Thông tin tài liệu
Financial Development and Bubbles: The Case of the Karachi Stock Exchange of Pakistan Ehsan Ahmed Department of Economics James Madison University Harrisonburg, VA 22807 USA J Barkley Rosser, Jr Department of Economics James Madison University Harrisonburg, VA 22807 USA Tel: 540-568-3212 Fax: 540-568-3010 Email: rosserjb@jmu.edu Jamshed Y Uppal Department of Business and Economics Catholic University of America Washington, D.C., 20064 USA March, 2010 Abstract: Speculative bubbles present a problem for the development of sophisticated financial markets in developing economies This paper discusses the evolution of regulatory institutions in Pakistan pertaining to the Karachi stock exchange and empirically tests for the presence of stock market bubbles in that stock market in recent years A fundamental is estimated using a VAR approach, and residuals of this fundamental are tested for trends using Hamilton regime switching and Hurst rescaled range methods Nonlinearities beyond ARCH are also tested for using the BDS test We are unable to reject the hypothesis of no bubbles or non nonlinearities during the period studied, indicating that Pakistan faces this difficult problem in developing appropriate regulations and institutions for the oversight of its financial markets Keywords: Asia, Pakistan, emerging markets, financial regulations, speculative bubbles Financial Development and Bubbles: The Case of the Karachi Stock Exchange of Pakistan Introduction Over the last two decades many developing countries have pursued public policies to foster financial market development through building regulatory frameworks and institutional development so that these markets may play a greater role in mobilizing capital for economic development In some countries the impetus for such policies arose from an endogenous demand from the capital market participants, and in others from international development agencies Substantial resources have been spent on financial markets development in efforts to transform the financial sector landscapes and bring the markets and institutions into the 21st century The capital market developments across countries have taken place in the backdrop of economic liberalization and a shift to market-based policies, which have greatly increased capital mobility across boarders In a number of countries while it has led to exponential growth in the market capitalizations and turnovers, it has been accompanied by increased volatility In many cases it has sparked spells of apparent speculative bubbles when the assets prices seem to be disconnected from the economic fundaments On the other hand one might expect that with capital market development the incidence of speculation should subside and valuations would come to rest on fundamentals Therefore, the question is to what extent the capital markets development has affected the incidence of speculation In this paper we address one aspect of the quality of the capital market, the appearance of speculative bubbles in the stock markets Specifically, we study the case of Pakistan, an emerging market where significant regulatory reforms, institutional built-up and financial sector development took place over a relatively short-period The capital markets development has been country’s declared public policy, prodded and underwritten by the international development institutions as a central piece in the overall economic development strategy Pakistan was among the foremost countries to lift restrictions on the capital flows and equity ownership Favorable policies to encourage foreign investment and privatize state owned enterprises (SOE’s) were put into place in the early 1990’s The country’s major stock exchange, the Karachi Stock Exchange (KSE) is one of the oldest stock exchanges among the developing countries, and its basic institutional framework has been in place for over 60 years, unlike some other emerging markets where such institution were built up relatively recently The Pakistan economy has remained a largely free-market one with a strong private entrepreneurship tradition, despite the presence of some socialist sectors and efforts at times to pursue an Islamic economics path The country, therefore, is an interesting case study of the public pursuit of capital markets development The rest of the paper is organized as follows We present an overview of the capital markets development in Pakistan since early 1990’s and of the KSE, the dominant stock exchange in the country The following section reviews the literature on speculative bubbles, and is followed by a description of our methodology and data Empirical results are presented next, and the final section presents our conclusions Capital Markets Development in Pakistan Capital markets development in Pakistan can be characterized as occurring in four broad phases Since the early 1950s the economic policies predominantly reflected a command-andcontrol approach based on central planning for economic management and development The second phase (1973-1988) reflected a national pursuit of a form of Islamic-socialism The first two pre-liberalization phases were, therefore, characterized by financial repression The third phase, the liberalization phase, marked a shift towards a market-based economy and is characterized by liberalization of external account, removal of regulatory barriers on private and foreign investment, building up-of the financial regulatory framework and institutions, and deregulation of financial markets The fourth phase, 2002 onward, has been marked by