Giải quyết tình huống giáo viên tố cáo hiệu trưởng không đứng lớp nhưng vẫn hưởng phụ cấp ưu đãi

BO MAO DIX VA DAO TAO TRIYONG CAN BO QUAN Lir GIAO DVC TP HO CHI MINI TIEU LON CUOI KHOA LOT b6i &tang nghiep vu cong täc vien Thanh tra gião dijc Nara - 2017 Thin tieu luan: "Gidi guy& tinh haling gido vien t4 ctio hien truintg khOng dirng ldp nhung van ngang nhién Iinh tiEn phy cap tru dai, phy cap than: mien" H9 va ten hoc vien: Cao Van Nheo Don vi cong tic Pheng Geo dye DA° t4o Tam Binh TP 118 OH MI NH, THÂNG 12/2017 MVC Lye MO clan trang 01 Nei dung trang 02 MO to tinh hueng trang 02 Xac dinh mile tieu xu ly tinh trang 02 Phan tich tinh (phan tich nguyén nhan \fa halt qua) trang 03 De xuat nh&ng giai phdp trang 06 To chirc thut hien giiti pile") de (Tat &rev nruric tieu de trang 08 Kien nghi, de xuAt trang 10 IC& 14n trang 11 Tdi lieu tham WAD trang 13 A MO" I) AU Hien Bang, Nita nu& ta, Nganh GM° due yd Dao tao chit twang, trien khai thkrc hien Nghi quyet Hei nghl Trung trang khoa XI (NQ 29-NQ/TW) de ra, Dai hei Dang Mn Mir XII de phuang hmang: Gido dye la gate sdch hang dam Phat trien GD & DT nharn nang cao dan tri, ciao tao nhan Mc, bei duerng nhan Mi Chuyen manh qua trinh gido dye In' chr yeu trang bi kien Milt sang phat then toan dien nang lkrc \fa phAm chat ngued hoc; phat trien GD & DT phai gait vai nhu can phdt hien KT - XH, xliy dung ya bao ye TO' quec, yai tien be khoa hoc, ding nghe; phAn dau flitting nam tat, tao chuyen bien can ban, manh me ye chAt Luang, hieu qua GD & DT; phan dm den nam 2030, nen giao due Viet Nam (tat trinh tien lien khu VCIC Trien khai thut hien hien chill twang tren thed gian quan dat lc& qua nhu sau: A A Time hien co hieu qua cong tdc tuyén truyen, nang cao nhan thirc va hank' deng clei met gido due Nang cao hieu qua c6ng tdc qudn li Xay dung va phät trien doi ngti nha gido Nang cao chat lacing gido due Xay dung id hei hoc tap, hoc tap suet clef Tang cuOng dau to ca se • vat chat, doi mai c8ng Mc quart hi tat chinh ya day manh cOng Mc la hed hoa gido due Trien khai ditt y hien nang cao chat lacing, hieu qua hoat Ong sang kien, nghien cite khoa hoc va Ung dung vat) ceng tdc quart li, hoat deng day hoc Dan vi cluec giao quyen hr chit, to chin trdch nhiem Mir chinh da clan deng su dung Icinh phi flgan sdch nha nude giao hieu qua hen de that hien nhiem vu; deng thai, chti deng sir dung tai san, liguen nhan Mc de phdt then va nang cao chat Meng dich vu, tao dieu kien tang nguen thu Tuy nhien, ben canh ket qua dat (Inge, van ten tai han cite Wm : Cac dan vi twang hoc chtra duet giao quyen to cha met each day du; chua time su khuyen khich cac don vi co dieu kien wan ten M chu a nnic cao han, ye cac khoan thu va mat thu, nguen thu clan yeti la hoc phi, natic thu hoc phi van theo khung hoc phi vita Nhit nu& nhung thdp, chin co khd nang bit dap chi phi cho cac hoat Ong cda dan vi He Meng die tieu chudn, dinh mire thus hien chin