THE UNITED STATES AND REGIONAL COOPERATION IN SOUTHEAST ASIA, 1945 67

DEVELOPING MULTILATERALISM: THE UNITED STATES AND REGIONAL COOPERATION IN SOUTHEAST ASIA, 1945-67 HAN SIYING, CHERYL (B.A (Hons), NUS) A THESIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE 2012 DECLARATION I herebydeclarethat this thesisis my originalwork and it hasbeenwritten by me in its all the sourcesof informationwhich havebeenusedin entirety I haveduly acknowledged the thesis Thisthesishasalsonot beensubmittedfor any degreein any universitypreviously HanSiYing, Cheryl 24 August2012 But without faith, it is impossible to please Him, for he who comes to God must believe that He is, and that He is a rewarder of those who diligently seek Him Hebrews 11: ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The completion of this thesis marks the end of my MA course in NUS It has been a journey of faith with God and a season of living in His amazing grace I have been truly blessed by my school experience these past two years and give all thanks to my Father in heaven who has never failed to watch over and guide me My favourite psalm in the Bible describes the walk of faith in which one goes from strength to strength I am extremely grateful to the people who have enabled me to grow in this manner:  My supervisor, Dr Quek Ser Hwee, who once again rose to the challenge of overseeing me and believed that I could more than I thought Her patience and firmness kept me on track and her kindness provided the environment for my exploration of ideas and commission of errors during my time in NUS It has been a great and valuable time working with her!  My family who fully supported my decision to pursue a MA in NUS It was their presence I looked forward to whenever I had to drag myself home from school after intellectually stimulating but challenging courses My mum never failed to cook my favourite dishes nor stopped me from buying whatever food I wanted when I was discouraged My dad always allowed me to drive to school so that I could be as comfortable as possible My brother, Matthew, sacrificed his valuable study time to help me edit the map in Appendix A to satisfaction  My church friends who continually bore my complaints and grumblings while writing this thesis For two years, they heard me say, "I am writing my Masters thesis." Their support and prayers have encouraged me to persevere and they no longer need to hear this from me! At least for a while i  Mr Tim Yap Fuan of the NUS Central Library whose help was invaluable in the acquisition of primary and secondary sources Mr Tim's quick response to all my queries is much appreciated  Dr Michael Montesano from ISEAS who generously assisted me in navigating the collections in the ISEAS library  My MA friends, Wen-Ci, Ming Guang, Hui Lin, Celisa, Lee Min, Edgar, Brandon, Jermaine and all others who filled post-graduate life with so much fun and laughter  The faculty members and staff of the History Department who assisted me in so many ways and gave me many fond memories of my six years in NUS Han SiYing, Cheryl Singapore, August 2012 ii iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements i Summary v Introduction Chapter 1: American Foreign Policy and Post-Second World War Regionalism in Southeast Asia, 1945-54 14 Chapter 2: Trends and Problems: Emerging Southeast Asian Regionalism and US Multilateralism, 1955-58 35 Chapter 3: The Promises and Problems of Southeast Asian Regionalism, 1959-65 58 Chapter 4: Realizing Regionalism Dreams, 1965-67 82 Conclusion 109 Appendices 117 Bibliography 133 iv SUMMARY By 1967, a trinity of major regional institutions could be found in Southeast Asia—the Southeast Asia Treaty Organization (SEATO), the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) SEATO was a military organization founded by the US and interested allies, ASEAN a purely Southeast Asian initiative and the ADB was somewhere in between, being a US-supported institution but run by Asians Because of the scale of US developmental assistance to Southeast Asia and diplomatic energy in inducing regionalism, no study of American and Southeast Asian international relations is satisfactory without due consideration of the regional institutions spearheaded by both sides As much as the US- and Southeast Asia-initiated regional bodies occurred quite separately from each other, bilateral ties influenced the process Therefore, bilateralism and multilateralism were closely interrelated and could help or hinder each other More importantly, these regional mechanisms were the result of the intellectual currents of the day and thus stemmed from the same premise—that peace in Southeast Asia was best achieved by development and multilateral cooperation Hence, I argue that the creation of regional developmental