1989-N2; PykoBponsman pone KIIB H ec IDH3HAHH€ B HOBOH KOHCTHTYUHH.. lHäpoKoe Dacipocrpanewne M€TOJIOB IDOH3BOCTB€HHỌ CAaMOOTOST€JIbHOCTH KPeCTbAHCKHX ABOPOB H OCYHI€CTBJI€HH€ DA3/NHHBIX
Trang 1MoeckopcKHii Í'Ocy/aDCTB€HHbIll COHHAJ1SHBLf YHHBCDCHI€E
IOpujiueCckHii LÍHCTHIYT
Ha ñnpaBa DyKOIHCH
Hryen Ban TxaHb
[IPABOBBIE HPOEJIEMBI IIOJINTHNECKOFO OBHOBJIEHLH7I BO BBETHAMI
(co Bropoli noioswubi 80-x rr 40 BropoH no/iosnibi 90-x rr XX Beka)
SN
h À9 CneunaneHocTb 12.00.01 - Teopua H HCTOpHA
Ze TOCY/IAPCTBA H npaBa, HCTODH4 NOMHTHYECKHX
\, TR¯ỜNG ẠI HỌC LUẬT PHONG ỌC _ ff | ^^ ee 3 HÀ NỘI
Jiucceprauua Ha CONCKAaHH€ yueHOK CT€TI€HH
_KAHJHHATâ IODHNHH€CKHX HayK
HaywHbIl DyKOBOHNHT©Ib
-1OKTOD !ODHJIMH€CKHX HãYyK
npoQeccop Bepuenko A 41Mocksa - 1998
Trang 2BBE]ENMHE
Inapa | COLI1AJISHO-2KOHOMHMFECKHE HIPEJITOCBIIKH NOJIUTHYECKOTO
OBHOBJIENHS B COLIMAJIMCTHMECKOH PECIIYBAMKE BbETHAM 7 1.1 BsaumMocsa3b H B3aHMO/I€ÏiCTBH€ JKOHOMHYECKOM pD€(ÙODMEI H IOJ1J1-
TH1€CKOTO O6HOBEHHE 9 1.2 Bo3pacranue pon HIDABA B MOJIMTHYeCKOM 2KH3HH Bb€THAMCKOTOo6imectna 22[nana IT OBHOR!IEH!IE NONMTHYECKON CHCTEMBI XH POJIb FOCY NAPCTBEHHO-
MIPABOBbIX YUPEXWEHUM COLIMIAJIACTHHECKOlH
BbETHAM
PI:CIIYBJINHKH
¬"~”II.1 OỐnopJicHne Kommynucruyeckoii Ïlaprnn Breruama, Kak npaBauteli
[I.2 IlonbItieHHe ponu uv 2(Ð(Ù€KTHBHOCTH /€ST€JIbHOCTH
HH3 Pocynapernenvoe ynpapnenve H p€{JODMA_ 87MHHHCTDATHBHOÍ
CHCT€MBI 82
1.4 CoBepIleHCTBOBaAHIH€ Cyn€ỐHO-IDABOBO CHCT€MI [II
I nana II [IPOBJIEMbBI JIAJIbHEliHIETO PA3BUTHA IEMOKPATHH B
COBPEMEH-HOM BbE-THAME 154IHT.1 Copepuieucrnospanne /I€MOKDATHH Kak 34KOHOM€DHOCTb pa3sBHTHA
counasu3ma B COIIHAJt8cTHueckoli PecnyØnnke Brernam 154
HHI.2 QCHOBHbI€ IYTH YyTJIYỐJ1€HH1 JeMOKpaTHH BO Bb€THaMe€ 162
3AKJHOYEHHE 192
Trang 33a HOCJI€HHHG TOJHBI B MHD€ CYHICCTB€HHO H3MCHHZIACB OỐCTaHOBKA | MR3Q@LYHADO/JIHbIX OTHOLICHHIIX BO3HHKIIH YCIOBHA /UÚ1 CHHDKEHHA KOHQOHTAHHIHT€HCHBHHI HDOH€CC H€MOKDATHH€CKOFO OỐHOBJI€HHS 34TDOHYJHI MHOFHI
TOCY/ADCTBA, B TOM HHCJI€ COLHGJIHCTHMCCKHC CTpaHbl, B KOTOPbIX HD€JHCTOZLL
JI4KBHHHDOBATb IIOC6NCTBH1 CHCT€MHOTO KDH3HCA TOT IpOHe€CC 3aTponyst Hu CPB
Ha done rnyÕOKHX I€DEMH, B D€3ÿJIbTdi€ MpOBOAUMbIX DAJHKJIbHBI:HDÊOƠDA43OBAHHÍ B COHHAIBHO-3KOHOMHU€CKO H IHIOHIHTHU€CKOÍ 3KH3HIpyKoOBO/Icrso CPB noÕn1oOcb 3â KODOTKH COK 3HA4HT€/IbHO Pa3BHTb 3KOHOMHKỳIIODBBIIICHHØ YDOBHI 3KH3HH HADOHA, H3Õ©K/IO MONHTHYCCKHX KOJLIH3H 1
COLHHAJbHOTO MpOTHBOCTOAHHA, H TEM CaMbIM COXPaHHJIO OCHOBHBI€ HCTODHu€CKUL
OpHeHTHpb! HA H3ỐDAHHOM HYTH Oro CBH€T€JIbCTBY€T O TOM, HTO BO b€THAMvCTaiO BO3MOMHBIM COMGIAHH€ JIHKBHJAIHH COLI137BHO-2KOHIOMHH€CKOÍ OTCTAJIOCTI
+
ii COBEDIHICHCTBOBaHHZ Haqarol c aprycra 1945 roga HOJINMTHH€CKO CHCT€MBI |
COBD@M€HHBIX YCJIOBHHX.,
B CPB, kak u B CCCP, KHP, c camoro Hauana npouecc peOpM O11 cBa3al
CO 3HA4HT€JIEHbBIM YCHJI€HH€M POH Npaba Wit NPOBEACHHA OCHOBHBIX HAïDABJI€EHHI.
OOHOBNCHHA CTpalbl, pD€AJH3AHMH BA3KH€ÏHHHX COHHMAIBHO-2KOHOMHH€CKMX L
IIOJIHTHH€CKHX 3a7au.
[(pOHGCC BOCNPHATHA, CTaHOBNeHHA M_ HCHO/IS3OBAHHT Bb€ØTHAMCKHN.OỐHI€CTBOM IDABA MpOWCXOAKT B CJIO3HBIX YCNOBHAX NOCHE /UIHT€JIBHBIX BỌI.COIDOTHBJI€HH4 H OCBOỐOXJI€HMI, a TâK2K€ HOCJI€BOCHHOTO KDH3HCA, KOTOPBIt
IDHB©IÍH K OTCTABAHHIO IDABOBOTO D€TYJIMDOBAHH1 B DA3HbIX C{)€DAX OỐII€CTB€HHII^
OTHOII€HHÌI, K MâCCOBBIM HADYIICHHSM 3aKOHHOCTH CKâ3bIBA©€TCä HH3KH YDOB€HI
IID4BOBOÌÍ KYJIETYDHI HAC€eHH1, H Mala1 2()€KTHBHOCTb AeATeMBHOCTH Cy€ÕHnoÏiBIACTH Dror mpouecc MH€T O/IHOBDM€HHO C OOJIbLUHMH H3M€GH€HHSMH BO
Bb@THâMCKOM OỐHI€CTBG H B TeCHOH CBH3H C 3KOHOMHYeECKOM pe(popMoH hi NOCTCNCHHbIM HOJIHTHH€CKHM OỐIIOBJICHHCM HberHaMCkKOe [IIDBABO BCe KPHDBHCC
Trang 4BO3/telcrpyeT Ha p€OpMHpOBAIII€ OỐIICCTBA Ono HTDA€T BAKHVIO poly p
COLHJIEHBIX II€DM€HAX BOOỐII€ H B OỐHOBI€HHH HOJIHTHI€CKOÍ CHCTeMbI, B
YaCTHOCTH.
Uccnenonanne pon Bb€THAMGKOTO HDA0A B HOIHTHICKOM OOHOBNENHH B
COBPeMeHHLIX YCJIOBHIX H€HICTABIIGT 3HAWHT€IbHH HHTepec l(papo Bb©THAMCKOTO OỐII€CTBA B T€Q€CHH€ TBICIUH JẾT ỐBULIO NOR B7IHZHH€M KOH(ÙyHHaHcrBa HÏaHHOHAIbHỌ OCOỐ€HHOCTBIO ero Obl HABOBOI HHTLLIH3M Tlocne nOJTHX B€KOB H3ONHHIHH H COIIHIA7bHO-IOJIHTHW€CKHX IIOTPIC€HHÍ OHO C OỐPA30BAHiI€M HOBOFO CTpos ï1 CO3/AHH€M HOBOH npaưobpoií cuctremoli, c 1945 roma BOBJIKIOCE B MHDOByiO HOJIHTHKY Ho 9ta HOBad IIDABOBA1 cHcTeMa mpHOOpena COBpeMenHbie €pTbI AMWE c 1986 roma B CB13H C NpHusTHM Ha VI cbe3je KIB KYDCOM OOHOBMEHHA H ABIETCA H€OTJ€JIHMOÍ YACTLIO HOJIHTHKH OOHOBIEHHA 3aBpeMA, IDOII€/II€€ nocne Havana OOHOBNeHHA, BO BreTHaMe HAKOHHJICIS II€HHBIÍOIIBIT MpHMEHEHHA IID3BOBBIX HODM MIA O2KHBJICHH H YCKOD€HHS IOJIHTHH€CKGlCHCT€MBI KH NpeoOpas0BanHsA 2KOHOMHKH B ITOH CBA3H DACCMOTD€GHHC€ /1AHHỌ TEMbIHM€€T MpakTuyeckoe 3HA4€HH€ AA Nawbnehwero IDOB€JI€HHSE IKOHOMHYCCKOH HIIONMTHM€CKỌf D€ODMBI
B CPB n3y9cliue BbeTHaMCKOTO TIDABA B HAyHHOM IJIAH€ Hả92/10Cb € 50-X.
TO/HOB Bo MHOTHX pabotax B OCHOBHOM ObLIH paCCMOTPeHbl BA2KHbt€ MOMOKEHHS
KOHCTHTYHHOHHOTO, AJIMHHHCTDATHBHOTO, ÿYTO/IOBHOFO ID3BA, NOKa3aHa pOJIb pasa
B CTDOMTCJIbCTBC HOBOTO OOII€CTBCHHOTO CTDOH
Bo propo nonopnnne 80-x - Hauane 90-x TT B CBA3H Cc I€D€XOJOM KYUPaBsICHHIO cTpanon Ha OCHOBE IIOJIHTHKH, 3aKD€II€HHOH B 3aKOHAX,HDHHIIHIIHAJ1EHBIC BOIDOCBI TO NOBBIMICHHIO POJIH WpaBa H371O2KCHBI B O(ÐHLtHa7IbIIbIX
BbICTYIUI€HH8X HW TDY/JAX DyKOBO/UIIIWX €ST€/I€Í BbeTHaMa.' OCHOBHbI€ BOIIDOCBI
CN, Hiyen Ban Jlinb 3a OỐHORT€HH€ MBIIIEHMS H CTHIIS paØom -Xanoli :IIpana.1987; Ha mya rđYyÕOFHX H
BCCCTODOHIW8X H3M€IicHHii, -Xanoli.:[Ipanza.I987; Qốnonnnenrte m1 mporpecca -Xanol(.:ÏIpanna,L989; Uniour THHS.
OGHOBJICHHC - 8KTY(IbHOC TDCỐOBAHHG CIDA1IbI H INOXH -Xauoii,:Ilpanna, 1987, Họ Muloli, Kisii yracprwacr H
pA3pUnaier kypc coốnonnerttt -Xanofi:[lpanu 1989; Coyne HADOHHOFO TOCV/LADCTBA: /IOCTHXKCHHH, 2ITBT
0ÕHopnennw -Xano.:Ilpan/m,l991: HeKoropnic 34/1H OOHOBJICHHf HH YIODH/IOICHIDI naprin.-Xanoft (992;
RODMIHDORIHIG COILHAJTHCTHSCCKOIT ACMOKPATHH H MpaBOBOTO TOCY/LADCTBA -Xanofli.1992: VcwneHie pena oỐHOBCHIHA
Trang 5COBPeMeHHOrO BbÈïHAMCKOTO HpaBa DACCMATDHBAIOTCA B paOoTax BbeTIAMCKHX
YYCHbIX IOPHCTOB, APyPHx HAYHTBIX uccylenoparenei’ JÏHIIb B HOCJIÈ/HH€ TOHBI
IIO#BHJIC1 pag HYỐIHKAHHÍ H nHCC€DTAHHOHHbIX DAỐOT, TPpyHOB KOJUI€KTHBOU ABTODOB, HOCBAHIHHBX B3âHMOH€CTBHIO HATHHHX ODFAHH3AHHH H
TOCVYADpCTB€HHHIX ODTAHOB, 2TAIAM pa3BHTHA BbÈTHAMCKOTO 34KOHOHAT€/IECTBA,
NOBLILUCHHIO 2(€KTHBHOCTH PYHKUHOHHPOBAHHA 3B€Hb€B HO/IHTHH€CKOÍ CHCT€MBI, OCMhICJICHHIO IDABOBOTO ObecneyeHHA IIDOLICCCA HÊMOKDATH3AHHH OỐII€CTB€HHOl
3C13HH, â TâK2K©€ CTAHOBJIEHHIO IIDABOBOTO roCy/ApCTBa B CPB > Cran DA3BHBATbG1
HHTe€pec COBCTCKHX H POCCHHCKHX VH€HHX, KODHCTOB K HCTODHH H )OJIH
BO HM¥ COIlUinH3MA -XaHoHđ.:ÏIpasna,l993; COB€DHICHCTBOBAHHC TOCY/NAPCTBCHHOTO AiHADATA H OƠHOBJICHHC IADTHHOFrO DyKOBOACIBA TOCYUADCTBOM //KOMMYHHCT.Ì992-MI];, FÍ3M€HeHHI H TOHOIH€HHH B KOHCTHTyIUMH HH BOINPOCbi (POPMHpOBaHHA đDaBOBOrO rOCY/AApCTBa.//oMMYHHCT 1992-5, Bo TH Konr QỐHOBJICHHC ODTdHH3ALUHH 31
I€XT€bHOCTH HADO/HHBIX COH€TOB - HDAKTHHCCKOC H€OTJO2KHOC TD€ỐOBAHH€ 3H32HH QA D€4H38LJ1H
HADOHOBJACTIUI.-BcryIieHHe Ha BceBkerHaMCKOÌ KoHipepeHUHH HapOnHkix Coberop 2 anpemi 1990 roaa, Bo Ban Keer EOcrunuua COBCDIICHCTHYCTCH, BLUHIOJHUIT HOCTABICHHBIE HADFHC H TOCY/4DCIBOM 3ân44H - BCTYALI€HHG Hà KOHỦCPCHIỤIH
0praHOB IOcrnuii CPB.(®espele 1993 roga.
2C JÏ[ÊMOKDATH32LH1 OỐII€CTB€HHỌ 3KH3HH CỐODHHK CraTch -XaHOl,1987, CTpOHT€IbCTBO BJIACTH H OTpACTEÌI npàa -XaHol.:IIpasna,l98?, Txai Bmmb Txanr KoHCrnryHuoHuoc pa3smnrue CPB -Baxy,1988; /ạo Un Yk YTO/JIOBHO-IDABOBI€ OCHOBBI ỐOpbỐbl c Np€CTyHIOCTbO B CPB -M.1988; HOCTHUHH: HOHWTH€, HOJIOKCHH€ H o6xosnetiuve.//Toc ú npaso 1989-Ned; Hek¡ropble OCHOBHbI€ 8ORpOCbi KoRCcTHrytuan //Komatynucr 1990-14; Hryệu Txyx OCHOBHbIC HUGH H HAIDABJICHHI OỐHOBJICHHH ODTBHH3LNH H ACSTEABHOCTH OpraHOB TOCY/1APCTBCHHỌL BI1AC1H //I'oSynapcrBpOo H mpapo.1989-h2; Hryen Mane Xynr HeKOTODEI€ ACH€KTbi OỐHOB€HHI OpraHH3auHHH HatuioHaneHoro CoốpanHm //Tocynapcrso H npaso.l989-M2, Xoanr Baw Xao O npDHHUHnâX OỐHOBI€HHS ODFAHM23ALHH HH
H€ST€IbHOCTH alinapatra COHHAIHCTMMGCKOrO roCynapcrsa //I'ocynapcrso 1989-N2; PykoBponsman pone KIIB H ec
IDH3HAHH€ B HOBOH KOHCTHTYUHH /TOCYHApCTBO H mpaso.1991-M2; O6 onpeneeHHH (yHKHHB HApTHỖHOTO DYKOBOTCTBA H FOCYHADCTB€IHOIO ÿYIDABIEIHM OỐUICCTBOM //KOMMYHHCT 1990-M9; Hro Jib Manb, HahHOHaneHOc
CoỐpanH€ - phiciHHÍ OpraH HAapOnHOrO HIp€NCTaBHT€IECrpa CPB.-M.,1989 3aKOHOHAI€IbHAú4 HCST€TEHOCTb Haunonaneuoro CoÕpanua so BberHawe //ÐecrnHK MIY, cepHx [lpaso 1990-1; an Jisem O CO3BAHHH H D€AH3ALJHN HapONHOÌ BNACrH B NepHog CraHoBeHna CPB //ÍocynapcTrso 1990-M2;, HryeH Ban Txao xYnpAB1CHH€ ÕUICCTBOM HOCP€CTBOM HODM HDAB4 H ()ODMHDOBAHM€ HpABOBOTO rOCynapCTba /KOMMYHHCT Ì99]-M3, HryeH Hrok KyaHr KOMMYHHCTHM€CKA4 IâpDTH4, FOCYAPCTBO H IDOUICCC 3KOHOMH1CCKOTO pâ3BHTHA //KOMMYHMCT 1991-36, HryeH Bak Txo [ÏDHHHHI R€MOKDATH3MA B ODFAHH34L#H H AexTeAbHOCTH TOCy/ADCTB€HHOTO ammapaTa // KOMMYHMCT.
1991-48; Hoan Your lyeH O rIaBHEIX B3FJ1I1AX H HARDABICHHIX COBCDLICHCTBOBAHHS TOCYJ/DCTB€HHOFO annapara //KOMMyHUCT 1991-Nt8;
3 Cụ Hryen 3yit Kyu O Co3aHHH nđpasoBoro rOCyApCTBA 8 Haiueli crpane //Kommynucr 1992-Ne4; Jun Ban May
COb€DUICHGTBOBAHH€ ODTAHH38HMH H DeaTeNbHOCTH MpaBurenscrea CPB (c yuerom 3apyGexaioro orikrra) -M.,1992,
3bioHT /[bIK 3yHr PA3TDAHHMCHH€ KOMIICTCHUMH B CHCTEM€ ODFaHOB HApOofO copera CPB
-M.,1992; Hayyenne xouIHMHHCKHX HI€Đ O rOCYHApCTB€ H npasc CỐopHHK Crareli -XaHol.:H3n-so Mninocr, 1993,HryeH Ban Tait [laprn4 w rOCYHAPCTBO: OMIT B3aHMOACHCTBHA B /I€MOKDATHM€CKOM OOHOBJICHHH BE€THAMCKOTO
o6mecrpa -M.,1993; Xoanr TxH HraH 3aHMOOTHOIICHHS mMexay HauHOHanbHbi CoốpaHHEeM CPB H ero [locrosnHu Komurerom no KoHcrnrytn 1992 r //Bectuux MIY, cepHx Ilpaso, 1993-M3; O pedbopme IOCTHUHHH.
