Shi hdnh phdp ludl 86 10 (331)-2019 Xir LY VI PHAM PHAP LUAT VE KIEM SOAT SUY THOAI NGU$N LOi THAY SAN THEO QUY DjNH CAA P H A P LUAT VIET NAM HIEN HANH • NGUYEN B A H I / N G ' Tdm tat; Bdi viit di cgp din vdn di xti ly vi phgm phdp lugt ve kiim sodt suy thodi ngudn lgi Ihuy sin Iheo quy dfnh cua phip lugl Vigt Nam hign hdnh, tit do, de xudt mptsd gidi phdp nhdm ndng cao higu qud cdng tdc ndy tmng thdi gian tdi Abstract; This article Is concerned with the handling law violations in eontmlling degradation of aquatic resoumes in accordance with the existing law of Vietnam, thereby, pmposes some solutions to impmve Ihe effectiveness of this work in next lime Xi> ly v! p h j m phdp ludt v i klim sodt suy tic, chO t h i , hlnh thire, hlnh ty, thd Igc khl xd IJvl thodi n g u i n \ifi thdy sdn theo quy djnh cua phdp ph^m hdnh chinh n i l chung vd klim sodt suy thoil luft Vift Nam hifn hdnh nguin lpi thiy sdn ndi riing Theo quy djnh cua phdp ludt Vifit Nam hifin hdnh, Vdn bdn phdp lufit quy dinh trye tiip hdnh vl vl viic xd \f cde hdnh vi vl pham phdp lufit v i klim sodt ph^m hdnh chinh klim sodt suy thodi nguin lpi suy thodi nguin lpi Ihiy sdn dupe thyc hifin dudi hai thiy sdn Id Nghj djnh s i 42/2019/ND-CP ngdy hlnh thdc Id xd 1;^ vl ph^m hdnh ehlnh hodc tmy cdu 16/5/2019 c i a Chlnh phfl quy djnh xd ph^t vl ph^m trdch nhifim hlnh sy d i i vdi t i chdc, cd nhdn cd hdnh vl vl ph^m Cg thi: 1.1 xa tf edc hinh vl vl phftn hinh chlnh vi klim soit suy thoil nguin lgi thiy sin hdnh ehlnh ITnh vi/e thuy sdn c i hifiu lyc thi hdnh k i td ngdy 05/7/2019 (Ngh| djnh s i 42/2019/NB-CP) - Hdnh vi vi phgm hinh chlnh kiim sodl suy Hifin nay, xd 1;^ vl ph^m hdnh chlnh v i klim sodt thoil nguin /pi thiy sin dut^c thgc hlln dudi cic suy thodi nguin lpi thiy sdn dupc quy d|nh d Lufit Xd 1:^ vi ph^m hdnh chlnh ndm 2012; Nghj djnh s i d^ng sau: (I) Nhim hdnh vi vi ph?m v i bdo vfi mfil tnrdng 81/2013/ND-CP ngdy 19/7/2013 cua Chlnh phd quy sing e i a edc lodi thOy sdn: Ddy Id nhdng hdnh vi djnh ehi tiit mit s i diiu vd bifin phdp thi hdnh Luft t i chdc, cd nhdn thuc hiin dnh hudng tdi hdnh lang X d IJ vl ph?m hdnh chlnh; Nghj djnh s i 97/2017/NO- dl chuyin, dudng di cu, khu sinh sdn tfip tmng, noi CP ngdy 18/8/2017 cOa Chlnh p h i sda dii, b i sung cu trd e i a cde lodi thdy sdn mfit s i diiu eOa Nghj djnh s i 81/2013/NB-CP ngdy (II) Nhdm hdnh vi vi ph^m v i bdo vfi cde lodi thiy 19/7/2013 cua Chlnh p h i quy djnh chi tiit mfil s i sdn: Nhdm ndy g i m nhttng hdnh vi thyc hifin khfing diiu vd bifin phdp thi hdnh Lufit X d IJ vi ph?m hdnh ddng quy