a continuing drive towards maturation of financial institutions, and deepening and broadening of financial markets The landmark year in the Pakistan’s capital markets development was 1991 when the country’s markets were substantially opened to the international investors This was part of a larger set of measures to place the economy on market-based principles The package included measures to liberalize foreign exchange regulations and foreign trade Decisions were made to privatize industrial units and banks, which had been nationalized earlier Securities markets were deregulated and auction markets for government securities were established The regulatory controls on corporate public offering of equity and on foreign ownership and underwriting of securities were removed Major changes in the tax system were simplification and reduction of tax rates, including exemption of capital gains on equity stock and a tax holiday for selected industrial and financial institutions As a result of post-1991 liberalization, the financial sector saw establishment of private sector mutual funds, off-shore funds, creation of Employees’ Stock Option Plans, corporate brokerage houses, investment advisory firms, many in collaboration with foreign securities firms and investment banks A process of privatization of nationalized commercial banks was initiated during the year 1991-92 and two state-owned banks, the Allied Bank Limited (ABL) and the Muslim Commercial Bank (MCB), were partially denationalized and their management transferred to the private sector A number of private commercial banks were established creating greater competition within the banking industry Controls on interest rates charged on bank loans and paid on deposits were also removed The banking sector’s balance sheets were strengthened by removing non-performing loans (NPLs), and strengthening the legal framework for the recovery of bank dues A credit rating agency, the Pakistan Credit Rating Agency, Limited (PACRA), was established in August 1994 as a joint venture between the International Finance Corporation (IFC), International Bank Credit Analysis, Ltd (now Fitch/IBCA) of UK, and the Lahore Stock Exchange A second credit rating agency, JCR-VIS Credit Rating Co Ltd, was incorporated in 19971 In 1994-95, a Central Depository Company (CDS) was established to implement an electronic book entry system for securities settlement In 1997, the government initiated a Capital Market Development Program (CMDP) with the help of the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to strengthen the capital market The key components of the plan included: (i) creation of a level playing field to enhance competition; (ii) strengthening governance; (iii) modernizing market infrastructure and its linkages; (iv) developing the corporate debt market; (v) reforming mutual fund industry; (vi) developing leasing industry; and (vii) promoting contractual savings through reforms of the insurance sector and pensions and provident funds The securities’ regulatory body, the Corporate Law Authority, was reconstituted in 1999 as an autonomous Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) The governance structure of stock exchanges was improved and its regulatory powers were enhanced Towards the end of 1990’s the goal of restructuring the financial sector and establishing a clear legal and regulatory framework had been substantially achieved, along with broader improvements in the general economic environment The policy focus shifted in December 2002 towards deepening and broadening of the markets with the initiation of the Financial (Non-bank) JCR-VIS is a joint venture between Japan Credit Rating Agency, Ltd (JCR) and Vital Information Services (Pvt.) Limited (VIS) of Pakistan, the Karachi Stock Exchange and the Islamabad Stock Exchange Markets and Governance Program (FMGP) financed by the Asian Development Bank The FMGP focused on (i) strengthening investor confidence through improved governance, transparency, and investor protection; (ii) increasing the depth and diversity of financial intermediation through new capital market issues to mobilize savings and investments; (iii) improving operating efficiency and risk management of intermediaries; and (iv) reducing financial sector vulnerabilities The 2000’s saw continued broadening and deepen of financial markets through market-based financial instruments and institutions Since market liberation measures of 1991, the equity market in Pakistan has undergone substantial structural changes and growth Table captures the salient features of the stock market over the 1989-2005 period at four year intervals Market capitalization, as a percentage of GDP which was only 6.5% in 1989, rose to 23.9% by 1993 post liberalization The market capitalization to GDP ratio dropped precipitously in 2001 to 6.9% following the 9-11 WTC terrorist attacks However, following years have seen a period of steady and strong growth pushing the capitalization ratio to ascent to 42.0% at the end of 2005), though the ratio is still low compared to other Asian markets Similarly, the trading value has increased from 231 million US $ in 1989 to US$140,996 million in 2005 In the post 2001 period, continued privatization and liberalization policies together with regulatory and structural reforms have led to further maturation of the capital markets The period also experienced an unprecedented increase in the share prices, which increased almost 10 fold after 2001 The market capitalization has largely been boosted by the listing of a number of large