CốopH -Xanoli.:m3n-po Muuroct,1993; Hryed Ban Hwen ®opMHpOBAHH€ npapoBorO rocynapcrpa BO b€THAMC(aonpocb: TeopHH H npakrmka) -M.,1993,; me Jit Txao TIpasosoe OỐCCH€4€HH€ mpouecca H€MOKDATH33LHHoỐuterea (na onerre CPB) -M.,1993; O Mmecrnol pnacrH: CỐOPH Xanoằ.:H4rpo MniiocT,1294, OỐnoBnciieOp(T\HMHMILHH Ho A€4TCIbHOCTH rOCyn0pCTneuHoro annapata cornacno Koucrrrytuw 1992r CốopH -Xanoil.:Tocnomr,]994; [ocynapcrso uw npaso CưopH -Xanol:FocnoanT,1224 Hryen Teen Jlour, AKIEI RABHTCRbCTBA,MMHWCTCPCTB H ð€noMcrs CPB -M,l994, Jie Ban Kam [poÕJICMIM OƠHOBnCliiu 3IKOIHO/1CCTBA Al
Trang 6Db€THAMCKOIO IDABA, IABOBOÌÍ IpakTrnke po DbernaMe' OnHaKO 37H paGorni
KACAJHCb JIHHIb OTH€JIBHBIX KOMNOHEHTOB IDABOBOÌ CHCT€MDI, OT/I€TIEHbIX Ccbep IIDABOBOTO D€TYJIHDOBAIIH NONHTHUeECKOH 2KH3HH,
OGbiuno npaso CPB uccnenyerca B CBA3H € HO/JIHTH1€CKHMH TI€DGMGHAMH,
IPOHCXO/JJHIHHMH B CTDpAH€C 2370 OƠYCIOBI€HO COHHAIbHO 0ỐtHtIOCTbIO
IOIHTHH€CKHX H IDABOBBIX ABJICHHH H OOJbUIMM BIIMAHHEM, KOTODO€ OKA3bIBATH IIOJIHTHW€CKH€ H3MCH€HH1 Ha pa3BHTHe Bb€THAMCKOTO HpABA Kpome toro, 2TO
OỐYyCJIOBJIHBAGICA H TCM, TO BO BbeTHaMCKOM O6ulecTBe /HOIrOS ppema
CYIH€CTBOBAJ18 HCA IDHODHT€TA NOAMTHKH I€D€J IDABOM.
3a nocneance Bpema B CPB IDHHAT pasa BA2KHbIX HONHTHKHX JOKYMILTOB,
IABOBBX aXTOB, KACAIOLHIHCCI aibiewero HDOB€H€HHS KDYHH€ÍHHIHX
IID€OỐPA3OBAHHÍ B HOJIHTHH€CKO 2KH3HH OỐIHecTBA Bce 2TO HYX/A€TCE B
HOIO/IHHT€JIbHOM aHaJIH3e, F1ỲOKOM H BC€CTOD€HHOM T€OD€TH€CKOM OCMbICJI€HHH
NPOHCXOAAWIHX B CTDAH€ /IHHAMHHHO, HHOTJ3 HDOTHBOD€MHBBIX HDOIECCOB, Hx
CYUIHOCTH, COJ/I€D3K3HHS H T€IJI€HLIHH DA3BWTH1.
B IpeniaraeMOlÍ pabote [/IABHO€ BHMAHH€ YJ€JIIGTCI T€ODGTHIECKHM H
IIDAKTHH€CKHM BOIIDOCAM IIDABORBIX 4CIIGKTOB IIOJINHTHW€CKOTO OỐHOBJI€HHA1 B CPB, NOW KOTODBIMH IOHHMA€TCđ DOJIb IIDAB, ID€J/I€ BC€TO DA3BHTH€ 3AaKOHO/JIAT€2ISCTBA
H TIDABOBO€ obecneuenne HOJIHTH1GCKOFO OOHOBNeHHA BO Äb€THAaMG,
OCHOBHDIM H€JIMCTOM HCCIGJOBAHHI ABNHIOTCH pasBHTHe HỘ OIP
BbD€THAMCKOLO IID4BA B O3HBICHHH NOUHTHYeECKOH KH3HH CPB B nepHon mocne IDOBO3IJIAII€HHS Kypca BC€CTODOHIETO OONOBNEHHA Bb@THAMCKOTO OỐIHIGCIBA HO HacToAulee BpemA (7.e nepBaw IHOnoBHHa 90-x TT.), IOCKOJIbKY Bb€TIHAMCKA1
NpaBOBaA CHCT€Ma mpnHobpena HOBbIe BA3XKHBIE HN€DTEIE HM€HHO B 2TOT IIEDHOI C
COBCPIHICIICTBOBAHHS TOCV/DCTRCIHOTO annapara BO Bsername //Toc H npano -M.,1996-R4; Uan Xay Txanp.
OCHOBitbi€ HDOỐJI€MbI CTAHODJIGHHS đpa5OBOro rocysapersa -M.,1996.
5 [lpoØncMa COBDCMCHHOTO BECTHAMCKOTO HABA HCCHGHOBAIACb B IODHUIPICCKO" H HONHTHICCKỌ COBGTCKỌ
antepitype cme c Kona 50-x ronos B Tpynax H7 Ka3antcnol, A.T.Bynanona, H.C Mepanakona, A.I.Maaaecba,
J].A.Tapacknnol, HIIHnbnnckoro, B.BIIcrunnurna, JILM.Ionoinnwkona, B.E.lipknua, A.C.Bopounna, H.A.Ornerona Bo nropoii 1onosniie 80-x H n 90-€ rr, AKTyA/IbiIbiC IDOỐTCMEI NOANTHEM H pana COHHATHCTHIICCKRX
CTPAH, B TOM HHCIG H CPB, UCCn€HOBAHbI 8 Tpyzax npe»k/te nccro B.E.WJnpknna, H.TIHnbrrrckoro, ].A.KepnMona,
[..Maricpa, C.A Mxnrapara, TT Mxnrapzna, M.ILWcaena, JLM.Tononnnkona, B.A.Crpamyna " paÕOTax
Trang 7HHHSTH€M HOBOH, deTBepTO Ho cuery KoncrnrynunH CPB B 1992 rony
OCOO€HHOCTbIO BbeTHAMCKOH TOCY/HADCTB€HHOCTH 3BJ11GI1G1 7 DYKOBO/HH POIbKoMMYHHCrH1eckKofli Ilaprun BberHaMa PacKpbITH€ TÊMPI H€BO3MO2KHO Õ€3 aHanH3anowHTHKH KIB, kKoropaa HAaD8HY C COLHAJ1bHbIM, KYJIbTYPHbIM IIDOH€CCAMH ABIIACTCHO/IHHM H3 aKTODOB (POPMHPOBaHHA BbeTHAMCKOPO IIDABA
I{pu w#CCJ€NOBAHHH Bb€THAaMCKOFO IHDABA Mbl HCXOIHM H3 H€OỐXOHHMOCTHOỐII€T€OD€GTHH€CKOFO IIOnXOHA STO OỐ5ICH2ICTCð TEM, HTO y H€FO OH€HB CJ1O2KHBI
IIYTE Pa3BHTHA, OCHOBHbIe ODHM€HTHDBHI KOTODPOFO €IH€ OKOHHAT€GJIEHO He
OID€I€JIHJHCb., Tako HOJIXON HO3BOJIIGT NOKa3aTb KaK OỐHIH€ H€TBI HDABOBEIXHBIICHHH, Tak HW HA€T BO3MOXHOCTb XâDAKF€DH3OBATb OTAEJIbHbIC fIPpaBOBbIe
HHCTHTYTbI H TCM CaMbIM PaCKPbITb DO(Ib NpaBa B HOJHTHYeCKOH pedopme B CPB
Apyrux yH(€Hbax Hacrisryra rocygapcrsa H npasa PAH, Hucrutyta socroxoseyennx PAH, a TawKe WincruTnyra
MCHAY HAX0/0LHX 3KOHOMHMCCKHX H DOJIHTHHCCKHX HCCIG/AAObannlf PALL.
Trang 8TJIABA I COI{H1AJIbHO-2KOHOMMHECKHE TIPEJIIOCbUJIKH
HO/IH-THYECKOrO ObBHOBJIEHHA B COIIHAJWHCTHUECKOH
PECHYBIHKE BbETHAM
Cpegu MHOTHX TeOpeTHYeCKHX H IDAKTHU€CKHMX BOIIDOCOB, OỐCYV3XABIIHXCSkak Ha VI ( neKaØps 1986r.), tak m ma VIL (mons l29]r.) c5e3xax KIHB,
ICHTDAJISHO€ M€CTO 38HHMAIOT mpo6Onembl HO/IHTMU€CKOTO OƠHOBJI€HHA Mono
CKka3aTb, HTO 2TO HE BJII€TCH MH€M-TO HOBBIM B HOJIHTHH€CKỌH ⁄413HH
COUHMAIMCTHYCCKHX CTDAH, IIOCKOJIbKY BOIOCbl COB€DIHICHCTBOBAHH1 NOMHTHYCCKOH
CHCT€GMBI H AKTHBI3ALHM CS 1€4T1€JIbHOCTH CO/I€P2KJ7IHCb H DAHBbII€ B IOKYM€HTAX
KOMMYHHCTHYECKHX NapTHi COHHIHCTHU€CKHX CTDAH, B TOM HHCJIE CCCP u KHP
Bo BberHaMe€ Oonbwoe 3HA1€HHM€ /JAHHBIM BOIDOCAM CTaIM IDHABATb C MOM€HTA
NPHHATHA Mep, HAIDABJI€HHBIX Ha D€ODFAHH34IHKEG IKOHOMHYECKOM CHCTeMbI H CTDYKTYJbI yipaBsICHHA GIO.
[(DNMHHBI Tako HOCTAHODKH BOIDOCA HMGIOT 38KOHOM€PHHI XâapaTep H
B3aHMOOTHOCATCH pyr € /DVTOM Ha nau B3121871, MO)KHO TICDCWHCJIHTb CJ1G/1V/1OIIH€
OCHOBHBIC BH€IHIHH H BHYTD€HIHTHC IIDHHHHEI.
Ilo T€OD€IHUCCKOÍI cxeme IID€JHHOJIATAIOCb, WTO B COHHA3HHCTH1€CKỌ
D€BOJHIOIIHH TPH DA3DYUIEIHH craporo OƠII€CTBA B OCOỐBHIlÍi I€p€XOHNHHIÏ nepnonD€ODMBI CONPOKOKNAOTeT CƠ3H/14HHÈM, KOTODO€ JOIOKHO BBICTYTIHT Ha nepppris
WiaH, CTaTb r71ABHOf HeJIbIO H 3anauel B 23KOHOMHK©, IIAJI3-KHBAHHCM HOBBIX
COHHAJISHO-HOIMTHI€CKHX OTHOUHICHHÍH, (ÙÌyHKHHOHHDOBAHHCM ITOCYJACTB3 ! ACMOKpaTHH HOPGrO Tuna Ha camom gene 1IpaKrHKa CCCP c 20-x ro/IOB noxa3ana,
HTO COHHAJIHCTHH€CKANH HIGS He IIOJIYHHJIA AHC€KBATHOTO H€MOKDATHH2CKOTO
BOIIOHIHHI ỦÍ1O Kacaerca CO3MNAHHi B 3KOHOMHM€CKOIW" C{€p?, TOHADOHHOXO3ãfCTBeHHa1 npakrnka CCCP ps 60-80 rr o6pexna ceỐq Ha 3acTOii Btevenne jecaTHieTHH B 80-e roan uonuTHueckaa cucrema CCCP, KOTopyIO 1O
2IOFO BDÊMEHH HỆ pas HBITAIHCB UpeoOpasonaTh B pamMkax COXpalsArUlelics
KƠMØAHJHHO-71M HHHGTDTHBHOI1 CHCTCM bl, BHOBb OKABANLAChL H€CIIOCOƠOHOIÍ
Trang 9IID/IOXDAHITb OỐIH€CTBO OT HADACTAIOHIELTO 3acTOA B COLJIA/IbHO-2KOHOMHH€CKOIi13HH B 3rnx ycoBwax B 1985 rony CCCP nposo3rnacun ”Ílepecrpolxy” Ha XIXBcecolo3Ho: KoHepennun KIICC Ona mpuuara pesomouns ”O ÊMOKDATH3A10HCOB€TCKOTO OỐIH€CTBa H pedbopMe NonHTHYeECKON CHCTGMEI”.
B To xe BpeMa B cTpaHax BocrouHoli EBpoHbi IpOHCXO/IT CJ1OXHHI€[IDOH€CCBI, OỐIHHM MpH3HaKOM KOTOPHIX CTAIO “KkpaiiHee H€JOBOIBCTBO Macc,
”KPH3HC HH30B” HIDH ABHOM H€CIOCOỐHOCTH ỐbIBIIHX “B€DXOB” K YHDABJI€HHIO HOBOMY, HX HIDHB€P2K€HHOCTb K CTapbIM KOMAHHHO-AHMHHHCTDATHBHBIM M€TOHAM
HO-ocylllecTBNenHsa BJIACTH”Ơ đ TDeỐOBaHHe D€IHIHT€JIbIHbIX I€D€MCH B OỐIHI€CTBe.
| OnHHM H3 BA3KHbIX BH€UHIHMX (ÙâKTODOB I1OJIMTHI€CKOFrO OỐHOBJIeHHä B CPB
4BJ/JIC1 H HOJIHTHHI€CKHÍ OnbirT KHP, B K TOpỌ akryaibHO CTOMI BOIpOC O
peopmMe noJ1IHrHdeCKO cwcTeMbi Ha XIII cSbpeane KIIK (oxra6pp 1987¡.) Onin
BbIABHHYT TÊ3HC O HeOOXOAMMOCTH /JÊMOKDATH3AHHH OỐII€CTB€HHOTO CTpO4, NPCOAONCHHA ƠIODOKPATHH H Oe33aKOHHA, JIIKBHJAHHH (Ù€OAJIEHBIX T€D€SKHTKOP,
OTKA3€ OT TpâHHIMOHHOFO HO2KH3HÊHHOFO H€ỐbBIB4HMS Ha DYKOBOJIIIHX HOCTâX,
BbIABHOKCHHE TaJIAHTJINHBBIX MOJIOJBIX JION€,
Hapany ¢ 3THM HY%KHO y4HTbIBaTb 3apoxnapuieeca B 80-e rr B
MOXAYHAPOAHBIX OTHOWICHHAX HOBO€ HOJIHTHH4€CKO€C MBILWIeEHHe, KOTOpOE BBIPAKACTCH B OTKA3€ OT KOHQDOHTAHMH H /I€HH€OIOTH3A4HIHH M€3KHYHADOHHEIX
OTHOHIHH H HDH3HAHHH OỐI€q€/iOB€d€cKHX H€HHOCTẹiS BM€CT€ c Tem
MOABJIAIOTCA HOBHC B3IJ1HBI Ha COHHAIH3M Kak OỐII€CTB€HHH crpoi H Ha MAPKCH3M KaK Hay4HylO T€ODHIO HMeHHO IIOIHTHH€CKO€ MEIHUI€HH€ IpHB@JIO K
paspaOorke B CPB kypca pa3BHTHA CTDAHEI B HOBBIX YCJIOBHAX C COOTB€TCTBY!OLIIHMHBHYTpeNHeH H BHeWIHeH nmomuTHKOH, HỐo ỐbinO nonaTHo, ITO 6e3 OỐHOBJIEHHä
HIOHHTHH€CKOTO MBILUICHHA H€BO3MO?KHO OỐHOB/ICHH€ B /IDYTHX OỐJ1ACTäX.
B 80-e rr, B cTpaH€ CTẠNH HO-HOBOMY ID€HCTAB/IATb I€P€XOHHHI 9Tan
COUHaIH3Ma, 4TO CHOCOỐCTBOBAnO pA3pa6orKe KOHHCHHHH pa3BHTHA OỐII@CTBA
* Muronarscs A.A, ANETCDHATHBHI B€KA: ro Bnepeau ? -M.:Jlyw,1992 -C.44-45,
* BexTHatizpoRa H.H., Hontunxosa B.A., Hosaxona O.B [lonrrwKa OỐHOB/ICHIU B Crpanax WinnokHras: Beernam,
Jlaoc, Kax6osa //Becruux Moc Vn-ra, Cepus 13, Bocrokopeaenne 1992 -N¿2 - C.47-48,
Trang 10HCXOAA H3 KOHKDCTHDIX HCTODHU€CKO-HALHOHAJIbHbIX y€nopHii lo po3elicTPneM
IDHM€P3 HOBEBIX HHAYCTPHaAJIbHbIX CTpan B a3HaTCKO-THXOOaAKEAHCKOM PeErHOHe BO
Bb€THAMCKOM OỐIHI€CTB€ YKD€TILIIIOTCI ““HALHOHAIbHO€ CAMOCO3HAHH€ H 3BOTIOUWHS
B3I7111QB Ha IIYTH HalMOHAIbHOrO pasBHTHa”’ `
CpenH BHYTpEHHHX (ÙaKTODOB IOIHTHu€CKOTO OỐHOBIe€HH1 BO berHaMe
DA2KHO HM€Tb B BHHÿ 3acrof CHOKUBLUCHCA NOJHTHYCCKOH CTDYKTYDHI PyKOBO/ICTBO
CPB B TeyeHHe !II€CKO/IbKHX JI€CITHJIETHÌ HDHI€PKHBAIOCb OỐIi@Ïi KOHHelitinn
COHHJIbHO-2KOHOMHU€CKOFIO H HOJIHTIHH€CKOFTO DA3BHTHI PB OCHOBHOM
34HMCTBOBAHHOH H3 T€ODHH H NpakTHKH COIHAJMCTHM€CKOFO CTDOHT€GIbCTBA B
CCCP, KHP mm npyrHx ỐbIBIHHX COHMAIHCTHu€CKHX crpan MeTOHOM 2TOrO
CTPOHTCJIBCTBa cra7a J.HD€KTHBHO-3IMHHHCTDATHBHA1 CHCT©MA YHDABJIEHHä
9KOHOMHKOH H OOULECTBOM He C MOMOLIbIO 3aKOHa, a FIABHBIM O6pa30M Ha OCHOBG
BBINOJHCHHS MaPTHHUbIX AHPCKTHB H PrOcyLapCTBeCHHBIX HOCTAHOPJIEHH Co3annan
B pesybtaTe AprycroscKoi peBonounn B 1945 roma, nosyunBuian cBoe pa3BHTHe B
OCHOBHOM B TepHOA BOHH COHDOTHBICHIH1 H OCBOƠO3X/IeHHS “CJIO?KHBHIA3ICS
NOJHTHeCKad CHCTeEMa OONaaia MHOPOUMCJCHHLIMH HGOCTATKAMH”Ề H OKa3anach
H€CIOCOƠHOÍÍ IID€/IOXPAHWTE OỐII€GTBO OT DOCTA 3aCTOHHBIX H KDI3HCHbIX #1BJI€HHÌI B
pA3HBIX C{€paX OỐII€CTB€HHOÍ 33HH Kak HpOHYKT ID€XHHX WCTOPIIECKHXYCJIOBHH B TeYCHHE MHOTHX s1eT He NONBEPpraBulaAHCA CYLIeCCTBEHHbIM nepeMeHiam,
CNOKABIUAACA MONHTHYeCKaA CHCT€MA yxKe He OTB€UAIA HOBDIM TD€ỐOBAHHSM
CTPOHTEbCTBA 2KOHOMHKH, KYJIBTYpbI W Apyrux OỐJ1acT€li CTAHOBHJIOCb BCe scnee, WTO H€BO3MO3KHO OCYUI€CTBJIITb OƠHOBJIGHH€ B COLHJ1bHO-2KOHOMH9eCKỌi cj€pe,
€30IIACHOCTH H OỐODOH€, ecu He OỐHOBHTE TIOIHTH4€CKY1O CHCTeMY.”
[.1 B3aHMOCBw3b H B3anMogelicrBHe 2KOHOMHd€CKOÌi pe0pMPI H
II0/IHTHH€CKOTO0 OỐH0B.:ÊHHH.
"Taat xe -C.48
*Jlo Munoilt, BerymirresibHoe C10B0 na 2-oM nuienyMe IU KTIB (7-ro co3erpa, 1991, 29 noxØpn)
//KoMMyimtcr -Xanoii,1989 -Ne].- C.10.
* Peiieirne 5-ro nnenyMa LU KIB (6-ro co3brpa, moun 1988 7) /Hmpyan: 26-7-1988,
Trang 11Anwin3upya ocobeHHOCTH HonHTHYecKOrO OOHOBIEHHA B CPB, HeBO3MOxHO
pacCMaTpHEATb HX B OTPbIBE OT IOBO/IHMỌÍ B CTpaHe 3KOHOMH€CKOÍÍ D€ODMHI.
