GRIGGS UNIVERSITY GLOBAL ADVANCED MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION PROGRAM
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT
BUILDING THE STRATEGY TO DEVELOP INTERNATIONAL PAYMENT SERVICES IN VIETNAM JOINT STOCK COMMERCIAL BANK FOR
INDUSTRY AND TRADE
Group Number: 09
Class: GaMBA01.X0310
Student’s name: Mai Khac Chinh
Trang 2C3 _ VietinBanlc=> >
CONFIRMATION OF
VIETNAM JOINT STOCK COMMERCIAL BANK FOR INDUSTRY AND TRADE
HUNG YEN BRANCH
We Vietnam Joint Stock Commercial Bank For Industry And Trade - Hungyen Branch confirm that we agree the research group including the members
mentioned below to be allowed to get access to the internal documents, data as
Well as contact with the operation fact to study about the strategic orientations of Vietnam Joint Stock Commercial Bank For Industry And Trade serving the research purpose of the group to complete the MBA course:
1 Mai Khac Chinh 2 Tieu Thanh Long 3 Pham Kieu Van
4 Dinh Thai Lam
Hungyen, November 30" 2011
DEPUTY DIRECTOR
Trang 3NTRODUCTION 1 The necessity of topic
In the trend of strongly internationalizing international economy, Vietnam’s economy is step by step integrating the regional and international economy On
January 11" 2007, Vietnam officially became the 150" member of World Trade
Organization (WTO) This was an important event which opened the opportunities as well as the challenges to Vietnam’ economy so that it integrates in the international economy deeply and widely, continuously promoting the industrialization and modernization of country
The development of foreign trade and international investment require the non- stopping development of payment, currency relation and international banking services The commercial banks play role as the bridge connecting the above economic relation Export-import payment is one of the important professions of commercial banks The good operation of export-import payment activity of commercial banks contributes to the promotion of business of Vietnam’ enterprises, in particular, and Vietnam’s foreign trade, in general The export-import payment brings the great benefits to the commercial banks External the service fees, commercial banks also develop other professions such as foreign currency profession, export-import financing profession, and_ international guarantee
profession, etc
Besides, since April 1°' 2007, to implement the process under the commitment when Vietnam joined WTO, the foreign banks are able to establish the sub-bank with 100% foreign capital in Vietnam This brought the Vietnam’s commercial
banks in general and state commercial banks in particular in great threats and challenges of competitiveness in Vietnam The competitive pressure for State commercial banks is not only from the foreign banks, but also from the joint stock commercial banks Therefore, although the market share of state banks still ———Eễễ_—ễ
Trang 4dominates the market, the decrease of market share in this bank block is considered
as a dispensable movement
Facing to this pressure, in order to survive, develop in competitiveness and do well the role of economy’s bridge, Vietnam Joint Stock Commercial Bank for Industry and Trade (Vietinbank), one of the big commercial banks, considered the export-import payment activity as one of the important tasks in upcoming years To survive and develop, Vietinbank need to build a strategy The building of suitable strategy has extremely important meaning; the timely strategy direction and adjustment is the foundation for great benefits of enterprise
Understanding the importance of building the business strategy of enterprise as well as the development of Vietinbank in the integration, our group did research and chose the topic: “Building the strategy to develop international payment services in Vietnam Joint Stock Commercial Bank for Industry and Trade” to be research target and hope to choose a right direction for Vietinbank in the future
International payment services can be considered as a strategic business unit (SBU) of VietinBank because of the following reasons:
- VietinBank just established an International Payment Transaction Office for international payment services which is located in Cua Nam Street, Hanoi This Office is independent and fully functional as both cost and profit center of VietinBank
| - VietinBank_has fully delegates authority and responsibility The International Payment Transaction Office to a senior executive who reports directly to the
| General Director of VietinBank
2 Purposes of research
- Systematize the theories and methodology about business strategy of
enterprise
- Build the business strategy for international payment services - Define target and propose solutions to develop that SBU 3 Scale of research
- The theories about business strategies of enterprise
RR EERE RE NEESER — a See]
Trang 5- Building the international payment service product business development in Vietinbank and solutions, detailed methods to implement the business strategy
4 Method of research
Group does research based on the knowledge to evaluate all the results of international payment service product business of Vietinbank Otherwise, we also use methods of statistic, analysis, predictability and collection based on the collected data to analyze the service business of bank and propose the business strategies for Vietinbank in integration condition
5 Structure of report
External the introduction, conclusion and reference, main content of the report
includes 3 chapters:
- Chapter |: Several basic theories on business strategies
- Chapter 2: Real situation about activities of doing business the international payment service products in Vietinbank
- Chapter 3: Targets and solutions to develop the international payment service products business in Vietinbank
aera renames omer ne a TERA SEL min nesses we:
Trang 6CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION OF BUSINESS STRATEGY AND INTERNATIONAL PAYMENT SERVICE
1.1 General introduction about business strategy 1.1.1 Definition of business strategy
Business strategy is researched by a lot of economist and they have bought out many definitions of the term “business strategy” like:
Business strategy is the art:
- Alain Threlart assumes that “The strategy is the art that enterprise uses against competition and wins”
- M.Porter thinks that “The strategy is the art setting up steady competitive advantages to defend”
- Hence, those authors believed that business strategy is a type of art to compete in market and develop enterprise
According to concept in management aspect, business strategy is a type of plan - G.Arlleret thinks that “Strategy is defining ways and means to reach established targets through policies”
- D.Bizrell and the author team assert that “Strategy is likely a general plan directing and orienting enterprise towards expected goals It is the basis to form policies and operating methods”
- Gluecl assumes that: “Strategy is a consistent, comprehensive, and genera kind of plan which is designed to ensure performance of enterprise’s goals
According to concept of combining unity:
- “Business strategy is the art of combining and controlling activities to get long-term goals of enterprise”
- Chandler considers strategy consists of defining long-term basic goals of company; selecting measures or action process; distributing essential forces and carrying out those targets
SA RTE PT EE OE ET TTT TE SEDO ET EE,
