Giái quyết đơn tố cáo hiệu trưởng và kế toán trưởng trường THCS vi phạm về thu chi tài chính

DOi yeti nganh Giao due va Dao tao GD&DT, HOi nghi BCH Trung dung Lan Mir 8, khod XI ban hanh , Nghi quyét so 29-NQ/TW ngay 04/11/2013, dOng tiled Chinh phi' ban hanh Nghi quyet , so 44/

BI(:) GIAO DUC VA DAO TAO TRIT(ING CAN BQ QUAN Lt GIAO DtJC TP HO Cut MINH

fe 02

TIEU LUAN CUOI KHOA LOP BOI DU'ONG NGRIEP VI) CIVTIGD TA1 SO GD&DT TINH LAM BONG NAM HQC 2017 - 2018

GIAI QUYET BON TO CAO

"ONG HIEU TRU'ONG T VA BA la TOAN Q

TRYONG THCS A, 111UYEN B, TINII LAM BONG

VI PRAM Vt THU, CHI TAI CHINK NAM HQC 2016-2017"

Ngirhi thtrc hien: MAI TAI KIM DUNG Dun vj cling tic: Truhng THCS Phan* Cit 2- Cit Tien

Tisk Linn Ding

Lam Ding, thing 01 aim 2018

MIJC LUC

Nguyen nhfin va hfiu qua ciia tinh hung Trang 5

Xfiy dyng va Icra chip phircrng an xit ly tinh hiding Trang 6

TAI LItU THAM ICHAO

DANH MVC CAC CHU CAI VIET TAT Gido due va Dâo tao (GD&DT)

Trung hoc co SO (THCS)

I:Jy ban nhan dan (UBND)

Tai chinh — Ka hoach (TC-KH)

Ccr st'r vat chAt (CSVC)

COng tic vién thanh tra giao due (CTVTTGD)

7 Gido vian (GV)

Tau lu'On cubli kh6a lop Ong tic vien TTGD-Liim DOng nem hoc 2017-2018

TIEU LUO Giái quyet chin to coo "Ong Hieu tru*ng T ye 13A ke town Q truing THCS A, huyen B, tinh Lam Deng vi pham ve thu, chi tei chinh nam hoc 2016-2017 "

A PHAN MO DAU Xay dtmg dOi ngii can b0, cong chuc, vien chirc trong sach, co nang lvc, pham chat dao dire tot la mOt van de rat co ban, quan tong duct Wang va Nha nuOrc ta thudng xuyen quan tam; van de nay cling la mOt trong nhung not dung dirge de cap trong nhieu van kien ,Dang DOi yeti nganh Giao due va Dao tao( GD&DT), HOi nghi BCH Trung dung Lan Mir 8, khod XI ban hanh , Nghi quyét so 29-NQ/TW ngay 04/11/2013, dOng tiled Chinh phi' ban hanh Nghi quyet , so 44/NQ-CP ngAy 09/6/2014 ye "DOi meri can ban toan din GD&DT, dap (mg yeu eau cOng nghiep h6a, hien dai h6a trong dieu kien kinh to thi tn.remg dinh hudng XHCN va hOi nhap quiic te" da dugc trién khai, tuydn truyén ring rai trén tat ca cac phuons tien thOng tin dai chimg, dirge sit quan tam dOng &do the tang 16p nhan dan, the cap clang, chinh quyen va the t6 chuc, doan the dia phurang not chung, nganh giao dvc dao tao not rieng MOt trong nhOm 9 nhiem

vv, giai phap dirge dot ra do la "DOi mai can ban cong tcic gulp? 152 giaocluc, ciao too, bao dam dan chit, titling nhat; tang guyen to chit va trach nhi'em hai cua cac co set gicio duc, dao Igo; coi trong glean 135 chat luting ".