TpajHUHOHHat MOJI€JIb 3KOHOMMd€CKO cwcreMbI CPB (ToqHee CepepHoro BbermawAa) no 1979r., KoTOpad YHPABI1IACb KOMAHHHO-AaIMHHHCTDATMBHBIMH
M€TO/IAMH H OPH KOTOPOM HTHODHDOBAJIOCb 3/I€KBATHO€ MAT€DHAJIbHO€ IOOIHD€HH€
TDYHSUHIWXC3, CO BD€M€H€M OKa3aNacb H€2Q(ЀKTHBHO, noTpeboBana TđyÕ0KO
pcOpraHH3auiun ÏljIapHBI (ÙâKTODBI TAKỌ 3KOHOMHYNECKOH CHCT€MBIL
-YPABHHT€JIEHO-H7IAHOBBIC HAHaJIA H IIDHHYHNHFỂHIBHBIC MCpONPHATHA - B KOHH©
KOHIIOB FIDIB€JIH K CHH2K€HHIO 3(0|€@KTHBHOCTH TDY/A, 3HAaYHTebHOA
COHHA/IEHO-3KOHOMHH€CKOÌÍ = HafipsaKeHHOCTH, BCe OH€BHIH€C IIDOSBIIBIIắCS Ha 2Tane
CTDOHT€JIbCTBA 3KOHOMMKH B CTDAH€ B HOCJI€BOEeHHbIie FO/Ib1 (c 1975 roRa)
SKOHOMHYCCKHH KDH3HG, KOTODOMY IIO/IB€DTJIACb CTpAHA B KOHWEe 70-x rOOB,
CKa3bIBaICA ID€3/JI© BC€FO B TOM, YTO 3KOHOMHH€CKH€ ODFAHH32LHHH BC€ ỐO/JIbLH€
[D€ƠOBAIMH, MTOỐbI FOCYHADCTBGIHA4S HOJIHIHKA OTB€UAJIA HX HHTepecam,CIOCOỐGTBOBAIA DACHHDHHO HX XO3Z2-ÍCTB€HHOI CâAMOCTOAäT€JIEHOCTH,ODH€HTHPOEAHHO Ha DBIHOHHBI€ OTHOWeHHA B MacliraÕ€ BC€l CTPAHbICÊJIbCKOXO3-CTB€HHbI€ KOOIICDATHBEI HOILUIH Ha ỸbUIb, M€CTAMH CTàJH HDHM€HSTbOPMBIL HOIDSHNHBIX H AD€H/HBIX OTHOHIEHH; TOCY/ADCTB€HHBIE NpeANpHATHA,IIbITAäCb HèK@ATb DA3JIHHHBIC HCTOdHHKH HOCTABKH, (ÙAKTHH€CKH BBIXONHIH H3
PaMOK, YCTAHOBJICHHbIX FOCYADCTBOM.
Ha gene nepBbl© 2KOHOMHH€CKH€ HỊD€OỐDA3OBAHHM4 HA4A/HCb B ATDADHOM
cekrope, HTDAIOIHICM D€LIAIOIHIYIO POb B HapOAHOM XO3afcrpe CPB (B C€bCKOM xo3aiictpe 3aHaTO go 80% WHCI€HHOCTH HaceleHHx cTPpAaHB) lH(äpoKoe
Dacipocrpanewne M€TOJIOB IDOH3BOCTB€HHỌ CAaMOOTOST€JIbHOCTH KPeCTbAHCKHX
ABOPOB H OCYHI€CTBJI€HH€ DA3/NHHBIX MOAPAAHbIX H AD€HHbIX (OPM B C€/IbCKOM XO34lCTB€ cTann MpHMenaTsca nocle 6-ro nieHyMa IK KHIB (4-oro copia, 1979r.)w nnpekrwpei Ne100 cexperapuara [TK KIIB, cyrbio KOTODpO, NO MH€HHIO MHOPHX Bb©€THAMCKMX 3KCH€DTOB, ABJIAJIOCb OốỐOỐMIeHI€ Onbira H€CKO/IbSKHX
Trang 12CCBCPIHBIX HOBHHIHHE B D€A/113ALI1H MCTO/IOB, AH1371OTHMHBIX TEM, WTO IPOBO/UIU1OCE,
BCTpaHe eile B kone 70-x rOHNOB.
K 93TOMy BD€MeHH €3KOC COKDAIIHH€ 3KOHOMHdeCKỌ noMOUlm
COIIHA3JIHCTHH€CKHX CTDAH, B OCHOBHOM CCCP, u M€XJIYHADOHNHBIX KD@JIHTOB HaJIBTOTHBIX YCJIOBH4IX 3ACTABHIIO HDOMBIHIJIIHbLI€ TIPCANPHATHA HHT€HCHBHO HCKATb HHCIIOJ1B3OBATb, KPOMe rogyAapCTBeHHbIXx NOCTaBOK, MHOIHO7IHHT€JIbBHbIG HCTOWHHEH,
nockompKy 3TH IIOCTABKH He NO3BOJIASIH HM MOJTHOCTBIO HDHMCHATL HMGIOIIH€CS
MOIHHOCTH Ta T€IIJI€HIIHS IO33€ oPaunanbuo 6puia đDH3Hana B pewienun No25
6-ro mienyma LK KIIB (4-6-ro CO3bIB3) H Nonyynsa yansueiuee OTpaxKenne BAupeKTuBe No306 Ilonwr6iopo LIK KIIB (mait 1986r.), nateneimol na o6ecneuerne
MIPOH3BOACTBEHHOH CamoctTosTenbHocTH HH30B, HO CYHICCTBY Ha OTKa3 oTYP4BHHT€7IbHO-H/IAHOBOTo pacnpe/tenenna.
DH€pPBI€ pa3pepnyTas w OTKPBITAT KPHTHKA COHHAJISHO-3KOHOMH1€KOFO
NONOKEHHA UPO3ByYasia BO Bpetuame na VI cbe3e KTIB (xekaốp 1986r.), rie Gain
oduunanbio o6bannen KYPC Ha OỐHOBJI€HH€ Bb€THAMCKOFO OGmeCTRA "ở OTM€GW€II
NepesIOM B 2KOIOMHUH€CKỌ HOJldrnke Crpaibl lla cbe3/te IIO7I€DICHR4/1G1
D€LIMTCJIbHbHÍE OTKA3 Or IODOKPATH1€CKOli KOMAIUIIO-AJIMHIIICTDaTH3I10lÍ
CTPYKTYpbl YIIDABJI€HHH, YVKfl3bIBAIOCb Ha “H€OƠXOJHMOCTE OỐHOBHTb M€XAIIH3M
YHAB/I€HH1”, “DeODITAHH3onaTb IIDOH380/ICTBO”, 10
B konue 80-x rr no Bhetname yoke HAM€THJIHCB CyUeCcTBeHTIBIe H€D€MEIIbI B
3KOHOMHW€CKOÍ OƠ/acTH: mepexon LOCYAPCTBCHHBX HW KOOI€paTnPiblxIP€HHHITHÍ Ha xo3pacuer, HOCHGAOBAT€IEHO€ COỐHON€HH€ HDHHLUHIA
3aHHTeEpeCOBaHHOCTH TDY/IOPbiBX KOJIICKTHBOB B DC3ÿVJIBTATAaX cpBoeii PaÕCThI,
HCROCTABJI€HHS NpaBa IDOBHIHIIHIM, a 3aTeM m OTDPäC/IIM BECTH CAMOCTOST€/IbIbI€
3KCIHIOTHO-HMIODTHI€ C7IGIKH, pa3BUTHe [IO/DZHBIX MeTOJOB B OƠIIHHX HHOOIHID€HHG CBOOONHỌI peanHsantun
CB€PXIJIAHOBOÍÍ Ce7IbCKO-Xo3#licTBeHnol NPOAYKLUAH, BB€/€HH€ CHCTeMBI YHPAJICHHH B TOCYHADCTBEHHBIX HDOMBIHIJIEIHIEIXNPeAN PHATHSX, NpeAnosaraouteit cpoðopnnoe HCHONb30BANHE — pIieriaitotoli
"VI cue+n ]
Trang 13IIDHỐBIIH, HOJIYdA€MOÍ Ha OCHOBE CaMOCTOATCIDHO H3bICKAHHbIX CbIPbA H MATCDHAJIOB, DTH T€CD€M€HBI ABHJIHCh Pe3yJIbTATOM aHasH3a DÊAJ1bHOFO HOJO)K€HHA
H OOHOBJCHHA 3KOHOMHH€CKOTO MBIIUI€HHS, WTO BesIO K OTXOAY OT TPANHIHHOHHOÍ MOJGnH Xo3#crpoBaHwa Mexny npoqnM, nepuog c 1979r no 1989r canranca
nepexOHbIM ia HOB€H€HHW /IAHHO p€(ÙODMHI P€eaIbHO€ HO/IOK€HH€ BO
BbeTHAM€ Tp€ỐOBAJIO OGecneueHHA CAaMOCTOATEIBHOCTH TDYHOBBIX KOJLIÊKTHBOB, BOCCTAHOBICHHA /HHCHHIUIHHbBIL B XO3AHCTBEHHOM /H€WST€/IbHOCTH, HOOIHP€HHSPpa3sBHTHA H HDYLHX H€COLtHA3JINCTHH€CKHX SKOHOMHYCCKHX yKJIAHOB, YJIYHHICHHSđDABOBOFO p€FY/IHDOBAHH% XO3/4ÏCTB€HHỌI AeaTembHOCTH, ”OCOỐOFO BHHMAHHS K NPOM@KYTOMHbIM XO3-CTB€HHBIM (ÙODMAM, K HOCTEI€HHOMY II€P€XONY OT HH3ULIHX
crynevef K BbICIUHM, OT M€JIKHX MãäCLITAaỐOB K KpynHbIM.”""
[lo Mepe yray6neHHa HpOBO/IHMOTO B CTDAH€ OỐHOBJI€HHZ YCJIO2KHSIJIHCb H PacIUNPWIHCh 34Qa4H 9KOHOMHYECKON D€QODMHI: ona ỐbUIâ IDH3BAHA OCYHI€CTBHTb
D€ODTAHWM3AHHIO BCeH 3KOHOMHU€CKOÍ CHCT€MBI H CTAHOBJICHHE “TOBapHoð2KOHOMHKH © JDA3IHHHbBIMH 23KOHOMHH€CKHMH VKIAHAMH B COOTBETCTBHH C
DbIHOHHBIMH M€XâHH3MAMH HDH TOCYHADCTB€HHOM YIDABJICHHH, ODH€HTHDYACb Ha
COHHAIH3M”!?: orka3 oT ỐIODOKPATHH€CKOTO H€HTPAH3MA, 1MHHHCTDATHBHBIX M€TOJOB, OT TPAHHHHOHHOFO HDOTHBOIOCTABI€HH3 TUIAHOBOÍ H TOBApHO 3KOHOMHKH H CO3HAHHỀ€ HOBỌ CTDYKIYDB YHDABIHH1I 23KOHOMHKOH,
COOTB€TCTBVIOHÌ OỐb€KTHBHBIM 3âKOHAM H YDOBHIO pa3BHTHA 9KOHOMHKH; >
OỐIHY1O ODH€HTAHHIO FOCYNADCTB€HHOTO yMpaBNeHHA HAapOAHBIM XO3AHCTBOM Ha
Mepexoq OT ympaBieHHa Ha OCHOBe NaprHivblx AMpeKTHB H HD€3BbIHAHO
HÈTAIIH3HDOBAHHHIX IUIAHOBBIX HOKA3AT€/I€l, CIlyCKaeMbIX CBepXxy, K YIIDABJICHHIO “B COOTBeTCTBHH € 3aKOHaMH” 4 :
!Ì VỊ cea KIB.- Tan: oe -C.44
'!KoHcruryuuw CPB 1992 Ha peetu a3 -Cr.15.
Vi cusag KTIB Tam xe -C.49
!* Cu Koncrurynmo CPB 1992 Ha spern #3 -CT.26.
Trang 14CnenyetT OTMETHTb BC/YHHYIO Poh TOCY/DCTBGHHDIXO HỌGJIHSTHÌ BbDBIHIOHHỌÍ IKOHOMHKC, YTO HANOMHHAeT O “TWIANOBO-TOBApHOH 3KonoMnke” KHP.'>Mexkay IpOWHM BO BbCTHAMCKOH HayuHO IHT€DATYD€ BEICKa3bIBAaIOTCA D43-1H11HbI€
MHCHCHHA O pOIH HI€HHDHSTHÍ FOCyADGTBEHIOTO cekTopa Mot n07/1€D2£HBAEM
KOIHICHHHIO “B€HNYIOLHẸ pon” TOCYJIADCTB€HHOFO IIDGHIHDHHHMATGIbCTBA B5
HBIHCHIHHX YCIOBHSX B TOM CMBICHI, HTO OHO ABIIAETCA DBIHATOM YCKOD€HHI
3KOHOMHW€CKOTO POCTa H DCLICHHI COHHAJIEHbIX HDOỐ/I€M, MAT€DHAJIbHOÌ CHIO!T, Cc IIOMOIHbIO KOTODOIÍ TOCVAPCTBO OCYII€CTBJII€T D€TYJIHDOBAHH€ H Makpoynpansienne SKOHOMHKOH CTDAHbIL CTDHHAW B€JIYLHY'O pOJb TOCY/ADCTBCHHBIX HD€JUIDHSTHÌI,
H€KOTODBI€ ABTOPhI H€IOOH€HHBAIOT 3I134€HH€ TOCYy/IADCTB€HHOTO D€TY/IHDOBAHI B
vy
82 * 16
HIHONHOH SKONOMHKE C COLUM AIIHCTHYUCHCKOH ODHCHTAILH€H BO beTHawe `
[ÍOKA3aT€/€I ror (baKT, HIO, B OTIH-H€ OT TD€JbL/UyLteli KQHCTHMTVHHH
J980r (cTr.2), B nelfcrnyiomeli Konernryunn CPB ner aKlenra na OTCVTCTBH€
2CH/IYATAHHH !'1€IOB€KA H€IOB€KOM KaK CYHUIIOCTHOÍ YepTe COIIH3/IHCTH+€CKOTO
CIDOA ITO CTAJO €3V/IBTATOM HOIHIHMAHHI TOrO, HTO JIA DA3BHTHA TOBADHoif
3KOHOMHKH HY)KHO HCHOJiB3OBATb HIOT€HIIHA)1 BCEX 3KOHIOMHICCKHX YKJIATOB, B TOM
HHCJIC HACTHO-KAIHTA/IICTHN€CKOTO HH TOCY/JA4DCTB€HHO-KAIINHTAJIHCTHH€CKOFO, TO
baKTH4€CKH BG/ICT K 2CTIJIVTIIHH tI€7IOB€KA ICJIOBEKOM
B Od}HUHAIIbHOÍÍ JIHT€ATYDG BBICKA35IBA€TCH B3IJH/U, B COOTBETCtRHH Cc
KOTOPbIM IIDOBOJIHMAIH 3KOHOMHUCCKad pedopMa, ODHCHTHDVSCb Ha DIHOSHO€
PCryJIHpOBaHHe, HOJD2KIA H30JCH5 BCe CTIO HO/IOJCHT€JIbIbI€ KqH€CIBA1 = LUI
'SQcoGo 3awerHo CxO/ICTBO Mexuny Koncriny1uteii CPB (penakuws 1992 1.) 4 Koncrrryume KHP (penakunx 1993 T)
IIPHMCHIT€IEHO K 3KOHOMHICCKỌÍ CHCTCMC ¡/0 COLHAJTHCTHICCKOMY XâDAKT€DY IKONOMHKH, HOBBHUCHHIG IJ:1BOBOFO [KIYHHPOBAHH5 B 3KOHOMIKC, TAK3K€ DYKOBO/IIHCÏÍ Pom FOCY.HADCTB€HHOTO CeKTopa B HADORHOM XO3AaÌÍCTB€ (cM.
nonpo6uee KoHcrmrynnto CPB, 1992 - (cr.15, 19, 20, 21) n KoHcrmryruno KHP, 1993 - (cr.6, 7, 15) Kpome 2Toro,
JAKPCIMICHHE HA KOHCTHTYHHOHHOM YPOBHC POs HACTHOTO HDGHITHIHMATGJIBCTBA CCTb HOBOC B HPAKTHKC OƠCHX CTDAH, NPH3IBAHHbIX CTDOITTb COIHATH3M.
'* Townwo O(HHHAEHbIX HAPTHIBIX NOKYMCITTOP, HO/TICDKHYBIIHX HCOỐXOHHMOCTb “TDABIUJIEHO HCTOJT3OD/ITE BCC
}KOHOMHWHCCKH€ YKJ4/UbI, CPCAH KOTODBIN TOCYACTBCHHBI CCKTOP OMKeH COXDpAHATE B€IYHU!IO DOIb B HI4X PACKPEITHA BCCX BR3MOIIIOCTCÍÍ poCra npodn3po/tcrpa (VI cue3wx KIIB -TaM xe -C.122.) 97a notnura Spina 3axperuicna B Koncrnryruin CPB 19927 (Cr.19), a tawoKe Oputa NOANCpAKCHA B PAAe nayutiblx TDY/OB, Cm Besyity10 P0.1b FOCYAAPCTBCHHOFO NPCAUPHAMMATCIBCTBA B DPIHOHHỌ( 3KOHOMHK€ Xanoit: u3a-no Doc nour acanemun, 1994 -
36, MADKCH3M-JICHHHHM ít nyTb CTpPOHT€nbcrn1 no Boername Xanoii 1993 -C.54; JIipyroit B3f/U/L MbL Biya B
Monorpaint Dan Cyan Lona Cat ero ae: Beernan - HYTb i OOHOBICHHIO M :Coio3 1997, -C 140
Trang 15HOCIPOCHHA COIHAJIH3MA OTHIOAb He Wit Toro, uroObl CTDAHA HOHUIAY m0
KaNHT@IHCTHYeCKOMY HYTH B 3TOH CBA3H HaCTOAULyIO 9KOHOMHYCCKY!IO peOpMy BOBoetHame, Ha Nall B3TJ181, MO2KHO CpaBHHTb € nonuTuKoH HOTIa B.M JleHuna pnawane 20-x rooB B Poccnn B Ka4€CTB€ HDAKTHU€CKHX 3aa4 IKOHOMH4ECKOIIpetpOpMbI OID€J€JICHBIL HEOOXOMHMOCTb YCTpaHeHHa 3KOHOMHU€CKO OTCTAIOCTH,
YCKOP€HH€ POCTa NPOM3BOAHTEJIbHIX CHI, DaCIHID€HH€ TOBADHOFO HDOH3BOJTCTBA,
IIDOỐYyK€HHC 1€IOBO AKTHBHOCTH JHOHR€ÏÍ, HOBBIII€HHC 2KH3H€HHOTO YDOBHi
HAC€JICHHZA, YCHIIGCHHE BH€IIH€2KOHOMHuHECKOl H€ZIT€JIEHOCTH, TO €CTb 3aa4dn, CBASAHHbIC C Pa3BHTHEM 2KOHOMHKH H COIIWA7IbHBIM MpOrpeccomM.
Kak ỐbIlO cka3aHo Bbune, c 1979 r LIK KIIB nonyexan BBenenne dbopm
NOUPARHbIX, AЀHHHBIX OTHOIIHH C HỆ€JBIO HDHOCTAHOBHTb YVHAHOK CẴ€/IECKOTO
XO3HHCTBa [ÏpOMBHH/ICHHHI© 3aBOJIbI, OỐ/1anaa HPOH3BOACTBEHHOA
CaMOCTOATCIIBHOCTHIO, HOJLYUaIH W HEMIAHOBbIe IOCTABKH.
Takum o6pa3om, TEN MCHA Ne PpBOHAYAIBHLIX 3KOHOMH1I€CKHX
IIDÈOỐDA3OBAHHÌÍ IIOJIYMHJA 3âKD€IUI€HH€ B TOI/JAUIHHX IIiADTH¡bIX IOKYM€HTAX,
KOTODPHI HO CYTH HOCAT Xapakrep HODMAIHBHOFO perynHpOBaHHA H ABNAIOTCA
KOHKP€TH3AIH€, OỐOỐIHI€HH€M OHBITA H HHHHATHBDI XO3/IÍCTB€HHBIX “HH30B”, a Taloke D€ATHDOB8HH€M “B€DXOB” Ha TD€BO)KHO€ 110/102£©HH€ B 2KOHOMHK€ CTDAHBiI.