trinh, phuong dn khai thdc Idm dnh hudng chlnh Nhdng vdn bdn ndy quy djnh khung v i nguyin x i u d i n s i lupng, chit lupng eda lodi thdy sdn, nhu: I Ddn ch£i & Phdp ludt • Bg Ndng nghigp vd Phdt triin ndng thdn Shi hdnh phdp ludl 8610 (331)-2019 Vi ph^m quy djnh v i khu vyc cim khai thdc thiy sdn; - Vi thim quyin xd phgt vi phgm hinh chlnh vl phym quy djnh v i qudn ly edc lodi thdy sdn nguy kiim soit suy thoii nguSn /pf ihdy sin: Chu thi cip, quJ, hiim ed thim quyin xd phat vl ph?m hdnh chlnh hong (Ill) Nhdm hdnh vl vl pham v i khai thdc trdi phdp kiim sodt suy thodi nguin Ipi thuy sdn dupc quy djnh nhu: VI ph^m quy djnh v i giiy phip khai thde; vl eg thi tu Diiu 46 din Diiu 53 Nghj djnh s i ph^m quy djnh v i han ngach sdn lupng khai thdc 42/2019/ND-CP Trong nhttng ehd thi cd thim quyin thiy sdn; sd dgng cde ngu cy bj cim d i khai thdc xd phfit viphamhdnhehlnh klim sodt suy thodi thily sdn; vi ph^m quy djnh v i sd dyng difin d i khai nguin Ipi thiy sdn, kiim ngu Id chu thi mdi dupc thdc thuy sdn, vl ph^m quy dlnh v i tdng trO, sd dgng quy djnh Lufit Thiy sdn ndm 2017, theo dd, ehit cim, hda chit cim, chit dfic d i khai thdc thiy klim ngu Id It^c lupng chuyfin trdch eua Nhd nudc, sdn; vi ph^m vCing khai thdc thiy sdn thyc hiin chdc ndng thyc thi phdp lufit Vifit Nam vd - vi hlnh thdc xd' If vi ph^m hinh chlnh ttong diiu ude quic t i ed lifin quan md nude Cfing hda xd kiim soit suy thoii nguin li;ii Ihdy sin: Hlnh thdc xd hfii chi nghTa Vifit Nam Id thdnh vifin v i khai thdc vd ph^t ehinh dii vdi hdnh vl vi ph^m klim sodt bdo vfi nguin lpi thOy sdn Cd thi thiy, Lufit Thuy suy thodi nguin lpi thiy sdn Id ph^t tiin lin din sdn ndm 2017 dd tao co sd phdp IJ d i lyc lupng 1.000.000.000 ding I^de tlin phat dupc quy djnh kiim ngu hofit dfing i n djnh, ding quy d|nh vd d|nh Nghj djnh s i 42/2019/ND-CP Id mdc dp dgng hudng phdt triin cia ngdnh, qua d i , ndng cao hifiu dil vdi cd nhdn, tn> hdnh vi vi ph^m quy djnh v i qudn qud klim sodt suy thodi nguin Ipi thiy sdn Klim IJ cdng ed T i chdc c i eCing hdnh vi vl ph^m nhu cfla ngu thye hifin klim tra vd xfl IJ edc vl phfim v i bdo cd nhdn Ihl mde ph^t tlin bdng hai lin mdc phfit tiin vfi nguin Ipi thuy sdn, dfic bifit Id cde ho^t dfing khai dil vdi cd nhdn TCiy theo tinh chit, mdc d i vl phfim thde mang tinh chit hOy difit, gfip phin ndng cao hifiu md t i chdc, cd nhdn cin c i thi hi dp dyng cde hlnh qud kiim sodt suy thodi nguin Ipi thiy sdn thdc xfl ph^t b i sung nhu: Tudc quyin sd dyng giiy Trfin thyc tlin, gin 05 ndm, k i tfl khl thdnh phdp, ehdng chl hdnh nghi c i thdi hfin, dlnh