Giải quyết tình huống phản ánh giáo viên có hành vi xâm phạm thân thể học sinh trong giờ học ở trường THPT

BO GIAO DIJC VA DA0 TAO TRIFONG CAN BO QUAN LY GIAO DUC TP HO CHI MINH Lop Boi duffing nghip vu ging the vién tra giao dye Kho6 21/08/2017 Tên tieAu 1u4n: Giai quy6t tinh phan dnh Gido viên có hanh vi )(dm pham than thé hoc sinh gier day hoc Trtremg THPT Dinh Tiên Hoang - huylèn San Tay - tinh Quang Ngai Ngtx PHAM VAN NAM Don vi cang tac: Trueyng THPT Dinh Tién Hoang, xa Son Dung, huyn San Tay, tinh Quang Ngai Quang Ngai, thAng 08/2017 NIVC LUC Trang MVC LUC MO dau Nei dung MO to tinh Xac dinh muc tieu xir ly tinh - Phan tich tinh De xuat nhfing giai phap TO chic thut hien gidi phdp de dat duct muc flew 11 Kik nghi, de xuat 14 III Ket Juan IV.Tai lieu tham khan 15 17 I MO DAU Trueng THPT Dinh Tien Hodng dOng tren dia it mien Ind cria huyen San Tay, tinh Quang Ngai, thutic 62 huyen ngheo cua ca nu gc each Thd.nh phO Qudng Ngai him 80km Nam hoc 2017-2018 nha tracing co 14 lap v gi tong so On 500 hoc sinh, hoc sinh em deng bdo dan toe thieu s6 chiem tren 97% Muc tiéu cua nhd truOng la ciao tao ngutin nhdn luc, g6p phan nang cao dan tri, bOi dugng phan tai timg boat dua huyen Son Tay thodt ngheo ben vang NU tru&ng co mot dOi ngii gido vien ire luOn co gang hoc tap nang cao trinh chinh tri va chuyén mOn nghiep vu, gido vien co trinh dO dat chuan la 100%, tren chuan la 7% Cling \Teri su phdt trien cua dat nu gc, thai buei cua kinh to tri thac va hOi nhap quOc to dOi hOi ngired phdi nang d'Ong sang tao Tap the cong vien chac ya nguiri lao dOng tai don vi khOng ngang hoc tap trau rOi them nhang kinh nghiem va sg sang tao cong tae quan ly, day va h9c, tich cgc do' i mei phuang phdp day hoc, dau to soan gilding, day manh viec ling dung cong nghe thOng tin cong the quan 132 va gide duc Tit lap truOng den nay, nha truemg chua bao gib de xay tinh can WO, gido vien, phan vien, phu huynh ya hoc sinh cling nhu than dan xung quanh nhd truong co nhang Wen anh, don thu gui den nha truang Cho den mot ngdy, cu the la 14/03/2017, lan dau tien nhd tru&ng nhan dugc dan phan anh cua co Dinh Thi A, Id phu huynh cua hoc sinh Dinh Van B phan anh thay Nguyen Van X co hánh vi danh hoc sinh gig day hoc mOn Todn 16p 11B1 cua truCmg NOi dung phan anh teen thuOc tham quyen giai guy& cita Hieu tnreng nhd tru&ng va de nghi nhd trirOng co bien phdp xi'r ly ya thOng bdo ket qua cho co Dinh Thi A Tir thuc to da xay ra, tOi guy& dinh chon de tai bai tieu luan cu6i khod la "Gicii quyEt tinh huang phcin dnh Gido vien co hanh vi -ram phym than thl hoc sinh gia dyy h9c a Trwang THPT Dinh Tien Holm - huyen San Tay - tinh Qucing Ngai" II NOI DUNG MO to tinh huOng vao lac 8h30 15/4/2017 co Dinh Thi A Id phu huynh hoc sinh Dinh Van B dang hoc lgp 11B1 ndm hoc 2016-2017 tai truang, den tru gng xin dugc gap Hieu trugng de gfri dun phan anh viec gido vien co BIM vi xam pham than the hoc sinh gi g day hoc mOn Toan Nhung Hieu -in/Ong nha truong co cuOc hop a SO Gido dgc y a Dao tao nen khOng gap dugc, co Dinh Thi A gui lai dun tai co Van thu nha truang, niter co Van thu gui truc tiep don cho Hieu tru gng Ngdy horn sau Hieu truOng nhan dugc don cin co A to co Van thu, not dung don nhu sau: " CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM DOc lap — Ty Do — Hanh phin DON PHAN ANH - Kinh Hieu truOng Trtreyng THPT Dinh Tien Honig TOi ten: Dinh Thi A — Sinh nam 1972 Thuemg ThOn Dak Tren, xa Son Dung, huyen Son Tay La phu huynh hoc sinh Dinh Van B dang hoc lop 11B1 nam hoc 2016-2017 Nay tOi viet don giri den Hieu truOng TruOng THPT Dinh Tien Hoang trinh bay su viec nhu sau: Vao luc 19h00 tai ngdy 13/04/2017 ca nha dang an corn tai thi tOi thay tai cam din an com rat khO khan, tOi hOi thi dugc trinh bay lai, cu the: Trong fiat hoc man Toni sang thu hai, ngdy 13/04/2017, thAy gido Nguyen Van X la gido vien cua tnrang, dau tiet Tont bap 11B1 thay kiem tra vex' bai tap town cim hoc sinh, nhitng hoc sinh nao khOng lam bai tap town thay cho ve nha thi bi thay lay coy thuac danh vao ban tay Ciing, vgi tOi thi co mgt so hoc sinh khac nita cling bi thay danh tuong to nhu the, viec thuOng xuyen xay gier hoc