schumpeter - history of economic analysis

[...]... the template for many of the analytical history of economics texts which followed.10 Until Schumpeter s 1954 History of Economic Analysis appeared, American (and presumably British) economics graduate students generally referred to several ‘old standbys:’ Eric Roll’s strange mixture of pro- and then a-Marxian (to coin a neologism) A History of Economic Thought (particularly the post-World War II 2nd [1946]... Schumpeter: A Biography Princeton: Princeton University Press Stark, W (1959) ‘The “Classical Situation” in Political Economy.’ Kyklos, 12, 57–65 Stigler, George J (1954) Schumpeter s History of Economic Analysis. ’ Journal of Political Economy, 82, 344–5 Taylor, O.H (1955) Schumpeter s History of Economic Analysis. ’ Review of Economics and Statistics, 37, 12–21 Viner, Jacob (1954) Schumpeter s History. .. (1954) Schumpeter s History of Economics.’ Southern Journal of Economics, 21, 261–72 Little, I.M.D (1955) ‘Essays in Bibliography and Criticism XXXI History of Economic Analysis. ’ Economic History Review: Series 2, 10, 91–8 Marx, Karl (1867) Das Kapital März, Edward (1991) Schumpeter: Scholar, Teacher, and Politician New Haven, CT: Yale University Press McCulloch, John Ramsay (1845) The Literature of Political... covers economics between 1790 and 1870 The initial three chapters cover the plan of the analysis, a bird’s-eye view of the economic history of the period, and a marvelous survey of the dominant idea-sets of that era Again, Schumpeter ‘reviews the troops’ (his phrase), and identifies his heroes, including Longfield and von Thünen, Cournot, J.S.Mill, Say, and Sismondi Schumpeter then devotes most of a... Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press Richardson, G.B (1955) Schumpeter s History of Economic Analysis. ’ Oxford Economic Papers 7, 136–50 Robbins, Lionel (1955) Schumpeter s History of Economic Analysis. ’ Quarterly Journal of Economics, 44, 1–22 Roll, Eric (Lord Roll of Ipsden) (1938) A History of Economic Thought London: Faber and Faber Roscher, Wilhelm Georg Friedrich (1851) Geschichte der Englishen... possibility of treating the history of economics like the history of any other science is controversial, Part I of the book is devoted entirely to the methodological questions that this approach raises and especially to the question how far the distinction between scientific economic analysis and economic thought is valid in spite of the interaction between the two Part II then tells the story of the growth of. .. unfinished History of Economic Analysis (HEA) is the most significant part of the fifth and last of Schumpeter s great projects To some, its development represents the somber reflections of an older scholar, one embittered by personal, career, and character tragedies To others, it is the quintessential, if uncompleted, final great professional tour d’horizon of the leading practiced academic professional economics... Development of Economic Doctrine: An Introductory Survey (1931) and Henry W.Spiegel’s The Growth of Economic Thought (1971) More advanced scholars relied on monographs on writers, schools, periods, and sub-sets of the topic (e.g monetary theory, etc.) None of the foregoing, however, is, in my view, magisterial—none attempts to synthesize a vision Since the appearance of the History of Economic Analysis. .. Types of Economic Theory: From Mercantilism to Institutionalism Edited with an Introduction by Joseph Dorfman New York: Kelley Perlman, Mark (1982) Schumpeter as a Historian of Economic Thought,’ in Helmut Frisch (ed.), Schumpeterian Economics, Eastbourne, East Sussex, England: Praeger, 1981, pp 143–61 ——(1986) ‘Perceptions of Our Discipline: Three Magisterial Interpretations of the History of Economic. .. important thing about Schumpeter s History of Economic Analysis is its impact on the profession Unfinished and published with obvious and identified lacunae, it can not serve as a good reference guide Yet, reference is regularly made to it Why? Although I will expand on this point later, let me say here only that it offers a complex but not-quite-idiosyncratic vision of economics Schumpeter knew Continental . class="bi x0 y0 w0 h0" alt="" HISTORY OF ECONOMIC ANALYSIS HISTORY OF ECONOMIC ANALYSIS BY JOSEPH A .SCHUMPETER EDITED FROM MANUSCRIPT BY ELIZABETH BOODY SCHUMPETER AND WITH AN INTRODUCTION. template for many of the analytical history of economics texts which followed. 10 Until Schumpeter s 1954 History of Economic Analysis appeared, American (and presumably British) economics graduate. that it offers a complex but not-quite-idiosyncratic vision of economics. Schumpeter knew Continental sources, with which most British- and American- and often imaginatively. Most of all,