chl ho^t Ifip, Klim ngu Vifit Nam dd phdt hifin, klim sodt, ding cd thdi hfin; tjch thu tang vfit, phuong tifin ngdn chfin 80.145 lupt chiic, d i , tdu cd nudc Ngodl ra, t i ehde, ed nhdn cin cd thi b| dp dyng cde ngodi Id trin 42.000 lupt chiic vi phfim phdp lufit v i bifin phdp khie phyc hiu qud nhu: Buic thd thiy sdn thfly sdn trin edc vCing blinl Trong 06 thdng diu cin sing tid Ifii mil trudng sing cOa chung; bufic ndm 2019, Ting cyc Thfly sdn dd xfl phfit 78 tdu ed chuyin giao thiiy sdn thufie danh myc lodi thdy sdn vl phfim vdi ting s i tiin xd ph^t Id 222,6 trifiu ding nguy cip, quJ, hiim dd chit cho co quan e i thim Chi 02 thdng diu ndm 2019, Chi cge Thiy sdn quyin d i xd IJ; buic thd b i sung thOy sdn nguy cip, Nghi An dd phil hpp vdi edc Din biin phing tuyin quJ, hiim theo quy djnh; bufic thdo dd tdu ed thuic biin, Chi cyc Klim ngu vOng thyc hiin kiim diin cim phdt triin hofic tdu cd dupc ddng mdi, cdi 156 phuong Ufin Qua d i , phdt hiin vd xd phfit vi hodn khing ed vdn bdn chip thufin cia co quan c i phfim hdnh chlnh 29 phuong tifin vdi ting s i tlin thim quyin; bufic khfil phyc Ifii tinh trfing ban diu dii 162.300.000 ding; tjch thu 06 bfi kich difin, 05 ludi vdi cde phdn khu chdc ndng Khu bdo tin biin, gid, 145 ddy dlfin^ Chi cyc ThOy sdn TP Dd Ning dd mil tn/dng sing cda thdy sdn, khu vyc biin t i chflc 02 dpt tra, klim tra 570 tdu cfi vd dd Ddn chit & Phdp lu^t Q I Shi hdnh phdp ludi xd phat hdnh chlnh 04 hfinh vi vi ph^m v i khfing cd 3610(331)-2019 ndy vd khfing quy djnh thu h i i giiy phfip khai thfic Id nhfit kJ khai thdc thdy sdn, khfing ghi nhfit kJ khai mfit tttmg nhttng hinh thde xfl phal Mfit nhttng thdc theo quy djnh^ hudng hpp bj thu h i i giiy phfip khai thfic Id khai thdc Cd t h i n i l , hfi thing phdp lufit v i xd IJ vl phfim thdy sdn trdi phfip ngodi vflng biin Vifit Nam dupc hdnh ehlnh ITnh vyc thdy sdn ndi chung, hong quy djnh tai Diiu 26 Nghj djnh s i 42/2019/ND-CP chi klim sodt suy thodi nguin lpc thuy sdn ndi rifing quy djnh hlnh thde xfl phat b i sung Id tudc quyin sfl ngdy cdng dupc hofin thifin, phfl hpp vdi thyc Uin, dyng giiy phfip hofit dfing h> 03 thdng d i n 12 thdng chO truong vd thfing Ifi quic t i Dfic bifit Id vlfic ban Nhu vfiy, Nghj djnh s i 42/2019/ND-CP dd thu hfip hdnh Nghj djnh s i 42/2019/ND-CP gIDp hodn thifin hinh thdc xfl phfit so vdi quy djnh tai Lufit Thiy sdn hfi thing vdn bdn Ngdnh Thiy sdn, qua dd, gdp phin ndm 2017 dua phdp lufit vdo thpc t i mfit cdch nhanh hon, hifiu (li) Nghj djnh s i 42/2019/ND-CP quy djnh bufic qud hon, bdo ddm tinh khd thi eda