man Todn cim ,thay thai gian day Do thay ding think danh n'en tay tOi sung len, bam tim, tOi da cho di kham, ding may la chat' khOng bi anh huOng den xuong, khöp tay Thiet nght hanh vi xam pham than the hoc sinh cin thay Nguyen Van X la hanh vi vi pham phap luat T6i vie't don vái mong muan Hieu tnxOng Tnrérng THPT Dinh Tien Hoang xixbrf hanh vi bao luc cua thay gide nOi tren Kinh mong dugc Hieu truOng Trueyng THPT Dinh Tien Honig xem xet, giai quyet./ San Tay, 14 thong 04 nam 2017 Nguiri viec dun (KY ten) Dinh Thi A" Khi then dugc don ctn co Dinh Thi A, Hieu truth-1g rat bdt nger veri sir xay Vi thay gido Nguyen Van X IA giao vien cot can cila nha trueng, co theri gian cong tac tai nha truang da lau Tit truerc ,den gig chua nghe hoc sinh hay mot khdc phan anh ve cong tat giang day cila thay Sau d9c ICST' don phan anh, Hieu truang xac dinh day la don to cao co day du thOng tin ngirCri to cao, nOi dung to can va yeu cau xir lyt cua phu huynh h9c sinh, thuOc tham quyen giai quyet cua Hieu trirOng Hieu trugrig nhä trireing meri cac thAnh vien Ban giam hieu va Thanh tra than dan den trao doi va len Ice hoach xac minh lai not dung vu viec: Tin? nhat: Trao dOc i not dung ma co Dinh TN A pit anh IA thay Nguyen Van X co henh vi bao lire vai hoc sinh tiet day dm thay Hanh vi gAn day la thiremg xuyen, xay vol nhieu hoc sinh ThIr hai: Phan cong dling chi Ban giam hieu( Ph6 Hieu truerng phu trach co ser vat chat, dam nhiem cOng tac xir ly vi pham tai don vi lam to trtrang to xac minh) va dOng chi Thanh tra nhan dan tien hanh xac minh vu viec nhu don phan anh co &mg sir that kheng? Ngay hOm sau nhan don, hai (tang chi dirge Hieu trirOng phan cOng da tien hanh gap co Dinh Thi A de xac minh thOng tin ve not dung ma co da phan anh va yeti eau nha, tnreng xir ly thay Nguyen Van X co dimg khOng? CO A xac nhan thing va cac dOng chi da vi& Bien ban de co A kyr xac nhan co phan anh the not dung (la neu don Ngoai yeu cau co A cung cap them phieu kham benh cua em Dinh Vän B nhu dun thu phan anh da néu Ngay hem sau, sau gap co A hai &Ong chi dirge phan cong di xac minh da "kin dão" mai lop truerng lop 11B1, dirge lap tn./Ong cho Net la co viec xay tai lop gi g hoc cilia thay Nguyen Van X va ké ten them mot so hoc sinh cling bi thay X danh nhu ban B la ban AA, BB Sau lam viec vol lop tnräng, hai clang chi ding "kin dap " mad cac em AA, BB cac em cling )(de than co viec dO xay Arai cac em Ngay 20/4/2017, sau nghe bao can xac minh cua TO )(de minh ve hanh vi danh hoc sinh cua thay Nguyen Van X theo dun phan anh cua co A IA dung Hieu twang dich than meri thay Nguyen Vän X den phOng lam viec Sau thOng bdo cac not dung don (gift bi mat ten, dia chi ngireri viec dun) va cat bien ban xac minh, tai lieu lien quan, yen cau thay Nguyen Van X gidi trinh sr viec ding hay khOng? Thay Nguyen Van X gidi trinh nhu sau: Trong cdc nam hoc truck day thay chua bao gi g co hanh vi nhu vay, thai gian gan day gia dinh gap kh6 khan ye kinh chOng thu6mg xuyen cai nhau, cai thi khOng nghe l gi cha me nen tinh t6, tinh sinh nOng Do vay, qua trinh giang , day thay da lchOng kiem the duqc ban than, hoc sinh nap IchOng nghe 16i la thay lay Ulu& danh, cling nham de hoc sinh so ma y ang lai, hoe tot han chi thay khOng coy danh hoc sinh vg Nhu vay nhitng not dung phan anh don cua co Dinh TN A la dung, vi the Hieu truang yeu cau thay Nguyen Van X ve viet ban kiem diem n'Op cho Hieu trugng NQi dung trinh bay lai sir viec, neu khuyet diem, sai pham cua minh cling nhu lchac phue sira china, cham nhat 02 ngdy sau nOp cho Hieu trugng Ngdy 24/4/2017 Hieu tracing quyet dinh lap HOi dOng ky luat gido vien va trieu tap cuQc hop m6i thay Nguyen Van X tham dg Tai cuOc hop sau vien dan the van ban qui dinh ve nhang hanh vi, viec lam bi rcam dOi vai gido vien, Hieu tru gng thOng qua Wan, bO not dung dan phan T6 )(de minh Ara mot so bien ban, tai lieu lien anh, ket qua xdc minh sir viec quan cho HOi dOng biet Sau thay Nguyen Van X trinh bay ban kiem diem cita minh cling nhu to than hinh thirc Icy 141 va rut kith nghiem, him se khOng tai pham Hieu trugng va cdc vien tham din cuOc hop ,da phan tich r6 nhitng khuyet diem cna thay X