Nghiên cứu công nghệ bê tông in 3d dùng cho công trình xây dựng

ỦY BAN NHÂN DÂN THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH SỞ KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ ĐẠI HỌC QUỐC GIA TP.HCM TRƢỜNG ĐẠI HỌC BÁCH KHOA CHƢƠNG TRÌNH KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ CẤP THÀNH PHỐ O C O TỔNG H P KẾT QUẢ NHIỆM VỤ NGHIÊN CỨU KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ NGHI N CỨU CÔNG NGHỆ TÔNG IN CƠNG TRÌNH Cơ quan chủ trì nhiệm vụ: Trƣ n Đ i Học NG ch Khoa – ĐHQG TP.HCM Chủ nhiệm nhiệm vụ: PGS.TS Trần V n Mi n Thành phố Hồ Chí Minh - 2022 NG CHO ỦY BAN NHÂN DÂN THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH SỞ KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ ĐẠI HỌC QUỐC GIA TP.HCM TRƢỜNG ĐẠI HỌC BÁCH KHOA CHƢƠNG TRÌNH KHOA HỌC VÀ CƠNG NGHỆ CẤP THÀNH PHỐ BÁO CÁO TỔNG H P KẾT QUẢ NHIỆM VỤ NGHIÊN CỨU KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ NGHI N CỨU CƠNG NGHỆ CƠNG TRÌNH TƠNG IN NG CHO NG (Đã chỉnh sửa theo kết luận Hội đồng nghiệm thu ngày 30/09/2022) Chủ nhiệm nhiệm vụ Trần V n Mi n Cơ quan chủ trì nhiệm vụ MỤC ỤC C Ố CC C C CC CC C 34 CC C Đ 33 ĐỒ 36 40 c n thi t ph i n hi n cứu 40 h n n nh h n t qu n hi n cứu 41 ục ti u nhiệm vụ 41 C Ổ CỨ Ứ C 42 1.1 i i thiệu c n n hệ in n tron x y nh h nh n hi n cứu v ứn 1.3 hi n cứu v ứn 1.4 o s nh v ụn c n n hệ ụn c n n hệ in a ch n c n n hệ in C C n 42 t n in t n tron n t n ph h p tron CỦ tr n th i i 44 c 53 i u iện iệt am 57 Đ C Ạ BÊ TÔNG IN 3D 60 2.1 C c t nh ch t xi m n 60 2.2 nh ch t i ica um v tro ay 61 2.3 nh ch t cốt iệu v phụ ia h a h c 62 2.4 C c t nh ch t s i ph n t n 64 C CỨ Đ 3.1 C Ạ C C 65 nh ch t 3.2 Co n t u i nv t n in h n n in h n h p t n 67 83 3.3 h o s t th m n c hối x y t n in 3.4 h o s t h n n ch u n n hối x y C t n in Ạ u aca tran tr 4.2 uy tr nh tr n 100 i n in t n in 4.3 uy tr nh in C 95 4: C 4.1 89 t n 100 t o h nh s n ph m aca t n t o h nh s n ph m aca tran tr 101 tran tr 102 Ạ 5: 106 5.1 u nh n ụn 5.2 uy tr nh tr n 5.3 uy tr nh in i n in t n in t o h nh t t n t o h nh t 5.4 Th n hiệm thi c n c n tr nh nh C t n t o h nh t n nh n nh ao 106 109 n ụn m h nh nh 110 n c n n hệ in 6: n t n 113 127 129 ỦY BAN NHÂN DÂN THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH SỞ KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ ĐẠI HỌC QUỐC GIA TP.HCM TRƢỜNG ĐẠI HỌC BÁCH KHOA CHƢƠNG TRÌNH KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ CẤP THÀNH PHỐ O C O THỐNG K KẾT QUẢ NHIỆM VỤ NGHIÊN CỨU KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ NGHI N CỨU CÔNG NGHỆ TÔNG IN CÔNG TRÌNH Cơ quan chủ trì nhiệm vụ: Trƣ n Đ i Học NG ch Khoa – ĐHQG TP.HCM Chủ nhiệm nhiệm vụ: PGS.TS Trần V n Mi n Thành phố Hồ Chí Minh - 2022 NG CHO ĐẠI HỌC QUỐC GIA TP.HCM TRƢỜNG ĐẠI HỌC BÁCH KHOA CỘNG HOÀ XÃ HỘI CHỦ NGHĨA VIỆT NAM Độc lập - Tự - H nh phúc Tp.HCM, ngày 29 tháng 08 năm 2022 BÁO CÁO THỐNG KÊ KẾT QUẢ TH C HIỆN NHIỆM VỤ NGHIÊN CỨU KH&CN I THÔNG TIN CHUNG T n nhiệm vụ: N hi n cứu c n n hệ Thu c Ch ơn tr nh/ ĩnh v c: t n in n cho c n trình ựn thu t v c n n hệ Chủ nhiệm nhiệm vụ: H tên: r n n i n y th n n m sinh 12 – 12 – 1979 Nam/ Nữ: Nam H c hàm, h c v : PGS, TS Chức danh khoa h c i n vi n cao c p Chức vụ i n vi n Điện tho i: Tổ chức: 028 38650714 Nhà riêng: Mobile: 0903810481 Fax: E-mail: tvmien@hcmut.edu.vn Tên tổ chức an c n t c r Đ a tổ chức: n h Đ a nhà riêng: / / n Đ i c ch hoa – Đ iệt C C i n h nh C Tổ chức chủ trì nhiệm vụ: Tên tổ chức chủ trì nhiệm vụ: r n Đ i c ch hoa – Đ Điện tho i: 028 – 38636856 Fax: 028 – 38636984 E-mail: Website: www.khcn.hcmut.edu.vn Đ a chỉ: h n iệt C H tên thủ tr ng tổ chức: PGS.TS Mai Thanh Phong Số tài kho n: 3713.0.1056923.00000 Kho b c: ho c h n c C II TÌNH HÌNH TH C HIỆN C Th i gian thực nhiệm vụ: - Theo H p ồn ã t: từ tháng 03/ n m 2021 - Th c t th c hiện: từ tháng 03/ n m 2021 -Đ n tháng 09/ n m 2022 n tháng 09/ n m 2022 c gia h n (n u có): - L n từ th n … n m… -L n n th n … n m… … Kinh phí sử dụng kinh phí: a) Tổng số kinh phí th c hiện: 2.995 tr tron + Kính phí h tr từ ngân sách khoa h c: 2.795 tr + Kinh phí từ nguồn khác: 200 tr b) Tình hình c p s dụng kinh phí từ nguồn ngân sách khoa h c: Thực tế đạt Theo kế hoạch Ghi Số TT Th i gian Kinh phí h n n m r Th i gian Kinh phí (Số đề nghị r toán) h n n m Tháng 4/2021 1.397 Tháng 1/2022 1.397 1.397 Tháng 6/2022 1.198 Tháng 8/2022 1.198 1.198 … c) K t qu s dụng kinh phí theo kho n chi: Đối với đề tài: Đơn vị tính: Triệu đồng Số Nội dung TT khoản chi Tr công lao ng (khoa h c, phổ thông) Nguyên, v t liệu, Thực tế đạt Theo kế hoạch Tổng NSKH 1.196,8872 1.438 Tổng NSKH 1.196,8872 1.196,8872 1.196,8872 1.438 1.434,882 1,434,882 Nguồn khác Nguồn khác n n ng Thi t b , máy móc Xây d ng, s a chữa nh Chi khác D ch vụ thuê phục vụ nghiên cứu 200 Tổng cộng 2.995 160,1128 160,1128 2.795 163,2308 200 200 200 2.995 163,2308 200 2.795 o thay ổi (n u có): Nguyên, v t liệu c u th u công khai, nên th c t khác d to n chi v n phòn ph m, in n bù cho kinh phí ph n nguyên, v t liệu Đối với dự án: Đơn vị tính: Triệu đồng Số Nội dung TT khoản chi Thi t b , máy móc mua m i h x ng xây d ng m i, c i t o Kinh phí h tr cơng nghệ Chi ph ao Nguyên v t liệu, n n ng Thuê thi t b , nhà x ng Khác Theo kế hoạch Tổng NSKH ng Nguồn khác Thực tế đạt Tổng NSKH Nguồn khác 200 Tổng cộng o thay ổi (n u có): - C c v n ản hành tron qu trình thực đ tài/ ự n: (Liệt kê định, văn quan quản lý từ công đoạn xét duyệt, phê duyệt kinh