B 3T0 BpeMA BCe OqGBHHH€G IDOSBILHUIH ce6aA B rOINTHM€CKO 3XH3HH
KPH3HCHBIC ABJICHHA H COIHHA/bHA HANPwKEHHOCTb, KOTODBIC B MepByIO O4epedb
ỐbUIH HODO3K/JI€HD 2KOHOMHH€CKHMH = (pakTropaMH: craOM HDOH3BOHCTBA,CYII€DHH(}JI11H€ÏÍ, BBICOKHM YDOBIM Õ€3DAỐOTHIHBI, pA3ÐBIBOM B YDOBH€ OXOHOBD4371HNHBIX TDYHH Hacenenua }ÍO sToro BpeMcHH BO BbeTHaM€ MâIIO ỐBIIO Tex, KTOID€JICTABJ4JI ce6e D€AIBHYIO H€IO OOHOBNeHHA HOJIHTHUIE€CKO CTDYKTYDpHIoOmectBa HacTyHHJIO BD€MII, KOTJâ CâMO KPH3HCHO€ SKOHOMHYECKOe HOJIO2K€HH€[OKA3A1O, MTO ỐIODOKDATHM€CKH H€HTDAIH3M, OCOỐ€HHO MHHHCTpATHBHO-CHñỐK€HU€CKAẲ CTDYKTYPA YHDABJICHHI, CYHI€CTBYIOU(T CO BpeMeH BOHDICONPOTHBJICHHA H ocBo60%x« qeHHA HO IDHHHHIIY BOCHIIO-TEITIOBOPO cHaOoKenua, YK
Trang 16HỆ COOTBGTCTBY€T NepcneKkrHBe pA3ø„rnad DibeTHawa.!” Hrar, na 8-oM nnenyme TÍKNB (5-ro cosbisa, mrOHb 1985r.) OTM€HAIHCb H€PBBI€ HIAFTH B HONHCKAX mm
pa3BHTHA 3KOHOMHKH CTDAHbI B H4IIDAB/I€HHH K DBIIKY Takast xe Tema H IIDOGJI€Mb
1010ỐØHbIX npeoSpasonannit B nonuTHYecKOl Õ71ACTH OỐCV2KIAHHCE H YTBCJ2/I€HE
ua VI Cbe3ne KIIB no $opMyle “naprma (KHIB) pykosogut, HapOJL XO33ÌicrByer
TIPA3BOBBIX YCJIOBHH 7151 Pa3BHTHA COLIHA7IHCTM1€CKONH H€MOKDATHH k
B mpouecce OỐHOBJI€III IO/IHTHI€CKOÍÍ CHCTeMbI 6BUIN OIID€7IC/IEHbI raKkHe
OCHOBHBI€ 3aqa4H, Kak OỐHOBJICHH€ PyKOBOACTBA npapamel IIIB ornocurembio TOCYJAPCTBA, HOBIIIIHH€C 2(CKTHBHOCTH /H€ST€GJIbHOCTH IID€/ICTABHT€JIbHbIX
opranoB, pe(ÙOpMa 4MHHWCTPATHBIOTO AIIIADATA H YCHII€IH€ pos HAÐO/UIbIXCy/IOB H IDOKYparypmi “°
B pe3ybTAaT€ HO/IHTHq€CKOFO OỐHOBJI€HHA IID€/UIAra1OCb_ ”C923/AIH€
COHHAJIHCTHWCCKOTO TOCYHAPCTBA - TOCYHADCTBA Hapoyla, THOJIYHAIOIICIOCIH oT
HADOA, CYHI€CTBYIOHICTO BO HMs HADO/14”” H ero HDO/IBH2K€HH€ HO HYTH pA3BHTOIÌI
”COHHanucrwecKoli neMoKpaTnw””, 7!
PEC, MaTepnambt VỊ cpeyia KIB -ram ae, a Takxe “Baronpr na nyTH petbOpM B Hryiokrrae” [lon pea Boric
Ljunggren -Xanoii.:Iloni3nar, 1994 -C.524,
tụ Kype BC€CTODOHH€TO O6HOBNCHHA nERTHAMCKOrO OỐ1I€CTBA OBIT IpHHAT VI Cb€3noM KIIB, Ha KOTODOM b1 caenar
đKHCHT HA 3KOHOMHM€CKYIO D€()ODMY B IOKYMCITTAX Cbe3/1a COIDXGLIHCb H TDHHLUIHHANEIEIC BOTTDOChl, OCHOBHBIE HAHDABICHHð HOHTHHCCKOTO OỐHOP/JICHH9, KOTODBIC IQJTY1HJIH HaHỐOJ€€ €TKO€ OTDA)KCHHC B MATCDHA/1X TUICHYMAX
LIK (6-ro co3bIma) w VII c+e3na KIB.
em, nonpoOuec: MaTrepranbi VỊ c1e+n KNB -tan oe, -C.95-100; Mateprtanst V(I cseaa KITB
-XaHoft :ÏIpanna,1991 -C.90-100.
” Baxoiiie ÕmkaÌitune it AANbHCHWHC 3414111 ONpPeACAHAHCh Ha Õ-OM, 7-0M, 8-OM nacHymMax LÍK KTTB (6-19 c03bIBA),
HA VII c5e3ne KIIB, meCbc3noecKolt konQiepertua LỊC KTIB (7-ro co3bIBAa), a TaOKe nDyrux macnymax LÍ (7-ro
CO3bIBA)
" Matepnanst VII c%e3xa KIIB -Tam zxe -C.90,113 Cueuyer OTM€THTb, WTO B O)HHHAJbHbIX HOKYHCHTAX BO
Db€THAMC WACTO I04€DKIIBRACTCS HGOỐXOHMOCTE, “YCTỌÏ*IIBO CJI€/OBATb, MO IIYTH K COLBfA1H3MY"” HcCMOTDI HA 3T0, B
KOHKDCTHỌI IO/INTHK€ BbCTHAMA TOCTABJICHHAS KOHCHHAW H@Db - COIIHA/H3M, MO2KHO CKa3ATh, OTKJIA/bBACTCW HẠ
H€OTDC/ICTGHHIÍÍ CPOK, 4A OXKHB.IICHHC HO/IHTHUCCKỌIL CHCTCMBI HH3BIHO CHOMATb KOMAEUTHO-A/IMHHHICT2ATHBHYTO
CHCTICMY, OƠHOBHTb pyKOBOnCTBO KIID B8 OrHouteHuu POCYAAPCTBA, YCIUDITb DONb CHCTCMDL TDC/ICTAITFCTbBHBIX OJHAHORP, HOBBICHTB xp PcKTHBUOCT b ULOCVY/IIDCTBC1LHOEO YUPARICHHA, BO3DO/LHTb HDABOIIOD/IOK Í{ OC'I[IHCCIPRIIE
Trang 17O)WiMM H3 TIẾDBBIX DDAKTHI€CKHX M€DOIDHSTHÍE OONOBICHHA IIOJIHTM4d€CKỌl
CIDYKTYDPHI #BHJIOCb CTD€MJI€HH€ K J€LH€HTDAJH3AHHH, YCTPAH€HHIO TPOMO3KOCTH,
MaJ1O3€KTMBHOCTH aJIMHHHCTpaTHBHOrO AHHADATA, nepectpohke Kâđp0BOl
CHCTEMBbI (JHHOBD€M€HHO IID€/UJIO3K€HO YCTpaHHTb I€P€IUICTÊHHC byHkunl
[iADTHHBIX H TOCy/JADCTB€HHBIX ODFAHOB Xora KIIB no-npexHemy pA3paỐaTbIBaeT
IOJIHTHU€CKHG YCTAHOBKH, HBIH€ OHA HaMepeHa ỐOJIBHIỆ HỆ BM€HIHBATbCS B
NOBCEAHEBHbIC €71a I(pasBHT€JIbCTBA.
C uenbio YK€TUI€HHS 1OB€DHS Macc MaprHiHOMy KYPCY, BOCCTAHOBNCHHA HX
[OJJIDXKHM JI€JIY OỐHOBJI€HHI H OCYHI€CTBII€HH% /N€ÍCTB€HHOTO KOHTPOJIS 3â
curyaueii ïIDoBonwMoro oốnogJIenwx KTIB 3aspusa 0 CaMOOỐHOBJICHHH B Hanane
1987r ỐbL1H HâH4ATHI MepOnpHATHA HO OHHIIÊHHIO HADTHH C YH€TOM
ÕIH€CTBEHHOFO MHCHHA H HIDH€M B HCC HOBbIX Han6onee HOCTOfHbIX WICHOB.
K yyacTwio B XOMe HO/JIHTHH€CKOTO OOHOBICHHA MpHBJICUCHbI HapOAHble MACCBL HO/L J1O3ÿVHTOM ”HADOH 3HaeT, HApO/L OỐCY3K/IAGT, HapoA H€/IAðT, HApO/ KOHTpOIHDy€T” HaHỐOI€€ BAKHbIMH WaraMH WIA âKTHBHOTO HOJIHTHHI€CKOFO yMACTH1 Macc 8818/HCb MpeoOpasopanHa H3ÕNDAäT€JIbHOÍ CHCT€MbI, YTO HHB€JIO K
Ị3XHEIICHMIO BbiÕo0poB B HaHHOHanbHoO€ CoOpanve, COCTOABLUIMXCA B AâHD€J€ 1987
roa.
HeManOBAXHO€ 3Ha4eHHe IDH/ABAJIOCb BOCCTAHOBJICHHIO ODTAHH3AIHHH H
JIÊ4T€IbHOCTH MaCCOBbIX OỐb€NHH€HH Hà /€MOKDATHH€CKHX Hadaax C KOHHA
1987r mwm go koHna 1988r Opin HDOB€H€HbI H€pBBÍ Cb€3T CCOHHAHHH KOOIIEDATHBHbIX KpecTban BbeTHaMA, O4€D€HHbI€ Rb€3/bi QỐb€HHH€HHð TDYHUHUIXCS
npodcois30s Bernama, OreqecrseHHorO pOHTa _ BbeTHaMa Cbe3nbL /BYyX
IOC/I€NHHX OCYLIECTBAAIMCh C HHHAäTHM HOBBIX YCTABOB H OOHOBJICHHEM
PYKOBO/U1H€TO COCTABA.
Tleppbie MeponpHaTHaA HO HOBBIUCHHIO OIH HauuoHaneHoro CoốpaHns
ðuIIH cneJ1aHkti B KOHUe 1988r., KOTHA C H€JBIO OƠ€CI€W€HHã CBOeH H€3ABHCHMOCTH
38KOHHOCTb Koraa 3TH uci ỐY/YT AOCTHYHYTH, 1OFA ỐyHẾT HPOHHAH OCHOBA ANA DCd/111)08HHH COUHANCTHYCCKOH
Trang 18or LIK KIIB HanHonabnoe Co0DAHH€ TIpOBOHHJIO O4€D€JHYIO C€CCHIO HIC€/I, a HỆ
nocne nenyMa LIK KIJB, kak 3T0 OƠbI4HO ỐbIUIO panbute Ha ceccHH HOH301111ACBOỐO/IHA1 JICMOKDATHH€CKA11 JIMCKYCCHA JI€IIYTATOB IIO 33KOHOIDO€KTAM BarkibIMHBOIPOCAMH, KOTOpble HO/UI©XAJIH OỐCY3KH€HMO Ha ceccHH lÍaHHOHA/IbHOTOCoØpanns Bp mione 1989r., ỐbI1O crpemnenHe OOHOBNEHHA IIADO/UIBIX COB€TOB H
KOMHT€TOB - B@KHBIX HHCTHTYTOB IA IIDHBI€H€HHH MACC K YVMACTHIO B
IOCY/JApCTB€HHbIX /I€1AX COOTB€TCTBHH C HOBBIMH H3ƠHDAT€/IBHBIMH 3AKOIlAMH,HPHHATBIMH Ha C€CCHH B OTKPbITOM H OƠHOB/JI€HHOM TIOPS1/JIK€, TDOBOJIHJIHCB BBIỐOPHI
B ODTAHBIL HADO/IHOTO IID€HICTABHT€GJIbCTBA, IDH3BAIIIbI YCTPaHHTb HOSBJIEHIS
()ODM8J1H3MA B €5T€7IbHOCTH COBCGTOB
Takum o6pa30m, slo Konua 1989 roa HOIIHTHUI€CKOC OỐHOBIICHHCG B
OCHOBHOM Haileneno Ha IIOBBIHCHH€ DOCTd MOBepHaA HADOIA K NapTHn H Ha
ID€O/IOJI€HHe€ “Oiopoxparnyeckoro I€HTDAIH3M””
——Ừ"””
Ae 4B |nanpueliiuem, nocne VII cre3sya KHIB (mone 199Ir.), ocoỐeHno co
CL N: ẻ
JðDØMeHfi | npHHaTHad Hopoli (nelicreytomel) Koncruryuun CPB (1992r.)
IIioahifá')e KOC OOHOBJICHH€C OTMCUCHO NaH6ovree T71YOOKHMH [ICDCM€IIAMH,
Bb€THAaMCKOTO OỐIII€CTBA Oba ỐbICTpO OCO3HAHaA DYKOBOJ1IIHMH BepxaMH CPB, eenporpamMa p23paðorana Bp IK KIIB H yVTB€DXKHEHA PBICHHM 3B€HOM ee
PYKOBOACTBa, OHAKO €€ ïIDOB€H€HH€ HOCHIO /IOCTATO4HO OCTODO?KHBIÏ XaDaKT€P.
[lonqepKHBAJOCb, MTO ”Ố€3 IID€HBADHT€IBHOTO CO3/AIHH1 H€ÕXOHHMBIX
NPCAMOCbIIOK HIOCIICIIHO€, YCKOD€HHO€G H H€IDABHJIbHO€ IIOJIHTH€CKO€ OỐHOB.ICIN€
MGXCT HDHB€CTH K OJIWTH4€CKOl HecTraOHAbHOCTH, B €53YJETAT€E Yyero JICsO
Trang 19OƠHOBJI€HI14 B LICJIOM HaTOJIKHETCH Ha MIHIOLOMHCJIOHHDIỊ = TpyAHOCTH H
22
peHATCTBHA
B o@uunasibHow HI€44TH OOpaujanocb BHAMalIve Ha TO, YTO AeN0 OOHOBNeHHA
MOTYT TODMO3HTb JHHAMHYeCKHe, HHOFHA KDAÍH€ HDOTHBOD€HHBBI€ COHHAJEHHI€
W3MCHeHHA IPH DaCTyHI€l KODBICTHOÍ, yTFOJIOBHỌÍ ID€CTYHHOCTH B cBa3H Cc 3THMH€OOỐXOHHMOỐ CTAHOBHTCä CTAỐHMJIbHA14 HOJMTHu€CKAA OỐCTAaHOBKa TONbKO HDHNOJIMTH4YECKOH yCTOHYMBOCTH MO2KHO (ÙODCHDOBATb OOHOBJIEHHE, NOCKOJIbKY HM€HHOOHa CO3HaeT YCIOBHA J1 OOeCrIeueHHA OỐIH€l YHOD4/IOM€HHOCTH B CrpaHe MHbimuCJIOBAMH, NOUMTHYeCKaN H€CTAỐHJIbHOCTb MOKeT NpHBeECTH K H€CTAỐHJIbHOCTH BApyrHx OỐII€CTBeHHbiX ciepax Ho HOJIHTHI€CKA4 ycroHunBoOcTb He O3HAHA€T3acTOH, CrarHauiMio, Tem Oonee HE HIDOTHBOD€HHT NOsHTHYeCKOMY OỐHOBJICHHIO Ona
He ABJLIETCH CAMOLJBIO, He (DYHKHHOHHDYGT pau ceOs câaMO, a npescrasnaerJINHIb "HEOOXOMHMBIE YCIOBHA JIA COLHAJIBHO-2KOHOMHH€CKOTO PasBHTHA BOOỐIH€”
H BA2KHBIÍ dakrop Wb NpHBeYeHHA WHOCTpaHHoro KAIHTAHA, npeoyomenns
“ocna6ieHHa AOBepua Hapoma” K KOMMYHMCTHYeCKOA napTHH H rocynapcray.?”
Ana noO/UIepKaHHä cTaOwibHOCTH Kak Bả3H€đUI€ momuTHuecKOH H€IH,
COTJIACHO MapTHAHbIM MOKyMeHTaM, H€OỐXO/IHMO OGecneyeHHe pyKoBogcTBa KHIB
BCCH IOJIHTHU€CKO CHCTeMOH H BC€M OỐIH€CTBOM, OTDHLHAHH€ H H€HOIYHICHH€
IIOIHTHH€CKOFO HLIIODAJI83MA H HAÐTHHO OIIO3HHMH, a TakoKe OỐ€CI€HeHHe
YCTOÍHHBOCTH OƠII€CTB€HHOFO Crpox C OỐHOBJICHHIM “BO HMA H H1 HApOHA”
POCy/JAPCTB€HHBIM annapatom “*
Kak npaBHno, 2Ù€@KTBBHHI ïđ€D€XO/A K DBIHOHHO 32KOHOMHK€ Ố€3 xaoca B
OỐII€CIBEHHO 3HH TpeOyer €ODpFAHH3AHHH HM KODCHHBIX H€€MEI B
I€WT€JIPIOCTH CTpyKTyp MouMTHYeCKOH cHCr€eMbI Bo BbeTHaM€ 3TO 03HaHAeT, 4TOWIM YCNeWHOFO OCYHI€CTBI€HMS IWiaBHOrO H€DXO/JlA B HO/IHTHd€CKO OỐ/1ACTH
HYKHO IDOBO/HTb ero MO 3TaHAaM B DYCJI€ OỔHI€TO OOHOBJICHHA, KJIOH€BbIM BHAOM
# Murepnanei VIE crea KIB -Ta oe -C 122
*` Jie Xwy Hrua OGecnevenne H0/HTHM€CKỌI cra6wibHOCTH H OONOBIEHUE HO/HEHSICCKOÌI CHCTEMAI //KOMMYHICT
Xanoil, 1994 Net C.42,43
-ÈÈ MaTCDia/iBI MGXC b€AnoscKoli onepeiruir LK KTIB (7-ro cosna) - Xanoit, 1224 -C.11-13,
Trang 20KOTOPOTO Ha II€CDBOM 2TAH€ /I072KHA OBITD 2KOHOMH1u€CKAS pebopMa.”” Cyst 0
Bcemy, TomnTHYeckoe OOnoOBICHHe B CPB poo6ie He BeneT K H3MCHGIHIO IIOIMTH1€CKOFTO Kypca - HIOCTDO€HHIO COIIHAJH3MA, a CHOCOỐCTBY€T IIABHJIbHOMY IOHHMAHHIO COHHAJIH3MA HM_ /JIOCTHMW€HHIO 2TỌ HIH COOTB€TCTBYIOILHMH
26
CD€/ICTBAMH H M€TO/IAMH “`
B CBđ3H C 2THM BIIOIH€ NONATHA PeaKUHA Bb€THAMCKOTO DYKOBQO/ICTBA HaATAKH, IIDGIIDHHWTbBI€E B KOIIte 80-x H Iradaje 90-x rofoB Ha COIIIATHCTHM€CKHIÍ crpol B Bocrounoit Enpone, CCCP, a TaK»K€ Ha HOJIHTHH€CKH€ 2MOLLHH KHTAÍÍCKOTO
crynenuectBa (nekaØps 1986r.) Ha 6-om, 7-om, 8-oM nienyMax IK KIB (6-roC03bIBA) PELUHTELHO OTPHUA! NepBbIE H3ACPAKH NONATHNECKOTO THIOPAJH3M H
27
IAPTHHHYIO OHIHO3HTLHO, IIDOSBJUIBIHH€OOT €D€/IH BE€TiIAMCIHX KOMMYHHCTOB
3necb HO/I€3©I1 OIBIT IIDAKTHM€CKOTO OOHOBIEHHA B CTDAH€ 3a HOC/IC/IHH€TO/IBI, a TAKXK€ YyDOKH nepecrpoiika B CCCP, đ€MOKDATHM€CKOFTO ABIDKeHHA B
Bocrounoli Espone vn onsir Mo/IepHH3annn B KHP Bo speriamcKol 0(ÐHtV14/15HOlÍ IICHATH BBICKA33bIBAIOTCH MHCHHA, B COOTBETCTBHH C KOTODBIMH OeCKOHEUHbIC
** Marepranht VII cse3na KITB -TaM oxe -C.J22 Hexctopie Bb€TiIAMGKPC HCTODHKH H HOIHTOHOTH CUItAIOT, STO
ANA OHTHMH38LHH DA3BHTHN OỐHICCTBA CHAYANA OCYUICCYBAACTCA IRONOMHMCKAA, A BATOM HDOBOHHICR
CCHIAbHO-I0onnrnwecKaa pepopwa Ha wai pari oGe pefopm AG0bl OFT DOBCTTCÐhi OATOBPTMCHHO, WOO OFM HMCIOT
TCCHY10 B3AHMOCBA3b CM Dan Cyan Lon Tam oxe -C.195.
bi Martepuansr VIII cpe3ga KI]IB.- Xanọii.:Ï'ocnomrr, 1996.- C.70.