institutions in 1967, the ADB and ASEAN, was the result of both long term US policymaking from 1945 as well as American and Southeast Asian responses to the immediate regional problems and instability When considering American involvement in Southeast Asia, the focus is almost always on the military aspect on the mainland in Cambodia, Laos and Vietnam and SEATO, suggesting a policy vacuum towards the peninsula area My research shows that US efforts in creating stability in the region were not limited to military means In fact, Washington also viewed Southeast Asia through the prism of multilateralism and modernization They v of their resources, making their economies more complementary, and promoting the orderly expansion of their foreign trade, in particular, intra-regional trade; (iv) to provide technical assistance for the preparation, financing and execution of development projects and programmes, including the formulation of specific project proposals; (v) to co-operate, in such a manner as the Bank may deem appropriate, within the terms of this Agreement, with the United Nations, its organs and subsidiary bodies including, in particular, the Economic Commission for Asia and the Far East, and with public international organizations and other international institutions, as well as national entities whether public or private, which are concerned with the investment of development funds in the region, and to interest such institutions and entities in new opportunities for investment and assistance; and (vi) to undertake such other activities and provide such other services as may advance its purpose ARTICLE FUNCTIONS Membership in the Bank shall be open to: (i) members and associate members of the United Nations Economic Commission for Asia and the Far East; and (ii) other regional countries and non-regional developed countries which are members of the United Nations or of any of its specialized agencies Countries eligible for membership under paragraph of this Article which not become members in accordance with Article 64 of this Agreement may be admitted, under such terms and conditions as the Bank may determine, to membership in the Bank upon the 127 affirmative vote of two-thirds of the total number of Governors, representing not less than three-fourths of the total voting power of the members In the case of associate members of the United Nations Economic Commission for Asia and the Far East which are not responsible for the conduct of their international relations, application for membership in the Bank shall be presented by the member of the Bank responsible for the international relations of the applicant and accompanied by an undertaking by such member that, until the applicant itself assumes such responsibility, the member shall be responsible for all obligations that may be incurred by the applicant by reason of admission to membership in the Bank and enjoyment of the benefits of such membership "Country" as used in this Agreement shall include a territory which is an associate member of the United Nations Economic Commission for Asia and the Far East 128 Appendix E: Bangkok Declaration, August 1967 268 The Presidium Minister for Political Affairs/ Minister for Foreign Affairs of Indonesia, the Deputy Prime Minister of Malaysia, the Secretary of Foreign Affairs of the Philippines, the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Singapore and the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Thailand: MINDFUL of the existence of mutual interests and common problems among countries of South-East Asia and convinced of the need to strengthen further the existing bonds of regional solidarity and cooperation; DESIRING to establish a firm foundation for common action to promote regional cooperation in South-East Asia in the spirit of equality and partnership and thereby contribute towards peace, progress and prosperity in the region; CONSCIOUS that in an increasingly interdependent world, the cherished ideals of peace, freedom, social justice and economic well-being are best attained by fostering good understanding, good neighbourliness and meaningful cooperation among the countries of the region already bound together by ties of history and culture; CONSIDERING that the countries of SouthEast (sic) Asia share a primary responsibility for strengthening the economic and social stability of the region and ensuring their peacefull (sic) and progressive national development, and that they are determined to ensure their stability and security from external interference in any form or manifestation in order to preserve their national identities in accordance with the ideals and aspirations of their peoples; AFFIRMING that all foreign bases are temporary and remain only with the expressed concurrence of the countries