phí, hợp đồng, điều chỉnh (thời gian, nội dung, kinh phí thực có); văn tổ chức chủ trì nhiệm vụ (đơn, kiến nghị điều chỉnh có) Số TT Số, thời gian ban hành văn Tên văn 7/ / ĐQPTKHCN, ngày th n n m 2021 H p ồng th c nhiệm vụ nghiên cứu Khoa h c Công nghệ Qu phát triển khoa h c cơng nghệ TP.Hồ Chí Minh v i r n Đ i h c Bách Khoa - Đ i h c Quốc gia TP.HCM 02/ Đ-Đ H p ồng giao nhiệm vụ “Nghiên cứu công nghệ bê tơng in 3D dùng cho cơng trình xây d ng” iữa r n Đ i h c Bách Khoa - Đ i h c Quốc gia TP.HCM PGS.TS Tr n n i n - KHCN&DA, ngày 12/03/2021 / Đ-Đ ngày 30 tháng n m Quy t nh Hiệu tr ng r n Đ i h c Bách khoa v việc phê duyệt k t qu l a ch n nhà th u gói th u: cung c p xi m n phụ gia, s i c t phục vụ nghiên cứu cho nhiệm vụ “ hi n cứu công nghệ bê tông in 3D dùng cho cơng trình xây d n ” / Đ-Đ ngày 03 tháng n m Quy t nh Hiệu tr ng r n Đ i h c Bách khoa v việc phê duyệt k t qu l a ch n nhà th u gói th u: cung c p d ch vụ d ch vụ thuê cho nhiệm vụ “ hi n cứu công nghệ bê tơng in 3D dùng cho cơng trình xây d n ” Ghi Tổ chức phối hợp thực nhiệm vụ: Số TT Tên tổ chức đăng ký theo Thuyết minh Nội dung Tên tổ chức tham gia thực Sản phẩm chủ yếu đạt tham gia chủ yếu C n ty Cổ C n ty Cổ ph n Nội dung 6: ph n x y p x y p th ơn riển hai th th ơn m i m i C C n hiệm thi (ACSC) c n x y n nh n c n n hệ in C n ty Cổ 3D bê tông: ph n hoa h c C n ty Cổ ph n hoa h c c n - hi t t c n n hệ ch c u v ch hoa Khoa TP.HCM n hệ ể thi TP.HCM c n th n hiệm nh c iện C n ty cổ ph n t ch m t n n o i C n ty cổ ph n t n n o i - riển hai th ơn th ơn thi c n th n hiệm in t n x y n C n ty Cổ ph n nh c t p o n u t iện t ch x y n i n m2 RICONS - Đ nh i ch t n c n tr nh sau hi ho n th nh in 3D bê tông 10 Đã triển hai thi t m t số m u nh c iện t ch m2 - Đã triển hai th n hiệm in m h nh nh t n nh n ụn - Ghi chú* Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa Wall 32 Mode 0.212228541 0.029057715 0.364808285 -0.180097036 0.0596727 Wall 56 Mode 1.249266392 -0.128524182 -0.456909775 -1.322268494 0.059721312 Wall 55 Mode 0.141987568 0.04549924 0.120708273 -0.02474083 0.002592557 Wall 58 Mode 0.039112852 -0.155238971 0.140465419 -0.283363124 0.001487407 Wall 32 Mode 0.249763907 -0.032619244 0.019875506 -0.415745727 0.048785453 Wall 56 Mode 0.019928781 -0.762141793 0.881303327 0.2246622 0.048831644 Wall 55 Mode 10 0.44953049 0.102523589 0.302901378 -0.013659874 0.008559415 Wall 58 Mode 10 0.070485434 -0.206503288 0.334501322 -0.693177694 0.007059732 Wall 32 Mode 10 -0.176625275 -0.244012038 0.575702893 -0.625719499 0.099407703 Wall 56 Mode 10 0.074403008 -2.21741021 2.371817001 0.63652609 0.09952545 Wall 55 Mode 11 0.166393602 0.036811199 0.112890077 -0.013698254 0.003078124 Wall 58 Mode 11 0.012083098 -0.100391515 0.118550621 -0.285004414 0.002208046 Wall 32 Mode 11 0.077759543 -0.076029486 0.097954742 -0.334478951 0.045604827 Wall 56 Mode 11 0.018056896 -0.856751513 0.922968738 0.238090561 0.045655226 Wall 55 Mode 12 0.166924327 -0.001839833 0.081399922 -0.000939202 0.00321891 Wall 58 Mode 12 0.05274027 -0.007948606 0.121261487 -0.170191985 0.003370793 Wall 32 Mode 12 -0.076940217 -0.351589692 0.403215018 -0.032397825 0.019908355 Wall 56 Mode 12 0.021484599 -0.759868787 0.741194523 0.189160996 0.019883203 Wall 55 -0.010841758 -0.056172864 -0.010710387 -0.053124399 1.96623E-05 Wall 58 -0.01272525 -0.063028285 -0.0125639 -0.0644876 1.73264E-05 Wall 32 0.00426496 -0.060678045 0.006103584 -0.059637197 4.55875E-05 Wall 56 0.005383655 -0.04989559 0.008750237 -0.052229373 4.65255E-05 Wall 55 -0.000146008 -0.003971551 -0.000556907 -0.003435102 4.42615E-06 Wall 58 -0.001670658 -0.008793796 -0.001618897 -0.009449282 8.30885E-06 Wall 32 0.000154963 -0.008910053 0.000427841 -0.008504878 8.37295E-05 Wall 56 -9.43349E-06 -0.003718216 0.003245721 -0.002927135 8.34337E-05 Wall 55 -0.011282601 -0.05984958 -0.01146 -0.0563663 Wall 58 -0.014532881 -0.071685107 -0.014239 -0.073879877 Wall 32 0.004292963 -0.069461138 0.0064819 -0.068092644 Wall 56 0.004942648 -0.053182233 0.0119157 -0.055076285 Wall 59 Mode -0.049361919 -0.359484165 -0.05865595 -0.32037231 0.000269696 Wall 60 Mode 0.065591433 -0.224870392 -0.024739792 -0.140585589 0.000157282 Wall 11 Mode 0.083601478 -0.177130499 0.07571514 -0.167377108 0.001380991 Wall 12 Mode 0.100569029 -0.254949078 -0.105928169 -0.388152775 0.001398262 Wall 59 Mode -3.81941E-06 -0.000593907 -9.46391E-05 -0.000529185 3.03303E-07 Wall 60 Mode 0.000270767 -0.000357913 6.9241E-05 -0.000244634 4.53615E-07 Wall 11 Mode -0.000101645 -0.000693896 0.000697929 -5.31367E-05 1.64379E-05 Wall 12 Mode 0.000512369 -0.000447676 -0.000452689 -0.000721764 1.64344E-05 Wall 59 Mode 0.002335159 -2.17278E-05 0.001628789 0.000349399 2.65739E-06 Wall 60 Mode 0.001782251 -0.000899847 0.00117253 -0.000172501 7.07689E-07 Wall 11 Mode 0.000346904 -0.004743128 0.002946929 0.001245735 0.000132166 Wall 12 Mode 0.005377865 0.002230267 0.000626264 -0.00602877 0.000132191 Wall 59 Mode -0.13937949 -1.086269089 -0.171805133 -1.079631446 0.00011207 135 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa -0.009031618 -0.481348246 0.00021763 Wall 60 Mode 0.059292025 -0.490857323 Wall 11 Mode -0.008619257 -0.583422085 0.351969183 -0.276888007 0.008279514 Wall 12 Mode 0.345004235 -1.007455466 -0.347163692 -1.06248524 0.008277412 Wall 59 Mode 0.110236247 -0.053797552 0.038013634 -0.008515534 0.000126475 Wall 60 Mode 0.106841552 -0.079199942 0.06108025 -0.030059057 3.36419E-05 