deng be, chain stra dal nhu dinh mire Trang giO giang, dinh mix bien cite the dO, chinh sach, tieu chuan, dinh mire chi tieu thieu tinh thut tiL, can nhieu bat cap nhung chua dupe kip thai b6 sung, sfra del cho phO hop Tfr t6 cOng tee tai don vi PhOng Gião duc — Deo tao huyen X, chfing tOi xin néu tinh hueng: "giai quyat tinh hiving giao vien to cdo 1/10 trtreng killing thing lop nhung vein ngang nhieu link tidn phy cap c •u phy cap Halm nien" de xem xth, giai quyet vai mong mu6n van dung kien thirc bOi cluang nghiep vu cOng the vien tra dugc hoc vac) viec giai quy& tinh thuc to hinh ky ndng co ban can thiet, ban dau cOa ngtren cOng tac vien tra B NOT DUNG IWO tã tinh Thong 01 nom 2013 thAy Man ducc dieu d6ng ve lam Hieu trtrâng twang Tieu hoc Thanh Long ( truerc din thAy Man la choyen vien PhOng Giao due — Dao tao huyen X phy trach chuyen mOn Tieu hoc) den 20/10/2016 thjy Man vi tie ch6i khOng Icy h6 so vay von Ngan hang cho co Le la gido vien cóa truOng (do so lien (Teri trach nhiem ky cho vay), mac flit bier hoar' canh kinh t6 gia dinh co Le khO khan, va co Le nhieu ran nang ni, giai thich nhung flak/ Man van nhat quy& khOng Icy, vi but tat Hieu truang khOng ky h6 so vay von Ngan hang cho minh nen 25/10/2016 co Le viec don gfri den UBND huyen X to cao thay Man khOng tham gia giang day dO s6 tiet theo quy dinh ma van huang the dO phu cap on phu cap thaw nien rift& giao Mc dinh Inv tieu xit 132 tinh huáng Viec xem xót, giai quyet not dung dal tinh nett tren nham dat dugc muc tieu chung va muc tieu cu the saw 2.1 Muc Well chung: Nham huOng tai viec xir hanh vi vi pham va ngireei co hanh vi vi pham, boo ve lqi ich cfta nha ntrOc, tap the, xa hOi Trang 2.2 Muc tiOtt cu th6: Darn bao thgc hien dUng quy dinh phap luAt, ma cu the la Quyet dish 244/2005/QD-TTg ngdy 6/10/2005 etla TIM Wang Ch.inh phb "Ve the phy cap uu d p i ct6; vai !The giao dang true tiep giang day cac se( giao cluc cong lap" va Nghi Binh so 54/2011/ND-CP 4/7/2011 "Ve the phu cap tham niên doi veri nha gido" deu cid quy dinh rat r6 rang, chi :nha giao true tier) dung lap giang day mai dugc huang hai the dO On dinh va phat then boat &Ong ena dun vi, IchOng a tao du ludn xdu rnOi bO clan vi va nganh giao chic huyen X.Tao su doan ket thOng nhAt cao cong viec va truly hien nhiem vu chinh tri cilia den vi, dap img vari nhu cAu di mai va pith trien cua nganh Tao niem tin, uy tinh cho doi ngli can bO, giao vies va nhän vien nha truang thay duoc tinh nghiern minh viec chap hAnh War phap va the quy dinh nganh, to c16 to nhin nhan,tu dank gi p lai ban than minh de co su dieu chinh, bd sung cho phi hop Tuyen truyen phi hien elaid truang, chinh sdch cua Bang, phap luat nha nuac cho gido vién biet dirge Dieu twang, phO hieu truang truang pha thOng ea nhiem giang day mot s6 tiet de nam duct nOi dung, chuong trinh giao due va tinh hinh hoc cna hoc sinh nham ming cao hieu qua cong tae guar) 1)% Tang