1+,ӊ09Ө9¬1Ӝ,'81* + NKұQ GLӋQ FiF \ӃX Wӕ WiF ÿӝQJ ÿӃQ OzQJ WUXQJ WKjQK FӫD NKiFK KjQJ FiQKkQYӟLEDJyFÿӝYӅ[mKӝLNLQKWӃYjDQWRjQWURQJJLDRGӏFK + ĈROѭӡQJPӭFÿӝҧQKKѭӣQJFӫDWUDRÿәL[mKӝLSKtWәQFҧPQKұ
Ĉ͙LW˱ͫQJQJKLrQFͱX
ĈӕL WѭӧQJ QJKLrQ FӭX Oj FiF \ӃX Wӕ WiF ÿӝQJ ÿӃQ OzQJ WUXQJ WKjQK FӫD NKiFK KjQJFiQKkQVӱGөQJGӏFKYө1+Ĉ7WҥL/kPĈӗQJWK{QJTXDÿӕLWѭӧQJNKҧRViWOj FiFNKiFKWKӇÿmYjÿDQJVӱGөQJGӏFKYө
1.3 3+Ҥ09,1*+,Ç1&Ӭ8 'RFy QKӳQJKҥQ FKӃ YӅ WKӡL JLDQYjQJXӗQOӵF QrQ QJKLrQFӭX Qj\ JLӟL KҥQ SKҥPYLWKӵFKLӋQOjFiFNKiFKKjQJKLӋQÿDQJVӱGөQJGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJÿLӋQWӱ WҥL /kP ĈӗQJ Fө WKӇ NKҧR ViW YLӋF Vӱ GөQJ WҥL FiF QJkQ KjQJ VDX1 1+ 1{QJ QJKLӋSYjSKiWWULӇQQ{QJWK{Q$JULEDQN- &1/kPĈӗQJ- %7UҫQ3K~)73 Ĉj /ҥW- /kP ĈӗQJ; 2 1+ 70&3 6jL JzQ WKѭѫQJ WtQ (Sacombank) - Ĉj /ҥW- 32 KX+zD%uQK)73Ĉj/ҥW- /kPĈӗQJ; 3 1+70&3È&KkX (ACB)- &1/kP ĈӗQJ± 59-3KDQ%ӝL&KkX- )73Ĉj/ҥW- /kPĈӗQJ; 4 1+70&34XkQĈӝL
(MB) - &1/kPĈӗQJ- 3KDQĈuQK3KQJ- )73Ĉj/ҥW- /kPĈӗQJ; 5 NH TMC3&{QJ7KѭѫQJ9LӋWQDP9LHWLQEDQN&1/kPĈӗQJ- /rĈҥL+jQK)- 73Ĉj/ҥW- /kPĈӗQJ; 6 NH 70&3Ĉ{QJÈ (DongAbank) ± 03-&ÿѭӡQJ, F173Ĉj/ҥW- /kPĈӗQJ
é 1*+Ƭ$ &Ӫ$ 1*+,Ç1 &Ӭ8
KtW͝QF̫PQK̵Q3HUFHLYHGFRVW
ĈӇKuQKWKjQKJLiWUӏFҧPQKұQNKiFKKjQJSKҧLVRViQKQKӳQJJuKӑQKұQÿѭӧFYӟLQKӳQJWKӭKӑÿmEӓUDEDRJӗPFiFFKLSKtWLӅQWӋYjSKLWLӅQWӋQKѭWKӡLJLDQQӛOӵF3KtWәQFҧPQKұQOjVӵÿiQKJLiWKHRFҧPQKұQFKӫTXDQFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӅFKLSKtWjLFKtQK Pj NKiFK KjQJ SKҧLWUҧ ÿӇ WKөKѭӣQJGӏFKYө(Tam, 2004)9ӟLFQJPӝWPӭFJLiGӏFKYөQKѭQJPӛLNKiFKKjQJNKiFQKDXVӁFyQKӳQJFҧPQKұQNKiFQKDXYӅVӕWLӅQKӑEӓUDYuYұ\QyOj\ӃXWӕUҩWTXDQWUӑQJFҫQÿѭӧFTXDQWkPWURQJGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJ3KtWәQFҧPQKұQ FӫD NKiFKKjQJWKӇKLӋQ QKӳQJTXDQ ÿLӇPFKӫTXDQYӅJLiFҧUҿPҳFKD\FҧP[~FFӫDKӑKӧSOêNK{QJKӧSOêYjFzQOj Vӵ VR ViQK JLӳD PӭF JLi WKӵF WӃ Yj JLi Fҧ NǤ YӑQJ FӫD Kӑ(Oh, Ahn, & Kim, 2003; Tam, 20049uSKtWәQFҧPQKұQQҵPWURQJQKyP³EӓUD´NKLVRViQKYӟLQKӳQJWKӭ³QKұQ ÿѭӧF´WURQJTXiWUuQKFҧPQKұQYӅJLiWUӏSKtWәQFҧPQKұQFyWiF ÿӝQJ WLrX FӵF ÿӃQ JLi WUӏ FҧP QKұQ(Brady & Robertson, 1999; Teas & Agarwal, 2000; Gallarza & Gil Saura, 2006)+D\QyLFiFKNKiFNKLNKiFKKjQJFҧPQKұQ
JLi Fҧ GӏFK Yө TXi PҳF Kӑ VӁ tW WKҩ\ QKӳQJ Ju Kӑ QKұQ ÿѭӧF Oj [ӭQJ ÿiQJ YӟL QKӳQJJuPuQKEӓUD1JRjLUDNKLFҧPQKұQJLiGӏFKYөTXiFDRNKiFKKjQJVӁGӉ GjQJTX\NӃWUҵQJQKjFXQJFҩSÿDQJFyKjQKYLFѫKӝLKRһFÿDQJPѭXOӧLNK{QJ FKtQKÿiQJWӯÿyOzQJWLQFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӟLWәFKӭFFNJQJEӏJLҧPV~W&KӫQJKƭD FѫKӝLÿѭӧFÿӏQKQJKƭDOjKjQKYLWUөFOӧLNK{QJFKtQKÿiQJFӫDWәFKӭFYӟLNKiFK KjQJFӫDKӑYjÿmÿѭӧFFKӭQJPLQKFyWiFÿӝQJWLrXFӵFÿiQJNӇÿӃQPӕLTXDQKӋ Yj Vӵ WLQ WѭӣQJ FӫD NKiFK KjQJ(Morgan & Hunt, 1994; Wathne & Heide, 2000;
7KHRQJKƭDFKXQJQKҩWVӵWLQWѭӣQJOjVӵWӵWLQPjPӝWQJѭӡLNǤYӑQJYӅFiFK WKӭF WӕWÿҽS Pj QJѭӡLNKiF VӁÿӕL[ӱYӟL PuQKYj ÿѭӧFQKҩQ PҥQKӣÿk\OjW\
WKXӝF YjR NLQK QJKLӋP WѭѫQJ WiF WUѭӟF ÿy FӫD QJѭӡL Qj\(Gefen, 2002) 6 WLQ W˱ͧQJ OjÿLӅXNLӋQWLrQTX\ӃWFӫDKjQKYLKD\Oj\ӃXWӕFѫEҧQQKҩWFӫDÿӡLVӕQJ[m
KӝL(Luhmann, 2000), Yj FNJQJ Oj Fѫ Vӣ FKR PӑL KRҥW ÿӝQJ WKѭѫQJ PҥL ÿLӋQ Wӱ (Gefen, 2002)ĈDSKҫQFiFQJKLrQFӭXYӅVWLQW˱ͧQJ ÿӅXWұSWUXQJYjRNKtDFҥQK QLӅPWLQEHOLHIKD\WtQKÿiQJWLQFұ\WUXVWZRUWKLQHVVYӕQGƭWKӇKLӋQÿѫQWKXҫQ QKӳQJFҧPJLiFWLQWѭӣQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJYjRWәFKӭFJohnson & Grayson (2005) ÿmWKәLYjROXӗQJJLyPӟLPҿNKLWtFKKӧSWKrPVӵÿiQKJLiYjVX\[pWFӫDNKiFK KjQJYjRQLӅPWLQWURQJNKiLQLӋPPӟLOjVWLQW˱ͧQJQK̵QWKͱF7KHRÿyVWLQ W˱ͧQJQK̵QWKͱF OLrQTXDQÿӃQQKӳQJEӕLFҧQKFөWKӇ(Gefen & Straub, 2004)YtGө
QKѭVӵWLQWѭӣQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJYjRWәFKӭFVDXPӝWWKӡLJLDQGjLVӱGөQJGӏFKYө YӟLÿӏQKQJKƭDVDX³6WLQW˱ͧQJQK̵QWKͱF OjVӵWӵWLQKRһFVӵVҹQOzQJWU{QJFұ\
YjRNKҧQăQJYjVӵÿiQJWLQFӫDQKjFXQJFҩS´-RKQVRQYj*UD\VRQWU
6WLQW˱ͧQJQK̵QWKͱF OjNӃWTXҧFӫDTXiWUuQKWUҧLQJKLӋPGӏFKYөQyFKӭDÿӵQJ
WtQK ÿiQJ WLQ UHOLDEOHQHVV WtQK GӉ Gӵ ÿRiQ SUHGLFWDELOLW\ Yj Fҧ Vӵ VX\ WtQK FDOFXODWLYHFӫDNKiFKKjQJYjGүQÿӃQQKӳQJKjQKYLWLQWѭӣQJFӫDKӑ1KѭYұ\
VWLQW˱ͧQJQK̵QWKͱF NK{QJFKӍÿѫQWKXҫQOjQLӅPWLQWKLrQYӅFҧP[~FFӫDNKiFK
KjQJPjQyFzQKjPFKӭDVӵÿiQKJLiFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӅWәFKӭFVDXPӝWWKӡLJLDQWLrX GQJ GӏFK Yө 7URQJ QJKLrQ FӭX Qj\ ÿӇ ÿѫQ JLҧQ KѫQ YӅ WKXұW QJӳ WiF JLҧWKӕQJQKҩWWKDPFKLӃXV WLQW˱ͧQJQK̵QWKͱFQKѭOj VWLQW˱ͧQJ
4XDTXiWUuQKVӱGөQJGӏFKYөNKiFKKjQJVӁKuQKWKjQKPӕLTXDQKӋYӟLQJkQ KjQJYjFKҩWOѭӧQJPӕLTXDQKӋQj\WKѭӡQJÿѭӧFSKҧQiQKTXDVWLQW˱ͧQJ YjV
KjL OzQJ :DOWHU 0ller, Helfert, & Ritter (2003) ÿӇ Wӯ ÿy WUӵF WLӃS GүQ ÿӃQOzQJ WUXQJWKjQK FӫDKӑ/LQ& 'LQJ&iFF{QJWUuQKNKiFFNJQJJKLQKұQVWLQ W˱ͧQJ Fy WtQKFKҩWÿӏQKKѭӟQJGjLKҥQ Yj Oj \ӃX WӕTXDQ WUӑQJÿӇ [k\ GӵQJOzQJ WUXQJWKjQK FӫDNKiFKKjQJ(Chiou, 2004)
Littler & Melanthiou (2006) ÿӏQKQJKƭDUӫLURFҧPQKұQOjQKӳQJѭӟFÿRiQFKӫ TXDQFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӅFiFPҩWPiWFyWLӅPQăQJ[ҧ\UDWURQJTXiWUuQKKӑWKHR ÿXәLPӝWPөFWLrXPRQJPXӕQYjQKӳQJWәQWKҩWQj\UҩWÿDGҥQJSKөWKXӝFYjR WӯQJQJjQKQJKӅVҧQSKҭPGӏFKYөULrQJELӋWĈӕLYӟLGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJÿLӋQWӱ WKuUӫLURDQWRjQF{QJQJKӋOjYҩQÿӅÿѭӧFNKiFKKjQJTXDQWkPQKLӅXQKҩWYjÿm ÿѭӧFFKӭQJPLQKFyWiFÿӝQJÿiQJNӇQKҩWÿӃQWKiLÿӝYjêÿӏQKVӱGөQJFӫDNKiFK KjQJVRYӟLFiFUӫLURFҧPQKұQNKiF(Lee, 2009) 5ӫLURF{QJQJKӋÿѭӧF[iFÿӏQK OjQKӳQJWәQWKҩWWLӅPҭQEҳWQJXӗQWӯOӛLKӋWKӕQJKRһFFiFKDFNHU[kPQKұSKӋ WKӕQJDQQLQKNKLӃQFKRFiFWK{QJWLQFiQKkQYjWLӅQWURQJWjLNKRҧQFӫDNKiFK KjQJEӏ[kPKҥL5ҩWQKLӅXNKiFKKjQJWLQUҵQJKӑFҧPWKҩ\EҩWOӵFWURQJYLӋFQKұQ ELӃWQKӳQJPӕLQJX\KLӇPYӅF{QJQJKӋNKLVӱGөQJFiFGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJÿLӋQWӱ QrQQKұQWKӭFUӫLURYӅF{QJQJKӋFyWKӇJk\WkPOêNK{QJDQWkPYjҧQKKѭӣQJ ÿӃQVӵWKRҧLPiLFӫDNKiFKKjQJ(Littler & Melanthiou, 2006)9uYұ\UӫLURFҧP QKұQOjPӝW\ӃXWӕNK{QJWKӇWUiQKNKӓLYjFyWiFÿӝQJWLrXFӵFÿӃQFiFKjQKYLFӫD NKiFK KjQJ(Babin & Kim, 2001; Chang & Chen, 2008) Yj JLi WUӏ FҧP QKұQ FӫD NKiFKKjQJ(Gallarza & Gil Saura, 2006)7URQJTXiWUuQKVӱGөQJGӏFKYөYLӋFOR OҳQJYӅQKӳQJUӫLURF{QJQJKӋFyWKӇÿһWNKiFKKjQJYjRWuQKWUҥQJFăQJWKҷQJWӕQ QKLӅXWKӡLJLDQF{QJVӭFKѫQGROX{QSKҧLGqGһWFҭQWKұQWURQJPӑLWKDRWiFOjP VX\JLҧPJLiWUӏFҧPQKұQFӫDKӑ
0ӕLOLrQKӋJLӳDVӵWLQWѭӣQJYjQKұQWKӭFUӫLURÿmÿѭӧFQKLӅXKӑFJLҧQJKLrQFӭXӣFiFNKtDFҥQKYjQJӳFҧQKNKiFQKDXWӯÿyQKLӅXTXDQÿLӇPNKiFQKDXFNJQJ ÿѭӧFKuQKWKjQK7KHRGefen (2000), hay Pavlou (2003)VӵWLQWѭӣQJÿѭӧFQҧ\VLQKNKLNKiFKKjQJÿӕLPһWYӟLQKӳQJJLDRGӏFKKRһFJLDRWLӃS[mKӝLWURQJPӝWP{L