phdp lufit Bfin chuyin giao thOy sdn thufie danh mge nguy cip, quJ Cfinh dd, nfing cao J thde, trfich nhifim cda ngudi ddn hiim dd ehit cho co quan cd thim quyin d i xfl IJ v i kiim sodt suy thodi nguin \i/c thfly sdn Tuy nhifin, Khodn Diiu Nghj djnh s i 26/2019/NO-CP quy thye tlin cho thiy, c i n nhiiu k h i khdn hong vific bdo dinh tnjdng hpp tang vfit Id bfi phfin hofic cd t h i dd vfi nguin lpi thfly sdn, vl dg d tinh Qudng Ninh, vdi chit phdl dupc bdn giao cho Bdo tdng Thiin nhiin dja bdn qudn IJ rfing, e i nhiiu ddo, vCing vjnh vd Viit Nam hofic co quan nghiin cflu khoa hpc d i Idm luing dl Ifii Irfin biin, tdu thuyin phdn tdn d edc ngu tifiu bdn, tmng bfiy, nghifin cflu, tuyfin truyin, gido tnidng khdc khiin cing tdc klim tra, klim sodt dye hofic tliu hfly Tuy nhiin, thdi gian phdn hOy cOa c i a ede lye lupng ehflc ndng gfip nhiiu khd khfin cde lodi thiy sdn Id khdc d i n tdl vlfic khl bdn Cfic d i l tupng x i u cd t h i tfin dgng y i u t i nfiy d i giao cho cde co quan c i thim quyin thi bfi phfin thyc hifin edc hdnh vl vi phfim Bfin Cfinh dd, hofie efi t h i khfing cdn dd tifiu chuin d i Idm tifiu bdn, chfim t r i qud trlnh xdy dyng vd ban hdnh vdn tnrng bdy hay nghifin cflu Bfin cfinh dd, m i i co quan bdn quy ph^m phdp lufit nfin mfit s i hdnh vi vl phfim c i thim quyin tiip nhfin chuyin giao thiiy sdn nguy mdi dupc phdt hifn nhung chua c i quy djnh d i xd cip, quJ, hiim phdi cd hfi thing, quy binh bdo qudn, IJ vl phfim hdnh chlnh; quy djnh c i a phdp lufit c i sy xd IJ Bdi vfiy, s i t i n kfim kinh phi cOng nhu hifiu qud bit cfip, c i sy mdu thuin gitta cde vdn bdn quy kiim sodt khing cao pham phdp lufit gdy khd khdn cho co quan chdc Xfl IJ vl ph^m hdnh ehlnh ludn ding val trd quan ndng vlfic xd IJ vi phfim td d i u ndm 2019 d i n trpng trang xd IJ vi phfim phdp lufit ndi chung, Cy thi: (I) Khodn Diiu SO Lufit Thuy sdn ndm 2017 vd kiim sodt suy thodi nguin lyc thiy sdn n i i rifing s i vg vi ph^m cdn nhiiu s§ dnh hudng tdl myc tliu khodn Diiu 45 Nghj djnh s i 26/2019/ND-CP ngfiy md phdp lufit m u i n diiu chlnh Do dd, nfing cao J 08/3/2019 c i a Chinh phi quy djnh chl tiit mfit s i thdc cOa ngudi dfin vifc c h i p hfinh quy d|nh diiu vd bifin phdp thi hdnh Luft Thfly sdn (Nghj djnh cila phdp luft v i klim sodt suy thodi nguin lpi thiy s i 26/2019/ND-CP) cfi quy djnh trudng hpp thu h i i sdn, gidm s i lupng ode vy vi phfim hdnh chlnh l i giiy phfip khai thdc Ihdy sdn Tuy nhiin, Nghj djnh s i diiu md cde co quan qudn IJ nhd nudc c i n hudng 42/2019/ND-CP khfing quy djnh nhttng tnrdng hpp tdi I Ddn chd & Phdp ludt