Full E-magazine Forbes English version (copyright)
Trang 1APRIL 2013
10 INSPIRING WOMEN FOR 2013
AMANCIO ORTEGA
$57 BILLION
THE RICHEST PEOPLE IN THE WORLD
• $5.4 TRILLION COMBINED WEALTH
Trang 2Mayapada Tower, Ground Floor – 3rd Floor Jend Sudirman Kav.28 Jakarta 12920 – IndonesiaPhone : +62 21 5212288, +62 21 5212300
Leading you to Indonesia
For over two decades, Bank Mayapada has proven to be a strong and reputable bank
in Indonesia We offer a wide range of financial services to meet our clients’ personalized
business needs supported by state of the art IT and knowledgeable staff With over than
170 branches in 19 provinces in Indonesia, Bank Mayapada will continue to serve the ever
growing economy in Asia.
Trang 3Mayapada Tower, Ground Floor – 3rd Floor Jend Sudirman Kav.28 Jakarta 12920 – IndonesiaPhone : +62 21 5212288, +62 21 5212300
Leading you to Indonesia
For over two decades, Bank Mayapada has proven to be a strong and reputable bank
in Indonesia We offer a wide range of financial services to meet our clients’ personalized
business needs supported by state of the art IT and knowledgeable staff With over than
170 branches in 19 provinces in Indonesia, Bank Mayapada will continue to serve the ever
growing economy in Asia.
Trang 42 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
Indonesia
8 | FACT & COMMENT // Steve Forbes
They succeed by meeting your needs.
10 | ThOughT lEADERS // Paul Johnson
The war on drugs a defining moment.
11 | DElIVERINg INFRASTRuCTuRE // Raj Kannan
Taking the bull by the horns.
ISSuES & IDEAS
12 | SOCCER DIplOMACy
Australia’s Intrepid Mines is using soccer diplomacy and other tactics
to regain a stake in the Tujuh Bukit gold mine, worth billions
By Jeffrey Hutton
16 | VOx pOpulI ONlINE
PoliticaWave’s Sony Subrata and Yose Rizal have tapped social media
to make more accurate political predictions
By Sonya angraini
18 | FRESh ThOughT // Taufik Darusman
Hard truth.
19 | REAlITy ChECk // James Kallman
Paying for privacy.
20 | glOBAl VIEwpOINT // Jennie S Bev
2020 megatrends and Indonesia.
21 | guEST COluMN // Eric Lascelles
Looking for trouble in Indonesia.
INSpIRINg wOMEN
23 | 10 INSpIRINg wOMEN
These 10 women have succeeded in various endeavors, and represent a diversity
of backgrounds They show how women can and do have a major impact
in whatever is their chosen profession or passion.
40 | 10 hONOR ROll
For good measure, we have included another 10 on our honor roll
CoVer PHotograPH By
DuSko DeSPotoViC / Sygma / CorBiS
p Page 24
“When I started
the sIntesa group
In 1999, I told my
father that I Was
no longer hIs staff
but hIs partner.”
— shInta KamdanI,
ChIef exeCutIve sIntesa group
Trang 5ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 3
Trang 64 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
BIllIONAIRES
48 | ThE TOp 20
This elite group is worth $714 billion, $80 billion more than last year
52 | INDONESIA’S RIChEST
With 25 billionaires, Indonesia now ranks ahead of Japan in billionaires.
54 | FROM OlIgARCh TO pRESIDENT?
Mikhail Prokhorov is a tycoon in Russia, Jay-Z’s partner in Brooklyn—and a strong candidate to eventually replace Vladimir Putin in the Kremlin, a prospect the
billionaire is turning into his full-time job.
By katya SoLDak
60 | DOgS BARk, BuT ThE CARAVAN ROllS
Pham Nhat Vuong’s valuation defies a fiercely difficult property sector in Vietnam.
By Lan anH nguyen
ENTREpRENEuR
64 | FlORAl BEAuTy
Harijanto Setiawan has successfully transformed flowers
into art with extraordinary value.
By yeSSar roSenDar
67 | CEO wISDOM // Andrew Tani
Dragon boat leader.
73 | lEgAl VIEw // Eddy Leks
Balancing franchise growth with aid to SMEs.
FORBES lIFE
74 | wARRIORS, hORSES & BlOOD
On Sumba, the ancient pasola battle still thrives to help secure a good harvest.
By muHammaD faDLi
78 | ThE EyE // Yessar Rosendar
Page 68 u
“my dream Is that In the
future, When people
talK about CeramIC
tIles, arWana Is the fIrst
name they thInK of.”
bag has a soul
and story behInd
It I belIeve that’s
Why people
appreCIate It.”
— nanCy goh,
founder bagterIa bag
Trang 7ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 5 CIMB NIAGA APRIL 2013 EDIT.pdf 1 3/22/13 6:54 PM
Trang 86 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
FORBES INDONESIA
siDelines
One of the missions of Forbes Indonesia is to provide role models and,
by extension, inspiration, whether one is an aspiring entrepreneur or
an established billionaire This issue has not one but two sets of role models to provide inspiration The first is our cover subject of billionaires, the wealthiest role models on the planet They show what can be done—on a grand scale Their stories are varied—these men and women come from a wide variety
of backgrounds and experience, demonstrating that the path to great wealth is not a narrow one but one with many avenues of opportunity
For a near-perfect example, we have in this issue a profile of the first lionaire in Vietnam, Pham Nhat Vuong of the Vingroup Turning closer to home, what is happening here in Indonesia in the billionaire arena is also inspiring The country can now boast it has 25 billionaires In the Asia-Pacific region, this figure puts Indonesia as the home to the fifth-largest group of billionaires, ahead
bil-of much wealthier countries such as Australia, Japan and Singapore
The second group in this issue to bring inspiration is our inaugural set of
10 inspiring women, accompanied by an honor roll of another set of 10 women Unlike the billionaires list, these women are not all entrepreneurs Instead the idea was to present a cross section of disciplines, such as politicians, celebrities and athletes By doing this, it shows that inspiration for women can come in many areas of endeavor and that women are achieving success in a variety of fields Entrepreneur Shinta Dhanuwardoyo pioneered the Internet advertising agency Bubu, a sector that normally is dominated by men At one trade show
in the early days of her company, a potential customer kept asking to speak to her boss, refusing to believe that a women could hold that position Our private equity investor Veronica Lukito of Ancora notes that companies that include a mix of men and women perform better than those without women Veronica too has succeeded in another male-dominated industry
One of the points of presenting this group of 20 women is not to do a long list—it is meant to be more of a sample showing the diversity of accomplish-ment One area of disappointment is that unfortunately these two lists don’t have any area of overlap The 25 Indonesian billionaires don’t include a single woman Indonesia has come a long way, and women are rising in the ranks of accomplished businesspeople, both in stature and net worth Under “lifetime achievement” we include Martha Tilaar, as she is truly a pioneer of women en-trepreneurs for the country, starting with one small beauty salon in 1970 Yet this lack on the billionaires list could also be a source of inspiration, for perhaps there is a woman out there who will strive to claim the title to be the first to enter the billionaires club Having a woman billionaire would no doubt inspire others to follow in her footsteps f
InSPIRIng
RoLE MoDELS
Indonesia
Justin Doebele Chief Editorial Advisor editor@forbesindonesia.com
eDitoriaL DePartment
Chief editorial advisor Justin Doebele
editor-at-Large Taufik Darusman
managing editor Ferry Irwanto
Senior Writers Ardian wibisono
Writers ulisari Eslita, gloria haraito,
Renjani puspo Sari
reporters Sonya Angraini, yessar Rosendar
art Director Mirna lidya Aprilla
Photo editor Ahmad Zamroni
executive assistant Seli widiati
BuSineSS DePartment
Publisher Jusuf wanandi
associate Publisher grace wong
Circulation & Subscription manager Andriansyah
Circulation executive Fitriyah
Production manager Mudafid Riyanto
Senior adv manager Tanti Jumiati
Senior adv Sales executive hilman Ahmad
Pr & event manager Rafki Ismael
executive assistant marketing Nancy heryana
accounting manager Indrawati Sonjaya,
Benny Tjoa
accounting Supervisor Inge Stephanie
accounting executives Tjhin Anna
administrative assistant Dahlia komala Sari
Pt WaHana meDiatama
President Director Millie Stephanie
Vice President Director Victoria Tahir
President Commissioner Jonathan Tahir
Vice President Commissioner Maria lukito
forBeS meDia LLC
Chairman & editor-in-Chief Steve Forbes
President & Ceo Mike perlis
Chief Product officer lewis D’Vorkin
Ceo / asia william Adamopoulos
editor, forbes asia Tim Ferguson
forBeS inDoneSia is published by PT Wahana Mediatama under
a license agreement with Forbes LLC, 60 Fifth Avenue, New York,
New York 10011 “FORBES” is a trademark used under license from
FORBES LLC.
