ộ1*+Ƭ$.+2$+Ӑ&9ơ7+Ӵ&7,ӈ1&Ӫ$1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8
Ĉẽ1**ẽ39ӄ+Ӑ& 7+8Ұ7
9 ;iFÿӏQKFiF\ӃXWӕFөWKӇYӅ1/4/FҫQWKLӃWFKRFiFQKj4/'$ÿӇKRjQWKjQK GӵiQ%,0PӝWFiFKWKjQKF{QJ
9 7uPUDFiF\ӃXWӕSKӭFWҥSFӫDGӵiQFyVӱGөQJ%,0
9 7uPUDQKӳQJPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳD NLQL, SPT và HSDA
9 1JKLrQFӭXJL~SKLӇXU}KѫQYӅFiFK%,0ÿѭӧFGQJÿӇFҧLWKLӋQ+6'$WK{QJTXDYLӋFVӱGөQJFiF1/4/
Ĉẽ1**ẽ39ӄ7+Ӵ&7,ӈ1
1ӃXFiFQKj4/'$KLӇXU}ÿѭӧFQKӳQJYҩQÿӅQj\WKuYLӋFNLӇPVRiWKLӋXVXҩWFӫDFiF GӵiQ%,0WUӣQrQGӉGjQJKѫQQKҵPWUiQKÿѭӧFQKLӅXUӫLURYjÿҥWKLӋXTXҧ/ұS ELӇXÿӗSKkQWtFKÿiQKJLiPӝWFiFKWәQJTXDQWӯÿyJL~SQJѭӡL4/'$KLӇXU}KѫQ YҩQÿӅ*L~SFiFQKj4/'$KLӇXU}YӅPӕLTXDQKӋ1/4/637WiFÿӝQJQKѭWKӃQjR WӟL+6'$
&KѭѫQJ;iFÿӏQKFiF\ӃXWӕFKtQKFӫDQăQJOӵFTXҧQOê
&KѭѫQJ;iFÿӏQKPӕLWѭѫQJTXDQJLӳDFiF\ӃXWӕQăQJOӵFTXҧQOêVӵSKӭFWҥSYj
&KѭѫQJ ӃWOXұQYjNLӃQQJKӏ
Ĉӎ1+1*+Ƭ$
7KHR0XKDPPDG 6DMLG KDWWD1/4/EDR JӗP NKtDFҥQK NLӃQWKӭFQăQJ VXҩWYjQăQJOӵFFiQKkQ&iFORҥLGӵiQNKiFQKDXFҫQÿѭӧFTXҧQOêWKHRQKӳQJFiFK khác
7KHR0RQD16KDKWKu1/4/WKѭӡQJÿѭӧF P{WҧFөWKӇQKѭOjNLӃQWKӭFWKiL ÿӝNӻQăQJ1/4/OjQKӳQJÿһFÿLӇPKRһFNKҧQăQJFӫDPӝWFiQKkQ1KkQYLrQYj FiFWәFKӭFFҫQSKӕLKӧSJLӳDNKҧQăQJKӑFWұSNKҧQăQJTXҧQOêYjJLҧLTX\ӃWF{QJ YLӋF
9LӋFWKLӃWOұSFiFWLrXFKtSKKӧSOjUҩWTXDQWUӑQJÿӇOӵDFKӑQQJѭӡL4/'$WKjQK F{QJÿLӅXQj\SKҧLSKҧQiQKQKXFҫXFӫDGӵiQ
7KHR6HUJKHL)ORULFHO637OjFiFUӫLURNK{QJFKҳFFKҳQYjU}UjQJWURQJFiF GӵiQSKiWVLQKUDQKӳQJFKLSKtYjWiFÿӝQJÿӃQGӵiQQӃX QJѭӡLWKDPJLDNK{QJJLҧL TX\ӃWVӟPWӯJLDLÿRҥQOұSNӃKRҥFK
7KHR0XKDPPDG6DMLG.KDWWD637FӫDGӵiQOjPӝWWURQJQKӳQJOêGRNKLӃQ GӵiQWKҩWEҥL%ҩWFKҩSQKӳQJWLӃQEӝNӻWKXұWQKLӅXGӵiQÿmWKҩWEҥL1KӳQJSKӭF WҥSQj\ÿmNKLӃQQJѭӡL4/'$JһSQKLӅXNKyNKăQ
7KHR*XDQJGRQJ:XKLӋXVXҩWOjPӝWF{QJFөTXDQWUӑQJÿӇÿROѭӡQJWKjQK F{QJFӫDFiF'$;'1KuQFKXQJ+6'$FyWKӇÿѭӧFSKkQWKjQKORҥLKLӋXVXҩWWәQJ WKӇ FӫD '$;' FKL SKt FKҩW OѭӧQJ WLӃQ ÿӝô ÿD PөF WLrX FӫD '$;' NK{QJ Fy [XQJÿӝWTXҧQOờUӫLURTXҧQOờNKLӃXQҥLôYjVӵKjLOzQJFӫDWҩWFҧFiFErQWURQJ '$;'&Ĉ7WKLӃWNӃQKjWKҫXô
7KHR0XKDPPDG6DMLG.KDWWD+6'$FyWKӇFҧLWKLӋQEҵQJOұSNӃKRҥFKFKtQK [iFTXҧQOêYjOmQKÿҥRWK{QJTXDKӋWKӕQJWUX\ӅQWK{QJKLӋXTXҧ
2.2 1Ă1*/Ӵ&&Ӫ$1*ѬӠ,48Ҧ1/é'ӴÈ1 ĈӇ Fy WKӇ OmQK ÿҥR ÿLӅX KjQK PӝW '$;' ÿҫ\ SKӭF WҥS WKu PӝW QKj 4/'$ FҫQ Fy QKӳQJ QăQJ OӵF OLrQ TXDQ ÿӃQ FKX\rQ P{Q Nӻ QăQJ WKiL ÿӝô Oj ÿLӅX EҳW EXӝF &y QKLӅXQJKLrQFӭXÿROѭӡQJ1/4/WKHRQKLӅXKѭӟQJNKiFQKDX
7KHR 0XKDPPDG 6DMLG KDWWDN FiF \ӃX Wӕ OLrQ TXDQ 1/4/ JӗP Nӻ QăQJ TXҧQOêNKҧQăQJQKұQWKӭFKLӋXTXҧÿiQJWLQFұ\WUXQJWKӵFViQJWҥRÿӏQKKѭӟQJ YjRNӃWTXҧNӻQăQJJLDRWLӃSQKLӋWWuQKNӻQăQJOmQKÿҥR
7KHR3%6&KDPLNDUDYjFiFFӝQJVӵFiF\ӃXWӕ1/4/JӗPNӻQăQJTXҧQOêYjOmQKÿҥRNӻQăQJOұSNӃKRҥFKYjGӵiQÿҥRÿӭFNӻQăQJJLDRWLӃSÿҩXWKҫX
EiR FiR Yj NLӇP VRiW WjL FKtQK TXҧQ Oê KӧS ÿӗQJ SKkQ WtFK NLQK WӃ ÿҧP EҧR FKҩW OѭӧQJNӻQăQJWUiQK[XQJÿӝWTXҧQOờFKLSKtVLrQJQăQJTXҧQOờUӫLURô
7KHR$\RGHML(PPDQXHO2NHFiF\ӃXWӕ1/4/JӗPTXҧQOêGӳOLӋXTXҧQOê WjLFKtQKFKăPVyFNKiFKKjQJTXҧQOêUӫLURTXҧQOê%,0VLrQJQăQJNӻQăQJÿiQK giỏ dӵiQKLӇXELӃWYӅF{QJQJKӋ[k\GӵQJVӭFNKӓHNӻQăQJOjPYLӋFQKyPô
Theo Mei-,&KHQJFiF\ӃXWӕ1/4/JӗPViQJWҥRÿӏQKKѭӟQJWKjQKWtFKNӻ QăQJWuPNLӃPWK{QJWLQKӧSWiFFK~WUӑQJQKXFҫXFӫDNKiFKKjQJNӻQăQJOjPYLӋF QKyPWtQKOLQKKRҥWNӻQăQJOmQKÿҥRQKyPWѭGX\SKkQWtFK
7KHR1JX\ӉQ1Kѭ7UDQJQăQJOӵFFҫQFyNKLOjPYLӋFYӟL%,0ÿѭӧFVҳS[ӃS WKjQK QKyP QăQJ OӵF FӕW O}L QăQJ OӵF TXҧQ WUӏ Yj OmQK ÿҥR QăQJ OӵF FKӭF QăQJ 7URQJÿy
9 1KyPQăQJOӵFFӕWO}L[k\GӵQJOzQJWLQNӻQăQJOjPYLӋFQKyPWUuQKÿӝ WLӃQJDQKNӻQăQJJLDRWLӃS[ӱOêPkXWKXүQNӻQăQJWKX\ӃWSKөFWKtFKӭQJ WK~F ÿҭ\ Vӵ WKD\ ÿәL NK{QJ QJӯQJ KӑF KӓL Nӻ QăQJ WKѭѫQJ OѭӧQJ FKLD Vҿ NLӃQWKӭF