” B obnnmansuoli newarw B CPB CHHTAIOT, WTO HCIh38 CIGpachisaTh CHIIO CHCUR(PHKY, HPCHMYTH€CTBä TC KCIHDODA7b
y 3anana Muoronaprtuiinyro CHCTCMY, HỐO OHA MOKCT IDHB€CTH K ỐODbƯ€ 3a TOCV/UI)CTBCHHYVIO BIACTb H TEM CAMB K
nommuyecxoit HCCTAỐHTEHOCTH Ha 3anane yÕ€»KHAIOTCI, 'TTO HHTETDALHS Tí:CY2PCTBA HCMBICIHMA Oc3 'CHCTCMLI
IAPTHÏHOTO IHDABICHHHỔ T.e HAPTHHỌ (1KTWDHOCTH, HOCKOIbKY COD€BHOBATCIPHBÏ HDHHUJIHIL H€W?CIBHOCTH HO/THTHMW€CKHX IADTHÌI OỐGCIGUHBACT BBIỐOP JIYHIHẸ{ 33 HHX B KAICCTB€ NDAâPALHCÍ ƠTHAKO HA HDAKTHES h:HIỊTHC
CrpaHbi, np€sne pcero CLUA, đABHO HDHJ€DXKHBAHCE HDHHHHIIA, B COOTBCTCTBHIH C KOTODBIM HOỐGHIBIIAZ Ha BLIGOpax MaprHa DACCMATDILDA/1A /(072KHOCTH B ODFAHAX HCNOMMATCABHOH BJIACTH H TDYTHX TOCYHADCT5SHIbIT OPTAHAX
KAK CBOIO “3AKOHHY1O đOỐbI4y” Ï]03TOMY OIHOHCHTLL /âHHO CHCTCMBI HCDG/IKO HA3bIBAIOT ec “CHCTCMỌí AOƠDIIH”
Pasymeerca, TO MHOTOIADTHÍHAI CHCT€MA TỊ)CHCTABJISGT COOO!H OHH H3 ACMOKPATHYCCKHX HHCTITIYTOP TD/IBOBOTO
IOCYIADCTBA JIHUIb TOFHA, KOIH3 HÕCHHBIIAS NapTHA HMCCT B CBOCM OTDXIC ACCTATOYHO WICCTHBIX H0/THTTHEOP,
KBAH.HHHDOBäHHbIX VHDABJICHIICB, KOTODBIC HE CTPCMATCH K z(CTO7bB70BAHHIO CBOCFTO MpeO PIAA Ha
TOCYADCTBCHHOÌ( cnyahe B JIHIHBIX IIH Y3KOLDYHIIOBBIX HHTCCCAX B POCCHH muoronaprniinax CHRCMA, HO
MHCHINO HCKOTOPbIX DOCCHÌCKHX YUCHLIX, NOANTONOFOD H JODHCTOB, AO CHX TOP He CKHA/Ubinacrcn, 160 CTA10
“HPHBBIIHBIM, ‘ITO NpoPeccnonambHpie NONNTIIKIE CO3HAIOT TapTHH HMCA B BLJIV HDCTAOVI pBcero ODECHICUCHHECOỐCTBCHHOÌI MOMITHYCCKOH KADbCPBI Takadt HADTHA HMIAMAIEHO HỆ MOSKT CTABHTb ncpea coOosi HIHOKIC
OGIICCTBCHHO-NOANTHYCCKHE Bata.” Ca nonpo6nee: [(pano H noma COBDCMCHHOlï Poccun, Kong art
- Mo Baunnia, $996, -C.29-39.
Trang 21-XOJI€ OOHOBJICHHA B CTpaHe He MONycKaeTca “GeckoHe4Had WeMOKpaTHa”, HOO OHa
MOXKET IIO/DBIBATE FOCY/ApCTB€HHI NpasonopsAOK H CTAỐM/IEHOCTb OỐII€CTBA [nH MOCTHXKCHHA 3KOHOMHM€CKOTO HOIB€MA APH COXpaHeHHH HOJIHTHq€CKOH
gmiổubiNobru BbeTHAM He HDHHILI MOI€IH 3aH4nA3, a CKOp€€ BC€TO
IIPH/€Pp2KHBAerci TpAHHHHOHHOI MOHeIH lƠro-BOCTOqHO À3HH, HOCKOIbKYy Bb@THAMIIbI HO-CBO€MY HOHHMAIOT H IUJHOCbI H MHHYCbI AeMOKpaTHH “ÏlÍopol Ha›Ke KaxkeTCA, UTO CBOỐO/â BbIOOpa H JDYTH€ KIACCHI€CKHG 34I1A1HbI€ CBOỐO/BI M€LHIAIOT
9KOHOMHYECKOMY pocry”.?? C 0nNHO GTOpOHBI, NpOBOAA NoMHTHYECKOe OOHOBEHHE,
BbeTHaM /I€/1A€T AKI€HT Ha IOJIHTHH€CKYIO CTAỐH/IbBHOCTb, YKD€TIUHIẾT PYKOBOAAILYIO DOJb €HHHCTB€HHO B crpaHe nonwTHd€cKO HaprwH - KHIB C npyroð - B xone [IOIMTHd€CKOTO OOHOBNeHHA B CPB rpaKHaH€, COF/IACHO HADTHÍHBIM IOKYM€HTAM, DACCMATDWBAIOTC# KAK AâKTHBHBIC Y4aCTHHKH OỐIHI€CTB€HHHX esl KH HDH3BAHbI OCYHIECTBJLITb KOHTPOJIb 38 /€HT€JIBHOCTBIO TOCY/ApCTBA NOx pyKOBOTCTBOM KIIB.Tlocneguee ecb OHHO H3 DpA31H4H M€2KHY Hb€THAMOM, OCYHI€CTBJIIIOIHHM H€HOOỐHOBJI€HH3, H OCTAIbHbMH crpaHaMH lOro-BocTrowHoli À3mH Takum o6pa3om, MO?KHO CKa3aTb, BE€THaM cam ceOe CO3/1AJ1 MOJ€JIb MONHTHYECKOrO OỐHOB/I€HM1.
B -2TO CB33H Cambie ỐOJIbHIH€ TDYHOCTH H HCMbITaHHA Wid COBD€M€HHOFO
BbeTHaMA, Kak HO/M€DKHYTO B MaTepwanax VỊ cbe3na KIIB, 3akKtOdaiOTCS B OTCYTCTBHH MONCH /AHHOTO OỐHOBJI€HH14, XODOHIO IDOB€D€HHOH BD€M€HÈM.
* tan Your Tax [ÏpaBH7SHO nOHHMaTb BEiBonbt [ionn6ropo LK (KIIB) no H1e010rHSCCKOR paÕO1€ (Han 3mm 1989,
23-24 auBaps.
? 4 Uynonces Caer H TeHH AeMoKpaTHH //Hoaoe npews, 1993 -N39 -C.34.
KCraTH ormerum, wro CHHranyp H Manaiizna c OFpAHI4€HBIMH noauTHueckuMH CBOỐO/LAMH, TalHpaib HlOxou Kopes, K TODBIC OỐBHHHIOTCS B 2HHKIA4TYp€, HOỐHJLHICb 3a KODOTKHỂ CDOKH YAMBHTCALNLIX IKOHOMHYCCKHX
Trang 22OJUIAKO 3KH3Hb Hasta “Harb YDOK”, NOKa3asIa H€/OIYCTHMOCTb HOCIICLIHOCTH oGuopnenna.” ECJIH ceroans H€/CTABHTb C€ỐG HCTODHIO HOC/I6/UIHX eT B BHJL€VIDOIIHHỌ CXeMBI, TO MO3KHO Cka3aTb, TO HO CPADH€HHIO Cc KYHICHH€Mc0Iain3Ma n Bocrownoli Enpone đ CCCP, nonutuseckoe o6nosenne B CPB net nanGoslee yMepeHHbIM TÊMHOM, B OFDAIIMI€HHBIX MacuiTaOax, q70 oTHOCHT B5€THaM
K HHCIV CTDAH Mpa, CTPeMALIMXCA OCYINECTBIATh TIABHO-YM€P€HHOC
l
õnonJienne.”! B stom cMbi©Jle BoernaM uv KHP nđM€IOT MHOTO o6wero.
Tlockonbky B Mmponecce oỐHOBJI€HHI Bb€THAaM /IBHK€TC" HO COỐCTB€HHOMY HYTH, CHELYeT BBLI©THTb H€KOTODbI©C MOMGIITbI DB33HMOCBI3H H B3AHMO/I€ÌïCTBH1
M@XQ/Iÿ DKOHOMMYECKON pe@opMoli H HOJIHTHN€CKHM OỐHOBJICHHM
EcnH pe(bOpMaA 2KOHOMHICCKOÍ CHCT€MbIL BO Bb€THaM€ XaDAKT€D13y€TCW
NepexOOM OT A1MHHHCTPATHBHỌÍ K TOBADHO-DBIHOHỌ' 3KOHOMHK€, TO OỐHOBJIHH€NONHTHYeCKOH CHCTeMbI O3HA4A©T I€D€XOJH OT IICHTPAJIH3OBAHHỌÍÍ HOJIHTHM€CKOÍÍBNACTH K CTAIOBJICHHIO H COBGDHICHCTBOBAHHIO COMMAIHCTHYeECKOM /€MOX<DATHH,OỐCCIICICHHIO peambuoro CYB€CHHT€TA napoga (OHOBIEHH€ HOJIH7E1€CKOl
CHCTCMbI, KAK H3BECTHO, /1OJIKHO COOTBGTCTBOBATb TD€ÕOBAHHäM 3KOHOMIII€CKOIi
pebopMhi C 1DYTOÍÍ CTODOHBI, D€(}OpM XO3/1lCTB€HHOIÍ CHCTEMBI C LI€/IbIO pasBHTHAT0BAJ)HO-DbIHOWHDIX OTHOIICHHÌE “I1Y2KJA€TCI B FADAHTHH JCMOKDATHH, AFGIICTB4,ïi0/IWIHq4€CKHX CBO6O/U” PbIHO4H38 IKOHOMHKA MO2K€T IOJIBCDTATbC1 ““TODMC2K€HHIO
ỐIODOKPä?HH M CðGDXKOHIICHTAIU1H BIACTH H IDOMWHX H€TâTHBHBIX (paxtopos”,”
€CIH OHA He IIOJICDXHBA©TCH H He 332HIHIIA€TC1 HÊ€MOKDATH€ÌÍ B HOJIHTHH€CKOH HApyrux oOnactax †CYTCTBH€ TaKOM AMAICKTHYECKON CBA3H M€3KHY OBYMA 8H113MHpedopmM MOXKeCT NPHBECTH K OCMOKUCHHIO H 1DYHHOCTSM Ha HYTH yruryOnenAs WenaoÕðnop1enux oỐitecrpa HbernaMa [(pH 3ToM ocHoBoH O6nOBNeHHA 3/%€TCW
O3NOPOBJICHHE 3KOHOMHKH HMCHHO HIOTOMY, HTO TOBADHA21 35KOHOMHKA (ÙOMHDY€T
ycnexon Onrr KH mp OTCYTCTBHH “HIIDOKỌÍ I€MOKDATHH” 3a HOCCHHH€ TONBI MOCDHH3A11H CBHJ(CTCIECTBYET O
HCƠbtA/I0M DOCTC HapoAHOrO xo3siicTRa,
'“ Matrcpnanbi VI cse+n KIT Tam oxe, -C.44-45
` *Bÿonbt nã 1YTH pe)opM B Hi/tokirrae” Tan oe -C.530
* Cit Bancu, Hexoropsic reop soupocer oỐnccrnennttix pe(bopM B Kirrae //TTpoốneMni /[anen Bocroka !983.-Ne4
-© 8®
Trang 236a3y jist “(ÙyHKHHOHHDOBAHHi 0€MOKparHn”.” J\pyruMu C/JIUBAMH,
“0I€D€2KAI)IHHMH TÊMIIAMH HH€T D€A)13ALH51 HEH OOHOBJICHHA B 3JKOHOMHYECKOH ÕØJ1ACTH HK JMHIb Ha 3TOKH 6a3e NpoHCxXOAHT peKOHCTpyKHHA B NOMTHYECKOH
cjepe””.”“ He MeHee BAHO€ 3HA4€HH© WM€€T HOIHTHHdeCKO€ OỐHOBJI€HH€ Dro OTHIOIb He OỐYCJIOBJIHO Tem, HTO MonMTHUeCKaa petbopMa HaxOAHTCA B NOHO!
H€3ABMCHMOCTH OT 9KOHOMMYeECKOM D€{ODMHI, craB ee “XBOCTOM”, a Haobopor,
nepBad HIDA@T AKTHBHYIO POJIb B OTHOIICHHH BTOPOH, IIOCKO/IbKy OHA CO3HA€T
VCIOBH*S 1O/IHTHH€CKO craOunbHOCTH Hu 23(€KTHBHOTO HABI€HHS, MTOỐbI 1088DI10-DLI10411A51 2KOHOMHKA YKP€IUJ1IACB H pasBuBasiacb [ÍCXOJI H3 3TOFO, BO
35
ÌbeTHaMG OỐa Bufa OỐHOBJIHHS HDH3BAHBI NPOBOAHTbCA OANOBpeMeHHO.” lÍHaqe
“H0JIWTHU€CKâ41 BJIACTb MOKẾT IDHHHHHTb 3KOHOMHMH€CKOMYV Pa3BHTHIO B€JIHuaInnli
32 3
BD/ILH MO%XẾT BbI3BATb DAC€TDATY CHJI H MAT€DHA)1A B MACCOBOM KOJIHH€CTB€ ,
1.2 Bo3pacranne D0/IH HpABA B NOJHTHUCCKOH 2KH3HH Bb€THAMCKOF00ốLIecTBiai
!2.1 B3qUMOC6ð13b NONUMUKU tt Npaea
[OBOpa O pOIH mpasa B ÕIHI€CTB€, B HO/IITHH€CKOÍ 3KH3HH, H€OỐXOHHMO
DACCMOTD€TB B3aHMOCBA3b HIO/IHTHKH H IDABA, HIOCKOJIbBKY OHH NpeACTaBILAIOT Ba
OOLIECTBEHHBIX ABIICHHA, T€CHO ÕYCJIOBJIHBAIOIIM€ Apyr Apyra
CyujHOCTb NONMMTHKH, Kak H NpaBa CB13âHA C OOMLECTBEHHOH, ID€?KH€ BCero CrocyapcTbenHOw BJIACTbIO "Bnacrb - 3TO CT€P)K€Hb H HOJIHTHKH, H NpaBa; yepes
BJI4CTb /IAHO HX €HHHCTBO, elO 3K€ OIID€JH€JLIETC# KAW€CTBO, xapaKTep /âHHOFO
©nuHcrea”.*7
B coHlƠanbHO crpykrype TâKA B3AH4MOCBI3b OTpaxkaeT HX (ÙyHKHHH B
'
o6ulécTBeHHOA cđcTreMe Ecnu đO/IHTHKä - CpeACTBO ODTAHI33LHH H D€TYJIIDOBAHH4
*KH3HH OỐUI€CTBA, TO npaBo, ỐynydH "opmMoH p€AIH3AHHH TOCYApCTB€HHOÍ
{
) Cun BaHkcH Tam oe -C.88
4 Auocosa JI.A BueTHaM Ha nopore XX1 Beka (NHHAMHKA H MO/CDHH3ALUUI MPOHSBOAMTCILHBIX CHỦI)
-M.:JIyu,!993 - Ho penenann ['na3ynoga E //IpoốneMu /JaneH Bocroxa,!994 -Nel,
** MaTcpHapi VII cbeana KIB Tam oe -C 122
Mapxc K., urease ® //Cou -T.37 -C.417
[paso H đ0nHTHKA CoBDecunoB PoccuH.- C.6
Trang 24ïIOIITHKH”” BBbICTYHA€T Kaic OHA H3 PAABI DIX HOPMaTHBHDbIX (CHCTEM,>
”D€TYJIHDYVIOIHIHX OTHOWeHHA B OỐII€CTP€, /N€ÌÏCTBHI HM TIOB€/ICHHI JHO/L€Í,
()YHKIHOHHDOBAHH€ OỐb€/IHII€IHÌI H TOCYJLIDCTB€HHBIX opranon”.?3
[ÍOJIHTHKA B JIHII€ TOCY/IADCTBA I10/U/1€Ð)KHBA€T H OƠ€CH€HWHBA€T IID3BO, TeM
CAMBIM Yepe3 I!ODHJIHU€CKVIO HOJIHTHKYV OID€JI€HIT OCHOBHDIC TDHHHHIBI,
HAIDAB/ICHHW DA43BHTHT HDABA, OKAa3bIBACT AKTHBHOE BIIHIHH€ Ha B€Cb IIDOI€CC
IIDABOTBODU€CKỌÍ, IIDABOHDIM€IIHT€JISHỌÍ H Ip3BOOXPAHHT€JIbHOÍ_ MesATesI_UOCTH,
DA3BHTH€ IDABOCO3HAHHH, OIID€JI€IIST M€TOJHBI, 38/1441 (ÙYHKIHOHHDOBAHH1
T0CVADCTB€HHBIX YWD€?KI€HHÍI
B OTTIHUH€ oT JYTHX HODMATHBHbIX CHCT€M, DCTYJIHDYIOLHHX OỐII€CTBCIITYIO
WM3Hb, TAKHX KAK HODMDI MODAIH, D€JIHTHH, TDAHHIHOHHBIC HOB€/ICHUCKH€
CT€D€OTHIIbI W.T.H., IDABO HAXOHHTCI B TECHOH CB13H C HOJIHTHKOÍÏÍ TOCY/13ÐCTBA H
OƠYCJIOBI€HO XAâPAKT€DOM 93TOH CDI3H TOJIbKO HOJIHTHKA Kak HDOIS3BO/THO€IOCYJAPCTBA “B COCTONWHHH OƠ€CICMHTb Y“epe3 MCXAHH3M BJIA4CTH yopaBsIenne,
IIDABOCYV/H€, D43pAOOTKY HM DCA/IH34HHIO €/IHHBIX, OỐII€OỐS3AT€/IbHBIX, M€TKO
OIID€HGJICHHDIX THHOBBIX MACIITAỐOB /UIN B3aHMOOTHOWeHHH HW IIOB€HCHH1 BOƠIIICCTBC, HADYUICHH€ KOTODBIX BHIGTCWH “H€BBIOHHBIM”, T.K - BJICHCTYCTAHOBJI€IIHBI€ JIA 3THX €IY1A©B rOCY/1ADCTB€HHbI€ M€pbI BO3/leÌicrpns”””” B To
Ke BPCMA, 44BJIHICb HODMATHBHỌ OCHOBOH HO/IHTHH€CKOI CHCT€MDI, npanoD€IYIHDYT H€ØT€IbBHOCTb TOCYHADCTB€HHBIX ODFAHOB, IpHnanasq cit
OIID€€JI€HHOCTb, OƠUICOỐ33ATCJIbHOCTb, OƠ€CHGM€HHOCTb
TOCYACTB€HHO-IIDABOBBIMH CD€/ICTBAMH Takum OƠDA3OM, IIDABO, B CBOIO O4€D€/Ib, IIOJUI€D2'CHBACT H
OỐCCI€IMBA6T HOJIHTHKY, IDHA©VT eH H€OỐXOIHMYR CTAƠỐHJIbHOCTb, IOMOTA€TH3Õ@3(AaTb BO3MO3KHBIX OTKJIOH€HHÍ OT €€ OCHOBHBIX HDHHUHWHIOB H HAạpABJIEHHÍÍ33BHTHI, a TAKJK€ HCKJIIOQA€T HDOH3BOJI H Oe33aKoHHe B3aHMOCBI3b M€?KHYNOJATHKOH W HABOM B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT ypOBHA HJI€OJIOTH3AI1HH OỐI1@CTBGHHOÍÍWII3HH, COIIHAJIbHOTO IIOJIO3K€HHS, KOHKPeTHOH TOCYHADCTB€HHỌ PHONBTHKH HIIDIBOBỌÍ KYJIBTYDBI, CK/JIA/bIBA9Cb MOA BO3€HCTBH€M IIDOHGCCA 23KOHOMEíWGCKOTO
Trang 25pa3sBHTHa, JU11AMMHKH COHH2/IbHO CTDYKTYDBI, Ha pA3HBIX 3Tallax pA3BHTHã OƠII€CTBa
xapakTepi3yerca MHOTOOOpa3HeM MCNONb30BaHHA TIDABOBPbIX Hatta! B NOJIHTHYECKOH
eaTeMbHOCTH.