©2010 PT Wahana Mediatama • ©2010 FORBES LLC, as to material
published in the U.S Edition of FORBES All Rights Reserved.
©2009 FORBES LLC, as to material published in the edition of
FORBES ASIA All Rights Reserved.
FORBES INDONESIA is published monthly, 12 times per year
Copying for other than personal use or internal reference or of
articles or columns not owned by FORBES INDONESIA without
written permission of FORBES INDONESIA is expressly prohibited.
ContaCt information
forbes indonesia: Menara Sudirman 19th Floor Suite 19D,
Jl Jendral Sudirman Kav 60, Jakarta 12190 Tel: (021) 522 6828,
Fax: (021) 522 7208 Website: www.forbesindonesia.com
: Forbes Indonesia Magazine : @forbes_id
Subscriber enquiries: Please contact Circulation Division SMS to
0817 0109 777, email: circulation@forbesindonesia.com Or visit
www.forbesindonesia.com to subscribe or advertise Single copy
price Rp 50,000, local subscription rate
Rp 420,000 + postal fee (Jabodetabek) for 12 issues.
april 2013 • Volume 4 issue 4
Trang 9ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 7
Trang 108 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
Fact & comment — steve ForBes
FORBES INDONESIA
“With all thy getting, get understanding”
The impressive increase in the
net worth of the world’s billionaires
and the fact that there are 200 more of
these folks than there were a year ago
will have leftists everywhere decrying
the growing gap between the haves and
the have-nots After all, they’ll howl,
why should the ranks and wealth of the
wealthy grow while most of the world’s
economies are struggling? But don’t
blame these rich for the governments’
poor economic policies More to the
point, the overwhelming majority of
these people have moved ahead through meeting
the needs and wants of other people, not through
inheritances or crony capitalism Their successes
didn’t come at the expense of everyone else
Free-market capitalism is not a zero-sum system
In fact, we should take heart from this list It
demonstrates that, despite pervasive antigrowth
policies almost everywhere, the entrepreneurial
spirit is showing surprising resiliency worldwide
Amancio Ortega from Spain has displaced
Warren Buffett in the No 3 spot by providing
low-priced fashions GoPro’s Nicholas Woodman
demonstrates that you can take your passion and
become rich pursuing it: Who’d have thought that
a guy interested in dangerous, high-skill sporting
activities would come to be worth $1 billion
and not just another bum? Tory Burch was an
unknown just a few years ago As was Diesel jeans
mogul Renzo Rosso
We’ve already seen astonishing rises in the
glob-al standard of living since the fglob-all of the Berlin Wglob-all
and the abandonment of communism in China
Someday the current bout of government economic
malpractice will pass, and it will be the
conven-tional wisdom of governments to pursue low-tax
and sound-money policies The impressive upward
march of humanity will again resume vigorously
ThEy SuCCEED
By MEETINg yOuR NEEDS
The Daily Show’s Jon Stewart should be awarded a Nobel Prize in economics The Nobel committee wouldn’t even have to issue a new one; it could just
revoke the one it awarded to New
York Times columnist Paul Krugman
in 2008 In January Stewart spoofed the idea of the trillion-dollar platinum coin, which had been floated as a way
of getting around the ceiling on the national debt The debt-ceiling crisis will reemerge soon, as will this silly proposal—the notion that the Treasury can mint such a coin and then turn
it in to the Federal Reserve for cash to keep the government going
Money out of thin air! Why wasn’t this thought of before? As Stewart asked, why not a
$20 trillion coin? You can watch his hilarious take
at january-10-2013/the-trillion-dollar-coin
http://www.thedailyshow.com/watch/thu-You’d think the coin nostrum was invented as
a joke by Saturday Night Live or The Daily Show,
but people like Krugman take it oh-so-seriously After all, as Krugman said, “Money is a social contrivance,” something to be played with for our own good by our betters in Washington Krugman
is so self-serious that he lashed out at Jon Stewart, calling him lazy and accusing him and his staff of a
“lack of professionalism.”
Stewart understood the issue all right: It is idiotic and destructive Stewart noted that “we need to take the U.S dollar seriously again.” Amen
to that!
Perhaps we should draft Jon Stewart to replace Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, whose monetary policies are doing immense harm to the U.S and global economies f
A nobel Man
By SteVe forBeS, eDitor-in-CHief
Trang 11ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 9
Trang 1210 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
thought leaDers
paul Johnson — current events
The BriTish government’s bill to
make gay marriage legal has already
had serious consequences It has split
the Conservative Party wide open
and threatens to make its defeat in
the next election, already quite likely,
absolutely certain It may also have
di-sastrous effects on the churches
An-glicans, belonging to a church that is
established by law as a national body,
are afraid that if the bill becomes law
any of their clergy who refuse to
per-form a same-sex marriage ceremony
will face criminal prosecution
Law-yers foresee years of intense
argu-ment, appeals and counter- appeals,
accompanied by fat fees, stretching
into the indefinable future
Once something is legal there’s
nothing to prevent a lobby being
formed by those who participate
in that activity, especially if there’s
money to be made An important
example of this is the movement to
legalize recreational drugs
The war on drugs is difficult and
expensive, and there are signs that
it is faltering, with battle lines being
drawn Many people, particularly in
the entertainment industry, are
al-ready campaigning to legalize a
vari-ety of so-called soft (or recreational)
drugs, such as marijuana Indeed,
pro-drug lobbies already exist here in
the U.K and in the U.S
If society gives way on this, the
consequences will be momentous,
precisely because the profits to be
made from the marketing and selling
of soft drugs will be enormous There
will be nothing to prevent a
large-scale international corporation being
formed solely to manufacture and
circulate such drugs Equally, ing pharmaceutical companies will be able to enter the trade The competi-tion will be fierce, which alone will drive down prices The products will
exist-be “improved” and exist-become more luring In no time supermarkets and corner shops will be selling marijua-
al-na, and the term “drugstore” will quire a new and deadlier meaning
ac-Vast sums will be spent on motion, especially among the young
pro-Equally large amounts of money will become available to expand the scope
of decriminalization, redefining the border between soft and hard drugs to eventually include heroin
And what of the violent criminal elements already involved in the drug trade—the Taliban, which sells and ships the fruit of the poppy out
of Afghanistan, and the cartels in South and Central America that run drugs into Mexico and the U.S.? The violence surrounding the drug trade will only escalate
Another possibility to consider is that a rogue state, such as North Korea, will enter the burgeoning drug market
North Korea’s evil regime survives by
performing tasks no other government
is able or willing to contemplate For instance, it has supplied nuclear tech-nology to other rogue states in contra-vention of all international law Both Syria and Iran have paid North Korea
in gold for its aid in their nuclear forts There is no way to stop these transactions as long as China refuses to take punitive steps against its former military and ideological ally
ef-TIPPIng THE BALAncE
Recreational drugs are comparatively easy for a ruthless and determined government to grow and/or manufacture Supplying these drugs
to Americans is precisely the kind
of prospect that would appeal to the North Korean leadership They’ve always claimed that capitalist democracies are essentially corrupt and decadent This would enable them to “prove” it, especially if the release of vast quantities of cheap soft drugs into Western cities were followed by an increase in the supply and use of hard drugs, as many experts believe would be inevitable.China, which has a drug problem
of its own, might be prepared to act against North Korea in this context But it would extract a high price from the West, which might result in the balance of power in the Pacific tilting
in China’s favor
I’ve been discussing possibilities But in the world of highly dangerous drugs, it’s safer to treat possible outcomes as probabilities If we allow this drug use to become legal, we’ll be embarking on a voyage into horror with our eyes open f
THE wAR on DRugS
A DEFInIng MoMEnT
PauL JoHnSon, EMINENT BRITISh hISTORIAN AND AuThOR; DaViD maLPaSS, glOBAl ECONOMIST, pRESIDENT OF ENCIMA glOBAl llC; amity SHLaeS, DIRECTOR, ThE 4% gROwTh pROJECT, gEORgE w BuSh INSTITuTE; AND Lee kuan yeW, FORMER pRIME MINISTER OF SINg ApORE, ROTATE IN wRITINg ThIS COluMN TO SEE pAST CuRRENT EVENTS COluMNS, VISIT OuR wEBSITE AT WWW.forBeS.Com/CurrenteVentS.