state-owned enterprises (SOEs), whose privatization drove market growth Six of the 10 largest listed companies are former SOEs, which together accounted for 42% of total market capitalization in 2006 Domestic institutional investors such as mutual funds and insurance companies also increased engagement in the capital markets, though the individual investors account for the bulk of exchange trading The investor base has also expanded due to interest by foreign portfolio investors Foreign portfolio investment rose to $354 million and $980 million during FY2006 and FY2007 respectively, up from an aggregate inflow of $202 million over the preceding years, led by dedicated emerging market funds activities Despite the series of reforms and structural developments the capital market instruments still play a minor role in mobilizing primary financing to the real sector In 2005 capital raised by corporations and financial institutions through equity and bond issues totaled only 0.3% of GDP Pakistan lags behind other emerging markets in resource mobilization issues of new equity through the capital market Similarly, bond market issues in Pakistan compared to other emerging markets are almost non-existent The market for derivative instruments has also not developed much The stock market lacks breadth as well as depth The 10 largest stocks accounted for 55% of the total market capitalization in 2007 Trading of stocks is likewise highly concentrated Free float is also rather limited; an average of only 20% of the shares of the listed companies are available for trading, resulting in relatively low market liquidity This coupled with a high turnover paints a picture of a highly speculative market According to Asian Development Bank report (ADB 2007) the key issues of concern, among others, are high equity market volatility, small public float (shares available for trading), and weak securities market legislation The ADB Report also notes that the Pakistan stock market’s volatility is partly due to a high volume of speculative short-term individual investment in shares and thin public float of the listed companies Karachi Stock Exchange (KSE) The Karachi Stock Exchange (KSE), established in 1947, is the oldest and the most active of the three stock exchanges in Pakistan, listing 662 companies with a total market capitalization of about $52 billion as of 2006 The KSE100 represents major blue chips companies and is fairly good representative of the market Besides the KSE there are two regional stock exchanges in Lahore and Islamabad which are relatively inactive For example, during July 2005-March 2006 period the average daily turnover at the KSE was 462.4 million share, while at LSE and ISE it was 65.4 and 1.7 million shares, representing 12% and 3% of the total market activity respectively Despite the small size of the market, KSE experiences a high turnover and high price volatility Table provides salient features of the KSE The KSE is relatively a much smaller market compared to other emerging markets, representing only 0.65% of the total capitalization of the emerging markets in 2005 It is interesting to note the sharp contrast between Pakistan’s capitalization ratio (which is low) and relatively high turnover ratio This characteristic most likely reflects greater noise trading and speculation than in other similar markets The spectacular rise in the KSE100 Index of 650% over the 2001-05 period is remarkable As a comparison we note that the appreciation in the Stock Exchange of Mumbai (BSE30) index was 137% for the same period The Pakistani stock market appreciation was four times higher than the Indian market despite a higher rate of growth in the Indian GDP for the same period As the above discussion shows there are indications that the Pakistani stock market may be characterized by frequent periods of speculative bubbles when the rapid increases in the stock prices may not be justified by the market fundamentals The market regulators all over the world consider market bubbles exhibiting “irrational exuberance” to have a potential for economic disruptions and distortions Besides, the perception of speculative behavior works against creating trust and a sense of fairness in financial markets When combined with allegations of market manipulations, insider trading, and outright scams, the speculative nature of the market can be a serious impediment to capital formation, and efficient functioning of the financial markets.i The existence of speculative behavior on the KSE is also indicated by specific episodes when there were widespread allegations for market speculation, manipulation and fraud For example, one such bubble appears to have developed over the 2002-2005 period and busted in March 2005 The KSE experienced a steady bull run as reflected in both the KSE 100 index and trading volumes, starting just after the last stock market crisis in May 2002, which accelerated towards the end of 2004 The KSE100 saw an unprecedented rise of 65%, from 6,218 on December 31, 2004 to 10,303 on March 15, 2005, along with an increase in the value traded from around $300400 million to $1-2 billion per day The market turned negative in the second half of March, 2005 and the index dropped to as low as 6,939 on April 12, 2005, a decline of 32.7 percent from its peak The sharp rise in the index could not be explained by any change in the fundamentals, which barely changed during this period The following precipitous fall is also somewhat of a puzzle Such a meteoric rise in index and a subsequent crash is indicative of a classical