Trang 7In business, “Business strategy is the art of designing, organizing means to reach long-term goals of company and it connects with changes of business and competitive environment”
1.1.2 Attributes of business strategies
- Business strategy identifies basic goals and management direction of enterprises in each period
- Business strategy is oriented in order to ensure the continuous and constant development for firms in highly fluctuated financial environment
- Business strategy is the guarantee for the maximum mobilization and optimal combination of exploitation and utilization of firm’s resources in current and future Therefore, it can encourage competitive advantages in long run
- Business strategy of firms is reflected during the continuous process from the building plan step to implementation step and supervision step
- Business strategy is often the offensive strategy It is established and built up on the basis of detecting and taking advantages of business opportunities, competitive advantages of firms to gain the highest operation efficiency
- Business strategy is built up through a long period of time (3.5 to 10 years) Therefore, business strategy has characteristics of long term tactic and is specified
in short term strategies, which are also called plans
1.1.3 Role of business strategy
According to modern business strategy, it is incapable to hedge changes of market without specific and flexible business strategy, which is really offensive Only by this way, firms can detect worthy opportunities or risks in order to give out
suitable policies Lack of business strategy, firms is unable to run its business
effectively, even lead to bankruptcy Therefore, business strategy has really important role in the operation and development of a business:
- Business strategy helps business determine clearly its purpose, direction as
a basis for its all business activities
RE EER i PRT PR SON IND ES 7 EE ETE
Trang 8
- Business strategy helps business reach financial chances and, simultaneously, have active measures to overcome risks and threats from competitive market
- Business strategy contributes to the increase of the efficiency of using resources, consolidates competitive position of firm, ensures for its constant development in the future
- Business strategy creates solid base for giving policies and determining suitable business activities to market fluctuations
1.2 Process of building business strategy 1.2.1 Analysis of business environment
Analysis of business environment of firms is the process of considering different environmental factors and determining influential level of opportunities and threats to firm The expectation is based on reliable analysis and assessment basis in order to take advantages of opportunities or to be active with financial and
business risks to firm
Rotate ee elle
_ Changes of GDP UTE NG pi meer ' _ distribution | Population, NI
TU ỐC Cultural and education
Jdhecyclesofeconomy Customs and traditions
echnological Ola
dai 00) 7 ỗ ' Technology transfr
Source: Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases (12th Edition) Fred R David Figure Error! No text of specified style in document 1: P.E.S.T Model
RE Am RE
Trang 91.2.1.1 Macro environment
Economic environment:
Macro environment is a really important factor which can not be ignored by strategy planners It changes create different opportunities as well as threats to each firm in different fields Environmental positions of macro environment are the main decisive factor and become the power of the whole economy:
- Growth rate of economy indicates the economic variation by the time Marx says that economic circle includes 4 steps: Crisis - Recovery — Depression and Flourishing When the economy is in the depression or crisis, income of residents decreases, consumption decreases and production is loss This is a difficult period to firms Vice versa, in the economic upward, enterprises have many opportunities to expand their scale and develop
- Interest rate: is one of monetary factors and is the typical factor which every firm makes concern Both high or low interest rate affect directly to business and market demand because it is the contributing factor of firm’s cost Interest rate fluctuation is influenced dramatically by the monetary policy of the Government
- Exchange rate: always has direct effect on activities of enterprises with foreign elements such as import — export enterprise, enterprises using direct or indirect foreign input or output The change of exchange rate directly affects the company competition in the international market
- Inflation: is always threat to business activities One of bad effects inflation
to the whole economy is that it can decrease the stability of the economy and reduce
economic growth In long run, inflation reduces investment efficiency of firms and
brings hidden risks, thus, businesses develop slowly, growth rate of economy is negatively affected
Politic and legislation environment:
Politic and legislation factors affect developing strategy of enterprises in different directions They may be opportunities to this firm but in contrast, be disadvantage to other firms Stable politic brings good condition for developing
ESET ED A AT —
GaMBA01.X0310 - Group 9 Page 8
Trang 10economy, vice versa, unstable politic will have negative influences on economy Besides, running in an economy which are adjusted by strict law system, enterprises may face both advantages and disadvantages because a clear and full law system will create healthy competitive environment and be a foundation for an attractive environment in the future One of the typical trends in recent years is the redirection to deregulation The eradication of exhibitions and regulations makes the import barrier become lessen and creates an intensive competition in some fields of industry In addition, the policy of encouraging various economic elements to include actively in business activities is the risk for state owned firms but the great opportunity for private enterprises because they can participate in the market more conveniently and easily
Technical environment:
Technical progressions have influence on many aspects of the whole society These impacts are through products, technical process and new materials Directions and fluctuations in technology may be chance for enterprises which are able to mobilize capital quickly and effectively, but vice versa, it is threat for firms fixed with old technologies and slow to adjust One of the most important effects of changing technology is on barriers of import and export and the restructuring thoroughly sector’s structure as well as on the creation of new jobs
According to M Porter, technological change is not important to
technological benefit itself, but it is important if it impacts on competitive
advantages and sector’s structure On the other hand, the development of technology will shorten product circle, thus, firms should pay attention to the trend of technological innovation Every firm has relation with many different and related kinds of technology Its business activities also have that various relation Therefore, an technology is very important to competition if it impacts on firm’s competitive advantages or on structure of financial sectors
Cultural and social environment:
SR ASE ESE AR RE LET SEL TE EET IO DN TOO EET SMU ES TNE MOE EE EE OT TE OT LEO TET MT IO