Trang 13ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 11
In Indonesia’s realm of
in-frastructure, the role of the
Ministry of Finance (MoF) in
infrastructure delivery has
re-mained somewhat ad hoc For
years, the market has been hoping for
a more direct involvement from MoF
in infrastructure delivery, in
particu-lar to increase the level of certainty of
the government’s contractual
obliga-tions under a concession agreement
To its credit, the MoF in recent
years had taken some concrete steps to
improve the certainty of investment in
infrastructure projects by creating
in-stitutions and products that included
the establishment of Indonesia
Infra-structure Guarantee Fund (IIGF), an
agency to guarantee the government’s
contractual obligations under a
con-cession agreement for public private
partnership (PPPs) projects and the
launch of viability gap funding (VGF)
to improve projects’ bankability
While IIGF is doing a great job
in its role as the extended arm of the
MoF, the implementation of VGF has
somewhat floundered since most
proj-ects seeking VGF have been poorly
prepared and lacked a risk framework
acceptable to the MoF For these
rea-sons, the MoF is finally taking the
pro-verbial bull by the horns and decided
to establish a public private
partner-ship unit directly under its wings
This new institutional framework
enables the MoF to assess and vet the
government’s fiscal support much
earlier in the project cycle, via its Risk
Management Unit (RMU) This step
negates the possibility of government
agencies going through the tender
pro-cess that effectively wastes the private
sector’s time—now projects that would never qualify for government fiscal support will not reach tender stage
Part of this new infrastructure livery paradigm is also the increased recognition that the government must pay for strategic infrastructure proj-
de-ects that are not yet fully financially viable In my previous column, I al-luded to a newly proposed procure-ment concept called a Performance Based Annuity Scheme (PBAS) that could likely become a de facto pro-curement method for government funding of infrastructure I am happy
to say PBAS is getting a good hearing
PBAS, in simple terms, is a PPP scheme where a government con-tracting agency (GCA), say a toll road regulator, seeks proposals from a
private consortium to design, build, finance and operate a toll road that is not financially viable but is needed for its economic importance However,
to avoid the past problem of the ernment receiving substandard proj-ects, a PBAS concession agreement will stipulate that no payments will be made until and unless the private sec-tor delivers the project as agreed.Once achieved, the GCA will make annuity payments for the agreed pe-riod, say 10 years During the conces-sion period the project consortium will also be paid separate fees for op-erations and maintenance of the toll road, also subject to performance No doubt, a PBAS scheme is a contingent liability on the government, which is why its usage must be controlled with the right risk level—something that should involve institutions such as the RMU and IIGF From the private sector, the key success factor for schemes like PBAS is their ability to convince investors that they can complete their projects Ac-cordingly, the completion guar-antees from the consortium’s contractors become important and the banks may require the contractors to joint venture with more capable part-ners PBAS may also spur the introduc-tion of new financing schemes such as project bonds tied to annuity payments
gov-In summary, the establishment of the new PPP unit directly under the MoF and government schemes like PBAS are positive news for fixing the infrastructure gap I am hopeful that the new Minister of Finance will continue to spearhead these reforms f
the mof Is fInally taKIng the proverbIal bull by the horns and deCIded
to establIsh a publIC prIvate partnershIp unIt dIreCtly under Its WIngs
Trang 1412 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
FORBES INDONESIA
ISSUES & IDEAS INTREPID mINES
The Tujuh BukiT gold deposit has
reserves possibly around two million
ounces—worth at least $3 billion, along
with significant deposits of silver (80
million ounces) and copper (7 million
ounces) Ownership of that gold mine,
which could become one of the largest
in Indonesia, is at the center of a
strug-gle between two powerful and wealthy
tycoons The tug-o-war has attracted
lawsuits, investigations, political
ma-neuvering and plenty of controversy
On one side is the Australia-based and
listed Intrepid Mines and the other
is its former joint venture partner PT
Indo Multi Niaga (IMN)
Into the fray last September
stepped Clayton “Tony” Wenas, 49, as
Intrepid’s executive general manager
for Indonesia Intrepid chose Tony,
in part, because of his local
knowl-edge and government contacts
We-nas is currently vice chairman of the
Indonesian Mining Association and a
former executive vice president and
general counsel of PT Freeport “We
were looking for a prominent
resourc-es businresourc-ess leader who had strong
relationships with various levels of
government and communities,” says
Intrepid’s Chief Executive Brad
Gor-don in emailed comments “Tony is
right up there with the best.”
Among other tactics, Tony is taking
the battle to the soccer field This month
he hopes to kick off the company’s first
sponsored soccer event in
Banyuwa-ngi regency, the home of Tujuh Bukit
Intrepid will pay for a tournament, its
prizes and even the uniforms if needed
by any of the participating teams
It sounds like a small step, Wenas
admits But in Indonesia, where
rela-tionships count in business, gestures
like these can make a difference “In
Indonesia you have to show people
you care,” says Wenas Intrepid needs
to win a few hearts and minds It is
scrambling to raise its profile after
Australia’s Intrepid Mines is using soccer diplomacy and other tactics to regain a stake in the Tujuh Bukit gold mine, worth billions
By Jeffrey Hutton
Clayton “tony” Wenas
Trang 15ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 13
“We want to operate the mine,”
says Wenas “We were cheated
We’re the good guys in this.”