speculative bubble in the equity market In this paper we, therefore, examine the existence of speculative behavior on the KSE, comparing it over the two periods in capital markets development; the first, financial liberalization and restructuring phase over 1993-2001, and second, the financial maturation and deepening phase, 2001-2007 Theory of Speculative Bubbles A speculative bubble involves an asset market dominated by agents purchasing an asset with the expectation that its price will rise in some near term future so that they can make a capital gain within some relatively near term period This then leads the price to rise above some long run fundamental value, presumably based on a present value of a rationally expected future stream of net real returns properly discounted While there is a long and classic literature arguing for the historical existence of such bubbles going back centuries (Kindleberger, 1978), theoretical literature faces certain complications The first is that it is difficult to reconcile such agent behavior with the assumption of rationality Indeed, Tirole (1982) argued that bubbles will not happen in a world of infinitely lived, perfectly informed rational agents, operating in discrete time markets Due to the idea that the bubble must end at some point and it will not be rational to be holding the asset in the period before it ends, an assumption of common knowledge feeds a backward induction argument to show that it is irrational to become involved in the bubble to begin with However, rational bubbles may be possible as some of these assumptions are relaxed Thus, Tirole (1985) showed that allowing finitely lived agents in overlapping generations models can pass a stationary bubble on to later generations, with this argument having been made for the long run existence of a stable fiat money (whose fundamental value is zero) But stationary bubbles are not empirically observable as most tests for bubbles (such as those we use below) involve seeking to observe apparently rapid movements away from presumed fundamentals Such bubbles can be rational if they are expected to crash in finite time and rise at an accelerating rate that provides a risk premium for rational agents (Blanchard and Watson, 1982) 10 defined by MSCI The data on the stock market indices, interest rates and exchange rates was obtained form the Datastream International, Ltd database We recognize that in principle it might be preferable to use a dividend series However, these are not available on remotely a daily basis, and it has long been argued that dividends are artificially smoothed by managers, thus removing a substantial amount of their usefulness except over long time horizons Furthermore, changes in dividends would presumably reflect changes in incoming economic news, which we hope to capture the daily aspect of with our set of broader economic fundamentals that vary on a daily basis Next, we remove the autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity (ARCH) effects from this VAR residual series.iii These residual series are then used to conduct regime-switching tests, rescaled range tests, and nonlinearity BDS tests Regime Switching Tests Hamilton (1989) introduced an approach to regime switching tests that can be used to test for trends in time series and switches in trends, as used in Engel and Hamilton (1990) and van Norden and Schaller (1993) We use this approach as our main test for the null of no bubbles on the residual series derived above which is given by ∈t = nt + zt (2) nt = µ1 + µ2st (3) where and zt - zt-1 = Ν1(zt-1 - zt-2) +…+Νr (zt-r - zt-r-1) + γt 14 (4) with s = being a positive trend, s = being a negative trend, and : I ≠ indicating the possible existence of a trend element beyond the VAR process Furthermore, let Prob [st = st-1 = 1] = p, Prob [st = st-1 = 1] = - p (5) Prob [st = st-1 = 0] = q, Prob [st = st-1 = 0] = - q (6) Following Engel and Hamilton (1990) a "no bubbles" test proposes a null hypothesis of no trends given by p = - q This is tested by with a Wald test statistic given by [p - (1 - q)]/[var(p) + var(1 - q) + covar(p, - q)] (7) The critical value for rejecting the null of no trends is χ2 = 3.8 Results are reported in tables 3a and 3b Clearly, the null is strongly rejected However, we caution that this does not definitively prove the presence of a bubble due to the misspecified fundamental problem Hurst Persistence Tests Hurst (1951) developed a test to study persistence of Nile River annual flows, which was first applied to economic data by Mandelbrot (1972) For a series xt with n observations, mean of x*m and a max and a value, the range R(n) is k k R(n) = [max ≤ k ≤ n Σ (xj - x*) - ≤ k ≤ n Σ (xj - x*)] j=1 j=1 (8) The scale factor, S(n, q) is the square root of a consistent estimator for spectral density at frequency zero, with q < n, q S(n, q)2 = g0 + 2Σwj(q)gj, wj(q) = - [j/(q-1)], j=1 15 (9) with g's autocovariances and w's weights based on the truncation parameter, q, which is a period of short-term dependence.iv The classical Hurst case has q = 0, which reduces the scaling factor to a simple standard deviation Feller (1951) showed that if xt is a Gaussian i.i.d series then R(n)/S(n) ∝ nH, (10) with H = 1/2, which implies integer integrodifferentiation and thus standard Brownian motion, the "random walk." H is the Hurst coefficient, which can vary from zero to one with a value of 1/2 implying no persistence in a process, a value significantly less than 1/2 implying "antipersistence" and a value significantly greater than 1/2 implying positive