Shi hdnh phdp luM 8610 (331)-2019 1.2 Xir If cic hanh vl phfm t^i gay suy thoai cda phdp lufit, qua d6 c i nhflng hdnh dpng phO hpp, nguin Igi thdy sin Bfi lufit Hlnh sy ndm 2015 vd Lufit sfla dii, b i sung mfit s i diiu cua Bfi lufit Hlnh sy s i trdnh vl ph^m phdp lufit Gin ddy, thing qua cde kdnh tmyin thing dai chflng, chOng ta biit dupc vlfic mua bdn tfim hOm dit 100/2015/QH13 khfing quy djnh tfil danh rifing dil vdi (tim edng di) thufie danh myc sinh vfit ngo?l lai cim edc ChO thi pham tfii gdy suy thodi nguin lye thuy nhfip khiu vfio Vifit Nam (ban hdnh kfim theo Thfing sin Tuy nhifin, Lufit quy djnh mfit s i diiu c i lifin quan lu s i 35/2018/n-BTNMT ngdy 28/12/2018 cOa Bfi din nguin lpi thuy sdn, mfil trudng sing cua thOy sdn Tdi nguyin vd Mfil hudng) Vlfic kinh doanh, tifiu thy nhu: Tfii hOy hoai nguin lpi thOy sdn (Diiu 242); Tfii lodi ndy Ifi vl phfim quy djnh phdp lufit v i da dang vi pham v i qudn ly, bdo vfi ding vfit nguy eip, quJ, sinh hpc vd thuy sdn Ngudi ndo c i tinh nhfip khiu, hiim (Biiu 244); Tfil vl ph^m edc quy djnh v i qudn IJ phdt tdn lofil tim hum d i ndy se bj tmy cflu trdch khu bdo tin thifin nhiin (Diiu 245); Tfii nhfip khiu, nhifim hlnh sy quy djnh theo Diiu 246 Bfi lufit Hinh phdt tdn edc Icdl ngo^l lal xdm h^l (Diiu 246) sy ndm 2015 (sda dil, b i sung ndm 2017) v i tfil Tmy cflu trdeh nhifim hlnh sy phdp nhdn quy djnh nhfip khiu phdt tfin edc lodi ngofii lal xdm hfii Bfi lufit Hlnh sy ndm 2015 Id diim mdi eOa phdp lufit hlnh sy Nfii dung nfiy dupc quy djnh tpi Vfla qua, Fonnosa - mfit phdp nhdn dd gdy sy c i mii trudng biin nghiim hpng tfii 04 h'nh ven biin Chuong XI gim 16 diiu vd rdi rdc trang mfit s i diiu miin Tmng (Hfi TTnh, Qudng Binh, Qudng Tq vd khdc Phdp nhdn thuong mai phdl chju tifich nhifim Thua Thiin Hui) Cd biin ehit hdng lofiL dnh hudng hlnh sy Irong 31 tfil ph^m quy djnh t^i Diiu 76, trang tdl nguin lpi thOy sdn ven bd, lofii sinh vfit biin ting dd, edc hdnh vl phfim tfil gdy suy thodi nguin Ipi thuy dfiy, hOy difit cfic rfin san hi Bfi Tdl nguyfin vfi Mfil sdn vdi chi tdl gim 03 hlnh thfle chinh Ifi: Phfit tiin, tmdng phil hpp cung Vifin Hdn Idm Khoa hpc vd dinh chi ho^t dfing cd thdi h^n vd dlnh ehi ho^t dfing Cing nghfi Vifit Nam, vdi sy tham gia cOa nhiiu nhd VTnh viin; 03 hlnh ph^t b i sung (cim kinh doanh, khoa hpc vfi ngodi nudc tlin hdnh diiu ha, ciin ho?t dfing mfit s i ITnh vyc nhit dinh; eim ddnh gid vd chi sau thdi gian khodng 02 thdng dd tim huy dfing vin; ph^t tlin khl khing dp dyng Id phfit nguyin nhdn vd xdc djnh thi ph^m gdy sy c i Id chlnh); 04 biin