claiming its joint venture partner IMN
secretly sold out its share to new
own-ers who, in July last year, with the help
of police, forced Intrepid off the
devel-opment in East Java
In return, last August Intrepid
enlisted the help of media mogul
and potential presidential candidate
Surya Paloh, allocating him 5% of the
company’s shares, which he can sell if
the company’s fortunes improve (he
reportedly also has an option to buy
another 10%) The company is
apply-ing for a local business license and
has asked Indonesian police to help it
regain access to some of its property,
from which it remains locked out
Aside from a loss of future
rev-enues, Intrepid also stands to lose
nearly A$106 million already spent
over five years through December
2012 developing Tujuh Bukit (also
known as the Seven Hills project) At
present, hopes of winning back Tujuh
Bukit may be fading as the impasse
drags on In December, Brad and his
chairman, Ian McMaster, said Intrepid
is pursuing IMN through the police,
accusing them of fraud and
embezzle-ment Intrepid said in a statement to
the Australian stock exchange that
husband and wife Maya Ambarsari
and Reza Nazaruddin transferred 80%
of their company IMN to a subsidiary
called Bumi Sukses Indo with links to
billionaire Edwin Soeryadjaya
The most recent disclosures show
Maya and Reza are no longer
share-holders of the company which holds
the license to mine Tujuh Bukit In
an interview with Australian media,
Edwin, while denying any interest in
IMN or Tujuh Bukit, reportedly offered
Intrepid a cut of the mine’s royalties
and what appeared to be a return of the
money spent developing the project
“We want to operate the mine,”
says Wenas “We were cheated
We’re the good guys in this.” IMN
didn’t respond to repeated requests
for interviews Wenas and Paloh are
trying to win friends where they can
Toward the end of last year Wenas and
Paloh paid a visit to Banyuwangi for
the opening festivities for the coastal
city’s three-day bicycle race and met with local leaders To commemorate Idul Adha, the Muslim day of sacrifice last October, when livestock are slaughtered to distribute meat to the poor, Wenas had Intrepid deliver six cows to surrounding villages
But Intrepid’s and Wenas’s ing and dealing may all be too little too late The company has lost 90% of its value since hitting a high in April
wheel-2011 around A$2 a share The current share price reflects little more than the A$108 million in cash the compa-
ny has on hand The company said in February its loss more than doubled to A$71.8 million during the 12 months ended December 31, 2012, compared with a year earlier
“Getting Paloh on board, this is stuff they should have down a long time ago,”
says Peter Gray, an analyst with cial firm Hartley’s in Perth “It’s been going on for so long, it’s hard to see how Intrepid walks away with an interest in the asset.” Cases like Intrepid’s add to Indonesia’s risk profile for international investors “Considerations of corporate governance will make Indonesia a hard sell,” says Bill Sullivan, a lawyer with law firm Christian Teo Purwono and partners in Jakarta
finan-Last year, Canada’s Fraser tute’s annual survey of mining com-panies found Indonesia regulatory environment had deteriorated for a fourth consecutive year, ranking ninth from the bottom as the riskiest place
Insti-to explore and mine resources, below countries such as Niger and Laos
Under its 2007 agreement with IMN, Intrepid paid to develop the mine while IMN managed public and government relations as well as secur-
ing necessary permits Once tional, Intrepid was supposed to reap 80% of the mine’s income But without much local presence, the company was vulnerable—it didn’t even have an of-fice here until after the July lockout
opera-“As a foreign investor, don’t give everything to the local partner The foreign investor needs to be involved
in meetings with government officials and media,” Wenas says “Otherwise they wonder ‘who are you?’ All we know is IMN.” By Intrepid’s account, IMN failed to secure a key permit that allowed foreign companies to operate domestic mining projects in 2009
Known as a PMA or Penanaman
Modal Asing, the permit would ognize foreign ownership of the joint venture project at Tujuh Bukit Secur-ing the PMA was a top priority for Brad who convened monthly meetings between the joint venture partners, according to sources But even as In-trepid was shelling out millions every month, IMN said local issues such as regional elections and the transition to
rec-a new rec-administrrec-ation rec-after mid-2010 slowed the approval process
One way out of the impasse is that Wenas hints that Intrepid may accept
a lower stake in the project to resolve the issue, pointing out that under the agreement Intrepid is entitled to at least half of Tujuh Bukit So far, major shareholders appear to be backing Intrepid’s current board, if only because work on the mine is continu-ing despite the impasse With plenty of cash left in reserves Intrepid has sworn to use it to regain control of Tujuh Bukit “I was hired to run a business,” Wenas says, “But first I have
to be sure I have a business to run.” F
Surya Paloh edwin Soeryadjaya
Trang 1614 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
Trang 17ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 15
Trang 1816 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
ISSUES & IDEAS — SOCIAL mEDIA
FORBES INDONESIA
LasT year, jakarTa was engrossed in The
gu-bernatorial election, and most pollsters predicted a reelection
for incumbent Governor Fauzi Bowo A small startup firm
PoliticaWave, founded only in May, chose to be different Two
weeks before the vote, it announced that former Solo mayor
Joko Widodo (Jokowi) would win the election, a prediction
at odds with the conventional wisdom As the election went
to a second round, PoliticaWave stuck by its prediction It
turned to be right as Jokowi won 53% of the vote
The secret to PoliticWave’s accuracy? “We monitor
social media so we can get insights all the time and this
information is continuously updated,” says Yose Rizal,
co-founder and director at PoliticaWave
PoliticaWave is a joint venture between two companies: PT Tridaya, owned by Sony Subrata, and PT Mediawave, owned by Yose The pair set up PoliticaWave
to monitor social media related to political issues, and uses its website to publish its findings Tridaya is engaged with government relations while Mediawave monitors social media for companies
The pair’s success with Jokowi wasn’t a one-off success
In the recent gubernatorial election in West Java, caWave announced that the incumbent Ahmad Heryawan and running mate Deddy Mizwar would lead the election with more than 30% of the vote The final result published
Politi-by the General Elections Commission (KPU) were precisely
PoliticaWave’s Sony Subrata and Yose Rizal have tapped social media
to make more accurate political predictions
By Sonya angraini
Sony Subrata (left) and yose rizal.
Trang 19ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 17
While monitoring social media for political
sentiments is common practice in the U.S and
other countries, PoliticaWave appears to be the
first to bring this technique to Indonesia
in line with that forecast Now the pair are focusing on the
gubernatorial election in Bali, which will be held in May
The two originally didn’t think of monitoring social
media for political trends, but then had an insight “If
we could measure what people think about certain
brands, then why don’t we use it for political issues?” says
President Director Sony Social media is a powerful way
to gauge public opinion as it spreads ideas that influence
political conditions, he adds
As many know, Indonesia ranks among the world’s top
five countries in the number of Facebook and Twitter
ac-counts While monitoring social media for political
senti-ments is common practice in the U.S and other countries,
PoliticaWave appears to be the first to bring this technique
to Indonesia It monitors not only Facebook and
Twit-ter, but also blogs, forums and other online outlets Unlike
polls, where respondents may not openly speak, people
are usually quite vocal on social media “People speak their
minds through this media with great candor,” says Yose
To measure social media, the pair have developed
tools to rank sentiment, such as how comments are
posi-tive or negaposi-tive on a candidate Another challenge in
monitoring social media is to find the right keywords
“Keywords need to be continuously
up-dated,” says Yose, adding that many use
slang, dialects and languages other than
Bahasa Indonesia Yose also says one has
to differentiate between
machine-gen-erated tweets and real ones “Campaign
managers often use automatic tweets to
increase their tweet amounts We
con-sider this spam, so we exclude them from
our consideration,” he explains
Anoth-er challenge is to detAnoth-ermine hype from
genuine tweets “People sometimes send
sensational tweets just to attract
follow-ers Because of this, many think that our
results are not credible,” says Sony “But
we do consider these accounts because
we can track their followers and analyze
their opinions.” They have also
devel-oped detailed profiles of various
politi-cians, which are available on the
Politi-caWave website
Yose says social media is being used
by a wide cross section of the population, but for now many who are active in social media are usually educated, and often from higher income levels These people will likely talk about their opinions as well in their groups, so there will be amplification, he adds Sony adds that even a small percentage of the population using social media can generate plenty of good data points to analyze
If, for instance, Internet users are only 10% out of a million people, that means PoliticaWave has 100,000 samples, Sony explains These samples generate much higher numbers compared to one-on-one surveys, which usually have at 1,000 samples “We may not have clear identification of the respondents but the amount of opinion is so big that it can’t
be ignored,” says Sony
Going forward, PoliticaWave will update its system
“Now, we can only read results of what is currently happening Next, we want to see where the trend is going,” says Yose It also plans to provide information for corporate clients related to political issues in Indonesia and analyze how this will affect business conditions in Indonesia It also plans to provide services for other institutions such as the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) or the House of Representatives to help them understand the importance of social media so they can use it as a way to communicate “People misunderstand these institutions and it’s time for them to change that image Social media is one way to do so, but if they don’t understand social media, they won’t be able to do it,” says Sony F
PoliticaWave predicted Joko Widodo’s winning in Jakarta’s gubernatorial election, two weeks before the vote by analyzing social media.