WUѭӡQJNK{QJFKҳFFKҳQ9tGөQKѭWURQJP{LWUѭӡQJQJkQKjQJÿLӋQWӱPӑLJLDR GӏFKÿӅÿѭӧFWLӃQKjQKWK{QJTXDSKѭѫQJWLӋQWUXQJJLDQOjPi\WtQKNKiFKKjQJ NK{QJWKӇWUӵFWLӃSFҧPQKұQQKӳQJGҩXKLӋXWKӇKLӋQVӵÿiQJWLQFӫDÿӕLSKѭѫQJ QKѭQpWPһWKD\FӱFKӍÿӇÿiQKJLiWuQKKuQKJLDRGӏFK7URQJWuQKKXӕQJKRjQWRjQ Eӏ ÿӝQJ Qj\ NKiFK KjQJ VӁ Wӵ [k\ GӵQJ WURQJ QKұQ WKӭF FӫD PuQK PӝW QLӅP WLQ EHOLHI WLQ WѭӣQJ UҵQJ ÿӕL WiF VӁ Fy QKӳQJ KjQK YL ÿҥR ÿӭF Yj Wӱ WӃ JLӕQJ QKѭ PRQJÿӧLFӫDPuQK7ӯÿyVӵWLQWѭӣQJQj\JL~SNKiFKKjQJFyFҧPJLiF\rQWkP ÿӇWKӵFKLӋQKjQKYLJLDRGӏFK.KtDFҥQKVӵWLQWѭӣQJӣGҥQJQLӅPWLQQj\ÿmÿѭӧF QKLӅX KӑF JLҧ FKӭQJ PLQK Fy WiF ÿӝQJ WUiL FKLӅX ÿӃQ FҧP QKұQ UӫL UR FӫD NKiFK KjQJQyJL~SNKiFKKjQJYѭӧWTXDQKӳQJORQJҥLÿӇKѭӟQJÿӃQFiFKRҥWÿӝQJJLDR GӏFK(Liu & cs, 2007; Kim, Ferrin, & Raghav Rao, 2008)1JRjLNKtDFҥQKQLӅPWLQ EHOLHIKD\VӵÿiQJWLQFұ\WUXVWZRUWKLQHVVVӵWLQWѭӣQJFzQÿѭӧFQJKLrQFӭXӣ PӭF ÿӝ KjQK YL EHKDYLRUDO WUXVW) (Mcallister, 1995) WKӇ KLӋQ QKӳQJ ê ÿӏQK KRһF KjQKYLFӫDNKiFKKjQJPjFyWKӇGүQKӑÿӃQWuQKWUҥQJUӫLURNK{QJÿѭӧFEҧRYӋ YtGөQKѭYLӋFVҹQVjQJFKLWUҧWUѭӟFNKLQKұQÿѭӧFKjQJ0һFGFiFKjQKYLQj\
FyWKӇJk\WәQKҥLÿӃQTX\ӅQOӧLFӫDPuQKQKѭQJNKiFKKjQJYүQFyWKӇWӵWLQWKӵFKLӋQEӣLYuKӑÿmFyVӵFkQQKҳFVRViQKJLӳDFҧPQKұQYӅUӫLURYjQLӅPWLQFӫDKӑYӅÿӕLWiFKRһFWәFKӭF1ӃXQLӅPWLQOӟQKѫQFҧPQKұQYӅUӫLURWKuNKiFKKjQJVӁVҹQVjQJFyQKӳQJêÿӏQKKRһFKjQKYLOLrQTXDQÿӃQVӵWLQWѭӣQJ9uYұ\NKL[HP[pWVӵWLQWѭӣQJӣNKtDFҥQKOjQKӳQJêÿӏQKKRһFKjQKYLWKuFҧPQKұQUӫLURFӫDNKiFKKjQJVӁOjQKӳQJWiFQKkQҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQTXiWUuQKFkQQKҳFYӅKjQKYLFӫDKӑYjWҩWQKLrQVӵҧQKKѭӣQJQj\PDQJWtQKFKҩWWUiLFKLӅX.KLNKiFKKjQJFҧPQKұQUҵQJVӵUӫLURӣPӭFFDRKӑVӁKҥQFKӃQKӳQJêÿӏQKKRһFKjQKYL[XҩWSKiWWӯ Vӵ WLQ WѭӣQJ FӫD Kӑ 7URQJ P{L WUѭӡQJ NLQK GRDQK WUӵF WX\ӃQ (Corbitt, Thanasankit, & Yi, 2003) ÿmÿӅ[XҩWP{KuQKJLҧLWKtFKUҵQJFҧPQKұQYӅUӫLUROjPJLҧPVӵWLQWѭӣQJFӫDFiFNKiFKKjQJGRDQKQJKLӋS7iFJLҧCorbitt & cs (2003) FNJQJÿm[k\GӵQJPӝWP{KuQKUҩWFKLWLӃWYӅVӵWLQWѭӣQJWURQJP{LWUѭӡQJWKѭѫQJPҥLÿLӋQWӱYӟLYLӋFSKkQWtFKVӵWLQWѭӣQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJӣFiFPӭFÿӝUҩWFөWKӇQKѭVDXVӵWLQWѭӣQJFѫEҧQEDVLFWUXVWOjQKӳQJQӅQWҧQJWLQWѭӣQJSKәELӃQQKҩWOjVӵWLQWѭӣQJJLӳDQJѭӡLYӟLQJѭӡLYjOjWLӅQÿӅFKRFXӝFVӕQJ[mKӝLVkXKѫQ
QӳDOjVӵWLQWѭӣQJÿҧPEҧRJXDUGHGWUXVWÿyOjVӵWLQWѭӣQJGӵDYjRQKӳQJJLDR NqRFKtQKWKӭFKD\QKӳQJOӡLKӭDYjFyWtQKFKҩWQJҳQKҥQ'ҥQJVӵWLQWѭӣQJQj\
VӁWKӇKLӋQTXDQKӳQJêÿӏQKKRһFKjQKYLYtGөNKLPӝWÿӕLWiFKӭDVӁJӣLKjQJ VDXNKLQKұQÿѭӧFWKDQKWRiQNKiFKKjQJVӁFkQQKҳFJLӳDUӫLUREӏPҩWWLӅQYj QLӅPWLQYjROӡLKӭDFӫDÿӕLWiFÿӇUDTX\ӃWÿӏQKFyFKX\ӇQWLӅQWUѭӟFFKRÿӕLWiF KD\NK{QJ9uYұ\VӵWLQWѭӣQJÿҧPEҧRQj\OLrQTXDQPұWWKLӃWYӟLFiFêÿӏQKYj KjQKYLYӅVӵWLQWѭӣQJEHKDYLRUDOWUXVWFӫDNKiFKKjQJ&XӕLFQJOjPӭFÿӝVӵ WLQ WѭӣQJ ӣ PӭF FDR QKҩW Vӵ WLQ WѭӣQJ Pӣ UӝQJ H[WHQGHG WUXVW Qy ÿѭӧF KuQK WKjQKTXDNLQKQJKLӋPWLӃS[~FOkXGjLYӟLFiFÿӕLWiFWUXVWHHNKLӃQPӝWFiQKkQ hRjQ WRjQ WLQ WѭӣQJ ÿӕL WiF Yj Wӵ WLQ OjP WKHR QKӳQJ ÿӅ [XҩW FӫD Kӑ 9t Gө PӝW QJѭӡL Fy WKӇ FKR EҥQ WKkQ FӫD PuQK YD\ WLӅQ Pj NK{QJ FҫQ QKӳQJ EҵQJ FKӭQJ FKtQKWKӭFQKѭKӧSÿӗQJYD\PѭӧQ1KѭYұ\NKLVӵWLQWѭӣQJӣPӭFÿӝVkXQy WKѭӡQJÿѭӧFWKӇKLӋQEҵQJGҥQJêÿӏQKKRһFKjQKYLYtGөQKѭYLӋFNKiFKKjQJVҹQ OzQJFXQJ FҩS WK{QJWLQFi QKkQ KD\JӣLWLӅQYjR QJkQ KjQJ ÿӇ Vӱ GөQJGӏFKYө
Corritore, Kracher, & Wiedenbeck (2003) ÿmÿӅ[XҩWUҵQJQKұQWKӭFYӅUӫLURFy WKӇ KҥQ FKӃ Vӵ WLQ WѭӣQJ FӫD NKiFK KjQJ 7KӵF Yұ\ NKL NKiFK KjQJ QKұQ WKӭF QKӳQJUӫLURFyWKӇPDQJOҥLWKLӋWKҥLOӟQWKuKӑVӁJLҧPWKLӇXQKӳQJKjQKYLWLQ WѭӣQJPjFyWKӇPDQJOҥLQKӳQJWәQWKҩWÿiQJNӇFKRPuQK7URQJPӝWQJKLrQFӭX WKӵFQJKLӋPYӅPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDVӵWLQWѭӣQJYjFҧPQKұQUӫLURFӫDNKiFKKjQJ
