BAIBAOKHOAHOC ILlfA CHON HE THONG TIEU CHI OANH GIA THITC T R ^ G CHOONG TRINH DAO TAO CUl NHAN NGANH HHAN LHYEN THE THAO TROONG OAI hoc the doc the THAO bAc NINH Nguyin Van H6a* Tran Thj Thu Hang** T[.]
I BAIBAOKHOAHOC LlfA CHON HE THONG TIEU CHI OANH GIA THITC T R ^ G CHOONG TRINH DAO TAO CUl NHAN NGANH HHAN LHYEN THE THAO TROONG OAI hoc the doc the THAO b A c NINH N g u y in Van H6a* Tran Thj Thu Hang** T6m tat; ^ B a n g c a c phu’c n g p p nghien ci>u thu’O’n g quy, de tai d a ly a c h p n d u’p’c h # th6ng ti§u o f f d a n h gia thi/c trgng chu'O’n g trinh d ^ o tgo ci> n n n g^ n h H u a n lu y|n th thao Tru’O’n g D ? i hoc T D T T B a c N in h nhllm phat hien xem chu’c n g trinh d ^ o tao d a d u g c thi^t k4, phat trien thyc thi CO the tgo s i n p h im d a o tao n h u m o n g m u 6n h a y kh o ng, h o a c x i c djnh hi#u q u i cQa chu’O’n g trinh d i o tao d a trien khai tho’i gian vCra qua Tir khoa: Ly-a chpn, h# thon g tieu chi d a n h gia chu ’O’n g trinh d a o tpo, K h o a h u i n luypn the thao, Tnj’O’n g O g i h oc T D T T B a c Ninh SELECTION ON SE TS OF CRITERIA OF A SS E SS IN G BACHELO R TRAINING PROGRAM IN SPORTS TRAINING FACULTY AT BAC NINH UNIVERSITY OF PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND SPORTS Summary: B y the com m o n research m ethods, the stu d y se le c ts se ts of criteria of assessing the B a c h e lo r training program in the S p o r t s Training Faculty at B a c N inh U niversity of Physical Edu ca tio n a n d S p o r t s to evaluate the d e s ig n e d and im plem ented p rogra m will create good training result or not, o r to define the efficiency of the p rogra m in the past time Keywords: select, se ts of criteria o f a s s e s s in g training program S p o rts Training Facul^, ^ a c N inh U niversity of P h y sica l E ducation and DAT VAN D E Muc tieu cua giao due dai hoc la dao tao nguoi hoc c6 p h ^ chat chinh tri, dao diic, c6 y thiic phuc vu nhan dan, c6 Iden thiic ky nang va nang luc thuc hanh nghe n g h i^ tuorng xiing vdi trinh dao tao Noi dung giao due dai hoc phm CO tinh hien dai va phat triin, dam bao co cau hop ly giua kiin thiic khoa hoc ca ban vai kiln thiic chuyen mon De npi dimg chuotig trinh d ^ tao cii nhSn ngM i Huin luyen dil thao luon dupe hifn dai va phat trien thi viec xay dimg, bo ximg, cap nhat hay d6i mdi chuong trinh dao tao phai la c6ng viec dinh ky va c ^ thiet Dua tren viec d ^ gia thuc trang chuemg trinh dao tao cu nhan nganh HLTT dang thirc thi d l tim nhung uu diem va han che ciia chuong trinh dao tao tu de nhung giai phap nhkn nang cao chat lupng dao tao cii nhSu nganh HLTT; vay viec lua chpn he thing tieu chi danh gia chuong trinh dao tao la viSc lam cin thiSt va rat quan trong qua trinh danh gia chuemg trinh, cac tieu chi phai phii hpp vdi dac thu dao tao cua nganh Huan luyen th6 thao