Wall 11 Mode 0.046555465 -0.198223659 0.109921952 0.042151607 0.005613665 Wall 12 Mode 0.288768909 0.030732304 -0.008007097 -0.28381476 0.005614989 Wall 59 Mode 1.001744168 0.18883627 0.997218847 0.174919191 6.60921E-05 Wall 60 Mode 0.41185469 0.082051954 0.454024876 0.07620724 9.37992E-05 Wall 11 Mode 0.425216106 -0.176805246 0.366872004 0.01934042 0.002195171 Wall 12 Mode 0.968269464 0.081705296 0.954911135 -0.031682894 0.002194162 Wall 59 Mode 0.095001997 -0.457428028 -0.035282852 -0.235600118 0.00021317 Wall 60 Mode 0.185470169 -0.362481424 0.031356904 -0.213330599 0.000135915 Wall 11 Mode 0.294846223 -0.313156553 -0.008451938 -0.218147772 0.008541412 Wall 12 Mode -0.120955273 -0.705770105 0.519642458 -0.212151171 0.008542991 Wall 59 Mode 0.15408693 -0.759480432 -0.063829734 -0.392032722 8.73871E-05 Wall 60 Mode 0.279931552 -0.613995332 0.025241387 -0.34072569 0.000277046 Wall 11 Mode 0.136753666 -0.689107926 0.210679029 -0.343806447 0.002434515 Wall 12 Mode -0.050802571 -0.824361488 0.29381274 -0.515838234 0.002420278 Wall 59 Mode 0.152863614 -0.451382832 2.16585E-05 -0.38301552 0.000323181 Wall 60 Mode 0.130476451 -0.265250544 0.030314041 -0.171413336 0.000442272 Wall 11 Mode 0.666632562 -0.184188171 -0.125466409 -0.508010799 0.004327839 Wall 12 Mode 0.416604446 -0.478327925 -0.220158864 -0.274790165 0.004317295 Wall 59 Mode 10 0.395888022 -0.4630003 0.184035365 -0.111784114 3.31305E-05 Wall 60 Mode 10 0.329711189 -0.413006507 0.108894454 -0.160092788 0.000444079 Wall 11 Mode 10 0.037411411 -0.968545873 0.573861245 -0.042636219 0.008656679 Wall 12 Mode 10 0.412030334 -0.508451398 0.057748926 -0.221604674 0.008645344 Wall 59 Mode 11 0.380538254 -0.302736352 0.240403232 -0.054989524 6.28059E-05 Wall 60 Mode 11 0.259874352 -0.256100148 0.10654127 -0.078079543 0.000463744 Wall 11 Mode 11 0.018661408 -0.935561484 0.643972007 0.062827886 0.011054392 Wall 12 Mode 11 0.459748937 -0.324950684 0.044340381 -0.158259138 0.011044839 Wall 59 Mode 12 0.503486877 -0.925307098 0.065591194 -0.705629037 0.000496055 Wall 60 Mode 12 0.260395369 -0.426031106 0.003256178 -0.21324089 0.001748869 Wall 11 Mode 12 3.136419961 0.133067124 -0.440314358 -2.66984855 0.049978595 Wall 12 Mode 12 0.310312077 -1.484958008 0.764782217 -0.117049725 0.04995045 Wall 59 -0.014182184 -0.071553093 -0.014145859 -0.073444741 8.40787E-06 Wall 60 -0.013167047 -0.068430228 -0.013596151 -0.069831945 5.44575E-06 Wall 11 0.010259673 -0.065330948 0.005963176 -0.0641247 7.13356E-05 Wall 12 0.004528757 -0.070338749 0.010206269 -0.065929583 7.16226E-05 Wall 59 -0.002590323 -0.013033116 -0.002585706 -0.013288919 2.04651E-06 Wall 60 -0.002275224 -0.011915184 -0.00227778 -0.011810631 1.23902E-06 Wall 11 0.002023289 -0.011126201 0.00108778 -0.011063244 1.20896E-05 Wall 12 0.000853731 -0.013043214 0.001682293 -0.01179043 1.21988E-05 136 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa -0.084585214 -0.016732 -0.086732767 Wall 59 -0.016773502 Wall 60 -0.015442974 -0.08034471 -0.015874 -0.081641672 Wall 11 0.012267785 -0.076441971 0.0070402 -0.075177277 Wall 12 0.005367177 -0.083366652 0.0118793 -0.077710822 Wall 60 Mode -0.026614176 -0.133092929 -0.008890524 -0.156006712 0.00024238 Wall 61 Mode -0.011122209 -0.057046616 0.011391575 -0.091720166 0.000224791 Wall 10 Mode -0.025501685 -0.186609649 0.206078078 -0.064615156 0.0026542 Wall 11 Mode 0.05797491 -0.182984236 0.009809146 -0.131555157 0.002655747 Wall 60 Mode 0.000325581 -0.000422126 0.000169899 -0.000335893 6.79888E-07 Wall 61 Mode 0.000423592 -8.07518E-05 0.000286695 4.44897E-05 4.59357E-07 Wall 10 Mode 0.00030103 -0.000406357 0.000289802 0.000117611 5.46125E-06 Wall 11 Mode -5.72592E-05 -0.000977612 0.0005087 -0.000108308 5.4842E-06 Wall 60 Mode 0.001700965 -0.000839117 0.000922647 9.79369E-05 3.35555E-06 Wall 61 Mode 0.000675604 -0.000754503 0.000901351 -0.000233041 1.78585E-06 Wall 10 Mode 0.000586488 -0.001711069 0.000531105 -0.000930262 4.58423E-05 Wall 11 Mode 0.000377163 -0.00475 0.002837471 0.00130465 4.59303E-05 Wall 60 Mode 0.236522921 -0.676015458 0.090396979 -0.572849604 0.000381226 Wall 61 Mode 0.378595565 -0.295754397 0.237874294 -0.124214806 0.000150152 Wall 10 Mode 0.271018284 -0.378099921 0.266391927 -0.17830108 0.002294072 Wall 11 Mode -0.041987885 -0.85876707 0.261093521 -0.497775173 0.00232068 Wall 60 Mode 0.121989923 -0.095470953 0.056304015 -0.024160182 0.00011816 Wall 61 Mode 0.065236275 -0.053641143 0.049240402 0.004739957 8.1211E-05 Wall 10 Mode 0.085976483 -0.046945986 0.00890484 -0.090037147 0.002402512 Wall 11 Mode 0.047495432 -0.221736504 0.104446204 0.02078037 0.002404044 Wall 60 Mode 0.508987941 -0.010115974 0.501647257 0.023619535 0.000114463 Wall 61 Mode 0.293607554 -0.158603106 0.245518128 -0.128008105 8.06362E-05 Wall 10 Mode 0.346034847 -0.025498339 0.233486985 -0.282273377 0.003539234 Wall 11 Mode 0.509432654 -0.054244057 0.535475897 0.052709911 0.003540166 Wall 60 Mode 0.204916657 -0.380554779 0.031961653 -0.215308481 0.000176713 Wall 61 Mode 0.075212853 -0.172183114 -0.016143426 -0.169695913 0.000335874 Wall 10 Mode -0.055535015 -0.321135817 0.348459222 -0.052587346 0.004967905 Wall 11 Mode 0.325062329 -0.305147188 0.046536947 -0.223426394 0.004959687 Wall 60 Mode 0.270312272 -0.603754921 0.074299587 -0.39040502 0.000372299 Wall 61 Mode 0.026291764 -0.331063973 -0.056628631 -0.291128592 0.000564172 Wall 10 Mode -0.265884197 -0.618393829 0.5287237 -0.177417819 