Công tác bồi thường giải phóng mặt bằng khi nhà nước thu hồi đất trên địa bàn quận tây hồ, thành phố hà nội

truOma «ai hoc quoc dan i LJU THANH THUY dai hoc ktqd tt ti-iong tin thU vi en PHONG LUAN AN-TULIEU cOng tAc bAi thong giai phAng mat bang NHA NUfiC THU hOi bAt TflfiN BIA BAN QUAN TAY H& thAnh phO hA nOi Chuy&n ngdnfr Kinh t£ vd qudn ly dja chfnh LUAN VAN THAC SY KINH TE • • 77/S Ngtfdi htf&ng dan khoa hoc: PGS.TS HOANG VAN CUONG Ha - SOU MUC LUC • • DANH MUC CAC CHtT VIET TAT DANH MUC SO DO, BANG BIEU, HINH VE TOM TAT LU AN VAN LCflNOI DAU CHU*ONG 1: CO SO KHOA HOC CUA BOI THUONG GPMB KHI NHA NUOC THU HOI DAT 1.1 Tinh tat yeu cua cong tac boi thirdng GPMB 1.1.1 Cac khai niem 1.1.2 Sir can thiet cua cdng tac boi thirdmg GPMB 1.1.3 Yeu cau doi vd'i cdng tac boi thir&ng GPMB 1.1.4 Nhirngyeu to anh hircrng den cdng tac boi thucmg GPMB 1.1.4.1 Co che chinh sach BT GPMB va to chuc thirc hien 1.1.4.2 Dac diem kinh te xa hoi cua noi co dat bi thu hoi 10 1.1.4.3 Cdng tac quy hoach, ke hoach sur dung dat .11 1.1.4.4 Cdng tac cap giay chumg nhan quyen sur dung dat, thong ke, kiem ke dat dai 11 1.1.4.5 Cdng tac dinh gia dat va tai san tren dat de thurc hien BT GPMB 12 1.1.4.6 Trinh chuyen mon, nghiep vu cua luc lupng can bo lam cdng tac GPMB 12 1.1.4.7 Sir hop tac cua ngudi bi thu hoi dat 13 1.2 He thong phap ly cdng tac boi thircrng GPMB 13 1.2.1 Khai qudt he thong chinh sach Boi thirdmg GPMB triro'c Luqt dat dai 2003 .’ 13 1.2.2 He thong van ban phap ly lien quan den cdng tac BT GPMB tic sau Luqt ddt dai 2003 15 1.3 Trinh tu*, thu tuc to chuc thirc hien cdng tac boi thirdng, ho trp va tai dinh cur 17 1.4 Chinh sach Boi thircrng, ho trp va tai dinh cir 27 1.4.1 Quy dinh chung viec boi thucmg, ho trey ve dat 27 1.4.1.1 Dieu kien de dupe boi thudng ve dat 27 1.4.1.2 Nguyen tac boi thircrng ve dat 29 1.4.1.3 Nhtrng trudng hop thu hoi dat ma khong duoc boi thucmg 30 1.4.1.4 Gia lam co so tinh boi thudng, ho tro dat 31 1.4.2 Chinh sach boi thircrng, ho trey thu hoi dat nong nghiep 32 1.4.2.1 Boi thudng ve dat 32 1.4.2.2 Boi thuong chi phi hop ly dau tu vao datcon lai 33 1.4.2.3 Boi thuong doi vdi cay trong, vat nuoi 33 1.4.2.4 Boi thuong ve di chuyen mo ma 34 1.4.2.5 Ho tro doi voi dat nong nghiep khu dan cu va dat vuon, ao khong dupe cdng nhan la dat d 34 1.4.2.6 Ho tro on dinh ddi song va on dinh san xuat 35 1.4.2.7 Ho trp chuyen doi nghe nghiep va tao viec lam 36 1.4.2.8 Ho trp thu hoi dat cdng ich cua xa, phudng, thi tran 37 r r r > r r r •> Chinh sach bdi thuong, hd trff, tai dinh cir thu hoi dat ff 31 Boi thubng ve dat 37 Ho tro di chuyen 38 Ho tro nguroi dang thue nha khong thuoc so huu Nha nude 38 Chinh sach tai dinh cur 38 Boi thu’d’ng tai san tren dat 41 Nguyen tac boi thubng tai san 41 Boi thubng doi vbi nha, cong trinh xay dung tren dat 42 Boi thubng nha, cong trinh doi vbi ngubi dang su dung nha b thuoc sb huu Nha nubc 43 Chuoug 2: THUC TRANG CONG TAC BOI THUONG GPMB KHI NHA NUdC THU HOI DAT TREN DIA BAN QUAN TAY HO, HA NOI 44 2.1 Khai quat dac diem tir nhien, kinh te, xa hoi va tinh hinh sir dung dat quan Tay Ho 44 2.1.1 Dac diem tic nhien 44 2.1.2 Thirc trangpit at trien kinh te va dac diem xa hoi 45 2.1.3 Tinh hinh quy dat va hien trang sir dung dat tren dia ban quan Tay Hd 47 2.2 Khai quat ve ket qua cong tac BT GPMB tren dia ban quan thbi gian vira qua 51 2.3 Thurc trang cong tac Boi thuong GPMB tren dia ban quan Tay Ho 54 2.3.1 Trinh tir • thu tuc • va tien do• thirc • hien • BT GPMB cdc dir • an tren dia • ban quan 54 2.3.2 Thue trang BT, HT doi voi dat nong nghiep 59 2.3.2.1 Boi thubng, ho tro ve dat: 59 2.3.2.2 Bdi thubng di chuyen mo 62 2.3.2.3 Boi thubng, ho tro doi voi cay trong, vat nuoi 63 2.3.2.4 Ho tro on dinh dbi song va bn dinh san xuat 64 2.3.2.5 Ho tro chuyen dbi nghe nghiep va tao viec lam 64 2.3.2.6 Thubng tien ban giao mat bang 65 2.3.3 Thirc trang bdi thuffng, hd trff, tai dinh cir doi vd'i dat ff 65 2.3.3.1 Boi thubng, ho tro ve dat: 65 2.3.3.2 Ho tro di chuyen 69 2.3.3.3 Ho tro bn dinh dbi song 70 2.3.3.4 Ho tro gia dinh chinh sach, gia dinh dang hubng che tro cap xa hoi phai di chuyen cho b 71 2.3.3.5 Thubng tien ban giao mat bang 72 2.3.3.6 Tinh hinh thuc hien cong tac tai dinh cu 73 2.3.3.7 Hotrokhac 76 2.3.4 Tinh hinh thuc hien BT, HTddi vffi nha, cong trinh xay dirng tren dat .76 2.4 Danh gia chung ve cong tac Boi thuong GPMB tren dia banquan Tay Ho thoi gian vira qua 80 2.4.1 Nhirng thuan Iffi cong tac bdi thuong GPMB tren dia ban quan 80 1.4.3 1.4.3.1 1.4.3.2 1.4.3.3 1.4.3.4 1.4.4 1.4.4.1 1.4.4.2 1.4.4.3 NhChig van