9 1KyPQăQJOӵFOmQKÿҥRYjTXҧQWUӏ[k\GӵQJTXDQKӋYӟLÿӕLWiF[k\GӵQJ ÿӝL QKyP WKjQK F{QJ SKiW WULӇQ QKkQ Vӵ TXҧQ Oê F{QJ YLӋF ÿӝQJ YLrQ Yj NKX\ӃQNKtFKô
9 1KyPQăQJOӵFFKӭFQăQJNLӃQWKӭFYӅ%,0NLQKQJKLӋPFKX\rQP{QNLQK QJKLӋPWKLF{QJNLQKQJKLӋPWKLӃWNӃNLQKQJKLӋP4/'$TXҧQOêYjFKLD VҿWK{QJWLQYӅ%,0[k\GӵQJYjWKӵFKLӋQNӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDL%,0ô
Theo BHDWD-DáRFKDFiF\ӃXWӕ1/4/JӗPNӻQăQJWѭѫQJWiFYjWҥRÿӝQJOӵF NӻQăQJOmQKÿҥRWLQFұ\WӵNLӇPVRiW NӻQăQJUDTX\ӃWÿӏQKFӣLPӣViQJWҥRNӻ QăQJÿjPSKiQÿӏQKKѭӟQJNӃWTXҧÿҥRÿӭFô
7yPOҥL1/4/FyWKӇÿDGҥQJQKѭQJFKXQJTX\OҥL WKu YүQÿѭӧFSKkQOjP QKyP chính sau:
9 1KyPOLrQTXDQÿӃQNӻQăQJNӻQăQJTXҧQOêGӳOLӋXNӻQăQJJLDRWLӃSNӻ QăQJOmQKÿҥRNӻQăQJOjPYLӋFQKyPNӻQăQJÿjPSKiQNӻQăQJJLҧLTX\ӃW YҩQÿӅô
9 1KyP OLrQ TXDQ ÿӃQ WKiL ÿӝ WUXQJ WKӵF VLrQJ QăQJ QKLӋW WuQK Fy WUiFK QKLӋPYӟLF{QJYLӋFô
9 1KyPOLrQTXDQÿӃQQăQJOӵFNLQKQJKLӋPEҧQWKkQWUuQKÿӝKӑFYҩQô 0һFG'$;'FKӭDÿӵQJQKLӅX\ӃXWӕSKӭFWҥSYjJLҧLSKiSFKRYҩQÿӅQj\FK~QJWD FKӍFҫQOӵDFKӑQYjÿjRWҥRQKӳQJQKj4/'$FyQăQJOӵFWұSWUXQJYjRQKӳQJQKyP
\ӃXWӕWUrQYuWӯQKӳQJQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟFFiF\ӃXWӕYӅQăQJOӵFFKӍWyPJӑQOҥLWKjQK QKӳQJQKyPWUrQ
4XDQWUӑQJQKҩWYүQOjQKyPNӻQăQJQJRjLÿjRWҥRNLӃQWKӭFWURQJWUѭӡQJFiFOӟSEӗLGѭӥQJQăQJOӵFUDWKuPӝWQKj4/'$FҫQWUDQJWKrPQKӳQJNӻQăQJQKѭNӻQăQJOjPYLӋFQKyPNӻQăQJWuPNLӃPWK{QJWLQNӻQăQJ[ӱOờYҩQÿӅô%ӣLYuQKӡQKӳQJNӻQăQJQj\QKj4/'$FyWKӇWKtFKQJKLYӟLF{QJYLӋFEuQKWƭQKYjJLҧLTX\ӃWYҩQÿӅ
9 ÿӝQJYLrQÿӗQJQJKLӋSKҥQFKӃQKӳQJUӫLURYj4/'$ÿLÿӃQWKjQKF{QJ
4XDQKӳQJSKkQWtFKYjQJKLrQFӭXWUrQFKRWKҩ\WҫPTXDQWUӑQJFӫDNӻQăQJFҫQFy FӫDPӝWQKj4/'$ĈӇKҥQFKӃQKӳQJSKӭFWҥSWURQJ'$;' YjFҧLWKLӋQKLӋXVXҩW FӫDGӵiQWKuQKӳQJQKj4/'$FҫQFK~WUӑQJYjRYLӋFWUDQJEӏQKӳQJNӻQăQJPӟL
'$;'Qҧ\VLQKQKLӅX637Jk\NKyNKăQFKRFiFQKj4/'$17;'FѫTXDQFKtQK SKӫô9uWKӃYLӋFÿROѭӡQJQKӳQJ\ӃXWӕSKӭFWҥSSKiWVLQKWURQJGӵiQOjUҩWFҫQWKLӃW
&yQKLӅXQJKLrQFӭXÿmÿROѭӡQJ637GӵiQWKHRQKLӅXKѭӟQJNKiFQKDX
TKHR1DHHP(MD]YjFiFFӝQJVӵFiF\ӃXWӕ637WURQJGӵiQJӗPÿLӅXNLӋQ WKӡLWLӃWҧQKKѭӣQJFӫDFKtQKWUӏNLQKQJKLӋPFӫDQJѭӡL4/'$QăQJOӵFQKjWKҫX WKLӃXODRÿӝQJFyNӻQăQJô
7KHR /DQ /XR FiF \ӃX Wӕ 637 WURQJ Gӵ iQ JӗP WK{QJ WLQ NK{QJ FKҳF FKҳQ PӭF ÿӝ [ӱ Oê WK{QJ WLQ NLQK QJKLӋP FӫD QKӳQJ QJѭӡL WKDP JLD WKLӃX NLӃQ WKӭF YӅ F{QJQJKӋUӫLURNKLVӱGөQJYӅF{QJQJKӋêWKӭFKӧSWiFҧQKKѭӣQJFӫDFiFErQOLrQ TXDQPөFWLrXNK{QJU}UjQJô
7KHR$EGRX6DHG0FiF\ӃXWӕ637WURQJGӵiQJӗPVӵU}UjQJFӫDGӵiQ F{QJQJKӋPӟLUӫLURNӻWKXұWWKLӃXQJXӗQOӵFYjNӻQăQJ\rXFҫXQJKLrPQJһW YӅ WLӃQ ÿӝ FӫD Gӵ iQ ÿLӅX NLӋQ WKӡL WLӃW FKҩW OѭӧQJ SKѭѫQJ SKiS Yj F{QJ Fө 4/'$ NK{QJFKҳFFKҳQô
Theo José R San Cristóbal (2018), các \ӃXWӕ637WURQJGӵiQJӗPF{QJQJKӋFiF ErQOLrQTXDQPөFWLrXSKkQF{QJODRÿӝQJTXiWUuQKWRjQFҫXKyDô
Theo Muhammad Sajid Khattak FiF \ӃX Wӕ 637 WURQJ Gӵ iQ JӗP WKLӃX NLQK QJKLӋPYӟLF{QJQJKӋӫ\TX\ӅQ\ӃXFӫDQJѭӡL4/'$PөFWLrXNK{QJU}UjQJWKLӃX KәWUӧFӫDFiFErQEҩWәQFKtQKWUӏFDQWKLӋSFKtQKWUӏYҩQÿӅYҩQÿDLô
1KuQFKXQJ637GӵiQNKiÿDGҥQJWX\QKLrQQKӳQJÿLӇPFKXQJPjFiFQJKLrQFӭX WUrQQrXUDÿyOjWKLӃXNLQKQJKLӋPYӅF{QJQJKӋUӫLURYӅNӻWKXұWVӵSKӕLKӧSJLӳD FiFErQOLrQTXDQӫ\TX\ӅQKӧSWiFôPөFWLrXNK{QJU}UjQJô
9uYұ\WDWKҩ\WҫPTXDQWUӑQJYӅYLӋF³FyNLQKQJKLӋPYӅF{QJQJKӋ´QKҩWOjQKӳQJ GӵiQFyVӱGөQJ%,0WKuYLӋFWuPKLӇXYjVӱGөQJ%,0PӝWFiFKWKjQKWKҥROjÿLӅX UҩWFҫQWKLӃW
9LӋFSKӕLKӧSJLӳDFiFErQOjUҩWTXDQWUӑQJĈLӅXQj\WK~Fÿҭ\GӵiQWKjQKF{QJYjtW JһSWUӣQJҥL1ӃXFiFErQOjPYLӋFPj NK{QJFy³WLӃQJQyLFKXQJ´WKu[ҧ\UDQKӳQJ [XQJÿӝWNKyNKăQYjFyWKӇҧQKKѭӣQJWLrXFӵFÿӃQGӵiQ
9LӋF ÿR OѭӡQJ +6'$ NKi Oj ÿD GҥQJ Yu W\ TXDQ ÿLӇP FӫD PӑL QJѭӡL &y WKӇ KLӇX +6'$ FNJQJ FKtQK Oj WKjQK F{QJ FӫD Gӵ iQ Yu +6'$ Oj FiF WLrX FKt ÿiQK JLi Gӵ iQ WKjQKF{QJ&yQKLӅXFiFKÿӇÿROѭӡQJKLӋXVXҩWFӫDGӵiQ