PHl/dNG P H A P N G H IE N CdU Qua trinh nghi8n ciiu sii d\mg cac phuong phap sau: Phuong phap phan rich vk tong hop tai lieu; Phuong phdp quan sat su pham; Phuong phap phong van tpa d ^ ; Phuong phap toan hoc thong ke K E T Q UA n g h i e n CLfU V A BAN LUAN Khao sat thirc trang van de danh gia yk cac tieu chi, tieu chuan danh gia chirong trinh dao tao cir nhan nganh HLTT DI tim hieu thuc trang vin d l danh gia va cAc tieu chi, tieu chuan danh gia chuong dao tao cii nhan nganh HLTT d 03 trudng: Trudng Dai hoc TDTT Bac Ninh, Trudng Dai hpc TDTT Da Nang, Trudng Dai hpc TDTT Thanh ph6 H6 Chi Minh, chiing toi tim hilu nhimg van de sau: - M6t la chuong trinh dao tao cii nhSn ngarii *ThS, T ruPng Dai hge T D T T B ac Ninh **ThS, Hpc vi#n C anh s^t Nhan dan 196 iSoTMVilllilNUntNTlilHU -S(iDACBIET/201S HLTT ciia Nha tnrcmg dugc to chiic dao tao theo hinh thiic hgc nien chi hay hpc chi tin chi - Hai la y kien cua cac chuyen gia, can bg QL va GV ve vai tro cua cong tac ddnh gia chiiomg trinh dao tao cii nhan nganh HLTT cua Nha tniong - Ba la chuorng trinh dao tao cii nhan n g ^ HLTT cua Nha truorng da dugc danh gid chua, Neu dugc danh gia thi t6 chiic nao danh gia Kit qua khao sat thgc t r ^ g v l vdn d l danh gia vd cac tieu chi danh gia chugng dao tao cu nhdn nganh HLTT dugc cac chuyen gia, can bo QL vd GV the hien nhu sau: * Hinh thuc dao tqo cua chmntg trinh dao tao cvr nhan nganh HLTT cua Nha trit&ng d I tim hieu dugc vin dl hinh thuc ddo tao cu nhan nganh HLTT cua Nhd trucmg theo hinh thiic hgc nien che hay theo hpc chi tin chi, chung toi tien hdnh phong van 156 chuyen gia, can bo QL vd GV Ket qua phong van cho thay: Truong DH TDTT Da Nang vd Truong DH TDTT Thanh Pho Ho Chi Minh dang t6 chuc ddo tao theo hinh thiic hoc chi tin chi; Truong DH TDTT Bac Ninh dang t6 chiic dao tao theo hinh thiic hpc nien che * t kiin cua ede chuyin gia, can bg QL vd GV ve vai tro cua cong tac danh gid chirong trinh ddo tgo cu-nhdn ngdnh HLTT Tiep theo chung toi tien hdnh phong van cac chuyen gia, can bp QL vd GV giang day chuong ddo t^o cii nhan nganh HLTT cac trudng Dai hpc TDTT vd vai tro cua cong tac danh gia chuong trinh ddo tao viec dam bao v l nang cao chat lugng dao tao, kit qud dugc trinh bdy tai bang Bdng Ddnh gia vnCec quan trgng cua cong tac ddnh gid chipcng dao tao cij> nhdn nganh HLTT doi v6i vide dam bao chat lipgng dao tao HLV TT N$i dung Tin so Phan tram (%) Rat quan trpng 142 91.02 Quan trpng 14 8.98 Blnh thuong 0 Khong quan trpng 0 156 100 T6ng cpng Quabangl cho thay: C6tdi91%cac chuyen gia, can bp QL vd GV lua chpn miic dp “Rat quan trpng” vd 9% y kiln cac chuyen gia, can b6 QL vd GV lua chpn miic dp “Quan trpng”, miic d6 “Binh thudng” vd “Khdng quan trpng” khong c6 can bp quan ly vd can bp giang nao lua chpn Nhu vay cac chuyen gia, can bp QL vd GV cd 03 Truong deu danh gia rat