persistence The significance test involves breaking the sample into sub-samples (namely, pre-bubble, duringbubble and post-bubble period) and then estimating a Chow test on the null that the subperiods possess identical slopes This technique is also called rescaled range analysis Sub-samples are determined on visual examination of the entire stock returns series Underlying conditions for these episodes (in sub-samples) are discussed later in this paper Tables 4a and 4b present the results of this test For each sample H (Hurst) coefficient is estimated Computed F values for the Chow tests of the significance of this coefficient are reported For a test of a model with both slope and intercept the computed F-Values are substantially above the critical value showing a significant rejection of the null hypothesis that the coefficient is equal to 0.50 (thus indicating no persistence) Results are reported for a test of a model with the intercept suppressed, the computed F values are above the critical values leading to the rejection of the null that there is no persistence As before, this test remains subject to the caveat that we may not have properly estimated the true fundamental 16 Nonlinearity Tests We test for nonlinearity of the VAR residual series in two stages The first is to remove ARCH effects Engle (1982) the nonlinear variance dependence measure of autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity (ARCH) as xt = δtµt (11) n δ = α0 + Σ αixI-i2 i=0 t (12) with µ i.i.d and the αI's different lags We use a three period lag and, as expected, found significant ARCH effects in all series, available on request from the authors The second stage involves removing variability attributable to the estimated ARCH effects from the VAR residual series for both models The remaining residual series is run through the BDS test due to Brock, Dechert, LeBaron, and Scheinkman (1997), with useful guidance on certain aspects in Brock, Hsieh, and LeBaron (1991) This statistic tests for generalized nonlinear structure but does not test for any specific form such as alternative ARCH forms or chaos The correlation integral for a data series xt, t = 1, …, T results from forming m-histories such that x = [xt, xt+1, …, xt+m+1] for any embedding dimension m It is cmT(ε) = Σ Iε(xtm, xsm)[2/Tm(Tm-1)] t 1, cm(ε) [c1(ε)]m equals zero Thus, sufficiently large values of the BDS statistic indicate nonlinear structure in the remaining series This test is subject to severe small sample bias with a cutoff of 500 observations sufficient to overcome this, a minimum both of our daily series easily achieve Tables 5a and 5b present the results of this test for embedding dimensions, m = to (m = is conventional) The critical value for rejecting the null of i.i.d is approximately Based on the estimated BDS statistics null is rejected Thus, there appears to be remaining nonlinearity beyond basic ARCH in the VAR residual series Of course, just as our earlier tests are subject to the validity of our original VAR specifications and the broader misspecified fundamental problem, likewise so is this test We also emphasize that the nature of the remaining nonlinearity remains unknown Conclusions Developing nations face difficult choices regarding the form of their financial systems On the one hand there is clearly a strong relationship between economic development and having a developed financial system that can support the real capital investment needed for that development At the same time, financial development opens a nation to influences coming from the outside world, making it susceptible to the volatility of world markets Also, a poorly regulated system that has more levels of sophistication and asset types may open opportunities for domestic sources of instability as inexperienced investors become involved in speculative 18 bubbles While experience may lead to fewer bubbles of some sorts, experiences such as the dotcom bubble in the U.S and the broader housing bubble in many nations show that experience is no guarantee against the appearance of speculative bubbles in sophisticated financial systems Pakistan illustrates many of the issues involved in this question of development It has joined many other emerging markets in attempting to develop a sophisticated financial system consistent with a higher level of economic development At the same time it has held back in some ways, with some of this reflecting its history of greater regulation of the financial system from its past efforts to pursue socialist and Islamic paths that downplayed such an approach In this paper recent data from the Karachi Stock Exchange was studied to check for the presence of speculative bubbles with possible nonlinear components A vector autoregression was estimated on a daily series of fundamental economic variables seen as providing information regarding profitable prospects for firms whose stocks are traded on the KSE Residuals of this VAR equation were studied using regime switching tests and rescaled range tests These tests quite strongly failed to reject the null hypothesis of no bubbles, and further tests failed to reject the presence of nonlinearities beyond ARCH effects Nevertheless, given the difficult problem of misspecified fundamentals, we note that one cannot argue definitively that speculative bubbles have actually been observed, although the evidence is clearly consistent with such a conclusion We finally note that if these findings are correct, this suggests that Pakistan faces difficult choices regarding policy Even with its lower level