Vix B3aHMOOTHOILI€HH€ IDH KOHKD€THbIX (POPMax OTPaxkKaeTCA B HEATCJIBHOCTH rocyHapeTBeHHoro almapata, B CT€TI€HH ero ỐIODOKPATH3ALMM WH XÊMOKDATH3AHHH,
TAKK€ B ©TO JMHaMHYHOCTH, YHDABJS€MOCTH M KOHTpOsMpyemocTH IIpu 3Tom
Hy3KHO HM€Tb B BAY, HTO YDOB€HE COBEPILICHCTBOBAaHHA NpaBOBOrO D€TYJIHDOBAHHä
0/IHTHU1€CKHX HHCTHTYTOB “BBICTYHA€T BC€THA YCTKHM HHNHKATODOM peasibHOCTH,
JÊMOKDATHH IIOJIHTHH€CKỌ 3H3HH CTDAHbI, BO3MO2KHOCTH [PA)KHAH B.IHSITB Ha
opMHpOBaiie H OCYHICTBI€HH€ TOCYADCTB€HHO HOIHTHKH, HOJIHOBIIACTHA
IID€/ICTABHT€/IbHbIX ODTAHOB TOCYJAPCTBA, Ha/IM4AA H CBO€BD€M€HHOFTO BKJIOH€HHS B
nelicrpHe MEXaHH3MOB IIOJINTHU€CKO H IODM/JIM4€CKOl OTB€TCTBe€HHOCTH”.5
VCTAHABJIHBA4 B3AHMOCBS3b HOJIHTHKH HW HpABA, BaxKHO YHHTBIBATbCOHWA7EHbBI€ OCHOBBI HX B3AHMHOFTO BJIHSHH1, IOCKO/IbKY HOJIHTHH€CKH€ H IDABOBBI€aBICHHA OỐYCJIOBJI€HBI IHABHBIM O6pa30M COHHAIbHO CTpYKTYpỌ OỐM€CTBA,
AMHaMHKOH COHHAIbHbBIX OTHOWeHHH B 2rol chepe PopMuUpyIOTCA H DA3BHBAIOTCäCOHHAIBHB€ IIOTP€ỐHOCTH, CJIYAKAHIH€ CTHMyJIATOPOM JIA pP€AJH34HIHH
nonuTHueckux (}yHKHH, HDHHAIOHIX “COHHAIBHYO AâKTYAIbHOCTb p43päỐOTK€
npaBoBbix POpM HOJIHTHM€CKO đeareneocrw”."
IHoốena HapOHHO-OCBOỐONHT€JIEHOÍ PeBOMIOWHH BO BberHawe Bs 1945r npupeyla K cCO3aHHIO HoBoro OỐII€CTB€HHOrO crTpoa [Ipouecc ykpemicHna NONHTHYeCKHX H COHHAIbHBX 3aBOeCBAaHHK D€BO/HOHHH, YTB€DP3I€HHAI HOBOTO
IOD3DKâ OỐIHIÊCTB€HHO 3KH3HH COHDOBO3KIAICSä IODHIMM€CKHM O(ÙODMIIHHCM H
3âKD@IUIHM€M COLUIAIEHBIX M3M€H€HH, OID€H€I€HH€M IHDHHUHMHOB HOBOÍ HOJIHTHKH, DAHMKATIBHEIMH H3MCHEHHAMH B 3AKOHOHAT€CIIbCTBC, oGecneyeHHemM
38KOHHOCTH, CTaHOBNeHHeM HOBOK, HapOAHOH cyeOHOH CHCTeMBEI.
39 NonnronorKa: SHUMKNONEAHYNeCKHA COBADb.- TAM 2KE.~ C.311.
® KyMannu E.B LOpiaueckas ROJHTHKA H NpaBoBadt CHCTCMA KHP -M.:Hayka, 1990, -C.10.
Tas xe -C 11
Trang 26B nepHon c l94ĩr no l954r TpeỐOBAHHIM Boennoro BpeMeHH ỐbUIO
IO/IUHH€HO H )23BHTH€ npana Hla nI€pBBiÏi tian BBHIUIO DGUIGHH€ HAHỐO/I€€ OCTPLIX
npoOsiem 34IUHTBI HOBOITO OỐIICCTBA H OCVIHICCTBJIIII© /THKTATYDBbL Mponerapuara
3aM€THO, WTO Ha IDABO BO3/1A78JIICb KADAT€JIbHbI€ H HJ€OTIOTHwecKHe (ÙyHKLI1H To0COỐ€HHO BAO Ha MpHMepax TIDOB€/I€HHS arpapHoli peopMII ua cepepe 3ueriiaMa
B Hadane 50-x rr., CđB3aH1IOli C KOI(}HCKAIH€Í HOM€IIHbMX 3eMenb, paGouero
CKOTA, C€/ISCKOXO38ÏïCcTBeitioro HHB€IITAD1 H DACHD€H€IGHH€M HMYII€CTBA CRp€HHÚ€33€M€JIbHbIX, HEHMYLIMX H IIY2KJ(AIOIIWXCSI B CPEACTBAX HDOH3BO/ICTBA K€CTbSH,Hecmorpa HA TO, HTO OCOỐO BAKHOG 3HA1GCHH€ Jin MHOTOMHCJIEHHOÌÏ MACCBI
Db€THAMCKHX KP€CTbAH HMCJIO TOT/IALIH€€ NPHHATHE 3AKOHA O 3€M€TbjtOÌi pebopMe
H HDOB€IÊHH€ yi43AHHOÍ p€(ODpMDI B OCHOBHOM HOCHIO JICMOKDATHJ€CKH
xapakTep, CJIGHY€T OTMCTHTb MACCOBBI€ HADyIH€HHS Cyn€ÕHOlÍ đDOH€JIYpbI BO BDEMS
IPOB€T€HH4 pe@opMbl, HTO HADYH1A7I0 IOH€/JYDBL Cy/1OYCTDOÌÍCTBA, 3aKD€IUIGHHbIG Bnepsow Koucrutyunn JIPB (1946r.)
B nepHoI nocne ocnoboxgenun Cepepnoro Buernawa go HavanaoOnopienua (c 1954r no 1986r.) caa3b HONMTHKH H MIpaBa BbICTyI1A/1A B (ÙÌODM€
OIID€€J11IOII€TO, /OMHHHDYVIOLI€TO BJINAHUMA 1OJIHTHu€CKOl nệTenbHocTn KIIB ua
npabo B HTOF€ 3TOTO /UIHT€/ISHO€ BDÊMS HIOJIHTHU€CKH€ M€TO/JIBI BO3/€ÌïCTBHS MOUTH
34MGIiII3H IDABOBBIG (ÙOPMbI ODTAHH3A111H OỐII€CTB€HHbIX OTHOLIeHHfi B oÕItecTpe
CYIICCTBOBAJIH IID€JCTABJI€HHä OO VHHB€DCAJIbHOCTH H BC€CHIHH HOIHTHUIECKHX
MCTOJLOB D€IHI€HHZ COLLH7IbHO-3KOHOMHUECKHX IDOỐJ€M, HTO BM€CT€ € ICHXO/IOFH€
K€CTbIHCKHX MACC, HOCALICH OTMeuaTOK (Ù€O/1AJ1SHBIX OTHOII€HHII, H BO3/I€ÌÌCTBH€M
KOH(YHHAHCKHX HOHSITHÌ 0 HpHOpHTeT€ MYMPOCTH, HDABCTB€HHOCTH
[OCYHAPCTBCHHBIX HHHOBHHKOB Hal 3aKOHOM, HODOXCIAIO HHTHIHCTHM€CKO€
OTHOII€HH€ K NpaBy H 3aKOHHOCTH B CPB, nonoÕHo Tomy kak B CCCP, KHP n5 -DYTHX COMUMAIHCTHYCCKHX CTAHAX OCHOBHOH YepTOH HOJIHTHKH B OTOT H€DHOJN
bUIA “peann3anua H/€OJIOTHMIECKOÌ YCTAHOPBKH O BO3MO)KHOCTH HCTODH1I€CKOTO
N€pBEHCTBA HOJIHTHKH HAN 3KOHOMHKOI, O BO3MOXHOCTH = pa3BH THs
[DOH3BO/JTHT€7IbIHBIX CHI Ha OCHOBE [IDHHYJHTEJTISHOTO oboOutecTBIICHHS
Trang 27COÔCIB€IIHOCTH, 2 KECTKOH HHTD3HH3AHHH YHDABJIICHHI, BHÈ3)KOHOMHUM€CKOTOIIDHHV2K/JICHHZ“ K TDYHY, MACCHDOBAHHOTO H/€OJIOTHH€CKOIO BO3eCHCTBHA Ha
oốitecreeHnoe co3Hanue”.” BMecre € TEM HY2KHO HAIOMHHTb, YTO /IOJFO€ BPeMA B
CPB nmpoBogHiach 3SKOHOMHYeCKad HOJIHTHKA, COIIDOBO2KJIABHIACäS ?K€CTKHMH
[UIAHOBBIMHM HadalaMH, OTDAHHH€HH€M /JOXOHOB Ha OCHOBE YpaBHHTellbHbIx
NPHHUMNOB, HeAOOUCHKOH MaTepHasibHOM 34HHT€D€COBAHHOCTH TDYHAHIHXCS,KOTODBI€ He TD€ỐYIOT IIDABOBOFO D€FTYJIMDOBAHUUI
VHiqbnkatna (opm COỐCTBGHHOCTH, KOMAHHHO-A/MHHHCTDATHBHbBI© M€TO/JbIynpaBJieHHA IKOHOMHKOK H OỐIH€CTBOM, TIDHHH2K€HH€ POH /ÊMOKDATHM€CKBX Haya
B IOCYJIADCTB€HHOIÏ H OÔHI€CTB€HHOÍ ?KH3HH BGJIH K YCHJICHHIO HOJIHTHU€CKHXMGTO/IOB BOSACHCTBHA B ÿYLI€DỐ HGI1OJIb3OBAHHIO IIDABA
OyHakO COB€DUIIEHHO H€HDABHJIbHBIM SBJLACTCA MH€HH€ O TOM, HTO B 2TOTnepHOA Ha IIDABO KaK HHCTDYM€HT ODTAHH32LIHH OÔII€CTB€HHBIX OTHOII€HH HeÕbIJIO OỐPALIEHO BHHMAHHE HH HE IDHABA7IOCb 3HAYCHHE DOJIH IIDABA B OỐHI€CTB€80BC€ Hao6opor, HM€HHO B 3TO Bpems nepe” KIIB B kauecTBe ñpaBømieli rIiapTHw BCPB, OcTpo BCTas BOIIDOG 0 CO3A2HHH HOBOFO 3AKOHOJATGJIBCTBA, CFO MpOBEACHHH B
»H3Hb BbUIH IpHHATbIL Koucruryuna 1959r, u KoHcrnryuma 1980r /JJocrarodHoỐbIJIH DA3BHTEI KOHKD€THbI€ OTDACJIH NpaBa: KOHCTHTYLHIHOHHO€, âMHHHCTDATHBHOe€,[DAX/JAHCKO€, YTOJIOBHO€, YTOJIOBHO-HIDOH€CCYAJIbHO€, C€M€ÍHO-ỐDAHHO€ H 1.H,Hadann (ÙOpMHDPOBATbECI HOBO€G HDABOCO3HAHH€ H CKJIAHBIBATbBCf HDABOBBIE
HHCTHTYTbI, KOTODBIC OK33AIH 3HAHHT€JIBHO€G BJIHNHH€ Ha TOCY/ADCTB€HHVIO
IOIHTHKY H IpAaBOBVIO cuctemy CPB.
K cookanenmio, 0 DA3HBIM IDHHHHaM B OỐHI€CTBG BC€ 3€ H€/OOH€HHBAIIACbpOIb npaBa Oro kacanocb H pAỐOTHHKOB TOCYJADCTB€HHBIX ODTAHOB /ÏAa H MHOTH€TpAK1âH€ HTHODHDOBAIH IDABO H3-3a ỐOJIbHIOTO pA3DBIBA M€XQIY YCTâHOBJICHHSMH,3âïIHCAHHBIMHM B IIDABOBBIX akTax, H MpaKTHKOM HX HDHM€H€HHZ, KOTODAñ 3A4aCTy!O
0CHOBbIBA/IACb Ha CBOCBOJIMH KâHOBbIX DAỐOTHHKOB, B TOM HHCJI€ DYKOBO/SIHHX
HHHOBHHKOB ELI€ OKA3AIHCbB 2KHBYYHMH CBOỐCTB€CHHbIC BO€HHOMY BD€M€HH
® KyMauan EB -Tau axe, -C,12.
Trang 28IDABOBỌi HHTHJIH3M, H€/IOB€DH€ K HOPMe, ONpaBsaHHe GOe33aKOHHA HO/I pA3/THWI IMI ID€/UIOraMH ÿyCJIOBH1X H€DA3BHTỌÍ 3AKOHO/LAT€IPHOÍÍ H€NT€IIEHOCTH, NpakTHKH 3AM©HBI IABOBBIX (ÙODM BO3/CHCTBAA HOIHTHH€CKHMH OTM€AIACb TeHNEHUHA K
HTHODHPOBAHHIO HOBBIX HODMATHBHO-HDABOBBIX AKTOB H OTCYTCTBH€ /1O7I2KHOf
ODTAHH3ALIHHW HX HCIIO/IH€HHH.
‹ Z
1.2.2 Ponte HỊ246 6 HOGblX ycnogusX NonuMuUYEeCKOU 2ICH3H1 6 CO1JHGUIMCIHMM€CKOff
PecnyOnuxe Beemuam
[lo Mepe D€AJ1H3ALHH akTYaJIbHbIX H H€OTJIO2KHBIX COMMAIbHO-NOJHTHYCCKHX
34A4, Pa3BHTHA 2KOHOMHKH H KYJIbTYpbl BO Bb€THAMCKOM OỐII€CTB€ Haun Halor
OCO3HaBaTbh HCOOXOMHMOCTb HCTIOJIB3OBATb MpaBO, e€FO COIHAJIbHBIÍ [IOT€HIIMA1.Takaa TE€HJ€HIH OCÕO nposBunacr B 80-e TT B CB83H C TD€ỐOBAHHIIMH HỊ)HH1STH1
CpOdHBIX MEP HO ID€O/OJI€HHIO COIIH3/IbHO-3KOHOMHU€CKOTO KPH3HCa, B KOTOPOM
Oka3aiacbh cTpaHa (CYHI€CTB€HHBIC MepeMeCHbI B 2KOHOMHK€C B 93TOT I€DHOJ,HWanpaBIcHHbie Ha ÕGCIICU€HH€ paBHONpaBHA D33JIHHHbIX XO3AHCTBEHNBIX YKIIaJOB
pH DACUHIHPVHHH C(€P TOBADHOTO IIDOH3BO/CTBA, CTAHOBJICHH€ HOBBIX3KOHOMHU€CKHX CTDYKTYP, DA3BHTH€ BH€IIH€3KOHOMHII€CKHX CB413€Ï' TOTp€ốOBAJIHKDYTOTO IIOBODOTA K HCIOJIB3OBAIMO MpaBa, B MOHHHKAHHH ero pD27IH B
0DTAHH3AIHH 2KOHOMHH€CKHX OTHOII€HHÍÍ
PbIHOHHBbI€ OTHOWCHHA B COBD€M€HHBIÍ H€DHOJH - 2TO BOBC€ He CTHXHJïHA13KOHOMHKA, CAMOD€TYJIHDYVIOLHIAWCSI, He HY2KHAIOHIAICI B KAKOM-JIHỐO BIIELHIICMDO3/\elicTBHm H(bIH€ 3TH OTIIOUI€IHS TD€ỐYIOT LI€I€HAIDABJI€HHOFO, 3)ЀKTI(HOTO[IABOBOTO D€T/IAM€HTHDOBAHHð, OỐRCI€HHBAIOII€TO 34IIWTY H 1I€I€COOO2233HO€HCIIOJIb3OBAHW€ COOCTBEHHOCTH, D€TYJIIDOBAHH€ HH, B33HMOCB13b BCex CyÕ›€@KTOB3KOHOMHH€CKHX OTHOII€HHÍ HDH ycraHOBIeHHA OOWerO IDHMHIIHHA DABHOIP138H1 H3KOIOMMH€CKO CBOƠO/HBIL HD€/IIDHHHMATGJIBCTBA HW TOPFOBIH Kpome 3TOTO,XO3/IÏÏCTB€HIIO-IIDABOBOFO_ D€TYJIHDOBAHHØ TD€ỐYIOT eHexKNO-KpenHTHad CHCT€MA,
Trang 29|ÍOCKOJIbKY 2KOHOMHKA CJIY2KHT LJIABHBIM, OHD€JIGDHIOHHM (ÙAKTODOM = JWIKaA4©€CTBGIHOLO HD€OỐP430BAHH4 IO7IHTHH€CKỌÍ H IDABOBO CHCTÊM, 2KOHOMH€CKA1
peÙOpMa, D€IrY/HMDY€MA3 IDABOM, B CBOIO OH€D€/Ib, CHOCOỐCTBYẾT CTaHOBJICHHIO
HOBOIO COHHAJIbBHOFO MCXAHH3MA B33HMOCBA3MH HOJIHIHKH H IDABA, OCHOBHbIMH
!1€DTaMH KOTODOFO ABJIAIOTCA FOCHOHCTBO HỆ NOJHTHKH, a 3AKOHA B OỐII€CTBeHHO
XH3HH H BM€CT€ C HHM IIHDOKO€ DâCHDOCTDAH€HH€ MpaBoBbIX M€TOJOB YIIDABJICHHä.
BHIICYIOMSHYTBIÍ M€XAâHH3M TD€ƠY€T OTKa3a OT MpaKTHKH HOJIM€HEBI 3aKOHOBHOJIMTHYCCKHMH HHDCKTHBAMH, AO TeX MOP DACIDOCTDAH/IBIHNMH CBO€ HeHcTBHe HaCaMbI WHPOKHH Kpyr JIHU, H YCTpaHeHHa TÈHH€HIHH O(ÙODM/JIHHS PewleHHiNPHHUKMMQIbDHbIX BOIIDOCOB BbTHäMCKOTO OỐHI@CTrBa He B 3AKOHOHAT€JIbBHBHIX AKTAX,
a B IAPTHBHbBIX AOKyMeHTax TT]paBo IDH3BAHO HDHJATb IIOJIHTHK€ CTAỐHJIbHOCTb H
ODFAHH3OBAHHOCTL, HOTOMY WTO HHKAKHC 2KOIOMHHCCKHC HMH_ HOJHTHHCCKHC
npeo6pa30BaHHA He OyAyT COHHAIbHO 3{0Q€©KTHBHbIMH, €CJIH FOCYApCTBY TDO3HTxaoc xoN€ pA3BHTH4 H YVKHP€ILUICHH3 IDABOBBIX Haya! OỐII€CTB€HHOÌ 3KH3HHD€LIAIOTCH OCHOBHBI, B33HMOOỐYCJIOBJI€HHB€ 34H144H: 3AKD€IUIHH€ DBIHOHHBIXOTHOUISHHA TPH HCHOJIb3OBAHHH IABA H pa3sBHTHe HNÊMOKDATHM€CKHX IDABOBHIXHHCTMTVFIOB, CHOCOỐHBX IDHBJI€qHb HapOAHbIe MACCBI K ynpasseHHtorOocyHapCTBEHHbIMH đ€JIAMH H OỐ€CH€HHTb 2()€KTHBHBI KOHTDOIE CO CTODOHEIOỐII€CTBA 3a N€W1€JIBHOCTbK) TOCY/IADCTBA J[eMOKpaTHA, 3AIHHHI€HHA1 MpaBoM, BCBOIO ON€D€/Hb, HỆCOMH€CHHO, Ốyner BA)KHEIM CTHMYJIOM JIA yCKOPCHHA NpoweccaCOBEpMICHCTBOBAHHA NOJHTHYeCKOM CHCTeMb! H HDOB€HEHHA ela OOHOBJIEHHAoOulecTBa B II€JIOM
[ÍporpaMMHHI xapakrep Ayla ÿCHJI€HHS DOJIH MpaBa, YKD€IUI€HH1 3aKOHHOCTH
H IIDẨOHOI€HH4 HPABOBOFO HHTMIM3MA MMGIH pelneHnz VỊ cbe3na KHIB, COCTộ—BIHerocã B KoHIe 1986r,, OỐOỐHIWBII€TO OHBIT HDOII€HIIHX 3TAIOB pasBHTHA Bb€THAMCKOTO OỐIII€CTBA, H OCYJHBHI€TO OHIHỐKH, H€/IOCTATKH, OIYHIÊHHI€ 3a 3TO
BD€MA.