concerned and are not intended to be used directly or 268 Bangkok Declaration, August 1967, reproduced in Association of Southeast Asian Nations, "Bangkok Declaration (1967)," August 1967, , August 2012 129 indirectly to subvert the national independence and freedom of States in the area or prejudice the orderly processes of their national development; DO HEREBY DECLARE: FIRST, the establishment of an Association for Regional Cooperation among the countries of South-East Asia to be known as the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN) SECOND, that the aims and purposes of the Association shall be: To accelerate the economic growth, social progress and cultural development in the region through joint endeavours in the spirit of equality and partnership in order to strengthen the foundation for a prosperous and peaceful community of South-East Asian Nations; To promote regional peace and stability through abiding respect for justice and the rule of law in the relationship among countries of the region and adherence to the principles of the United Nations Charter; To promote active collaboration and mutual assistance on matters of common interest in the economic, social, cultural, technical, scientific and administrative fields; To provide assistance to each other in the form of training and research facilities in the educational, professional, technical and administrative spheres; To collaborate more effectively for the greater utilization of their agriculture and industries, the expansion of their trade, including the study of the problems of international commodity trade, the improvement of their transportation and communications facilities and the raising of the living standards of their peoples; To promote South-East Asian studies; 130 To maintain close and beneficial cooperation with existing international and regional organizations with similar aims and purposes, and explore all avenues for even closer cooperation among themselves THIRD, that to carry out these aims and purposes, the following machinery shall be established: (a) Annual Meeting of Foreign Ministers, which shall be by rotation and referred to as ASEAN Ministerial Meeting Special Meetings of Foreign Ministers may be convened as required (b) A Standing committee, under the chairmanship of the Foreign Minister of the host country or his representative and having as its members the accredited Ambassadors of the other member countries, to carry on the work of the Association in between Meetings of Foreign Ministers (c) Ad-Hoc Committees and Permanent Committees of specialists and officials on specific subjects (d) A National Secretariat in each member country to carry out the work of the Association on behalf of that country and to service the Annual or Special Meetings of Foreign Ministers, the Standing Committee and such other committees as may hereafter be established FOURTH, that the Association is open for participation to all States in the South-East Asian Region subscribing to the aforementioned aims, principles and purposes FIFTH, that the Association represents the collective will of the nations of South-East Asia to bind themselves together in friendship and cooperation and, through joint efforts and sacrifices, secure for their peoples and for posterity the blessings of peace, freedom and prosperity 131 DONE in Bangkok on the Eighth Day of August in the Year One Thousand Nine Hundred and Sixty-Seven 132 Bibliography Primary Sources Archival Sources (Including Databases and Online Material) Declassified Documents Reference System Digital National Security Archive Documents from the National Archives and Records Administration Foreign Relations of the United States 1945, Vol.6; 1949, Vol.7; 1952-54, Vol.12; 1955-57, Vol.21; 1958-60, Vol.15, Microfiche Supplement Vol.15/16; 1961-63; 1964-68, Vol.27 Newspapers The New York Times The Straits Times Internet Sources Asian Development Bank "About ADB: Overview." June 2012 Association of Southeast Asian Nations "Bangkok Declaration (1967)." August 1967 August 2012 133 “Joint Communique The First ASEAN-US Dialogue Manila, 8-10 September 1977.” July 2012 Dwight D Eisenhower, "Letter to Joseph M Dodge Designating Him as Special Assistant to the President and as Chairman, Council on Foreign Economic Policy," 11 December 1954 Gerhard Peters and John T Woolley, The American Presidency Project , August 2012 Dwight D Eisenhower, "Remarks at the First Meeting of the Commission on Foreign Economic Policy," 22 September 1953 Gerhard Peters and John T Woolley, The American Presidency Project , August 2012 Education Place "Asia and the South Pacific." August 2012 Farolan, Ramon J "ADB Headquarters: Manila, not Tokyo." Philippine Daily Inquirer 30 April 2012 August 2012 Lyndon B Johnson, "Address at Johns