Policy Issues In The Development Of Personalized Medicine in Oncology docx

[...]... commentary on the following areas:   PERSONALIZED MEDICINE IN ONCOLOGY • The current state of the art of personalized medicine technology, including obstacles to its development and use by clinicians and patients • The current approaches to test validation, including analytic validity, clinical validity, and clinical utility • The regulation of personalized medicine technologies, including the approaches’... field of personalized Â� cancer medicine forward The views expressed in this summary are those of the speakers and discussants, as attributed to them, and are not the consensus views of the participants of the workshop or of the members of the National Cancer Policy Forum Personalized Cancer Medicine Technology S everal speakers illustrated both the accomplishments of personalized cancer medicine and the. .. concept has great promise, a number of policy issues must be clarified and resolved before personalized medicine can reach its full potential These include technological, regulatory, and reimbursement hurdles To explore those challenges, the National Cancer Policy Forum held Â� a workshop, Policy Issues in the Development of Personalized Medicine in Oncology, ” in Washington, DC, on June 8 and 9, 2009... Bonoff stressed that “for a biomarker to be clinically meaningful it must improve patient outcomes in a meaningful way, and predict disease outcome in the absence of treatment or guide the use of therapy targeted to the marker.” Dr Richard Schilsky of the University of Chicago and the Cancer and Leukemia Group B (CALGB), added, “Biomarker development needs to start off by defining the intended use of. .. determined by assays with FLT3 inhibition using patient serum In leukemia cell lines, a drug could inhibit 80–90 percent of FLT3 receptor activity in the presence of some patients’ serum, but only achieve 60–70 percent inhibition in the presence of serum from other patients In addition, this study found that clinical response to these drugs correlated with the degree of inhibition achieved in the assays... of the report before its release The review of this report was overseen by Melvin Worth Appointed by the Institute of Medicine, he was responsible for making certain that an independent examination of this report was carried out in accordance with institutional procedures and that all review comments were carefully considered Responsibility for the final content of this report rests entirely with the. .. American Society of Clinical Oncology, JCO = Journal of Clinical Oncology, JNCI = Journal of the National Cancer Institute SOURCES: Shak (2009); Wolff et al (2007) PERSONALIZED CANCER MEDICINE TECHNOLOGY 21 tion in HER2 testing, Dr Shak said Ms Bonoff added, “There’s significant variation in the results of these commonly used HER2 tests in different laboratories, as well as different tests for the same marker,... 2009) “There are a number of patients who are no longer receiving therapy uselessly, and there has been a lot of money saved,” said Dr Amado However, Dr Mark Ratain of the University of Chicago Hospitals said that the more we learn, the more we know we don’t know.” Deciphering the clinical implications of predictive tests can be challenging, even when they assess the function of just one key protein Genetic... Instead, he relied on the National Cancer Institute (NCI) for funding Only when the FDA changed the drug label of irinotecan to include information that linked a specific genetic variant with a heightened risk of an adverse reaction to the drug did corporations show an interest in developing predictive tests for the variant, he said The reluctance of drug companies to support the development of predictive... bloodstream products have on the binding of a drug on its target Human plasma has numerous proteins that can bind to drugs A recent study indicated that binding can change the concentration of drugs in the bloodstream from the nanomolar range to the micromolar range, he said (Levis et al., 2006) (Figure 5) Different patients show different bind- 14 PERSONALIZED MEDICINE IN ONCOLOGY 120 Medium vs Serum . citation: IOM (Institute of Medicine) . 2010. Policy issues in the development of personalized medicine in oncology: Workshop summary. Washington, DC: The National. on the following areas: Introduction 2 PERSONALIZED MEDICINE IN ONCOLOGY • The current state of the art of personalized medicine technology, including