Liie b i y gid, mdt so td bao d Phap va d Odng Duang da eoi viec mdt ngudi Viet Nam dd dau ky thi Thae sT tai Oai hpe S u pham pho Ulm la mpt hien tugng hilm la, bilu hien cua met tai na
Trang 1Can siru tam di cao cua nha triet lioc Tran Dire Tliao
vao Liru tru> quoe gia
TRAN DU'C MANH
G iao SU' Tran DLHC Thao - nha Mac-xit, nha Hien tu'O'ng hoc dac s i c - con ngu'O'i
sieu viet cua Viet Nam da v l coi vTnh hang Nhu'ng nhii'ng di cao vo ^ia cua ngu'O'i du'ac coi la thien tai do v i n con "lu'u lac hong t r i n " Trong boi canh nganh Van thu', Lu'u tru" Viet Nam dang co nhCPng dong thai tich CLPC d l d i y manh viec BU'U tam tai lieu quy hiem, Tap chi Van thu' Lu'u trO Viet Nam gid'i thieu bai viet nay vd'i
hy vpng khoi di cao cua Giao su' Tran Du'c Thao se s a m ket thuc cuoc "ICi' hanh vat va" d l tim du'O'c mot vj tri binh yen va xu'ng dang trong lu'u trii' qudc gia, ddng thd'i d l tri tue cua ong - niem kieu hanh, t i f hao chinh dang cua nhan dan Viet Nam - se du'ac phat huy va mai mai tru'O'ng t i n trong ky LPC dan toe va nhan loai
Mpt con ngu'O'i uyen bae va yeu nu'6'c
Co Giao su T r i n Dde Thao sinh ngay
26/9/1917 tai thdn Song Thap, xa Chau Khe,
huyen Tir- San, tfnh Bae Ninh, m i t ngay
24/4/1993 Ong la Nha trilt hpe dugc t h i gidi
ghi nhan nhu mdt trilt gia bien chirng duy vat
lich sir xuit s i c nhit ciia Viet Nam t h i ky
XX Thdi nien thiiu, dng theo hpe Trudng
Albert Sarraut, rdi dd "tii tai Tay" leal xuit
sic Chua hpe h i t nam thir nhit trudng Oai
hoc Luat Ha Ndi, nam 1936 dng dugc nhan
hpe bdng sang Pariss d l thi vao trudng Oai
hpe Su pham p h i Ulm - ngdi trudng tirng
dao tao nen nhilu nha t u tudng, nha khca
hoc Iirng danh Nhilu chinh khach III lac,
nhilu nha bae hge doat Giai thudng Nobel
vin liy lam hanh dien n l u thdi tre minh tii'ng
la "hoc trd su pham" Mdt sd tri thirc nude ta
diu t h i ky XX thudng gpi trudng nay la "tii
cao hpe phu" eua nude "Phap Lan Tay"
Trong suit t h i ky XX d i n nhirng nam d i u
t h i ky XXI, Viet Nam chi cd mpt s l nha khpa
hoc n i l tiing da theo hpe d trudng "nay nhu:
Hoang Xuan Han, T r i n Dire Thae, T r i n
Thanh Van G i n day, GS Ngd Bap Chau,
Phan Duang Hieu cung da bae ve thanh
GS Trin Dwc Thao Anh tw lieu
ccng luan an T i i n sT tai ngdi trudng danh tiing nay
Ougc hgc tap tai ngdi trudng hang d i u
t h i gidi, T r i n Oire Thao ngay dem tim tdi, nghien eiru Trong d i u dng ngap tran t u tudng eiia eae hiin nhan, Ong dae biet quan
Trang 2tam d i n tac p h i m eua Husseri Vi thdi gian
nay, tae p h i m eua Husseri la chu d l cua h i u
h i t mpi cude dam luan v l trilt hpe va xa hdi
Phat xit Oire c i m day tac p h i m ciia trilt gia
nay d cac trudng dai hpe Nen gidi trilt hpe
phuang Tay hy vpng cd t h i khdi phue tinh
than ciia van minh nhan loai qua viee nghien
ciru Hegel va Husseri Vuqyt qua mpi gian
nan, thiiu thdn trong nhCrng nam Chiln tranh
the gidi thir II, dng xuit sac gianh t i m b i n g
tot nghiep Thae sT Trilt hpe hang nhit tai
Phap khi mdi 26 tudi, sau dd bao ve thanh
edng luan an eao hpe roi T i i n sT v l "Hien