de bat cap, kho khan cdng tac Bdi thudng GPMB va nguyen nhan chuyeu 82 2.4.2.1 Ve nhan sir tham gia vao cong tac BT GPMB 82 2.4.2.2 Nhung bat cap cac chinh sach bdi thudng, ho tro 83 2.4.2.3 Cdng tac dieu tra, xac minh 85 2.4.2.4 Ve cong tac tai dinh cir 86 2.4.2.5 Y thuc cua ngudi dan bi thu hoi dat 87 Chtrong 3: MOT SO GIAI PHAP TRONG CONG TAC BOI TRUONG GPMB KHI NHA NLJOC THU HOI DAT TREN DIA BAN QUAN TAY HO, HA NOI 89 Phuong hird’ng, nhiem vu cong tac boi thudng GPMB thon 3.1 gian toi cua quan Tay Ho 89 3.1.1 Phuong hud'ng 89 3.1.2 Nhiem vu cu the 90 Cac quan diem cdng tac bdi thudng GPMB 91 3.2 3.2.1 Dua tren cu sa ket hop hai hoa lai ich cua cac ben 91 3.2.2 Dam bao khoiphuc lai mice song ban dau cho ngudi bi thu hoi dat 92 3.2.3 Bdi thudng GPMB can co su tuong ddi dong deu giira cac du an cung ph am vi dia phuong .93 3.2.4 Su tham gia dong gop y kien cua ngudi bi thu hoi dat va vai tro cua to chirc quan chung nhan dan va y kien cua ngudi dan cdng tac BT GPMB 93 Cac giai phap day nhanh cdng tac Bdi thudng GPMB tren dia ban quan 93 33 3.3.1 Nhom giaiphap ve cff che chinh sach BT GPMB 94 3.3.1.1 Kip thdi de xuat UBND Thanh phe duyet tang mure bdi thudng, ho trpr cho tirng du an cu the 94 3.3.1.2 Thuc hien tot chinh sach Tai dinh cu 3.3.1.3 Giai quyet viec lam cho ngudi bi thu hoi dat 96 3.3.2 Nhom giaiphap ve to chirc thuc hien cdng tac BT GPMB 97 33.2A Thuc hien cdng khai hoa, dan chu hoa cdng tac BT GPMB 97 3.3.2.2 Hoan thien he thong ho so dia chinh 98 3.3.2.3 Thuc hien tot cdng tac dieu tra, kiem dem hien trang 99 3.3.2.4 Cdng tac tuyen truyen van dong ngudi bi thu hoi dat va nang cao vai tro cua to chuc quan chung nhan dan cdng tac tuyen truyen van dong 99 3.3.2.5 Dao tao doi ngu can bo lam cdng tac BT GPMB 101 3.3.2.6 Kien toan Ban Bdi thudng GPMB quan va tang cudng su phoi hop giira cac lire luong cdng tac BT GPMB 102 3.4 Mot so kien nghi nham day nhanh cdng tac Bdi thudng GPMB tren dia ban quan 103 3.4.1 Kidn nghi ddi vdi UBND Thanh phd Ha Noi: 103 3.4.2 Kien nghi doi vdi Chinh ph u 104 KET LU AN 105 TAI LIEU THAM KHAO 107 2.4.2 r A ~ \ r A r A A Ar DANH MUC CAC CHI'’ VIET TAT TN • X • •> • Dien giai Chu viet tat GPMB Giai phong mat bang BT Boi thuong HT Ho trp TDC Tai dinh cu UBND Uy ban nhan dan x Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat -Giay chung nhan r GCNQSDD GCN QSD Quyen su dung DANH MUC SO DO, BANG BIEU, HINH VE So 1.1 Trinh tu thuc hien cong tac boi thuong GPMB 18 Bang 2.1: Thong ke, kiem ke dat dai quan Tay Ho den 01/01/2011 48 Bang 2.2 Thong ke, kiem ke dien tieh dat quan Tay Ho theo don vi hanh chinh den 01/01/2011 49 Bang 2.3 Tinh hinh GPMB tren dia ban quan Tay Ho 51 Bang 2.4: Ket qua thue hien cong tac BT GPMB so du an diem cua quan (Tinh den thang 5/2011) 53 Hinh 2.1 Ban quy hoach su dung dat quan Tay Ho 50 i Quan Tay Ho la mot quan nam d phi'a bac noi thu Ha Noi, dugc lap tir nam 1995 va dugc xac dinh la trung tarn dich vu - du lich - van hoa, vung co canh quan thien nhien cua Ha Noi Theo dinh hudng phat trien cua thu Ha Noi den nam 2020, toan bo quan Tay Ho thuoc khu vuc phat r y trien cua Thanh trung tarn, co dieu kien dac biet thuan lgi thu hut cac r y y 9 nguon luc von tai chinh, nguon nhan lire va khoa hgc cong nghe de thuc day nhanh sir phat trien kinh te - xa hoi cua quan noi rieng va cua Ha Noi noi chung Do quy dat Nha nude can phai thu hoi de thuc hien cac du an xay y yr dung tren dia ban quan Tay Ho nhung nam gan day va sap tdi dugc thirc hien vbi so lugng Ion, nhung phan Ion lai bi ach tac d khau boi thuong GPMB y r rv r r r y cho ngudi bi thu hoi dat dan den tien boi thuong GPMB mot so du an cham, keo dai Nguyen nhan chu yeu la chinh sach BT, HT, TDC cua Nha y \ r r nude cd nhieu diem chua hgp ly ap dung tren thuc te, ngudi bi thu hoi dat r y r thay minh chua dugc bdi thuong thoa dang, dac biet la doi vdi nhung ngudi y r y dan dien di ddi phai thay ddi nghe nghiep, dieu kien song, hoc tap, thay r y /• y doi tap quan va cac van de tarn ly, xa hoi khac Do vay de phan nao thay dugc y r birc tranh toan canh cua cong tac bdi thuong GPMB doi vdi cac du an Nha nude thu hoi dat tren dia ban quan Tay Hd thdi gian vira qua, tir de r r yr r y dugc nhung giai phap va kien nghi thiet thuc nham khac phuc cac van de ton tai, kho khan va vudng mac cong tac bdi thuong GPMB tren dia ban quan nham day nhanh dugc tien bdi thuong GPMB thdi gian tdi, toi y y y xin chgn de tai “Cong tac boi thirong giai phong mat bang Nha nude thu hoi dat tren dia ban quan Tay Ho, Ha Noi” lam de tai luan van cua minh r y r De lam ro dugc