cueing cong the kiem tra not bO truang hoc nham tang cueing kSi cueing, ne nep va ngAn than, Ichac phuc the hien tuyng lieu cue the hoat dOng cua nha taräng PhOng Gido due — Da° tao co hien phdp viec to eh& gidm sat viec thus hien dinh mire tiet day theo quy dinh, va mOt se' boat dOng Ichat dugc quy dOi that-1h tiet day Phial tich tinh hu6ng Trang Qua tim hieu mot se gido vien vä nhan vien nha truemg cho biet: Th Man Hieu truerng nha truerng kh6ng tham gia day du so net theo quy dinh ma van hutng phu cap tru dai va phu cap Main nien la do: 3.1 Nguyen nh5n a Nguyen nhan khach quan: Viec kiem tra, thank tra cua cdc nganh, cat cap ma tryc tiep PhOng GD&DT huyen X chua thuOng xuyen, khOng kip thei phat hien ngan than Tinh thAn dAu tranh phé binh va to phe binh dia Chi b0, tap the CBGV truerng Tieu hoc Thanh Long cOn yeu, chua dugc phdt huy Ciao vien, nhan vien truong "so" Hieu trtrOng kheng dam phan anh, khOng len tieng, cap wen co the biet nhung nhain mat cho qua Trong viec dieu hanh nhã truth-1g va mOi quan he vai cdc gido vien truOng Thay MAn cling lam chua tot, cOn bieu hien tinh gia truPng, clOc dodm bao thu de la mot nguyen nhan dan den su biro xiic cOa giao vien trongnha truPng h Nguyen nhan chu quan: Hieu truOng cho rang be day tau giCr quen kien dint, phuong phap truy'en thy, tut hau v.v; cho rang trach nhiem lam quan 11T cao, ceng viec nhieu khOng co thOi gian &lull de day De dai phO vâi 1?hOng Ciao dyc — Dan tao cite truOng nep bang phan °Ong chuyen men, tiled khOa bieu len co ten * (la, men day, so tiet day dm Hieu trunng Nhung thttc to chi day tren giay cOn thyt chat gião vien van day thay cho Hieu trirOng de hop thitc Ban than Hieu trthing killing )2 thirc duot hau qua viec minh clang lam Day co the coi la nan tham nhiing giao dyc NO khOng !lilting lam lam thiet hai ngan sach nha nuO• , phd v0 ne nep, ki cuong, quy the den chu trutng hoc, ma cOn lam "xOi mOn" niem tin dm nhang quan lam den glen duc Trang 3.2 Hiiti qua: y e chuyen men, can be quail ly cat nha truerng kheing tham gia giang day se" kheng nam bAt dirge nei dung, chuang trinh gido due va tinh hinh hoc tap cad hoc sinh nen dan den hien tugng quan lieu, bdo thu, bat cap viec chi dao chuyén men, ding tac quan ly se kern hieu qua Gay thiet hai cho ngan sach nha nuae, lam mat uy tin, danh du ca nhan, vi pham dao due nha gido vi loi gian lan Gay ânh hugng den uy tin nha twang, den mei truang sir pham va niem tin dm hoc sinh, play huynh del y eti cac thay co gido,tao nen sir bac xn.c, mau than, a doan ket ca quan, dan vi 'Edo nen sir bat ding viec thtic hien the lao deng, lam dung ding sac, thai gian cad ngtrai Ude, Idli van nhan hen ngan sach trai quy dinh Thai gian nha trunng pi-aj Lye vu cho kiem tra, xtic minh cua ca quan chile nang se dull hirerng den chat lu'ong clay hoe cua giao vien, to gian tip anh twang d'L hoc sinh Lang phi thei gian ding sac cho viec giai quy& dam thu to coo etla