tugng hpe cua Huserl" Liie b i y gid, mdt so
td bao d Phap va d Odng Duang da eoi viec
mdt ngudi Viet Nam dd dau ky thi Thae sT tai
Oai hpe S u pham pho Ulm la mpt hien tugng
hilm la, bilu hien cua met tai nang xuit
ehiing
Nhung b i u khdng khi each mang ndng
hdi trong nude da keo dng khdi nhO'ng suy t u
triru tugng d l trd v l vdi manh d i t thye tai
Nam 1944, T r i n Dde Thao duge cir lam bao
eao vien ehinh tri tai Oai hdi kilu dan Odng
Duang hpp trong Tea thi chinh Avignon, nai
ma dng Th| trudng la mdt dang vien edng
s i n , Trudc Oai hdi, T r i n Dde Thao trinh bay
ban dy thao euang ITnh ddi
thilt lap n i n dan chu d Ddng
Duang, Cach mang Thang
Tam thanh edng d Viet Nam
cang khich le dng hang say
hoat ddng xa hdi, Tir kinh
thanh Paris hoa le - kinh dd
anh sang cua t h i gidi, dng
thay mat sinh vien va tri thire
Viet Nam vilt thu gui v l T l
quie bay td tinh yeu nudc
nong nan d l i vdi d i t nudc
vira gianh duge dde lap h i i
thang 8 nam 1945, La thu
dugc in tren td Co giai
phdng, ca quan tuyen truyin
ed ddng TW eua Oang Cdng
san Odng Duang '^', Ong cdn
viet tai lieu tuyen truyin, t l
chirc cae cude hpp bao d l
img hd Viet Minh va Chinh
phii H i Chi Minh Chuyen k l
Kt«^ W /id
LA M N ; | | ; I K l>l PKhSKM MV.l.VI
ring, trpng mpt budi hpp bap, mdt nha bap Phap hdi; Ngudi Viet Nam se ddn t i l p ra sao khi quan dpi v i l n chinh Phap d l bd? Ong danh thep tra Idi: Nd siing! M i y ngay sau,
m i u d l i thoai n g i n ngui nay x u i t hien tren td
Le Monde, dng lap tire bj b i t roi bj giam c i m trong nha tii Prison de la Sente, vdi tdi danh
"xam pham an ninh nudc Phap" Trong thdi gian bj giam, nhilu t d bao t i i n bd da len tiing ddi tra t y do cho dng Tong Bien tap tap chi Les Temps Modernes da vilt mdt ban kiln nghj giri tdi tay m i y nghin tri thirc Phap, tap sire ep d u luan d l bap ve tinh mang cho dng Tuy nhien ba thang trpng tii khdng hpan tpan la quang thdi gian b i t hanh M i t ty do
t h i xac nhung dng lai tim d y g c t y dc eho tu duy: eng vilt dugc m i y bai bae va mdt cdng trinh n l i tiing sau nay eua dng da hinh thanh, dd la edng trinh "Hien tugng hoc va ehu nghTa duy vat bien ehirng"
Trong thdi gian Chu tieh Hd Chi Minh sang Phap, nam 1946, dng bay td vdi Chu tjeh nguyen vpng se trd ve nudc tham gia each mang ngay sau khi vilt xong luan an
T i i n sT Va dng da lam dimg nhu vay Thang
8 - 1951, cudn Hi^n tugng hpe va chii nghTa
duy vat bien chirng dwgc Nha xuit ban Minh
Tan in d Paris Bing tiin nhuan biit eua euln sach vira x u i t ban, dng tir bd giang dudng, tir bd kinh thanh Paris vdi cac thinh phdng trilt hpe dang hira hen ca mpt sy nghiep danh gia huy hoang d l mua ve may bay, bi mat trd v l T l q u i c theo mpt hanh trinh vdng veo tii' Paris sang Luan Ddn, qua Praha, Mat-xca-va, Bic Kinh v l Viet Bic
v l nudc dng trd thanh mpt giao s u dai hpe d chiln khu Nam 1953, dng lam viec tai Van phdng Tdng Bi thu va djch tae
p h i m Khang chien nhit
dinh thing Igi cua d-^ng chi
Trudng Chinh ra tiing
Trang 3Phap Ong cdn dugc cu lam Uy vien Ban
Van-Sir-Oja, t i i n than eua Vien Khoa hpe Xa
hdi Viet Nam, Phd Giam d i e Trudng Oai hpe