Lee, Yoon, & Lee (2007) ÿmFKӍUDUҵQJ PһFGUӫLUROjWLӅQÿӅÿӇVӵWLQWѭӣQJ[XҩWKLӋQ0LWFKHOOQKѭQJEҧQFKҩWTXDQKӋJLӳDFK~QJOjVӵWѭѫQJKӛSKӭFWҥSVӵWLQWѭӣQJFӫDPӝWNKiFKKjQJFyWKӇWKD\ÿәLOLrQWөFYjEӏJLҧPWKLӇXEӣLFҧPQKұQUӫLUR7URQJGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJÿLӋQWӱYLӋFTX\ӃWÿӏQKVӱGөQJGӏFKYөFXQJFҩSWK{QJWLQFiQKkQYjJӣLWLӅQYjRWjLNKRҧQ[XҩWSKiWWӵVӵWLQWѭӣQJQKұQWKӭFFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӅNKҧQăQJFӫDQJkQKjQJ.KLWKӵFKLӋQQKӳQJKjQKYLWLQWѭӣQJWUrQNKiFKKjQJSKҧLFyVӵWLQWѭӣQJYӅX\WtQYjNKҧQăQJJLҧLTX\ӃWFӫDQJkQKjQJQӃXFyEҩWNǤVӵFӕQjR[ҧ\UD9uYұ\WiFJLҧFKRUҵQJQKӳQJFҧPQKұQYӅ UӫLURF{QJ QJKӋ QKѭWK{QJWLQFi QKkQ EӏWLӃWOӝKD\ WKҩWWKRiWWjLVҧQFy WKӇJLҧPWKLӇXVӵWLQWѭӣQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӟLQJkQKjQJ
UDRÿ͝L[mK͡L6RFLDO([FKDQJH
7URQJNKLSKtWәQFҧPQKұQYjUӫLURFҧPQKұQWKXӝFYӅQKyP\ӃXWӕ³EӓUD´
WURQJYLӋFÿiQKJLiJLiWUӏFҧPQKұQFӫDNKiFKKjQJQKѭÿmÿӅFұSӣSKҫQWUrQWKu
\ӃXWӕ³QKұQOҥL´PjÿӅWjLQj\WұSWUXQJQJKLrQFӭXWURQJGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJÿy FKtQKOjWUDRÿ͝L[mK͡L
7UDRÿәLOjKjQKYLQKұQÿѭӧFPӝWWKӭJuÿyWӯYLӋFFKRÿLPӝWWKӭNKiF4XDQ KӋ WUDR ÿәL [m KӝL SKiW WULӇQ NKL PӝW Fi QKkQ QJѭӡL FXQJ FҩS GӏFK Yө Eә tFK WӟL QJѭӡLNKiFFyQJKƭDYөYӟLDQKWD7KӵFKLӋQQJKƭDYөQj\QJѭӡLWKӭKDLSKҧLFXQJ FҩSOӧLtFKFKR QKӳQJQJѭӡLÿҫXWLrQOҫQOѭӧW(Blau, 1964)1yLFiFKNKiFWUDRÿәL [mKӝLÿzLKӓLPӝWQJKƭDYөNK{QJ[iFÿӏQK(Blau, 1964).KLPӝWQJѭӡLQjRNKiF PӝWQJѭӡLӫQJKӝFyPӝWNǤYӑQJOӧLQKXұQWURQJWѭѫQJODLPһFGNKLFKtQK[iF QyVӁ[ҧ\UDYjӣKuQKWKӭFQjROjNK{QJU}UjQJ(Wayne, Shore, & Liden, 1997) ĈӃQPӭFPjFҧKDLErQiSGөQJFiFFKXҭQPӵFQKkQQKѭӧQJOүQQKDXÿӇ[k\GӵQJ PӕLTXDQKӋFӫDKӑÿӕL[ӱѭXÿmLEӣLPӝWWURQJKDLErQÿѭӧFÿiSOҥLGүQÿӃQNӃW TXҧÿ{LErQFQJFyOӧL(Rhoades & Eisenberger, 2002)
TKHRKӑFWKX\ӃWWUDRÿәL[mKӝLVRFLDOH[FKDQJHWKHRU\NKLNKiFKKjQJYjWә FKӭFWѭѫQJWiFYӟLQKDXFҧKDLSKtDÿӅXPRQJPXӕQWӕLÿDKyDQKӳQJOӧLtFKYjWӕL WKLӇXKyDQKӳQJSKtWәQFӫDPuQK(Salam & Pegels, 1998).KLQKӳQJQӛOӵFWӯPӝW ErQEӓUDÿѭӧFÿiSWUҧ[ӭQJÿiQJWKuQLӅPWLQYӅOӧLtFKTXDOҥLJLӳDKDLErQVӁGҫQ ÿѭӧFSKiWWULӇQYjOӧLtFKFӫDYLӋFWUDRÿәL[mKӝLVӁFjQJFDR(Russell Cropanzano
& Marie S Mitchell, 2005).KLVӱGөQJGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJErQFҥQKQKӳQJOӧLtFK YӅ NLQK WӃ WKu OӧL tFK [XҩW SKiW Wӯ WUDR ÿәL [m KӝL FNJQJ UҩW TXDQ WUӑQJ YӟL NKiFK KjQJEDRJӗPEDWKjQKSKҫQOj: K͟WUͫWͳW͝FKͱFK͟WUͫWͳQKkQYLrQYjK͟WUͫWͳ
2.1.6.1.&̫PQK̵QK͟WUͫWͳW͝FKͱF3HUFHLYHGRUJDQLVDWLRQDOVXSSRUW- POS)
&ҧPQKұQKӛWUӧWӯWәFKӭFÿѭӧFÿӏQKQJKƭDOjPӭFÿӝNKiFKKjQJNǤYӑQJYjRQKӳQJJLiWUӏPjWәFKӭFFyWKӇPDQJOҥLYjWLQWѭӣQJUҵQJWәFKӭFVӁTXDQWkPÿӃQTX\ӅQ OӧL FӫD PuQK(Eisenberger, Huntington, Hutchison, & Sowa, 1986) 7K{QJTXDVӵWѭѫQJWiFOLrQWөFYӟLPӝWWәFKӭFNKiFKKjQJFyWKӇFҧPQKұQÿѭӧFVӵKӛWUӧFӫDWәFKӭFFNJQJQKѭQKkQYLrQVӁOjPJu1KѭYұ\NKiFKKjQJFyWKӇFҧPWKҩ\
WӕWKѫQYӅGӏFKYөEӣLKӑ QKұQWKӭFÿѭӧFUҵQJWәFKӭFQj\F{QJQKұQQKӳQJÿyQJ JySFӫDKӑYjFXӕLFQJOjKjLOzQJYӟLWәFKӭF
&ҧPQKұQKӛWUӧWӯWәFKӭFÿѭӧFVӱGөQJÿӇFXQJFҩSPӝWOӡLJLҧLWKtFKFKRVӵ KRjLQJKLFӫDWәFKӭF+RjLQJKLWәFKӭFFyOLrQTXDQÿӃQYLӋFOjPKjLOzQJQyOj PӝWWKiLÿӝÿӕLYӟLPӝWWәFKӭFSKҧQiQKYӅQLӅPWLQKRһFNLQKQJKLӋPFӫDNKiFK KjQJQKѭOjPӝWSKҫQFӫDWәFKӭF&NJQJQKѭ326JLҧLWKtFKFҧPJLiFFӫDQKkQYLrQ YӅ JLi WUӏ ờ QJKƭD EҧQ VҳFô Qy JLҧL WKtFK FҧP JLiF FKiQ QҧQ FӫD QKkQ YLrQ Yj NKRҧQJFiFKWӯWәFKӭFFӫDKӑ1KjWkPOêKӑF-DPHV'HDQQJKLrQFӭXQKkQYLrQ YjWKҩ\UҵQJQJX\rQQKkQOӟQQKҩWFӫDVӵKRjLQJKLOjVӵWKD\ÿәLÿyOjFҧPQKұQOj QJRjLWҫPNLӇPVRiWFӫDQKkQYLrQRhoades & Eisenberger (2002) WuPWKҩ\UҵQJ QKӳQJWKD\ÿәLWURQJWәFKӭFtWÿѭӧFVӵKӛWUӧFӫDQKkQYLrQNKLFiFWKD\ÿәLÿm ÿѭӧFFRLOjQJRjLWҫPNLӇPVRiWFӫDKӑ