vg i tu each la mot gide, vien phdi het sire guang mau Thay da co hanh vi )(dm pham den than the khOng nhitng mot hoc sinh ma nhieu hoc sinh khdc nita, hanh vi Ay thu gng )(ay thin gian gan day, day la hanh vi thay trung hoc phO gido IchOng dirge phep lam theo Dieu le Tru gng trung ,hoc ca tuyen thOng va trugng phO fluting ,c6 nhieu cap hoc, la van de ma nha twang nhac nth nhieu Ian, da qui dinh qui the ling xis cua nha trugng truyen Hanh vi cua thay Nguyen Van X la vi pham dieu 35, chuang IV, ThOng tu so 12/2011/TT-BGDDT cua BO Gide dye lid Den tao va vi pham Dieu 19, Lust Vien chirc nam 2010 HOi &ring ky luat bleu quyet bang phieu kin xin ly hinh thirc ky luat la Khien trach Thay X th6ng nhat v gi hinh thirc ky 141 tren Hieu tracing ket luSn va quy6t dinh ky luat thay X bang hinh thirc Khien trach, dOng thai yeu eau thay Nguyen Van X den timg gia dinh hoc sinh bi thay danh, xin loi gia dinh va hoc sinh, mong gia dinh thOng cam va b6 qua Ngay 28/04/2017 Hieu trugng riled co A den nha tru gng thOng bao cho co not dung xir 1y thay X dm nha throng, co A thong nhat v g i each )(it ly ky luat d6 kh6ng coy kien gi them CuAi gang nha trugng thOng bao quy& dinh ky luat thay X euiic hop ca quan dinh ky thang va yeti cau the cong chitc, vien chine, ngtrai lao ciOng dan vi lay lam bai hoc kith nghiem cho ban than XAc dinh Inv lieu xir IST tinh huting fM xay dung dugc died ngfi cong chfrc, vien chfrc Ira nguad lao deng a truang Hieu truang Truamg THPT Dinh Tien Hoang co pham chat dao dire tot, co nAng loc chuyen men yang yang nhat IA c6 nang song, ky nAng Ong xir cuOc song, sinh hog cling nhu nhAm day math cong the gi g) duc phap luat tai don vi Khi xfr 132 tinh hueng tren ban than la Hieu truang tOi huang tai cac muc tieu sau: - Khan truang tin hAnh gidi quyat don pilau Anh met each kip thai, dimg qui trinh, dam bait thai gian, tranh dnh huang xau den tap the su pham nhA truang, gilt gin hinh Anh Mt dep cUa nha gi g), gift gin uy tinh cho truang, cho nganh tren co dam bac) ding quy dinh phap lug vOi viec xac minh chinh 'tat, xfr lyr nghiem minh, thau tinh dat 157 a - ,Qua viec xfr brr, pilau tich hyp tinh hop lyr, thay X thay nhltng khuyat diem yeti kern cfia ban than, tir co 3", thfrc sfra chfra de co nhltng bien phap phan &au vuan len, vugt qua moi hoan canh khO khan, co each Ong xfr chu g' moc gia dinh de tra met nha gi g) mau mut - Gilt nghiem quy the cua nganh Gi g) due, luat Vién chirc va Phap lust dm Nita nuerc Qua gial quyat tinh hueng, can lam cho cong chfrc, vien chfrc va nguad lao citing tai don vi thay dugc tinh nghiem tut moi hoat Ong cua nha truang Cdc cap quan ly co bien phap viec to chirc cho ding chirc, vien chirc, va nguai lao deng toan nganh hoc tap va thoc hien chit truang, chinh sach Hang va phap lust cfta Nha nu& va cac quy dinh cfm nganh co nei dung ma nha gig) — vien chfrc khOng duce lam - Viec thuc hien cac trinh to xfr lyr dan thu giftp cho cong tac kiam tra nOi be truang h9c nhAm tang cuOng kjr cuang, na nap va ngdn chAn, kit phut cac hien tug tieu cot, vi pham qui the Ong xfr cac hog dOng cua nha truang - Giai quyat tinh tren dam bao dugc su hop tinh, hop l5r bad nguyen nhan cua tinh hueng Qua viec xfr ly/ cling la met bust de cho dOi ngu cong chirc, vien chirc va ngtrad lao ,dOng dm don vi not rieng va cong chat, vien chfrc Ira ngulai lao dOng nganh, thay dugc tinh nghiem minh viec chap hanh luat phdp va cac quy dinh cua nganh, tfr dO to thin nhan, to dénh gid lai each ling xfr dm ban than minh de co so diau chinh, be sung cho phft hop Deng thai gilt lay lOng tin cua nhan dan doi veil nhfing nguiti lam cong tac nganh gian doc a Tang &rang cong the quail ly, chi dao de nang cao chat lugng cong tac pha Bien gido due phdp luat nha twang, dac biet tinh hinh hien chUng to Bang day manh viec Hoc tap lam theo tu tuang, dao disc, phong cash Ha Chi Minh - Ph& hop vOi tot Thanh tra nhan dan tai don vi viec xu ly don thu khieu nai, to cao qua ciing nam dugc hoan canh khO khan cita tong gido vien, tro, tao dieu kien thuan lgi cho gido vien an tam cong tac Phan tich tinh hutmg Sau tiep nhan dun mita co Dinh Thi A, Hiau truang tim hien va xdc minh su