Su pham Van khpa, Chu nhiem Khoa Sir
Trudng Oai hpe T i n g hgp Ha Ndi (nay la Oai
hoc KHXH&NV - OHQGHN) Sau dd dng bj
quy tdi dinh liu d i n phong trao Nhan van Giai
phim khi cdng b l hai bai bao ed ban d i n
mdt sd van de ve t u do, dan chii Sau sy kien
nay dng chia tay vdi giang dudng v l lam
cdng tac djch thuat eho Nha xuit ban Sy that
(nay la NXB Chinh tri Q u i e gia) Nam 1992,
dng sang Phap ehCra benh k i t hgp vdi
nghien ciru va m i t tai Paris vao nam 1993
Di hai dng duge nha nudc dua v l an tang tai
Khu A NghTa trang Van Diln, Ha Ndi Nam
2000, dng dugc Nha nudc Viet Nam truy
tang Giai thudng Hd Chi Minh ve khoa hpe
xa hdi
La nha trilt hpe thien tai nhung cude
sdng ddi thudng eua dng ehira d i y nhii'ng
oan khuit, v i t va Tuy nhien, vugt qua mpi
khd khan, thilu thin, tir khii dc minh trilt cua
mpt hiin nhan phuang Odng, nhung tae
phim xuit chiing l i n lugt ra ddi: Sw hinh
thanh con ngudi; Vin de con ngwdi va ehu
nghTa ly luan khdng cd con ngwdi; Tim hieu
nguon goc ngdn ngw va y thCre Nhirng edng
trinh nay dugc in tai chau Au da lam cac nha
khoa hpe phuang Tay kinh n l Khdng it
ngudi mdi m i t ngdng ehd T r i n Dde Thao tir
Viet Nam Mdt s l ngudi edn d i n Viet Nam
de tim "dng T r i n " '^',
Vdi t i t ea nhCrng gi dng da eing hiin cho
sy phat triln ciia tu tudng nhan loai, cac hpe
gia trong va ngoai nudc da danh cho dng
nhung Idi t i t dep nhit Ldi gidi thieu euln
"Nghien eCru nguon goc cita y thirc va ngdn
ngCr" cua dng, Nha xuit ban Xa hdi d Paris
vilt ring: tu tudng cua trilt gia T r i n Dde
Thao da ghi d i u i n quan trpng d i n tinh t h i n
ciia ca t h i he tri thirc, sinh vien Phap nhung
nam nam muai Ngay tai nudc Dwc, d i t
nude cua trilt hpe, cung cd nhilu trilt gia t y
nhgn la mdn de cua T r i n Dwc Thao Trong
cudn Tii' diln cac nha trilt hpe - mdt cdng
trinh han lam d l so, day 2.725 trang, gidi
thieu than t h i va sy nghiep cua cac nha trilt
hoc tren t h i gidi tii' thdi eo dgi chp d i n thdi
nay, ed nhCrng tnit gia chf dugc danh cho
2-3 ddng ngin ngiii, nhung T r i n Dire Thao dugc trang trpng gidi thieu tdi 3 trang k h i Idn
Nhan xet v l dng, GS Trin Van Giau tran
trpng ndi: "Nghe ciia anh Trin Dwc Thao la
phai nghT xa hon cai thwc ti lich sir trwdc mit Tdi nghT gia ma anh Thao lam cai viec tdi lam tw nam 60 den nay, vi lich sw tw twdng Viet Nam Tdi khdng phai la ngwdi khiem tin lam dau, trai lai la khac, nhwng tdi nghT anh Thao lam cd le anh se dl xa hon tdi Khdng sg thieu thwc tien, chi sg thiiu tw duy
va sang kiin ma diiu dd thi anh Thao cd Anh Thao khdng muon "lam quan", anh muin viit nhii'ng tae phim sau sic hon la lam mdt
"dng quan" Dd la mdt trong nhirng ngwdi
cd the dai bieu cho tri thirc Viet Nam Minh khdng cd truyen thing thit hgc, niu cd thi ndi cd mdt nha thit hge thi ngwdi dd khdng phai la Trin Van Giau - Trin Van Giau la mdt giao sw triet hgc hay nha nghien ciru thit hgc Ngtrdi dd chinh la Trin Dire Thao '^^'
Nhan dip xet truy tang Giai thudng Hd
Chi Minh cho edng trinh "Tim hieu ngudn gde
ngdn ngCr va y thirc" eua ed Giao su Trin
Oire Thao, GS Phan Ngpc chia se: "Sw