van de cua luan van, tdi phan bo cue cua luan van lam chuong, cu the nhu sau: CHLONG 1: CO sd LY LUAN CUA BOI THLONG GPMB KHI NHA MOC THU HOI DAT I Cac van de ly luan cong tac BT GPMB Cac khai niem: lam ro cac khai niem ve GPMB, thu hoi dat, BT Sy can thiet cua cong tac BT GPMB: khang dinh vai tro cua cong tac BT GPMB tren thuc te bdi doi vdi bat ky loai dat nao bi thu r \ /• y hoi cung tao nen nhung kho khan nhat dinh cho ngudi bi thu hoi dat vay cong tac BT GPMB la khong the thieu nham dam bao on dinh cuoc song cho ngudi dan, dam bao lai ich hop phap cua ngudi sur dung dat Cong tac BT r r \ GPMB neu dupe thuc hien tot se gop phan quan giup cho viec GPMB dupe thuc hien suon se, rat can thiet de xay dung cac cong trinh mdi dap ung nhu cau doi mdi cua xa hoi; nham su dung dat dai hpp ly va hieu qua hom Yeu cau doi vdi cong tac BT GPMB: - Phai thuc hien theo dung cac quy dinh cua Nha nude: tu va Nha nude r r r - Dam bao tien thuc hien nhanh chong, chinh xac so lieu thong ke dat dai va tai san tren dat nham dam bao quyen lpi cho ngudi bi thu hoi dat - Dam bao dupe tinh dan chu, tao dieu kien cho ngudi dan phat huy quyen lam chu cua minh; cong khai qua trinh thuc hien va thuc hien Nhirng yeu to anh huong den cong tac BT GPMB: r - Co che chinh sach, cac van ban quy pham phap luat linh vuc BT GPMB co anh hudng ldn nhat; can phai co su thay doi timg giai doan r de phu hop vdi thuc te - Dac diem kinh te, xa hoi, trinh dan tri cua tung dia phucmg khac nen cong tac BT thiet hai GPMB cung co nhung dac trung rieng d tung noi - Cong tac quy hoach, ke hoach su dung dat la la phuong tien quan A A gop phan dam bao cdng bang, dan chu, van minh cdng tac BT GPMB r r Bat ky phuong an BT GPMB nao cung phai dua tren mot quy hoach va ke r •> r r a a hoach su dung dat de dat dupe cac yeu cau ve hieu qua kinh te xa hoi cao nhat r r r a - Cdng tac cap Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat la can cu phap ly r \ quan de tien hanh viec BT GPMB, tao dieu kien thuan lpi, nhanh chong cho viec lap phuong an bdi thudng, ho tro va tai dinh cu; tranh dupe nhung r r r r \ khieu kien tranh chap lien quan den khu dat bi thu hoi - Cdng tac dinh gia dat va tai san tren dat neu sat vdi gia thuc te tren thi r > a trudng se nhan dupe su dong tinh, ung ho cao cua ngudi bi thu hoi dat - Trinh chuyen mon, nghiep vu cua luc lupng can bo lam cdng tac GPMB a a r - Su hop tac, dong thuan cua ngudi bi thu hoi dat II Khai quat he thong phap ly cong tac BT GPMB: - Hien phap nam 1980 va Luat dat dai nam 1988 quy dinh dat dai thuoc so huu toan dan, vay khong dupe BT ve dat GPMB ma chi dupe BT trudng hop ngudi bi thu hoi dat can cd dat de su dung thi dupe cap dat r r i khac Sau Luat dat dai 1993 ddi da danh dau su thay ddi ldn chinh a y r ' sach thu hoi dat va BT GPMB, da quy dinh trudng Nha nude thu hoi dat r r dang su dung cua ngudi su dung dat de su dung vao muc dich quoc phong, an ninh, lpi ich quoc gia, lpi ich cdng cong thi ngudi bi thu hoi dat dupe den bu thiet hai r A Sau Luat dat dai 1993, Nha nude da ban hanh nhieu van ban dudi Luat > a r •> * de thu hoi dat va bdi thubng thiet hai Tuy nhien vdi su phat trien va thay doi r r a a nhanh chong cua dat nude, da phat sinh nhieu van de qua trinh GPMB •> r ma nhung quy dinh cua phap luat hien hanh khong the giai quyet dupe - Luat dat dai 2003 dbi va cac van ban dubi Luat dupe ban hanh da r r dua dupe nhung chinh sach thoa dang, khac phuc dupe nhung han che va r cang phu hop hon ap dung vao thuc te cua nude ta Da cd nhieu van ban dudi luat de bo sung hoan thien cho cong tac BT GPMB nhu Nghi dinh 197/2004/ND-CP 03/12/2004; Nghi dinh 84/2007/ND-CP 25/5/2007; Nghi dinh 69/2009/ND-CP 13/8/2009 cua Chinh phu III Trinh tur, thu tuc to chirc thuc hien cong tac boi thubng, ho trp va tai dinh cu: dupe quy dinh tai Dieu 29, 30, 31 cua Nghi dinh 69/2009/ND-CP; ddi vdi cong tac BT GPMB tai Thanh Ha Noi dupe quy dinh chi tiet, cu the tai chuong VI Quyet dinh 108/2009/QD-UBND gom cac A budc sau, moi budc cd quy dinh cu the ve thbi gian va thu tuc thuc hien: - Thong bao thu hoi dat - Thanh lap Hoi dong BT, HT va TDC; lap To cong tac r r r ' - Lap, phe duyet ke hoach tien chi tiet giai phong mat bang -Tham tra du toan chi phi to chuc thuc hien cong tac bdi thubng, ho trp va tai dinh cu - Ngubi co dat bi thu hoi thuc hien ke khai hien trang nha dat - To chuc dieu tra hien trang, xac minh noi dung ke khai r a ~ - Lap phuong an chi tiet bdi thubng, ho trp va tai dinh cu - Niem yet cong khai, lay y kien ve phuong an BT, HT, TDC va quy che bat tham can ho, lb dat