Luận án đổi mới và hoàn thiện pháp luật về công chức nhà nước ở nước ta

BO GIAO DUC VA DAO TAO HOC VIEn CHfNH TRI QUOC GIA H6 CHI MINH NGUYEN VAN TAM D(5l MOl VA HOAN THIEN PHAP LUAT VE CONG chug NHA NUOC Nude TA ' ChuySn nganh : Ly luan Nha nude va phap quven Ma s6: 5.05.01 LEAN AN PHO TIEN Si KHOA HOC LUAT HQC Ngucri hudng dan khoa hoc : 1- PTS : Doan Nang 2- PGS.PTS : Trdn Ngoc Duong Ha Noi -1997 (! Ldl CAM DOAN Tdi xin cam doan day la cdng trinh nghien cixu cua ri£ng tdi Cac sd lidu, ket qua ndu luan an la trung thuc va chua timg duqc cdng bd ba't ky cdng trinh nao khac Nguydn Van Tam MUC LUC Trang MO DAU huong CONG CHUG VA PHAP LUAT v£ CONG CHUG NHA NUdC 1.1 CONG CHUG VA VAI TRO CUA CONG CHtG NHA NVOC 1.1.1 Quan niem ve cong chuc, cong vu nha nude 1.1.2 Vai tro cua edng chirc nha nuac - bd may hanh chinh qudc gia 2.1 PHAP LUAT vt CONG CHUC NHA NUdC 1.2.1 Quan nidm pham vi diOu chinh cua phap luat vO edng chirc nha nude 1.2.2 Vai tro cua phap luat vO edng chirc nha nude ndn hanh chinh qudc gia 2huomg PHAP LUAT v£ edNG CHUG NHA NVOC - THUG TRANG VA NHUNG Ddl HOI KHACH QUAN VE Ddi MOI 2.1 2.1.1 THUG TRANG PHAP LUAT vti CONG CHUG NHA NVOC NUOC TA Thue trang vO edng chirc nha nude d nude ta qua cac thdi ky 2.1.2 Thue trang phap luat v£ edng chirc nha nude d nude ta hiOn 2.2 NHUNG Ddl HOI KHACH QUAN DOl MOl VA HOAN THlfiN PHAP LUAT v£ CONG CHUG NHA NVOC NUOC TA HDiN NAY 2.1.1 Ddi mdi va hoan thiOn phap luat vd edng chuc nha nude bat ngudn tir ddi hoi cai each ndn hanh chinh qudc gia, mdt ndi dung quan cua cai each ndn hanh chinh 2.2.2 Ddi mdi va hoan thiCn phap luat vd edng chirc Nha nude bat ngudn tir ddi hoi xay dung Nha nude phap quydn cua dan dan va vi dan d nude ta 2.2.3 Ddi mdi va hoan thidn phap luit vd cdng chuc nha nude bdt nguon tu ddi hoi xdy dung ddi ngu cdng chuc phuc vu su nghiep cdng nghidp hoa: hidn dai hoa dit nude 2.2.4 Ddi mdi va koan thidn phap luat vd cdng chuc nha nude bdt nguon tu doi hoi phai thich ung vdi thdi dai mdi huomg PHUONG HUCJNG, giai phap tiE'p tuc dOi MCJI VA HOAN THI&N PHAP LUAT Vt CONG CHlTC NHA NUCJC NUdC TA 3.1 QUAN DCfcvi VA PHUONG HUONG Ddl MOI VA HOAN THlEN PHAP LUAT v£ CONG CHUC NHA NUdC NUdC TA 3.1.1 Nhung quan didm co ban vide ddi mdi va hoan thidn phap hictt vd cdng chuc nha nude d nude ta 3.1.2 Phuong hudng ddi mdi va hoan thidn phap luit vd cdng chuc Nha nude d nude ta 3.2 CAC GIAI PHAP TRONG VlEC Ddi MOI VA HOAN THlEN PHAP LUAT v£ CdNG CHUG NHA NUdC NUOC TA 3.2.1 3.2.2 Ddi mdi va hoan thidn ddi ngu cdng chuc nha nude Hoan thidn hd thdng van ban phap lu&t vd cdng chuc nha nude d nude ta 323 Xac dinh hinh thuc pham vi va ndi dung didu chinh cua phap luat vd cdng chuc nha nude theo vdu cdu ddi mdi kEt luan Phu luc hd thdng phap luAt vd cdng chuc nha nude tu 1945 - 1996 Danh muc tai lidu tham khao Md DAU 1- Tinh cap bach cua de tai Cai each bd may nha nude