nghiep ciia dng la khach quan, ciia ca the gidi viec trao giai thwdng cho nha triet hgc Trin Dire Thae da vwgt ra ngoai pham vi mot giai thudng, ma khing dinh mdt dwdng lit ciia Dang ta doi vdi nhCrng lao ddng tri dc ndi ehung va doi vdi Viet kieu lam viec tri dc ndi neng ' '
GS NGND Nguyin Dinh Chii - trg giang eua GS T r i n Oire Thao tai trudng DH Su
pham Van khoa nam 1957 tam sy: "Thiy
Tran Dire Thao la mdt con ngwdi sieu viet eua Viet Nam da danh, Thiy cdn dang cho nen van hoa Phap tw hao Con ngwdi dd cung cd phin ciu thanh eua chung nhan loai "'"
Khdi tu" lieu, tai lieu quy gia cua c6 Giao su" T r i n DLPC Thao hien o- dau
Theo nhilu nguln tin tren bao ehi, hien nay g i n nhu toan bd ban thao va di cao eiia
CO Giap su T r i n Dde Thao dang dugc Tiin
sT Trilt hpe - MT hpe Cii Huy Chir, em trai ciia
e l Thi sT Cii Huy Can luu giu' Hien nay TS,
Trang 4Cii Huy Chir dang s i n g tai quan Thu Dwc,
TP H i Chi Minh
TS, Cii Huy Chir eho bilt, giCra dng va
GS T r i n Dire Thao ed m l i quan he tir
nhu'ng nam 1960, dae biet mat thilt han tii'
nam 1967 trd v l sau nay: "O Ha Ndi, tdi giup
Giao sw nhwng viec nhw danh may ban thao,
Iwu giCr ban thao, chuyen giri bai viet eua
Giao sw cho nhCrng ngwdi cd mdi lien he vdi
Giao sw, chii yeu la thit hgc Tdi eung tim
mdt sd tw lieu, soan thw muc theo sw chi dan
cua Giao sw Tdi rit hirng thu lam cdng viec
iy, vi day la dip may hiim cd dwgc tiip xue
vdi mdt thien tai Ban thao goe eua Trin
Dire Thao hien cdn giir lai kha diy du va he
thdng trong thw vien cita tdi do GS Tran Dire
Thao trao lai trong qua trinh tdi ed moi quan
he vdi Giao sw tw nhCrng nam 1960 eho din
lue eudi ddi."^'^^
Theo dng Cu Huy Chu, GS Trin Dire
Thao chi ed mdt ngwdi thira ki hgp phap duy
nhit la Bae sT Tran Dwc Tung, hien dang
sdng tai TP, Ho Chi Minh Hai eu than sinh
eiia GS T r i n Oire Thao ed hai ngudi con
trai Ngudi con trai ea la liet sT T r i n Dde Tao
Ong Tao chf cd mdt ngudi ccn trai duy nhit
la bae sT Tung Ngudi con trai thir hai la GS
T r i n Dde Thao, trudc day lap gia dinh vdi ba
Nguyin Thi Nhit, nhung da ly hdn ngay
05/01/1967, khdng cd eon Ban ehinh quylt
dmh ly hdn nay GS T r i n Oire Thao true t i l p
giao cho dng Cii Huy Chir giCr Tir dd d i n
ngay mit, GS T r i n Oire Thao sing dde
than Bae sT Tran Dire Tung da iiy quyin ehe
dng Cu Huy Chir toan quyin sir dung va
cdng bo tac phim ciia GS Trin Dire Thao va
gin giCr di san ciia Giao sw
Theo dng Chir: t h i he tre Viet Nam se r i t
t y hao v l T r i n Dde Thao, nha trilt hpe ldi lac
ciia dan tde va eiia t h i gidi T r i n Dde Thao
d l lai t i m guang ciia mot nha khoa hpe chan
ehinh hoc tap suit ddi, c i n m i n sang tao
suit ddi, vugt qua mpi khd khan, dau k h i d l
sdng trung thyc va trong sang Trilt hpe T r i n
Oire Thao khdng chf cua hien tai ma edn la
cua tuang lai, bdi cae edng trinh cua dng
ludn ludn cd can cir khoa hpe, nhit la khoa
hpe sinh gidi va khpa hpe vu tru Treng dilu
kien phat triln cua d i t nude va eua dan tdc
hien nay, 6k cd mdt t i m nhin vira sau sac,