tai dinh cu - Hoan chinh va tham dinh phuong an chi tiet BT, HT, TDC - Quyet dinh thu hoi dat 98 r r bo chu chot cua UBND Thanh cung dai dien cac So ban nganh co lien quan nhu So Tai nguyen va mdi truong, Sd tai chinh, Sd xay dung, Sd quy r r \ •> hoach kien true, Sd ke hoach dau tu cung tham gia budi hop dan de /■ ' r •• A r lang nghe va giai dap moi thac mac cua dan, neu phai dieu chinh bo sung se de dang duoc thong qua hon de xuat len UBND Thanh (vi da cd A dupc su dong thuan cua cac Sd ban nganh) Nen bo sung them phan Thanh tra quan vao Hoi dong BT, HT, TDC va To cdng tac de giai quyet cac don kien nghi cua ngudi dan dong thdi dam bao cdng tac BT GPMB dien theo dung quy dinh cua phap luat 3.3.2.2 Hoan thien he thong ho so dia chinh Thuc tien cdng tac BT GPMB cho thay ho so dia chinh dong vai trd e r e a a quan trong viec xac dinh dat cd du dieu kien hay khong du dieu kien dupc BT Nhieu trudng hpp cac ho dan thieu GCNQSD dat, viec dac lai Ar tao su chenh lech ve dien tich nen da gay nhieu tranh cai, khong nhat tri a Ar cua cac ho dan hoac cung cd cac trudng hpp ho so dia chinh thieu gay kho r r r a khan viec xac dinh nguon goc dat, thdi gian su dung dat r a r a Vi vay can nhanh chong thiet lap va hoan thien he thong ho so dia chinh mot each day du, chinh xac bang each day nhanh viec hoan cap A GCNQSDD Day la co sd quan dam bao quyen lpi cua ngudi dan bi - - x r r r r r thu hdi dat; cung cap sd lieu chinh xac, ngan chan dupc tinh trang lan chiem r e r r r dat trai phep gay khieu kien phuc tap Thuc te tinh trang cap GCN cua quan cham so vdi yeu cau dat ma nguyen nhan chinh la mot sd ho gia r Ar r dinh su dung dat ong cha de lai, thua ke da trai qua nhieu the he nhung a a r r r khong cd nhu cau ve chuyen nhupng, mua ban, the chap vay xuat hien tu tuong khong can cap GCN 99 X x a a Ngoai can thuong xuyen theo doi chinh ly bien dong kip thcri ve dat dai tren thuc te Viec luu tru, bao quan ho so dia chinh qua cac thoi ky cung r r x r \ la van de quan trong, tranh that lac, mat mat ve sau 3.3.2.3 Thuc hien tot cong tac dieu tra, kiem dem hien trang Day la cong viec can duoc coi hang dau, la tien de cho viec trien khai cac cong viec tiep theo cua cong tac BT GPMB Viec lap ho so kiem dem dien tich dat dai, tai san, hien trang cong trinh, cay coi hoa mau phai trung thuc; can cu vao ket qua dac cu the, chi tiet co doi chieu vdi so r •> ax r x thua dat, ho so dia chinh, so bo thue, ho so giao ruong, giay chung nhan QSD A X dat va su xac nhan cua chinh quyen dia phuong # X AX X Cong tac dieu tra hien trang ban dau la cong viec chiem nhieu thoi gian nhat va cung kho khan nhat cong tac BT GPMB; neu dupe thuc hien ti mi, chinh xac se giup cho cac giai doan sau dupe thuc hien thuan lpi, rd rang; phuong an BT, HT, TDC lap it phai sua doi dieu chinh gay mat thoi gian X A A Muon vay dpi ngu to cong tac lam nhiem vu dieu tra, kiem dem phai dupe dao tao chuyen sau, co trinh chuyen mon vung vang, dong thdi phai cd trach nhiem vdi cong viec dupe giao Trudc dieu tra hien trang phai tiep X A X X can vdi ho dan dien thu hoi dat de tao niem tin, dong thdi qua A X A A A trinh dieu tra phai cong khai ket qua thu thap dupe va ddi chieu vdi ket qua ke khai cua dan vdi su chung kien cua ho Ket qua dieu tra dupe phan anh trung A A A A A thuc se giam thieu cac yeu to tieu cue phat sinh, cac khieu kien thac mac nhan dan X X A 3.3.2.4 Cong tac tuyen truyen van dong ngudi bi thu hoi dat va nang cao vai tro cua to chuc quan chung nhan dan cong tac tuyen truyen van dong X A A - Thudng xuyen td chuc tuyen truyen van dong nhan dan, bien che do, chinh sach hd trp bdi thudng va tai dinh cu; tang cudng thuc hien quy che 100 dan chu d ca sd, phat huy quyen lam chu cua nhan dan, dau tranh vai cac bieu hien tieu cue, quan diem sai trai cong tac boi thuong, GPMB; xay dung cac phong trao thi dua tim hieu chinh sach, phap luat lien quan den dat dai, chinh sach ho tra, boi thuong, tai dinh cu x x - Phat huy vai trd cua cac Hoi cdng tac tuyen truyen van dong quan chung nhan dan nhu: Mat tran To quoc, Hoi cuu chien binh, Hoi phu nu, Hoi nong dan, Hoi nguoi cao tuoi Day ia luc luong cd nhieu bien phap tich cue, cung nhu co tieng noi nhan dan, co hieu qua tham gia tuyen truyen van dong cac chu truong, chinh sach BT GPMB tdi ngudi su dung dat Nen dua vien cua cac Hoi true tiep tham gia cac to cdng tac GPMB d cap co sd z z r r - Phoi hop tot giua cac nganh, khoi dan van tu quan den phudng X z cdng tac tuyen truyen van dong nhan dan chap hanh chu truong chinh sach cua Nha nudc ve bdi thudng GPMB z - Tang cudng