of financial market development than some other emerging markets, it is not free from instabilities such as bubbles 19 References ADB (2007) Proposed Program Loan and Technical Assistance Grant, Islamic Republic of Pakistan: Second Generation of Capital Market Reforms Asian Development Bank, Report and Recommendation to the Board of Directors, Project Number: 41108, Manila Ahmed, E., Koppl, R., Rosser, J.B., Jr., White, M.V (1997) Complex bubble persistence in closed-end country funds Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 32(1), 19-37 Ahmed, E., Li, H., Rosser, J.B., Jr (2006) Nonlinear bubbles in Chinese stock markets in the 1990s Eastern Economic Journal, 40(1), 1-18 Ahmed, E., Rosser, J.B., Jr., Uppal, J.Y (2010) Emerging markets and stock market bubbles: Nonlinear speculation? Emerging Markets, Finance, and Trade, forthcoming Baumol, W.J (1957) Speculation, profitability, and instability Review of Economics and Statistics, 34(3), 263-271 Black, F (1986) Noise Journal of Finance, 41(3), 529-542 Blanchard, O., Watson, M.W (1982) Bubbles, rational expectations, and financial markets In: P Wachtel (Ed.), Crises in the economic and financial structure Lexington: Lexington Books Bouchaud, J.-P., Potters, M (2003) Theory of financial risk and derivative pricing Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Brock, W.A., Davis, W.D., Scheinkman, J.A., LeBaron, B (1997) A test for independence based on the correlation dimension Econometric Reviews, 15(3), 197-235 Brock, W.A., Hsieh, D., LeBaron, B (1991) Nonlinear dynamics, chaos, and instability: statistical theory and economic evidence Cambridge: MIT Press Canova, F., Ito, T (1991) The time series properties in the risk premium of the yen/dollar exchange rate Journal of Applied Econometrics, 22(2), 213-223 Chiarella, C., Gallegati, M., Leombrini, R., Palestrini, A (2003) Asset price dynamics among heterogeneous agents Computational Economics, 22(2), 213-223 Davidson, P (1994) Post Keynesian macroeconomic theory: a foundation for successful economic policies for the twenty-first century Aldershot: Edward Elgar DeLong, J.B., Shleifer, A., Summers, L.H., Waldmann, R (1991) The survival of noise traders in financial markets Journal of Business, 64(1), 1-19 Elwood, S.K., Ahmed, E., Rosser, J.B., Jr (1999) State-space estimation of rational bubbles in the yen/deutschemark exchange rate Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 135(2), 317-331 20 Engel, R., Hamilton, J.D (1990) Long swings in the dollar: are they in the data and markets know it? American Economic Review, 80(4), 689-713 Engle, R.F (1982) Autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity with estimation of the variance of United Kingdom inflation Econometrica, 55( 2), 251-276 Feller, W (1951) The asymptotic distribution of the range of sums of independent random variables Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 22(3), 427-432 Föllmer, H., Horst, U., Kirman, A (2005) Equilibria in financial markets with heterogeneous agents: a probabilistic approach Journal of Mathematical Economics, 41(1-2), 123-155 Flood, R.P., Garber, P.M (1980) Market fundamentals versus price level bubbles: the first tests Journal of Political Economy, 88(4), 745-776 Hamilton, J.D (1989) A new approach to the economic analysis of nonstationary time series and the business cycle Econometrica, 57(2), 357-384 Hurst, H.E (1951) Long term storage capacity of reservoirs Transactions of the American Society of Civil Engineers, 116(2447), 770-799 Khajawa, A., Mian, A (2005) Unchecked intermediaries: price manipulation in an emerging stock market Journal of Financial Economics, 78(1), 203-241 Kindleberger, C.P (1978) Manias, panics, and crashes: a history of financial crisis New York: Basic Books (4th edin 2000, New York: Wiley) Lo, A.W (1991) Long memory in stock prices Econometrica, 59(5), 1279-1313 Mandelbrot, B.B (1972) Statistical methodology for nonperiodic cycles: from covariance to r/s analysis Annals of Economic and Social Measurement, 1(3), 259-290 Minsky, H.P (1972) Financial instability revisited: the economics of disaster Reappraisal of the Federal Reserve Discount Mechanism, 3(1), 97-136 Norden, S van, Schaller, H (1993) The predictability of stock market regime: evidence from the Toronto stock exchange Review of Economics and Statistics, 75(3), 505-510 Shiller, R.J (2005) Irrational exuberance, 2nd edn Princeton: Princeton University Press Sornette, D., Zhou, W.-X (2005) Predictability of large future changes in market financial indices International Journal of Forecasting, 22(1), 154-168 Tirole, J (1982) On the possibility of speculation under rational expectations Econometrica, 50(5), 1163-1181 21 Tirole, J (1985) Asset bubbles and overlapping generations Econometrica, 53(6), 1499-1528 Zeeman, E.C (1974) On the unstable behavior of the stock exchange Journal of Mathematical Economics, 1(1), 39-44 22 Table 1: Karachi Stock Exchange Summary Statistics Year No of listed Companies Market Capitalization (mil US $) Market Capitalization as percentage of GDP Trading Value (mil US $) Turnover ratio (%) P/E Ratio* Price to Book Value* Dividend yield (%)* % Change in KSE100 index (over previous 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005 440 653 781 747 661 2,457 11,602 10,966 4,944 45,937 6.5% 23.9% 17.4% 6.9% 42.0% 231 1,844 11,476 12,455 140,996 8.0% 18.7% 103.7% 226.8% 375.7% 8.0 27.6 14.8 7.5 13.1 1.3 4.2 2.3 0.9 3.5 8.3% 1.5% 3.2% 12.5% 2.5% 680.5% -19.0% -27.4% 650.6% period) Share of emerging market capitalization S&P/IFCG Composite Index correlation, over 