Xac dinh dugc tam quan trong cua do, i nel can bc), cong chtic trong viec t6 chirc, then khai thvc hien 10 trinh coi each hanh chinh cua Nha nude, tai ky hop Mir 4, ngay 13/11/2008 Qu6c hOi kh6a XII da th6ng qua LIS can b0, cOng chirc (co hieu ltrc tit ngay 01/01/2010), Lust nay thay the Phap lenh cOng chirc 2003 Lust can b0, cong chirc ban hanh IA the the hOa day chit tnrong, chinh sach cua Dang va Nha mrdc ti6.p tut

dei moi host dOng cOng vv va phuang auk quan ly can b0, cong chirc phil hop v6i the the chinh tri d nudc ta trong qua trinh hOi nhap kinh to qu6e te; xay dung mOt nen hanh chinh dan chit, trong sach, \Tang manh, tong budc hien dai veri mOt dOi net can b0, cOng chirc ce, dii pham chat va nang lye Qua dO, phvc vy tot cac nhu tau cua xa hOi, No dam quyen va lgi ich hgp phap cua cong dan; dap ling yeu eau phai tri'en nhanh va ben \fling

dm oat nude

Ky luat can b0, cOng chdc, vien chdc la mOt nOi dung thuOc cOng tat quan ly hanh chinh Nha nude Khi xem 'cat ky luat can b0, cOng chuc, vien chirc mac sai lam khuyet diem phai dac biet chit y lc& hop chat the, da clang cac nguyen the quan ly khac nhau Tren co sd nhirng nguyén the dO, dOi hOi mal co quan trong cong the quail lY can b0, cong chirc, vien chirc phai thuOng xuydn qua y iy ca ye tieu churn, ca ye to tuerng dao duc, the phong lam viec, lay giao chic thuyet phvc la chinh de ngan chan khuyet diem va lieu eve Song khi phat hien can b0, cOng chirc co khuyet diem thi phai co bien phap dau tranh kien quyet, khOng bao the; xem xet sit vat, hien tugng mOt each toan diem triet de, Ice ca mat khach quan va chi) quan de xi( ly mOt each chinh xac, dam bao giu nghiem ky luat Wang, phap luat NhA nude

Phat trie'n giao due va dao tao IA glide sach hang au, la it* trong nhfing dOng lye quan trong thnc day sit nghiep cOng nghiep hod, hien dai hod dot nude, IA di'eu kitn

Ngtrai thirc hien: Mai Thi Kim Dung Trang 1

Tian Than cull khda lop c'png tac via TTGD-Lam Dâng ntim hpc 2017-2018

de Oat huy nguOn luc con ngued Day la trach nhiem cUa toan Bang, toan clan, trong do nha giao Ira can b0 quail ly gido due la lye lugng nOng ceyt, c6 vai trO quail tong Trong lich sir nithe ta, "ton six tong dao" la truyen thOng quy bau ciaa dan Mc, nha gilt) bao gier clang dugc nhan dan yeu men, kinh trong Nhirng nam qua, chUng ta cid xay dung dirge dOi ngil nha gido va can b0 quart ly gido chic ngdy cang dOng dao, phan lön c6 pham chat dao dire va 57 thire chinh tri t6t, trinh do chuyén m6n, nghiep vix ngay cang dugc nang cao, dap img quan tr9ng yeu cAu nang cao dan tri, dao tao nhan lye, duetng nhan tai, g6p phari vao thang lgi elm su nghiep each mang cda dat nuere

Trong nhiing nam qua, Bang Ira Nha nu& ta da c6 nhieu d6i med trong cOng tac quail lyr,can b0, c6ng chirc, timg bit& xay dung b0 may chinh quyen the cap dap Ung skr phat trien elm dat nuerc Song trong qua trinh thuc hien nhiem viii vAn con can b0, cOng chirc thieu tinh than trach nhiem trong c6ng viec, bu6ng lOng trong cOng the quail chi dao tao ke" her de cAp duOi lgi dung lam nhang vice sai trai, vi pham phdp lust Nhang sai lam, vi pham dO can dirge phat hien, giai quy6t dirt diem d gOp phAn xay dung Nha nuerc ta that su "trong sach, vilng manh, cOng bang, dan chili, van minh"