vira vugt trude thdi dai, dng Chir tin ring cae t h i he dde gia Viet Nam, dac biet la t h i
he tre, se ddn nhan tae p h i m cua T r i n Dire Thao nhu mdt bau vat T r i n Du'c Thao sing mai trcng tri tue Viet Nam.'^*
Ngpai TS Cii Huy ChCr, ngudi dang gin giCr kha d i y dii di cap eua GS T r i n Dire Thap, cdn mdt khii di cap cua Giao su dang dugc luu giCr tai Nha x u i t ban Oai hpe Quie gia Ha Npi Khii tai lieu nay trude day do Nha tha Viet Phuang - nguyen la trg ly ciia
c l Thu tudng Pham Van Odng quan ly Vira qua dng da trap toan bp khoi di cap cua nha Trilt hge T r i n Oire Thao giri Thu tudng cho Nha xuit ban Oai hpe Qudc Gia Ha Npi Chuyen k l ring: GS, T r i n Oire Thae va Thii tudng Pham Van Odng cd m l i quan he dac
biet Do vay GS, T r i n Dde Thao thudng giri
cac ban thae cua minh che Thu tudng, Thu tudng Pham Van O l n g da nhan dugc nhilu tap ban thao, du ca danh may lan vilt tay, tiing Phap l i n tiing Viet eua GS, Trin Dire Thae giri tang Thii tudng thudng dpc rit ky
va giac chp dng Viet Phuang bao quan Thu tudng dan dng phai tim each xuit ban din
Do vay dng "ehpn mat giri vang", phd thae lai eho Nha xuit ban Oai hpe Q u i c gia Ha Ndi Theo Idi k l eua Nha tha Viet Phuang:
"Thii tudng Pham Van Ddng ed sy g i n gui
va cam thdng r i t sau s i c vdi nhilu tri thirc
Idn, nhilu van nghe sT, T r i n Dde Thae la
ngudi dac biet trong sd dd Ong Thao bj
phan biet d l i xd va bi eoi nhu khdng dang tin
cay suit cude ddi, va Pham Van O l n g , vdi tu each vira la Thii tudng vira la ngudi ban tri
am, da gat dd eho T r i n Dire Thao, da giiip dng mdt phin nao dd v l tinh t h i n va vat chit Nhung sy giiip d d eiia dng nhd thdi nhung da lam eon ngudi ngay tha va vung dai trong ddi thudng cua T r i n Dire Thae qua dugc nhCrng can k h i n khd nhat Nhung giiip
dd v l vat chit thi dng thudng thdng qua mdt edng sy khac la GS Pham Nhu Cyang - sau nay la Vien trudng Vien Trilt hpe Ngoai ra, cdn ed dng Ha Huy Giap va dng Ha Xuan Trudng, Cdn sy giiip dd v l tinh t h i n , nhit la saeh vd, tai lieu thi thudng thdng qua tdi Cd nhirng tai lieu ngudi ta giri tang dng, thudng
Trang 5bang tiing Phap, dng ludn giri cho T r i n Dde
Thao Va dng Thao eung vay, td khi d chiln
khu v l , da d i u dan giri nhirng tac phim eiia
minh (ea dugc in va khdng duge in) eho Thii
tudng dpc
NhCrng tae phim d i u tien la ban djch va
binh mdt so doan quan trpng trong Hien
tugng luan tinh t h i n ciia Hegel dng Thao
d|ch tii' tiing Dde Tae phim thir hai la Logic
eiia Hegel, dng Thao djeh tii' tiing Oire ra
tiing Phap Ong cung vira djch vira binh
bing tiing Phap Thii tudng dpc rdi tang lai
tdi Cd mdt ngudi nCra eung sang mugn Thu
tudng d l dpc la Tdng bi thu Le Duin Ong
Le Duin eung thich dpc trilt hpe va dpc
dugc tryc tilp bang tiing Phap V l sau tir
1964 trd di, dng Thao bit d i u giri thanh hai
ban, mdt ban cho Thii tudng va them mdt
ban cho tdi."'^'
Nha tha Viet Phuang edn chp bilt: T r i n
Dde Thao gianh dugc sy tran trpng eua
nhii'ng vT nhan eiing t h i he vdi dng Nam
1971, Bertrand Russell (trilt gia Anh noi
tiing) va J, P Sartre (nha van, nha trilt hpe
Phap tirng dat giai Nobel) - nhirng ngudi ehu