phoi hop vdi co quan bao, dai d Trung uong va dia XX X phuong de tuyen truyen chinh sach, dang tai kip thdi thong tin ve du an, ve cdng tac BT GPMB Can quan triet tu tudng ung ho cac du an GPMB tren cac phuong tien Z phat cua phudng, td dan pho, khu dan cu; tranh hien tupng dang tai z z nhung vu khieu kien cua ngudi dan, nhung bat cap cdng tac BT GPMB vi nhu vay se de tao nen tac dong tieu cue ddi vdi viec thu hdi dat X Thanh lap cac td tuyen truyen van dong, thong tin hang tren he Z X Z X thong loa cua phudng ve tien nhan tien BT, HT, thuc hien ban giao mat 101 bang; bieu duong cac ho guong mau chap hanh; nhac nho cac ho cham tre, vi r r n* pham, ke ca cac doi tuong la can bo, Dang vien thieu guong mau 3.3.2.5 Dao tao doi ngu can bo lam cong tac BT GPMB Coi cong tac dao tao, boi duong nang cao nang luc, trinh chuyen mon; trach nhiem, pham chat dao due cua doi ngu can bo lam cong tac BT GPMB r •> r UBND quan phai co chu truong tang cudng tap huan, bien nghiep ' _ vu ve cdng tac bdi thudng GPMB cho cac vien Ban Bdi thudng GPMB, cac to cdng tac cung nhu nhung can bo cac phong ban chuc nang cd lien quan den cdng tac GPMB Dac biet UBND phudng can cd ke hoach cur can bo lam cdng tac quan ly dat dai di hoc tap huan thudng xuyen Viec tap huan se giup lam ro va thong nhat each hieu cac van ban, chinh sach, phap luat cua Nha nude lien quan den cdng tac BT GPMB, dong thdi giup moi r o r ngudi chia se kinh nghiem giai quyet cac tinh huong kho khan co the sinh qua trinh thuc hien Ngoai UBND quan nen de nhung quy dinh cu the ve che khen •> r thudng phu hop de khuyen khfch dong vien y thuc trach nhiem cua ngudi can bo Dong thdi cung phai co nhung quy dinh nghiem khac de xu ly nhung trudng hop can bo cdng chuc lpi dung quyen han, chuc vu, lpi dung nhung ke ho cua chinh sach va phap luat de muu loi rieng; hoac nhung trudng hpp can r a bo thieu y thuc trach nhiem, y lai lam thiet hai cdng sue tien cua cua Nha nude va nhan dan viec thuc hien cdng tac BT GPMB Su am hieu phap luat, each giai quyet nhanh gon cung vdi su cam r thong, ton lpi ich cua ngudi dan, thau hieu dupc tam ly va nguyen vong cua ngudi dan thuc thi cdng vu cua can bo, cdng chuc se dong vai trd rat 102 quan trong viec tao dung su hop tac cua nhan dan vung du an nham tranh cac phan ung tieu cue lay lan gay bat lpi cho tien BT GPMB e r a 3.3.2.6 Kien toan Ban Boi thudng GPMB quan va tang cuong su phoi hop giua cac luc lupng cong tac BT GPMB _ a r a Ban Bdi thudng GPMB quan la co quan dau moi chuyen mon giup A rv A •> UBND quan ve cdng tac bdi thudng, ho trp va tai dinh cu Viec kien toan td r r a x r chuc Ban BT GPMB la rat can thiet bdi co quan dong vai trd nhu cau noi trung gian ho trp thuc hien cac khau, cdng doan cdng tac BT GPMB Hoi dong BT, HT va TDC quan va Td cdng tac chi dupe lap sau r r \ dupe UBND Thanh chap thuan chu truong dau tu du an va se giai tan sau < r r cdng tac BT GPMB ket thuc, trudng hop xay khieu nai td cao sau ve cdng tac BT GPMB thi viec tham muu cua Hoi dong GPMB cho UBND r r r a r quan giai quyet se rat han che nen vai trd cua Ban Bdi thudng luc la rat can thiet viec tham muu, giup dd UBND quan tiep nhan va giai quyet don cua ngudi dan Hien quan sd Ban BT GPMB quan Tay Ho co 15 ngudi sd can bo true tiep lam cdng tac GPMB la 10 ngudi vdi sd lupng du an GPMB thuc hien tren dia ban quan nhieu, trung binh moi ngudi phai dam nhiem cung luc 7-8 du an Sd lupng cdng viec phai dam nhan qua nhieu nen ddi khong tranh khoi su cham tre viec thuc hien cac nhiem vu dupe giao Vi vay UBND quan can phai kien toan ca ve td chuc cung nhu trinh chuyen mon A nghiep vu cua Ban Bdi thudng GPMB A _ A Ngoai ve cdng tac td chuc thuc hien UBND quan chi dao Ban Bdi thudng GPMB chu dong phoi hop vdi cac phong ban chuyen mon tap trung 100% nhan luc, td chuc lam viec them gid (ngay nghi, le, tet) de dam bao tien cdng viec Dong thdi UBND quan cung phai thudng xuyen chi dao cac 103 A phong Ban chuc nang, Ban Boi thuong GPMB, UBND cac phuong va chu r A dau tu co su phoi hop chat che, luon tich cue va chu dong hoan cong ' , , A viec ddi vdi nhiem vu thuoc trach nhiem cua don vi, gop phan hoan nhiem vu chung 3.4 Mot so kien nghi nham day nhanh cong tac Bdi thuong GPMB tren dia ban quan Qua nghien cuu thuc trang cong tac BT GPMB cua quan Tay Ho, thay Z A z A dupe nhung van de ton tai, vuong mac, kho khan cua cong tac trien khai thuc hien, tdi xin de xuat kien nghi mot sd van de nham dua cong tac BT GPMB dien thuan lpi, phu hpp vdi thuc te, vua dam bao yeu cau phat trien Z A kinh te vua dam bao yeu cau phat trien xa