Ban than tOi dang cOng tdc tai twang thuOc dia ban cOn kh6 khan, trong thäi gian qua toan nganh da va dang trien khai, Uwe hien c6 hieu qua cac cuOc van dOng nhu: "Hoc tap va lam theo fir twang, phong each, ctgo Jar Hi) Chi Minh"; "Nal khang vai lieu coy trong thi vã benh thank tick trong gicio dpc, noi khOng val viac

vi phgm dpo der nha gide; "frial thay giáo, ca giao la mat trim gtrang dgo Mk, ty hpc viz sang tgo"; qua kh6a hpc b6i dung Nghiep Iry cOng tac vien thanh tra giao duc tai SO Gido duc \fa Dan tao tinh Lam D6ng ndm hoc 2017-2018, dirge trang bi nhfing kien thirc T6ng quan v Thanh tra gido dye va Ks nang co ban dm Ong tac vién thanh tra giao due, tOi chon tinh hu6ng Gicii vat den ti So "Ong Hiau trtrOng T vti ha ICJ loan Q trtrang THCS A, huyan B, link Lam Diing vi phgm v thu, chi tai chink nam hoc 2016-2017 "lam de tai tieu 1un eu6i khod h9c Day la mOt d tai

a ban than van clung nhang kien thirc da hoc, lien he veld thuc t, tren co ses do suy nghT, tim tOi dna ra nhang giai Oaf) thiet thuc phü hgp giUp cho qua trinh cOng tac ban than ngly cang Mt hcrn

Vai su hieu biet dm ban than cOn han eh, theri gian nghién elm chua &Kit nhieu, rAt mong nhan dirge su quan tam, ghlp d cda quyr thAy cO gido trong truedig CBQLGD thanh ph6 H6 Chi Minh de nhang nOi dung trinh bay trong lieu luan nay dirge day di hem, c6 gid tri lau dai trong thuc ti8n.

Tieu luari dirge b6 cue 3 phan cu the:

Phan mer dAu

Phan nOi dung

C- Phan ket luan Ara kien nghl

Nguiri limy hien: Mai Thi Kim Dung Trang 2

Tian lutin cud! kh6a hip Ong ttic vien TTGD-Liim Diing nam him 2017-2018

B PHAN NO' DUNG

I MO to tinh hitting

Hain canh ra clai ciia tinh hung

Vao hid 8 gier ngay 25/08/2017, Uy ban nhan dan (UBND) huyen Ira phOng Giao duc va Ddo tao (GD&DT) huyen B, tinh Lam Deng deng thbi nhan duce don cda giao vien C t6 cat, ve viec "Ong Hieu trirOng T va ha ki loan Q trusöng

THCS A vi pham )41 thu, chi tai chinh nam hpc 2016-2017 " Truerc tinh hinh

do ph6ng GD&DT cid tham muu cho UBND huyen B ra Quyet dinh s6 145/QD-UBND ngay 05/9/2017 ve viec thanh lap doan thanh tra cong tat quan ly tai chinh nam hoc 2016-2017 tai truang THCS A UBND huyen B da giao cho phOng GD&DT chu tri ph6i hop voi phOng Tdi chinh - Ke hoach (TC-KH) huyen tien hthih thanh tra viec thu, chi cac khoan tien trong nam hoc 2016-2017 tai trutmg THCS A; nitic dich la de nam bat thuc trang ve thu, chi tai chinh, xac minh lam re viec t6 cao cua giao vien C co diing su thtrc hay khOng?