0.33% - 0.73% - 0.51% 0.26 0.19% - 1990-95 & 2000-2005 periods Gross Domestic Product (mil US $) 37,977 48,590 63,020 71,496 109,502 0.65% 0.32 Source: Global Stock Markets Factbook 2006, Standard and Poor’s Note: * based on S&P IFC Global Index Table 2: Pakistan: Market Returns February 1992-July 2008 23 RETURNS 10 08 06 04 02 00 -.02 -.04 -.06 3900 3950 4000 4050 4100 Table 3a 24 4150 4200 4250 Wald Test Results on Residuals from Four Variable VAR Model of Pakistani Stock Returns, Exchange Rate, Pakistan LBOR, and World Stock Index Sample Period Sample Period February 18, 1992-July 15, 2008 H0: P1=1-P2χ(1) 2410.07 Critical Value χ2(1)=3.84 Table 3b Wald Test Results on Residuals from Four Variable VAR Model of Pakistani Stocke Returns, Exchange Rate, PakistanREP6M and World Stock Index Sample Period Sample Period February 18, 1992-July 15, 2008 Critical Value χ2(1)=3.84 Table 4a 25 H0: P1=1-P2χ2(1) 2474.15 Hurst Coefficients and Related Chow Tests Hurst Coefficients and Chow test Results on Residuals from Four-Variable VAR Model of Pakistani Stock Returns, Exchange Rate Pakistan LIBOR and World Stock Index Pre Period: February 1992-September 2001 During: October 2001-December 2006 After: January 2007-July 2008 Hurst Coefficient=0.365 Chow Test For Slope and Intercept: Critical Value of F=4.6 Computed Value of F= 54.33 We reject the null hypothesis that pre and post bubble periods are the same Chow Test for Slope Alone: Critical Value of F= 6.63 Computed Value of F=36.84 We reject the null hypothesis that pre and post bubble periods are the same Table 4b Hurst Coefficient and Related Chow tests Hurst Coefficients and Chow Test Results on Residuals from Four Variable VAR Model of Pakistani Stock Returns, Exchange Rate, PakRep6m and World Stock Index Pre Period: February 1992-September 2001 During: October 2001-December 2006 After: January 2007-July 2008 Table 5a 26 Hurst Coefficient= 0.405 Chow Test for Slope and Intercept Critical Value=4.6 Computed Value of F= 122.40 We reject the hypothesis that the pre and post bubble periods are the same Chow Test for Slope Alone: Critical Value of F= 6.63 Computed Value of F= 1391.4 We reject the hypothesis that pre and post bubble periods are the same BDS/SD Results Sample 1: No of Dimensions No of Observations 4272 4272 4272 BDS/SD Results 22.16 26.83 30.10 Table 5b Sample No of Dimensions No of Observations BDS/SD Results 3000 18.92 3000 23.26 3000 26.76 Critical Value (for sample >1000, with m2) is approximately 4.70-6.92 27 i Manipulative behavior on the KSE is documented in Khwaja and Mian (2005) There are certain assets where it may be possible to come close to identifying a fundamental An example of such is closed-end funds whose net asset values are reasonable estimates of fundamentals, assuming those assets can be readily bought and sold, although there may be some deviations due to management fees or tax effects See Ahmed, Koppl, Rosser, and White (1997) for a study of bubbles in closed-end country funds iii The method of studying residuals of a VAR-estimated fundamental was initiated by Canova and Ito (1991) iv Lo (1991) has criticized the use of the classical Hurst coefficient for studying long-term persistence in stock markets precisely because of this presence of short-term dependence for which he proposes a method for avoiding However, this is not a problem for us because it is precisely short-term dependence that we are interested in detecting ii ... below We examine daily returns behavior in Pakistani stock returns over periods of about 16 years We use daily values of the market’s major index, and compute stock index ? ?returns? ?? as the first... International, is considered a stock market index of 'world' stocks and includes a collection of stocks of all the 23 developed markets in the world, as 13 defined by MSCI The data on the stock market indices,... Wald Test Results on Residuals from Four Variable VAR Model of Pakistani Stock Returns, Exchange Rate, Pakistan LBOR, and World Stock Index Sample Period Sample Period February 18, 1992-July
Ngày đăng: 20/10/2022, 21:13
Xem thêm:
![Pakistani Stock Returns Paper (4) updated 3-16-10[1]](data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg width='210' height='280' viewBox='0 0 210 280' fill='none' xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%3E%3Crect width='210' height='280' fill='%23F6F6F6'/%3E%3Cpath d='M129.893 116.272C129.728 118.805 129.189 121.233 128.65 123.708L128.147 126.046C127.732 127.981 127.315 129.916 126.896 131.85C126.541 133.489 126.188 135.129 125.837 136.77L125.339 139.067L125.037 140.482L124.895 141.122C124.633 142.361 124.459 143.528 124.578 144.801C125.38 145.45 125.38 145.45 126.361 145.342C127.606 145.02 127.983 144.691 128.772 143.681C129.026 142.824 129.107 141.964 129.192 141.077C129.853 135.799 131.445 130.905 135.766 127.46C138.635 125.703 141.484 124.998 144.842 125.63C146.606 126.203 147.409 127.333 148.281 128.893C148.841 130.298 148.839 131.84 148.91 133.334C151.082 133.07 151.082 133.07 152.846 131.894C153.163 131.412 153.472 130.925 153.771 130.432C155.296 127.958 157.631 126.509 160.359 125.602C162.635 125.209 165.039 125.239 167.09 126.342C168.532 127.859 168.607 128.988 168.58 131.034C168.495 131.868 168.42 132.324 167.945 133.003C166.798 133.823 165.938 133.775 164.571 133.615C164.273 133.108 164.273 133.108 164.012 132.496L164.292 131.656C164.317 131.231 164.329 130.806 164.327 130.38L164.329 129.715C164.328 129.121 164.328 129.121 164.013 128.579C163.159 128.579 162.554 128.658 161.908 129.248C159.057 132.838 157.441 138 