minh gid ciing gfin vdi mpt vy vifc cy t h i Cd sfl hpa thfle tien qua cac a n If TrSn cac tap khac bift gifla vifc t i n g k i t kinh nghifm ehi mfi sinh viSn luat dfldc t i l p cfin thi ehi xet xfl eua TANDTC vfi vai trd giai thich riSng cd Tap chi Khoa hpc phfip ly mdi cd phap luat de tao r a cfic fin If eua cac Tda stf 7-2017 NHAN LUC KHOA HQC XA HQI Q ] s d DVNG AN I4) TRONG DAO TAO CtyNHANLUAT an Tdi eao cfic hf thdng phap lufit nude ngofii Bdi vfiy, si^ phat triln fin If cua TANDTC edn phai tfip trung vao ehfle nfing xlt xfl gifim die thim, tfii thdm cae vy an cu thi An If dfldc thfla nhlin d Vift Nam cd nghia lfi vifc edng bd' cde ban an cua TANDTC lfi mdt ySu edu khfing the thilu d Viet Nam Thudng xuySn dua giang viSn tham gia vao cde ldp tfip hudn, bdi dfldng vl vifc s^ dung an If dfio t^o lusit Ben c^nh dd, ddi ngu nfiy nen ehu ddng e^p n h p kien thfle vl ban an, quyS't dinh eua tda an, dfic bift Ifi cfic quylt djnh giam ddc thdm eua Hpi ddng tham phdn TANDTC va cac tfii lif u lufit mdi de gidi thieu, phfin tieh bfii giang Giang viSn lu^t khdng nSn thda raan vdi nhflng hiiu bilt phap lu^t gidi han d hf thing phap luat nflde Sfl tim hiSu, nghien cflu phap luat nflde ngofii thflc tiln xlt xfl, cae fin If cua phfip luat nfldc ngofii cd thi giup cho sinh viSn luat ciia Vift Nam tim thfi'y cac giai phfip phap ly d nUdc ngofii, Tha hai, gida trinh ludt cdn bd sung, lUn h$, vien ddn vd phdn tich nhiiu hOn d^n cdc dn li U efie nude phfit triln, cfic giao tnnh, tfii hfu cfic tnidng lufit du^e xay d}fng theo hinh thflc giao trinh gdn vdi cac an If vfi cfic vfin ban lu^it ed hSn quan Trong dd, hf thd'ng giao trinh luat nhilu trfldng l u ^ d Vift Nam cdn h^n ehe bdi sii gidi h ^ ndi dung d sU phan tich van ban quy pham phap lu^t Cac vi dy phfip lu^t ddn gian cd thi dUdc tim thdy nhilu giao trinh lufit, cae vi dy QI NHANLQC KHOA HQC X A H O I nfiy ehfla thflc sfl la ngudn bd sung thUc tien cho ndi dung ly thuylt cfic gifio trinh dd Ben canh dd, hf thdiig phap luSit Vift Nam dang cd sii gia tfing nhanh chdng nhilu lufit vfi cfic vfin ban phfip quy Vi thi, giang viSn vfi sinh vien lufit ed thi cd sU chu y nhilu hdn tdi cac vfin ban quy pham phfip lufit hdn la viee tim hiiu cfic l u ^ nfiy dUdc ap dung nhU the nao qua cae vy vifc cy thS dUdc xdt xfl bdi tda fin Tuy nhiln, ne'u chflng ta ehi giang day luat vdi cac vfin ban phap lufit thi se khfing dat hifu qua cao Bdi vi, efie vfin ban phap lufit liSn tuc cd sU thay ddi vfi nhiing kien thfle phap lufit quy pham thudn tfly lufin triiu tfldng ddi vdi sinh vien vfi nd se nhanh ehdng bi lac hfiu Chinh vi vfy, giang viSn vfi cfic nhfi nghiSn eflu luSit d nflde ta hifn biSn so^n gido trinh ddi hdi ddng thdi vdi viec phfin tieh vfin ban quy pham phdp luat cdn cd sfl lien hf, vifn dfin, phdn tieh cac an If Giao trinh luat edn hf thd'ng hda cac ban an Dfiy Id mot nhfliig tfii heu quan trpng