hoi: 3.4.1 Kien nghi ddi vdi UBND Thanh Hd Noi: - Xay dung bang gia dat d hang nam sat hon vdi thi trudng, tang don r a gia bdi thudng dat nong nghiep A - Quy dinh lap them Hoi dong tham dinh gia cho tirng du an thu hoi dat r a - Xay dung khu tai dinh cu tap trung dam bao ve chat luong cong trinh, A A A day du tang ky thuat va tang xa hoi - Sua doi, bo sung mot sd chinh sach BT GPMB: z ' r + Doi vdi nhung trudng hpp bi thu hoi dat d tai vi tri ngoai bdi AZ thudng ve dat nen tang muc hd trp cho ho bdi nhung ngudi d vi tri cd thu nhap ldn nhd vao viec cho thue hoac md cua hang kinh doanh hon nhieu so vdi dat d vi tri lai A A AZ + Quy dinh cu the, rd rang hon ve viec dao tao nghe, hudng nghe va bo AZ Z tri viec lam cho ngudi bi thu hoi dat nong nghiep, dua chu truong la bat Z AZ buoc doi vdi cac du an thu hoi dat 104 + Khi xem xet bo tri TDC ngoai tieu chuan ve dien tich dat, so nhan r x khau, can tinh den dien tich san xay dung + Nen sua doi quy dinh thu hdi dat, chi nhung ngudi dan an d tai noi GPMB va khong co cho d khac mdi duoc bo tri TDC bdi hien co nhieu r r gia dinh co nha mat chap nhan di thue cho d khac de cho thue cua hang r x nham co them thu nhap cai thien ddi song 3.4.2 Kien nghi doi vdi Chinh phu Can sua ddi Nghi dinh 188/2004/ND-CP 16/11/2004 cua Chinh r r x phu ve phuong phap xac dinh gia dat va khung gia cac loai dat va Nghi dinh 123/2007/ND-CP 27/7/2007 cua Chinh phu sura doi bd sung, mot sd dieu cua Nghi dinh 188/2004/ND-CP Theo khong nen quy dinh khung gia dat r r ' r toi da va toi thieu ma chi nen quy dinh phuong phap dinh gia dat, UBND cap tinh se dua tren cac phuong phap dinh gia ma xay dung bang gia dat cua r dia phuong Nhu vay mdi co the dam bao bang gia dat hang nam cua UBND r r cap tinh cdng bd sat vdi gia thi trudng, tranh dupc tinh trang gia dang xay hien 105 KET LUAN Cong tac BT GPMB Nha nuoc thu hoi dat thuc hien cac du an dau r r \ tu xay dung la cong tac het sue nhay cam, phuc tap, lien quan den quyen va loi ich cua nhieu ddi tuong khac nhau, phai co sir phoi hop thirc hien cua r _ x va Thanh Ha Noi noi chung cong tac BT GPMB dang gap phai nhieu kho r r r x khan, vuong mac sir khong hop tac, chong ddi tir phfa ngudi dan bi thu hoi dat Nguyen nhan chu yeu la chinh sach BT, HT, TDC cua Nha nudc cd e x < r x r nhieu diem chua hop ly ap dung tren thuc te, ngudi bi thu hoi dat thay minh chua duoc bdi thudng thoa dang, dac biet la doi vdi nhung ngudi dan dien di ddi phai thay doi nghe nghiep, dieu kien song, hoc tap, thay doi r x tap quan va cac van de tarn ly, xa hoi khac r x _ Cac kien nghi cong tac BT GPMB tir phia ngudi dan phan lon tap x x r trung d viec doi tang muc bdi thudng ve dat, tang cac muc hd tro, noi long kien hon cho ngudi dan viec bo tri tai dinh cu; doi vdi cac du an gap nhieu kho khan UBND quan da chu dong lap cac td cong tac tuyen X truyen, van dong ngudi dan Vi vay thdi gian vira qua cong tac BT GPMB quan Tay Hd da dat r r r duoc nhung ket qua nhat dinh, dac biet da hoan mot sd du an diem chao mirng ky niem 1000 nam Thang Long Ha Noi Tuy nhien ben canh tai hau het cac du an BT GPMB tren dia ban quan trien khai van khong • • r • r r r tranh khoi nhung kien nghi, chong doi, bat hop tac tir phia ngudi dan dac biet doi vdi nhung ho bi thu hoi dat d Cong tac BT GPMB van chua duoc thuc 106 xay dung nua De lam duoc nhu vay cong tac BT GPMB ddi hdi phai co tinh than trach nhiem, su dong cam, linh hoat, nhay ben d nhung ngudi thuc hien; phai co su van dung tong hop tir chu truong, co che, chinh sach cua Dang, Nha nudc, Thanh den tinh hinh thuc tien cua tung dia phuong, tinh chat x / x cua tung du an; dong thdi khong the thieu tinh than trach nhiem, nang luc, trinh do, kinh nghiem, ban linh va y thuc trach nhiem cao truoc nhan dan cua nhung ngudi true tiep xu ly cdng viec, dac biet ngudi can bo phai co tarn va dao due nghe nghiep 107 TAI LIEU THAM KHAO • Ban Boi thudng GPMB quan Tay Ho (2011), Bao cao tien thuc hien du an xay dung dudng vanh dai II, Ha Noi Ban Boi thudng GPMB quan Tay Ho (2011), Bao cao cdng tac GPMB r y thuc hien du an xay dung tuyen dudng Van Cao - Ho Tay, Ha Noi Ban Bdi thudng GPMB quan Tay Ho (2011), Bao cao ve tinh hinh thuc hien cdng tac GPMB du an xay dung cau Nhat Tan, Ha Noi Ban Bdi thudng GPMB quan Tay Ho (2011), Bao cao tinh hinh trien khai thuc hien du an xay dung khu Tai dinh cu Xuan La phuc vu xay dung khu thi mdi Tay Ho Tay, Ha Noi Bo Tai chinh va Bo Tai nguyen & Mdi trudng (2008), Thong tu lien tich sd 14/2008/TTLB-BTC-BTNMT 31/01/2008 huong dan thuc hien mot sd dieu cua Nghi dinh sd 