cao vai tro quan trpng ciia cong tac danh gia chuong dao tao cii nhan ngdnh HLTT vi?c dam bao vd chat lu ^ g ddo tao GV, HLV * Hep theo chung toi tim hieu xem chtr&ng trinh ddo tao ctr nhan ngdnh HLTT cua Nhd tru&ng da dtrgtc ddnh gid chira; Neu dirffc danh gid thi tS chirc, cd nhan ndo ddnh gid, Thgc tl khao sat 03 Truong B^i hpc TDTT dau ngdnh cd nude cho thay Truong DH TDTT thdnh ph6 Ho Chi Minh mdi dao tao cii nhan ngdnh HLTT tu nam 2012 den nay, theo hinh thiic ddo t^o hpc che tin chi; Truong DH TDTT Dd Nang mdi ddo tao cii nhan ngdnh HLTT tu nam 2013 den nay, theo hinh thiic ddo tao hpc chi tin chi, nen cd 02 Truong chua tiln hdnh danh gia chuong trinh ddo tao; Con Truong DH TDTT Bac Ninh ddo tao cii nhan ngdnh HLTT tu nam 2004 den nay, theo hinh thiic ddo tao nien che vd dang dugc Hoi dong nha Trudng danh gia cho toan Trudng Li^a chpn cac tieu chi danh gia thi^c trang chu'vng trinh dao tpo cu* nhan nganh HLTT * Nguyen tac xdy d^rng tieu chi ddnh gid chuong trinh ddo tgo cu nhan ngdnh HLTT De xay dgng cac tieu chi danh gia chuong trinh dao tao cii nhan nganh HLTT chung toi 197 BAIBAO KHOAHOC Vi$c xay d^’ng, bo xung, c|p nh|t hay doi mdi c h u ’O’n g trinh dao t^o phai la edng viec djnh ky (a n h m in h h g a ) dua vao cac nguyen tac sau day: - Nguyen tic 1: Dam bao tinh kha thi - Nguyen tic 2: Dam bao tinh t o ^ dien - Nguyen tac 3: Dam bao tinh Idioa hoc - Nguyen tic 4: Dam bao tinh chlnh xac - Nguyin tic 5: Dam bao tinh de six dung * Phong van true tiep Itfa chon cac tieu chi ddnh gia chutmg trinh dao t^o cir nhan nganh HLTT Can cu vao muc tieu dao tao cua nha tnicmg, dao t ^ san pham dap ling dugc nhu cau xa hoi, dao tao theo xu the hoi nhap quoc te, dac biet la cac nude khu v\rc Dong Nam A Hien mang ludi cac Truong Dai hoc hang diu khu vuc Dong Nam A ASEAN University Network (AUN) da dua sang kien danh gia chat lugng giao due dai hoc theo nhung tieu chuan d ^ bao chat lugng chung cua khu vuc De cd the ap dung cac tieu chi danh gia chuemg trinh dao t?io mot each c6 co sd khoa hoc, d ^ bao chat lugng va hieu qua cua chuong trinh, can khao sat lay y kien cua cac chuyen gia, giang vien, can bg quan ly dao tao ve cac tieu chi bg tieu chuan Cac chuyen gia cho rang: Mdt so tieu c h u ^ danh gia dua nen nit ggn, mgt so tieu chi trung va khdng ck thiet nen dieu chinh lai Tiep thu y kien cac chuyen gia chung toi nit ggn cac tieu chuk danh gia tu 18 tieu chuan, 102 tieu chi xuong 15 tieu chuan va 92 tieu chi * K it qua phong van bang phieu lua ch^n cac tieu chi ddnh gid chirtfng trinh dao tqo cd nhan nganh HLTT De dam b ^ tinh khach quan tren co sd lu^ an da de xuat 15 ti6u chuSn vdi 92 tieu chi danh gia chuong trinh dao tao cu nhan nganh HUT ma luan an da de xuat, l u ^ an da tien hanb phong van cac chuyen gia, can bg quan ly, giao vien bang phidu hoi v6 lua chgn cac tieu chi