7KHRWUX\ӅQWKӕQJWLrXFKtFѫEҧQÿyOjFKLSKtWLӃQÿӝYjFKҩWOѭӧQJ7X\QKLrQ
YLӋFWyPJӑQOҥLWURQJWLrXFKtQj\NK{QJWKӇEDRTXiWWRjQEӝYuFiF'$;'QJj\ FjQJSKӭFWҥS
7KHR5RVKDQD7DNLPFiF\ӃXWӕ+6'$ÿѭӧFÿROѭӡQJWLӃQÿӝFKҩWOѭӧQJWjL FKtQKVӵDQWRjQQăQJVXҩWVӵKjLOzQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJô
7KHR+HH6XQJ&KDFiF\ӃXWӕ+6'$ÿѭӧFÿROѭӡQJKRjQWKjQKÿ~QJWLӃQÿӝ
DQ WRjQ P{L WUѭӡQJ FKL SKt FKҩW OѭӧQJ NLӇP VRiW UӫL UR Vӵ KjL OzQJ FӫD NKiFK KjQJô
7KHR6DL2Q&KHXQFiF\ӃXWӕ+6'$ÿѭӧFÿROѭӡQJKLӋXTXҧF{QJYLӋFWKӡL JLDQVӭFNKӓHYjDQWRjQFKLSKtFKҩWOѭӧQJVӵKjLOzQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJô
7KHR1JX\ӉQ%ҧR1JӑFFiF\ӃXWӕ+6'$ÿѭӧFÿROѭӡQJFKLSKtJLiWUӏYjOӧL QKXұQDQWRjQODRÿӝQJWLӃQÿӝP{LWUѭӡQJFKҩWOѭӧQJVӵKjLOzQJFӫDFiFErQWKDP JLDVӵKjLOzQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJô
'GӵiQFySKӭFWҥSÿӃQÿkXWKuFiFWLrXFKtÿiQKJLiYүQOjQKӳQJ\ӃXWӕWKHQFKӕW ÿyOjFKLSKtVӵKjLOzQJFӫDNKiFKKjQJWLӃQÿӝWKӡLJLDQP{LWUѭӡQJFKҩWOѭӧQJ DQWRjQ&yQKӳQJ\ӃXWӕNKiFҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQ+6'$QKѭQJTXDQWUӑQJQKҩWOj\ӃX WӕÿѭӧFOLӋWNrӣWUrQ
7KHR 0XKDPPDG 6DMLG KDWWD WKu 1/4/ FjQJ WăQJ WKu 637 FӫD Gӵ iQ FjQJ JLҧPWӭFOjPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFK~QJOjWӹOӋQJKӏFKYӟLQKDX1JKLrQFӭXQj\FKRWKҩ\ UҵQJ 637 FӫD Gӵ iQ Fy WKӇ NKҳF SKөF EҵQJ FiFK QkQJ FDR FKX\rQ P{Q FӫD QJѭӡL 4/'$KD\FzQJӑLOj1/4/
7URQJ'$;'QKj4/'$FyQăQJOӵFFDRWKuGӵiQVӁWKjQKF{QJFDR1Kj4/'$ QJRjLQKӳQJNӻQăQJ4/'$PjFzQSKҧLFyQKӳQJWKiLÿӝWtFKFӵFQKѭÿiQJWLQFұ\ QKLӋW WuQKViQJWҥRWUXQJWKӵFô0XKDPPDG6DMLG.KDWWD
7KHR1JX\ӉQ1Kѭ7UDQJQJKLrQFӭXQj\FKRWKҩ\ÿӇFyWKӇKLӇXU}YjVӱGөQJ
%,0PӝWFiFKWKjQKWKҥRWKuQJѭӡL4/'$FҫQFyQKӳQJQăQJOӵFFҫQWKLӃWYjSKKӧS QKѭQJRҥLQJӳWKiLÿӝNLQKQJKLӋPô1JѭӧFOҥLYLӋFVӱGөQJ%,0YjRGӵiQVӁWUӣ WKjQK637YjY{WuQKJk\NKyNKăQFKRQKӳQJQKj4/'$
1KӳQJYҩQÿӅOLrQTXDQÿӃQ'$;'FKtQKOj637FӫDQy9jÿӇJLҧLTX\ӃW637FӫDGӵ iQWKuÿzLKӓLVӵSKӕLKӧSJLӳDQKӳQJQJѭӡLFyQăQJOӵFNKiFQKDXQKҵm hoàn thành GӵiQ1JX\ӉQ1Kѭ7UDQJÈSGөQJ %,0 YjRGӵiQPӝWFiFKWKjQKF{QJWKu YLӋFWK{QJWKҥRWLӃQJ$QKUҩWTXDQWUӑQJYjFҫQWKLӃWYӟLQKӳQJQJѭӡLOjPYLӋFWURQJ GӵiQ%,09uWLӃQJDQKOjQJ{QQJӳSKәELӃQӣKҫXKӃWPӑLTXӕFJLDYjQKӳQJQJXӗQ WjLOLӋX%,0KLӋQQD\ÿӅXVӱGөQJWLӃQJ$QK1JX\ӉQ1Kѭ7UDQJ
9LӋFiSGөQJ%,0 NKL PӟLVѫNKDL YjÿDQJ FKX\ӇQWӯFiFKӋWKӕQJWӯFNJVDQJ PӟL
11 ĈLӅX Qj\ VӁ Jk\ UD NKy NKăQ Yu WKLӃX NLQK QJKLӋP YӅ F{QJ QJKӋ 'R ÿy FiF QKj 4/'$FҫQSKҧLKӑFKӓL FұSQKұWFKLDVҿNLӃQWKӭFWKtFKӭQJÿӇiSGөQJ%,0PӝW FiFKWKjQKF{QJYjRGӵiQ 'RÿyFK~QJWDFyWKӇWKҩ\PӕLTXDQKӋJLӳD1/4/Yj 637FӫDGӵiQ1JX\ӉQ1Kѭ7UDQJ
7ULӇQNKDL%,0WKjQKF{QJWKuFiFErQOLrQ TXDQEDR JӗPWKLӃW NӃWKLF{QJ4LDA FҫQFyNLӃQWKӭFYjNLQKQJKLӋPWURQJ[k\GӵQJWKuPӟLFyWKӇKLӇXYjYұQGөQJ%,0 PӝWFiFKKLӋXTXҧ1JX\ӉQ1Kѭ7UDQJ
7KHR QKѭ QJKLrQ FӭX FӫD &DR +jR 7KL FKR WKҩ\ FiF \ӃX Wӕ QKѭ P{L WUѭӡQJ FKtQK WUӏ P{L WUѭӡQJ NLQK WӃ P{L WUѭӡQJ SKiS OXұW P{L WUѭӡQJ F{QJ QJKӋô Fy WiF ÿӝQJÿӃQ+6'$9jÿӗQJWKӡLQJKLrQFӭXFNJQJÿmNӃWOXұQUҵQJP{LWUѭӡQJәQÿӏQK FjQJFDRWKuVӵWKjQKF{QJGӵiQFjQJFDR
CÁC 7,Ç8&+ËĈ2/ѬӠ1*+,ӊ868Ҩ7'ӴÈ1
VAI TRÒ CÔNG TÁC
%̫QJ 6: Vai trò công tác
Hình 4 6: Vai trò công tác
1JKLrQFӭXQj\WiFJLҧFKLDOjPQKyPFKtQKÿӕLYӟLYDLWUzF{QJWiF
9 Nhóm 1 là Nhóm CKӫÿҫXWѭ JӗPFy&KӫÿҫXWѭ&Ĉ7 và %4/GӵiQ (Ban QLDA)
9 1KyPOj1KyP7ѭYҩQ[k\GӵQJJӗPFyTVGS và TVTK
9 1KyPOj1KyP1KjWKҫX[k\GӵQJ JӗPFy1KjWKҫX chính và Nhà WKҫX SKө
1KұQ[pW 1KyPQKyP1KjWKҫXFKLӃPÿӃQWURQJNKҧRViWFKRWKҩ\