Tako mpouecc COIPOBO3JAGTCđ IIOCT€H€HHBIM OỐHOBJIEHH€M IHDABOBOl
HÊOJIOPHM, HI€D€CMOTDOM Pa3BHTHA BbeTHAMCKOFO npaBa, HTO B HACTOSLI€C BPeMA
Trang 30CTAJ1O !IACTBIO OIBITA IIDABOBOTO CTPOHT€JIbcTpa B CPB ”]JÏputU1O Bp€MS, KOI/(A C
OƠHOBJICHH€M 23KOHOMHI€CKOTO MBIHUICHHRS I€OỐXOHHMO OỐHOBMTb IODI/IHU€CKO€
MbI1IUICHH€, HJIAHHPODATb 3AKOHO/IAT€JIbIIYIO /I€IIT€JIbHOCTb, ÿVCKODHTb pa3paOorKy H
IIDHHITH€ 3AKOHOJIAT6TEHBIX AKTOB, IDCOJIO/ICTE M€JUIHT€JIBHOCTb B 3TOM Jee”.
Ba?KHBI€ IIOJIO?K€HHS HOBBIII€HH POH TIpABA 3akpeneHbI B DpeuleHHax VỊ HuVII cbseanop KIIB
Hopaa KoHcrnryunan CPB, npnHsTan B 1992r., umeeT IDHHIHIHHaIEHO€
4 we
3HaNeCHHe MIA pa3sBHTHA 34KOHO/IAT€JIbCTBA, YJIYHII€HHZ DÃỐOTBI HO OỐ€CIGIHHIO1AKOHHOCTH H IIOBBIH€HHS YPOBHA MpaBOBOH KYyJIBTYPbl BO Bb€THAMCKOM OỐII€CTB€
3 ormmune or mpenbigyunx ner (1945-1954 rr., 1954-1986 rr.), Korna HUIO
-T€AHOBIICHHE H I€PBHHHO€ Pa3BHTHe 33KOHO/7IAT€7IBCTBA, Ppa3sBHTHE IIDABA B IICDHOH Cc
-epeyuubl 80-x TT HH€T Ha 6a3e IDGCMCTB€HHOCTH Bb€TIAMCKOTO TDA/MHHOIIIOFO
IDABA H YCHJI€HH1 €TO HDABCTB€HHO-TYMAHHOTO IOT€HIIHA1.
Hy3xHo 3AMCTHTb, HTO B HACTOZIUI€€ BDCMZI BheTHAMCKOC IIDABO BCe aKTH3Hee
‘ropraeTca B Mpowecc HOJHTHdICCKOrO oOnoBNenHA B CPB, duKcupys ero
€OHH€TTHMIO H 3aKPCINLIA D€3YJIETATBI CrO BBIHOJIH€HH4I Ilpano CIIOCOGCTBV€T:
- COBC€DIHI€HCTBOBAHHED FOCY/IADCTBA, YIHDABJIICMOTO HADO/JHHOM, TIOJTYWI1OTICIL'O
‘BOH CYB€D€HHT€T OT HADO/IA H ()YHKLUOHHDYIOII€TO pawn HApO/13;
~OCYLI€CTBJI€HHIO €1HHOl TOCYJ13ÐCTB€HHOlÍ BJIACTH C p331€/1€HH€M (ÙyHFIHH
{CA LY BCTBAMH BJTACTH,
-Pa3BHTHIO Mpaba Hapoga ỐbITb XO3AHHOM !1€D€3 HD€JCTABHT€IDHY H
IETOCD€/TCTB€HHYIO NEMOKPATHIO, 3AIIHT€ KOHCTHTIYLHOHHBIX IDAB H MIIT€DSCOB
DAX/JHAH, OTDAHHI€HHIO 3/IOYVHOIP€ƠI€HHI CJYXK€OHBIMH TOIHOMOHEIMH
Trang 31BO3DACTaHH€ DOJIH IIDABA B MONHTHYeCKOH 23KH3HH B HOBBIX YCIOBHAXBbCIHAMCKOTO OƠHI€CTBA COIIDOBOMCIAGICI H€OỐXOHHMOCTBIO PaCIHPeHHA HHVIJIYỐN€HH4 IIDABOBOFO perysIHpOBAaHHA, a TâK2K€ COB€DIH€ICTBOBAHH4 M€TO/IOB
IDABOIDHM€HHT€JIEHỌÍ MW MpaBOOXpaHHTebHOH I€4T€JIEHOCTH DTO OỐYCJIOBJI€HO
YCJIOKH€HH€M 343W fIOIHTHH€CKOTO OOHOBNEHHA, 10 Mepe NpOBeseHHA KOTODOTOBO3HHKAIOT HOBBI€ IIOTD€ỐHOCTH H Cdepbl OfHOII€HH
Ilpo6nembt B3aHMOCB13M IIOJIHTHKH H papa, Dâa3rpaHueHHä (ynHKnnli KIIB
H TOCVADCTBA, B34HMOOTHOII€HHAS BeTBeH B/IACTH, DâCHIHD€HH€ HâDO/HOBJIACTHS,
BBECHHE HOBbIX HDABHI CYH€ỐHOFTO A3ỐHDAI€JIbCIBA, I€HOCTABI€HH€CAMOCTOSIT€JIbHOCTH H HHUUHATHBS! HH3ObUIM 3BCHbAM, NpeAOTBpallleHHe H ỐODpbÕa CcHCTATHBHbIMI COLHAJEHBIMH ABNCHHWAMH H TH: a TâKK€ MHOTOOỐPA3HbIC Hpa3sHOxapakTepHble CBA3H H B3AHMOOTHOHICHH4 ODIFAHOB, ODFAHH3ALHÍÍ, JIHL TD€ỐY!1OTCOOTB€TCTBYIOIHI€TO HDABOBOFO OƠ©CHI€U€HH3S, YeTKOH D€T/IAM€HTAHHH 323THXOỐII€CIB€HHBIX OTHOWCHHH C H€JIbIO NPHAAHHA ODTAHH3OBAHHOCTH, HHCHHIUIHHbIIIDH €4/1H3AH11 OỐIHI€OỐZ134T6/bBHbIX HODM
C€JY€T HH3HATb, TO He H32KHT MpaBOBOM HHTHIH3M, KOTODH B
3HAH4HT€JIbHOÌÏÍ CT€H€HH CBđ34H C YIIDOII€HHbIM HOHHMAHHCM HDAB3 JHHIb Kak
IIDHHYHHT€JIbBHOFO CP€HCTBA HOJIHTHH€CKOFTO BJIACTBOBAHHI M yHDpABI€HuI B
CO3HAHHM MIIOTHX Bb€THAMII€B 3€KOH MOHHMAeTCA Mpexk Ae BCerO KaK âKT C 3alnpeToM,
KapoH, Haka3aHHeM ECT€CTB€HHO, mpaBoBad HODMA MOKeT 3AïD€ILIATb TO, 4TOABNACTCA BD€RHbIM HH OIACHHIM Jia OỐIH€CcTBa Ho Ona MOoKeT ỐbITb DA3D€UII€HH€M H
CTHMYJIOM, HOOHIDCHHM HH HD€NHHCAHHM HO3HTHBHOFO D€TYJIHDOBAHHA.
2}j©KTHBHOCTbE HDABOBOTO D€TY/IHDOBAHH4 paccMaTpHBaeTca “He B CBW3H C
€CTKO -D€T/IaM€HTALHH€ OTHOIHICHH, He C yCHIeHHeM IDHHY/IHT€JIbHO-BJIACTHBIX
M€T0/IOB Ha CYỐb€KTBI IDABOBBIX oTHoineHnii”."°
C_ nepexOHOM K DEIHOdHO 3KOHOMHK€, KOTOPad TâK3K€ OK23bIBA@T CBO€
BIHAHH€ Ha H3M€H€HHE MCTOAOB MpaBoBoro BOSAeCHCTBUA, B NpaBOBOH ?XH3HH BbeTrHaMa B Nocuwemiee BpeMA (ÙAKTHHI€CKH CYUI€CTBYET OỐI€O3BOJIHT€JIbHbI
OCCHHCKOC 31KOHO/A1€/1LCTBO: HDOỐ/€MEI H IÍCDCHCKTHBMI, -Tam xc, -C L8,
4 P
Trang 32M€TOI DC8/IH34IHH IDABA, COTJIACHO KOTOPOMY MO3BOJIACTCA BCe, KOMG TIPAMO
3AID€II€HHOFO B 3AKOHe ÏÏ€CMOTDØ1 Ha TO, HTO TaKOH MeTOA IDHM€HI€TCSL JIA YaCTHOMpaBOBbIX OTHOUHI€IHH”, ON KACA€TGI, MO2KHO CKa3aTb, BC€X CyÕb€KTOB
0ØII€CTBA Ognako cnenyeT OTJIHYaTb ero OT pa3peluHTeNbHOrO M€TOjHA,
IIDHM€HS©€MOTO /UII D€T/IAM€HTAIHH /JI€4TCIBHOCTH TOCYHADCTB€HHBIX ODFAHOB,
J0JKHOCTHBbIX JHU CornacHo nocsieqHeMy M€TOHY OHH OCYLI€CTBJLIIOT TOJIbKO Te
1}
()YIIKHHHM, IDABA, KOTODBI€ NpAMO ID€YCMOTP€HBI B 3aKOHOATeNBCTBE
Trang 33[JIABAIIL OBHOBJIEHHE IIOIWTHUECKOH CHCTEMBI H POI
FOCVHAPCTBEHHO - ITPABOBbIX YYPEXK EHH
COLIHAJIHCTHUECKOl PECIIYBJIAKH BBETHAM
COBD€M€HHHIÍ 3TAH pa3BHTHA Bb€THaMCKOTO oOulecTBa OLH€HHBA€TCAS BO
RberHaMe€ kak I€D€XO/IHHIÏ NepHog K CTPOHTeJIbCTBY COHHaJIH3Ma (VI n VII cbe3nbiKTIB)
Touuruueckat cucrema CPB corjacHo Kouncruryrynn 1992r BamouaetHHCTHTYTbI pa3JIMYHOrO ypOBHA H HasHaueHHaA: KOMMYHHCTHYECCKy!IO HAPTHIOBberHaMa, (redecrpeHHHÌ pour BbeTiaMa, HJI€HAMH KOTODOTO ABJINIOTCH0/uiHCrBeiiaad BO BbeTHaMe (c 1982 roma) nojnnrndeckậ napraa (KIIB) uw ypyrHe0JDLAHM3ALHH, OObECAHHAIOWINE DA3J11HHbI€ CJIOH OỐIH€CTBa CreweCTB€HHbII DOHTBbeTHaMA CHHTAGTCI HOJIHTNH€CKOH OCHOBOH HApOHHO Banacru (KOHCTHTYHHäS1992r., cr.9) B nOCJI€IH€€ BpeMa ero JI€8T€JIbHOCTb O2KHBHJIACb ÏIaBHO 3anaueliOreyectBenHoro DpOHIA sABLIeETCA HDHBI€U€HHC Macc K BBIIOJIH€HHOnowHTHYeCKHX yCTaHOBOK KIIB wu HCHOJIHCHHIO 3aKOHOB, D€IHI€HHÍ rocygAapcrBa.Hostomy, rosopaA OO OỐHOBJICHHH MOJHTHUCCKOH CHCTreMbl BbeTHaMa, MbIl HM€€M BBHAY Ip€2ne Bcero KIIB BbeTHaMCKO€ FOCYADCTBO
Il l.Oðnopnenne MK@MMyHHCTHuecKoI HHaprnn BbeTHaMaA kak
HaD5IHI€ÍÍ IIADTHH B HOJIHTH€CKỌÌÍ CHCTeMe
11.1.1 IipoØneMbpi KLIB 6 HO@blX ycroewix
OnHa H3 OCOỐ€HHOCT€Ì MONHTHYECKOA CHCTCMBI B COIHAIHCTHH€CKHXcIpaHax BooØine, B CPB B taCTHOCTH, 3aKIO4“aeTCA B TOM, UTO KOMMYVHHCTHu€CKA1
NapTtHA BBIOTYHA€T Kak IIDABZIIHA11 IOJIWTHH€CKA1 NapTHaA.
Oguako B TeqeHwe cpoero cyLiecreopanns KITB “copepuimsia OLIHỐKH H3-3a
~ 29 6CYỐb€KTHBHbIX MHeCHHH M HADYHICHHS OỐb€KTHBHBIX 3aKOHOB 6 O6 sT0M
CBHJ€T€JIbCTBOBAJH HOIIBITKH DYKOBOJCTBA KHB B€CTH CTDAHy 4epe3 H€OIDABNAHHbI€ H3MCHCHHA B NPOH3BOACTBEHHBIX OTHOWCHHAX B
* Mavepran VII ceesya KIB - Tam se -C.151
Trang 34“COMMANIUCTHYCCKHX MpeoOpaz0BpaHHAx” Ha Cepepe l3beriaMa 5 50 - 60-e ros HH
1Ore BbeTHaMa B Konue 70-x ro/ton Xora Ha [Ore 3TH IpD€OỐPa3OBAHH1 ne nocrurnl
TaKOÌÏi KDAalHOCTH, KOTODA3 ÕbI1A4 1OHYLI€HA Ha C€B€p€, O/HAKO OHH HiocranHni
nepeq BE@THAMCKHM OỐHI€CTBOM C€PbC3HD€ mpoOsempt ]KpOM€_ OLIHỐOK nonyiIeHHbix KIIỒ OTHOCHT€JIbHO pa3BHTHA HOH3BO/ICTBEHHBIX OTHOIIGHHIÍ, ỐbUHCOB€DII€HbIL OIIHÔKH B3 MONMTHKE HMHYCTPHAIH3AHMHH, M€XAHH3M€ YHDABIICHH:
2KOHOMMKOÍ HM B DYKOBOHCTB€ HX peann3aueii."” SOTO €CTb OHIHA H3 THABHDI;
HDHHHH, HDHBCHIHMX BbCTHAMCKOC OỐII€CTBO K COLIHAJIbHO-3KOHOMHUICCKOM')
KDH3CY B KOHIIE 70-x TT.- HauaIe 80-x TT
Uro kacaetca BIYTDHIADTHHOÌÍ 3KH3HH, TO Ha VỊ, VII cbe3nax KIIB ex
PYKOBOACTBO NpH3Hao, 4TO 3a HDOULHI€IIIHÍ H€DHON B HADTHH HDOH3OHUII
OIIP€/IGI€HHBI€ nedopmaunn, yrpata JH€MOKDATHH€CKHX TPAHNHIHÌ, KOTOPBbIt
IDHCYLIH edt H31144871SHO H 3A1013/16IBAJIHCb MHOTOJI€THHMH yCHJIH1MH Xo [In Munna
J@MOKPATH1 mo CyHI€CTBY IHOỐpeIA (ÙOpMAIbHHÌE XâpAKT€D Bo MHOTH)
IADTHÍHBIX OpraHH3allWAX OTM€HAIHCb CBOCBOIH€, Y3YDHHDOBAHH€ DIACTH
IAT€DHAJIH3M, M€CTHHW€CTBO, IIOJ1A4BJI€HH€ HHaKOMBICJIHA, oc OyeHHe
CIIOUCHHOCTH, H€THCHHIINHHDOBAHHOCTb, MOPasIbHoe II€DeD0›K/I€HH€
HIHIODHDOBAHH€ 3AKOHOB, KODDYIHIIMI, KOTODBI€ CHOCOỐCTBOBATIH OCTY H€TATHBHDI2
ABNeEHHH B OỐII€CTB€ H BBI3BA/IH 1I€/IOBOJIbCTBO Cpe KOMMYHHCTOB H B 1iApODE.”CamMbIM Cepbe3HbIM H€/OCTATKOM, /101nyL1€HHDM KHIB 3a npOtHetiiee ‘epems
ARIACTCA TO, WTO “NapTHA CM€ULIA714 CBOH H (YHKLIHH TOCYJADCTB€HIIOTO annapata
49
B HTOT€ II4DTH4 HE MOIJ13 OCVLI€CTBJISTb D€AJIbHYIO 2(Ù)€KTHBHY!O JI€ZT€JIBHOCTE”
WÍM€HHO psig OUHIHOOK H H€IOCTATKOB, /IOHYUI€HHbIX I4DTODFAI132H8MH
p33HBIX 3B€HB€B B IIDOIIICHTIHC€ BYeMA, H MHOTOWHCJICHHHI€ TDYHHOCTH B
CO)(HAJIBHO-3KOHOMMM€CKOl 13HH BbeTHaMa B 70-e wn 80-€ rr 3aCTaBHIIH pyKOBOjc:po KIIBIICDCOICHHTb OỐCTAHOBKY, OCO3I131b H€OỐXO/IHMOCTb CaMOOÔHOBJI€HH
\ Matepramp VI c5e3na KTIB -Tam xe -C 101-102
* Jonan LIK KHB (6 co3srsa) o HaAPTCTPONTCIbCTBE H BHCCCHHH TIOTDABOK B Ycras uaptin.- Xanoli [Tprp,ta T991,
-€.I1-1.
” ]o Minoit -TaM xe -C_11
Trang 35LÏDOBOJUI OỐHOBJICHH€, yWHTB1BA11 YDOKH /JIDYLHX ƠbIBIIHX COLMAIHCTHq€CKnxCTDAH, CID€MSCb H3ÕG2KATb OIIHỐOK UH KDAÌHOCT€Í, BO MHOIOM OIHDAICB Ha OHBITMO/€pHH3anun B KHP, BbteTHaM ue BCrai Ha nyTb OrcrpaHenni KIIB orDYKOBO/ICTBA TOCÿApCTBOM W OỐUII€CTBOM “OHiHỐOHHbI H KDẠÍH€ BD€/HNHbI JIOỐBI€
B3T)15/Ib1 H JIVïCTBH1, KOTODBI€ CTaBAT MO COMHEHHE Ce PYKOBOMALLYIO pOIb (KTIB),
CO/I€ỐCTBYVIOT OCJ1A3ỐJI€HHIO HIM OTDHLIAHHIO ee 3HAYeHHA Kak NpaBalen napruu”.°5
MHpOBO onbir HOKA3AI: KOIHA CTADBIC HHCTHTYTbI BJIACTH D33DYLIAIOTCS Õ€3 [IO/IOTOBKH HOBLIX, CIOCOƠHBHIX B3ATb Ha CeOa (ÙÿYHKLH DYKOBO/CTBA FOCYADCTBOM, MO?K€T ©03/1ATbGI1 BAKYYM BJIACTH, BO3DACT€T HảïID32KCHHOCTb H XaOC B OỐHI€CTB€ Ilo
MÈD€ TOPO, KAaK KOMMVHHCTHU€CKA1 MapTHA JIMLUMTCA B)1ACTH, BLIOOP TOJIMTHI€CKOFO
Kypca CTpaHbl MO#KCT NOABCPPrHYTbCA BITHAHHIO Pa3JIHYHbIxX MOJIHTHYCCKHX CHỦI, B TOM HHCJI© OTHIONb HỆ HDOTDCCCHBIIHIX.
11.1.2 OOnoeienue DÿKO8OỊCHG Koamynucmuyeckoit l)aqpmuu PoeinnaMa 6
vOAQCMU 2O0CYOUPCINBEHH 020 CMPOUMeNbCMBA.