cac ca quan chac Be xuat nliiimg giai 014 Tu vice phdn tich nguyen nhan khach quan va cha quan xd tinh huAng neu treu, de trien khai giai quy& tinh hueng dot hieu qua chAng quy dinh cua phap luat, pint hop val awe te, dot muc tieu de ra, chOng tai de xuat cac giai phap de gidi quy& nhu sau: 4.1 Can ct • Slap 13% de xuat giai phap: Viet de xuat cac giai phdp giai quy& tinh dirge can cu cac quy dinh phap luat gem: Trang Lu'at to cdo ndm 2011 Nghi dinh 76/2012/ND-CP ngdy 03/10/2012 cua Chinh phit quy Binh chi tiet mot so dieu cna Ludt to cdo Thong to 06/2013/TT —TTCP ngdy 31/10/2013 quy dinh quy trinh giai guy& t6 cdo Thong to 05/2013/TT-TTCP ngdy 29/7/2013 quy dinh thAm guyen, nQi dung tra trdch nhiem thut hien phdp luat t6 cdo ThOng to 07/2014/TT-TTCP ngdy 31/10/2014 &la Thanh tra Chinh phil ye quy dinh quy trinh xtt 132 don lchieu nai, to cdo, don kien nghi, phan dnh Thong to 40/2013/TT-BGDDT ngdy 18/12/2013 quy dinh ye tiep ding clan, gidi guy& khieu nai, giai quyat t6 cdo cad BQ Gido dye vd Ddo tao Thong to 28/2009/TT-BGDDT ngdy 21/10/2009 dm BGDDT ban hdnh quy dinh ye the ldm \nee dei veci gido vien thong ThOng to lien tich se 01/2006/TTLT-BGD&DT-BNV-BTC ctia Lien bQ Gido (Mc va Ddo tao — Bo Noi vu- TA/ chinh huang da-n thuc hien Quyet clinh se 244/2005/Qp-TTg ngdy 06/10/2005 dm Thu tueng chinh phn ve the dO plm cap uu dai doi vai nhd giao dang true tiep giang day cdc co se gide duo cOng lap Nghi dinh so 54/2011/ND-CP ngdy 4/7/2011 "Ve the de phu cap thAm nien y e• nha gido" ye Thing to se: 68/2011 /TILT- BGDDT- BNV — BTC - BLDTBXH, ngdy 30/12/2011 dm BQ giao duc va Dd.° tao, BQ NOi vu, BQ Tdi Chinh, BQ Lao &Ong Thuong binh va XA hQi hueng dan thtrc hien mot se dieu cna Ng14 dinh se 54/2011/ND-CP ngdy 04/7/2011 cna chinh phA ve the c10 phy cap thdm niên dei yei nhd gido 4.2.Các giai pluip xulit Trang a.Giiii 04 1: Kiem diem rat kinh righiem buOc thay Man nOp lai SO tien nhan sai quy dinh Can Gilt vac) bien ban ket Juan sai pham cfia doan tra, Pheng Gido due — Dao tar) thnc thien su chi dao cua UBND huyen X co buOi lam viec yeti HOi &Ong six pham cOng khai not dung sai pham buec thay Man nOp lai tien nhan sai quy dinh, cam ket khOng tai pham, thu:c hien gier day theo dfing quy dinh - U u diem: Xt:r ly nhanh, kip thdi ltheng de keo dal tao du luankhOng Mt, khOng gay xito trOn nhan su - Han cho: Co khd nang CO Le bi trii dap, nOi bg mat doan ket Du than cho rang thay Man gay khuyet diem lam mat uy tin ca nhan va tap the song van dugc cap tren tin nhiem, khOng co the dung giao due nguel Ichac d'dn den coi thu gng phdp luat Co kila "rang CO Le se tie p don to ea° len co: quan cap tren co Le cam thay van de chua &rot giai guyet thoa clang b Giiii pluip 2: Kiem diem rut kinh nghiem buOc thay Man nOp lai so tien nhan sai quy dinh &mg thäi chuyen sang lam Hieu trtremg Or mot don vi khac Can d • vacs ket luan cna doan tra Phông Gido due — dao tao thuc hien