Ngay 11/9/2017, doan thanh tra da ve lam viec tai truemg THCS A, qua qua

trinh thanh tra doan da phat hien met s6 van de bat thuang trong viec pan ly thu,

chi tai chinh cua nhd truerng Ma lei chi) yeu la do Ong hieu twang T va be ke toan Q kh6ng minh bach trong cac chirng to thu chi (gem chi ngan sach nha nuerc va thu, chi quy xa hei hoa ngu6n huy dOng tfr phu huynh hoc sinh), cu the nhu: Ke toan de ngodi s6 sach 10 trieu deng (s6 tien nay Ice toan giai thich Id do ban nhieu viec nen chua kip lap he so nhap quy); co 18 trieu deng tien lam nha de xe hoc sinh cda nha twang do HOi phu huynh cid dim cho Ong hieu twang T de thanh toan cho nha than nhung Ong A khOng thuc hien

MO to tinh htning

Ong Nguyen Van T la Hieu twang twang THCS A cda huyen B Ong T sinh

ra ya len len a huyen B, tinh Lam Deng, nam 2002 tot nghiep Dai hoc su pham Da Lat chuyen nganh Ngil van, v6i tam bang loth kha Ra twang Ong duet phan cong

ve cong tac gidng day tai twang THCS B (twang thuec yang dac biet khO khan ctia tinh), huyen B, tinh Lam Deng, sau 6 nam cong tac Ong dirge be nhiem lam ph6 Hieu twang tai twang THCS B Tit khi dirge nhan nhiem vy mei Ong T luOn hoan thanh tot nhiem vv., dac biet la chAt luting giao due mtli nhan cua twang THCS B lueon dUng trong top dau cua huyen

Den thang 8 nam 2015, Hieu twang cua twang THCS A nghi huu yd twang THCS A la met truerng rat khO khan ve co so vat chat (CSVC), chat luong giao dye luein dung a yip sau cua huyen nen can met Hieu twang mei nang thing, sang tao de dim phong tit cila twang di len Ong T la nguai dirge ph6ng GD&DT tham muu cho UBND huyen be nhiem lam Hieu twang tai twang THCS A to thang 9 nam

2015 Qua trinh lam Hieu truerng tai twang THCS A, Ong T da phan ndo kitac plum

dirge nhung kh6 khan Gila truemg nhimg trong qua trinh pan 15T khOng phdt huy

NawM thin' hill:v Alai Thi Kim Dune Trim° 1

Mitt ludn culi kltha lop cOng tdc viên TTGD-Lam &Ong nám hpc 2017-2018

duct tinh dan chtit, thieu minh bach trong ang Ichai tai chinh 6 co quan nen nOi be cila twang khOng doan ket COn bã Deng Thi Q la ice than eüa truang THCS A tir nam 2014 NM Ong T 6 each truang tren 10 km, hoan canh gia dinh Ong T rat khO khan, vg thuang xuyen dau 6m, hai con dang cOn nh6 Vi vay, moi cOng viec gia dinh 6ng T phai ganh vac

Tir ngay &we be nhiem lam Hieu trugng tai truang THCS A 8ng T lai cang ban ren han vi CSVC cUa truang cid xueng cAp nghiem tong, nang luc chuyen men cüa dOi ngil giao vien kh6ng deng du nen chat lugng day hue rAt thdp DØ1 ng5 gião vien cüa truang da se mei ra twang, kinh nghiem giang day, cOng tac chit nhiem lem

va quart ly hoc sinh cOn han che Do ban viec gia dinh, cOng Arai cOng viec tham mtru cho dia phuang d tim nguen de xay dtmg CSVC twang hoc nen Ong T thuang xuyen khOng c6 mat tai truang; viec quart ly chi ciao chuyen m6n va met se cOng viec khac cña nha tnrang Ong phO mac cho deng chi PhO Hieu truOng dieu hanh toan b0 Vi \Tay, viec sinh hoat chuyen men elm the t6 chuyen mOn va HOi deng su pham tnrang A tin hanh khOng thuang xuyen, nhang lUc c6 mat 6 tnrang Ong T thuang b0c 10 tinh bao the va quan lieu vai gião vien va nhän vien

Ve c6ng the pan ly tai chinh trong nha truang Ice tir khi Ong T velam Hieu twang c6 nhieu bat cap dO la gan 3 nam rei ma kh6ng kiem tra, khOng bão cao,cOng khai, thu chi kh6ng minh bach; mac dit the gião vien trong truang da nhieu Tan de nghi 6ng T thut hien nghiem tüc viec c8ng khai tai chinh cüa truang nhung Ong T khOng nghe; ve mua sant tai san trong nha twang thi chit yeu la do Hieu tnrang Ira Ice toan by di mua Ira ve tu thanh guy& toan Ve nguyen the Ong T va ba Q c15 khOng tuan thu theo nhang quy dinh ctim Mir chinh