ndi chung, cai each n£n hanh chinh qudc gia noi ridng theo Vin kidn Dai hpi Dai bie'u toan qudc ldn thir VIII cua Dang Cdng san Viet Nam la mdt much dinh hudng co ban de phat trie’n dit nude ta tir den nim 2000 vi nhirng nim tie'p theo Thue tien much nim ddi mdi vtra qua cho thiy tuu ddi mdi ve kinh te gin bd chit che vdi nhidm vu cai each ndn hanh chinh qudc gia Vi viy Dang ta da xac dinh cai each ndn hanh chinh qudc gia Id khiu tim cua cai each bd may nha nude Muc tieu cua cai each ndn hanh chinh qudc gia la : Xiy dung mdt ndn hanh chinh sach, cd du ning luc su dung dung quydn luc va tung budc hidn dai hoa de quan ly co hidu luc va cd hidu qua edng vide Nha nude Suy cho cimg muc tieu chi co the dat dupe nhin td ngudi bd may quydt dinh Do ddi mdi va hoan thidn ddi ngu edng chirc la mdt ba ydii td die bidt quan ciu ndi dung cai each n£n hanh chinh qudc gia dang tien hanh o nude ta Hien nay, vin de hang diu ddi mdi hoan thidn ddi ngu edng chirc Id ddi mdi vi hodn thidn phap luit didu chinh cac quan he xa hpi linh vuc Bdi vi thuc tien o nude ta cung nhu nhidu nude tren the gidi chi ring hoat dOng edng vu cua edng chuc chi co the7 co hidu qua ddi ngu co du phim chit chinh tri, trinh cao vd ning luc chuydn mdn va nghidp vu, dupe bd tri, su dung mdt each khoa hoc, phii hop vdi quy luit khach quan cua su phat tridn kinh te xa hdi va cd co so phap ly vung chic Tir nhidu nim qua, nude ta vdi nen hanh chinh tip trung quan lieu bao cip, phap luit ndi chung va die bidt la phap luit tren linh vuc edng chirc , edng vu ndi ridng khdng dupe quan tim xiy dung dung mire, cac quy dinh phap ly trdn linh vuc thidu ro rang, nhit quan VI the hoat ddng edng chirc va edng vu kem hidu qua va hidu lire Miy nim ddi mdi gin diy, Nha nude ta cd quan tim hon vide xiy dung phap luit vd edng chtrc , edng vu, mdt sd van ban phap quy dudi luAt nhu Nghr dinh 169HDBT 25 thang nam 1991, Nghi dinh 25-CP 23/5/1993 Nghi' dinh 26-CP 23/5/1993 v.v da lAn Inert ddi nhirng nhin chung vAn chip va thieu quan diem thdng nhA't va cu the chua dap ung yeu cdu nAng cao hieu lire va hieu qua cac hoat ddng quan ly Nha nude Dieu doi hoi phap luAt ve edng chuc, edng vu - mdt bd phAn quan trong he thong phap luAt nude ta, edn phai sdm dupe ddi mdi va hoan thien gop phAn xAy dung ndn hanh chinh quO'c gia vung manh, thuc hien dupe muc tieu cai each Dang va Nha nude de Ddi mdi va hoan thien phap luAt ve edng chuc , edng vu o nude ta dat nhu la mdt nhiem vu co tinh thdi dai Bdi vi trudc su phat then nhu vu bao cua cudc each mang khoa hoc, edng nghe va tin hoc cung vdi nhung bieh ddi sAu sAc quan he giua cac qudc gia, hAu het cac nude trdn the gidi mac dAu da co he thdng phap luAt ve edng chuc edng vu ddi sdm va kha hoan chinh nhung cung da va dang tieh hanh ddi mdi, hoan thien phap luAt trdn finh vuc nay, nhAm lam cho chd dd edng chuc va edng vu phii hop vdi thdi