phdp tu phdp (tjch thu vfil, tiin Iryc Cing ty TNHH Hung Nghifip Fomiosa Hd TTnh tiip llin quan din til phfim; trd ifii tdl sdn sda chfla (Fomiosa) Trudc nhttng chflng cfl khoa hpc vd rfi hofic bii thudng thifit hfii, bufic cing khai xin lii; rdng, Fonnosa dd phdl nhfin bfich nhifim vd xin lii buic khil phye l^i tinh tr^ng ban diu; buic thyc hiin Chlnh phO, nhdn ddn Viit Nam v i viic gdy sy c i mil s i bifin phdp khic phyc, ngdn chfin hfiu qud tiip mfii trudng biin miin Tmng Ngdy 30/8/2016, tyc xdy ra) Bfin Cfinh d i , vdi vlfic djnh r i ranh gidl gifla vl ph^m hdnh chlnh vdi tfil phfim d Diiu 242 B i lufit Hlnh sy ndm 2015 s i glOp edc CO quan t i tyng thing nhit, thufin tifin, minhbfich vific gidi quyil cde vv vific vl pham gdy suy thodi nguin Ipi thOy sdn; t i chflc, ed nhdn cOng d i ddng hiiu dupc cfic quy djnh Formosa dd hodn thdnh viie thyc hiin chuyin tiin bil thudng cho Viit Nam vdi ting s i tlin Id 500.000.000 d i la MJ theo ding cam kit Ding thdi, B i Tdl nguyin vd Mii hudng cOng dd ban hdnh quyit djnh xfl ph^t vi phfim hdnh chlnh dil vdi Formosa vdi s i tiin phfit Id 4.485.000.000 ding vd buic Fonnosa phdl thye hifin cfie bifin phdp khic Ddn chCi & Phdp ludt @ Shi hdnh phdp luM 86 10 (331)-2019 phyc hfiu qud vi ph^m theo quy djnh eOa phdp lufit klim sodt cudng lyc khai thde, bdo ddm sd dyng bin Nhu vfiy, Formosa khfing bj khdi t i vflng, klim sodt suy thodi nguin lpi thOy sdn Ba li, vlfic xdy dyng k i hofich tuin ba, klim sodt Tfl nhflng quy djnh vd vy vifie trfin cd thi thiy ring, quy djnh v i vlfic xfl IJ edc hdnh vl phfim tfil gdy dya bin ddnh gid tinh hlnh thyc tiin v i tdu thuyin, suy thodi nguin Ipc thOy sdn Urong dil diy dO Tuy ngu tmdng, cfin cfl mia vy, thdi t i i t Nfii dung ki nhifin, din nay, chua cd vg khdi l i theo quy djnh cOa hofich phdl xdc djnh rfi myc tifiu, phfim vi triin khai, nfii dung, phuong phfip triin khai, don vj chO til, phii Bfi lufit Hlnh sy ndm 2015 Mpt s i gidi phdp ndng cao hifu qud xfl IJ vi hpp d i nfing cao hifiu qufi klim sodt nguin lpi thOy phjm phip ludt v i kiim sodl suy thoil nguin Ipi sdn Xfl IJ nghifim cde trudng hpp tdu cd vi ph?m thdy sdn d Vift Nam thdi gian tdl quy djnh v i khai thdc D i tdng cudng vd ndng cao hifiu qud hofit dfing Bin li, tdng cudng kiim tra, gidm sdt vific ddng kiim tra, tra vd xfl IJ cfic hdnh vi vi phfim phdp kJ, ddng klim tdu cfi vd cip giiy phfip khai thdc thOy Iufil v i klim sodt suy thodi nguin Ipi thOy sdn d Vifit sdn Cin cd bifin phdp xd IJ nghifim khic edc tmdng Nam hifin ein thyc hifin mfit s i gidl phdp sau hpp khai thdc khl chua c i