II Xic din!' myc tieu xü I tinh huOng

1 Myc dich, yeu au

Viec quart ly can b0, c6ng chirc, vien chirc la nhiem vu het sire quan trong cim the co quan Nha nugc, cüa cAp üy, chinh quyen the cep 'Chi met can b0, cOng chirc, vién chire vi pham phap luat, thi ca quan quail Iy true tiep Ira ca quan quart ly cap tren c6 tharn quyen c6 the xir 1 the hinh thirc ky luSt theo the mire do vi pham

Vic vi pham Icy Itht dm Ong T can phai dugc xtir ly kip thai va nghiem minh theo Dieu 79 vã Dieu 82 - LuSt can b0, ceng chire 2008, cO hieu lye ke tir ngay 01/01/2010; Dieu 118 - Lust Gião due 2005, stira dei be sung nam 2009; dE Jiang cao chat lugng det ngil can b0 quart I trong nganh GD&DT, tang cuang phap the

Xa hei chit nghia

Viec ba Q khOng thuc hien qui che c6ng khai tai chinh cila don vi theo ThOng

tu 21/2005/TT-BTC, ngay 22/3/2005 dm BO Tai chinh hutmg clAn la ba Q d5 vi pliant lchoan 2, Dieu 19 LIMA vien chirc se 58/2010/QH12, ngay 15/11/2010 can phdi duce xir 1 ky that ba Q theo Dieu 52, Dieu 56 Lu4t vién chirc va Dieu 10, Dieu 24 Nghi dinh 27/2012/ND-CP ngay 06/4/2012 dm Chinh phtit

lienti Th;

Tien luOn cuoi khOa lop cong tkc vien TTGD-Lam Mug nam hpc 2017-2018

2 Muc tieu can giäi quyet

Xir 19 vi pham ding ngtrei, ding UN lam trong sach dei nga can We cong chic, vien chin trong don vi

Cling co tat t6 chin cua trueng THCS A, than chinh viec thtrc hien k9 luat lao Ong, ne nap chuyan men, ph& huy dan chit, xay dung tot m6i doan kat not be cua nha trueng

Chan chinh viec thu, chi tat chinh sai quy dinh dm Ong hieu truting T va ba

ka toAn Q tai tuning THCS A; thu hei se tien that thoat de nhap quy theo quy dinh; tra cho viec xay dung CSVC;

III Nguyen nhan va hail qua ciia tinh hung

3.1 Nguyen nhfin

3.1.1 Nguyen nhfin chi quan

Ban than hieu trueng va ke town kh6ng y thin dirge hau qua viec minh dang lam nen gay hau qua la lam cho not be nha truong mAt doan kat, thian dan chit, hieu qua cong tac khOng cao

Ca nhan 6ng T, ba Q chua nghian thu kg cac van ban quy dinh cua Nha nuge

ve tai chinh; chua trung thkre trong viec thus hien quy cha cia nganh, dm the cap, cua Chinh phi da quy dinh

Hieu trträng T va ka than Q cita tithing THCS A thiau tinh than, trach nhiem trong viec t6 chin, trian khai time hien the cha de chinh sach ciia Wang va phap luat cua Nha nage IQOng lang nghe y kin dOng gOp ctia gido vien, nhan vien trong nha trueng; trong lanh dao thiau nguyén tac tap trung dan

Ong T la ngtrei co Mc phong lam viec mang Ong tinh bao thu, gia twang, coi thueng du luan; lam viec kh6ng co ke hoach nen cong tat quail 19 va dieu hanh Float Ong cna nha trueng chin thOng su6t; cong tac quail 19, chi dao bang léo, thiau dan chi nen dan dan str mau thuan, xuat hien hien tugng chia be, keo cart mAt doan kat nOi b0