Hopkins University: "Peace Without Conquest."," April 1965 Gerhard Peters and John T Woolley, The American Presidency Project , June 2012 “President Eisenhower's News Conference, April 7, 1954, Public Papers of the Presidents, 1954, p.382.” Mount Holyoke College , November 2010 134 Singapore Parliament Reports “Yang Di-Pertuan Negara's Speech: Debate on the Address (Third Day).” August 2012 S Rajaratnam, "National Day Message from the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mr S Rajaratnam," August 1966 National Archives of Singapore , p.1, August 2012 “Statement of Policy by the National Security Council on United States Objectives and Courses of Action with Respect to Southeast Asia, NSC 124/2, 25 June 1952.” Mount Holyoke College, The Pentagon Papers , November 2010 The American Presidency Project "John F Kennedy: Inaugural Address." 20 January 1961 May 2012 Secondary Sources Journal Articles Brands, H.W “The Idea of the National Interest.” Diplomatic History 23, (1999): 239-261 Gordon, Bernard K "Economic Impediments to Regionalism in Southeast Asia." Asian Survey 3, (May 1963): 234-244 Jones, Matthew "A "Segregated" Asia?: Race, the Bandung Conference, and Pan-Asianist Fears in American Thought and Policy, 1954-1955." Diplomatic History 29, (November 2005): 841-868 135 Levi, Werner "The Future of Southeast Asia." Asian Survey 10, (April 1970): 348-357 Liow, Joseph Chinyong "Tunku Abdul Rahman and Malaya's Relations with Indonesia, 19571960." Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 36, (February 2005): 87-109 Logevall, Fredrik “A Critique of Containment.” Diplomatic History 28, (2004): 473-499 Ott, Marvin "The Search for Solidarity and Security." Asian Survey 8, (February 1968): 127-132 Ozaki, Robert S "Japan's Role in Asian Economic Development." Asian Survey 7, (April 1967): 237-244 Parker, Jason "Cold War II: The Eisenhower Administration, the Bandung Conference, and the Reperiodization of the Postwar Era." Diplomatic History 30, (November 2006): 867892 Parmer, J Norman "Malaysia: Changing a Little to Keep Pace." Asian Survey 7, (February 1967): 131-137 Pollard, Vincent K "ASA and ASEAN, 1961-1967: Southeast Asian Regionalism." Asian Survey 10, (March 1970): 244-255 Rahman, Abdul (Tunku) "Malaysia: Key Area in Southeast Asia." Foreign Affairs 43, (July 1965): 659-670 Schaller, Michael “Securing the Great Crescent: Occupied Japan and the Origins of Containment in Southeast Asia.” Journal of American History 69, (September 1982): 392414 Sodhy, Pamela "Malaysian-American Relations during Indonesia's Confrontation against Malaysia, 1963-66." Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 19, (March 1998): 111-136 136 van der Kroef, Justus M "Indonesia, Malaya, and the North Borneo Crisis." Asian Survey 3, (April 1963): 173-181 Wan, Ming "Japan and the Asian Development Bank." Pacific Affairs 68, (Winter, 199596): 509-528 Wilson, David A "Thailand: Old Leaders, New Directions." Asian Survey 3, (February 1963): 83-88 Theses Lodge, Peter M The United States Role in the Creation and Development of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations Thesis (PhD) University of Maine, The Graduate School, 2008 Books Acharya, Amitav Constructing a Security Community in Southeast Asia: ASEAN and the Problem of Regional Order New York: Routledge, 2009 The Quest for Identity: International Relations of Southeast Asia Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000 Acharya, Amitav and See Seng Tan Asia-Pacific Security Cooperation: National Interests and Regional Order New York: M.E Sharpe, 2004 Adas, Michael Dominance by Design: Technological Imperatives and America's Civilizing Mission Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press, 2006 Ahmad, Abdullah (Dato') Tengku Abdul Rahman and Malaysia's Foreign Policy 1963-1970 Kuala Lumpur: Berita Publishing Sdn Bhd., 1985 137 Black, Eugene R Alternative in Southeast Asia London: Pall Mall Press, 1969 Brands, H.W What America Owes the World: The Struggle for the Soul of Foreign Policy New York: Cambridge University Press, 1998 Borden, William S The Pacific Alliance: United States Foreign Economic Policy and Japanese Trade Recovery, 1945-1955 Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press, 1984 Buszynski, Leszek SEATO: The Failure of an Alliance Strategy Singapore: Singapore University Press, 1983 Costigliola, Frank France and the United States: The Cold Alliance since World War II New York: Twayne Publishers, 1992 Emmers, Ralf Non-Traditional Security in the Asian-Pacific Singapore: Eastern University Press, 2004 Emmers, Ralf and See Seng Tan The ASEAN Regional Forum and Preventive Diplomacy Singapore: S Rajaratnam School of International Studies, Nanyang Technological University, 2009 Engerman, David C., Nils