chi dao cha UBND huyen X co buOi lam viec vai Hoi cleing sir pham cong khai nOi dung sai pham buec flak, Man nep lai tien nhan sai quy dinh, cam ket khOng tai pham, thgc hien gier day theo &mg quy Binh va chuyen sang lam Hieu trtrOng tai mot don vi truang hoc khdc huyen - Uti diem: XCr It' tinh triet de, tren co sä van ban phdp War; the hien tinh lchach quan, ceng bang; tranit dugc kha ndng khieu nai cfia co Le len co quan cap tren Viec chuyen thay Man sang ding tac not khdc se lam cho gião vien truerng khOng ban tan ve vu viec da xdy ra, ban than thay Man sang truang khac ding bed: di su to ti, mac cam Trang Han che: Trude mat don vi thieu mot lanh dao, hieu phO phai can clang them nhieu cong viec tiled gian chef bd nhiem Hieu truang mei, mat thai gian cho cong tac ban giao, it nhieu anh huang den hoat dOng cua dan vi philp 3: Giang chirc thay Man, buOc thay Man nOp lai so tien nhan sai quy dinh tfu diem: KhOng xdo trOn nhieu cong tac nhan su, x • viec clugc >d • 19 nhanh ch6ng lam diu du Wan Han the: Thay Man cam thAy to ti mac cam v6i dang nghiep, va thAy Man se' khOng phuc day la ran dao hen thay Man mac sai pham va viec Hieu truang va PhO Hieu tru• ng IchOng tham gia day du so ti & t theo quy dinh la ph6 hien cac truang phd thOng o dia phuang TO ch (re thk • e hien giiii phap de deft dtrqc any tieu cfe • Qua phän tich, t • u diem, han che ciia cac giai phap de xuat néu tren, giai guyet t6i au tinh hueng, chUng tOi chon giai phAp s6 vi giai phap vita phit hop vol quy dinh cna phap luat, imp ly vai tinh hueng xay ra, tao duot s • &mg thuan cac ben De giai quy& tinh huong, can cu quy dinh cUa phdp luat ve luat tra 2010 duoc quy dinh tai 05/2014/TT-TTCP, chling t8i t6 chIrc trien khai thu • hien theo cac buck sau: 5.1 Batt 1: Vi dan thu co giri den UBND huyen nen UBND huyen mai lanh dao PhOng Gido due — Dao tao len lam viec vad ChU tich huyen Qua ban cdo PhOng Giao duc — Dao tao va not clung ghi thu t6 cao cna co Man ve hanh vi vi pham cua thay Man la nghiem trong, chit tich UBND huyen coy kien chi dao nhu sau: Giao Thanh tra nha ntr • c huyen ket hop v • i PhOng Giao dye — Dao tao tham muu trinh UBND huyen quyet dinh lap doan tra dOt xuat truang Tieu hoc Trang Thanh Long dAng thai thAng bdo cho cac don vi ca nhdri co lien quan biet de time hien 5.2 But 2: Time hien quy& dinh sS 256/QD-UBND ngdy 25/10/2016 Doan tra hen hdrih tra cong be) guyAt dinh tra, not dung tra, thai gian tra la 30 ngdy ke tit ngdy cong bA guy& dinh tra truck su chin-1g kien ct:ia Ban Odin hien nhd trueng, COng dodn truang, Dodn nien, Ban 41 dien dha me hoc Binh, ke todn, this guy va tien hánh tra cac not dung sau: Viec tuyen truyen, phO bien, gudn triet chu truang, chinh sach, phdp luat Ddng va Nha nutt ve phAng, chAng tham nhang nhd truang Viec xdy dung vd to chtiv -Mut hien chuong trinh, ke hoach cong tdc pheng, chong tham nhang cua don Viec cong khai, minh Bach hoat deng mua sam