dai mdi, vAn dung co hieu qua tuu cua nhAn loai vao quan ly nha nude Trong di£u kien do, ne'u khdng tieh hanh ddi mdi va hoan thien phap luAt ve edng chuc, edng vu, nguy co tut hAu tren finh vuc tAt ye'u se dien ra, nen edng vu va edng chuc d nude ta khdng theo kip va phu hop vdi dieu kien qudc te mdi Rd rang xuAt phat tir thuc tien nude cung nhu xu the phat trid’n cua thdi dai, nghien cuu vide ddi mdi va hoan thien phap luAt ve edng chuc Nha nude d nude ta la ddi hoi cAp bach, cd y nghia ly luAn va thuc tien thiet thuc 2- Tinh hinh nghien cuu de tai Trude dAy sach bao khoa hoc phap ly nude ta dudng nhu rAt it cong trinh viet ve edng chuc MAy nam ddi mdi gAn dAy, trudc yeu cAu cua thuc tien, mdt sd de tai khoa hoc vd vAn de da ddi nhu : J • "Xcly dimg va ddi mdi ddi ngu cdng chuc hanh chinh nha nude” Pho Giao su, Pho Tidn sy Luong Trong Ydm lam chu nhiem dd tai nam 1992 • "Co so khoa hoc cua vide bd tri cdng chuc cac co quan Trung uong va cap tinh” dong chi Trdn Manh Ldc Vu trudng Vu bidn chd tidn luong Ban Td chuc can bd Chinh phu lam chu nhidm dd tai nam 1995 / Tuy nhidn cho ddn chua co mdt cdng trinh khoa hoc nao nghidn cuu mdt each hd thdng toan didn van dd cdng chuc dudi phuong didn luat hoc Day la cdng trinh ddu tidn nghidn cuu mdt each co ban va hd thdng co sd lv luan va thuc tidn cua vide ddi mdi va hoan thidn phap luat vd cdng chuc nha nude 3- Muc dich, nhiem vu, gicri han va phirang phap nghien cuu cua luan an • Muc dich cua luan an lam ro co so ly luan va thuc tidn cua vide ddi mdi va hoan thidn phap luat vd cdng chuc nha nude nhdm tao mdi trudng phap ly dn dinh cho chd dd cdng chuc nha nude chinh quy, hidn dai phu hop vdi tinh hinh dac didm cua hd thdng chinh tn nude ta, dap ung nhung ddi hoi cua cdng cudc cai each ndn hanh chinh qudc gia va phu hop xu thd phat tridn cua thdi dai • De thuc hien muc tieu tren luan dn co nhiem vu : Mdt la, nghidn cuu mdt sd van dd ly luan vd cdng chuc va phap luat vd cdng chuc va thuc tidn hinh thanh, phat trid’n phap luat vd cdng chuc cua nude ta va phap luat vd cdng chuc cua mdt sd nude trdn thd gidi Hai la, hinh co so ly luan cho vide ddi mdi va hoan thidn phap ~ luat vd cdng chuc nha nude theo tu phap ly mdi vd cdng chuc nha nude Ba la, xac dinh phuong hudng va kidn nghi nhung giai phap dd ddi mdi va hoan thidn hd thdng phap luat vd cdng chuc nha nude d nude ta • Gidi han cua luan an la d chd chi tap trung nghidn cuu vd phuong didn ly luan phap luat vd cdng chuc bd may hanh chinh nha nude, nham xac dinh can cu khoa hoc cho vide xhv dung va hoan thidn phap luat vd edng chirc o nude ta, ma khdng di sau vao cac chd dinh phap ly cu thd khac thudc khoa hoc LuAt hanh chinh • Bing phuong phap luan khoa hoc cua chu nghia Mac - Ldnin tu tuong Ho Chi Minh va nhung tuu cua khoa hoc xa hdi, ddng thdi coi cac phuong phap phan tich, tdng hop, so sanh thong kd dd lam