2.1.6.2 &̫PQK̵QK͟WUͫWͳQKkQYLrQ3HUFHLYHGVHUYLFHSURYLGHUVXSSRUW-PSP)
&ҧPQKұQKӛWUӧWӯQKkQYLrQJLDRGӏFKOjVӵÿiQKJLiFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӅPӭF ÿӝ Kӛ WUӧ NKiFK KjQJ FӫD QJѭӡL FXQJ FҩS WUӵF WLӃS GӏFK Yө FKR NKiFK KjQJ /ê WKX\ӃWWUDRÿәL[mKӝL(Blau, 1964) FNJQJQKѭFiFQJKLrQFӭXKLӋQWҥLFKRUҵQJFҧP QKұQ KӛWUӧWӯQKkQ YLrQJLDRGӏFKFy OLrQTXDQ ÿӃQ VӵKjLOzQJFӫD NKiFK KjQJ 7KHROêWKX\ӃWWUDRÿәL[mKӝLNKLFiQKkQÿDQJӣWURQJPӝWPӭFFKҩWOѭӧQJFDRYj PӕLTXDQKӋWtFKFӵFKӑFѭ[ӱWKHRFiFKFyOӧLFKRÿӕLWiFWUDRÿәLFӫDKӑFXQJ FҩSGӏFKYөFKҷQJKҥQQKѭWKӵFKLӋQPӝWFiFKKLӋXTXҧYjWҥRUDÿѭӧFVӵQӛOӵF KѫQQӳD.ӃWTXҧOjYLӋFVҧQ[XҩWYjFXQJFҩSGӏFKYөÿѭӧFQkQJFDRGRÿyGүQ ÿӃQVӵKjLOzQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJ
2.1.6.3.&̫PQK̵QK͟WUͫWͳNKiFKKjQJNKiF3HUFHLYHGFXVWRPHUVXSSRUW- PCS)
&ҧPQKұQKӛWUӧWӯNKiFKKjQJNKiFOjVӵÿiQKJLiFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӅKjQKYLKӛWUӧKӑEӣLFiFNKiFKKjQJNKiFWURQJEӕLFҧQKWѭѫQJÿӗQJ.KiFK KjQJWURQJFiFWuQKKXӕQJFXQJFҩSGӏFKYөWѭѫQJWiFYӟLFiFNKiFKKjQJNKiF%ӣLYuKӑWҥRUDPӝWP{LWUѭӡQJ[mKӝLWtFKFӵFFKRWUҧLQJKLӋPGӏFKYөYjFѫKӝLYӟL[mKӝLKӑWKӵFKLӋQPӝWYDLWUzÿӕLӭQJYӟLFiFNKiFKKjQJNKiFYjGRÿyJySSKҫQWKӵFKLӋQGӏFKYөYjVӵKjLOzQJ(Zeithaml & Mary, 2003)%ҵQJFKӭQJWKӵFQJKLӋPOLrQNӃWWѭѫQJWiFJLӳDFiFFiQKkQÿӇFҧLWKLӋQWK{QJWLQOLrQOҥFKӧSWiFYjVӵKjLOzQJ
(Glaman, Jones, & Rozelle, 2002)&iFWKjQKYLrQFyWKӇFXQJFҩSFKRQKDXYӟLVӵ KӛWUӧ[mKӝLYjFҧP[~FFӫDJLiWUӏFiQKkQGүQÿӃQFҧP[~FFӫDOzQJWUXQJWKjQK (Sherony & Green, 2002) 6ӵKӛWUӧQKұQWKӭFFӫDÿӗQJQJKLӋSOjUҩWTXDQWUӑQJÿӇ KRjQ WKjQKFiF QKLӋP YөYj OLrQ TXDQ ÿӃQYҩQ ÿӅ Y{KuQK(Susskind, Kacmar, &
Borchgrevink, 2003)GүQÿӃQVӵKjLOzQJ Bettencourt (1997) [iFÿӏQKNKiLQLӋPYӅFҧPQKұQKӛWUӧWӯNKiFKKjQJNKiF QKѭPӝWWLӅQÿӅTXDQWUӑQJÿӇWUDRÿәL[mKӝLWURQJEӕLFҧQKWLrXWKө&өWKӇKѫQ PӝWVӵFҧPQKұQKӛWUӧWӯNKiFKKjQJFDRGүQÿӃQPӝWVӵVҹQVjQJFDRFӫDNKiFK KjQJÿӇGX\WUuPӝWPӕLTXDQKӋWUDRÿәL[mKӝLYӟLF{QJW\YjGRÿyÿӇKӧSWiF QKLӅX KѫQ FӫD NKiFK KjQJ WURQJ TXi WUuQK SKiW WULӇQ GӏFK Yө(Bagozzi, 1995;
7URQJTXiWUuQKWѭѫQJWiFYӟLWәFKӭFFiFKjQKYLÿӏQKKѭӟQJNKiFKKjQJFӫD QKkQYLrQJLDRGӏFKFzQWiFÿӝQJUҩWOӟQÿӃQWKiLÿӝYjVӵKjLOzQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJ (Hennig-Thurau, Gwinner, Walsh, & Gremler, 2004) Solomon, Surprenant,
Czepiel, & Gutman (1985) FKR UҵQJ TXi WUuQK JLDR WLӃS JLӳD QKkQ YLrQ Yj NKiFKKjQJPDQJWtQKFKҩWOӧLtFKWѭѫQJKӛFӫDWUDRÿәL[mKӝLYjTXDÿyNKiFKKjQJKuQKWKjQKFҧPQKұQVӵKӛWUӧWӯQKkQYLrQYjTX\ӃWÿӏQKVӵKjLOzQJYӟLGӏFKYө1JRjLUD Vӵ WѭѫQJ WiF JLӳD FiF NKiFK KjQJ YӟL QKDX FNJQJ Fy YDL WUz TXDQ WUӑQJ ҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQQKұQWKӭFYjWKiLÿӝFӫDNKiFKKjQJÿһFELӋWOjWURQJQKӳQJQJjQKGӏFKYөFyWtQK[mKӝLKyDFDRYi & Gong (2009) ÿmNKiPSKiWKjQKF{QJNKtDFҥQKKӛWUӧWӯNKiFKKjQJYӟLYDLWUzOjJLiWUӏFӫDTXiWUuQKWUDRÿәL[mKӝLWURQJQJjQKJLiRGөFÿҥLKӑF7URQJGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJÿLӋQWӱFҧPQKұQKӛWUӧWӯNKiFKKjQJÿѭӧF ÿӏQKQJKƭDOjPӭFÿӝFӫDVӵF{QJQKұQVӵWUӧJL~SWӯQKӳQJQJѭӡLNKiFKRһF FѫKӝL[~FWLӃQQKӳQJPӕLTXDQKӋ[mKӝLPjNKiFKKjQJQKұQÿѭӧFNKLWLrXGQJGӏFKYө7yPOҥLFҧEDORҥLKӛWUӧWUrQWӵXFKXQJÿӅXFyWtQKFKҩWFӫDJLDRWLӃS[mKӝLWtQK[mKӝLKyDYjOӧLtFKWѭѫQJKӛ- QKӳQJFăQQJX\rQFѫEҧQQKҩWFӫDJLiWUӏFKҩWOѭӧQJTXDQKӋYjOzQJWUXQJWKjQKFӫDNKiFKKjQJ(Zeithaml & Mary, 2003; Bock, Zmud, Kim, & Lee, 2005; Yi & Gong, 2009)9uYұ\ÿӅWjLQj\[HP[pWFҧEDORҥLFҧPQKұQKӛWUӧWUrQFQJNӃWKӧSYӟLQKDXSKҧQiQKFKRNKiLQLӋPFKXQJOjWUDR ÿәL[mKӝLÿӇWKӇKLӋQFKRFҧPQKұQQKӳQJOӧLtFKPjNKiFKKjQJFyÿѭӧFWӯSKtD