Trang 11Cultural values and social attitude build up the foundation of society, thus, it yften results in changes in conditions of technology, politic — legislation, economy and human Cultural and social environment may affect on strategic decisions such as: selecting fields and item of goods, selecting brand name, color, form distribution channels Social change in concept of life meaning and consumption meaning also orings opportunity as well as threats to firms
Natural environment:
In comparison with economic, politic, cultural, social, technological factors,
effect of natural factor is very difficult to expect The fluctuation of natural factors such as climate change, flood or disasters is always hidden risks to enterprises, especially those which have direct relation to natural environment like agricultural enterprises
International environment (globalization):
In the condition of strong globalization happening all over the world recently, the internationalization is not an option but an inevitability Issues of globalization affect dramatically on operating and business activities of enterprises in every aspects such as output market, input sources, finance, human resource Globalization brings many great benefits for enterprises, however, it also consists some complex issues due to graphical scale and differences of cultures, societies and politics
1.2.1.2 Business sector environment
Business sector environment includes all factors which directly influence decision making of firms in one sector A business sector consists many firms which have supplement or substitute products or services, so the concern is how firms analyze and expect competitors in its business sector in order to identify opportunities as well as risks The following is a popular model of Michael Porter with 5 competitive forces Five main factors affect to company’s operation as: potential rivals, suppliers, customers, current rivals and substitute products The below table will indicate the affection of these factors to company
ee NTR TST TI TE PE SAE tO Ea ATR AE ST TOT
Trang 12nối
Source: Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases (12th Edition) Fred R David
Figure 1.2: Michael Porter’s five forces model Right of customers:
Customers are consumers of firm’s products, services Customers can put pressure on firms by requests of discount or requirement of higher quality products, better services Therefore, these requirements of customers may be factors to reduce profits of enterprises in the sector However, the high or low ability to pressure of customers depends on the correlation between business forces and their customers The relationship between them may become threats or chances for enterprises in the sectors of economy
Customer pressure depends on the following factors:
Concentration of customers: in a field, the higher the quantity of customers is, the more competition they deal with
Ratio of purchasing activities: measured by the ratio of amount of money for shopping and total expenditures of customers The higher this ratio is, the higher pressure customers put on firms
The difference of products and transfer cost of this supplier to other, paid by customers The higher the shipping cost, the lower the pressure customers have on firms
Level of information about products and customer services
Sn
NE NE IRE IRS LPR TENE STEELS CLE TET CENT TCT ESE I EE IEEE TEE
Trang 13Threat of merge: have bad effect on price and profits of enterprise These enterprises must take actions to prevent customers from merging
Authority of suppliers:
Suppliers are able to pressure on firms through price of input, quality or payment methods In specific, suppliers can create threats to firms when they increase selling price of goods or decrease input quality Vice versa, with supportive suppliers, firms may have opportunity of price deduction or higher quality of goods
Authority of suppliers depends on:
- Quantity of suppliers: If suppliers are concentrated while firms in sector are diverse, the pressure of suppliers on firms is very high That is the reason why firms never depend on one supplier only
- Number of substitutes for products, services of suppliers: The more substitute of goods and services, the lower the pressure of suppliers is
- Costs of changing suppliers: If this cost is high, the pressure of suppliers on firms is high, obviously
- Ability of integration: the higher this ability is, the lower the pressure of suppliers on firms
Analysis of competitors within business sector
Companies within a business sector or in the same field of business are considered as competitors or rivals Each field has specific competition problems
The competition becomes more severe in the international scale, within all fields
Therefore, organizations should have relevant information of their competitors
Trang 14- The industry is slowly developing or going down - Fixed cost or storage is high
- It is difficult to make change or transferring cost is low - Strategic interest is high
- There are many obstacles when a company wants to leave industry Analyzing potential new rivals
Potential competitors are those who now do not appear in industry but possibly join in industry The more new companies are, the more difficult the old face up in getting market share and gain profit Therefore, the higher threat from new potential entries is, the bigger impact on interest of firms is, and vice verse As a result, information about potential rivals is so significant for enterprise to plan
Strategy
The threats from potential competitors depend on:
- The customers’ loyalty towards brand name of products of the firm in industry - Cost advantage of the firms in industry since they have experience in the familiar sector - Advantage of scale - The capacity of approaching distribution channel is one of barriers joining in industry
- Technology secret is always efficient obstacle so that the enterprises in industry use to prevent other ones from taking part in
- The policies of the State: This is the barrier against potential rivals through investment imitating policy in some industries or lobby of the enterprises in industry
- Approaching material sources
The bigger factors of barriers against industry joining are, the more difficulty they cause to the goal of potential competitors in joining industry
Trang 15The substitute products
They are the goods which like products of the firms in industry can meet the needs of customers The more similar the substitutions are to products of enterprises in industry, the greater threats are to the enterprises This probably restricts price, sales and impacts on profit of enterprise If there are few substitutions, enterprise will have chance to increase price and get more earnings Thus, enterprises should aim to take advantage of this aspect
Competitive environment:
In order to from a long-term orientation or strategic decision, the managers have to comprehend clearly strategic status, nature of company, competitive conditions it has to cope with, measures to matching forces and capacity for those conditions
So as to assess competitive climate of an industry, it must clarify the key issues on:
- The outstanding economic features of industry;
- The competitive forces in industry, character, strength of each;
- The motivations causing changes in industry and their impacts;
- The companies in the strongest and weakest positions in industry, who possibly creates next moving in industry;