0.004709101 Wall 11 Mode 0.187328963 -0.669754543 0.274414461 -0.321979676 0.004689984 Wall 60 Mode 0.295052503 -0.432625911 0.095447767 -0.233747747 0.000379432 Wall 61 Mode 0.146865412 -0.275445552 0.045861059 -0.048851128 0.000492973 Wall 10 Mode 0.215055478 -0.146091587 -0.02388959 -0.288839034 0.005382335 Wall 11 Mode 0.611020346 -0.244307116 -0.053902112 -0.700879028 0.005373125 Wall 60 Mode 10 0.422641595 -0.504248493 0.225877247 -0.278764002 0.000590491 Wall 61 Mode 10 0.1447697 -0.292079187 -0.007660694 -0.188191055 0.000631869 Wall 10 Mode 10 -0.098911592 -0.5173838 0.385401756 -0.104939317 0.004047964 137 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa Wall 11 Mode 10 0.112499781 -0.912496617 0.770575859 -0.097744391 0.004041712 Wall 60 Mode 11 0.373847402 -0.368532877 0.210669824 -0.183748418 0.000576247 Wall 61 Mode 11 0.160401511 -0.197526931 0.022579279 -0.115115644 0.000543881 Wall 10 Mode 11 -0.010457677 -0.329177786 0.261018637 -0.066507857 0.007251629 Wall 11 Mode 11 0.069399275 -0.876213416 0.818420626 0.005166548 0.007254128 Wall 60 Mode 12 0.655391897 -0.823839528 0.246181676 -0.453354494 0.001931952 Wall 61 Mode 12 0.210969885 -0.451036302 0.073555206 -0.124694937 0.001346581 Wall 10 Mode 12 0.094786118 -0.234110823 0.325746538 -0.344804253 0.041593896 Wall 11 Mode 12 2.988333415 0.08377741 -0.358985983 -2.955921562 0.04161696 Wall 60 -0.013353542 -0.068178898 -0.013886944 -0.069605988 3.27541E-06 Wall 61 -0.013626584 -0.068086908 -0.013591687 -0.068426837 3.05785E-06 Wall 10 0.008646301 -0.064238683 0.006112155 -0.063849725 1.11396E-05 Wall 11 0.009433521 -0.065309876 0.005275212 -0.064022165 1.12013E-05 Wall 60 -0.002144846 -0.012037418 -0.002311555 -0.011785 1.06902E-07 Wall 61 -0.002297744 -0.011498155 -0.002298339 -0.011760996 1.16065E-06 Wall 10 0.000863577 -0.011299458 0.001860842 -0.01045619 1.32635E-05 Wall 11 0.001855135 -0.0111758 0.000989238 -0.011123388 1.32131E-05 Wall 60 -0.015563703 -0.080151001 -0.081382995 Wall 61 -0.015929595 -0.079579796 -0.016206 0.0158988 Wall 10 0.009508467 -0.075536731 0.0079723 -0.074305245 Wall 11 0.0062471 -0.075128277 Wall 61 Mode 0.037785506 -0.107738603 0.016588563 -0.095132882 4.13098E-05 Wall 62 Mode 0.016905202 -0.029734163 -0.003399518 -0.036592535 6.72297E-05 Wall Mode -0.010653027 -0.115641937 0.084895324 -0.032323289 0.00142339 Wall 10 Mode 0.042873359 -0.097341794 -0.013512502 -0.101418393 0.001422401 Wall 61 Mode 0.000415839 -7.67847E-05 0.000301782 3.31891E-05 4.35138E-07 Wall 62 Mode 0.000727874 -0.000102041 0.000503572 9.72172E-05 9.59866E-08 Wall Mode 0.000788355 1.77871E-05 0.000427893 -0.000339042 1.33338E-05 Wall 10 Mode 0.000177724 -0.000766899 0.000556757 0.000374813 1.33406E-05 Wall 61 Mode 0.000715961 -0.000719361 0.002020185 -0.001427374 3.0182E-06 Wall 62 Mode 0.001236928 -0.00181001 0.001679173 -0.001616251 1.69263E-05 Wall Mode 0.028937853 0.005046844 -0.004013966 -0.023408011 0.000543436 Wall 10 Mode -0.001390162 -0.008545136 0.015028776 0.002568813 0.000543181 Wall 61 Mode 0.259332411 -0.185158282 0.183690196 -0.061363669 0.000126163 Wall 62 Mode 0.468894856 -0.026904997 0.448417874 0.039353487 0.000706489 Wall Mode 1.292260737 0.481403721 0.185061415 -1.187431297 0.026540266 Wall 10 Mode 0.035655358 -0.795533545 0.608491909 0.18942029 0.026531162 Wall 61 Mode 0.038272844 -0.023859638 0.105262167 -0.054099882 0.000252418 Wall 62 Mode 0.092276327 -0.066652513 0.105641074 -0.047797097 0.00089114 Wall Mode 1.385581656 0.280898212 -0.160264078 -1.176566184 0.02432004 Wall 10 Mode -0.032254025 -0.297882835 0.543340316 0.09855385 0.024305019 Wall 61 Mode 0.23627443 -0.094468427 0.215703392 -0.104994924 1.4937E-05 Wall 62 Mode 0.022841016 -0.160830069 0.046512408 -0.169574352 0.000454432 0.011248171 138 -0.076445192 -0.080178997 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa Wall Mode -0.24935556 -0.944930549 0.773363514 0.008203627 0.018941764 Wall 10 Mode Wall 61 Mode 0.508487752 0.094209924 0.039300443 -0.541151619 0.018936318 0.034796423 -0.137640179 0.10886554 -0.288831383 0.000803621 Wall 62 Mode 0.111678669 -0.233270205 0.082965534 -0.261608411 0.001734852 Wall Wall 10 Mode -0.528908233 -2.303963857 2.095720871 0.232706478 0.035054012 Mode 0.129472998 -0.088531095 -0.030104094 -0.497857738 0.035020278 Wall Wall 61 Mode -0.049641809 -0.255493623 -0.011726458 -0.335667543 0.000917286 62 Mode -0.053516009 -0.287769828 -0.060948363 -0.330056777 0.000618474 Wall Mode 0.085205584 -0.276136759 0.414992112 -0.210665337 0.012091702 Wall 10 Mode -0.386253016 -0.745147219 1.261952491 -0.03739511 0.012110663 Wall 61 Mode 0.027855479 -0.151919724 0.138362593 -0.145868556 0.001277807 Wall 62 Mode 0.288355298 -0.25454272 0.195621819 -0.149388476 0.002294559 Wall Mode 3.055840225 0.565746308 -0.420915834 -2.564332121 0.041026306 Wall 10 Mode 0.208456691 -0.036763086 0.314932458 -0.061903613 0.040982016 Wall 61 Mode 10 0.00769653 -0.152366768 -0.030055278 -0.168435721 0.0010888 Wall 62 Mode 10 -0.042825309 -0.232515957 -0.045122678 -0.245706464 0.000646131 Wall Mode 10 0.11990495 -0.207624041 0.308762893 -0.18075412 0.016212546 Wall 10 Mode 10 -0.311376356 -0.98791765 1.437384727 0.125208133 0.016236214 Wall 61 Mode 11 0.009873406 -0.045591773 -0.00613911 -0.087804309 0.001026809 Wall 62 Mode 11 -0.015783474 -0.140327614 -0.024721367 -0.135306456 0.000769213 Wall Mode 11 -0.14095677 -0.328434046 0.469570248 -0.037108435 0.008530932 Wall 10 Mode 11 -0.209169702 -0.862597698 1.074342292 0.14697323 0.008558004 Wall 61 Mode 12 0.056566849 -0.294894425 0.154088433 -0.206967006 0.002942444 Wall 62 Mode 12 0.360295358 -0.360040081 0.148564433 -0.165034982 0.002352212 Wall Mode 12 1.619439875 0.113659918 -0.274915922 -1.201168332 0.017501006 Wall 10 Mode 12 2.662271797 0.359244773 -0.596322932 -2.443168975 0.017590062 Wall 61 -0.013585442 -0.068186559 -0.013521467 -0.068438548 4.15377E-06 Wall 62 -0.013438677 -0.069132173 -0.013847488 -0.070477927 7.75147E-06 Wall -0.001074677 -0.067817798 0.012825747 -0.063902211 0.000162973 Wall 10 0.010179881 -0.06387964 0.001830562 -0.06493549 0.000162841 Wall 61 -0.002231044 -0.011579079 -0.002205014 -0.011840096 1.73371E-06 Wall 62 -0.002236035 -0.012307458 -0.002383263 -0.012686254 2.94054E-06 Wall -0.001573332 -0.012648631 0.003444372 -0.011039611 4.82662E-05 Wall 10 0.001699033 -0.011125831 0.000364749 -0.010997377 4.82078E-05 Wall 61 -0.015841115 -0.079741009 -0.015767 -0.080237719 Wall 62 -0.015706666 -0.081407678 -0.016253 -0.083141709 Wall -0.002709344 -0.080405093 0.0162641 -0.074935856 Wall 10 0.011872271 -0.074998828 0.0021360 -0.075873567 Wall 62 Mode 0.054085429 -0.065558063 -0.003522131 -0.03782625 0.000157476 Wall 63 Mode 0.037175727 -0.044975331 0.019554503 -0.028183514 0.000153488 Wall 8 Mode 0.013894944 -0.005490837 0.023440162 -0.059244797 0.001550741 Wall Mode -0.012652206 -0.107777639 0.109202055 -0.052565138 0.001551141 Wall 62 Mode 0.000554463 7.2348E-05 0.000587249 1.25633E-05 1.32985E-06 139 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa Wall 63 Mode 0.000288324 -2.21243E-06 0.000417848 6.79359E-05 1.61815E-06 Wall 8 Mode 0.001312636 0.000436163 0.000154047 -0.001564825 1.57943E-05 Wall Mode 0.000802024 -5.0572E-05 0.00041957 -0.000378274 1.57674E-05 Wall 62 Mode 0.001516848 -0.002035607 0.000847323 -0.000838725 2.02725E-05 Wall 63 Mode 0.000345435 -0.004803429 -0.000675172 -0.003418804 8.38799E-06 Wall 8 Mode 0.001455006 -0.005045831 0.006679111 -0.001951416 0.000424087 Wall Mode 0.030217938 0.005047479 -0.004075041 -0.022011698 0.000424488 Wall 62 Mode 0.41619239 0.02755923 0.490300874 -0.004291274 0.0011948 Wall 63 Mode 0.287181965 0.037647552 0.392044326 0.044512327 0.00091042 Wall 8 Mode 0.368844161 0.319722857 0.254720599 -0.534767442 0.010903965 Wall Mode 1.172495702 0.504607088 0.169431723 -1.269639285 0.010931383 Wall 62 Mode 0.10467631 -0.077219642 0.074850722 -0.018839599 0.000906817 Wall 63 Mode 0.062857952 -0.185858204 -0.015895892 -0.097331259 0.00025668 Wall 8 Mode -0.031852341 -0.361224482 0.498261624 0.010440766 0.023783301 Wall Mode 1.442970873 0.2761355 -0.162823777 -1.120961836 0.023799198 Wall 62 Mode 0.034083537 -0.170408965 0.105931147 -0.230656716 0.0004906 Wall 63 Mode -0.023650638 -0.157431878 0.048921171 -0.24267719 3.64239E-05 Wall 8 Mode 0.37393156 -0.068038355 -0.15724422 -0.480298924 0.017877249 Wall Mode -0.237314613 -0.859988444 0.878861303 0.000579354 0.017883942 Wall 62 Mode 0.153456309 -0.277052982 0.037616055 -0.214253794 0.001458566 Wall 63 Mode 0.324735884 -0.195175388 0.15244459 -0.029355992 0.000291462 Wall 8 Mode 0.924977569 0.092576264 -0.11894386 -1.067601907 0.044824239 Wall Mode -0.511085753 -2.4319734 1.987484701 0.233699014 0.044847017 Wall 62 Mode -0.036984467 -0.304928177 -0.060908357 -0.329469978 0.000345168 Wall 63 Mode 0.055647046 -0.2729395 -0.012447497 -0.256947986 0.000368339 Wall 8 Mode -0.017691672 -0.272271505 0.602644774 -0.126130024 0.002442817 Wall Mode 0.057738572 -0.288967975 0.397177792 -0.224999858 0.002439431 Wall 62 Mode 0.296806643 -0.266488288 0.1088677 -0.059140135 0.00132195 Wall 63 Mode 0.194571835 -0.28686793 -0.025608353 -0.142448321 0.001121786 Wall 8 Mode -0.44756371 -2.365788484 2.831663928 0.427134473 0.077300563 Wall Mode 3.170083706 0.53007508 -0.418403786 -2.495910104 0.077303727 Wall 62 Mode 10 -0.033158814 -0.239441132 -0.044756073 -0.248814389 1.8338E-05 Wall 63 Mode 10 -0.020548564 -0.240138505 -0.044738888 -0.227533536 0.000184776 Wall 8 Mode 10 0.491195562 -0.119312642 -0.04071924 -0.228480107 0.005155728 Wall Mode 10 0.133587636 -0.212033426 0.307735828 -0.159817381 0.005152448 Wall 62 Mode 11 0.023254894 -0.175812267 -0.027850892 -0.135730645 0.000129324 Wall 63 Mode 11 0.000794606 -0.160815793 -0.021180753 -0.119190671 0.000533082 Wall 8 Mode 11 0.902723914 0.039933885 -0.250877472 -0.703970697 0.017025594 Wall Mode 11 -0.110301403 -0.359333616 0.473176442 -0.031478091 0.017017737 Wall 62 Mode 12 0.444244662 -0.457998067 0.124691568 -0.127153434 0.000940385 Wall 63 Mode 12 0.212928942 -0.114964613 -0.01579156 -0.05465442 0.003088961 Wall 8 Mode 12 -0.691361368 -4.060992821 4.351230344 0.804632483 0.079773674 Wall Mode 12 1.748615513 0.048509005 -0.264650579 -1.172698922 0.079719393 140 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa Wall 62 -0.013593505 -0.068918083 -0.013961486 -0.070423193 9.10536E-06 Wall 63 -0.014208876 -0.071042734 -0.014018908 -0.070106172 3.22211E-06 Wall 8 0.006619749 -0.065566872 0.005566926 -0.06750077 0.00011074 Wall -0.000630325 -0.067526127 0.013441899 -0.063685988 0.000111067 Wall 62 -0.002337754 -0.01218383 -0.00246046 -0.012630966 3.09321E-06 Wall 63 -0.002587647 -0.012938385 -0.002558364 -0.012792093 6.99102E-07 Wall 8 0.0012302 -0.011915747 0.000639009 -0.012414888 4.2498E-05 Wall -0.001482988 -0.012446565 0.003680177 -0.010948571 4.26047E-05 Wall 62 -0.015943488 -0.081089683 -0.016430 -0.083046046 Wall 63 -0.016796589 -0.083981053 -0.016574 -0.082898137 Wall 8 0.007849261 -0.07748193 0.0062057 -0.079915436 Wall -0.002132741 -0.079953264 0.0171199 -0.07463242 Wall 63 Mode 0.000894108 -0.009453835 0.007766424 -0.015635313 5.68871E-05 Wall 64 Mode 0.004088172 -0.005262878 0.009416704 -0.022250831 6.06937E-05 Wall Mode -0.002252855 -0.047076926 0.032189391 -0.004540599 0.000193055 Wall Mode -0.002096321 -0.035634333 0.01879527 -0.005165387 0.000191892 Wall 63 Mode 0.000438515 -0.000134147 0.000770623 -0.000303096 1.26878E-06 Wall 64 Mode 0.00099364 -0.000992161 0.000998976 -0.001073626 3.16092E-06 Wall Mode 0.004854938 0.000513037 -0.00057063 -0.004072052 7.34553E-05 Wall Mode 0.000339967 -0.000624454 0.001308665 0.000546181 7.33983E-05 Wall 63 Mode 0.000703848 -0.005120707 -0.000393659 -0.003741452 1.34777E-05 Wall 64 Mode 0.002818548 -0.008773051 7.46987E-05 -0.007855519 9.35831E-06 Wall Mode 0.007090275 -0.009105974 0.000554195 -0.006002911 0.000166475 Wall Mode 0.015872763 -0.001785942 -0.005227986 -0.011139897 0.000166757 Wall 63 Mode 0.404984391 -0.079597539 0.424227862 0.011771455 0.001059298 Wall 64 Mode 0.633873399 -0.449366712 0.507809817 -0.304423838 0.000687716 Wall Mode 0.672533906 -0.657331253 0.278019656 -0.357788257 0.01563815 Wall Mode 1.165280509 0.297761207 0.107989469 -1.26210363 0.015658892 Wall 63 Mode 0.072254758 -0.194571803 0.003768618 -0.117678977 0.000489366 Wall 64 Mode 0.107289884 -0.317715908 0.005572642 -0.271970307 0.000319767 Wall Mode -0.07597797 -0.694056828 0.55686547 -0.111929677 0.018192203 Wall Mode 0.8338372 -0.001342678 -0.223498944 -0.693498296 0.018195975 Wall 63 Mode -0.022405951 -0.153379129 0.004444787 -0.203498243 0.000211863 Wall 64 Mode -0.003598372 -0.181192551 0.008601161 -0.196537533 0.000831945 Wall Mode 1.633709016 0.140471382 -0.327996929 -1.237379385 0.031647507 Wall Mode -0.247652908 -0.563600595 1.003563281 0.014383065 0.03163728 Wall 63 Mode 0.319888105 -0.191764657 0.197234563 -0.072708918 0.000666615 Wall 64 Mode 0.493013881 -0.178386674 0.437522297 -0.042074046 0.000746523 Wall Mode 1.58451194 0.29953085 0.07502607 -1.400864671 0.03831729 Wall Mode -0.033120388 -1.430813438 1.225532348 0.339179302 0.038315816 Wall 63 Mode 0.128936641 -0.349902662 0.104802909 -0.370524825 0.00059938 Wall 64 Mode 0.336987038 -0.434602901 0.294986224 -0.393303908 0.000313616 Wall Mode 0.614615901 -0.34223449 0.235608188 -0.294922406 0.012662644 141 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa Wall Mode -0.116744589 -0.781014313 0.887313633 -0.067241928 0.012672942 Wall 63 Mode 0.041678395 -0.139262384 0.002270337 -0.165039117 0.000818841 Wall 64 Mode 0.062002089 -0.328655137 0.039216886 -0.369264046 0.002277715 Wall Mode -0.778990317 -3.292025376 3.178482989 0.244023983 0.057056719 Wall Mode 0.741701637 0.003736487 -0.222685758 -0.834913648 0.057017118 Wall 63 Mode 10 -0.013535078 -0.246184041 -0.022679906 -0.250560468 0.000125853 Wall 64 Mode 10 -0.006506328 -0.18833357 0.008479912 -0.215645662 0.000598919 Wall Mode 10 1.228014032 0.047819301 -0.273800132 -0.713413426 0.019642655 Wall Mode 10 -0.070208209 -0.319365886 0.638837119 -0.091597092 0.019633925 Wall 63 Mode 11 -0.023374744 -0.134344244 -0.023533477 -0.119140146 0.000450858 Wall 64 Mode 11 0.037580306 -0.138488352 -0.000896072 -0.104053606 0.000893316 Wall Mode 11 1.332045169 0.147442953 -0.237282767 -0.978480139 0.017369157 Wall Mode 11 0.128233487 -0.10990207 0.223795635 -0.072936722 0.017352028 Wall 63 Mode 12 0.211235222 -0.120332542 0.182085461 -0.245469792 0.003056595 Wall 64 Mode 12 0.645870336 -0.692363682 0.422941034 -0.476764927 0.00274235 Wall Mode 12 -0.101045803 -2.373672658 2.034307912 0.208556764 0.007817333 Wall Mode 12 -0.406061968 -2.61732018 2.4914893 0.427874652 0.007933032 Wall 63 -0.014186432 -0.071043063 -0.014021784 -0.070125412 1.3854E-06 Wall 64 -0.014299327 -0.071483894 -0.014319655 -0.071611419 2.87965E-06 Wall 0.00364578 -0.067600198 0.009522008 -0.067137845 2.39898E-05 Wall 0.005490054 -0.065787383 0.00808228 -0.067017602 2.38566E-05 Wall 63 -0.002580562 -0.012935683 -0.002560545 -0.012799698 4.08249E-07 Wall 64 -0.002656494 -0.013282646 -0.002669361 -0.013352818 1.11762E-06 Wall -4.45847E-05 -0.012707349 0.002252877 -0.012420839 1.00421E-05 Wall 0.000733019 -0.01200797 0.00165878 -0.012218892 9.98809E-06 Wall 63 -0.016767152 -0.083978588 -0.016582 -0.082925056 Wall 64 -0.016956458 -0.084765902 -0.016989 -0.084963842 Wall 0.003600833 -0.080307185 0.0117744 -0.079558259 Wall Wall 10 64 Mode 0.011669466 -0.012155795 Wall 10 65 Mode 0.004471813 Wall 10 Mode 0.013751811 Wall 10 Mode Wall 10 64 Mode Wall 10 65 Mode Wall 10 Wall 10 Wall 10 Wall Wall 0.006223009 0.0097410 -0.079236486 -0.001948788 -0.011573716 -0.008524578 0.003421073 -0.008741232 4.21109E-05 -0.001216851 -0.001106485 -0.023677364 0.000714371 -0.007807682 -0.038839508 0.038926918 -0.009164528 0.000714817 0.001103684 -0.001092021 0.000516152 -0.000600986 3.12873E-06 0.000201468 -0.001455373 -0.000201018 -0.001010398 1.36303E-06 Mode 0.000461638 -0.001417557 0.001147756 -0.000750715 6.92652E-05 Mode 0.0053158 0.000586646 -0.000514211 -0.003554964 6.93225E-05 64 Mode 0.001697966 -0.007722404 -0.000756392 -0.006954493 1.23177E-05 10 65 Mode -0.000575254 -0.003440015 -0.001002112 -0.005620893 2.13945E-05 10 Mode -0.007100049 -0.022789969 0.027906802 -0.000232313 0.000377338 Wall 10 Mode 0.006868138 -0.007798818 0.001224617 -0.005606515 0.000376933 Wall 10 64 Mode 0.672435563 -0.48509634 0.499298218 -0.298744775 0.000451917 Wall 10 65 Mode 0.270795287 -0.342459402 0.114708099 -0.237919658 0.00075399 142 -0.07779529 4.90916E-05 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa Wall 10 Mode -0.038041569 -1.052672986 0.840386645 0.049811991 0.012822919 Wall 10 Mode 0.781686693 -0.544350788 0.396869969 -0.251953456 0.012808707 Wall 10 64 Mode 0.083047035 -0.295879277 0.001586117 -0.265577564 0.000852654 Wall 10 65 Mode -0.018340431 -0.099438224 -0.036699279 -0.177464405 0.00100429 Wall 10 Mode -0.247669213 -0.829229035 0.975202647 0.014117196 0.005369637 Wall 10 Mode -0.112564536 -0.609692964 0.595874473 -0.106076727 0.005343353 Wall 10 64 Mode -0.030300883 -0.152747268 -0.030260732 -0.159418413 0.000965835 Wall 10 65 Mode -0.029467807 -0.246181524 -0.046345813 -0.228881555 0.000286334 Wall 10 Mode -0.107795359 -0.326794322 0.628465879 -0.097803567 0.026358429 Wall 10 Mode 1.661978273 0.143753198 -0.346804383 -1.184705054 0.026374564 Wall 10 64 Mode 0.490175132 -0.17332366 0.445208193 -0.051984207 0.001599148 Wall 10 65 Mode 0.168364517 0.031144816 0.286945898 0.043806713 0.001511328 Wall 10 Mode 0.975645504 0.341312604 0.041312999 -1.174787296 0.004881086 Wall 10 Mode 1.429361041 0.355233977 0.078439353 -1.499737046 0.004908988 Wall 10 64 Mode 0.370753397 -0.472035011 0.282534111 -0.377186043 0.000280654 Wall 10 65 Mode 0.306240897 -0.231310656 0.25531788 -0.161747086 0.000368626 Wall 10 Mode 0.582503704 -0.045665131 0.106707677 -0.415770909 0.003155668 Wall 10 Mode 0.498379988 -0.399803574 0.204359758 -0.439595412 0.003146605 Wall 10 64 Mode 0.010869593 -0.278142203 -0.033698309 -0.29572929 0.002142203 Wall 10 65 Mode 0.269432591 -0.275349245 0.081245907 -0.130615124 0.000607072 Wall 10 Mode 1.159577203 0.021116073 -0.26848515 -1.143133022 0.061839195 Wall 10 Mode -0.764388051 -3.3671888 3.099130297 0.26010732 0.061873311 Wall 10 64 Mode 10 0.043780641 -0.242466303 0.035929707 -0.239249693 0.000446923 Wall 10 65 Mode 10 0.047154474 -0.170888472 0.031938091 -0.190626803 0.000390762 Wall 10 Mode 10 -0.227631658 -0.654923349 1.112403314 0.061907218 0.026457113 Wall 10 Mode 10 1.17489879 0.043875528 -0.217886406 -0.828715326 0.026458003 Wall 10 64 Mode 11 -0.008108009 -0.096190091 -0.015604163 -0.085955461 0.000499761 Wall 10 65 Mode 11 -0.011276286 -0.087462928 -0.022421893 -0.114160459 0.000573102 Wall 10 Mode 11 -0.262421724 -1.004095541 1.35163208 0.149827375 0.0334616 Wall 10 Mode 11 1.342663296 0.138260051 -0.230723034 -0.985794282 0.033460424 Wall 10 64 Mode 12 0.587190781 -0.620588192 0.358641366 -0.425561193 0.00099216 Wall 10 65 Mode 12 0.316898179 -0.318675247 0.310639939 -0.171532599 0.00291821 Wall 10 Mode 12 4.203288941 0.707493474 -0.766185328 -4.435878138 0.090865147 Wall 10 Mode 12 -0.057025572 -2.572434619 1.852630333 0.247901297 0.090823694 Wall 10 64 -0.014282167 -0.071480844 -0.014312097 -0.071639186 2.30575E-06 Wall 10 65 -0.014420122 -0.072117513 -0.014238595 -0.071214153 3.31112E-06 Wall 10 0.008594794 -0.066333905 0.005107424 -0.068525261 6.77043E-05 Wall 10 0.003931917 -0.067549457 0.009830989 -0.067094309 6.76626E-05 Wall 10 64 -0.002651177 -0.013280432 -0.002666021 -0.01336369 7.92518E-07 Wall 10 65 -0.00269448 -0.01347313 -0.002665001 -0.013329337 6.72528E-07 Wall 10 0.001818858 -0.01234653 0.000601821 -0.012900962 2.54129E-05 Wall 10 7.68179E-05 -0.012684653 0.002383561 -0.01240191 2.54164E-05 Wall 10 64 -0.016933571 -0.016978 -0.085002307 143 -0.08476105 Design Type Shell Element Joint Step Type Step Number SMax Top SMin Top SMax Bottom SMin Bottom SMaxV Average MPa MPa MPa MPa MPa Wall 10 65 -0.017114602 -0.085590642 -0.016903 -0.084543266 Wall 10 0.010413621 -0.078680403 0.0057089 -0.081425892 Wall 10 0.00400867 -0.080234044 0.0122139 -0.079495664 Wall 11 65 Mode 0.000261288 -0.004661673 0.001850477 -0.006823015 Wall 11 66 Mode 0.002946274 -0.003155169 0.000921981 -0.007064946 1.67927E-05 Wall 11 Mode 0.004585503 0.000177008 0.000269318 -0.006798877 0.000220319 Wall 11 Mode -0.004974864 -0.010388682 0.012860808 -0.002285374 0.000220424 Wall 11 65 Mode 7.43085E-05 -0.001299576 -6.47159E-06 -0.001233581 3.53053E-06 Bn n ch u cho th y ứn su t t av 3,1 a Khi so s nh nhữn o uốn v c n thể in n o v ứn su t c t n nh t xu t tr n m nh 8,4 MPa cao hẳn ứn su t m nh n y iữa ứn su t c t a c n tr nh ể in p t n in v y c thể ho n to n c thể n thi c n cho c n tr nh ch u o o uốn thi c n c n tr nh n y 144 n y t n a xu t tr n t n v c n a c n cao hẳn so v i nh i r n v i thi t n c p phối tc ut n i tr n y v i i tr c n t n in th th y r n c n 1.81162E-05 i n tr c v t n c t nh ch t nh tc u n CHƢƠNG KẾT U N VÀ KIẾN NGH 6.1 Kết luận t qu n hi n cứu th c n th i iểm t i cho nhữn t u n ch nh nh sau - C n n hệ m y in t n th o n uy n tr i c n n hệ in m y in th o n uy n ơn i n in c n trục c nhữn c iểm c nh tay ro ot nh c n n hệ ch t o c c n tr nh x y n c ch th c n v ph h p v i i u iện v t iệu v c n n hệ iệt am i m y in - t n c chứa s i th p m nh v cốt iệu c o i s h n man qu tổn thể v nc ụn h m i hiệu qu ch th n n ụn h n n in c n nh t n th p c n hối v i v mm h n in n ch t v s i h n n man t nh i hiệu h n nứt o co n t t n - C c c p phối t n in s n ph m tran tr v t STT t n v i th nh ph n n uy n v t iệu c a a C p XM i phối (kg) PP th nh