[mKӝLNKLWLrXGQJGӏFKYөQJkQKjQJÿLӋQWӱ1JRjLUDYuEҧQFӫDYLӋFJLDRWLӃS Yj WѭѫQJ WiF Oj QJXӗQ JӕF KuQK WKjQK QrQ Vӵ WLQ WѭӣQJ(Gefen, 2000; Gefen &
Straub, 2004) QrQWUDRÿәL[mKӝLÿѭӧFNǤYӑQJNK{QJQKӳQJJLDWăQJJLiWUӏFҧP QKұQPjFzQWҥRQrQVӵWLQWѭӣQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJ
2.2.1 1JKLrQFͱXFͯDGallarza & Gil Saura (2006)
7URQJ PӝW QJKLrQ FӭX FӫDGallarza & Gil Saura (2006) QJKLrQ FӭX YӅ PӕL TXDQKӋFiFFKLӅXFӫDJLiWUӏNKiFKKjQJJӗPJLiWUӏFҧPQKұQVӵKjLOzQJYjOzQJ WUXQJWKjQKFӫDNKiFKKjQJÿӕLYӟLKjQKYLGXOӏFKFӫDFiFVLQKYLrQÿҥLKӑFWURQJ EӕLFҧQKOLrQTXDQÿӃQGXOӏFKVӱGөQJKӋWKӕQJ+ROEURRNYjNӃWKӧSQyYӟLFiF
\ӃXWӕÿҫXYjRWLrXFӵFNKiFFӫDJLiWUӏ1JRjLUDWiFJLҧFNJQJNKiPSKiPӕLTXDQ KӋJLӳDFҧPQKұQFӫDNKiFKKjQJYӅJLiWUӏFҧPQKұQVӵKjLOzQJYӟLOzQJWUXQJ WKjQKFӫDNKiFKKjQJ+DLPөFWLrXQj\ÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQEҵQJFiFK[k\GӵQJPӝW P{KuQK/,65(/KuQK ӃW TXҧ QJKLrQFӭXNKҷQJ ÿӏQKWӗQWҥLPӕLTXDQ KӋ FӫDFKXӛLFKҩWOѭӧQJ- JLiWUӏ- VӵKjLOzQJ- OzQJWUXQJWKjQKYjPLQKKRҥFiFFKLӅX SKӭF WҥSFӫD JLiWUӏ ÿѭӧF[HP QKѭOj \ӃXWӕFy ÿӝQKҥ\ FDRWӟLWUҧL QJKLӋPFӫD NKiFKKjQJ
+uQK10{KuQKQJKLrQFӭXÿӅ[XҩWFӫDGallarza & Gil Saura (2006)
&NJQJQJKLrQFӭXYӅVӵKjLOzQJYjêÿӏQKKjQKYLVDXPXDFӫDNKiFKKjQJYi
& Gong (2009) ÿm[k\GӵQJPӝWP{KuQKWәQJTXiWYӅTXDQKӋWѭѫQJWiF[mKӝLFӫD NKiFKKjQJWURQJÿyWUҧLQJKLӋPFӫD NKiFK KjQJÿyQJYDLWUzWUXQJJLDQ1JKLrQ FӭXQj\WuPFiFK[iFÿӏQKEҵQJFiFKQjRPӕLTXDQKӋWѭѫQJWiF[mKӝLFӫDNKiFK KjQJWiFÿӝQJÿӃQVӵKjLOzQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJYjWLӃSÿyVӵKjLOzQJWiFÿӝQJÿӃQê ÿӏQKKjQKYLPXDOҥLVҧQSKҭPGӏFKYө'ӵDYjRP{KuQK625VWLPXOXV±organism- UHVSRQVH PRGHO WiF JLҧ FKR UҵQJ QKӳQJ QKұQ WKӭF Wӯ Vӵ Kӛ WUӧ FӫD Fѫ TXDQ- Wә FKӭFKӛWUӧWӯNKiFKKjQJNKiFYjKӛWUӧWӯQKjFXQJFҩSGӏFKYөFyҧQKKѭӣQJ ÿӃQ Vӵ KjL OzQJ FӫD NKiFK KjQJ Yj Wӯ ÿy WiF ÿӝQJ ÿӃQ ê ÿӏQK PXD OҥL +ѫQ QӳD QJKLrQFӭXQj\FNJQJFKRWKҩ\UҵQJ\ӃXWӕKӛWUӧWӯFѫTXDQ- WәFKӭFÿѭӧFFKROj
\ӃXWӕTXDQWUӑQJQKҩWWiFÿӝQJÿӃQVӵKjLOzQJYӟLQKӳQJNKiFKKjQJFyQKLӅXWUҧL QJKLӋPQJѭӧFOҥL\ӃXWӕKӛWUӧWӯQKӳQJNKiFKKjQJNKiFOҥLOj\ӃXWӕTXDQWUӑQJ QKҩWҧQK KѭӣQJÿӃQ VӵKjLOzQJFӫD QKӳQJ NKiFK KjQJ FytWWUҧL QJKLӋP1JKLrQ FӭX Qj\ WKӵF KLӋQ PӝW FXӝF NKҧR ViW FKR KӑF YLrQ FӫD YLӋQ QJ{Q QJӳ QѭӟF QJRjLWURQJPӝWWUѭӡQJÿҥLKӑF7ҩWFҧFiFJLҧWKX\ӃWFӫDQJKLrQFӭXÿӅXÿѭӧFӫQJ Kӝ+uQK
+uQK20{KuQKQJKLrQFӭXFӫDYi & Gong (2009)
7URQJPӝWQJKLrQFӭXYӅPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFKҩWOѭӧQJGӏFKYөJLiWUӏFҧPQKұQ YjKuQKҧQKF{QJW\ÿӃQOzQJWUXQJWKjQKFӫDNKiFKKjQJWURQJEӕLFҧQK PӭFÿӝ WKD\ÿәLFӫDFiFORҥLFKLSKtFKX\ӇQÿәL(Wang, 2010) ÿmPӣUӝQJNKiLQLӋPJLiWUӏ FҧP QKұQ NKiFK KjQJ Yj KuQK ҧQK F{QJ W\ Yj FKӭQJ PLQK UҵQJ FiF ORҥL FKL SKt FKX\ӇQÿәLOj \ӃXWӕTXDQWUӑQJҧQKKѭӣQJWӟLTX\ӃWÿӏQKӣOҥL YӟLQKjFXQJFҩS GӏFKYөFӫDNKiFKKjQJ
7iFJLҧFNJQJ[k\GӵQJPӝWP{KuQKQJKLrQFӭXOLrQTXDQÿӃQJLiWUӏFҧPQKұQ NKiFKKjQJKuQKҧQK F{QJW\YjFiFFKLSKtFKX\ӇQÿәLFNJQJQKѭFKӍUDUҵQJWiF ÿӝQJFӫDJLiWUӏFҧPQKұQNKiFKKjQJYjKuQKҧQKF{QJW\ÿӃQOzQJWUXQJWKjQKFӫD NKiFKKjQJJLҧPWURQJÿLӅXNLӋQFiFORҥLFKLSKtFKX\ӇQÿәLWăQJ+uQK+D\
QUY 75ẻ1+ 1*+,ầ1 &Ӭ8