- The primary factors for successful competition, industry attractiveness in term of profitability over average
1.3 Setting up matrixes to select business strategy 1.3.1 Externai factor evaluation matrix (EFE)
EFE matrix evaluates external factors, synthesizes and summarizes main
opportunities of external environment which impact on operation of enterprise Then corporate managers can assist reaction level of enterprise to chances, threats and give arguments whether external factors are advantages or difficulties for enterprise The steps to set up this matrix are:
| ene aS IR RN NC trơn! aS ANN TAS
Trang 16- Step 1: Make a list of factors as key opportunities and threats which are considered as great impacts on success of enterprises in business sector/industry
- Step 2: Assign weight to each factor, depending on influencing level on industry
- Step 3: Assign a rating to each factor up to reacting level of enterprises to the factors
- Step 4: Multiply weight of each factor by its rating to define the weight score of each factor
- Step 5: Evaluate effecting level of factors
13.2 Internal factor evaluation matrix (IFE)
Internal factors are appropriated as such importance in business strategy and targets which enterprise establishes After judging internal factors, the strategic managers ought to build up matrix from these factors aiming to assess ability of reaction and argument on strengths and weaknesses As a result, enterprise can explore maximum strengths and prepare to face up weaknesses and look for method to improve the weaknesses There are five steps to set up IEF matrix:
- Step 1: Make a list of factors as basic strengths and weaknesses impacting on companies or their targets established
- Step 2: Assign weight to each factor, depending on influencing level on industry
- Step 3: Assign a rating to each factor up to reacting level of enterprises to the factors
- Step 4: Multiply weight of each factor by its rating to define the weight score of each factor
- Step 5: Evaluate effecting level of factors
The IFE and EFE are most clear pictures to show out company’s business
environment, company’s internal and external factors as follows
Trang 17Tablel.1: Internal and external factors evaluation matrixes
Table 1.la EFE matrix Opportunities Weight Rating Weighted score Threats Poor (1), below average (2), above average (3), superior (4)
Total Weighted score
Source: Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases (12th Edition) Fred R David Table 1.1b IFE matrix Strengths Weight Rating Weighted score Weaknesses Major weakness (1), minor weakness (2), minor strength (3), major strength (4)
Total Weighted score
Source: Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases (12th Edition) Fred R David
1.3.3 SWOT matrix
SWOT stands for thee English words: Strengths; Weaknesses: Opportunities’ Threats SWOT analysis helps enterprise consider all changes that it can take advantage as well as understand every shortcomings of enterprise SWOT analysis between enterprise and its rival is such a useful tool to support us to find out issues and make decision on management, organizing and business
Strengths: Are capacity of enterprise to carry out essential points well
Weaknesses: Are problems needing to be overcome because they prevent enterprise from success on the work
Opportunities: Are trends, motivations, events and ideas that enterprise possibly applies
Threats: Are pressures outside controlled reach, which enterprise should take
count or create the ways to limit their impacts Using strengths to explore opportunities Using strengths to avoid threats
Cutting down weaknesses to explore opportunities
LE LI GHỢUGHHNGHIHNNGEDNNGEEEEGSUNNEONODUNNNUUDEDG0000000nunEEHDHNEDDUNNNNNEEWDNEDDNDNWANEEEGNNHENN NSE NE SRR CR ITO ĐEN
GaMBA01.X0310 - Group 9 Page 16
Trang 18- Minimizing threats and avoiding risks
SWOT matrix of M Porter analyses opportunities and threats of external environment toward operation of enterprise as well as its strengths and weaknesses
Table Error! No text of specified style in document 2: SWOT matrix analysis y O - Opportunities x T — Threat z S-O S-T
9D & |Promote strengths to take Promote strengths to limit the kg 5 advantage of opportunities and |risks and overcome challenges | {business orientation Nn _ = = ~ |W-O W-T g $ ND ` *
° & |Overcome weaknesses to take |Overcome inside difficulties and ầ 2 advantage of opportunities need to carefully prepare to
o Š overcome challenges from outside 5 > ‘a | — z
Source: Strategic Management and Competitive Advantage: Concepts, Prentice HallJay
Steps of setting up SWOT matrix:
- Step 1: Selectively make a list of opportunities and threats of external environment from the table of general external environment
- Step 2: Selectively list strengths and weaknesses of internal climate from the table of synthesizing and analyzing corporate internal climate
- Step 3: Build up possibilities basing on combining factors as strength, weaknesses, opportunities and threats There are 4 ways of combination:
¥ Combination of SO: Utilize strengths to explore opportunities from
external business climate
¥ Combination of ST: Utilize internal strengths to reduce and watch for
impacts of threats from external environment
CORTE LLY TE LTE IT I EC OTST TTR ROO INE ETT EES, TERR ATEE ESTE GA TT SE OT A A
Trang 19Vv Combination of WO: Take advantage of external opportunities to make good internal shortcomings of companies
v Combination of WT: Is the defensive strategy which tries to overcome
weaknesses and reduce (or avoid) external threats
1.4 Business strategy selection
The selection of trading strategy decides the success or failure of each business The strategy decides the future of business or the business will lose the market position to competitors In nay period, growth or crisis, trading strategy has to be set up and selected basing on the harmony coordination among strength, weakness of business, opportunities and challenges of trading environment
Before selecting trading strategy, business has to consider following factors: - Evaluate accurately the current strategy of business to make foundation for selecting trading strategy in the future as well as affirming strategy
- Re-consider results of techniques analyzing strategy
- Consider main factors affecting directly to strategy regarding as: strength of sector and business; objectives of managing director; financial sources Financial sources usually cause pressure to selecting strategy
Strategy implementing: Strategy forming or setting up is not enough for employees of an organization, they have to take action to implement strategy This is the process of putting different strategies into reality The measures 0 carrying out different levels are cemented to strategy setting up
Evaluating effectiveness of established strategy: The final stage of strategy management is evaluating strategy All strategies depend on future changes because internal and external factors all change regularly Three primary activities of this stage are: (1) Reconsider factors as basis for present strategies; (2) Measuring achievements and (3) Perform adjustment The evaluating Stage is so essential since present success does not ensure the future
1.5 Product life circle model
Ị XĩÏ mm aa LAIN ae
pitt iene ace aaa GaMBA01.X0310 - Group 9 Page 18
Trang 20Product
Sales
Introduction Growth Maturity Oecline
{Qutock WIESLS com