Trang 2018 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
integ-Of course, high-level government corruption exists all over the world, even in advanced countries But what seems to set Indonesia apart is the in-credible level of greed in some, if not most, in high and even low govern-
ment echelons So it’s not enough, for example, for a low level tax official
as Gayus Tambunan to help himself
to a couple of billions, as is the norm among officials in his department He had to amass about Rp 74 billion be-fore the law caught up with him
By the same token, senior nesian police official Djoko Susilo just couldn’t be happy with a house
Indo-or two and several plots of lands in his hometown in Central Java, not to mention three gas stations and a num-ber of tourist buses No mean feat for someone whose monthly salary is Rp
30 million He also has apartments in Australia and Singapore, all of which the antigraft body KPK alleges could only have been purchased with funds acquired by illegal means And this involves a person who had sought a career as a crimebuster
So how to describe survey dents who want the nation led by an
respon-“honest and pro-people” officials? Hopeless romantics? Unrealistic opti-mists? Well, perhaps In the meantime ordinary people express their disgust over corruption by using murals and wall posters to deliver their message
“God, hopefully my parents are not corrupt,” depicts one mural in Central Jakarta, while not far away a poster says: “I do not wish to have a corrupt person as my husband.”
Even today the words of the late prominent Muslim scholar Nurcholish Madjid still resonates strongly among the country’s intelligentsia: How do you reconcile Indonesia as a country with the world’s largest Muslim population with it being one of the most corrupt?
No one seems to know or even dare to seek the answer, as we often find hard truths difficult to accept F
A recent nationwide
sur-vey says that 47% of
respondents want an
“honest and
pro-peo-ple” person at the helm
of the nation, as opposed to the 1%
who prefer an “intelligent” or the 7%
for a “religious” president The
sur-vey, conducted by Pusat Data
Ber-satu (PDB, or Center of United Data),
also shows that respondents care less
about the nation’s future leader’s
eth-nic, civilian or military background
The survey reflects a significant
paradigm shift within our society For
only a few months ago many surveys
say most respondents prefer a “firm”
leader more than anything else, the
public’s allusion to their weariness of
what it sees as indecisiveness in the
current national leadership
The survey seems to suggest
that the so-called “Jokowi effect” is
beginning to kick in Jakarta Governor
Joko Widodo’s (Jokowi) transparent
and pro-people management style
has not only made him a local hero
of sorts; it has also made him the
standard against which government
leaders are measured For now, the
prevailing conventional wisdom on
leadership here seems to be that
integrity and strong connectivity to
the people matter most
With daily media coverage on
high-level corruption and on
politi-cians looking much more after their
own welfare rather than that of the
people, it is no surprise that the
public prefer integrity over
intelli-gence in their leaders By this logic,
it makes no sense having intelligent
people governing the country if they
taufik DaruSman IS ONE OF INDONESIA’S mOSt ExpERIENcED jOuRNAlIStS HE HAS HElD cHIEF EDItOR ROlES At Business Week indonesia AND investor mAgAzINES,
AND the indonesian oBserver NEwSpApER.
HIgH-level government corrUPtIon exIStS all over tHe World, even In advanced
coUntrIeS BUt WHat SeemS to Set IndoneSIa aPart IS tHe IncredIBle level oF greed.
Trang 21ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 19
With all that data out there, it’s hardly surprising that it has been investors rather than governments who have been the first to recognize the tremendous value of these assets
The valuation of the likes of Facebook, Google or Amazon, for instance, are hard to defend unless one takes into account these intangible but very real data assets that don’t appear in books
However, there have been stirrings of late and the European Union launched an initial foray into the matter of web privacy by
introduction of the EU Cookie Law, which came into effect last May and requires websites to request permission from the user before planting certain cookies on the user’s machine This law seems unlikely to have much effect, as the wording is somewhat ambiguous and most just click their acceptance
Since then, however, a report was put out in mid-January at the behest
of the French government, which raised the idea of taxing the collection
of personal data by Internet firms One can appreciate their desire,
as some $2 billion of Google’s $30 billion advertising revenue each year originates in France, and the French Treasury receives precious little in the way of tax revenue
The belief is growing that sonal data is the fuel for the digital economy, backed by the number of businesses being built on the promise
per-of mining and exploiting ever more detailed personal data Given this, there could be further investigation into possible ways of taxing the min-ing of personal data in an appropriate manner One suspects, however, that this step will require international co-operation, not least in the revision of accounting standards
It does appear that the gloves are off, however, with Google being threatened with punitive action by the data protection services of the 27
EU countries should it fail to make changes to the new privacy policy it implemented last year At the end of the day, though, it all comes down to how much the individual is prepared
to pay for their privacy F
“Civilization works only if those who
enjoy its benefits are also prepared to
pay their share of the costs.”
I can’t claim credit for the
quote, which came from a
re-cent feature on tax evasion in
the Economist, but it is timely
considering that I was just
working on preparing my annual tax
filing This quote can be tied to
anoth-er gem I came across, that each day
we are bombarded with as much data
as our ancestors just five centuries
ago received in their whole lifetime
How much of this is actually
neces-sary for us to lead productive lives may
be debatable, but there can be no doubt
that data is big business nowadays
The question to be asked, though, is: to
whom does this data actually belong
and do those who enjoy its benefits pay
their share of the costs?
Take social media, for instance
Nothing has so rapidly empowered
the right of the individual to speak out
and enjoy free speech Yet this does
not always come without cost, as for
some the use of social media may
ex-pose them to persecution in their own
land, as not all of the world’s citizens
enjoy the same freedom of expression
as in the U.S and other nations
Even in more enlightened
coun-tries, however, free speech comes at the
cost of loss of privacy, such as the buzz
of my handphone interrupting a
relax-ing evenrelax-ing with my family So from
that side of things, I’m certainly paying
for the convenience it affords me
Nevertheless, we are increasingly
living in an Orwellian world as far
as personal privacy is concerned—
JameS S kallman IS A SENIOR pARtNER OF glOBAl AccOuNtINg AND cONSultINg FIRm, mAzARS A 30-yEAR vEtERAN OF EmERgINg mARkEtS, jAmES IS AlSO tHE
pARtNER-IN-cHARgE OF mAzARS’ glOBAl EmERgINg mARkEtS pRActIcE.
tHe BelIeF IS groWIng tHat PerSonal data
IS tHe FUel For tHe dIgItal economy.
Trang 2220 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
gLObAL vIEwPOINT
JENNIE S bEv
this trend The former is now tional corporations’ favorite destina-tion for offshore call centers, while the latter is for offshore IT desks
multina-Resource scarcity is another ous issue to tackle As more stresses are placed on the globe’s megacities,
seri-resource scarcity will be more lent Increased demand for food, water, energy, land and natural resources has been exponentially amplified in an un-precedented manner Since 2002, tech-nological advancement and human inventiveness is fighting a losing battle with the law of diminishing returns
preva-According to forecasts by the IMF and the World Bank, Asia’s economic output will be sixfold of today’s, from
$30 trillion to $230 trillion by 2050
Such an increase in GDP per capita
would impose more stress on global resources due to intense consumer consumption The U.S Food and Agriculture Organization also predicts
a 40% deficit between water supply and demand by 2030
The third trend is the extreme mate change that results in a negative impact on many planetary conditions, including ocean chemistry, air qual-ity and climate The oceans are being acidified with the nitrogen and phos-phorus elements in food fertilizers leaking into bodies of water Increased number of automobiles results in in-creased air pollutants By 2050, there will be 3 billion cars worldwide.Recent worldwide severe winter storms, for instance, might be caused
cli-by Arctic warming that has shifted
wind patterns Extreme climate changes would cause increased food prices and conflicts as communities and countries battle for access to shifting areas of arable land
Many economists believe that the world economy isn’t a zero-sum game because the total sum is much greater than its parts However, it is more realistic to calculate not merely the present measurable production, but also the social debts incurring in the future F
This column is the first of two parts, the
second will appear in the May issue.