rd ndi dung nghidn cuu cua luan an, dua cac kidn nghi phuong hudng va giai phap ddi moi va hoan thien phap luat vd edng chirc phu hop vdi didu kien thuc td d nude ta 4- Nhtrng dong gop mdi ve mSt khoa hoc cua luan an Day la edng trinh chuydn khao ddu tidn nghidn cuu mdt each cd hd thong va toan didn phap luat vd edng chirc nha nude o nude ta Luan an co mdt sd ddng gop mdi chu ydu sau day : • Lam rd cac khai nidm va pham tru vd edng chirc, vidn chirc nha nude, vai tro, dac trung, pham vi ddi tuong didu chinh va nhung nguydn tie cua phap luat vd edng chirc nha nude, quan he giua edng chirc va vidn chirc giua phap luat vd edng chirc vdi kinh td, chinh tri va xa hdi • Danli gia qua trinh hinh thanh, phat tridn cua phap luat vd edng chirc, tir rut nhung dac didm vd chd dd phap luat edng chirc qua cac giai doan each mang d nude ta Ddng thdi luan an cung so sanh vdi nhung dac didm hinh va phat tridn cua phap luat edng chirc cua mdt sd nude trdn thd gidi • Dua trdn co so ly luan va thuc tidn, luan an da xay dung dupe mdt hd thdng cac quan did’m co ban vd ddi mdi va hoan thien phap luat vd edng chirc nha nude Cac quan didm cd v nghia chi dao hoat ddng thuc tidn xay dimg phap luat edng chirc dang tidn hanh o nude ta • Luan an kidn nghi cac giai phap ddi mdi va hoan thidn phap luat vd edng chirc nha nude Trong dd dang chu y la hoan thidn hd thdng van ban phap luat phu hop vdi tung loai nhu : can bp dan cu, edng chirc, vidn chirc Kidn nghi hinh thirc van ban phap luat pham vi, ddi tuong va nhung ndi dung ccrban cdn didu chinh bing phap ludt v£ cdng chuc Dac bidt li kidn nghi vd xdy dung ludt cdng chuc 5- Y nghTa thirc ti£n cua luan an Ludn an co thd su dung lam tai lidu tham khao cho nhung co quan va nhung ngudi lam cdng tac hoach dinh chinh sach, xdy dung phap luat vd cdng chuc nha nude, cho nhung ngudi lam cdng tac nghidn cuu khoa hoc phap ly Ludn an cung co thd su dung lam tai lidu tham khao cho vide bidn soan giao trinh giang day v£ mdn Ludt cdng chuc nha nude Vidt Nam cac trudng chuydn luat hoac khdng chuydn luat 6- Ket cau cua luan an Ngoai Idi mo ddu kdt luan, phu luc va danh muc tai lieu tham khao luan an gom ba chuong IP Chtrcmg CONG CHUG VA PHAP LUAT Vfi CONG CHUG NHA NUdC LI CONG CHUC VA VAI TRO CUA CONG CHUC NHA NUCC 1-1 1- Quan niem ve cdng chuc, cdng vu Thuc chat cua cdng vu chinh la cdng vide cua cdng chuc Van dd can quan tarn d day chinh la ndi dung cdng vide, tinh chat, vai tro va su mdnh - cua no; Dd chinh la xuit phat didm cua vide xay dung ddi ngu cdng chuc, theo quan nidm vd cdng vu ma co quan nidm vd cdng chuc Theo quan nidm cua cac nude, thi ndi dung cua cdng vu bao gdm nhung cdng vide : hue hidn cac hoat ddng quan ly cua Nha nude cac Finh vuc kinh td van hoa, xa hdi, y td, giao due, an ninh qudc phong nhdm thoa man nhu ciu chung cua xa hdi: Trdn co sd dudng ldi chinh tri da hoach dinh, tat ca