cho qua trinh dfio tao lufit Mdi cudii gifio trinh cd he thdng hda cfic ban dn dfl^ coi lfi cfic fin If tiSu bieu cho cac linh vflc phap lufit mdi mdn hpe Tha ba, thay ddi viic sa dung dan thudn cdch tiip can vdi phdp lugt theo hudng chl coi v&n ban quy phgm phdp ludt ddo tgo ludt Sinh viSn lu^t d Vift Nam thfldng lfi nhiing hpc sinh tdt n ^ f p trung hpc phi thdng vfi vfldt qua k^ thi dai hpc vfio cac trfldng lu$t se trd thfinh sinh viSn luM Tiidng thudng nfim thfl nhdt ho^c stf 7-2017 HOANG VAN TOAN nfla ddu cua nfim thfl hai nhiing sinh vien luat bfit ddu phai ed gfing di t i l p n h a n cac k i l n thflc cd ban v l phap luat thdng qua mdn hpc "Ly luan v l nhfi nfldc vfi phfip lu|it" Khai niem chinh thflc v l phfip lu^t h e thd'ng phap lu$t XHCN dUde giang cho sinh viSn theo each h i i u phap lufit la hf thd'ng cac quy tfic xfl sU dUde thfla nh$n va ban h a n h bdi Nhfi nfldc Lufit Nhfi nude b a n hfinh dUdc the hifn dudi efie hinh thfle vfin b a n quy p h a m theo luat dinh Cach hieu n a y Iam t a n g thera sfl tin tfldng r a n g chi cd mpt hinh thfle phap luat chinh thflc cd quan n h a nflde ban h a n h hoae thfla n h a n raa thfii Vl vay, thfle tiSn dao tao lufit hifn ddi hdi eae ehuyen gia, ede n h a nghiSn eflu vfi giang day n e n ed each t i l p can vdi khai nifra phap luat thflc tien va da chilu hdn Phfip lu^t nSn h i i u bao gdm: Lufit cd quan Nhfi nUde b a n hfinh va mfit thfle t i l n ciia phap luat (trong dd cd a n If) Cae mdn hpc luat so sanh hifn cd t h i giflp sinh vien lufit md rdng tfl phfip ly de hieu va t i l p cfin hdp ly k i l n thflc cua cfic hS tho'ng phfip lufit trSn t h e gidi Sinh viSn se tim thay sU hflng thii chflc nfing cua fin If d ca hai h e thfiiig d a n luat thfinh vfin va h e thfi'ng thdng lufit Tha tu, chu trgng vdn dung phUOng phdp gidng dgy vu viic ddo tga, bcfi chinh phuang phdp vu viec doi hoi phdi sa dung dn li Phfldng phap nfiy ldn dau t i l n dflde gidi thif u mfit sd trfldng luat eua My tfl cudi the ky XIX Trfldng Dai hpe Lu|it Harvard lfi cd sd dao t^o luat ddu tiSn eua nfldc My gidi thif u vd p h a t trien phfldng stf 7-2017 phap vy vifc dao tao luat Phfldng phap vu vifc la each giang day luat dfla trSn cd sd eae fin If la tfii lifu hpe tfip vfi k i t hdp vdi phfldng phap t r a n h luan gid giang xoay q u a n h npi dung cac an If ciia tda an Hifn nay, phUdng phfip nfiy dflde t i l p n h a n bdi n h i l u trfldng luat eae nfldc thufie he thohg dan luat t h a n h van O Vift Nara, vdn cdn tdn tai nhiing hieu biet chfla thUc sU day du dpi ngu giang viSn day luat v l phUdng phdp vu vifc Mpt sfi' ngUdi nhdm Ifin phUdng phap vy vifc vdi phfldng phfip giai quyS't cfic tinh hud'ng phfip luat mfi giao viSn sfing tao de hdi vfi eho sinh viSn thao lufin thay vi sfl dyng an If cy t h i eua tda fin nhfl ban ehdt eua phfldng phap vu vifc D I ap dung dUde phUdng phfip nfiy vao thiic tien giang