YLӋFGQJ%,0FKRGӵiQÿѭӧFFiFQKjWKҫXWULӇQNKDLUӝQJUmL+DLQKyPFzQOҥL OjQKyPQKyP&Ĉ7FKLӃPNKRҧQJYjQKyPQKyP7ѭYҩQFKLӃP NKRҧQJFKӭQJWӓYLӋFiSGөQJ%,0YjRGӵiQNK{QJTXiQKLӅXÿӕLYӟL QKyPQj\VӕOLӋXQJKLrQFӭXWKXWKұSÿѭӧFÿiQKJLiÿѭӧFNKiFKTXDQWuQKKuQK KLӋQWҥL0өFÿtFKWӯYLӋFFKLDOjPQKyPYDLWUzFKtQKWURQJGӵiQFyVӱGөQJ
%,0ÿӇÿiQKJLiYj[HP[pWPӕLWѭѫQJTXDQÿӗQJWKӡLVRViQKÿLӇPJLӕQJYj
NKiFQKDXWӯQKӳQJQKyPÿӕLWѭӧQJQj\NKLÿiQKJLiYӅ1/4/637Yj+6'$ FyVӱGөQJ%,0
%̫QJ 7 4X\P{OͣQQK̭WFͯDGiQ%,0ÿmWKDPJLDJ̯Qÿk\
Hình 4 7 4X\P{OͣQQK̭WFͯDGiQ%,0ÿmWKDPJLDJ̯Qÿk\
1KұQ [pW;pWYӅTXLP{QJXӗQYӕQWKuFyNKRҧQJGӵiQ%,0YӟLPӭF ÿҫXWѭWUrQWӹFKRWKҩ\QKӳQJGӵiQFyTXLP{OӟQKRһFUҩWOӟQ&zQQKӳQJ GӵiQFyTX\P{WUrQWӹWKuYLӋFiSGөQJ%,0WKuUҩWKӧSOtYjSKKӧS
1KұQ[pW9LӋFiSGөQJ%,0YjR'$;'WKuPӭFÿӝKjLOzQJYjUҩWKjLOzQJFӫD
&Ĉ7PjQKӳQJOӧLtFK%,0ÿHPOҥLWURQJGӵiQFKLӃPNKRҧQJFKRWKҩ\ UҵQJ%,0ÿmJySSKҫQÿiQJNӇWURQJ'$;'FyӭQJGөQJ%,0
%̫QJ 9 0ͱFÿ͡K͟WUͫFͯD&Ĉ7 WURQJGiQ
Hình 4 9 0ͱFÿ͡K͟WUͫFͯD&Ĉ7WURQJGiQ
1KұQ [pW 1KuQ FKXQJ WKu &Ĉ7 Kә WUӧ NKi WӕW WURQJ Gӵ iQ Fy Vӱ GөQJ %,0 ӣ PӭFÿӝ7UXQJEuQKFKLӃP NKRҧQJYj &DRFKLӃP NKRҧQJ&Ĉ7 NKiOjTXDQWkPWҥRÿLӅXNLӋQYjKәWUӧWURQJGӵiQ%,0
%̫QJ 10 0ͱFÿ͡K͟WUͫWͳK WK͙QJWK{QJWLQOLrQO̩FWURQJTXiWUuQKWKF
Hình 4 10 0ͱFÿ͡K͟WUͫWͳK WK͙QJWK{QJWLQOLrQO̩FWURQJTXiWUuQKWKF
1KұQ[pW1KuQFKXQJWKuPӭFÿӝKӛWUӧWӯKӋWKӕQJWK{QJWLQOLrQOҥFWURQJTXi WUuQK WKӵF KLӋQ Gӵ iQ NK{QJ ÿѭӧF FK~ WUӑQJ OҳP PӭF ÿӝ ËW FKLӃP NKRҧQJ Yj7UXQJEuQKFKLӃPNKRҧQJ
%̫QJ 11 0ͱFÿ͡WK˱ͥQJ[X\rQFͯDF{QJWiFW̵SKX̭QY͉%,0WURQJGiQ
Hình 4 11 0ͱFÿ͡WK˱ͥQJ[X\rQFͯDF{QJWiFW̵SKX̭QY͉%,0WURQJGiQ
1KұQ [pW1KuQFKXQJWKuPӭFÿӝWKѭӡQJ[X\rQFӫDF{QJWiFWұSKXҩQYӅ%,0 WURQJ Gӵ iQ NK{QJ ÿѭӧF FK~ WUӑQJ OҳP PӭF ÿӝ ËW FKLӃP NKRҧQJ Yj 7UXQJEuQKFKLӃPNKRҧQJ
%̫Q g 4 12 0ͱFÿ͡FKLDV̓WK{QJWLQYjNL͇QWKͱFY͉%,0JLͷDFiFErQWKDP
Hình 4 12 0ͱFÿ͡FKLDV̓WK{QJWLQYjNL͇QWKͱFY͉%,0JLͷDFiFErQWKDP
1KұQ[pW1KuQFKXQJWKuPӭFÿӝFKLDVҿWK{QJWLQYjNLӃQWKӭFYӅ%,0JLӳDFiF
ErQWKDP JLDWKӵFKLӋQGӵiQӣ PӭFÿӝWUXQJEuQK7UXQJEuQKFKLӃP NKRҧQJ Yj&DRFKLӃPNKRҧQJ
%̫QJ 13 0ͱFÿ͡FKLDV̓WK{QJWLQYjNL͇QWKͱFY͉%,0JLͷDFiFFiQKkQ
WURQJW͝FKͱFWKFKL QGiQ
Hình 4 13 0ͱFÿ͡FKLDV̓WK{QJWLQYjNL͇QWKͱFY͉%,0JLͷDFiFFiQKkQ
WURQJW͝FKͱFWKFKL QGiQ
1KұQ[pW1KuQFKXQJWKuPӭFÿӝFKLDVҿWK{QJWLQYjNLӃQWKӭFYӅ%,0JLӳDFiF
FiQKkQWURQJWәFKӭFWKӵFKLӋQGӵiQӣPӭFÿӝWUXQJEuQK7UXQJEuQKFKLӃP NKRҧQJYj&DRFKLӃPNKRҧQJ
1KұQ [pW&iFPүXTXDQViWKӧSOӋWKXYӅÿѭӧFÿmWUrQQăPNLQKQJKLӋPWUӣ OrQ7UrQQăPNLQKQJKLӋPFKLӃPSKҧQiQKÿӝWLQFұ\NKiFDRFӫDGӳ OLӋX
%̫QJ 15 7͝QJWKͥLJLDQWKFKL QFͯDGiQ
Hình 4 15 7͝QJWKͥLJLDQWKFKL QFͯDGiQ
1KұQ[pW7әQJWKӡLJLDQWKӵFKLӋQFӫDGӵiQWUrQWKiQJFKLӃPÿDVӕWӯ-12 WKiQJFKLӃP-WKiQJFKLӃPYj!WKiQJFKLӃP
%̫QJ 16 7͝QJWKͥLJLDQWKFKL QWKFW͇FͯDGiQ
Hình 4 16: 7͝QJWKͥLJLDQWKFKL QWKFW͇FͯDGiQ
1KұQ[pW7әQJWKӡLJLDQWKӵFKLӋQWKӵFWӃFӫDGӵiQWUrQWKiQJFKLӃPÿDVӕ Wӯ-WKiQJFKLӃPYj!WKiQJFKLӃP
X.1 Kӻ QăQJWә chӭc và sҳp xӃp công viӋc 0.415 0.753
X.2 Kӻ QăQJ SKӕi hӧp vӟi các bên liên quan 0.35 0.758
X.6 Kӻ QăQJOұp kӃ hoҥch triӇn khai dӵ án 0.369 0.756
X.11 Có nhiӅXQăPNLQKQJKLӋm quҧn lý 0.42 0.753
X.12 Ý thӭc trách nhiӋm trong công viӋc 0.331 0.759
X.14 1ăQJOӵc ngoҥi ngӳ (TiӃng Anh) 0.373 0.756
X.15 NҳPU}FiFSKѭѫQJSKiS P{KuQKKyD trong BIM 0.111 0.774
X.16 Kӻ QăQJ TXҧn lý, chia sҿ thông tin và dӳ liӋXOLrQTXDQÿӃn BIM 0.454 0.749
X.17 KiӃn thӭc vӅ các phҫn mӅm BIM 0.432 0.751
X.18 Am hiӇu các tiêu chuҭQ WKHR TX\ ÿӏnh cho dӵ án dùng BIM 0.178 0.769
X.19 Am hiӇu quy trình, pháp lý thӵc hiӋn dӵ án dùng BIM 0.248 0.764
+ӋVӕ&URQEDFKảV$OSKD!QKѭYұ\OjWKDQJÿRÿҥWWUrQPӭF\rXFҫX YӅÿӝWLQFұ\+RjQJ7UӑQJ&KX1JX\ӉQ0ӝQJ1JӑF 'ӳOLӋXÿDQJFy ÿҥWÿӝWLQFұ\FDRYjÿyQJJySWӕWWURQJYLӋFÿROѭӡQJFNJQJQKѭP{WҧNKiLQLӋP
Y.1 Nguӗn lӵc có chuyên môn sҹn có vӅ ӭng dөng BIM 0.345 0.644