ĈL͉XNL͏Qÿ͋SKkQWtFK()$
3KkQWtFK()$GӵDWUrQFѫVӣPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFiFELӃQÿROѭӡQJYuYұ\WUѭӟF NKLTX\ӃWÿӏQKVӱGөQJ()$FҫQSKҧL[HP[pWPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFiFELӃQÿROѭӡQJ Qj\6ӱGөQJPDWUұQKӋVӕWѭѫQJTXDQFyWKӇQKұQELӃWÿѭӧFPӭFÿӝTXDQKӋJLӳD FiFELӃn 7Kӑ1ӃXFiFKӋVӕWѭѫQJTXDQQKӓ.WKuVӱGөQJ()$NK{QJ SKKӧp (Hair & ctg, 2006) 0ӝWVӕWLrXFKtÿiQKJLiPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFiFELӃQYj VӵSKKӧSYӟLGӳOLӋXWURQJSKkQWtFK()$QKѭVDX
- LӇPÿӏQK%DUWOHWWGQJÿӇ[HP[pWPDWUұQWѭѫQJTXDQFySKҧLOjPDWUұQ ÿѫQYӏ,LGHQWLW\PDWUL[OjPDWUұQFyFiFWKjQKSKҫQKӋVӕWѭѫQJTXDQJLӳDFiFELӃQEҵQJNK{QJYjÿѭӡQJFKpRKӋVӕWѭѫQJTXDQYӟLFKtQKQyEҵQJ1ӃXSKpS
NLӇPÿӏQK%DUWOHWWFySJLҧWKX\ӃW+REӏWӯFKӕLPDWUұQWѭѫQJTXDQOjPD WUұQÿѫQYӏQJKƭDOjFiFELӃQFyTXDQKӋYӟLQKDXWURQJWәQJWKӇYLӋFSKkQWtFK QKkQWӕOjSKKӧSÿӕLYӟLWұSGӳOLӋXÿDQJ[pW
- LӇPÿӏQK.02.DLVHU-Meyer-2ONLQPHDVXUHRIVDPSOLQJDGHTXDF\OjFKӍ VӕGQJÿӇVRViQKÿӝOӟQFӫDKӋVӕWѭѫQJTXDQJLӳDKDLELӃQ; i Yj; j YӟLÿӝOӟQ FӫD KӋ VӕWѭѫQJTXDQ ULrQJ SKҫQ FӫD FK~QJ(Norusis, 1994) GQJÿӇ ÿiQK JLiVӵ WKtFKKӧSFӫDGӳOLӋXYӟLSKkQWtFKQKkQWӕNKiPSKi7UӏVӕ.02WKtFKKӧSFyJLi WUӏWӯ± FzQQӃXQKѭFKӍVӕQj\QKӓKѫQ.WKuSKkQWtFKQKkQWӕ FyNKҧQăQJ NK{QJSKKӧSYӟLFiFGӳOLӋu 7UӑQJ 1JӑF 'Rÿy.02FjQJOӟQFjQJ WӕWYuSKҫQFKXQJJLӳDFiFELӃQFjQJOӟQĈӇVӱGөQJ()$.02SKҧLOӟQKѫQ.5
.DLVHU ÿӅ QJKӏ 02 UҩW WӕW 02 WӕW 02 ÿѭӧF 02.6WҥPÿѭӧF.02[ҩXYj.02.NK{QJWKӇFKҩSQKұQÿѭӧF
- +ӋVӕSKѭѫQJVDLWUtFK9DULDQFHH[SODLQHGFULWHULDOjSKҫQWUăPSKѭѫQJVDL WRjQEӝÿѭӧFJLҧLWKtFKEӣLFiFQKkQWӕ3KѭѫQJVDLWUtFKFҫQÿҥWPӭFWLrXFKXҭQWӯ WUӣOrQÿӇSKҫQWUăPVӵ ELӃQWKLrQFӫDFiFQKkQWӕFyWKӇJLҧLWKtFKÿѭӧFEҵQJ SKҫQWUăPVӵELӃQWKLrQFӫDFiFELӃQTXDQViW
- tFKWKѭӟFPүXĈӇVӱGөQJ()$FҫQNtFKWKѭӟFPүXOӟQ9ҩQÿӅ[iFÿӏQK NtFKWKѭӟFPүXSKKӧSOjYҩQÿӅSKӭFWҥSWK{QJWKѭӡQJGӵDWKHRNLQKQJKLӋP (Hair & ctg, 2006) FKRUҵQJÿӇVӱGөQJ()$NtFKWKѭӟFPүXWӕLWKLӇXSKҧLOj WӕWKѫQOjYjWӹOӋTXDQViWELӃQÿROѭӡQJOjQJKƭDOjPӝWELӃQÿROѭӡQJFҫQ WӕLWKLӇXTXDQViWWӕWQKҩWOjWUӣOrQӢQJKLrQFӭXQj\FӥPүXÿmSKKӧS [HPOҥLSKҫQFKӑQPүXYjNӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭX
&yQKLӅXSKѭѫQJSKiSFKӑQQKkQWӕFzQJӑLOjFKӑQÿLӇPGӯQJFҫQFK~êWKrP Oj FiF QKj QJKLrQ FӭX NK{QJ Vӱ GөQJ PӝW SKѭѫQJ SKiS ULrQJ ELӋW QjR WURQJ [iF ÿӏQKVӕOѭӧQJFiFQKkQWӕPjKӑWKѭӡQJNӃWKӧS QKLӅXWLrXFKtNKiFQKDXHair & cs, 2006)%DSKѭѫQJSKiSWKѭӡQJÿѭӧFVӱGөQJOjWLrXFKtHLJHQYDOXHWLrX FKtÿLӇPJm\VFUHHWHVWFULWHULRQ&DWWHOOYj[iFÿӏQKWUѭӟFVӕOѭӧQJQKkQ Wӕ
- 7LrX FKt HLJHQYDOXH Oj PӝW WLrX FKt Vӱ GөQJ SKә ELӃQ WURQJ [iF ÿӏQK Vӕ
OѭӧQJQKkQWӕWURQJSKkQWtFK()$ÿҥLGLӋQFKRSKҫQELӃQWKLrQÿѭӧFJLҧLWKtFKEӣL PӛLQKkQWӕ9ӟLWLrXFKtQj\VӕOѭӧQJQKkQWӕÿѭӧF[iFÿӏQKӣQKkQWӕGӯQJӣ QKkQWӕFyHLJHQYDOXHWӕLWKLӇXEҵQJYjSKѭѫQJVDLWUtFK!.*HUELQJYj
$QGHUVRQ7URQJQJKLrQFӭXQj\SKѭѫQJSKiSQj\ÿѭӧFWiFJLҧVӱGөQJ - 7LrXFKtÿLӇPJm\FNJQJWKѭӡQJÿѭӧFVӱGөQJÿӇ[iFÿӏQKVӕOѭӧQJQKkQWӕ 7LrX FKt Qj\ GӵD YjR ÿѭӧF ELӇX GLӉQ JLӳD Vӕ QKkQ Wӕ WUөF KRjQK Yj JLi WUӏ HLJHQYDOXHWUөFWXQJĈLӇPJm\OjÿLӇPWҥLÿyÿѭӡQJELӇXGLӉQHLJHQYDOXH I Vӕ QKkQWӕWKD\ÿәLÿӝWQJӝWÿӝGӕF
- &KӑQWUѭӟFVӕOѭӧQJFiFQKkQWӕVӕOѭӧQJQKkQWӕÿѭӧF[iFÿӏQKWUѭӟFGӵD YjROêWKX\ӃW
3.3.5 3KkQWtFKQKkQW͙NK̻QJÿ͓QK&)$YjP{KuQK6(0