viec Xac nhan su viec )(ay nghiem anh huang dan kat qua cong tac day va hoc tai nha trip:mg Anh huang den uy tinh nha truang, mat lOng tin vei phu huynh hoc sinh dth voi gido vien cfm truang Hiau truang triu tap cdc vien co lien quan nhu: PhO hieu truang, Ban Thanh tra than dan Qua k& qua xac minh su viec cho thay nhilng nth dung co don phan anh la hoan toan dung su that va thay Nguyen Van X cling this nhan nhitng hanh vi sai pham cua minh Dieu dO lam anh fluting den tam ly, kat qua hoc tap va ren luyan &la hoc sinh 3.1 Nguyen nhan (Ian den tinh hutmg Nguyen nhan khach quan: Do hoan canh gia dinh thay X Thai gian gan day gia dinh gap kh6 khan ve kinh te, vg chang thuang xuy'en cal nhau, cat thi khOng nghe lai cha me, hoc sinh thi khOng chiu lam Jodi tap ye nha - Nguyen nhan chii quan: Thic nhiit: Taring THPT Dinh Tien Hoeing Dieu dugc the hien la qua trinh quart ly dm Ban giant hieu nha truang cong tac tuyen truyen van de chap hanh nth qui qui the cua nganh, DMu le truang trung hoc (TT 12/2011/TT-BGDDT), Luat vier' elute ( Ludt so 58/2010/QH12) cho dth ngil cong chitc, vien chg c, nguai lao dOng tai don vi chua that su hieu qua COng tac quail ly, chi dao cila Ban giant hieu va C8ng doan nha chua thuang xuyen nam bat kip thai tam tu, tinh cam, hoan canh gia dinh cua cong chgc vien chirc va nguai lao d'Ong tai don vi Da xay truang hop gido vien co hanh vi Bao lye gia dinh nhu tren, thi hoat Tang quan ly, lath dao cita nha truang chua tot, khOng kip thai, can phai lchk phuc *Thin hai: ThuOc ve they Nguyin Vein X + ThAy Nguyen Van X, kinh to gia dinh gap khO khan, vg than thugng xay mau thuan, cdi khOng nghe lai cha me nen tinh tinh sinh n6ng nay, khOng kiem cha duce hanh vi cua minh, lam xau di hinh anh cua mot gido vien cot can da co thai gian cong tic law dai tai nha truing + Can cu vac, cac quy dinh cua nganh, Dieu le Truing trung hoc, Luat vien chirc thi thay X cao ,hanh vi vi pham nhOng dieu gido vien — vien chirc khOng dugc lam, vi pham qui tae frog xir cua truing, anh huOng den hinh anh nha gido mat nhan dan, chua that guang mau Ung xu Trong cuOc song, mai cong chirc, vien chIrc va ngued lao deng lam viec mai truing gido duc phai la met tam guang sang cho moi ngueri not theo nhat la viec chap hanh phdp luat; nhung nguyen nhan da phan tich tren, xac dinh cac gidi phdp , quyet tinh huOng, to can di saw phan tich them hau qua dm no 3.2 Hau qua ciia tinh hua6ng Tir tinh huOng thay X vi pham quy cha ngdnh, vi pham Dieu 14' truing trung hoc, Luat vien nau xu 13'7 khOng kip then se dAn dan cac hau qua: - Ranh vi vi pham cua thAy X khOng throe giai quyat kip thai thi thay X se flap tuc co hanh vi dinh hoc sinh neu hoc sinh khOng lam bai tap, khOng nghe 16i thay gido, nghiem hon nau nhu hanh vi ay gay thuong tich nang hon dai van hoc sinh, cac ca quan chirc nang se vao cuec va xir 15T dAn den hau qua se nang ne han Ben canh thay X can dinh mat di hinh anh tot dep cua ngtrogi thay gido mat nhan dan va hoc sinh.Truarc hat, ban than thAy X phai chiu hinh thdc 1(57 luat Wang ximg van nhang sai pham cua minh va anh huOng ye nhieu mat sr nghiep dm ban than • - NhOng hanh vi vi pham cda thay X tai truing, anh huarng xdu den viec giang day Ira hoc tap dm hoc sinh, lam anh huOng dan uy tin dm truing Vi vay, neu khOng co bien phdp than ger kip thai thi thay X se to loai minh khOi do, i dia nhilng ngueri lam nganh Gido dye - MOt M hoc sinh se xin chuyan lop khdc, gay mat on dinh lop - Phu huynh hoc sinh co bi thay Nguyen Van X dank se to tim thay X de lam re su viec, nau phu huynh khOng Nat kiam the se clan den hanh vi vi pham phap luat, lam anh huarng den an ninh trot to nai thAy X song Tir nhang phan tich nguyen phan va hau qua dm tinh dua lai, viec xac dinh cac giai phap giai guy& tinh la van de rat quan de tir dua cac gidi phap xir lyr tai uu W' xuAt nhirng giai Trude tinh hug ng do, can co hinh tithe xir 15T the nao cho dimg voi quy dinh cita nganh, nhung phii hop vei thuc tá? Tinh hugng dat ra, khign cho nguai co trach nhiem phal trait tref suy Day la met bdi toan kho, ngtrai quan 15T phdi gidi quy6t nhu the nao cho ven tinh, hop 1Yr giva phu huynh vai gido vien, dam