Y.2 Tâm lý ngD ҕLWKD\ÿәi cӫa các bên 0.293 0.655
Y.3 'XQJ Oѭӧng thông tin khá lӟn, khó
Y.4 Chi phí khi triӇn khai, ӭng dөng BIM trong dӵ án 0.281 0.658
Y.5 Nhu cҫu ӭng dөng BIM trong dӵ án cӫa các bên 0.307 0.652
MӭF ÿӝ rõ ràng trong các tiêu chuҭn, quy chuҭQ Kѭӟng dүn ӭng dөng BIM cӫa dӵ án
Y.7 Tӕn thӡi gian cho viӋc tìm hiӇu và sӱ dөng BIM 0.299 0.655
.Ky NKăQ WURQJ YLӋc tә chӭc và phân chia trách nhiӋm quyӅn hҥn cӫa các bên tham gia dӵ án có ӭng dөng BIM
Y.9 Sӵ ÿӗng bӝ cӫa các bên tham gia dӵ án vӅ sӱ dөng BIM 0.502 0.61
+ӋVӕ&URQEDFKảV$OSKD!QKѭYұ\OjWKDQJÿRÿҥWWUrQPӭF\rXFҫX YӅÿӝWLQFұ\+RjQJ7UӑQJ&KX1JX\ӉQ0ӝQJ1JӑF 'ӳOLӋXÿDQJFy ÿҥWÿӝWLQFұ\FDRYjÿyQJJySWӕWWURQJYLӋFÿROѭӡQJFNJQJQKѭP{WҧNKiLQLӋP
Z.1 Sӵ dӉ dàng trong viӋc bҧo trì công trình 0.395 0.697
Z.2 Cung cҩp cái nhìn trӵc quan vӅ công trình 0.269 0.714
Z.3 Phát hiӋn sai sót và xӱ Oê[XQJÿӝt 0.34 0.705
Lұp dӵ toán chi phí cӫDF{QJWUuQKÿѭӧc thӵc hiӋn mӝt cách nhanh chóng và chính xác
Z.5 Sӵ dӉ dàng kiӇm soát tiӃQÿӝ 0.312 0.71
Z.7 Cung cҩSÿҫ\ÿӫ thông tin vӅ dӵ án 0.553 0.676
Z.8 Lұp kӃ hoҥch triӇn khai rõ ràng và minh bҥch 0.369 0.701
Z.9 7ăQJFѭӡng sӵ hӧp tác giӳa các bên 0.294 0.713
Z.10 Giҧm thӡi gian thӵc hiӋn cӫa dӵ án 0.473 0.684
Z.11 DӉ GjQJÿӗng bӝ thông tin mô hình khi chӍnh sӱa 0.357 0.703
+ӋVӕ&URQEDFKảV$OSKD!QKѭYұ\OjWKDQJÿRÿҥWWUrQPӭF\rXFҫX YӅÿӝWLQFұ\+RjQJ7UӑQJ&KX1JX\ӉQ 0ӝQJ1JӑF 'ӳOLӋXÿDQJFy ÿҥWÿӝWLQFұ\FDRYjÿyQJJySWӕWWURQJYLӋFÿROѭӡQJFNJQJQKѭP{WҧNKiLQLӋP 7iFJLҧPXӕQJLӳOҥLWRjQEӝFiF%46WUrQYu x Do NtFK WKѭӟF PүX Oj EҧQJ NKҧR ViW KӧS OӋ Yj FRQ Vӕ Qj\ NKi OӟQ FKtQKYuWKӃFQJPӭFêQJKƭD\rXFҫXWKuÿӝOӟQVӁJLҧP[XӕQJ x 9LӋFORҥLEӓQKӳQJ\ӃXWӕQj\VӁOjPPҩWÿLWK{QJWLQNKy P{WҧÿѭӧFKӃW YҩQÿӅWURQJQJKLrQFӭXÿһFELӋWOjQKӳQJEѭӟFSKkQWtFKTXDQWUӑQJVDX Qj\QKѭphân tích EFA, hӗLTX\ x 1ӃXNK{QJORҥLEӓQKӳQJELӃQQj\ÿLWKuEӃQEѭӟFSKkQWtFK()$FNJQJVӁ WӵÿӝQJORҥLFiFELӃQQj\ x 1ӃXEӓÿLWKuKӋVӕ&URQEDFKảVDOSKDLI,WHP'HOHWHGVӁNK{QJTXiFKrQK OӋFKQKLӅX VRYӟLKӋVӕ&URQEDFKảVDOSKD
6DXNKLSKkQFKLDWKjQKQKyPFKtQKWURQJGӵiQ%,09ӟLYLӋFSKkQWtFK777 GӵDWUrQQKyPÿӕLWѭӧQJWUrQÿӇWuPUDQKӳQJÿLӇPJLӕQJYjNKiFWURQJTXDQ ÿLӇPULrQJFӫDWӯQJQKyPYӅ1/4/637Yj+6'$[k\GӵQJFyVӱGөQJ%,0 9LӋFSKkQ WtFK777ÿѭӧFWLӃQKjQKQKѭVDX
9 3KkQWtFK777GӵDWUrQTXDQÿLӇPFӫDWҩWFҧFiFQKyPÿӕLWѭӧQJ
%̫QJ 23 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%461/4/GDWUrQTXDQÿL͋PFͯD
X.18 $P KLӇX FiF WLrX FKXҭQ WKHR TX\ ÿӏQK
X.15 1ҳP U} FiF SKѭѫQJ SKiS P{ KuQK KyD trong BIM 4.43 0.77 2
X.1 ӻQăQJWәFKӭFYjVҳS[ӃSF{QJYLӋF 4.21 0.925 3 X.3 ӻQăQJUDTX\ӃWÿӏQK 4.21 0.898 4
X.19 $PKLӇXTX\WUuQKSKiSOêWKӵFKLӋQGӵ án dùng BIM 4.17 0.935 5
X.4 ӻQăQJJLҧLTX\ӃWYҩQÿӅ 4.05 1.011 8 X.6 ӻQăQJOұSNӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDLGӵiQ 4.02 0.811 9 X.7 ӻQăQJÿiQKJLiGӵiQ 3.93 0.947 10 X.9 ӻQăQJGLӉQÿҥWWK{QJWLQ 3.88 0.993 11
X.2 ӻ QăQJ SKӕL KӧS YӟL FiF ErQ OLrQ quan 3.81 0.862 13
X.14 1ăQJOӵFQJRҥLQJӳ7LӃQJ$QK 3.38 0.909 19
1KұQ[pW 7KHRTXDQÿLӇPFӫDQKyP&Ĉ7WKuÿӕLYӟL1/4/WKuFҫQDPKLӇXYj
QҳPU}FiFWLrXFKXҭQSKiSOêTX\WUuQKWURQJGӵiQFyVӱGөQJ%,0YuKLӇXU} SKiSOêÿӇWULӇQNKDLGӵiQKLӋXTXҧÿҥWÿ~QJPөFWLrXPRQJPXӕQNLӇPVRiWWӕW ÿӝLQJNJWULӇQNKDL%,0
%̫QJ 4 24 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%461/4/GDWUrQTXDQÿL͋PFͯD
X.19 $PKLӇXTX\WUuQKSKiSOêWKӵFKLӋQGӵ án dùng BIM 4.37 0.831 1
X.15 1ҳP U} FiF SKѭѫQJ SKiS P{ KuQK KyD trong BIM 4.35 0.974 2
X.18 $P KLӇX FiF WLrX FKXҭQ WKHR TX\ ÿӏQK