truang lap Tda an q u i c t l xet xir tdi ae ciia
d l quie My trong chiln tranh Viet Nam - ed y
djnh sang Viet Nam Trong ehuang trinh dy
dinh d Viet Nam khoang b i n ngay, yeu c i u
diu tien ciia J.P.Sartre la dugc gap gd T r i n
Dire Thao trpn ngay d i u tien Vi nhilu ly do,
chuyin di khdng thanh, nhung cd t h i nhan
thay tinh cam cung nhu sy tran trpng ma
nhii'ng ccn ngudi t i m cd nhu Sartre da danh
cho Trilt gia T r i n Dire Thao
v l con ngudi ciia T r i n Dde Thao, Thii
tudng Pham Van O l n g ludn ludn ndi: "Od la
mdt tai nang va la mdt ngudi bj pan khuit"
Nhung mpi ndi oan khuit ma dng phai ganh
chju suit cude ddi khdng h i d l lai trong dng
dii chf la mdt d i u v l t nho nhit cua sy ciru
han Con ngudi dng trcng sang d i n mire
ngay tha Cd l i n dng ndi vdi Thu tudng: Tap
chi Trilt Hpe eiia VN tcan la chinh trj, chang
cd chiit trilt hpe nao trong dd ea va Thii
tudng eung phai edng nhan dieu dd
Trong s l ban thao di cac dng Viet
Phuang trap tang NXB OH QG Ha Ndi va
Thu vien qudc gia, cd kha nhilu tac pham
ehua tirng duge edng bd, Trong dd cd nhirng bire thu dng Thao giri neng eho Thii tudng,
cd nhCrng bire thu ma cae nha trilt hpe t h i gidi giri eho dng Thao va ea nggi dng nong nhiet ngoai sire tudng tugng eiia ngudi VN, Nhu la thu ciia Lucien Sevre - mdt trong nhCrng nha trilt hpe xuit sac nhit eiia nudc Phap hien dai vilt v l dng: "Nha trilt hoc VN
ma nhirng bai giang da d l lai d i u i n cho ca mdt t h i he tri thirc nude Phap", ed ea tae phim culi ciing ciia dng trudc khi mit, vilt tai Phap bing tiing Phap: Legie eiia eai hien tai sinh dpng
o l k i t cho bai vilt nay xin dugc d i n Idi eua Giac su Daniel J Herman'®': "Hy vpng chan that ring T r i n Oire Thao, nha Mac-xit
va nha Hien tugng hpe dae sac, eudi eiing se tim duge ehd dirng xirng dang trong ljeh sir
t i n g quat ciia y nghTa,"'^°' Va cung hi vpng
rang di eao ciia GS, T r i n Dde Thao - "Nha
Trilt hpe duy nhit ciia Viet Nam" '^^* - "Ngudi ICr hanh v i t va"'^^' - "Ngudi tu duy khdng bilt met"*^^' - "Con ngudi sieu viet eiia Viet Nam"*^'*' - "Con ngudi dang d l cho n i n van hda Phap ty hao"'^^' - "Con ngudi dd eung ed phin eiu thanh ciia ehung nhan loai" '^^' cung se sdm ket thiic cude "lir hanh" de tim dugc mdt vj tri binh yen va xirng dang trong luu trCr quic gia Viet Nam O l khii di cao ciia Giao su duge khdng chf dugc bao quan an toan trong dilu kien toi uu, va dd cung la dilu kien d l tri tue eiia dng - nilm kieu hanh,
ty hao ehinh dang eiia nhan dan Viet Nam se
mai trudng ton trong ky dc dan tde va nhan
Icai./
1 Bao C& giai phong sd 22 ra ngay 4 thang 9 nam
1945
2 5 14 15 16 KiSu IVIai Son, Tuanvietnam.vn
3 Bao Van nghe.ra ngay 2/6/1993
4 Bao Tidn phong Chii nhat, sd 22-23, nam 2000 6.7 Bao Van nghe tre so 9 (536) trang 18 ra ngay 4/3/2007
8 Bao Tuoi Tre ngay 04/06/2006
9 Giao sw t^i Dai Hoc West Fionda 10.Bach khoa thw vd Hien twang hoc, Kiuwer Academic Publishers 1997, tr 707
11 GS Tran Van Giau Bao Van nghe 2/6/1993 1.2.Nguyen Dinh Thi Bao Doan kdt thang 7/1993
13 Ha Xuan Trw&ng Bao Van nghe Thw bay 24-7-1993