Source: Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases (12th Edition) Fred R David
Figure 1 1 Product Life Cycle [Eng 2]
In this model, there are four stages in the lifecycle of a product: Introduction, Growth, maturity and decline which any product has to go through Characteristics of each stage as follows:
Introduction: This is the initial stage of the product Products are new to the market Consumers are unfamiliar with the existence of them Reasonable strategy for this stage is that the manufacturer should focus on researching products to meet consumer tastes, concentrating on production and branding
Growth: This is a period of strong growth of the product For this stage, it is necessary to promote the expansion of production in order to capture as much market share as possible, because in this stage, other competitors also begin to seeing the attractiveness of the market and join This is the stage in which the demand is greater than the supply
Maturity: the saturation stage is the stage where the number of products provided in the market is extremely abundant Prices tend to decline and the market is in favor of the demand, it means that the profit per product will slow down and tend to decrease The strategy of this phase is to research to add value or different values for the product to compete
Decline: This is the recession stage of the product Product is no longer
attractive and the profit per product falls fast Feasible strategy is that the
Trang 21
manufacturer needs to focus on research and bring new products to start a new cycle Manufacturers have two trends either to develop product to a new step or conduct descending scale and phase out products from the market
The model of the product lifecycle helps companies have strategies which are reasonable in their operation strategy in each stage of business from which it can help maximize profits and reduce risks in business activities
CONCLUSION OF CHAPTER I
The chapter | presents theoretical foundation and definitions of basic terms to set up base of establishing business strategy for enterprise
The theories and methods are; understanding of strategy, steps of setting up strategy, measures of assessing and analyzing to select business strategy, performance and evaluation of effectiveness of strategy
All above theories and methods will be applied to analyze operating environment and build up business strategy for VietInBank which in the capstone project report is concretized as Business strategy to international payment service of VietInBank
L— LANH 58tr Hi, PP AREA REE ST POT EE IIE tS ET Re ONO IRSA E A
Trang 22CHAPTER 2: REAL SITUATION ABOUT ACTIVITIES OF DOING BUSINESS THE INTERNATIONAL PAYMENT SERVICES IN
VIETINBANK
2.1 Introduction of Vietinbank
2.1.1 Establishment and development history
Vietnam Joint Stock Commercial Bank for Industry and Trade (VietinBank) VietinBank was established in 1988 after being separated from State Bank of Vietnam Being one of the four largest State-owned commercial banks of Vietnam, VietinBank’s total assets account for over 20 percent of the market share of the whole Vietnamese banking system
VietinBank has developed an operations network comprising of 01
Transaction Centers, 149 branches, 527 transaction offices, 166 savings offices, 02 Representative offices, 04 Subsidiaries, 03 administrative units and 1042 Automatic
Telling Machines (ATMs)
Being diversified with 06 independent accounting subsidiaries such as VietinBank Leasing Company, VietinBank Securities Company, Ltd., VietinBank Asset Management Company, VietinBank Insurance Company and 03 non-profit making units: VietinBank Information Technology Center, VietinBank Card Center and VietinBank Training Center
Being the founder of the following Financial Credit Institutions: - Saigon Bank for Commerce and Industry
- Indovina Bank (the first joint-venture bank in Vietnam)
- Vietnam International Leasing Company — VILC (the first financial leasing
company in Vietnam)
- Vietinbank Insurance Company Ltd
It sas established correspondent relationship with 850 banks, financial institutions of 90 countries and territories all over the world Being the official member of:
- Vietnam’s Banker Association
ae eae eA eee eR ERE NRE ERC
Trang 23- Asian Banker’s Association
- Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunications (SWIFT) - Visa International Services Association
Being the first bank in Vietnam to apply modern technology and e-commerce in its banking operations
2.1.2 Organization structure and products 2.1.2.1 Organization structure
With about 23 years of development and operation in financial sector, Vietinbank now becomes one of the 4 biggest commercial banks in Vietnam with agents and branches in all provinces of Vietnam To be efficient in operation Vietinbank needs to have a clear organization structure with clear defining jobs for
each section in the bank Details about Vietinbank structure can be seen as below
figures:
weap |, BRANCH | _ REPRESENTATIV BUSINESS UNDER |
SỈ EXCHANGE = TT UYHH (| TEOPPICH |) SUNID 9) 1 COUPANV - _T ˆ SAVING FUND -
Source: Vietinbank Head office
Figure 2.1: System organization of VietinBank
a Le ee RN
Trang 24
Source: Human reasource, Vietinbank
Figure 2.2: Structure of the organizational structure and operating headquarters ~ AUDITING © DEPARTME TRADING | SAVING NTS ~ ROOM FUND
Source: Vietinbank’s website
Figure 2.3: Structure of the executive apparatus of the transaction offices,
Branch level 1, Branch level 2
With clear operation for each section in both head-quarter and branches Vietinbank has opportunities to become the best commercial bank of Vietnam with most comparative products and services
ee eee RENTS
Trang 252.1.2.2 Products and services
Capital mobilization:
- Get cash and deposits with a term in VND and foreign currencies of economic organizations and residents
- Get savings with various forms extensive and compelling: Savings and term limits in VND and foreign currencies, bonus savings plans, savings accrue etc
- Issuance of promissory notes, bonds .etc Lending and investment:
Short-term loans in VND and foreign currencies
Medium and long term loans in VND and foreign currencies Financing export and import negotiation of export documents
Co-financing and loan syndication for large projects, long payback period Loans funded, mandated under the program: Taiwan (SMEDF); Vietnam Germany (DEG, KFW) and the framework credit agreement
Overdraft, consumer loans
Contributing to joint ventures with other credit institutions and financial institutions in the country
Investment in capital markets, money markets in the country
Guarantees
Issue, letter of credit payment import notification, confirmation, payment letter
of credit
- Collection of import and export (Collection) collection sight draft (D/P) and acceptance of the draft collection (D/A)
- Transfer of national and international
- Western Union Money Transfer
- Billing, collection, payment order, check
Trang 26- Buying and selling foreign currencies (Spot, Forward, Swap .)
- Purchase and sale of valuable papers (government bonds, treasury bills, commercial paper .)
- Income and expenditure in VND and foreign currencies in cash .etc
- Safe for rent; kept preserved gold, silver, precious stones, valuable papers, patents of inventions,
Cards and Internet Banking
- Issue and payment of domestic credit card, international credit cards (VISA, MASTER CARD .)