danh gia chuong trinh dao tao chuyen nganh HLTT vdi thang diem danh gia nhu sau: Rit ck diiet= 3; Candiiet = 2; Binhthudng= 1; Khong can thiet = Doi tugng phong vin 68 chuyin gia, can bg lanh dao trudng, can bg quan 1^ c^c phong, khoa, trung tarn, va giang vien c6 kinh nghiem tham gia true tiep giang d^y chuong trinh dao tao nganh HLTT, ket qua dugc the hik d bang 198 B a n g Ket qua p h d n g v i n I m c h o n cd c tieu ch i ddnh gid chiFomg tn n h d i o t^o cw nhan Kit qua TT Cac ti§u chuin v k ti§u chi Rit cIn thilt SL Can thilt SL I Bmh thu>d>ng % SL Khdng can thl4t ~ SL % Oilm trung binh Tidu chuan Kit qui hpc tap mpng dg*! (Chuan diu ra) 1.1 C h u in d lu cCia chirang trinh dao tgo d u a c xac djnh phCi hq/p v6i s Cp m ?ng cua n h l trifang va yeu c lu xa hpi 61 89.71 10.29 0 0 2.9 1.2 ChiFang trinh d io tao du’O’c xSy di^ng nham thiic d ly ho?t dpng hoc t|p, vi#c hoc phu’o n g phap hpc t|p va tpo cho sinh vien th6i quen hoc t|p s u it d li 55 80.88 8.82 10.29 0 2.71 1.3 Chuan dau cua chu-ong trinh dao tpo xac djnh ro cdc c hu in mo’c v l kiln IhiJ’c, ky nang, thai dp ngu’dri tot nghiep c in dpt dirpc 59 86.76 10.29 2.94 0 2.84 14 Chuan d iu cOa chu on g trinh dao tpo dap Cmg dirpc yeu cau va nhu cau cua thi trirdng lao dpng xa hpi 58 85.29 10 14.71 0 0 2.85 2.69 0 2.69 1.5 Chtrang trinh d io tao dLPpc djnh ky d in h gi^, dieu chfnh va scat 51 75 13 19.12 5.88 1.6 C h u in dau du’p c xSy di^ng vS dirpc de cpp ro rang chirang trinh dao tao 52 76.47 11 16.18 7.35 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 * Ti§u chuan Chifong trinh dao tpo chi tilt Bi Chipang trinh dSo tpo du’p c x§y dpng tren c a s o chuan dau ra, phO hpp vai quy djnh cua BO G iao dye vO Oao tpo bO tiOu chuan kilm djnh chat iu-png trirang dai hpc, cao dang 56 82.35 10.29 7.35 8.82 0 2.75 1.47 2.69 C ho o ng trinh dao tao nganh HLTT c6 sCr dung b ln mO t l chirang trinh chi tilt 55 80.88 8.82 Chipong trinh chi tilt nOu ro ket q u i hpc tap mong dpi va each thiic dat dope kit qua’ hpc tip mong dpi C ho o ng trinh chi tilt cung c ip nhieu thOng tin, d o p e phO bien va co san cho cac ben lien quan 53 77.94 11 16.18 5.88 0 2.72 25 36.76 13 19.12 12 17.65 18 26.47 1.66 Thoi iopng c ho on g trinh phu hpp vOi npi dung 49 72.06 12 17.65 10.29 2.62 Tieu chu an Npi d u n g c Su true cua c h u ^ n g trinh 3.1 Npi dung chu’O’ng trinh phan anh tarn nhin va sti" mang cua Nha truang 56 82.35 10 14.71 2.94 0 2.79 3.2 Chu’o'ng trinh dao tpo dam bao su’ can doi giOa cac khoi ki^n thCpc dai cu'ang ca sd, chuyen nganh va cac ky nang can thiet 60 88.24 8.82 2.94 0 2.85 3.3 S ip ddng gop cua tCrng mon hoc cho viec d?t dipp-c C h u in d iu du-ac the hien •5 r^ng 53 77.94 8.82 13.24 0 2.65 3.4 Chu’O’ng trinh dao tao du'gc thiet k§ mach lac, cac mon hoc c6 ihau 27 39.71 22 32.35 10 14.71 13.24 1.99 3.5 Chipo-ng trinh the