bac) thuc hien dugc kST cuing cua Phdp lust, quy ché cua nganh va cita quan Murk \Tay, can tim hig u, phan licit Id nhirng nguyen nhan va hau qua cita tinh dua lai, co nhu vay mai xac dinh dugc giai phap de gidi quyet tinh co hi'eu qua co aa 4.1 Can cfr Oars 157 xuk phwcrng an gidi quy4t: Can cu vac) cac van ban Phan lust co lien quan de gidi quyét tinh tren nhu sau: Lust lao d'eng; Lust gido due; Lula vien chirc; Nghi dinh 27/2012/ND-CP 06/4/2012 dm Chinh phit Quy dinh ve xir 1ST kST lust vien chirc va trach nhiem bei thukg, hoan tra cua vien chile; Dieu le truang trung hoc co se, truang trung hoc pita thOng va truang phi thOng co nhieu cap hoc nam 2011; Nghi dinh so 76/2012/ND-CP ngdy 03/10/2012 dm Chinh pith quy dinh chi tik mot s6 dieu cfia Luat To cdo, ThOng to se 06/2013/TT-TTCP ngdy 31/10/2013 cita Thanh tra Chinh phit quy dinh ye quy trinh giai quyet to cao 4.2 De xuAt cac phtrung an va Ikra chip phi/rang an giai quyet: Cdc phuang an dugc xay dung va lua chin giai quy& tinh huang can pha.i, dugc can dr muc tieu da xac dinh Do dO, tac gia de xuat cac phirang an gidi quyet nhu sau: a Giai phi") 1: Hieu twang yeu cAu tie xac minh, xac minh va thu thap thOng tin, bdo cdo chinh xac bang van ban Can cu van c/O Hieu truang to chirc hop lien tich de xem x gt sit viec va dg i chieu v6i ket qua dieu tra Hieu truang nha truang yéu eau thAy Nguy g n Van X dimg hanh vi xam pham than the hoc sinh Tg chirc cuec hop hei Ong sit pham rut kinh nghiem dei vái toan the can be, gido vien nha truang Yeu cau thAy X phal viat cam k6t khOng tai pham harsh vi xam pham than the hoc sinh, true tip den lop xin loi hoc sinh va chuyen thay X day 16p khac Dai dien lanh dao nha truang true tiep gap gO, trao dOi \Rai phu huynh hoc sinh de giai t6a nhfing bite xAc va van Ong phu huynh rut don phan anh ( KhOng co hinh thdc 1(5[140 I * Cu diem: - Phuang an phii hop yeti hoan canh gia dinh va ban than thAy X Mat khac, day IA Fan dau lien thay X vi pham, cac Mtn hoc khac khOng xay hAnh vi Han nth vi pham co nguyen nhan khach quan, IA hodn canh gia dinh va hoc sinh tao nen ch g thay X khOng co tinh vi pham - Han 6'8 du Juan xa hOi lAm anh huOng den uy tin gido vien, nhA tnräng va ngAnh gido dye - Ngän ngira co the xay mau thuan giita thay X Arai phi huynh hoc sinh va ved hoc sinh 16p 11B1 - Tam 1)2 tha thay X khOng bi nang ne d6i dien ved d8ng nghiep, phy huynh, hoc sinh * Han ch& - Giai quy& khOng cifing Luat giao due Mm 2005, Luat giao d ye b8 sung nam 2009; Luat vien chitc; ThOng to 12/2011/TT-BGDDT, ngAy 28 thang nam 2011 cila BO Gido due va DAo tao ban hank dieu le truang trung h9c; Nghi dinh so 76/2012/ND-CP 03/10/2012 dm Chinh phi" quy dinh chi tiet mot s6 diL Luat T6 Me, ThOng to so 06/2013/TT-TTCP ngAy 31/10/2013 dm Thanh tra Chinh phil quy dinh va quy trinh giai quy& to cAo - KhOng phat huy duge rhieu lye pan 1)2, giai guy& sg vie nang ye tinh cam, khOng dome né nep, k)2cucmg nhA tn.rang - Phy huynh hoc sinh kh8ng du niem tin vac nhA truOng va co the xay hien tuning khieu kien vuot cap b Giai 04 2: Hieu truang yen eau t6 dieu tra, 'the minh, thu thap timing tin va bao cao chinh xac bang van ban Can ca vdo dO Hieu truemg quy& dinh lap HOi thing k)/ luat Hieu truemg yeu eau thay X viet ban ktem diem, dua khuyet diem va ty nhan hinh thirty k)2 Mt Nghiém khac kiem diem thAy X tnrac town the hOi dang six pham nhA trthang Can cu vac bien ban Ma cac cuOc hop tren, Hieu truemg quyet dinh k52 Mat thay X yeti hinh thirc khi6n nth Chuyen May X day lam khdc * tin diem: - Giai quy& &mg theo [mat gido dye nam 2005, Lust giao dye sin dei be' sung nam 2009; Luat vien ch gc; ThOng to 12/2011/TT-BGDDT, ngdy 28 thang nam 2011 Ma BO Giao due va Ddo tao ban hanh dieu le tnremg trung hoc; Nghi dinh so 76/2012/ND-CP ngAy 03/10/2012 cUa Chinh phU quy dinh chi tie't mot so l0 dieu cua Luat T6 can, ThOng to so 06/2013/TT-TTCP 31/10/2013 cilia Thanh tra Chinh phu quy dinh v'e quy trinh giai quy& to cao \Lai hinh tilde kY lulat mire khien trach d6i vai thay X, the hien dugc tinh nghiem minh cua phap luat va quy the cua nganh Xa han nfra IA thing to dang xir ly tinh huang co ly, co tinh, tao ca h6i de