Gilman, Mark E Haefele and Michael E Latham Editors Staging Growth: Modernization, Development, and the Global Cold War Boston: University of Massachusetts Press, 2003 Fenton, Damien To Cage the Red Dragon: SEATO and the Defence of Southeast Asia 19551965 Singapore: NUS Press, 2012 Fifield, Russell H Southeast Asian in United States Policy New York: Praeger, 1963 138 Frey, Marc, Ronald W Pruessen and Tan Tai Yong Editors The Transformation of Southeast Asia: International Perspectives on Decolonization Singapore: Singapore University Press, 2004 Gaddis, John Lewis Strategies of Containment: A Critical Appraisal of American National Security During the Cold War New York: Oxford University Press, 2005 Gilman, Nils Mandarins of the Future: Modernization Theory in Cold War America Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2003 Haas, Michael Editor Basic Documents of Asian Regional Organizations Vol.4 New York: Oceana Publications, Inc., 1974 Editor Basic Documents of Asian Regional Organizations Vol.6 New York: Oceana Publications, Inc., 1979 The Asian Way to Peace: A Story of Regional Cooperation New York: Praeger, 1989 Herring, George C America's Longest War: The United States and Vietnam, 1950-1975 New York: McGraw Hill, Inc., 1996 Hogan, Michael J and Thomas G Patterson Editors Explaining the History of American Foreign Relations New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004 Jackson, Karl D., Sukhumbhand Paribatra and J Soedjati Djiwandono Editors ASEAN in Regional and Global Context Berkeley: The Regents of the University of California, 1986 Jorgensen-Dahl, Arnfinn Regional Organization and Order in South-East Asia New York: St Martin’s Press, 1982 Leifer, Michael ASEAN and the Security of Southeast Asia New York: Routledge, 1989 139 Indonesia's Foreign Policy London: George Allen and Unwin (Publishers) Ltd, 1983 Latham, Michael E Modernization as Ideology: American Social Science and "Nation Building" in the Kennedy Era Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press, 2000 Mahapatra, Chintamani American Role in the Origin & Growth of ASEAN New Delhi: ABC Publishing House, 1990 Mackie, Jamie Bandung 1955: Non-Alignment and Afro-Asian Solidarity Singapore: Editions Didier Millet, 2005 McMahon, Robert J The Cold War: A Very Short Introduction New York: Oxford University Press, 2003 The Limits of Empire: The United States and Southeast Asia Since WWII New York: Columbia University Press, 1999 Milner, Anthony Region, Security and the Return of History Singapore: ISEAS, 2003 Osborne, Milton Southeast Asia: An Introductory History London: Allen and Unwin, 2010 Patterson, Thomas G and J Garry Clifford America Ascendant: U.S Foreign Relations Since 1939 Lexington: D C Heath and Company, 1995 Ryan, David US Foreign Policy in World History New York: Routledge, 2000 Remme, Tilman Britain and Regional Cooperation in South-East Asia, 1945-49 London: Routledge, 1995 Rotter, Andrew J The Path to Vietnam: Origins of the American Commitment to Southeast Asia Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1987 140 Severino, Rodolfo C Southeast Asian in Search of an ASEAN Community: Insights from the former ASEAN Secretary-General Singapore: ISEAS Publishing, 2006 Siddique, Sharon and Sree Kumar The 2nd ASEAN Reader Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 2003 Stueck, William Rethinking the Korean War: A New Diplomatic and Strategic History Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2002 Suryadinata, Leo Indonesia's Foreign Policy under Suharto: Aspiring to International Leadership Singapore: Times Academic Press, 1996 Tan, See Seng and Amitav Acharya Editors Bandung Revisited: The Legacy of the 1955 Asian-African Conference on International Order Singapore: NUS Press, 2008 Tarling, Nicholas Regionalism in Southeast Asia: To Foster the Political Will New York: Routledge, 2006 Southeast Asia and the Great Powers New York: Routledge, 2010 The Cambridge History of Southeast Asia, Volume 1, Part Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1992 Wolters, O W History, Culture, and Region in Southeast Asian Perspectives Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 1982 141 ... Malaysia, Indonesia, the Philippines and Singapore The mainland sub-region comprises the modern nation states of Laos, Myanmar, Thailand and Vietnam According to Milton Osborne, mainland and island Southeast. .. Americans, in deference to the British and the French, agreed not to include the Indochinese states in 51 Cited in Kai Dreisbach, "Between SEATO and ASEAN: The United States and the Regional Organization... was disbanded but the ADB and ASEAN remain to this day and stand partly as testimony to US efforts to influence and retain a role in Southeast Asian affairs The US has been involved in Southeast