3.1.2 Nguyen nhan khAch quan

Viec quart 19, chi dao cda phOng GD&DT huyen B ve cac mat cong tat theo tham quyen doi vgi co se chua thueng xuyan, viec tuyan truyan gido dye ve y thin, Inch nhiem, dao dire nghe nghiep cho can be, gido vien, nhan vien con xem nhc

Viec kiam tra, thanh tra cila cac nganh, cac cap ma truc flap la phOng GD&DT huyen B chum thutrng xuyan kiem tra, d'eti !chi con mang nang hinh thin, qua loa, dai khdi, na nang, chua kip thei nam bat thuc trang cua the don vi co se

Viec be nhiem can b0 quan 19 mai chi da va se lugng nhung chua that chit 9

va mat chat lugng, chin quan tam met each tit& clang den viec rho tao, bei clueing can be quart 19 da nang cao trinh delta nang luc diau hanh tai cac nha trueng

A/Int 77,.;

rib luan cudi kh6a lOp Ong tac vien TTGD-Lam &Ong lam hpe 2017-2018

Tinh than (tau tranh phe binh va tr phe binh dm chi b0, tap the can b0, gide, vien, nhan vien trueng THCS A eon yeu, chua dugc phat huy

Trinh d'O dan tri elm nhan dan con thdp an den sr Welt Net ve phdp lust vã the quy che phei hgp eüa nganh giao due cOn hart che nen viec t6 chirc xay dvng CSVC, ban giao kinh phi kheng dung nguyen the tai chinh tan ke lig de ngugi khdc lgi dung

Viec kiem sok chi tieu tai chinh tai cdc twang hoc cila phOng GD&DT va phOng KH - TC huyen B kh6ng thuOng xuyen clan den vie Ong T va ha Q thu, chi tai chinh tai don vi kheng dung nguyén the

Khi co che thi twang mei dm, met be phan can b0, ding chge khOng gig dugc pham chat dao dire, da bi &Ong tien lam thay dei nhan thirc clan den firth tang quan lieu, tham nhung, true lgi cho ban than; day cling la inOt bai hoc kinh nghiem

&An vOri ngtrOi dan va ding la met van d'e de nguiyi dan xem nhe v dao dire ala nha gido trong nganh giao dye Ira dao tao

3.2 Hu qua

Vic lam sai trai cfm Ong T va ha Q gay anh huemg )(Au ve mat la heir, lam mat uy tin trong deng nghiep cling nhu trong phu huynh Ira trong nit dan Lam cho nhan clan kh6ng tin tuemg vao nha truOng, lam giam uy tin dm ngued can be, quart 15i gido dye nOi rieng va nganh GD&DT nOi chung Lam met !Ong tin del vgi phOng GD&DT, UBND huyen va cac ban nganh trong huyen

Quyen Igi chinh clang ala giao vien Ara phv huynh hoc sinh bi xam hai

Cac hoat deng chuyen mon vd hoat deng ngoai khOa ala nha tnreng kheng thvc hien dugc; khOng tao dugc khi the thi dua sei nei trong nha tnrOng

Vi bluing bang quail ly, nhAt la d6i vOi quail l nguen tai chinh nett khOng phat hien, giai guy& kip thed lam that thoat nguen kinh phi, gay met doan ket nei be anh huerng Au den chat lugng giao due toan dien va phong trap chung ala nganh, dia phuang trong than huyen

Neu giai quyet sv viec khOng tet c6 th'e d bi gay bat binh trong nit dan lam anh huOng den ding tac dan van; c6ng Mc id hei hea gido due; lam cho nhan dan nghi nger den sv lanh dao, chi dao ala nganh gido due n6i rieng va dm Wang vã Nha nuele n6i chung