X.3 ӻQăQJUDTX\ӃWÿӏQK 4.24 1.045 4 X.6 ӻQăQJOұSNӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDLGӵiQ 4.09 0.896 5 X.1 ӻQăQJWәFKӭFYjVҳS[ӃSF{QJYLӋF 4.04 1.045 6 X.8 ӻQăQJEiRFiRYjNLӇPVRiWWjLFKtQK 3.98 0.658 7
X.2 ӻ QăQJ SKӕL KӧS YӟL FiF ErQ OLrQ quan 3.94 0.94 8
OLӋXOLrQTXDQÿӃQ%,0 3.89 1.076 10 X.4 ӻQăQJJLҧLTX\ӃWYҩQÿӅ 3.85 1.071 11 X.5 ӻQăQJOjPYLӋFQKyP 3.76 0.95 12 X.9 ӻQăQJGLӉQÿҥWWK{QJWLQ 3.76 0.93 13
X.14 1ăQJOӵFQJRҥLQJӳ7LӃQJ$QK 3.74 0.873 15
1KұQ[pW ĈӕLYӟLQKyPWѭYҩQYӅTXDQÿLӇPFyQpWWѭѫQJÿӗQJYӟLQKyP&Ĉ7
QKӳQJ\ӃXWӕFҫQWKLӃW1/4/FӫDQKj4/'$FҫQFyOjKLӇXYjQҳPU}FiFWLrX FKXҭQSKiSOêTX\WUuQKWURQJGӵiQFyVӱGөQJ%,0%ӣLYuJLҧLWKtFKYjWѭYҩQ PөFWLrXPj%,0PDQJOҥLFKR&Ĉ7KLӇXU}YҩQÿӅYjNLӇPVRiWFNJQJQKѭWKHR G}LFiFKRҥWÿӝQJFӫDQKjWKҫXNKLWULӇQNKDLGӵiQ
%̫QJ 25 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%461/4/WKHRQKyP17;'
X.18 $P KLӇX FiF WLrX FKXҭQ WKHR TX\ ÿӏQK
X.19 $PKLӇXTX\WUuQKSKiSOêWKӵFKLӋQGӵ án dùng BIM 4.41 0.825 2
X.11 &yQKLӅXQăPNLQKQJKLӋPTXҧQOê 4.24 0.955 3 X.1 ӻQăQJWәFKӭFYjVҳS[ӃSF{QJYLӋF 4.23 0.92 4 X.3 ӻQăQJUDTX\ӃWÿӏQK 4.21 0.899 5
X.15 1ҳP U} FiF SKѭѫQJ SKiS P{ KuQK KyD trong BIM 4.14 0.889 6
X.2 ӻ QăQJ SKӕL KӧS YӟL FiF ErQ OLrQ quan 4.13 0.797 7
X.7 ӻQăQJÿiQKJLiGӵiQ 4.07 0.906 8 X.4 ӻQăQJJLҧLTX\ӃWYҩQÿӅ 4 0.851 9 X.6 ӻQăQJOұSNӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDLGӵán 3.97 0.916 10
X.14 1ăQJOӵFQJRҥLQJӳ7LӃQJ$QK 3.76 0.97 13
X.5 ӻQăQJOjPYLӋFQKyP 3.73 1.02 15 X.9 ӻQăQJGLӉQÿҥWWK{QJWLQ 3.71 0.919 16
1KұQ [pW ĈӕL YӟL QKyP QKj WKҫX FNJQJ Fy TXDQ ÿLӇP NKi WѭѫQJ ÿӗQJ YӟL QKyP WUrQ ĈӇ WULӇQ NKDL P{ KuQK %,0 ÿ~QJ YӟL NǤ YӑQJ FӫD &Ĉ7 Fy WKӇ Vӱ GөQJYjNKDLWKiFWӕWP{KuQK%,0WURQJVXӕWGӵiQ ĈiQKJLi QKyPÿӕLWѭӧQJWUrQKҫXQKѭÿӅXFyTXDQÿLӇPNKiJLӕQJYӅ QKӳQJ
\ӃXWӕOLrQTXDQÿӃQ1/4/FҫQWKLӃWPjQKj4/'$WURQJGӵiQ%,0WURQJÿyOj ³Kӻ QăQJUDTX\ӃWÿӏQK´³$PKLӇXFiFWLrXFKXҭQWKHRTX\ÿӏQKFKRGӵiQGQJ
%,0´³1ҳPU}FiFSKѭѫQJSKiSP{KuQKKyDWURQJ%,0´7LӃSWKHRSKkQWtFK
777 WҩW Fҧ FiF \ӃX Wӕ 1/4/ GӵD WUrQ WәQJ KӧS PүX TXDQ ViW WKX ÿѭӧF ÿӇ ÿiQKJLiWәQJTXDQ1/4/WURQJGӵiQ%,0
%̫QJ 26 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%461/4/
X.19 $P KLӇX TX\ WUuQK SKiS Oê WKӵF KLӋQ Gӵ án dùng BIM 4.34 0.857 2
X.15 1ҳP U} FiF SKѭѫQJ SKiS P{ KuQK KyD trong BIM 4.28 0.893 3
X.3 ӻQăQJUDTX\ӃWÿӏQK 4.22 0.943 4 X.1 ӻQăQJWәFKӭFYjVҳS[ӃSF{QJYLӋF 4.16 0.962 5 X.11 &yQKLӅXQăPNLQKQJKLӋPTXҧQOê 4.11 0.901 6 X.6 ӻQăQJOұSNӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDLGӵiQ 4.02 0.88 7 X.2 ӻQăQJSKӕLKӧSYӟLFiFErQOLrQTXDQ 3.99 0.867 8 X.4 ӻQăQJJLҧLTX\ӃWYҩQÿӅ 3.96 0.965 9 X.7 ӻQăQJÿiQKJLiGӵiQ 3.93 0.938 10 X.8 ӻQăQJEiRFiRYjNLӇPVRiWWjLFKtQK 3.89 0.904 11
X.9 ӻQăQJGLӉQÿҥWWK{QJWLQ 3.77 0.938 14 X.5 ӻQăQJOjPYLӋFQKyP 3.73 0.973 15
X.14 1ăQJOӵFQJRҥLQJӳ7LӃQJ$QK 3.66 0.932 17
1KұQ[pW 4XDSKkQWtFKWUrQGӵDWUrQTXDQÿLӇPFӫDFҧQKyPYjWәQJTXiWWKu
FyQpWWѭѫQJÿӗQJ YӟLQKDXFKӫ\ӃXTXD\TXDQKYӅDPKLӇX YjQҳPU}QKӳQJ WLrXFKXҭQTX\WUuQKSKiSOêWURQJGӵiQFyVӱGөQJ%,0
ӃW OXұQ 7әQJTXDQWKuFiF\ӃXWӕÿӅXFyWUӏVӕ0HDQWӯWUӣOrQÿӝOӋFK FKXҭQ 6WG 'HY a QJKƭD Oj NK{QJ Fy %46 QjR ҧQK KѭӣQJ tW KRһF NK{QJ ҧQK KѭӣQJ&iF\ӃXWӕWUrQSKKӧSYӟLWKӵFWӃ
%̫QJ 27 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%46637GDWUrQTXDQÿL͋PFͯD
Y.4 &KL SKt NKL WULӇQ NKDL ӭQJ GөQJ %,0
Y.5 1KX FҫX ӭQJ GөQJ %,0 WURQJ Gӵ iQ FӫD các bên 4.29 0.636 2
Y.7 7ӕQ WKӡL JLDQ FKR YLӋF WuP KLӇX Yj Vӱ
Y.2 Tâm lý ngD ҕLWKD\ÿәLFӫDFiFErQ 4.12 0.772 4
Y.1 1JXӗQOӵFFyFKX\rQP{QVҹQFyYӅӭQJ
Y.3 'XQJ OѭӧQJ WK{QJ WLQ NKi OӟQ NKy NKăQ