moi ngtrai mac sai lam, khuyet diem co dieu kien d sira china va phan dau vucm len cu6c song va cong viec Theo phuang an moi sai pham lap tire dugc ket th6c Nguth lam sai se thay dirge Ichuyet t diem, to nhan hinh thirc luat va khOng tai pham, dang thin co co tac dung ran de dth vai nhang gide vien Tang eueng hieu lye quail ly cac hoat Ong gido due tai dia,phuemg Han che nhang sai pham dan den vi pham phap luat, anh huang den nghe nghiep, uy tin ban than va nganh Bao y e quyen cua cong dan, cua phu huynh, hoc sinh, ngan chan duce du luAn xau xa hth, dem lai niem tin nhan dan dOi vai nhd tnr&ng, nganh gido due Ngän ngira co the xay mau thuan giixa thay X vai phu huynh hoc sinh va y eti hoc sinh lOp 11B1 Tam ST dm ilia)! X kh6ng bi nang ne dth dien vai &Ong nghiep, phy huynh, hoc sinh Han che: * Uy tin dm thay X y eti dong nghiep, hoc sinh va phu huynh hoc sinh bi giam - Phan nao lam anh huOng du luAn thay X bi kY luAt khien trach T Ci a ant that hie's' giii phap Sau phan tich uu diem va nhugc diem elm moi phuOng an, can dr vac edc van ban ve phdp luat co lien quan nhu : Lust gido due 2005; LuAt gido due sira dth va bli sung 2009; Dieu le trueeng trung hoc 2011; Lust vien chile clam 2010 Hay theo Nghi dinh 27/2012/ND-CP quy dinh ve xir ly ky 141 vien chin va trach nhiem bth thuOng, hoan tra ciaa vien Thay X da vi pham dieu 19, Chuang II, Luat vien chirc 2010; vi pham dieu 35, chuong IV, Dieu le truemg trung hoc 2011; vi pham qui tac Ung xir cua truemg Warn 2017 Can cir the van ban neu tren, thAy X co the bi Icy luat khien filch, nhtmg cling co the bi mire k5/ luSt thrift cao De gi6p thay X nang cao tinh than trach nhiem vugt qua moi khO khan thuc hien tot nhiem vu ciaa minh thi thuc hien gidi phdp tire xir ly vai mire khien trach la phii hop 11 nhat Day la giai phap tói uu de xir ly tinh sai pham quy the cua thy Nguyen Van X Don phan anh cua co Dinh Thi A la thuOc loci don t6 cao nen dugc gidi quyet theo Lust to cao s6 03/2011/QH13 cua Quec hOi nuOt CHXHCN Viet Nam thOng qua 11 thing 11 nam 2011 Quy trinh giai quyét t'6 cao dugc quy dinh tai LuSt TO can nam 2011, Nghi dinh s6 76/2012/ND-CP, ngdy 03 thing 10 nam 2012 cila Chinh phu, ThOng to so 06/2013/TT-TTCP, 30 thing nam 2013 dm Thanh tra Chinh He chAn chinh viec gide vien c6 hanh vi xam pham than the hoc sinh va han qua dm nhang vi pham aped gian qua, tirng bu6c nang cao chAt lugng day va hoc, chfing to can thyc hien nghiém the cac van ban: Dieu le truing trung hoc 2011; Luat vien chirc nam 2010; qui the Ang xfr dm co quan; Nghl dinh 27/2012/ND-CP quy dinh ve xu ly Icy 141 vien chile va trach nhiem b8i Jarring, hoan tra &la vien Vol vai trO mot can b0 quan ly tai truing t8i dua Ice hoach giai quy& to cao da neu tit duge t6 chat thyc hien nhu sau: - But 1: Tip nh4n do'n t6 cao: Tip than don cda phu huynh, ghi rO ngdy, thing, nam t6 cao; ho, ten, dia chi dm nguai to cao; not dung t6 cao, yéu tau xir ly cua ngueyi to cao - Btrerc 2: nth' loci dun va xir 1y thong tin t6 cam TOi xac dinh day la don dm phu huynh phan anh ( t6 cao) giao vien truing THPT Dinh Tien Hoang, huyen San Tay, tinh Qudng Ngai don ghi r0 ho, ten, dia chi cila nguOi t6 cao, not dung t6 cao, yeti call xu ly hanh vi vi pham Vi vay don phdi dugc thu ly, thuOc tham quyen giai quyet cua Hieu truing - Btrac 3: Thu IS/ giai quy6t t6 cam xfiy dying ke hoach xac minh not dung to carp: buOt can tien hanh cdc tong viec cu the sau: Thu VT giai quyet -CO cao: Ban hanh quy& dinh thy 15T giai quyet to cep, 1Sp t6 xac minh t6 cao g6m: PhO hieu truing, cdc t'6 truing t6 chuyen mOn, ban tra nhan clan va giao vien chu nhiem 16p 11B1 Doan Ph6 hieu truing lam t8 truing c6 nhiem vu vOng muai ngdy xac minh nhang nOi dung to cap don ThOng bac) viec thu ly to cao: Trong then Ilan muai sau flap than don t6 cao, Hieu truerng th6ng bdo cho co Dinh Thi A biét ve viec thy 15/ don phan anh cfm CO 12 c Gait thOng bao yeu cau co Dinh Thi A cimg can sly 16p 11B1, hoc sinh bi thAy xam pham va giao vien chit nhiem lOp 11B1( neu can) cung cap thOng tin, tai lieu, bang chimg co lien quan den not dung to cao don TO xac minh yeu can hgp tdc - But 4: Xac minh nOi dung t6 can