hipn du-gc chieu rgng va chi^u s§ u vh kh6i Itpgng kien thi>c 25 36.76 16 23.53 13 19.12 14 20.59 1.76 3.5 Chipang trinh th i hien r5 hoc phan c a bin, hoc phan co" s a nganh, hoc p hin shuyin n gin h va thgc t$p hope lu$n van t6t nghiep 56 82.35 11.76 5.88 0 2.76 3.6 ^oi dung chuang trinh dipgc c ip n hit djnh k;yr dap ling nhu cau xa h6i 57 83.82 10.29 5.88 0 2.78 3.7 Cac mon hpc chu-ang trinh c6 s g logic bo su n g cho 29 42.65 20 29.41 11.76 11 16.18 1.99 3.8 Chu’o'ng trinh d io tao du’g c thiet ke theo hu’d’ng lien thong hgp 19 giCfa cac trinh 16, cac p haang thu'c to chiic dao tpo, chu’O’ng trinh dao tpo k h ic 51 75 14 20.59 4.41 0 2.71 3.9 C h u a n g trinh dao tpo m4m deo n h im giOp ngu’o’i hpc c6 kha nang Iga chpn mdn hpc, ti4t d6 hpc t$p, phiro’ng phap kilm tra danh gia, phu’O’ng thCrc va thd’i ]ian hpc t#p phu hgp 54 79.41 13.24 7.35 0 slp lien k^t vd* Ti4u chu&n C hi4n l u ^ gid n g d ^ y v k h g c tap 4.1 C h u a n g trinh d&o tgo kp d yng ck c phu-o-ng phap gi§ng d ?y ngu’d’i hpc lam trung tdm hpc t$p theo hu-6ng Illy 88.24 5.88 5.88 4.2 DOi ngu giang viSn ho$c bO mon cd chien lirgc giang day wk hoc t#p ro rang phat huy dirge 47 69.12 tinh sang t^o cCia sinh vien 11 16.18 11.76 4.3 Chien lirgc gidng day va hge t$p giup sinh vien hieu dirge va v$n dyng du-gc kiln thii-c 53 77.94 12 17.65 4.41 50 2.82 2.94 2.51 2.74 4.4 Chien lirgc giang dgy va hgc tap h irin g v l sinh vidn va ki'ch thi'ch vi$c hge c6 chit lirgng 25 36.76 16 23.53 18 26.47 13.2^ 1.84 4.5 Chirong trinh g iln g dgy kich thich sinh vidn hge t|p chCi dgng vd hS trg cho vige hge, c ic h hoc phij hgp 51 75 13.24 8.82 1.47 2.6 0 2.88 Tieu chu an K ilm tra danh gid n gu ’O’i hge 5.1 Danh gid ngirvi hge bao gom danh gia d iu vdo, d in h gid theo qua trinh vd danh gia d iu 'a 61 89.71 8.82 1.47 5.2 Ddnh gid d ga tren c ic tieu chi 56 82.35 7.35 8.82 5.3 Mgirai hge dirge danh gia thdng qua nhieu phirang phap 24 35.29 22 32.35 15 22.06 5.4 ^ige danh gid phan dnh dirge yeu cau cua Chuan dau va ngi dung cua chu’O’ng trinh 49 dao tao 72.06 17 25 2.94 5.5 Cac tidu chi kilm tra danh gid r5 rdng vd dirge cong khai 47 69.12 12 17.65 13.24 5.6 Cdc phirgng phdp ddnh gid hird’ng den vige dgt dirge ede mge tieu cua chirang trinh hge 21 30.88 22 32.35 18 26.47 5.7 Cdc c h u in m ge dirge sir dgng ddnh gid la ro rang v l c6 tInh nhat q u in 23 33.82 23 33.82 19 27.94 4.41 5.8 Cac quy (SHnh v l thu tgc khilu ngi ket qua danh gia ngirdi hge dirge edng b6 cong khai 47 69.12 13 19.12 7.35 4.41 2.53 5.9 Dg tin c|y va tinh g i l trj cua cac phirang p h ip kiem tra din h g i l d a g e djnh ky thim ^n h 41 60.29 18 26.47 13.24 0 2.47 5.10 Ket q u i hge tgp dirge cong bo kjp thdri, chinh xac den ngaai hge v l liru trCr day du d im b io tinh p h ip ly tin c|y 46 67.65 19 27.94 4.41 0 2.63 1.47 2.71 10.2£ 1.93 2.69 2.56 10.2E 