WURQJYLӋFFKLDVҿYjOѭXWUӳ 3.98 0.869 6 Y.6 0ӭFÿӝU}UjQJWURQJFiFWLrXFKXҭQTX\ 3.86 0.926 7
FKXҭQ KѭӟQJ GүQ ӭQJ GөQJ %,0 FӫD Gӵ án
WUiFKQKLӋPTX\ӅQKҥQFӫDFiFErQWKDP
1KұQ [pW ĈӕL YӟL TXDQ ÿLӇP FӫD QKyP &Ĉ7 WKu ÿӕL YӟL \ӃX Wӕ OLrQ TXDQ ÿӃQ 637FӫD'$;'FyVӱGөQJ%,0ÿyOjFKLSKtWULӇQNKDLWӕQWKӡLJLDQWuPKLӇX YjVӱGөQJQKXFҫXYjWkPOêQJҥLWKD\ÿәLOjQKӳQJYҩQÿӅÿDQJ[ҧ\UDWURQJ QKӳQJGӵiQ%,0PjKӑÿmYjÿDQJWKDm gia
%̫QJ 28 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%46637GDWUrQTXDQÿL͋PFͯD
Y.4 &KL SKt NKL WULӇQ NKDL ӭQJ GөQJ %,0
Y.7 7ӕQ WKӡL JLDQ FKR YLӋF WuP KLӇX Yj Vӱ
Y.5 1KX FҫX ӭQJ GөQJ %,0 WURQJ Gӵ iQ FӫD các bên 4 0.869 3
WUiFKQKLӋPTX\ӅQKҥQFӫDFiFErQWKDP
Y.1 1JXӗQOӵFFyFKX\rQP{QVҹQFyYӅӭQJ
Y.2 Tâm lý ngD ҕLWKD\ÿәLFӫDFiFErQ 3.87 0.848 7
FKXҭQ KѭӟQJ GүQ ӭQJ GөQJ %,0 FӫD Gӵ án
Y.3 Dung OѭӧQJ WK{QJ WLQ NKi OӟQ NKy NKăQ
55 1KұQ[pW ĈӕLYӟLQKyPWѭYҩQYӅTXDQÿLӇPFyQpWWѭѫQJÿӗQJYӟLQKyP&Ĉ7
QKӳQJ\ӃXWӕOLrQTXDQÿӃQ637FӫD'$;'FyVӱGөQJ%,0ÿyOjFKLSKtWULӇQ NKDLWӕQWKӡLJLDQWuPKLӇXYjVӱGөQJQKXFҫXYjWkPOêQJҥLWKD\ÿәL%ӣLYu KDRSKtFKLSKtYұQKjQK[k\GӵQJ YjGX\WUuÿӝLQJNJWӕQWLӅQFKRYLӋFFұSQKұW OѭXWUӳYjFKLDVҿWK{QJWLQYjGӳOLӋX
%̫QJ 29 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%46637WKHRQKyP17;'
Y.4 &KL SKt NKL WULӇQ NKDL ӭQJ GөQJ %,0
Y.7 7ӕQ WKӡL JLDQ FKR YLӋF WuP KLӇX Yj Vӱ
Y.5 1KX FҫX ӭQJ GөQJ %,0 WURQJ Gӵ iQ FӫD các bên 4.07 0.873 3
Y.2 Tâm lý ngD ҕLWKD\ÿәLFӫDFiFErQ 4 0.885 4
Y.1 1JXӗQOӵFFyFKX\rQP{QVҹQFyYӅӭQJ
Y.3 'XQJ OѭӧQJ WK{QJ WLQ NKi OӟQ NKy NKăQ
FKXҭQ KѭӟQJ GүQ ӭQJ GөQJ %,0 FӫD Gӵ án
WUiFKQKLӋPTX\ӅQKҥQFӫDFiFErQWKDP
1KұQ [pW ĈӕL YӟL QKyP QKj WKҫX FNJQJ Fy TXDQ ÿLӇP NKi WѭѫQJ ÿӗQJ YӟL QKyPWUrQ&KLSKtWULӇQNKDLWӕQWKӡLJLDQWuPKLӇXYjVӱGөQJQKXFҫXYjWkP OêQJҥLWKD\ÿәLFNJQJOjQKӳQJYҩQÿӅPjQKyPÿӕLWѭӧQJQKjWKҫXÿDQJJһSSKҧL NKLVӱGөQJ%,0 ĈiQKJLi3 nhóm ÿӕLWѭӧQJWUrQKҫXQKѭÿӅXFyTXDQÿLӇPNKiJLӕQJYӅQKӳQJ
\ӃXWӕOLrQTXDQÿӃQ637FӫD'$;'FyVӱGөQJ%,0WURQJÿyOj³&KLSKtNKLWULӇQNKDLӭQJGөQJ%,0WURQJGӵiQ´³7ӕQWKӡLJLDQFKRYLӋFWuPKLӇXYjVӱGөQJ%,0´³1KXFҫXӭQJGөQJ%,0WURQJGӵiQFӫDFiFErQ´7LӃSWKHRSKkQWtFK777WҩWFҧFiF\ӃXWӕ637GӵDWUrQWәQJKӧSPүXTXDQViWWKXÿѭӧFÿӇ
%̫QJ 30 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%46637
Y.4 &KL SKt NKL WULӇQ NKDL ӭQJ GөQJ %,0
Y.7 7ӕQ WKӡL JLDQ FKR YLӋF WuP KLӇX Yj Vӱ
Y.5 1KX FҫX ӭQJ GөQJ %,0 WURQJ Gӵ iQ FӫD các bên 4.1 0.821 3
Y.2 Tâm lý ngD ҕLWKD\ÿәLFӫDFiFErQ 3.99 0.846 4
Y.1 1JXӗQOӵFFyFKX\rQP{QVҹQFyYӅӭQJ
Y.3 'XQJ OѭӧQJ WK{QJ WLQ NKi OӟQ NKy NKăQ
FKXҭQ KѭӟQJ GүQ ӭQJ GөQJ %,0 FӫD Gӵ án
WUiFKQKLӋPTX\ӅQKҥQFӫDFiFErQWKDP
1KұQ[pW 4XDSKkQWtFKWUrQGӵDWUrQTXDQÿLӇPFӫDFҧQKyPYjWәQJTXiWWKu
FyQpWWѭѫQJÿӗQJYӟLQKDXFKӫ\ӃXTXD\TXDQKYӅ³&KLSKtNKLWULӇQNKDLӭQJ GөQJ %,0 WURQJ Gӵ iQ´ ³7ӕQ WKӡL JLDQ FKR YLӋF WuP KLӇX Yj Vӱ GөQJ %,0´ ³1KXFҫXӭQJGөQJ%,0WURQJGӵiQFӫDFiFErQ´
ӃW OXұQ7әQJTXDQWKuFiF\ӃXWӕÿӅXFyWUӏVӕ0HDQWӯWUӣOrQÿӝOӋFK FKXҭQ 6WG 'HY a QJKƭD Oj NK{QJ Fy %46 QjR ҧQK KѭӣQJ tW KRһF NK{QJ ҧQK KѭӣQJ&iF\ӃXWӕWUrQSKKӧSYӟLWKӵFWӃ
%̫QJ 31 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%46+6'$GDWUrQTXDQÿL͋PFͯD
/ұS Gӵ WRiQ FKL SKt FӫD F{QJ WUuQK ÿѭӧF
WKӵFKLӋQPӝWFiFKQKDQKFKyQJYjFKtQK xác
Z.2 &XQJ FҩS FiL QKuQ WUӵF TXDQ YӅ F{QJ trình 4.24 0.431 3
Z.8 /ұS NӃ KRҥFK WULӇQ NKDL U} UjQJ Yj PLQK
Z.5 6ӵGӉGjQJNLӇPVRiWWLӃQÿӝ 4.02 0.811 5 Z.1 6ӵGӉGjQJWURQJYLӋFEҧRtrì công trình 3.93 0.745 6 Z.7 &XQJFҩSÿҫ\ÿӫWK{QJWLQYӅGӵiQ 3.93 0.712 7
Z.10 *LҧPWKӡLJLDQWKӵFKLӋQFӫDGӵiQ 3.93 0.838 8
Z.11 'Ӊ GjQJ ÿӗQJ Eӝ WK{QJ WLQ P{ KuQK NKL
Z.9 7ăQJFѭӡQJVӵKӧSWiFJLӳDFiFErQ 3.71 0.944 11