tai san, to sera co sef vat chdt; tai chinh ngan sach, quail 1)1/ va sU dung cac ichodn 1-16 trg, huy ding khdc; cong tdc phdn ding cong chirc, vien chi•° Viec xdy dung quy the chi tieu nei be , Viec thuc hien quy tac ling xCr, 4o disc nhe gido Viec ke khai tai san, thu nhap theo quy dinh Trach nhiem cua hieu trueng ding tdc pheng, chong tham nhang Sau xong cac not dung, doan tra den henh hop, tong hqp )", kien tis cac be phan de dua du thdo ket luau 5.3 But 3: Thong bdo dc • thdo ket Man cita dodn tra tru• c Ban gidm hien nhd twang, COng dodn truang, Dodn nien vd Ban dai dien cha me hoc, lee town, this quy, dodn tra danh gid Mu:Mg viec lam duvc Can phdt huy han thai gian tad dAng thai cling neu len nhfing mat ton tai, han the can khac phuc Dac biet sai pham cna thAy Man viec chua chAp hánh het day theo quy Trang ctinh tai khodn 2, dieu thOng tu 28/2009/TT-BGDDT cOa Bq Gido due - Dao tao va Quy (firth the dQ lam viec d6i vcfri gide vien phi du/Mg va diem c, mac 1, phan I thong to lien hell s6 01/2006/TTLT-BGDDT-BNV-BTC ngAy 23/01/2006 huOng dan that hien quyet Binh so 244/2005/QD-TTg 6/10/2005, nhung van duos hutng Phu cap ur u dai, phu cap tham nian nItà gi g() vol tang sal tien 150.644.588d; 5.4 But 4: Xd19 kat qua tra: Dip vac) kat Juan giai quyet t6 cdo cUa Chu tich UBND quan, theo quy dinh va phan cap quan 19 Truing phOng GDDT oh& tri, ph8i hop veci PhOng NQi vu tham muu cho UBND huyan X lap I-16i Sing k9 luat va quyet dinh hinh thi •c k9 Mat thay Mn d theo y kin cua tap the Hoi ol8ng k9 Ludt cap huyen Kien nglq, de xuat - Qua tinh huOng va viec glad quyet, de that hien tot tong tdc thOi gian tOi, chUng tOi xin nau len the de xuat kian nghl cu the nhu sau: 6.1 DOI vfri quan chii quan Tang cueing six kiam tra, gidm sat viec thvc hien nhiem vu giAng day bat buQc d6i vOi Hiatt truing, PIM hieu truing cua cdc co quan quan 19 cap tram Dac biet IA sks gidm sat dm chinh can IDO , gido vien, nhan vien nha truang Khi phat hien cdc trtrông hop 'lieu trutng, Pho hiau taring sai pham, the co quan co than quyen can xu li nghiem minh, nghiem khac han nhtr co the each chisc, buQc thei viec Tang cuing tong tdc gido due phAp luat cho dQi ngii can bQ tong chirc, vien chirc; cl4c biet Id tang cueng phAp the Xa 110i chit nghia, lam cho moi ngtrQi luOn coy thdc tuna thd phdp luat 6.2 Doi vai dun vi Trang 10 Can thoe hien tot eel-1g tao kiem tra not be, phat huy vai trO gidm sat dm Ban tra nhan dam Trong cOng tat dank gid Wan Ioai cOng chat ne nang, ne tranh khOng darn gOp )2 Thot hien clay clU ea° kien nghi neu ket Man cua clodn tra 6.3 DO) vai ca ninin Hieu trutrig chap hanh nghiem chinh edc quy dinh cua phdp luAt, kheng thodi tilde tie tranh trâch nhiem Thu h'ei va nep van tai khodn tarn gift chO xu lY cua Thanh tra huyen ma tai KNNN huyen X ( s6 hieu TIC 3941.0.90432:1.00000) tong so tien chi sai nguyen tac Id :150.644.588d C KET LUAN Qua gidi quyet tinh hueng cho