c n ph h p ứn ụn ch t o n n c n tr nh nh sau hụ ia si u (kg) (Lit) o VMA N/CKD CL/CKD (Lit) SF FA (kg) (kg) MF-1 522 3,48 8,7 2,6 0,30 87 261 MF-2 517 3,45 8,6 2,6 0,32 86 259 MF-3 855 3,42 7,7 2,5 0,34 86 257 MW-1 595 1,79 8,9 1,8 0,36 60 179 MW-2 585 1,76 7,0 1,8 0,48 59 176 145 ốc - in m y in th nh c n t o h nh t c nhi u n - ron hi aca in n ể thi c n x y t n n tran tr ph h p tốc in c n thay mm/s t n in c h n n chốn th m n ch u n n cao so v i t hai m t n ụn n phức t p th tốc ụn m y in hổ n mm/s ph h p ể in n nh n n t uốn mm/s hi s ổi v n x y n ch c tốt v c t s t nun n ã t ho n thiện n vữa xi m n - Đ t i ã triển hai thi c n th n hiệm th nh c n n hệ in t n c n tr nh n c n v i quy m  C n tr nh c quy m r n  C n tr nh c quy m r n m m i m v cao i m m v cao m 6.2 Kiến n hị h m vi n hi n cứu t in yc i i h n v n i un ph h p v i th i ian n hi n cứu t ơn ứn , c thể ph t triển n hi n cứu ể ho n thiện c n n hệ in tông 3D th o nhữn n i un sau: hi n cứu iện ph p t - ỡn hối t n in n nứt tron qu tr nh thi c n c n tr nh in hi t c n ồn - Đ nh i t n ể h n ch t n n i n o i th t v c nh quan i n c n n hệ in - Đ nh i - o n o i tr i; m v i c n tr nh thi ; h n n chốn ch y c n tr nh in n t n ; n vữn m y in 3D; thuy t t nh to n t c u cho c n tr nh in phức t p 146 t n v i h nh n TÀI LIỆU THAM KHẢO [1] https://3dprinting.com/what-is3d-printing/ [2] https://blogin3d.com/cong-nghe-in-3d-be-tong-ky-nguyen-xay-nha-voimay-in-3d.html [3] T Wangler, Lloret, L Reiter, N Hack, F Gramazi, MKohler, “Digital concrete opportunities and challenges”, RILEM Tech Lett (2016) 6775 [4] A Perrot, D Rangard, A Pierre, “Structural built-up of cement-based materials used for 3D-printing extrusion techniques”, Mater Struct 19 (4) (2016) 1213-1220 [5] Ali Kazemian, Xiao Yuan, Ryan Meier Behrokh Khoshnevis, “ Concrete Printing Technology: Construction and Building Applications”, McGraw-Hill, page 18 [6] http://www.master-builders-solutions.basf.us/enus/products/masterfiber/1649 [7] P.K Mehta, PJ.M Monteiro, Concrete: Microstructure, Properties, and Materials, fourth ed., McGraw-Hill Education, 2013 [8] A.A Ramezanianpour, A Kazemian, M Nikravan, M.A Moghadam, Influence of a low-activity slag and silica fume on the fresh properties and durability of high performance self-consolidating concrete, International Conference on Sustainable Construction Materials & Technologies (SCMT3), Kyoto, Japan, 2013 [9] i rr rrot an an ar based materials used for 3D- printin “ tructura ui t-up of cement- xtrusion t chniqu s” Mater Struct., pp 1213– 1220, 2016 [10] D Feys, R Cepuritis, S Jacobsen, K Lesage, E Secrieru, and A ahia “ asurin h o o ica 147 rop rti s o C m nt ast s ost chniqu s common roc ur s an Cha n s” RILEM Tech Lett., pp 129–135, 2017 [11] G De Schutter, K Lesage, V Mechtcherine, V N Nerella, G Habert, and I Agusti-Juan “ ision o printin with concr t -Technical, economic, and environmental potentia s”, Cem Concr Res., 91, pp 399–404, 2017 [12] T.T Le, S.A Austin, S Lim, RABuswell, A.G.F Gibb, T Thorpe, “ ix si n and fresh properties for high-performance printing concr t ” Mater Struct 45 (2012) 1221-1232 [13] R A Buswell, W R Leal de Silva, S Z Jones, and J Dirrenberger, “ printin usin concr t xtrusion roa map or r s arch”, Cem Concr Res., 112, pp 37–49, 2018 [14] https://www.designboom.com/architecture/shanghai-3d-printedconcrete-bridge-jcda-01-21-19/ [15] https://baomoi.com/nha-noi-in-3d-hoan-thanh-trong-48-gio-ton-tai-mottheky/c/35301980.epi?fbclid=IwAR2KHDRxuq5YPiHDaUmAg41WD2 zxEM_d9pWi9asBM8Zh-toG58V-is5 nU uy n h [16] ồn c c t nh ch t in ” hun uy n h nh Đ t “ hi n cứu ch t o v t n cốt s i po ypropy n s u n v n tốt n hiệp s r n ụn tron c n n hệ Đ i c ch hoa TP.HCM, 2020 uy n i n [17] in ” n “ hi n cứu ch t o u n v n tốt n hiệp s t n c r n Đ i nh t ph h p ể c ch hoa TP.HCM, 2020 [18] https://www.designboom.com/technology/chinese-winsun-3d-prints-sixstory-apartment-mansion-building-01-20-2015/ [19] an r t a “ i ita Concr t RILEM Tech Lett., vol 1, p 67, 2016 148 pportuniti s an Cha n s” r [20] a raus ach r chth rin “ tu ying printability of fresh concrete for formwork free concrete on-site 3D printin t chno o y C rint ” 25th Conference on Rheology of Building Materials, Regensburg, 2016 [21] L Anell, Concrete 3D Printer, Lund University, Sweden, 2015 an [22] G Ma, “ critica r vi w o pr paration si n an workability measurement of concrete material for largescale 3D printin ” Front Struct Civil Eng (2017) 1-19 [23] Jonathan Thomas Kuchem “Development of test methods for characterizing extrudability of cement-based materials for use in 3D printing” Masters Theses, summer 2019 [24] Yi Wei Daniel Tay, Ye Qian, Ming Jen Tan, “Printability region for 3D concr t printin usin s ump an s ump ow t st” Composites Part B, 174, 2019 [25] A.V Rahul, Manu Santhanam, “Evaluating printability of concretes containin i htw i ht coars a r at s” Cement and Concrete Composites, 109, 2020 n inh [26] iệt inh h ơn n hiệm v ĩnh v c [27] o run h nh uy n n u n t số t n in t iệu v o c o tổn t t iệu i th o y t i C ụn c n n hệ in iện n y n uy n C n t qu n hi n cứu th c hoa h c th iện t iệu mã số y -20, tron ch t o v t iệu x y n i u n ni n n m n t i“ – i hi n cứu ứn n t nh n n cao” [28] Pegna, J., Exploratory investigation of solid freeform construction Automation in construction, 1997 5(5): p 427-437 [29] https://forcetechnology.com/en/articles/3d-printing-technology-needsnew-standards 149