IV Xfiy dtrng Ara hp clap phtrcrng An xfr ly tinh hung

4.1 Xfiy dying phtrang An

4.1.1 Pluming An 1: Ra quytt dinh cfinh can Ong T va be Q

Dva vao kEt luan cüa doan thanh tra, truOng phOng GD&DT huyen A mOi Ong T Ira ha Q len Op Ulm tiOp, yeu cAu 6ng T phai thanh quyet todn 18 trieu dOng cho nha thau xay dvng; ba Q lam he so ket toan nhap 10 trieu deng van guy nhA twang; deng theri yeu cau Ong T va ba Q viet giay cam ket khOng tat Own khuyet

c

Tian !new cuni khOa lop cOng tic vien TTGD-Lam Thing nam lux 2017-2018

diem De nghi UBND huyen ra guy& dinh ky lust hai ngued bang hinh di& canh cat) truck toan nganh va keo dal died gian len luting la 6 that-1g, 6ng T va ba Q van tiep tuc ding tic binh thuang tai twang THCS A

* Cu diam ctia phwong an 1:

Giai guy& nhanh sir viec truce mat, khOng gay xdo trail cOng viec, t6 chile nhan skr cila threw THCS A, Ong T van gill' cline vu Hieu twang, ba Q van lam lee loan tai twang THCS A, cOng viec ke toan dm twang van on dinh

* Him the cria phwang an 1:

Viec Ong T van tiep tuc lam Hieu twang va ba Q van lam k6 toan tai twang THCS A se gay sir bat binh cho tap the gido vien, nhan vien nha truing Du luan cho rang Ong T gay ra khuyet diem lam mat uy tin ca nhan va tap the song van dirge cap tren tin nhiem Viec xir ly vi pham nhu ;Tay khOng co tic dung gido due ngtred kirk, tit do de dan den viec coi thuemg phap lust

Ban than Ong T va ba Q se khOng thay dirge hau qua Ara trach nhiem do viec

vi pham khuyet diem cua minh gay ra, lit dO se khOng coy thirc to minh dieu chinh phong each sting va lam viec

Phong trio hoat dOng ve moi mat cila nha throng dirge duy tri theo the dlei sinh hoat ca, khOng dirge day manh vi the chat luting day hoc khOng dirge nang len;

ve cOng the ke toan de dan den hien tuong "ngira quen du6ng khOng thay doi le lai lam viec

Viec vi pliant chap hanh kY lust lao clang cna Ong T la co he thong, khOng the mat semi mat chieu co the thay dai dug; cho dit Ong to viet ban cam ket se khOng tai pham khuyet diem, mat khac 6ng T van a ctrang vi lanh dao nen viec gap y phe binh Ong se khOng dirge ced ma, vOi ban tinh gia truing co the frit dap, dinh kien vai nhirng gido vien gOp y thing than khuyet diem cua 6ng, lam cho cdc giao vien nay khOng co dieu kien that huy dirge Ufa nang cua minh

Thirc to Ong T teen cuang vi la Hieu twang khOng co dd nang lire lath dao nen cOng tic chi dao kh8ng the thuyet phue cac gido vien trong Hai ding nha truing dang tam that tri de hoan thanh nhiem vu Chung vita nha twang, hien Wong chia be, Uri canh lai tiep dien va viec mat dean kat not 1)0 la khO tranh khOi

4.1.2 Phircrng an 2: CAch chin Ong T vi ba Q chuyen di don vi 'chic

Can dr vao kat luan cua doan thanh tra, twang phOng GD&DT huyen B 8ng T Ira ba Q len gap true tiep, yeu eau 6ng T phai thanh guy& toan 18 trieu &Ong cho nha that' ?ray dung; ba Q lam ha so ket town nhap 10 trieu dOng vao quy nha twang Lap ha so de nghi UBND huyen ra quyet dinh ky lust bang hinh tithe each chirc doi vOi Hieu twang, kdo dal thai gian len luting mat nam, ding thai co quyet dinh thuyén chuy'en Ong sang twang THCS D each nha gia dinh Ong khoang 4 km lam gido vien giang day lid ba nhiem Ong B la phO Hieu twang kiem Chil tich cOng dodn twang THCS A len lam Hieu twang thay 6ng T va de nghi 14 lust ba Q bang