thAy, nguyen nhan clan den tinh trang tren la Hieu trueng ne tranh trach nhiem, co quan chit quan thieu kiern tra giam sat , tap the don vi khOng darn clAu tranh gOp y xAy dung de sv viec kao ddi Vi vAy, a khOng xdy nhiing van de Prong Pr ve phia co quan chU qudn, lanh dao clan vi vd ca nhan can that hien met se cOng viec sau: Tuyén truyen phO bien sau rang mei chit Chuang cluOng lei cria Ddng, chinh sach phdp luat cua Nhd nuOt cho clOng ddo quAn chUng, can be, cOng ehdc, vien chi:re hieu rb vd qr gide thuc hien Phat buy tinh chu do, ng sang tao cUa can be co se, tang cueing phei hop vai cde doh the co quan Nang cao vai tr6 klub dao cua ngueri dung dau co quan Khi xdy vu viec can nam day du, tron yen thOng tin vu viec, phan tinh nguyen nhan, de cdc giai phdp gidi quyet thAu tinh, dat IY, darn bao dung quy dinh plidp Mat y d thoc tin boat cleng ca nhan, clan vi Trang 11 Viec giai guyet dat hieu qua nen tren, gop phan nAng cao hieu lttc, hieu qua quart 1Y cila co quan don vi, Oat huy vai trO, nang htc cha cOng tac vien tra qua trinh tham rtmu, de xuAt thn trtiOng giai quy& dam bac van dung kien thitc Icy Wang cQng tac vien tra throe bpi clueing vat) thvc tin OM guy& cong viec tai co quan don vi ceng tac thvc hi'en chirc trach, nhiem vu cua cQng tac vien tra theo guy dinh cna phap luAt va theo nhiem vu duce lanh ciao phan cOng./ Tarn Binh, ;1 thang Endm 2017 Nguti viet Cao Van Nheo Trang 12 D.TAI LIEU TAM KHAO Lujt to cao nam 2011 ,Nghi dinh 76/2012/ND-CP 03/10/2012 dia Chinh phi) quy dinh chi tint met so dieu caa Luat to cao x , to cao Thong tu 06/2013/TT —TTCP 31/10/2013 quy dinh quy trinh giai quyet Thong tu 05/2013/TT-TTCP 29/7/2013 quy dinh thAm guyen, not dung tra trach nhiem thue hien phap luat ye to cao Thong to 07/2014/TT-TTCP 31/10/2014 ,cl:1a Thanh tra Chinh phi) ye quy dinh quy trinh xi1t lY don khiéu nai, cao, don kien nghi, phan anh ThOng tu 40/2013/TT-BGDDT 18/12/2013 quy dinh ye tiep cOng dan, giai guyet lchieu nai, giai guy'et to cao dm BO Giao chic ya Dan tao Tilling tu 28/2009/TT-BGDDT 21/10/2009 dm BGDDT ban hanh quy dinh ye the lam \flee deli yari giao Arian pile tilting Thong to lien tich se 01/2006/TTL.T-BGD&DT-BNV-BTC dm Lien be Glen due y a Dao tao — BO Nei vu - Be Tai chinh huOng dan thirc hien Quyet dinh so 244/2005/QD-TTg 06/10/2005 dm Tilt) arcing chinh plu) ye ché de On cap au dai dOi Axed nha giao dang true tiep giang day cac co se,' giao due cOng ljp Nghi dinh so 54/2011/ND-CP 4/7/2011 "Ve the phu cap thaw nién den voi nha giao" ya ThOng tu so: 68/2011 /TTLT- BGDDT- BNV — BTC BLDTBXH, 30/12/2011 cna Be giao due ya Dan tao, BO Nei vu, Be Tai Chinh, Be Lao deng Thuong binh va Xa hei huOng dAn thvc hien met so dieu Nghi dinh se 54/2011/ND-CP 04/7/2011 dm chinh phi) ye ché phu cap thaw nien del voi nha giao 13.TruOng Can be Quail ly giao dye TPHCM (2017) Tai lieu hoc tap, bei dung nghiep vu ceng tac \Lien tra gido due; Trang 13