1KұQ [pW 7KHR TXDQ ÿLӇP FӫD QKyP &Ĉ7 WKu ÿӕL YӟL \ӃX Wӕ OLrQ TXDQ ÿӃQ +6'$ÿyOjSKiWKLӋQVDLVyWYj[ӱOê[XQJÿӝWOұSGӵWRiQQKDQKFKyQJOұSNӃ KRҥFKWULӇQNKDLU}UjQJWUӵFTXDQKyDF{QJWUuQKĈk\FNJQJFKtQKOjQKӳQJJu PjQKyP&Ĉ7PRQJÿӧLWӯYLӋFiSGөQJ%,0YjRGӵiQ
%̫QJ 32 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%46+6'$GDWUrQTXDQÿL͋PFͯD
/ұS Gӵ WRiQ FKL SKt FӫD F{QJ WUuQK ÿѭӧF
WKӵFKLӋQPӝWFiFKQKDQKFKyQJYjFKtQK xác
Z.8 /ұS NӃ KRҥFK WULӇQ NKDL U} UjQJ Yj PLQK
Z.2 &XQJ FҩS FiL QKuQ WUӵF TXDQ YӅ F{QJ trình 4.06 0.712 4
Z.11 'Ӊ GjQJ ÿӗQJ Eӝthông tin mô hình khi
Z.6 %ӕWUtQJXӗQOӵFSKKӧS 3.93 0.821 7 Z.7 &XQJFҩSÿҫ\ÿӫWK{QJWLQYӅGӵiQ 3.93 0.723 8 Z.1 6ӵGӉGjQJWURQJYLӋFEҧRWUuF{QJWUuQK 3.91 0.734 9 Z.9 7ăQJFѭӡQJVӵKӧSWiFJLӳDFiFErQ 3.81 0.826 10
Z.10 *LҧPWKӡLJLDQWKӵFKLӋQFӫDGӵiQ 3.56 0.904 11
1KұQ[pW ĈӕLYӟLQKyPWѭYҩQYӅTXDQÿLӇPFyQpWWѭѫQJÿӗQJYӟLQKyP&Ĉ7
QKӳQJ\ӃXWӕOLrQTXDQÿӃQ+6'$ÿyOjSKiWKLӋQVDLVyWYj[ӱOê[XQJÿӝWOұS GӵWRiQQKDQKFKyQJOұSNӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDLU}UjQJWUӵFTXDQKyDF{QJWUuQK 1KӳQJ OӧL tFK Pj %,0 ÿHP OҥL VӁ JL~S NK{QJ FKӍ YӟL QKyP &Ĉ7 Pj FzQ YӟL QKyPWѭYҩQÿyOjJL~SFKRYLӋFGӵWRiQWUӣQrQQKDQKFKyQJWUiQKÿѭӧFQKӳQJ VDLVyWOұSNӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDLU}UjQJJL~SFiFErQFyWKӇQҳPU}ÿѭӧFWK{QJWLQ WӯF{QJWUuQKÿDQJ[k\GӵQJ
%̫QJ 33 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%46+6'$WKHRQKyP17;'
Z.8 /ұS NӃ KRҥFK WULӇQ NKDL U} UjQJ Yj PLQK
/ұS Gӵ WRiQ FKL SKt FӫD F{QJ WUuQK ÿѭӧF
WKӵFKLӋQPӝWFiFKQKDQKFKyQJYjFKtQK xác
Z.2 &XQJ FҩS FiL QKuQ WUӵF TXDQ YӅ F{QJ trình 4.2 0.651 4
Z.6 %ӕWUtQJXӗQOӵFSKKӧS 4.07 0.906 5 Z.7 &XQJFҩSÿҫ\ÿӫWK{QJWLQYӅGӵiQ 3.93 0.767 6 Z.5 6ӵGӉGjQJNLӇPVRiWWLӃQÿӝ 3.89 0.894 7 Z.1 6ӵGӉGjQJWURQJYLӋFEҧRWUuF{QJWUuQK 3.86 0.873 8
Z.11 'Ӊ GjQJ ÿӗQJ Eӝ WK{QJ WLQ P{ KuQK NKL
Z.9 7ăQJFѭӡQJVӵKӧSWiFJLӳDFiFErQ 3.71 0.903 10
Z.10 *LҧPWKӡLJLDQWKӵFKLӋQFӫDGӵiQ 3.64 0.869 11
1KұQ [pW ĈӕL YӟL QKyP QKj WKҫX FNJQJ Fy TXDQ ÿLӇP NKi WѭѫQJ ÿӗQJ YӟL QKyPWUrQ3KiWKLӋQVDLVyWYj[ӱOê[XQJÿӝWOұSGӵWRiQQKDQKFKyQJOұSNӃ KRҥFKWULӇQNKDLU}UjQJWUӵFTXDQKyDF{QJWUuQKFNJQJOjQKӳQJJuPjQKyPÿӕL WѭӧQJQKjWKҫXPRQJÿӧL ĈiQKJLi QKyPÿӕLWѭӧQJWUrQKҫXQKѭÿӅXFyTXDQÿLӇPNKiJLӕQJYӅQKӳQJ
\ӃXWӕOLrQTXDQÿӃQ+6'$Oj³3KiWKLӋQVDLVyWYj[ӱOê[XQJÿӝW´³/ұSGӵWRiQ FKLSKtFӫDF{QJWUuQKÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQPӝWFiFKQKDQKFKyQJYjFKtQK[iF´³/ұS NӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDLU}UjQJYjPLQKEҥFK´³&XQJFҩSFiLQKuQWUӵFTXDQYӅF{QJ WUuQK´7LӃSWKHRSKkQWtFK777WҩWFҧFiF\ӃXWӕ+6'$GӵDWUrQWәQJKӧS PүXTXDQViWWKXÿѭӧFÿӇÿiQKJLiWәQJTXDQ+6'$%,0
%̫QJ 34 %̫QJ[͇SK̩QJ777FͯDFiF%46+6'$
/ұS Gӵ WRiQ FKL SKt FӫD F{QJ WUuQK ÿѭӧF
WKӵFKLӋQPӝWFiFKQKDQKFKyQJYjFKtQK xác
Z.8 /ұS NӃ KRҥFK WULӇQ NKDL U} UjQJ Yj PLQK
Z.2 &XQJ FҩS FiL QKuQ WUӵF TXDQ YӅ F{QJ trình 4.16 0.626 4
Z.6 %ӕWUtQJXӗQOӵFSKKӧS 3.98 0.891 5 Z.5 6ӵGӉGjQJNLӇPVRiWWLӃQÿӝ 3.96 0.859 6 Z.7 &XQJFҩSÿҫ\ÿӫWK{QJWLQYӅGӵiQ 3.93 0.735 7 Z.1 6ӵGӉGjQJWURQJYLӋFEҧRWUuF{QJWUuQK 3.89 0.794 8
Z.11 'Ӊ GjQJ ÿӗQJ Eӝ WK{QJ WLQ P{ KuQK NKL
Z.9 7ăQJFѭӡQJVӵKӧSWiFJLӳDFiFErQ 3.75 0.885 10
Z.10 *LҧPWKӡLJLDQWKӵFKLӋQFӫDGӵiQ 3.69 0.88 11
60 1KұQ[pW 4XDSKkQWtFKWUrQGӵDWUrQTXDQÿLӇPFӫDFҧQKyPYjWәQJTXiWWKu
FyQpWWѭѫQJÿӗQJYӟLQKDXFKӫ\ӃXTXD\TXDQKYӅ³3KiWKLӋQVDLVyWYj[ӱOê [XQJÿӝW´³/ұSGӵWRiQFKLSKtFӫDF{QJWUuQKÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQPӝWFiFKQKDQK FKyQJYjFKtQK[iF´³/ұSNӃKRҥFKWULӇQNKDLU}UjQJYjPLQKEҥFK´³&XQJFҩS FiLQKuQWUӵFTXDQYӅF{QJWUuQK´