84/2007/ND-CP Bo Tai nguyen va mdi trudng (2009), Thong tu 14/2009/TT-BTNMT 01/10/2009 quy dinh chi tiet ve bdi thudng, ho tret, tai dinh cu va r r yr trinh tu, thu tuc thu hdi dat, giao dat, cho thue dat Chinh phu (1998), Nghi dinh 22/1998/ND-CP 24/4/1998 ve viec > a r r den bit thiet hai Nha nude thu hdi dat de su dung vao muc dich quoc phong, an ninh, leti ich quoc gia, lai ich cdng cong Chinh phu (2004), Nghi dinh 197/2004/ND-CP 03/12/2004 quy A A AZ dinh ve bdi thudng, ho tra va tai dinh cu Nha nude thu hdi dat Chinh phu (2007), Nghi dinh 84/2007/ND-CP 25/5/2007 quy dinh y r r y r bd sung ve viec cap GCNQSD dat, thu hdi dat, trinh tu thu tuc BT, HT va TDC 10 Chinh phu (2009), Nghi dinh 69/2009/ND-CP 13/8/2009 quy dinh - ? a r r y r bd sung ve quy hoach su dung dat, gid dat, thu hdi dat, BT, HT va TDC 108 11 UBND Thanh ph6 Ha Noi (2009), Quydt dinh sd 108/2009/QD- UBND A A ~ 29/9/2009 quy dinh ve boi thudng, ho tra vd tdi dinh cu Nha r \ r nudc thu hdi dat tren dia ban Ha Noi 12 UBND Thanh Ha Noi (2010), Quydt dinh so 02/2010/QD- UBND \ a r r 18/01/2010 cua ban hanh quy dinh ve thu hdi dat, giao dat, cho r r 9 a thue dat, chuyen muc dich sic dung dat de thuc hien du an dau tu vd lam nha a nong thon tai diem dan cu nong thon tren dia ban Ha Noi r a 13 UBND quan Tay Ho (2011), Bao cao ket qua thuc hien cdng tac gidi r a a phong mat bang cac du an nam 2010, ke hoach gidi phong mat bang nam 2011, Ha Noi 14 UBND quan Tay Ho (2011), Bao cao thong ke kiem ke dat dai quan Tay Ho nam 2011, Ha Noi 15 r a UBND quan Tay Ho (2011), Bao tong ket phong trao thi dua 15 nam _ \ cua quan Tay Ho, Ha Noi r a 16 UBND quan Tay Ho (2011), Bao cao ket qua thuc hien cdng tac giai A phong mat bang cac du an diem, Ha Noi 17 So tai chinh (2009), Thong bao so 6838/STC-BT GPMB 31/12/2009 don gid bdi thudng, ho tra GPMB cac loai cay, hoa mau tren dia ban Thanh Ha Noi nam 2010 18 Webquyhoachthudo.com 19 Web dangcongsan.vn: bao dien tur Dang cong san Viet Nam Phu luc DANH MUC CAC CONG TRINH, DU* AN TRONG KE HOACH SU DUNG DAT QUAN TAY HO GIAI DOAN 2011-2015 ST T HANG MUC 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Duong vanh dai II Dudng Xuan Dieu Dudng Dang Thai Mai Tram dien 220KV Muong Thuy Khue - Buoi Tuyen dudng sat thi so True 6-6 THT (1.050mx30m) song song Nguyen Van Huyen va VD2 True 7A-7A (500m x 25m) Dudng noi bo 10-10 (1.220x15m) Tuyen TT di bo 8-8 (1.250x23.5m) Tuyen TT di bo 8-8 (710x23.5m) Tuyen TT di bo 9-9 (355x21.5m) tuyen true 5-5 (2.400x40m) Dudng noi bo 10-10 (1250x15m) Dudng noi bo 10-10 (525x15m) Duong Nguyen Van Huyen noi dai Dudng noi Nguyen Van Huyen noi dai voi vanh dai (275x64m) Cong hoa muong Xuan La Ngo 23 Xuan La Ngo 23/12 Xuan La Ngo 77 Xuan La Ngo 77/47 Xuan La Ngo 445/46-23/36 Xuan La Dudng to 5A, 5B Ngo 569 Lac Long Quan Ngo 38 Xuan La Ma rong dudng Nguyen Hoang Ton Ngo 45 Vong Thi Ngo 596 Hoang Hoa Tham Ngo 282 Lac Long Quan Dudng true Phu Thuong 32 33 34 35 Dudng BT-TN to 45 cum Bai xe (Cty SX Bao Bi) Ngo 67 To Ngoc Van Dudng Td Ngoc Van 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 DIEN TICH (ha) 19,20 3,00 4,00 0,2 2,5 DIA DIEM 3,15 XLa, PThuong Quang An Quang An Phu Thuong TKhue, Buoi Ngam Tay Ho Tay Trung tarn THT 1,25 1,82 2,94 1,66 0,75 9,6 1,87 0,79 3,62 1,76 Trung tarn THT Trung tarn THT Khu TTTC, Xuan La Khu TTTC, Xuan La Khu TTTC, Xuan La Khu TTTC Xuan La Ngoai trung tarn THT Ngoai trung tarn THT Xuan La Xuan La 0,12 0,1 0,1 0,12 0,25 0,09 0,27 0,07 0,43 1,00 0,35 0,17 0,15 1,9 Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Buoi Bucri Buoi Phu Thuong 0,6 0,43 1,5 1,05 Phu Thuong Phu Thuong Quang An Quang An GHI CHU 2015 2015 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 13x2 000m 2012 2015 2011 2011 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 Ngo 124 Au Ca Ngo 310 Nghi Tam Ngo 72 Thuy Khue Ngo 123 A Thuy Khue Nha van hoa P.Tu Lien Nha sinh hoat cum Nha sinh hoat cum Nha sinh hoat to 34 cum 10 Nha sinh hoat to 30 Nha sinh hoat to 21 Nha sinh hoat to 19 Nha sinh hoat to 18 Nha sinh hoat, san chai to 7+9 Vuon hoa, cong trinh VH di bo Nha sinh hoat KDC 1B Nha sinh hoat KDC 4B Nha sinh hoat KDC 5B Nha sinh hoat P Xuan La Khu van hoa ho Dong Tam Khu van hoa ao An Thanh Nha sinh hoat cum 1A Cong trinh VH cong cong to 23 cum Xay dung moi truong THPT Ma rong truong mam non P Thuong Truong tieu hoc Tu Lien Truong THCS Tu lien Truong mam non cum Mo rong truong Mam non Quang An Truong mam non THT Truong THCS khu TTTM THT Trudng mam non khu TTTM THT Trudng THCS (phan ldn lai thuoc Xuan Dinh) Trudng mam non(sau UBND