1.84 1.97 Tidu c hu an C h i t liPQ'ng d$i n gu can b $ g i ln g d^y 6.1 Dpi ngu g iln g vien c6 nang lye tircng xipng vdi nhi^m vg du’p’c giao 42 61.76 13 19.12 11 16.18 2.94 2.4 6.2 Dpi ngO g iln g vi^n c6 /3 ky ndng cua giang vidn 51 75 13.24 11.76 0 2.63 6.6 yc tham gia hpc tip va td chipc c ic gili thi d Iu truydn thdng dinh k^ h in g nam 48 70.59 12 17.65 8.82 2.94 2.56 u S i Ti@u c hu Sn Hd tro* vd tir vdn sin h vien 9.1 Sinh vidn nh$n du-g-c suk tu’ v in hoc t§p, h§ trg va phSn hdi day du ve viec hpc cua hp 42 61.76 13 19.12 11 16.18 2.94 9.2 Ho^t dpng cd van cho sinh viSn la thda dang 26 38.24 19 27.94 15 22.06 11.76 1.93 9.3 Vloi tryong tarn ly, v3t chdt vd xa h$i cho sinh vien la thoa dang 11.76 45 66.18 13 19.12 Ngii’d'i hpc dLpp'c ho tro c6 hidu quii vide gido dgc tu”tu’dng, dgo dCpc va hlnh n hin 47 9.4 edeh cung nhif loi s6ng Idnh mgnh, sdng 69.12 13.24 11 16.18 44 64.71 12 17.65 8.82 9.5 Hd Irp”ngu'd’i hpc thdng qua ede hlnh thCrc cau Igc bp 2.4 2.94 2.49 1.47 2.5 8.82 2.38 4.41 2.49 2.72 Tieu c hu an 10 Trang thiet bj va co* s v tiing 10 46 67.65 12 17.65 10.29 C d thir vidn didn tCr, thu* vlpn cd day du sdeh, giao trinh, tai lidu tham khao ddp d’ng nhu cdu cOa 54 ngu'd’i hpc, gidng vIdn va edn bd 79.41 13.24 7.35 10.3 Thiet bj phdng thf nghiem, thidt bj nghidn c Cpu khoa hpc day dCi va epp nhpt 30 44.12 15 22.06 12 17.65 11 16.18 1.94 10.4 M ay vi tfnh day du va du p e epp nhpt, nang cdp 46 67.65 11 16.18 10 14.71 1.47 2.5 10.5 Tieu chuan ve an toan vd vp sinh moi trud’ng dpt yeu cdu cua dja phu’o’ng ve tdt cd ede mdt 39 57.35 18 26.47 10 14.71 1.47 2.4 Cd ede bidn phdp ddm bdo hidu qua s u dgng ede trang thiet b|, co* sd’ vpt chat cua ch u on g trinh 10.6 43 Sdo tpo 63.24 12 17.65 10 14.71 4.41 2.4 10.1 C ddy du hd thong phong hpc, nha tap (gidng du’o’ng, ede phdng hpc nhd, sdn t|p,) 12.2 11 Tieu chu an 11 D a m bao c h it lu 'p n g qud trinh g id n g d py va h p c tpp 11.1 C hu ang trinh hpc dup e xdy dpn g bai tat cd ede gidng vien 40 58.82 13 19.12 12 17.65 4.41 2.32 11.2 Ngud'i hpc dupe tham gia vdo vide phdt tridn chu on g trinh hpc 38 55.88 20 29.41 11.76 2.94 2.38 8.82 11.3 Mha tuyen dgng dup e tham gia vdo vipc phdt then ch u o n g trinh hpc 48 70.59 10 14.71 5.88 2.5 11.4 C hu ong trinh hpc thudng xuyen d up e ddnh gid theo chu ky phu hpp 43 63.24 11 16.18 13 19.12 1.47 2.41 11.5 Cac hpc phdn vd chu on g trinh dao tpo nhdn d up e s p ddnh gid cd hd thdng eda sinh vien 47 69.12 11 16.18 10 14.71 0 2.54 11.6 X ay dpn g hd thdng tidu chf ddnh gid hoat ddng gidng dpy cCia gidng vidn 49 72.06 13.24 2.94 2.54 :i)ud trinh dpy vd hpc, kd hopch vd p hu o ng phdp ddnh gid ludn hud'ng tOi mpe tidu ddm bdo chat 23 11.7 lu’p n g vd Olvoc edi tiin lien tge 33.82 22 32.35 15 22.06 11.76 11.76 1.88 Tieu chu an 12 Cdc h o ft d ^ n g phdt triln ddi n gu can nhu c^u d