day edn phai: Chinh sfla giao trinh theo cfieh phfin tich va binh lufin n h i l u hdn v l cac fin If; giang day can ehu y de'n qua trinh tranh lufin cua sinh vien Bdi vi, sfl tranh luan ddi thoai lfi mpt boat dpng rdt quan trpng eua phfldng phfip nfiy ddi hdi sinh viSn phai chu dpng thao luan cac vu fin, vfi cfic vfin ban tfii lieu lufit khfic mfi giao viSn gidi thifu mdi bai giang Ngofii ra, de cd t h i tham gia vfio ldp hpc sii dung phfldng phap nfiy thi tfi't ca nhflng sinh viSn lu|it eua mfii ldp hpc d i u phai chudn bj cho mdi gid hpc bfing cfieh hp phai dpe vfi phfin tieh r a t ky v l nhflng vy a n theo ySu eau eua mdn hpc Thong thfldng, giang viSn dSit cau hdi dS sinh viSn cd the tdm tdt v l vu an, sau dd sinh viSn se dfldc hdi nhiing cfiu hdi hSn quan deii cac vdh de phfip ludt NHAN LUC KHOA HQC XA HQI Q sti* DUNG AN LE TRONG DAO TAO CU" NHAN LUAT cua vu an de luyfn cho sinh viSn ky nang trSn cfic Tap chi ldn Cae bfii phfin tieh, phfin tich Ifip lufin hdp 1^ doi vdi mdi vu binh luan nfiy thudng dUdc giang viSn fin cy t h i Sinh viSn lufit thfldng xuySn khfic, sinh viSn, nghien cflu sinh dpc dflde khuyS'n khieh tim cac van d l phfip Khdng rapt sach nao phuc vu eho hpc tfip, lufit tfl moi vu an ey t h i cfic an If nghien eflu cfic giang vien cd uy tin Bdng each nfiy sinh viSn lufit ed t h i hpe dflde cdng bd mfi lai khdng ed fin If cua hdi dfldc cfieh dfio sau efie khia canh phfip Tda an T i i cao Phap D i l u dd cho thay, an lufit cfic vy an thflc tien IS eua Tda fin Toi cao P h a p thflc sfl dfi tr3 Phfldng phap vy viSe thfle sii la each di giup sinh vien ren luyfn cdc ky nfing vfi ky thufit sfl dyng an If nhU lfi mdt nguon Tha ndm, thUcfng xuyen cong bo dn li dinh gidm dao tao lufit tai Phap Vifc phan tieh, binh lufin eae an If trSn cac tap chi khoa hpc phfip ly thflc sfl rdt lufit ed ban hf thdng phap lufit vd Quyit t h a n h mdt ndi dung khdng the thieu dfldc ddc thdm cua Hgi cdn thie't cho dfio tao lufit d Vift Nam hifn Hdu h i t cac trfldng lufit cua Vift ludn Nam hifn deu ed cac tap ehi phap lufit kem theo trin cdc tgp chi khoa hgc phdp eua hp Khi fin If, eae quySt dinh quan dong Thdm phdn TANDTC, eo binh ly Bdy chinh Id kinh di cdc bdn dn cua trpng eua TANDTC vfi cac tda fin khac edc tda dn din vdi ngudi dgc mdt cdch hieu ea nflde dflde edng bo', thi cac tap chi qud nhdt nghien cdtu phap ly nSn cap nhfit, phan Trong cfic tai lifu dUde edng bd' d Vift tich vfi binh lufin v l an If, nhflng quyet Nam v l giao trinh Luat so sfinh, Phap hdu djnh, ban an q u a n trpng dd Hoat dong nhu ehi dUdc biet den vdi mdt hf thd'ng se Ifim cho dao tao lufit cua nfldc ta phfip lu$t h a n h van vfi khfing dUdc b i l t gdn hdn so vdi thflc tien eua phap lufit den nhu dat nUdc sfl dyng fin If Tuy Ket l u a n nhien, viee dfio tao luat t^i Phap l£u gdn Trong bm eanh hifn nay, Vift Nam Uln vdi dn If ciia Tda an Tdi cao Phfip Tfl dang