Living in a modern society
involves risks and some
are bigger than others
In 2020, the world shall
encounter an important
milestone: make it or break it
Accord-ing to economist Thierry Malleret, by
that year the six global megatrends
will be engendering worldwide
in-stability: unfavorable demographics,
resource scarcity, climate change,
geo-political rebalancing, indebtedness and
fiscal issues, and rising inequalities
The world population is aging In
developed and certain Asian countries,
the birth rate is falling Of course,
In-donesia isn’t included, which is both
a pro and a con Approximately 4
mil-lion are born in Indonesia annually,
which is almost the size of Singapore
Singapore itself is losing population
rapidly, which it attempts to offset
with encouraging immigration
poli-cies and supportive “pro baby”
taxa-tion provisions
Japan’s labor force started to
shrink in the 1980s, while South Korea
and Taiwan will be losing population
within 15 years If Indonesia can
man-age its population well with
meaning-ful social and vocational developments,
it has an unprecedented opportunity
to penetrate various job markets in
Asia and, even, worldwide The trend
of elite “national plus” bilingual and
trilingual K-12 schools is a good start
in cultivating young leaders with an
international attitude The Philippines
and India have been capitalizing on
Jennie S Bev IS AN AwARD-wINNINg AutHOR, cOlumNISt, AND ENtREpRENEuR BASED IN NORtHERN cAlIFORNIA
Trang 23ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 21
gUEST COLUmN
ERIC LASCELLES
when the global economy is suffering
a tepid recovery As such, it is useful to evaluate what could go wrong
Some threats emanate from side the country Take the possibility
out-of a sharp decline in commodity
pric-es Despite the consolation prize of a suddenly affordable energy subsidies, Indonesia would nonetheless reel if the lower commodity prices persisted for an extended period A dispropor-tionate share of growth over the past several years has been on the wings
of rising commodity prices Indonesia could easily find itself growing at just 4% per year instead of the customary 6% if conditions worsen
Even more alarming would be a
Chinese hard landing However, this risk appears small: by all accounts, China has managed a soft landing to healthier levels of growth But China has plenty of other issues, such as ex-cessive local government debt If any
of these issues were to metastasize,
a Chinese hard landing would cast shrapnel across all of Asia, most tan-gibly impacting Indonesian exports and global commodity prices and also potentially undermining financial con-ditions and confidence If there is a
scenario that could take Indonesia (and the rest
of Asia) back to the ery of 1998, this is it. Other risks are do-mestic in nature, and within Indonesia’s con-trol Inflation is a distinct risk at a time when the unemployment rate is at an all-time low, the current account has dipped into deficit, minimum wages are ris-ing quickly and credit is expanding
mis-at a heady pace Alternmis-ately, foreign investment could prove flighty given recent protectionist actions in the mining sector Indonesia is at risk of succumbing to the “resource curse” that turns resource wealth into a mill-stone around the neck of many de-veloping nations
To be clear, none of these risks are currently likely, and Indonesia’s prospects remain quite promising But the country that neglects to acknow-ledge its vulnerabilities is the one at greatest risk of suffering from them F
I was recently in Jakarta to
speak at an economic summit
on the potential threats to
Indonesia’s economy This
proved to be a surprisingly
difficult exercise, as Indonesia has
done much to shield itself from
trouble To its considerable credit,
Indonesia has managed a remarkable
combination of smooth yet rapid
economic growth for several years,
regularly outpacing its neighbors
Indonesia has nimbly deflected
any number of threats over the past
15 years The global crisis of 2008 was
little more than a blip, despite a
drop-off in global demand and commodity
prices A key source of Indonesia’s
resilience is the flexibility afforded
by a rock-bottom public debt load,
paired with sizeable foreign exchange
reserves Each is the product of 15
years of fiscal discipline
A second source of stability is the
diversity of Indonesia’s economy The
nation’s generous endowment of
nat-ural resources and substantial
manu-facturing sector provide important
off-sets to one another A large consumer
base provides a more generalized
anchor of stability Finally, Indonesia’s
relatively small trade orientation
of-fers insulation against foreign shocks
Of course, Indonesia has taken
some hard lumps The 1996 Asian
financial crisis still looms large in
the country’s psyche, and avoiding a
repeat of this experience demands
constant vigilance The margin for
error is particularly small at a time
LookIng foR TRouBLe
In IndoneSIA
eriC laSCelleS IS tHE cHIEF EcONOmISt FOR RBc glOBAl ASSEt mANAgEmENt AND SpEAkS ON EcONOmIc tOpIcS tO AuDIENcES AROuND tHE wORlD.
to ItS conSIderaBle credIt, IndoneSIa HaS managed a remarkaBle comBInatIon oF SmootH yet raPId economIc groWtH For Several yearS.
Trang 2422 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013 ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 22
task to narrow our choice to these women—yet the goal was to provide selected examples
of role models These 10 women have succeeded in various endeavors, and represent
a diversity of backgrounds They show how women can and do have
a major impact in whatever is their chosen profession
or passion For good measure, we have included another 10
on our honor roll Regardless of your gender, it is hoped that all on these lists can be a source
of inspiration.
Indonesia
Trang 25SMAILING TOUR APRIL 2013 EDIT 1 3/11/13 6:25 PM
Trang 2624 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
“When I started the Sintesa group in 1999, I told my father that I was no longer his staff but his partner,” says Shinta Kamdani.
Trang 27ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 25
Her family is Johnny Widjaja, who
is a second generation business
tycoon and who ran the Tigaraksa
conglomerate With roots going
back to 1919, the Tigaraksa group
was later absorbed by the Sintesa
group, which is controlled under PT
Widjajatunggal Sejahtera, the family’s
holding company
Growing up, Shinta remembers
few normal holidays Each time the
school holiday started, Shinta spent
most of the time by working, either in
her family business or at other private
companies Then, when she finally
took the reins in 1999, it was hardly
an auspicious time for the country A
year earlier the Asia financial crisis
had struck and the former strongman
regime of Suharto has finally ended
The outlook for Indonesia was
uncer-tain, with numerous family
business-es going bankrupt or struggling with
major debts Yet Shinta rolled up her
sleeves and set to work
She had two goals One was to
ensure Sintesa’s long-term success as
a sustainable business—a major goal given the business climate at the time Second, the group had centralized management in the founder and then the son As the third generation to take the reins, Shinta was determined to turn Sintesa into a more professionally managed business, while still keeping
it under family control (only two of the 17 Sintesa group companies are publicly listed) For her success as an entrepreneur, Shinta qualifies to be named as one of ten inspiring women for this year’s list
In 1999, she inherited a tion of companies that were focused
collec-on property and industrial products Now 46, she made a major foray into energy through PT Metaepsi Pejebe Power Generation, or Mepoggen Meppogen built and operates a com-bined cycle gas power plant with 80 megawatts of capacity in South Suma-tra The plant will be connected to the South Sumatra-Riau grid Meanwhile, the gas supply is secured through an agreement with Medco E&P
Since 1999, Shinta Widjaja Kamdani has been the chief executive of the Sintesa group Her business career,
however, started much earlier At 13, she was selling
books door-to-door She is also surrounded by a family
of entrepreneurs She is married to businessman Irwan Kamdani, whose family owns IT company PT Datascript
entrepreneur
Shinta Kamdani
Chief Executive Sintesa Group
46, marrIed, 4 chIldren
Trang 2826 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
In a short run, the capacity of the
power plant will be increased by up
to 30 megawatts In order to realize
the plan, at the end of last year Sintesa
secured a $100 million loan from Bank
Internasional Indonesia to develop the
project, as it requires $120 million to
increase the capacity In Banten,
Sinte-sa has a gas power plant, which
pres-ently has 110 megawatts of capacity
and will be developed into 340
mega-watts in a few years This year the
power plant will start to be exploited
“I believe in the next five years the
energy sector will play a major role
within the group,” Shinta predicts
In a long run, Sintesa plans to build
a total of 1 gigawatt of power plants
by 2020 by adding 200 megawatts of capacity each year in order to meet the national energy needs amounting to
10 gigawatts “We plan to support the government’s plan to provide more electricity,” says Shinta, who graduat-
ed from Columbia University
Currently Sintesa is eyeing a thermal plant in North Sulawesi The group estimates it could have a capac-ity up to 50 megawatts Besides that, Shinta is preparing a bio-ethanol proj-ect in South Sulawesi To support that effort, Sintesa already has a sorghum plantation in South Sulawesi “Bio-ethanol business needs a lot of dedi-cation to make it happen Even if we don’t have the technology, we are hop-ing in the next two years we can start the business,” says Shinta Apart from the energy sector, Shinta wants to bring long-term growth to all the busi-nesses in the group “We want Sintesa