io tgo va ph^t then d6i v&i d$i ngu giang vien vd nhan viSn h5 tr? 44 64.71 15 22.06 8.82 4.41 2.47 12.2 C ac boat d$ng ddo tgo vd phat trien doi vd-i doi ngu gidng vien vd nhdn vidn hS trey phCi h^yp v6i nhu cllu da xac djnh 48 70.59 11 16.18 10.29 2.94 2.54 12.3 Hoat d$ng phdt triSn edn b$ tirang xu’ng vd*! nhu c^u 55 80.88 8.82 8.82 1.47 2.69 12.1 13 C ke hogch ro rSng Tieu chu an 13 L a y y k iln phan h l i tip ede ben iiSn quan 13.1 y kiln p h in hoi tO thj tru’d’ng lao d|ng direyc thu thSp d ly du vii cd h| thing 58 85.29 7.35 7.35 0 2.78 13.2 y kiln phdn hoi tip ngudi hpe vd c^u sinh vien d u a c thu thlp d ly du va cd h| thing 59 86.76 8.82 4.41 0 2.82 13.24 4.41 0 2.78 13.3 14 Y kien phan hoi tu> doi ngu can b|, chuydn gia vd gidng vien d up e thu thap 56 82.35 day du va cd he thing Tieu chudn 14 Ke q ua dau 14.1 Ty le tit nghifp thda dang vd ty l| thdi hpe d m uc chap nh|in d up e 46 67.65 12 17.65 7.35 7.35 2.46 14.2 Thd’i gian tit nghipp trung binh Id hpp ly 41 60.29 15 22.06 11 16.18 1.47 2.41 14.3 Tinh hlnh co vipc lam cua sinh vien tot nghiep la thoa dang 42 61.76 13 19.12 11 16.18 2.94 2.4 14.4 MCpc dp them gia cac ho$t dong nghidn clpu khoa hpc cua gidng vien vd ngudi hpc dat yeu c lu 25 36.76 17 25 18 26.47 11.76 1.87 15 “ i =1i Tieu chu an 15 Su> hai i6 n g cua cac bdn lidn quan 15.1 Phdn hoi cCia sinh vien d li vd-i hogt dong gidng dgy cCia giang vien vd qua trlnh t l chCrc giang day chuo'ng trlnh ddo tgo Id thda ddng 59 86.76 13.24 0 0 2.87 15.2 Phdn hoi cua cuu sinh vidn d li vd-i hogt dong gidng dgy cOa gidng vidn va qua trlnh to chi>c giang dgy chuo’ng trlnh ddo tgo la thda dang 60 88.24 5.88 5.88 0 2.82 15.3 C an b| qudn ly, gidng vidn danh gia sinh vien: H i s o luu dilm va rdn luydn (diem kiem tra cac phan cua ede hpc phdn, h i s o hpc bg) 43 63.24 12 17.65 11 16.18 2.94 2.41 15.4 y kiln cCIa ngucyi si> dpng lao d|ng d li vd’i hogt dong gidng dgy cua gidng vidn va qud trlnh t l chCrc giang dgy c hu an g trlnh ddo tgo Id thda ddng 56 82.35 11.76 4.41 1.47 2.75 i B A IB A O K H O A H O C Cdng tac danh g ii chu^ng trlnh dao tfo cu> nhan nganh HLTT c6 vai trd quan trqng vifc dam bao chat lipong dcio tfio HLV De dam bao nbung tieu chi bo tieu chuSn dirge Iga chon la nhiing tieu chi tieu bieu nhat dung danh gia chuong trinh d^o tao cur nhan nganh HLTT, l u ^ m da loai bo cac tieu chi c6 dilm so trung binh thap dudi 2.0 diem tuc la tong phan % cac y kien cho rmg nguong can diiet va rat can diiet chi dat dudi 80%; cung nhu chi lua chon cac tieu chi tieu chu&i c6 diem so trung binh chung cao tren 2.0 diem, CO tur 80% so y kien cho rang tieu chi dat nguong can thiet va rSt can thiet Qua bang chiing toi nhm thay: Co 71 tieu chi b6 ti6u chuin c6 diem trung binh chung dat dugc tren 2,0 diem va c6 tong % y kien d^t nguong miic cin diiet va rat cin thilt dat tren 