- Free ATM card, cash card (Cash card)
- Internet Banking, Phone Banking, SMS Banking Other activities
- Exploitation of life insurance, non-life
- Investment Advisory and Financial - Financial leasing
- Brokerage, dealing, underwriting, portfolio management, consulting, securities custody
- To receive, manage and exploit the foreclosed assets through debt management companies and asset exploitation
2.1.3 Vision and Mission
Mission: Mission of Vietinbank is to become a leading financial banking group in Vietnam, operate in multi sector to provide standard-quality products and
services, and improve the value of life
Vision: Become a leading, modern and effective financial banking group in Vietnam and international
Core Value
- Comprehensive and continuous renovation;
- Creative, active, professional, whole-hearted, obvious, modern
Slogan: Improving the values of life
EEE
Trang 272.2 Business environment for international payment services of Vietinbank
2.2.1 External environment analysis
2.2.1.1 Macro environment Political:
Parties in international payment methods come from many diffrent countries and business feilds So, international payment is much affected by political environment in countries A slight fuluctuation in political environment or society may cause big difficulty for international commerce and for international payment also Political risk in international payment come from unstable in politic of concerning countries Normally, the main unstable factors are : suddent changingin
tariff, quotar, exchange rate, import- export rules These nonforecated changes force
parties of payment contract cannot finish their responsibilities lead to cancel of services and cause lost for involved parties Besides, crisis, strike, war or coup in involved countries also cause risks for payment progress
Legal system of Vietnam is not perfect, but Government and Congress is trying to build and perfect legal environment, facilitating and encouraging enterprises in general and banks in particular to develop in equally competitive environment In the upcoming years, the significant changes in economy, law and State management will affect the banking-finance system
In process of opening economy according to the commitment with WTO,
Trang 28International environment: According to the committed process of opening banking-finance service of Vietnam within WTO, Vietnam has to open the banking- finance strongly in the upcoming years The commercial banks of Vietnam in general and Vietinbank in particular have faced to the severe competition, not only in the domestic market, but also the the foreign bank system in all aspects Many studies have shown that: the international integration in banking field brought the big opportunities and challenges for commercial banks of Vietnam
Coupled with the implementation of opening policy and international economy integration of Vietnam, the foreign banks have more and more freedom in field and scale in Vietnam Their diversification of service products, technology and experience in applying banking services promote the reform to restructure the financial system of Vietnam and care more about banking services In aspect of integration and innovation, that Vietnam joined AFTA and WTO brings the main effects as follow:
- Liberalize trade and investment, remove barrier and protectionism
- Foreign capital investment in Vietnam increases quickly
- Policy reform is implemented deeply and widely in all levels and fields
- Competition among enterprises, fields, service products of Vietnam and other countries increases day by day, equivalent to the integration level of Vietnam in regional and international economy
Domestic environment: Vietnam’s economic growth in recent years was at high speed in region; the income of citizens is improved much more than that in 1990s In 1990s, personal income was only 300 USD In 2010, personal income reached 1.024 USD Therefore, demand for international trade of Vietnam increased, leading to the growth of the international payment through banks Import and export value are the most important factors which affect to LC service From 2006 until now import and export value of Vietnam have increased gradually, even when the whole economy has been suffering from financial crisis, Vietnam import and export value
mm —————————.——— -—-—-—-—-—-—————— -— -— -—-— -srsrssrsry-ssry- -.-. -r. .- - zzzZnửẳnnn
Trang 29were affected slightly, these values recovered in 2010 and will increase in 2012 onward because of open policy of Vietnam 90 80 70 60 50 44,89 68.8 40 30 20 10 0 Billions USD 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 wf Export i Import
Source: Statistic data of General Statistic Office
Figure 2.4: Import and Export value of Vietnam from 20006 to 2010 Increase in import and export value will be the big chance for commercial bank to develop their LC service and it’s also the chance for Vietinbank to expand the bank’s market share and profit in this field
Interest controlling: In front of changes of currency market, series of policies on interest of State Bank have brought the positive results in order to stabilize and develop currency market, facilitating banking activities and effective allocation of funds of Vietnam’s economy
Exchange rate: At present, in order to stabilize interbank exchange rate and keep balance the international balance of payment, State Bank has implemented the more dynamic exchange rate policies by changing interbank exchange rate and updating the domestic economic situation Besides, it met the demand for foreign
currency of commercial banks, State Bank, and banned the foreign currency business
in the free market This helped enterprises easily approach the foreign currency source at acceptable rate, contributing to the export-import activity promotion
Trang 30
Inflation: Inflation in Vietnam in recent years has reached the alarming level at more than 10% This caused many negative effects on the economic life of Government, stagnating the national economy Besides, the increasing price strongly affected the life of people, especially the poor Inflation decreased the growth speed of GDP, because it made the people become poorer, restricting production of enterprises However, the Government has implemented many timely solutions in order to restrict inflation such as implementing demand stimulus package, narrowing public investment, supporting agriculture industry development and export, etc Thanks to this, inflation of Vietnam is not so serious that leading to the depression
Technology:
Vietinbank always focuses on investment, innovation and modern banking technology application to reserve the business management and advanced network development Vietinbank is one of the leading banks in applying Silverlake technology in Vietnam, which is the most advanced technology applied in many countries With completed IPCAS and SWIFT system, Vietinbank is able to supply the modern banking products and services to all domestic and international customers, of which international payment service is safe and accurate
Social and Natural environment:
Social situation is also an important factor, including: population, intellectual level, personal income, customs With the population over 83 million, Vietnam is an attractive market for the domestic and international commercial banks
Export products of Vietnam mainly are agriculture products Therefore,
natural environment affects a lot the export activities of enterprises 2.2.1.2 Micro environment
Competition of rivalry:
Until the end of 2010, the Vietnamese financial system of Vietnam
comprises 5 commercial banks, 6 joint venture banks, and 9 banks of 100% foreign capital, 39 joint- stock commercial banks, 44 foreign brands, 10 financial companies and 998 credit funds All these financial organization are providing LC
EEE
Trang 31service with this competition Vietinbank is suffering from big competition of these banks and credit funds So, competitors of Vietinbank can be divided into 5 groups as the followings:
Group of commercial banks and state own banks includes: Vietnam Foreign Trade bank (Vietcombank), Bank of investment and development of Vietnam (BIDV), Vietnam bank for Agriculture and Rural development (Agribank), Bank of Housing Development in Me kong delta These are banks which were established and developed in the same period with Vietinbank, some ones even have longer history of development than Vietinbank as BIDV: have larger scope and operation scale, high capital potential, traditional customers relationship with big customer groups like corporations or big mother companies Therefore, this is really rival group to Vietinbank
Group of joint stock banks: There are currently 36 joint stock banks in both cities and countries These banks were established after the group of state owned
banks and have quite small of scale of operation, which are almost concentrated in
citizens However, in recent years, some joint stock banks have very rapid development with suitable direction in the future It cannot be denied that such banks are potential competitors to Vietinbank Competitive advantage of these banks is the small scope and scale of operation, which can be easily changed and adjusted to the diversified demands of customers; flexible in operation mechanism
Group of foreign banks, joint venture banks and foreign branches These are experiential and skillful banks, then, they have advantages in supplying modern banking products and services However, because of the limited scale of operation, this group is not a current dangerous competitor for Vietinbank Despite of that, Vietinbank should be cautious with this group because it promises a very quick development in the next open future
Group of financial and insurance companies: In recent years, these
companies have grown rapidly with the introduction of series of domestic insurance companies and other foreign insurance companies, financial companies, investment
Trang 32funds The growth of this group indicates that the market share of raising capital of banks will be reduced Instead of depositing in only banks as before, currently, customers have many other alternatives such as investing in stock market, buying insurances, authorizing investment
Group of postal saving companies is dangerous competitors of banks The system of postal companies is easy for agricultural residents to approach rather than banks Thus, they are competing directly to banks
Threat of entrance of potential banks:
According to the open roadmap of banking system since the participation into WTO, since April 12007, banks with 100% foreign capital are entitle to establish and till January 1‘, 2011, foreign branches will be treated fully, in other words, will be able to act as a Vietnamese bank Together with the born of some
100% foreign capital banks in Vietnam since the end of 2007 as HSBC, ANZ,
Standard Chatered Bank, Shinhan Vietnam and Hongkong Vietnam Bank, joint stock banks also dramatically develop, especially in big cities or industrial districts, which put more and more pressure in banking field The market participation of groups of foreign banks, joint venture banks and foreign branches is expected as the superior in skills, advanced banking technology, advantages in supplying modern banking products and services By time, this is also a hard rival for Vietinbank, especially this group expands their business in the future
Pressure from customers:
Main customers for international payment services in Vietinbank are: the State owned enterprises, Non-state owned enterprises, cooperatives, households and
individual
To state owned enterprises: Main customers of Vietinbank are Pertolimex, Vietnam Coal and Mineral, Viettel etc With long-term history of cooperation, these state owned enterprises have the loyalty to Vietinbank service
For small and medium enterprises, their loyalty to Vietinbank services is not very high they can easily change to using other banks, with these customers
Trang 33Vietinbank need suitable policy to keep customers loyalty and expand the banks activity to new customers
Due to the development of the investment policy and enterprises law, together with the expansion of SMEs in the context of global, there are many enterprises are apporoaching global market To Vietinbank, the bank has commitment with Vietnamese SMEs Association in 2007 to support for enterprises of the association to reach to the world market With this commitment Vietinbank will be the agents for SMEs in making payment with foreign partners Then SMEs have become potential customers for Vietinbank in developing international payment methods Besides, the bank also provide guidance for SMEs about international trade policy and other related issue
Threat from supplier products:
Suppliers in banking are quite diversified They may be share holders funding the bank or companies in charge of the system as Banknet, SWIFT or maintaining ATM The number of the suppliers is not enough As a result, pressure from supplier wining a contract is raised
Controlling original document is one of the most important factors to LC process Documents for payment have been sending via DHL service DHL is the most prestigious express agent in Asia and the relationship with Vietinbank for years This supplier can support Vietinbank in urgent cases and also ensure the safety of transportation
Threat from substitute products:
There are 6 types of international payments: Remittance, Open account,
collection, authority to purchase, letter of credit, Cash against documents Three
main types of payments now are using in Vietnam are: Collection, LC and remittance Using ration of these methods can be show as below figure
errr EERE TERRE REESE ARTE REESE
Trang 342010 2009 2008 2006 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
bể |mportLC ti ExportlLC ~ Collection & Remittance
Source: The State Bank of Vietnam
Figure 2.5: International payment methods in Vietnam
Although LC is the method with highest profit for banks because of its high safety, but LC is also the most expensive payment method to exporter and importer then they will change to remittance or collection to reduce payment fee for each transaction On the other hand, LC is the method that requires both importer and exporter to submit many kinds of document with strict and long process To expand this activity each bank need to establish a professional officer to support customers in completing these documents
2.2.1.3 External factors evaluation matrix
Bank system is business unit, therefore, during the period implementing the business strategy; it is under a lot of pressure from 5 forces in industry environment, especially in the unstable period as at present To see clearly the effect of each business environment factor on developing international payment services of commercial bank, it can be used method calculating points for each factor for that factor quantification The calculating point method bases on the opinions of experts in banking-finance industry From those opinions, we have table collecting the external environment factors, which affect Vietinbank’s international payment activity as follow:
ee eames NSE ee)
Trang 35Table 2.1: EFE Matrix f External factors Weight | Rating Weighted No score 1 2 3 4=2*3 l Political environment 0.1 3 0.3 Legal framework for banking industry 0.15 3 0.45 Export-import growth and the demands for international | 0.1 4 0.4 3 payment products
4 Banking technology development 0.1 3 0.3
5 Business network widening 0.2 3 0.6
6 Inflation, interest rate, exchange rate development 0.1 2 0.2 7 Expansion of free trade agreements (BTA, AFTA, | 0.2 4 0.8
8 Market entrance of foreign banks 0.15 3 0.45 Total 1 3.15
Through the table analyzing external environment factors to see the effects on the LC service of Vietinbank:
(1): International economic integration helps bank penetrating in the international market, having chance to approach new capital, receiving experience from the most modern banks over the world The international changes also lead to the unstable currency policy International economic also help to expand import and export value then increase both number and amount of each international payment transaction
(2): That the economy grows at high speed leads to the high demand for international payment services
(3): Banking-finance experts evaluate that inflation strongly affects bank industry
(4): Exchange rate affects the industry in general and Vietinbank in particular at medium level
(5): Stable politic — legal environment and State policies will attract the foreign investment and oversea remittance, creating foreign currency for bank
— ——————————
Trang 36(6): The development of information technology meets the demand for
developing products and services This factor affects bank at high level It determines the success in industrial competition of Vietinbank in integration
(8): High population, potential market, intellectual level of people lead to the high demand for import and export goods then create big demand of using international payment service
(9): Competitors: foreign financial institutions, joint stock banks doing business in profitable areas put pressure on the banks This factor is considered affecting strongly the industry and Vietinbank
(10): The development of alternative brings the challenges in technology and LC service innovation
(11): The increase in quantity and scale of enterprises leads to the high demand for international transaction and payment via bank
(12) Customers are the ones who determine the service products of which bank
(13): The experts evaluate that effects of this factor are at medium level Because changing the suppliers in banking industry costs much, should consider carefully before making decision
The external environment factors affect international payment service of Vietinbank at medium level This requires Vietinbank to make breakthrough in innovation to keep its stable position in this competitive environment and have best solutions in business
2.2.2 Internal environment analysis 2.2.2.1 The bank’s valuable chain
The most important factors that determine quality and development of international payment service in a bank are: process, quality of human resource and quality of marketing activity To Vietinbank these factors are focused to innovate and ensure to provide best service to customers Details of each activity can be explained as following:
nr
Trang 37LC process:
Simple LC application process is one of the most important competitive
factors to banks to attract customers With strict, safe and simple process for LC
payment, Vietinbank can attract a large number of customers and provide them the best and convenience service to save both cost and time for payment LC process for import and export payment can be summarized as following figures:
¥ * Recieve and check application for LC
* Approval and issue LC limitation * Registation and issue import LC * Recieve and check documents e Making payment
Figure 2.6: Import LC payment process in Vietinbank
Making payment for exportation via LC method is also applied via a simple and complete process in which customers are full supported by bank’s officers LC process is summary as below:
* Recieve and check application for LC * LC notice * Recieve and check documents | * Making payment for export LC `
Figure 2.7: Export LC payment process in Vietinbank
With below process of LC making payment Vietinbank can ensure a competitive product customers with fast, safe and efficient service
Human resource operation:
—— _—————————————>—
Trang 38- Human resource management: Currently, all Vietinbank system has nearly
18 thousand of staffs in: 01 Head Office, 01 Transaction Office, 03 career unit, 02
representative office, 149 branches level 1, 892 transaction offices and 56 saving funds in 63 provinces and cities under Center over country and 01 branch in Germany
- Human resource development: Vietinbank built a human resource training and developing School at large scale in Van Canh — Hanoi with capability over
10.000 staffs joining short-term trainings per year
- Salary policy: Workers are paid based on job position, productivity, quality and work efficiency, rewarded according to the job completing level
Human resource policy now is improving which create the strength for Vietinbank to expand all activities and international service as well
2.2.2.2 Financial analysis General statement:
Financial ability is one of the most important factors that help a bank to develop all its activities in general and international payment service in particular
Vietinbank is the bank with long term of development, large operation scale and
famous prestige These factors help the bank to expand its operation year by year and reduce bad debt ration From 2008 to 2010, the whole economy has been suffering from impact of the world financial crisis but Vietinbank can maintain its profit and expand is financial ability in all fields Below table will show out the development in financial ability of Vietinbank from 2008 to 2010
Trang 39Total called-up capital | eon 174,905 220.591} 339.699 Totaldedt | yp! | 120-752] 163.170 — Prombeforetx Capital Adequacy Ratio | ÝNp | 2436 | 3373| 439 % 12,23% 6,06% 8,02% ¬ seit SE a | sem “soo - oo om ‘aang loan | % | 1%) grr] 066M
Source: Vietinbank’s Annual report 2008, 2009, 2010
Some main financial indexes are also developing stably and gradually from 2007 to 2009 Table 2.2: Financial indexes in the period of 2007 to 2009 Criteria 2007 2008 2009 Total assets 16,5% 25,9% 50,8% Charter Capital - — 14%| 45.8% 34,8% " sort So a Total called-up capital 15,6% | 26,1% 54,0% nee —n am oi | TINH mm
Source: Vietinbank’s Annual report 2008, 2009, 2010
About financial ability and financial indexes indicate that Vietinbank has big opportunities to expand the bank’s activity in the future The bank can catch up with market demand and operating efficiently its services to achieve stable growth rate of profit and operation scale
Growth of LC service:
Despite of impaction of global financial crisis, the whole world activity (included cross border trade) has been slightly down, total payment amount for import and export LC increased from 2008 to 2010 Payment amount for importation increased 46% from 2008 to 2010 and the percentage for exportation
was 33.4%
ee ESSE
Trang 408 702 8 6 = § 4 z 2 0 2008 2009 2010
id Paymentof import L/C ii Payment of export L/C
Source: Vietinbank’s annual report 2008, 2009, 2010
Figure 2.8: Growth of LC payment from 2008 to 2010
Growth rate of both import and export value for LC payment indicated Vietinbank ability to expand this activity in the future The difference between import and export LC reflected the trade deficit status of Vietnam T ogether with development of international trade in Vietnam, the bank has opportunity to continue
to expand this activity in the strategic period of 2012 to 2016
Characteristics of Import Letter of Credit service product are often related to the foreign capital funded to the customers Therefore, in recent years, Vietinbank has focused on finding and mobilizing the foreign currency to meet the demand for import of customers By strongly developing the export funding activities, Vietinbank has the stable foreign currency source for export enterprises Besides, Vietinbank also develops the oversea remittance transfer services such as Weston Union to exploit the foreign currency transferred from oversea to sell or lend import customers
2.2.2.3 Vietinbank’s prestige and reputation
Development of culture and brand name is the most important operation of VietinBank In 2010, the bank widely announced and applied the new brand identity nationwide The new brand recognition of Vietinbank was built on the basis of careful research and analysis about colors, meanings, symbols, in accordance with
ee