B 80-e rr B page COMMAIHCTHYCCKHX Crpali BIICDBbI€ B HCTODHH peaibHoroCOLMA)1/3MA IIOHLJIH CNOpbl O HOBOM OỐ/IHK€ KOMMYHHCTHYCCKOA MapTHH, O TOM, HTO
CMOKCT JH KOMMYHHCTHYCCKAA NaAPTHA OCYIHCCTBJUITB PYKOBOACTBO COBMCCTHO Cc
JIDYTHMH_ IIOJIHTHKO-OOIHI€CTB€HHBIMH CHJIaMH, OJDKHa JIM HDABSHHAAS nmaprHsiorKa3aTbCa OT HO/IHO MOHOIOJIHH Ha Bhacrh HT nm B To xe Bpema B KIIBNPH3bIBAIH HE MOMycKaTb JIOỐBIX HOIBITOK, BEAYIWHX K OCJ1AỐ/I€HMIO pykKOBOAAMIEHp01H KOMMYHHCTHU€CKOÍ IapTHH `
Cnenyer OTM€THTb, „TO € Hauaja 1990-ro roma yCwnusanacs 6opbốa B KITB
MexKIy CTODOHHHKAMH COXDAH€HHS CYLI€CTBYIOHEÍ YKOBOHNIHe€ pOHHKOMMYHHCTHYCCKOH HADTHH, CHOXHBIIeCS HOIHTHM€CKO CTDYKTYPH H 0IODOHHHKAMH ỐOle€ DAHHKAIbHBX ,H€MOKDAIHH€CKHX HD€OỐPA3OBAHH B NOMHTHYECKOH %XH3HH (KOPeHHad D€ODFAHH34HH HOJIHTHH€CKO CHCT€MHI, NOMMTHYeCKHA IUIODAIH3M WH MHOTOHADTHÌHOCTb) ƠnHaKo K KoHuy 1990-ro rofa
© KHrora XIV cbe3na KOK Kpyrasrit cron HB //IpoốneMsi /JanbHero Bocroka -M.,1993.- Net.- C.49
“MarepHa/mi VII cee+a KIB -Tam xe -C.95,123,127
Trang 360/ICD3KAJIM B€DX CTODOHHHKH II€pBỌi TeHJICHUHH “Mobi ne TDH3HA€M HQ/II1TH11CCKHIÍ|
t¯MOpanH2M”, - aanpu H.B JInnb, ÕtIBiinli IeHepabnbii Cexperapp KIIB eite Ha 6-om riieHyMe KIIB (6-ro co3bipa), 34 H€CKOJIbKO HH€Í O TAHbSAHbMIHbCKHX
CoốbiTH
B matepuanax LIK KIB, c ofHo CTODOHBI, OCy2KA€TC1 BCđKO€ HCK)KCHH€
HIH HHTHJIICTHM€CKO€ QTHOULICHH€ K MADKCH3MY-JI€HHHH3MY, HOH4€DKHBA€TCSI ero
0COỐ€HHO BA3KHO€ 3HA€HH€ JUI1 Bb€THAMCKOTO OỐIH€CTBA, TIDOBO3F/IAHIA€TCI KYDC,
"es Apyroi
-nalpaBleHubl Ha 1anbHelfiiiee nponoJkenne mytH Xo lHÍn Muna,”
C0J€D3KATC1 yKa3aHHa Ha TO, NTO “JIA COMMAIMCTHYECKOH CTPAHBI DYKOSO/ICTBO
KOMMYHHCTHYeCCKOH NapTHH sIBIKNeETCA HCTODIH€CKOl H€OỐXO;tHMOCTBIO”.”” B camomnene, pyKoBpogzsuiat por KIB cyltecrpyST co nHỊ ocnopanusa JIPB H mataoTpakeHne B Koucruryunax CPB 1980 u 1992 rr Crates 4 nelicrpylolteliKonHcrnTryunn CPB xeknapnpyer, uro KIB - apaHrapn u Ốocbol urra6
BbeTHAMCKOrO pabouero KJIACCA, ABJIETCA G/IIICTBGHHIOl CHIỌÍÍ, DYKOBOJU1H€fÍ
FOCYHA3DCTBOM H OƠOII€CTBOM
B CHJIÿ pa3ibix MPH BTCUCHHE ACCATIJIETHH DIT IOJIIHTHH€CKOII CHCTEMBICPB Oblna xapakrepHa Hepa3jeyleHHOCTh OCHOBHBIX (ÙYHKHH H KOMJICT€HIHH
IADTHHBIX ODTAHH3aHHÍ H rocynapcrBenHbix OpraHOB KIIB OCcyHI€CTEI3SIA4 H
MONMMTHYECKOE H BOCHIIO€ PYKOLOACTBO, B OCHOBHOM BBHIT2I12111 3a4£GIIG7ATð87TbIIBI©,
AIMHHHCTDA4THRHEIG (ÙWYHKH1H H BMTCTHH8214Cb B J€IT€/IEHOCTb CyMeOnslx ODEIHOB
B c3 € 3THM O/HIỌi H3 D4/HK8JBHDUX TDOỔJI€M OỐIIOBJI€HHS T1O/11T191€CKỌÍCHCT€MbL CPB, a TaKX%© HOBPBIUIEHH3S DYKOBOnCTBA KII3S HDHM€GHHTGISHO KI0CYJA)CTBY #BJIS€TCZ ÐA3I1DAHI1I€HH€ (ÌYHKHHÍ H TOIHOMONHÍ MC2KIY Napruei HrOCyRaPCTBOM C LICJIbIO H27113C10111H9 AX B3IAMMOOTHOIUEHHH CyTb jena COZTOHT BTOM, HTOỐbI KAKALI HIICTHTYT BBIIOJIHSI CBOIO DOIb HO (opmyne, BEI/IHHYTỌcamo KIIB: “HapTH3 DYKOBOZHT, a TOCV/ADCTBO YHDABJSGT"” ““23N€Cb HbHIC HeT
IIDOTHBOITOJIO)KHOCTH MOXY [IIOBBIHICHH€M pom HAaDTHH H YCHTCHHEM
“Marepnanst VII csesta KIB -Tam xe, -C 109
“Ilo Muroli ~TaM xe, -C 14,
Trang 37BOJIO Bb@THAMCKOFO HADO/JA, NapTHa Aenaer BBIỐOP cBoeH IO3HHMH, 3aHHMacTCA
BbIDÃOTKOÍ Aa BC€FO OỐIHI€CTBA NOMHTHYECKHX YCTAHOBOK, MPHHHMaeT D€II€HHä
MO BAKHLIM MOsHTHYeCKHM BOnpocaM `” KTIB e03aeT HeEOOXOAMMBIe ÿCIOBH4 JIA
toro, NTOỐbI HaHHOHAJIbHO€ COỐPaAHH€ kak BBICHIHỐ H€HCTABHT€JIBHBIB OpraH
MOrNO HOHCTHH€ IIDHHHMATE PCHICHHA NO )KH3HCHHBIM BOIDOCAM CTDAHNI,
B cBoiO ouepegb, IOCJI6NH€€ H1O0J2KHO KOHKD€TH3HDOBATb DÊIHI€HHS HADTHH,
K TODHI€ 3AT€M, COIJIACHO CYIHI€CTBVIOIHI€ HNIpOH€JYDP€, CTaHOBATCA 3aKOHaMH H
p€LI€HHSMH FOCY/HADCTBA.
Uro kacaeTcd BOMpOCOB ODFAHH3AUIHH TOCY/ADCTB€HHOTO alnapatTa, TO
NaprHaA OnpenenAeT €€ HIDHHHHHEI, OCHOBHbI€ HallpaBICHHA, a “nocueqHee D€II€HH€
IIDHHA/162KHT TOCYApCTBY” KOMMYHHCTHu€CKâ1ä napTHa DYKOBONMT
[OCVADCTB€HHHMH JH€IAMH HYT€M BBIIBHK€HHA KAHHHHATYD DYKOBO/HIHHX
[OCYHADCTB€HHBIX HHHOBHHKOB TakHM OỐPA3OM, 3TO H €CTb “BaxkHOe M€DOIIDHSTH©,KoTopoe OƠ€CH€MHHBAGT YCHJIICHH€ YIABJICHH€CKOI pOIH TOCYHADCTBA,
OMHOBPpeMeCHHO HOBBIIHI4IOII€€ PyKOBOAALIyIO pDOJIb NaprHH B OTHOHICHHH
rocyapcrsa’”’.”°
Tlapruiinbie ODFAHH3aAIH W KOMMYHHCTBI, DAaÕØOTAIOHIH€ B FOCY/ADCTB€HHBIX
opraHax, IIDH3BAHHI TakoKe HOBBICHTb CBOIO DOJIb H OTBETCTBCHHOCTh, HOCKOJIbKY
yepe3 HHX NapTHA OCYHI€CTBJII€T PYKOBOACTBO TOCY/JADCTBOM, MOỔHJIH3ÿ4 HADO/HHI€ MACCBI Ha NPCTBOPCHHe B 2KH3Hb IOJIHTHHCCKHX YCTAHOBOK OnHOBD€M€HHO qep©3
# Marepna VII c1eaa KIB -Ta xe - C.124
5 Jloxnaa LK KTIB (6 CO3EI8n) O NApTCTOHT€JIECTB€, H BHCCCHHH NompasoK B YcraB HapTHH -Tam xe -C.19-20
5 Jlo Mmioli -Tam ox -C.15,16.
Trang 38HHX HADTHZI OCYHICCTBJUI€T KOHTOJIb 3a J€AT€JIbHOCTBIO r0cy/1apc19a Ha rI61yMAXLIK KDB 6-ro w 7-ro ©O3bIBOB ỐbIJIO HAM€UW€HO YCHJICHH€ KOHTPOJIA 33 BBIIIO/HI€HH€MIApTHÌHỌÍ IOJIHTHKH TOCY/IADCTB€HHBIMH ODTAHAMH, HOO KOHTDOIIb Ø1B/I€TCH H
cofepxkaHHeM, H M€TOHOM IIA4DTHHOTO DYKOBO/CTBA, 6e3 Hero HET DYKOBO/ICTBA [pH 3TOM HD€/IYCMATDHBA€TCä YyCTpAaH€HH€ “yyyOnupoBaHun”, OTO2K/I€CTPJI€HH
Baknesiluum coObirHem BuyTpHnapTHinok 3KH3nw II co mua ee co3nanHa
CUHTACTCA Tak Ha3bIBaMOe ““T1OBBIHII€HH€ ỐO€BHTOCTH IIADTHH”, Kak OO 3TOM 34⁄187I€HO
na VI cCb€3/t€ NapTHH Ira T€H/I€HIHMS TI0J1ÿyWHJ1A Aaibneiuiee pa3BHTHe na VII KMBche3qe HOJI HA3BAHH©€M “OOnopsenHe H YHODpSInOdeHH€ maptTHn’ Brepepie BcepenHHe 80-x rr ObINO IDH3HAHO, NTO NyKHO HayaTb eNO OOuoBNeHHA C CamoKIB “Tonpko BOCCTAIOBHB NOpAOK B HapTHH MOMHO BOCCTAHOBHTb HOPAOK BOỐIII€CTBG”,” HOCKOJIbKY D€3YJIbTATbI VIOD4/IO4€HHS HADTHH p€LIAT Cy/UỐy “nenaOHNOBNEHHA, CTPOHTEIbCTBA COII1/113M H 341INTbI OTeyectBa”’
[ÏbaKTHKA MHOTHX J€T HOKA347A, HTO /ÊMOKDATHU€CKHÍ H€@HTPAJIH3M Kak
BAKHEHUIMH HDHHHIHHN, HAIDABJIIOIHH ODFAHH34IHOHHVIO 765T1€7I5HOCTb,
BHYT€HIIOIO CH3HBb HW CTHUIE pDaØOTBI KOMMYHHCTHUeCKOH IIADTHH, He BCeFHa
COƠJI!O/1821C1 M€cTo Hero — OTMCHA/I4Cb ODM4'IbI1Aã €MOXDATH1,
“6lopoKparwecKnli LICHTA/IM3M”” Ilpn (OpMaJEHOÍÍ 7ÊMCKDATHH
“TIapTODTAHM3AI11M €TpAHDVIOT H CTaHOBATCA 610poKpaTH4SCKHMH
0DTAHH3ALIHSMH, FAC AHCUMMIKNAa TIOTJ€D)KHBA€TCS M€XâHHW€CKHM HO/LH1HII€HH€M
HWKECTOALIHX, 4 DYKOBOHNAHIH€ KAHDEI TH YCIOBHH Ố€CKOHTpOIbHOCTH JI€TKONPOABJLAIM CBO€BOIH€, YV3VDHHpOBAHH€ BJIACTH” Ha HApTHHHX coGoanuaxðO0đbU1A1 dACTb paOoyero BD€M€HH YJ©JIUIACb BBICTYILUI€HHIO nOKJIanuuKì\ lÏpnBHPÀOTK€ D€HICHHÍ H€ỐD€XKHO OTHOCHJIMCh K MIICHHIM, HD€JUIOX€HHIM
oa Ho Muiolt -Tam oe -C 15,16
Trang 39HIH2K€C1O5HHIHX IADTODT :IH3AHH H DIIOBbIX KOMMYHHCIOB MHeHHA PyKOBO/ LINX Kâ/IDOB OỐCY31AJIHCb O/HOCTODOHH€, “B OCHOBHOM O/IOƠPZUIH, 3aTeM YTB€D3XJAJ1H KAK D€CLIHH% ỐOJIbLIMHCTBA KOIUIEKTHBA” Hy3KHO 3aMeTHTb, HTO He ỐBLIOHACTOZIH€ÏÍ HHCKYCCHH, âJbT€DHATHBHbIX MH€HH, YTO B€JIO K TOMY, !ITO BO MHOTHXcAyuaaxX IDHHSTH€ €HIHHÌ He OTB€HAIO HHT€D@CAM KO/LI€KTHBA, a Ốb¯IO JIHUIB
NpOAYKTOM CYỐb€KTHMBHBIX MHeHHH y3KOH TDYHHB DYKOBOHSIIHETO CocTana.”
[[oci0/IEKYV '“YHHB€DCAJIBHbIM KIIOWOM UIA NpeOAOIeCHHA BC€X TpyAHOCTeH ABIACTCA
0CÿII€CTBJIÊHH€ ZeMoKpaTHH”,” neppoouepemHad 341444 - BOCCTAHOBHTb JIÊHHHCKO€
[OHWMAHH€ /JJ€MOKDATHMCCKOTO II€HTDAIH3MA, DACHIHDHTb BHYTPHIADTHHVIO
đ€MOKDATMIO
Hauaraa Bp 1987 rony KaMIaHH3 mo 1H€rKe pxyOB KIIB napTug mpH3BaHaỐbllÄ OCyAHTh “BCAKHE NPOABMEHHA NPOH3BOsIa, 1BAHCTBA, IDHT€CI€HHä MAaCC” H HCKJIOHATb H3 HADIHH Tex, KIO “nogBepraerca MODA/IbHOI HW NOJATHYECKOH
JÊIDAHAHHH, C€€T packon, (ÙDAKHHOHHOCTb, COB€DLIACT
H€CTYIUI€HH€-KODDYIIHMIO ”” a TaK2K€ rex, KTO “ IDO4BJLUI€T OC/IAỐJ1eHH€ ÕoeswTrocrw”.
B coorbBeTcTBHu c peLiennsMH Tloanrốiopo, LK KIIB (6 co3bIBa), ocobeHHO
© peeHiaMM 3 1UienyMa LIK KIIB (7 co3niBa) yCHJ1MJ1ACb KOHTDOJIEHAä pAƠOTA 3a
BBIIOJIHCHMM KOMMYHHCTAMH HOCTABJII€HHbBIX 3AHad HepBbi€ B Yy€IOBHäX
[/IACHOCTH B WeHTpe H Ha MeCTax CD€HCTBA MâCCOBỌ HHODMAHMH HE TOJIbKO
[IPOIArAHHDOBAJIH NIHHHIO H KYDC KOMMYHHCTHYECKOA HADTHH, HO H HD€HABATHracHOCTH (akrbl Cepbe3HOrO HapyWieHHA HODM HOB€JÊHHZE CO CTOPOHbI tUIẾHOB
IADTHH, B TOM HHCJIC KAHDOB BBICOKOFPO PaHra.
BbilieyTIOMSHYTA4 KaMIAHHä Jala CBOH pesyibTatE EcJiH B TeqeHHe 10 net (1976-1986 rr.) 6110 HCKIHIOq€HO H3 D3OB KOMMYHHCTHW€CKO HapTHH HIDHM€PHO
190 Tbicaw KOMMYHHCTOB, B TOM HHCJIC 3HAHHT€/IbHA1 “aCTb 3a HapyuicHHe HODM
# Marepnanw VI csesna KIB -Tam xe -C.110
® Jie Bau 3aur PassHTHe ACMOKpATHH H YROPAONCINC NHCHJHI/MIIEL BH H 1641011 LHOCTH KTIB ia COBDCMCHHOM
grane //JJeMOKpATi3A1001 BHYTDHNADTHÍHO 3KH3HH H pYKOBOAALIC NexTeMbuOcTH nàpTHH 4.1 -M.,1990 -C.65, 66,
16.
© Xo LH Mu O HapO/Mbix Maccax -Xanoii,1970 -C 104
#Marcpuaipt VIE che3ua KILB -Tam 3e, -C 29
Trang 40MODA/ISHOTO HOBeMeHHA, H€KOTODbIG ÕBUIH HIO/IBGDEHYTbI CyJI€ỐHBIM CAHKIHSM, ” T0]
T0/IbkO 3a TpH roma c VI cbe3na KIIB (c nekaØpx 1986 r no nekaốpb 1990 r.) aI Ố0pbÕe 3a OHII€HH€ pADOB IApTHH ỐbUIH NpHMeHeHbI M€pbi Haka3anHaA K 206181 DA3/1OHB_IHMC" WH MepepoAMBLWHMCH KOMMYyHHCTAaM (npaMepHo no 10% pcero coctasa HApTHH), B TOM tHCJI€ HKImOdeHB M3 MapTHH 78206 (oKono 3%
WHCJIEHHOCTH napTun).”> 3a 1993r., B uacTHOCTH BO BCeH NapTHH ỐbIUJ1H HDHM€GIHbI
Mepbl B3bICKaHHA Bcero 2,3 % COCTABA KOMMYHHCTOB, HTO HO CpAaBH€HHIO c 1992
010M yBewuwJIocb Ha 42% cÒ€HHO CJI6/Y€T OTM€THTb, HTO KO/IHM€CTBO 1UI€HOB
IADTKOMOB, HO/IBGDTABIMXCHI MepaM B3bICKAHH5, Taloke yB€NIHMHIOCB Ha 36%
omnocutenbHo 1992 rona.
B napTHiioM CTOHT€/IbCTB€ 3a NOCUEAHHE TO/IbI OTM€H€H HOBPIÏT CJIBHT B
CB13H C TM, NTO B TCH€HH€ ỐOJIC€ WeECTHACCATHIIETHA CBO€TFO CYILCCTBOBAHHA Kcenennnue 1991 roja KIIB umena Bp cponx panax no 23% cocTaBa KOMMYHHCTOB -
N€NCHOHEPOB, BaXKHbIM BOIIDOCOM IIADTCTDOHT€JIbCTBA CTAHOBHTCA IIOIO/IH€HH€
COCTABA HADTHH 3a cueT MO/IOnC2SKH, C yexa6ps 1986 r no mionn 1991 roxa ỐbUIOHIpPHHITO B— HapTHO 303237 djneHOPB B TOM uncne 68 % H3 Colo3aKoMMYHHCTH1€CKOli MononexKH HMeHH XO llln Mnna Ilo cpanneHmo c 1991 r B
1992 rony KOMHUECTBO HOBBIX 1JI€HOB IApTHH BO3pOCIO Ha 3,2%, a B 1993 rony Ha30% no cpapHenwro c 1992 r
I.1.4 Opzauuzayuonuno-Kaopoeaa paboma
3anadH oOHOBNeHHA MH YVHODIIOHCHH3 /J€WT€IbHOCTH Haprnn B CPBPpacCMaTpHBalOTCA B TCCHOM CBaA3M C OpraHH3aWHOHHOH H KagpoBoli patoToH HnpobnemamMu = =Kagposoro OỐCCH€NCHHI TOCY/ADCTB€HIO-A3IMHHHCTDATHBHOTO
annapara, HCO O/bIUHHCTBO KAHNOBbIX pa6cTHHKOB, OCOỐ€HHO DYKOP(/UILIHX,
ABNAIOTCA KOMMYHHCTAMH.
6” Marepitanni VI cbeana KTIB -Tam xe -C 113
& i
? Jlokraa LK KIIB (6 c035154) o đADTCTDOHTC/ISCTHC, H BHCCCHHIT HONpaBok B Yctap HADTHH, TM ace -C.”,] 2
“ Hcpaaic pesyabrarh HO OƠHOBJICHHIO H ynoprnoucHino naprud /T(apTCTpOHICIbCIBO -Xanolt, 1994 -Ne7-C.7,8