80% dugc chung toi Iga chon de danh gia chuong trinh dao tao cii nhan n g ^ HLTT; c6n 21 tieu chi c6 diem trung binh chi dat dudi 2.0 diem khong dugc lua chon Nhu vay kit qua phong phan cac chuyen gia chiing toi da lua chon dugc 15 ti6u chuin vdi 71 tieu chi nhim danh gia thuc tr ^ g chuong trinh dao tao cu nhan nganh HLTT K E T LU A N - Qua trinh khao sat thuc tr ^ g vin d i danh gia va cac ti6u chi, tieu chuan danh gia chuong dao tao cur nhan n g ^ HLTT d 03 trudng cho thay: Trudng DH TDTT Thanh ph6 H i Chi Minh mdi dao tao cd nhan nganh HLTT tu nam 2012 den nay, theo hinh thiic dao tao hoc che tin chi; Trudng DH TDTT Da Nang mdi dao tao cu: nhan nganh HLTT tu nam 2013 den nay, theo hinh thuc dao tao hoc chi tin chi, nen ca 02 Trudng chua tien hanh danh gia chuong trinh dao tao; Con Trudng DH TDTT B5c Ninh dao tao cii nhan nganh HLTT tir nam 2004 din theo hinh diuc d ^ tao nien che va dang dug^ Hoi dong Nha trudng danh gia Cac chuy^gia, can bg QL va GV ca 03 Trudng deu dM i gK cao vai trd quan cua cong tac danh gia chuong dao tao cu nhan ngaih HLTT vi^ dam bao chit lugng dao tao GV, HLV; - Ket qua phong van cac chuyen gia, cm bg q u ^ ly va giao vien c6 tham nien cong tac giang day chuong trinh dao tao nganh HLTT chung tdi da lua chon dugc he thong cac tieu chi bg tidu chuan AUN, vdi 15 tieu chuan va 71 tieu chi nham danh gia thuc trMg chuong trinh dao tao cii nh§n nganh HLTT dang thgc thi qua xac dinh nhung uu diem va han che cua chuong trinh dao tao de de xuat nhung giai ph^ nham n ^ g cao chat lugng dao tao cu nhan nganh HLTT Trudng DH TDTT Bac Ninh TAI L IE U TH AM KHAO Bui Quang Hai (2014), “Danh gia chat lugng dao tao dai hgc he chinh quy nganh GDTC d Trudng Dai hgc TDTT B5c Ninh giai d o ^ 2008 - 2013”, De tdi cap ca sa Trudng DH TDTT Bac Ninh Tran Thi Horn (2009), Nghien ciiu dinh gia diam dinh chuong trinh giao due dai hgc, Ludn an tien si quan ly giao due Pham Quang Long (2012),“Hf thong tieu chi danh gia chuong trinh nghifp vg su pham dai hgc su p h ^ ” Ludn an tien sT, Nxb Vi?n Khoa hgc Giao dgc Viet Nam Ha N6i Nguyen Diic Van (2000), Phuang phdp thong ke TDTT, Nxb TDTT, Ha Ngi AUN Secretariat, Guide to AUN Actual Quality Assessment At Programme Level Version No 2.0, June 2011 • 206 ... nang h u in luypn ede mdn the thao thdnh tich cao 51 75 8.82 11.76 4.41 2.54 36 so lopng 16*0 giao vidn tham gia dieu hdnh c6c t l choc hipp hdi lidn 6.12 5oPn th i thao n o P c vP q u ic t l 42... nganh HLTT Trudng DH TDTT Bac Ninh TAI L IE U TH AM KHAO Bui Quang Hai (2014), “Danh gia chat lugng dao tao dai hgc he chinh quy nganh GDTC d Trudng Dai hgc TDTT B5c Ninh giai d o ^ 2008 - 2013”,... Thanh Pho Ho Chi Minh dang t6 chuc ddo tao theo hinh thiic hoc chi tin chi; Truong DH TDTT Bac Ninh dang t6 chiic dao tao theo hinh thiic hpc nien che * t kiin cua ede chuyin gia, can bg QL vd