buck can lien hanh cac tong viec cu the sau: Xay dung k'e hoach xac minh • Ke hoach xac minh t6 truang to xac mirth lap va phé duyet ThOng ban guy& dirih lap to xac minh cho nguai bi t6 cao co Dinh Thi A— phu huynh hoc sinh Dinh Van B lOp 11B1 c Thu thap, xir ly thOng tin, tai lieu, bang chirng lien quan den nOi dung to cao ThOng qua nhang thOng tin co Dinh TN A cung cap, to xac minh tien hanh lam viec Hang vat tong can su lop, viec vol hoc sinh 134 -Lay danh, lam viec vat tap the lOp (neu can); kiem tra, dOi chieu cac thOng tin de" lam r6 d'6 chinh xac cac nOi dung don to cao d Lam viec true tip vol Sy Nguyen Van X (ngthai bi t6 can) va co Dinh Thi A(ngtrai to cao) TO kiém tra yen can thay X ‘ gidi trinh bang van ban ye nhang nOi dung bi tocdo, cung cap thOng tin, tai lieu, bang chirng lien quan den not dung to cao, not dung giai trinh DOi vai co A, to xac minh lam r6 nhfing not dung don to cao , e Baia cao ket qua xac minh: Th6ng qua qua trinh xac minh, t6 xac minh bac, cao bang van ban ket qua xac minh nhu sau: Cdc not dung don cita co Dinh TN A phan anh viec thAy X co hanh vi xam pham than the hoc sinh hoar} tan dUng su that, co co sec NOi dung gidi trinh cua thay X ve cac niSi dung bi t6 cao theo don la dung - Xac dinh gift co Dinh Tin A va thAy Nguyen Van X kh6ng he co mau than gi ter truck den - Cac thOng tin t6 xac minh thu thOp dugc to can su lOp, hoc sinh bi thay dank, gido vien chit nhiem au thing khOp vol nhang not dung don to cao cua co Dinh TN A Tir cac kenh thOng tin neu teen: TO xac minh khang dinh thay X vi pham Dieu le truemg trung hoc am 2011; vi pham Lust vien chile näm 2010; vi pham qui tac Ung xir cua don vi vita ban hanh tram 2017 Tit t6 xac minh th'Ong nhat dua bien phap xir 132 ky luat O mitt dO khien trach del vol naing sai pham cit' a thay X, buOc thAy X pal dimg hanh vi vi pham cua minh, rut kinh nghiem, xin hoc sinh va phu huynh hoc sinh 13 - But 5: Ban hanh, cong khai kêt Juan not dung to cao, , quyéct dinh zit ly vi pham dugc phat hi?il qua giai quyêt to cao; rap, quan hO so' giai quyét to cao 15 buck can tin hanh cac cong viec sau: Ban hanh ket luan v'e Mi dung t6 cao: Trixec nhfing sai pham v g hanh vi lam pham than the hoc sinh, Hieu truang de hinh thirc ki luat gn -nth dg i vei thay X COng khai ket luan nOi dung t6 cao, guy& dinh xir ly hanh vi vi pham bi t6 cao: Sau co ket luan cua t6 kig m tra, Hieu truang trueng THPT Dinh Tien Hoang guy& dinh xir 132, cong M guy& dinh /dr ly hanh vi vi pham cua thay X truác toan the hqi dOng sir pham biét va thOng bac) cho co Dinh Thi A biet c Lap, quan li 118 so gidi quyet to cao: Lap hO so giai quyet -CO caw tap hop nhang thOng tin, tai lieu, bang chung, chung sir lien quan den nOi dung to can, ket qua xac minh, luan, kien,nghi, quyet dinh /dr ly to cao dugc hinh M so gidi quyet to cao den dOng h8 so theo thing trinh tu, thu tic H8 so luu tai Van thu ccia tracing Trong qua trinh gidi quy gt tinh hug ng, Ban gidm hieu nha truang luOn dam bdo bi mat ve ngued via don phan anh Sau to click Mac hien giai phdp theo trinh to néu tren, Ban giam hieu nen mai thay, X len trO chuyen, trao dOi, nam bat tam tu nguyen vong xem thay thong nhat vái each giai quy gt ten khOng a Phi hop Arai COng dodn quan tam hoan cânh gia dinh cua thay X, tim each chia se: giap dos thay than go nhimg lch6 khan cuOc song, wan len hoan nit nhiem vu dugc giao Kin nghi va de xuAt Tfr tinh hutmg tren, de ngan ngira co hieu qua cac truang hop tuang to va giai quyet nhanh gon cac tinh dang xa'y ra, tOi co nIning kien nghi saw - D8i vOi cac co quan Bang, Nha nu6c: Can ban hanh cac van ban hanh chinh huong an co the luat Lao dOng; Luat gido doc; Luat vien chits den moi can bO cong chIrc, vigil chire de"' ho hieu dugc nth:mg viec can lam, nhang hanh vi bi cam - Doi vai tnrang THPT not chung va Truang THPT Dinh Tien Hoang not rieng: 14 + Ban giam hieu nha truing can quan tam tang cueing cong tac kiem tra not b 16 taking hoc, thuang xuyen kiem tra viec thyc hien chuyen de va kiem tra toan dien dei vii can b0, gido vien va nhan vien Sinh hoat chuyen men dinh kST deu va co chat logng, danh gia sat uu khuyet diem (raj vial the can