giai doan hdi nhfip n l n kinh t l bac dfio tao cii nhfin d i n dfio tao Tien si qude t l , t h a m gia vfio cac d i l u flde thfldng lu^t, hpc viSn d i u phai nghiSn cflu an le mai qud'c t l song phfldng hoae da phUdng eua tda fin tdi cao Phap Hpe vien thudng va gia nhfip WTO Thiie t i l n nfiy d^it xuySn dUde t i l p cfin vdi n h i l u quyet djnh ySu cdu lfi eong tae tfii p h a n phai t i l p eSin gifim doc tham eua Tda fin tm eao Phfip cfic vy fin ed y l u td' nUde ngoai Dilu nfiy eae mdn hpc ehinh Sinh vien dfldc tao dUde sfl tin tfldng eua edng ddng qud'c ySu cdu phfin tieh, binh lufin quyet dinh te nhfl lfi mpt d i l u kifn quan trpng de cfic eiia Tda an tdi cao Phfip nhfl mdt ho^t doanh n h a n cd t h i ySn t a m v l vifc lfla ddng hpe tap thfldng xuyen Hdn nfla, ehpn tfii p h a n t a i Vift Nam thay vi phai quylt dinh giam dd'c thdm quan trpng ciia dfla vy t r a n h cha'p r a cfic ed quan tfii phfin Tda an tdi cao Phap thfldng dxiac giang eua nflde ngofii Vifc sii dung fin If tao vien dai hpc cd uy tin phan tich, bhih lufin sfl binh dfing vifc x6t xii cac vu Q NHANLQC KHOA HQC XA HQI stf 7-2017 HOANGVANTOAN gidng nhau, gdp p h d n giai thieh cac quy djnh chfla ro cua phfip luat, tien doan Nam", Tgp chi Tda dn nhdn ddn, ky I, thang 10 (sd 19) d\i(ic k i t qua giai quylt vu an, tang cfldng Lflu Tien Dung (2003), Thae si lufit hpe, "Vai trd eua fin IS d eae nfldc theo He nhan, to chflc vfi ngofii nfldc v l tinh thdng Common Law (eommonlaw) vfi cac minh bach, cfing k h a i cua hf thfi'ng Tda nflde theo hf thd'ng dfin lufit (civil law)", an Chmh vi vfiy, cac trfldng dao tao Thdng tin khoa hgc xet xa, sd 5, TANDTC Hdi ddng T h d m phfin TAND tfii cao lufit, vifc a\t d u n g a n If eua TANDTC edn 03/2015/NQ-HBTP dxioc quan tfim hdn An If cua TANDTC cd (2015A Nghi quyit dfldc thye sfl phfit t r i l n hay khfing phy vi quy trinh lUa chgn, cong bd'vd dp dung thude n h i l u vfio cfic trfldng T h i l t dn le Khoa Lu^t - Trfldng D ^ hpc NewYork nghi neu dfldc tiep cfin vdi a n IS tfl cdn hpc tai n h a t n i d n g thi r a trUdng sinh (2007), NhOng vdn di cO bdn cua ludt viSn se khdng bd ngd vdi thUe t i l n va hp phdp My, Nxb Chinh trj qude gia, Ha Ndi Nguyen Vfin Nam (2007), NghiSn eflu sfl dung a n If n h u mdt IS dUdng nhiSn giai quylt cae va'n d l p h a p Iy thude linh so sfinh ngudn lufit fin If hf thdng Phfip lufit nfldc Anh, Tgp chi Nghiin cOu viie eua minh ChduAu, (so 3) 10 Nguyin Vfin Nam (2011), Ly lufin T A I L I E U T H A M KHAO vfi thUc tien v l fin If hf t h i n g phfip Bd Chinh tri (2002), Nghi quyit sd lufit cua cfic nUdc Anh, My, Phfip, Dfle vfi 08/NQ-TW ngdy 02-1-2002 vi Mdt sd nhiing kieii nghi ddi vdi Vift Nam, Lu4n an nhiim vu trgng tdm cua cdng tdc tUphdp tiSn SI Lufit, Trfldng Dai hoe Luat Ha Ndi BS Chinh trj (2005), Nghi quyit sd 11 Tda fin nhfin dfin Tfii eao, Cd quan 48/NQ-TW ngdy 24-5-2005 vi Chiin lUOc h