geo-to be a sustainable group,” says Shinta
In the property business, Shinta plans to expand its hotel holdings, which currently includes the Menara Peninsula Hotel in Jakarta and the Hotel Sintesa Peninsula in Manado
This year the group will inaugurate a budget hotel in South Sumatra, while
in Bali it is developing a five-star hotel
in Jimbaran Going forward, Shinta plans to develop two hotels every year “Nowadays, budget hotels have a very good demand and of course make good money If run properly, they could give a 25% margin or more,”
says Shinta
One of the group’s two public companies is distribution company Tigaraksa Satria, established in 1987
by Shinta’s father and two uncles Last year the company booked revenues
of Rp 6.5 trillion, an increase of 16%
compared to the previous year of
Rp 5.6 trillion Up until now, the distribution division had been a major
moneymaker for the group “The distribution division’s size is still the biggest in the group,” Shinta says.Before taking the top job, Shinta started her career at Tigaraksa in 1989
as regular staff Ten years later her father gave the chief executive role but spun off the distribution to her uncle Robert Widjaja and her cousin Chandra Widjaja Meanwhile, Shinta got the other parts: manufacturing, property and energy “Sintesa is my baby When I started the Sintesa group in 1999, I told my father that
I was no longer his staff but his partner,” says Shinta
Will there be a fourth generation to take over from Shinta? That decision has not been made Shinta says she
is not pushing her children to day run the business “They have their own preferences,” says Shinta “It de-pends on them.” Shinta’s sister Paquita Widjaja, for example, is a socialite and singer, and has recorded several al-bums—but is not involved in the busi-ness To fuel the entrepreneurial spirit
some-in the company, each company some-in the group has its own profit and loss ac-counting, and managers are empow-ered to make decisions on their own
“I just make the target They make it happen,” says Shinta
Source: Sintesa group material
The group has many branches,
established over many years, but with
a focus on property, industrial products,
energy and consumer products
Consumer produCts
• PT Tigaraksa Satria (1987)
• PT Biolina Trio Sintesa (1999)
• PT Cipta Sintesa Mustika (2006)
• PT Sinar Indonesia Merdeka (1979)
• PT Tanah Sumber Makmur (1986)
• PT Tekun Asas Sumber Makmur (1992)
SinteSa’S
Wide Spread
By Ulisari Eslita
Trang 29ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 27
Trang 3028 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
phIlanthropIst
Michelle Sampoerna
Chairperson Putera Sampoerna Foundation
41, marrIed, 2 chIldren
Michelle established the Putera Sampoerna
Foundation (PSF), a non-profit institution
dedicated to improving the quality of education
in the country in March 2001 With $150 million
pledged over 10 years from her father, the
billionaire Putera Sampoerna, the PSF is one of
the best-funded privately run foundations in the
country Michelle has progressively improved
the foundation’s programs, and has even helped
send some students abroad to get MBAs at
the Kellogg and Wharton business schools
in the U.S Previously, she held the position
of communications manager at the family’s
cigarette company, now majority owned by
Altria She also documented her family heritage
in a book entitled “The Sampoerna Legacy.”
Karen is the first woman head of the country’s state energy company, appointed in 2009 to a five-year term that was recently renewed for a second term Pertamina has done well under Karen, booking a net profit of Rp 26 trillion last year, the highest in the company’s history She has a long background in the industry, having served in executive positions at Mobil and Halliburton’s Indonesian operations
In 2006 Karen first joined Pertamina, heading its upstream division, and helping implement an international diversification strategy More recently she has pushed the company into developing promising coal bed methane
exeCutIve
Karen Agustiawan
Chief Executive Pertamina
Trang 31ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 29
Her films Ada Apa Dengan Cinta,
Laskar Pelangi and Sang Pemimpi
demonstrated that Indonesian films could be both well-made and
a commercial success at the box office, and helped revive the decline
in Indonesian filmmaking She has also produced the high-quality
children’s film Anak Seribu Pulau in
1996 Her original interest was music,
as her mother and father are both musicians A graduate of the Jakarta Art Institute, she wrote her first song
at 16 but later choose to focus more
on film Currently she is working
on several films, one of them titled
Sekolah Rimba inspired by the story of Butet Manurung who dedicated her life providing education for kids in a remote area of Jambi National Park
Mira Lesmana
Film Producer
48, marrIed, 2 chIldren
CreatIve talent
Trang 3230 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
build Ancora into one of the leading
local private equity firms in the
country because investors trusted her
to provide great returns
Veronica started Ancora
Interna-tional in 2007, after getting more than
ten years experience in investment
banking She earned a B.S in
Busi-ness Administration from the Haas
School of Business at the University
of California Berkeley She started
her career at Citibank Indonesia as a
banker for three years before moving
to PT Bahana Securities as assistant
vice president At Bahana, she met
Minister of Trade Gita Wirjawan, who
is the other co-founder of Ancora
In-ternational Her last position before
starting Ancora was vice president in
the investment banking division at J.P
Morgan Indonesia
In the same year it was founded,
the company acquired an oil drilling
company PT Bormindo Nusantara,
which is now consolidated under PT
Ancora Indonesia Resources with a
market capitalization of more than Rp
300 billion In 2008, through Ancora
Capital, it raised $300 million and
acquired a majority stake in
Apexin-do Pratama Duta, an oil drilling firm,
in partnership with Mitra Rajasa, a
transport company, worth Rp 5.2
tril-Conventional wisdom holds that private equity is about
managing investments Veronica Lukito, co-founder and
chief executive of PT Ancora International, says private
equity is also about managing trust For almost six years
heading the private equity firm, Veronica has managed to
fInanCe
Veronica Lukito
Chief Executive Ancora International
2 chIldren
returns than an investor could get in more liquid and safer investments However, with the returns on simple stock investing in Indonesia now fairly good, it means private equity investors must work that much harder to find returns that can beat returns from investing in listed stocks
For being a leader in the dominated field of private equity, and making a success of it, Veronica Lukito is named as one of ten inspiring women in the category of finance
male-Indeed, the strong returns of the past few years are making some investors nervous “This year the concerns in the industry are whether the hype in Indonesia is sustainable, whether the market is too crowded, and whether valuations are already too high,” Veronica adds, saying these factors could influence how future fundraising goes Despite these concerns, Veronica believes the prospects for private equity remains good in Indonesia given its strong fundamentals such as rising domestic consumption, a growing population and the isolation of the economy being protected from volatile world markets Going forward, besides natural resources, Veronica sees consumers and infrastructure as the most appealing sectors to invest in She acknowledges that some companies may be overvalued, but that the consumer industry is so wide that it still has many smaller companies that have the potential to grow bigger to invest in As for the infrastructure sector, despite many projects to invest
in, private equity companies and investors are still waiting for clear policies, such as on land clearance, the tender process, and permits
To balance her life with the busy business rhythm, Veronica spares
lion and took over Bakrie & Brothers’
debts worth $75 million in exchange for 5% of Bumi Resources shares at the time (later in 2009 it was reported that Ancora profited Rp 664 billion from selling back 4.2% of the Bumi Resources shares) Now, instead of large bets, Veronica says her firm is more focused on midsized invest-ments, ranging around $25 million
“My education background was finance, my first career was finance
at Citibank, and I was interested in learning about a business, to gauge its growth prospects, to know the risks and to be able to protect an invest-ment,” says the mom of two about why she has chosen the private equity path
“Private equity also has potential, since the total investment of private equity
in Indonesia is only $2.5 billion pared to $25 billion in India,” she says
com-With international investors eager
to put money into the country, some people think private equity is a piece
of cake, but in reality it’s a really hard work, she says “The average IRR in the industry now ranges from 20%
to 25%,” Veronica says Of course there is no guarantee that investors will get those kind of returns, and it’s precisely that risk that requires private equity investors to offer higher ahmad zamroni / f
Trang 33ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 31