be, gido vien va nit can be, gido vien va nhan vien duqc kiem tra Xay dyng tiéu chi thi dua phu hop vien co gang pilaff &du a + Ban giam hieu thfrang xuyén thi sat tinh hinh day va hoc tai lop + Chi be nha truing, cong doan, doan nién nha truing gan gal ding vien cac can be, gido vien va nhan vien truing co gang vuan len moi hoat thing chuyen men, vuot qua moi khO khan cua gia dinh de hoan tot moi nhiem vu duqc giao - ID& vii can be, gido vien va nhan vien nha twang: Can nam yang not dung cac loai van ban v'e luat phap, nil& la cac van ban lien quan den nganh giao dye, cac quy dinh cua nganh Gill gin va phat huy lucmg tam va trkh nhiem cua ngued lam nganh Giao dye va thyc hien Mt cac cuec van Ong va cac phong tan thi dua cUa nganh va don vi phât deng III !CET LUAN Mfg the - kiem tra, giai quy& kieu nai, to can la met hoat Ong rat quan trong, bth no la met hoat ding thgc thi quyén hanh phap cua Nha mac, la su the Ong co to chic bang quyen lye phap luat nha nu& &Si vii cac qua trinh xa 110i \fa hanh vi boat ding cua ngued cua b0 may hanh chinh nha mac tit trung uang den dia phuang de tri va ph& then xa hei La ngued can 130 quan lyr dan vi twang hoc, thi gt nghi can phai biet chdc va quan 13"/ bang quyen lye Nha nu& (Quyen lap phdp, quyen hanh phap, quyen to phap) dirge the hien cu the thong qua viec van dung sang tao cac luat nhu: Luat gido dyc; Luat vien chdc; Dieu le truing hoc va cac van ban co lien quan de tri on dinh don vi va dieu chinh cac hanh vi cua tong ca nhan don vi, nham thyc hien Mt nhiem vu chinh tri ciaa don vi G6p phan tithe &Ay dan vi pilaf trien va fiat dugc 'nye tieu giao due phii hop theo tong giai doan Ira tang tiled kSr ma Nha nu& da xay dung Xir lyT moi viec plied hop 115/ hgp tinh, giup ngued vi pham nhan biet dugc hanh vi vi pham cua minh, tao co hei cho ho sfra chtia, rut kinh nghiem, Ong thai gidp can be, giao vien, nhan vien khac to soi lai minh Giai guy& dan phan anh met cach kip thai, Ong qui trinh, dam bao thai gian, trait anh huemg xAu den tap the su pham nha twang, gilt gin hinh anh tot dep cua nha gift gin uy tinh cho truing, cho nganh teen co so dam bao Ong quy dinh phap luat 15 vat viec xac minh chink xac, xi( ly nghiem minh, thAu tinh dot ly, tranh tinh tang gin don vugt cap Tit day la mot se gidi phdp ma citing tOi da duo xir ly tinh ve van de don thu to cao gido vten co harsh vi )(dm pham than the hoc sink tai mot don vi cu the Qua co Mc dung tech cue den toan 130 he thong Trong qua trinh de giai phap xir ly cho tinh huOng, chnc chan co flitting han ché, bai flitting cong viec rat quan tong khdc, la viec chuan bi mot s6 cong viec cho nava hoc meri da den, rat mong dugc su dOng g6p cua quy thAy co de tieu luan cua tOi duce hodn chink va co gid tri thuc to cao Xin chan cam and Quiing Ngc7i, 29 thong 08 ndm 2017 Ngtreri viet yeav, vocc //c443/ 16 IV TAI LIEU TRAM K16.0 Quac hai, so: 38/2005/QH11, 14/6/2015 va s6: 44/2009/QH12 25/11/2009, va Luat gido duc va sira doi, b6 sung mat so diau cua Luat gido duc BO Gido duc va Deo tao: Dieu 1a truang trung hoc co sa, trtrang trung hoc pha thong va tn.reng ph6 thOng có nhiau cap hoc nam 2011 (TT 12/2011/TT —BGDDT) Qu'ac hai, so 58/2010/QH-12, 15/11/2010, va Lula vian chirc Chinh pita, Nghi dinh 27/2012ND-CP, 06/4/2012, Quy dinh va xtr ly IcY luat vien chIrc va trach nhiarn bai thoOng, hoan tra oda vian chirc Luat To cdo nam 2011, Nghi dinh so 76/2012/ND-CP, ngdy 03 thóng 10 nam 2012 caa Chinh phi), ThOng to so 06/2013/TT-TTCP, 30 thang nam 2013 cua Thanh tra Chinh Qui tac dng )(ft cua nha trtrang 17 ... Thiet nght hanh vi xam pham than the hoc sinh cin thay Nguyen Van X la hanh vi vi pham phap luat T6i vie't don vái mong muan Hieu tnxOng Tnrérng THPT Dinh Tien Hoang xixbrf hanh vi bao luc cua... gide, vien phdi het sire guang mau Thay da co hanh vi )(dm pham den than the khOng nhitng mot hoc sinh ma nhieu hoc sinh khdc nita, hanh vi Ay thu gng )(ay thin gian gan day, day la hanh vi thay... quy dinh cua nganh, Dieu le Truing trung hoc, Luat vien chirc thi thay X cao ,hanh vi vi pham nhOng dieu gido vien — vien chirc khOng dugc lam, vi pham qui tae frog xir cua truing, anh huOng den