giiy phfip khai phfip khai ddy: M^t li, tiip tge hodn thifin phdp lufit xfl IJ vi ph^m thdc Nim li, thiit Ifip hfi thing bdo qudn lodi thOy sdn phdp lufit v i kiim sodt suy thodi nguin Ipi thOy sdn nguy cip, quJ, hiim phyc vy cing tdc nhfn chuyin theo hudng sda dil cde quy djnh chua rfi rdng, Ihliu giao tfl t i chdc, cfi nhdn vl phfim nhim ndng eao Hnh khd thi; thing nhit nfii dung edc quy djnh c i sy hiiu qud bdo v i lodi IhOy sdn mdu thuin gifla edc vdn bdn quy phfim phdp lufit d i Siu ti, Sio tfio, ndng cao nghifip vg eda lyc tfio sy thufin lpi, ding nhit hong vific hiiu yd dp lupng klim ngu Diu tu dfil tfiu m?nh d i Ihyc thi dgng phdp lufit, ching hfin nhu, ein ed sy thing nhit nhifim vg, trang bj cfing cg h i trp, thiit bj hifin d^l vi gitta Lufit ThOy sdn ndm 2017, Nghj djnh s i c i ehlnh sdeh tdl ehfnh bdo ddm diiu kifin, chi dfi 26/2019/ND-CP vdi Nghj djnh s i 42/2019/NB-CP Idm vlfic cOa klim ngu d i hp yfin tdm hoat dfing gidm viic quy djnh md rfing hay thu hpp hlnh thflc xfl sdt khai thde thOy sdn trfin biin Lyc lupng klim ngu phfit vl phfim hdnh chlnh v i klim sofit suy thodi eQng Id lyc lupng tiip xOc nhiiu vdi ngu ddn, thyc nguin lpi thOy sdn hifin hudng din, ndng cao J thdc cOa ngu ddn chip Hal li, eo quan qudn IJ nhd nudc tfl uong hdnh cde quy djnh cOa Nhfi nudc, hiiu rS hon v i val din dja phuong phil hpp vific xdy dyng k i tri cOa nguin Ipi IhOy sdn khing chl dflng Ifii d gid trj hojch tra, klim tra vd triin khai cfing tde qudn kinh t i , vl vfiy vlfic ddo tao vd ndng cao nghifip vg IJ nhd nude ho^t dfing khai thde thOy sdn nhim cOa lyc lupng klim ngu Id vific Idm cin thiit • 1.htlpsMx)ilie.vn/Uem-ngu-phal-hien-42-OOO^uot-taiH:a-mioc-ngoai-vl-pham-lmng-S-nBm2019041214311293.htm htlp://vasep.a>m.vn/rin-Tuc/1462_54782/Chan-chinh-linh-lrang-khal-lhachatsan-bat-hop-phap.htm, tmy c$p ngiy 14/3/2019 httpsM>neii/s.vn/dB-neng-km-golcac-dia-phuong-khac-phuc-the^ang-iiiu/1205SZhbnl, tniy dp ngiy 25/4/201S, I Ddn chO & Phdp ludt ... 8610 (331)-2019 Vi ph^m quy djnh v i khu vyc cim khai thdc thiy sdn; - Vi thim quyin xd phgt vi phgm hinh chlnh vl phym quy djnh v i qudn ly edc lodi thdy sdn nguy kiim soit suy thoii nguSn /pf... thufin tifin, minhbfich vific gidi quyil cde vv vific vl pham gdy suy thodi nguin Ipi thOy sdn; t i chflc, ed nhdn cOng d i ddng hiiu dupc cfic quy djnh Formosa dd hodn thdnh viie thyc hiin chuyin... IJ vi hpp d i nfing cao hifiu qufi klim sodt nguin lpi thOy phjm phip ludt v i kiim sodl suy thoil nguin Ipi sdn Xfl IJ nghifim cde trudng hpp tdu cd vi ph?m thdy sdn d Vift Nam thdi gian tdl quy