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bjectives Level Focus Level Criteria C1 Sub Criteria @ )* $ C2 C’1 C’2 A1 A2 ……… ……… Cn-1 Cn C’n-1 C’n An-1 An-2 ' ……… ? #$ ) #( $ * + )*, - ( +% $ $ ? & ) $ " & ( " " $$ & " & $ $ ( $ " & & " $ &( " / " 44 & $ " $ $ & ; +< < , No Domain name Decision Maker/ Group Decision Maker DSS/GDSS identification / Training Quality and Quality Assurance of VNU Evaluation of the domain in specifications TQM Evaluation ( a group of experts) Top administration (Dean) X Top Staff X Top Instructor X Alternatives TQM Evaluation ( Decision maker) TQM evaluation for faculty / college of VNU $ * ; ( $ $ *: & &+ ( $ ", *( ' + " & " " A & ( + " ") B " " A " !9 ( & ( < & " " $ ( $ < $$ (8 & " !9 !9 " +% , " , & !9 < $ " & *2* +% & "0 ' < "( " 88 ( $0 " & & " *2* " & +% $ $ " " ' ' &0 & ' ( ( ' / "" " & & $ " & "( ( $ ( " $ *2* " * "( $ *2* " " $ ( &$ $ $ *2 * "0 $ " & ; # A * " " " $ " " ( , " " " $ " & , ' " $ " & ' = $" & " ' " ' " ( $$ & * " $$ " * * & +% $ & " & " * " & $ $ "* '3 / & " * ' & " '3 ( ( $ " < ? %9 *2* "0 ' ? ( ( + $ ( D' C ... #$ + )*, ) #( $ * $ $ Objectives Level Focus Level Criteria C1 Sub Criteria @ )* $ C2 C? ?1 C’2 A1 A2 ……… ……… Cn -1 Cn C’n -1 C’n An -1 An-2 ' ……… ? #$ ) #( $ * + )*, - ( +% $ $ ? & ) $ " & ( "... & & " $ &( " / " 44 & $ " $ $ & ; +< < , No Domain name Decision Maker/ Group Decision Maker DSS/ GDSS identification / Training Quality and Quality Assurance of VNU Evaluation of the domain in... #$ ! $ & ' $ * $ #$ ! ) $ * #( #( + )*, - *$ $ * $ !/ !/ / $ ' - &#) & ! &1 "( +% $ " & " $ " , ( +% $ "( $ * ' "0 " *2* *2* ( "0 "0 " $ $ " & " ' ( "( $ " $ ' & +% $ $ "