6DXNKLSKkQWtFK()$WiFJLҧWLӃQKjQKNLӇPWUDOҥLÿӝJLiWUӏJLiWUӏSKkQELӋW YjJLiWUӏKӝLWөFӫDWKDQJÿRFNJQJQKѭ[iFÿӏQKVӵSKKӧSFӫDFiFFҩXWU~FWURQJ P{KuQKQJKLrQFӭXEҵQJNӻWKXұWSKkQWtFKQKkQWӕNKҷQJÿӏQK &)$ĈӗQJWKӡL WtQKWRiQÿӝWLQFұ\WәQJKӧSFRPSRVLWHUHOLDELOLW\YjSKѭѫQJVDLWUtFKYDULDQFH H[WUDFWHG 0{ KuQK FҩX WU~F WX\ӃQ WtQK 6(0 ÿѭӧF Vӱ GөQJ ÿӇ NLӇP WUD FiF JLҧ WKX\ӃWFӫDP{KuQKQJKLrQFӭX7ҩWFҧFiFNӻWKXұWWUrQÿѭӧF[ӱOêEҵQJSKҫQPӅP SPSS 20 Yj$PRV
7URQJNLӇPÿӏQKWKDQJÿRSKѭѫQJSKiS&)$WURQJSKkQWtFKP{KuQKFҩXWU~F WX\ӃQ WtQK Fy QKLӅX ѭX ÿLӇP KѫQ VR YӟL SKѭѫQJ SKiS WUX\ӅQ WKӕQJ QKѭ SKѭѫQJ SKiS KӋ Vӕ WѭѫQJ TXDQ SKѭѫQJ SKiS SKkQ WtFK QKkQ Wӕ NKiP SKi ()$ 3KѭѫQJ SKiS&)$FKRSKpSNLӇPÿӏQKFҩXWU~FOêWKX\ӃWFӫDFiFWKDQJÿROѭӡQJQKѭPӕL TXDQKӋJLӳDPӝWNKiLQLӋPQJKLrQFӭXYӟLFiFNKiLQLӋPNKiFPjNK{QJEӏFKӋFK GRVDLVӕÿROѭӡQJ0һWNKiFFK~QJWDFyWKӇNLӇPÿӏQKJLiWUӏKӝLWөYjJLiWUӏSKkQ ELӋWFӫDWKDQJÿRPӝWFiFKUҩWÿѫQJLҧQWUӵFTXDQYjQKDQKFKyQJPjNK{QJFҫQ QKLӅXWKӫWөF7URQJNLӇPÿӏQKJLҧWKX\ӃWFNJQJQKѭP{KuQKOêWKX\ӃWSKѭѫQJSKiS
&)$FNJQJFyOӧLKѫQSKѭѫQJSKiSKӗLTX\ÿDELӃQYuQyWtQKÿѭӧFVDLVӕÿROѭӡQJ0һWNKiFSKѭѫQJSKiSQj\FKRSKpSNӃWKӧSÿѭӧFFiFNKiLQLӋPWLӅPҭQYӟLÿROѭӡQJFӫDFK~QJYjFyWKӇ[HP[pWFiFÿROѭӡQJÿӝFOұSKD\NӃWKӧSFKXQJYӟLP{
KuQKOêWKX\ӃWFQJPӝWO~FÿѭӧFVӱGөQJUӝQJUmLWURQJFiFOƭQKYӵFWLӃSWKӏQKӳQJ QăPJҫQÿk\ ĈӇ ÿR OѭӡQJ PӭF ÿӝ SK KӧS FӫD P{ KuQK YӟL WK{QJ WLQ WKӏ WUѭӡQJ QJѭӡL WD WKѭӡQJ Vӱ GөQJ &KL-square (CMIN); Chi-VTXDUH ÿLӅX FKӍQK WKHR EұF Wӵ GR
&0,1GIFKӍVӕWKtFKKӧSVRViQK&),B&RPSDUDWLYH)LW,QGH[&KӍVӕ7XFNHU /HZLV7/,B7XFNHU /HZLV,QGH[&KӍVӕ506($5RRW0HDQ6TXDUHError
$SSUR[LPDWLRQ0{ KuQKÿѭӧF[HP OjWKtFKKӧS YӟL GӳOLӋXWKӏWUѭӡQJNKL NLӇP ÿӏQK &KL-VTXDUH Fy 3-YDOXH ! 7X\ QKLrQ &KL-VTXDUH Fy QKѭӧF ÿLӇP Oj SKө WKXӝFYjRNtFKWKѭӟFPүX1ӃXP{KuQKQKұQÿѭӧFFiFJLiWUӏ*),7/,&),.9 (Bentler & Bonett, 1980) &0,1GI PӝW Vӕ WUѭӡQJ KӧS &0,1GI Fy WKӇ (Carmines & McIver, 1981); 506($.08 ÿѭӧF[HPOjUҩWWӕW(Steiger, 1990), WKu P{KuQKÿѭӧF[HPOjSKKӧSYӟLGӳOLӋXWKӏWUѭӡQJKD\WѭѫQJWKtFKYӟLGӳOLӋXWKӏ WUѭӡQJ7Kӑ 7UDQJ (2009) FKRUҵQJQӃXP{KuQKQKұQÿѭӧFFiFJLiWUӏ7/,&),
.&0,1GI506($.WKuP{KuQKSKKӧSWѭѫQJWKtFKYӟLGӳOLӋX WKӏWUѭӡQJ
&iFWLrXFKXҭQÿiQKJLiPӭFÿӝSKKӧSFӫDP{KuQKWKHRFiFWKXӝFWtQKJLiWUӏ EDRJӗP
- ĈӝWLQFұ\FӫDWKDQJÿRÿѭӧFÿiQKJLiWK{QJTXDKӋVӕWLQFұ\WәQJKӧSȡF WәQJSKѭѫQJVDLWUtFKÿѭӧFȡYFKӋVӕWLQFұ\Į&URQEDFKảV$OSKD7URQJÿy SKѭѫQJVDLWUtFK SKҧQiQKOѭӧQJELӃQWKLrQFKXQJFӫDFiFELӃQTXDQViWÿѭӧFJLҧL WKtFKEӣLELӃQWLӅPҭQHair & ctg, 1998)ÿӝWLQFұ\WәQJKӧSÿROѭӡQJÿӝWLQFұ\
FӫD WұS KӧS FiF ELӃQ TXDQ ViW ÿR OѭӡQJ PӝW NKiL QLӋP QKkQ Wӕ KӋ Vӕ WLQ Fұ\
&URQEDFKảVDOSKDÿROѭӡQJWtQKNLrQÿӏQKQӝLWҥL[X\rQVXӕWWұSKӧSFiFELӃQTXDQ ViWFӫDFiFFkXWUҧOӡL(Schumacker & Lomax, 2004).7LrXFKXҭQÿiQKJLiPӭFÿӝ SKKӧSFӫDP{KuQKEӣLÿӝWLQFұ\FӫDWKDQJÿROjȡF> 0.KRһFȡYF!.KRһFĮ
- 7tQKÿѫQKѭӟQJÿѫQQJX\rQFӫDPӝWWKDQJÿRWKӇKLӋQP͟LP͡WEL͇QTXDQ ViWFK͑ÿ˱ͫFV͵GͭQJÿ͋ÿRO˱ͥQJGX\QK̭WP͡WEL͇QWL͉P̱Q Theo Steenkamp &
Van Trijp (1991)PӭFÿӝSKKӧSFӫDP{KuQKÿROѭӡQJYӟLGӳOLӋXWKӏWUѭӡQJFKRFK~QJWDÿLӅXNLӋQFҫQYjÿӫÿӇNӃWOXұQWұSFiFELӃQTXDQViWÿҥWÿѭӧFWtQKÿѫQ
KѭӟQJWUӯNKLFiFVDLVӕFӫDWұSFiFELӃQTXDQViWFyWѭѫQJTXDQYӟLQKDX
- *LiWUӏKӝLWө&RQYHUJHQWYDOLGLW\WKӇKLӋQJLiWUӏÿROѭӡQJPӝWNKiLQLӋP WѭѫQJTXDQFKһWFKӁYӟLQKDXVDXQKӳQJÿROѭӡQJÿѭӧFOһSOҥL7KHRAnderson &
Gerbing (1988), WKDQJÿRÿѭӧFFRLOjÿҥWÿѭӧFJLiWUӏKӝLWөNKLFiFWUӑQJVӕFKXҭQ KyDFӫDWKDQJÿRÿӅXFDR!.YjFyêQJKƭDWKӕQJNrWӭF3.05
- *LiWUӏSKkQELӋW'LVFULPQDQWYDOLGLW\WKӇKLӋQVӵ NKiFELӋWJLӳDFiFNKiL QLӋPWURQJP{KuQKQJKLrQFӭXYjÿLӅXQj\[ҧ\UDNKLKӋVӕWѭѫQJTXDQJLӳDFiF NKiL QLӋP WUrQ SKҥP YL WәQJ WKӇ ÿӅX NKiF ELӋW YӟL Yj Fy ê QJKƭD WKӕQJ Nr (P