quan) Mo rong trudng tieu hoc Xuan La Trudng mam non An Duong Trudng tieu hoc Nhat Tan GDH Benh vien Khu mdi Tram y te Tu lien Cdng vien TDTT (khu cho) Cdng vien cay xanh phia dong dudng Lac Long Quan Cdng vien cay xanh truoc nha khach Thanh Vuon hoa cay canh khu T79 va trudng dao tao lai xe Dat cay xanh noi bo khu TTTM Dat cay xanh noi bo khu TTTC 1,07 0,9 0,14 0,2 0,2 0,18 0,14 0,03 0,09 0,03 0,09 0,02 0,15 6,54 0,02 0,02 0,01 0,3 0,51 0,35 0,01 0,01 1,0 0,3 0,7 0,6 0,6 0,3 0,5 1,94 0,39 0,38 0,30 0,30 0,50 0,40 9,00 0,23 0,98 2,1 Tu Lien Quang An Thuy Khue Thuy Khue Tu lien Tu lien Tu lien Quang an Quang an Quang an Quang an Quang an Quang an TTTC THT Xuan La Xuan la Xuan la Xuan la Xuan la Yen phu Yen phu Nhat tan Nhat tan Phu thuong Phu thuong Tu lien Tu lien Tu lien Quang an KDT THT Xuan la KDT THT Xuan La KDT THT Xuan La KDT THT Xuan La Xuan La Xuan La Yen Phu Nhat Tan Phu Thuong Tu lien Phu thuong Nhat tan 3,5 0,49 Nhat tan Xuan la 1,1 TTTM THT Xuan la TTTC THT Xuan la 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2013 2011 2011 2011 2011 2012 2014 2011 2011 2015 2012 2011 2011 2011 2012 2013 2013 2013 2015 2015 2015 2012 2015 2015 2011 2014 2015 2015 2013 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 ' - -Cong vien ho Dam tri San chai tre em to 26 Khu vui chai giai tri, bai xe dac 12 San TDTT giai tri Dat ca quan hon hop Dat tru sd Khu tru sa ven vanh dai Khu tru sa ven dudng Nguyen Hoang Ton Tru sd dai su quan My Dat van phong- TTTM ngoai khu trung tam Dat van phong - TTTM khu TTTC Dat thuong mai khu TTTC Kho tang (Cty SX Bao Bi) Khu cong vien cay xanh, to chuc su kien va am thuc Van phong cho thue ket hop khach san Dat d xen ket Dat d biet thu khu trung tam THT Dat d chung cu cao tang khu trung tam THT Dat d ven KDT mdi THT Dat d cai tao khu dan cu cu (l,68ha ben trai dudng Nguyen Van Huyen) Dat d ven KDT mai THT (giap N^hTa do) Dat d ven KDT mdi THT (phia Bae) Dat d ven dudng vanh dai (sau UBND quan) Dat d ven dudng vanh dai (sau trudng tieu hoc) Dat dau gia to 29 cum Dat dau gia to 37 cum Dat dau gia to 35 cum Quang Ba Khach san ket hap van phong va nha d Md rong cho Nhat Tan Ha tang vung dao Phu Thuong Cac du an xay dung HTKT phuc vu dau gia quyen su dung dat Trudng mam non Trudng THCS tu thuc Chia khoa vang Nha may xu ly nude thai ho tay Trung tam giao dich cdng nghe thudng xuyen Khach san Trang An Khach san va can ho cao cap cho thue Ho Tay view Khu TDC phudng xuan la phuc vu KDT mdi THT To hap cdng trinh VP, dich vu va can ho cao cap Thuy khue HI-END Residece Giao thong tinh Cong: 3,45 0,03 3,03 0,4 4,14 0,3 0,3 1,2 8,4 1,44 0,38 1,82 0,18 0,4 4,52 6,88 2,4 0,36 Quang an Quang an Tu lien Yen phu Khu DTM THT Khu DTM THT Khu DTM THT Xuan la Phu thuong Khu DTM THT Khu DTM THT Khu DTM THT Phu thuong Xom mau Quang An Thuy khue Phu thuong Khu DTM THT Khu DTM THT Khu DTM THT Khu DTM THT 2012 2011 2011 2011 2013 2015 2015 2015 2013 2013 2015 2015 2012 2011 2011 2012 2012 2012 0,9 0,56 0,65 1,22 0,03 0,02 0,14 0,67 0,25 7,7 1,04 Khu DTM THT Xuan la Xuan la Xuan la Xuan la Xuan la Quang an Quang an Nhat tan Phu thuong Cac phudng 2012 2012 2014 0,3 0,5 1,6 0,73 0,06 3,2 3,5 0,27 1,52 7,34 184,26 Nhat tan Quang an Quang an 2015 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 Quang an Xuan la Thuy khue Thuy khue PT, XL, NT, QA, TK Nguon: Bao cao UBND Quan Tay Ho 2011 2013 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 Phu luc DANH MUC CAC CONG TRINH, DU* AN TRONG KE HOACH SU* DUNG DAT QUAN TAY HO GIAI DOAN 2016-2020 STT HANG MUC DIEN TICH DIA DIEM GHI CHU (ha) Duong de boi bai song Hong Tuyen duong sat thi so Dudng dan cau Tu Lien 6,25 Tu lien 2016-2020 Du an ke cac ho nhd ven Ho Tay Quang an 2016-2020 Vubn hoa, cong trinh van hoa di 3,55 bo TTTC THT Xuan la 2016-2020 Trubng day nghe Phu thuong 2016-2020 Truong THPT KDT THT 1,05 KDT THT xuan la 2016-2020 Dat cay xanh each ly duong Nguyen Van Huyen keo dai 1,4 Khu THT xuan la 2016-2020 Dat cay xanh noi bo khu TTTC 0,5 TTTC THT xuan la 2016-2020 10 Dat van phong - TTTM 3,5 Khu DTM THT 2016-2020 11 Dat thuong mai khu TTTC 24,19 Khu DTM THT 2016-2020 12 Kho tang (khu Cho) 0,6 Phu thuong 2016-2020 13 Dat cong trinh TMDV 2,22 Phu thuong 2016-2020 14 Dat DVTM TT khu d (khu trudng 0,8 THPT) Phu thuong 2016-2020 15 Khu ky thuat XLNT Ciputra Phu thuong 2016-2020 16 Cac cong trinh tang khu du lich Hd tay va phu can QA, YP, TL, NT, TK, XL, B 17 Ha tang khu du lich ven song Hong Cac phubng Cong 16,2 PT, NT, TL, QA, YP 2016-2020 Ngam Tay Ho Tay 69,26 Ngudn: Bao cao UBND Quan Tay Ho 2011