not provide barriers on levels to be reached—the main criteria to advance
in the industry is the profits that a person generates, regardless of their gender She also cites research that a mix of male and female staff improves returns “I went to a women confer-ence and there was a presentation showing that a company with women employees performs better than one with none, but of course there has been no research showing a company made up entirely of female employees
is better,” she smiles
some time for travelling outside her business travels “I try to visit one
or two new places a year Last time
I went to Borobudur and stayed for a week, it’s enough to feel the ambiance of the people who live there I like to see what life is like in other countries and compare it to what it is like here,” she says Another hobby of her is music and Ancora has
a music division that helps budding Indonesian musicians
Although Veronica does not deal directly with the artists, she helps
to decide which musicians have
potential for the market One of the musicians she evaluated is Smash, an Indonesian boy band “I heard their music and I believed it was something new and could be accepted, so we decided to support them,” she says
Besides supporting Smash, Ancora’s music division also became the producer for pop singer Dewi Lestari and jazz singer Tompi
When asked whether she finds
a special challenge being a woman chief executive, Veronica says she sees finance as one of the sectors that are more open to women and do By ardian WiBisono
Veronica lukito believes the prospect for private equity remains high in Indonesia given its strong fundamentals
Trang 3432 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
@ Central Park Tribeca - UG Floor
Visit our
Marketing Gallery &
Show Unit
@ Central Park - LG Floor
Visit our Preview Lounge
Located
at Jakarta’s prominent address
Tugu Pancoran
Mixed use development
Residential Office Mall
Trang 35ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 33
@ Central Park Tribeca - UG Floor
Visit our
Marketing Gallery &
Show Unit
@ Central Park - LG Floor
Visit our Preview Lounge
Located
at Jakarta’s prominent address
Tugu Pancoran
Mixed use development
Residential Office Mall
Concept
Small Office Home Office
Flexible
payment scheme
SOHO APRIL 2013 2 HAL EDIT.pdf 1 3/22/13 4:42 PM
Podomoro City • Jl Let Jend S Parman kav 28 • Jakarta021.5698.5555
65%
Main Lobby
Sky Terrace Lift Lobby
Another Prestigious
AGUNG PODOMORO LAND
Located At The Prime Gateway Of Podomoro City
Visit our Marketing Gallery at Central Park - Tribeca on UG floor
Visit our Exhibition at Central Park Jakarta - LG floor
SOHO APRIL 2013 2 HAL EDIT.pdf 2 3/22/13 4:42 PM
Trang 3634 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
Mari is the first Chinese Indonesian woman to hold a position as a minister in
the country Mari was the Minister of Trade from 2004 to 2011 before being
reshuffled to her current position as the Minister of Tourism and Creative
Economy Mari obtained her bachelor and masters degrees from the Australian
National University, and her doctorate in economics from the University of
California at Davis, United States She was previously active at the Centre for
Strategic and International Studies and trade forums before being appointed
as minister She was also a respected figure at the WTO during her seven years
time as trade minister due to her strong stance on free trade There is talk that
she may have a shot at replacing Pascal Lamy as the director general of WTO,
after his term ends in August
polItICIan
Mari Elka Pangestu
Minister of Tourism and Creative Economy
Trang 37ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 35
Agnes started her career at the young age of six, and has made a name for herself as an award- winning, best-selling singer and highly acclaimed actress With eight albums under her belt, Agnes has gained commercial success in many countries outside Indonesia, including Brunei, Holland, Malaysia, the Philippines and Singapore After performing at the 2008 and 2009 Asia Song Festival in Seoul, Agnes also attained fame in China, Korea and Taiwan Agnes broke into the international music scene through collaborations ranging from those with American R&B singer Keith Martin to Latin heartthrob Christian Chavez She recently recorded a duet with singer Michael Bolton and is now working on
an album with rap artist Timbaland.
Trang 3836 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
Yet public opinion was on her side,
supporting the mayor’s campaign to
reduce billboards with tax increases
and other measures, saying it was a way
to stop the city from becoming a forest
of billboards
Among other issues, the mayor
had found advertising companies
were underpaying their taxes and
were able to put up billboards
any-where they wanted—such as in green
areas Agencies were also putting up
billboards in areas already crowded
with advertisements
Despite the limitations, tax
revenues for the city from billboards
actually went up due to better
Surabaya Mayor Tris Rismaharini, 51, made headlines in
January 2011 when Surabaya’s local parliament tried to
impeach her just four months after she had been sworn in
as mayor Tris was accused by the legislative assembly of
raising taxes on billboard advertising above the legal limit
regIonal
leader
Tris Rismaharini
Mayor Surabaya
51, marrIed, 2 chIldren
as one of the most environmentally friendly cities in the Asia-Pacific re-gion, scoring above Seoul, Yokohama and Penang “A city is the home for its inhabitants You should treat it like a house—you must clean it, and make it beautiful and comfortable, with lovely gardens and good facilities When you build your house, at the same time you also have to build the character of your family members, by free tuition, good public services, and entrepre-neurship And I consider Surabaya as
my home,’’ explains the mayor For her tireless work to improve Surabaya, the mayor is included on the ten inspir-ing women’s list under the category of regional leader
The style of Tris’s leadership is more like a mother than a bureaucrat The mayor likes to personally visit the slum areas, or other parts of the cit-ies, to see conditions for herself She has gone to red light districts to talk
to sex workers, hoping they’ll come in for job training For years, Surabaya was a center for human trafficking Not long after she was elected mayor, Tris was asked to close the red light districts But Tris didn’t agree with
an immediate closure “You can’t just close the areas without giving [sex workers] an alternative So, I prefer to give them job training first,” she says She has so far managed to close two red light districts, although others re-main Another priority is improving the schools In 2013, the government agreed to increase the education bud-get by around 36% to Rp 5.6 trillion Despite her good track record, Tris has made enemies from those who have a stake in the status quo She has received many death threats over the years To that she is philosophical: “I believe that my life and death belong to God.”
enforcement of the rules, even while restricting the areas where billboards could be posted Previously, the city got around Rp 91 billion from the billboard tax, and the mayor was able
to raise that to Rp 117 billion
But where Tris is best known is in improving the public parks and other green spaces She has worked to make
it more difficult to get permits to pave over mangrove areas, and launched a fine for anyone who cuts down a tree
in a public or other restricted area
“Last year, we got Rp 40 million from those illegally cut trees,” she says
Her passion for parks arises from her time as head of the city’s Mu-nicipal Environment and Sanitation department Today, Tris is working hard to add more green to the city It has, among other areas, some 30 hect-ares of gardens, 50 hectares of parks,
31 hectares of protected forests and 2,500 hectares of mangrove areas In total, about 20% of Surabaya’s 33,000 hectares are classified as green areas
“This percentage is still lower than target It should be 30 to 35% of the total,” says the mayor “We still need more areas for sport centers and camp sites Why? Teenagers love to play basketball, volley or just jogging.”
Her works are gaining tion In 2012, Surabaya was cited by international ratings agency Citynet ahmad zamroni / f
• Raised revenues from taxes on
advertising
• Defeated a plan by the central
government to build a toll road
through the middle of the city
• Launched plans to build a monorail
and tram system for the city
• Closed some red light districts
and provided job trainings to
former sex workers.
• Fired 40 city officials for being
corrupt
• Establishing rules to protect trees
in public spaces
SUrabaYa reFOrMS
By rEnjani PUsPo sari
SOME SELECTED ACHIEvEMEnTS
OF THE MAyOR:
Trang 39ApRIl 2013 FORBES INDONESIA | 37
“a city is the home for its inhabitants
You should treat it like a house—you must clean it, and make it beautiful and comfortable,” says Tris rismaharini.
Trang 4038 | FORBES INDONESIA ApRIl 2013
global
leader
Sri Mulyani
Managing Director World Bank
50, marrIed, 3 chIldren
Sri Mulyani has served
as a managing director
at the World Bank since
May 2010 There, she is
responsible for its global
operations in Asia, Africa,
Europe, Latin America, and
the Middle East, among
other responsibilities
Formerly, she was the
minister of finance and the
coordinating minister for
economic affairs During
her tenure, the country’s
tax income increased
20% annually yet she had
to leave the post due to
controversy surrounding
the Bank Century
bailout case, on which
she is scheduled to be
questioned this month by
the Corruption Eradication