157.579 142.565C157.708 143.511 157.884 144.282 158.419 145.081C159.595 145.755 160.455 145.689 161.723 145.362C163.268 144.838 164.612 144.017 165.969 143.123C165.805 145.431 165.233 147.069 163.505 148.665C161.394 150.369 159.15 150.855 156.477 150.596C154.08 150.207 152.638 149.493 151.01 147.69C150.016 146.163 149.918 144.488 149.923 142.722L149.921 142.067C149.962 139.806 150.489 137.724 151.146 135.572L148.629 135.852L148.617 136.439C148.388 141.143 146.579 145.142 143.185 148.4C140.79 150.422 138.194 150.585 135.19 150.443C133.154 150.269 131.902 149.439 130.556 147.949C130.234 147.557 129.919 147.159 129.609 146.757L129.208 147.207C127.545 148.984 126.215 149.995 123.749 150.208C123.348 150.221 122.948 150.231 122.547 150.236L121.966 150.245C120.737 150.223 119.96 150.016 118.981 149.274C118.353 148.557 117.832 147.828 117.304 147.036L116.902 147.485C115.108 149.401 113.318 150.491 110.663 150.681C108.808 150.652 107.273 150.198 105.835 148.994C104.249 147.182 103.714 144.481 103.816 142.11C104.315 136.665 106.022 131.329 110.221 127.599C112.158 126.09 114.108 125.707 116.534 125.675L117.115 125.663C118.334 125.675 119.139 125.854 120.1 126.619V127.179H120.659L120.69 126.702C120.86 124.607 121.304 122.612 121.795 120.571L122.033 119.558C122.226 118.742 122.42 117.926 122.617 117.111C123.618 116.969 124.622 116.83 125.622 116.691L126.484 116.57L127.315 116.454L128.079 116.348C128.771 116.27 128.771 116.27 129.889 116.27L129.893 116.272ZM115.413 130.144C112.498 133.242 111.426 137.725 111.345 141.882L111.313 142.967C111.45 144.119 111.727 144.56 112.551 145.362C113.35 145.712 113.35 145.712 114.228 145.642C115.956 144.744 116.947 143.539 117.585 141.726C117.796 140.907 117.974 140.081 118.148 139.253L118.3 138.534L118.613 137.036C118.771 136.272 118.937 135.512 119.102 134.749L119.405 133.291L119.557 132.604C119.804 131.381 119.95 130.533 119.261 129.42C117.781 128.432 116.668 129.01 115.41 130.145L115.413 130.144ZM141.081 129.418C137.769 132.855 136.479 138.551 136.484 143.197C136.628 144.097 136.908 144.628 137.445 145.361C138.228 146.002 138.228 146.002 139.087 145.884C140.448 145.503 141.261 144.784 141.957 143.571C142.147 143.202 142.333 142.831 142.514 142.458L142.808 141.866C143.688 140.009 144.132 138.163 144.438 136.128L143.598 135.569C143.262 134.559 143.227 133.831 143.318 132.771C143.685 132.3 144.058 131.834 144.437 131.372C144.575 130.216 144.534 129.837 143.877 128.855C142.661 128.395 142.075 128.614 141.08 129.415L141.081 129.418Z' fill='%2300A888'/%3E%3Cpath d='M101.447 115.574C103.021 116.808 103.953 118.259 104.257 120.249C104.379 122.565 103.628 124.842 102.153 126.632C100.984 127.889 99.7154 129.025 98.2868 129.977L98.8996 130.318C101.171 131.654 102.416 132.952 103.426 135.379C104.01 138.822 103.458 141.736 101.583 144.677C99.5999 147.39 96.9413 149.472 93.6385 150.265C90.0743 150.758 86.1543 150.896 83.0943 148.787C81.4025 147.398 80.3856 145.894 80.1055 143.682C79.9043 141.287 80.0851 138.82 81.5918 136.846C83.315 135.204 84.9371 135.132 87.2307 135.169C88.565 135.335 89.0531 135.67 89.8952 136.69C89.8952 137.337 89.8952 137.337 89.615 138.089C89.138 138.309 89.138 138.309 88.5489 138.49C87.6627 138.781 87.375 138.93 86.6959 139.626C85.7834 141.672 85.8055 143.599 86.5159 145.701C86.9098 146.348 87.2281 146.506 87.9377 146.758C89.8315 147.035 91.4112 146.756 92.9722 145.639C94.8761 143.822 95.5535 141.669 95.629 139.067C95.5442 136.349 94.8159 134.411 92.9544 132.425C92.103 131.655 91.1718 131.095 90.1744 130.536L89.3349 129.976L90.1422 129.588L91.2049 129.068L91.7346 128.814C94.3405 127.531 96.1511 125.553 97.1468 122.794C97.5568 121.345 97.6289 120.161 97.1289 118.72C96.4804 117.768 96.0102 117.487 94.9262 117.111C93.7115 116.959 93.1292 117.027 92.041 117.6C90.9842 118.485 90.7712 118.908 90.6421 120.275C90.7754 121.849 91.2507 123.027 92.4069 124.103C90.9307 125.287 89.7118 125.733 87.8079 125.638C86.6297 125.415 86.19 125.02 85.4133 124.103C84.7122 122.67 84.6128 121.135 85.0033 119.596C85.8734 117.071 87.577 115.743 89.9181 114.579C93.4348 113.259 98.3046 113.513 101.438 115.573L101.447 115.574ZM75.9309 115.503C77.3706 116.559 78.0556 117.903 78.4308 119.629C78.8611 123.922 77.7899 127.561 75.0846 130.944C72.7461 133.631 70.0765 135.916 67.2694 138.09C65.132 139.749 63.116 141.383 61.6501 143.683L62.1433 143.664C63.4836 143.635 64.7186 143.709 66.0369 143.964C68.979 144.486 72.1646 144.778 74.7952 143.124C75.3553 142.638 75.8811 142.113 76.3689 141.555L76.7518 141.166H77.3111C77.4554 147.709 77.4554 147.709 75.6338 149.837C74.1679 150.787 72.8683 150.826 71.1766 150.814H70.3694C68.0215 150.766 65.8145 150.348 63.5422 149.775C61.3768 149.23 59.6248 148.966 57.4891 149.836C56.0945 150.395 56.0945 150.395 55.496 150.395C55.2422 145.569 56.8228 142.369 59.9635 138.806C61.1403 137.505 62.3617 136.245 63.6253 135.029C67.8254 130.863 70.9542 126.042 70.9907 120.025C70.8727 119.01 70.6444 118.483 70.04 117.67C69.0825 116.952 68.1259 117.009 66.9638 117.111C65.8926 117.587 65.4435 117.994 65.0055 119.069C64.7849 120.648 64.9614 121.906 65.8451 123.265L66.4044 123.545C66.1387 124.246 65.8629 124.648 65.3035 125.153C63.9954 125.688 62.7612 125.723 61.37 125.502C60.2673 124.953 59.59 124.118 59.1316 122.985C58.8515 120.917 59.1537 119.167 60.2504 117.392C63.7883 113.069 71.3625 112.736 75.9309 115.505V115.503ZM56.0537 114.034C55.8695 116.011 55.5206 117.916 55.1047 119.858L54.8984 120.832L54.2253 123.997L53.7585 126.202L52.7806 130.811L51.6491 136.141C51.2867 137.853 50.9237 139.565 50.56 141.276L50.0974 143.46L49.4506 146.502L49.2562 147.418L49.078 148.25L48.9235 148.976C48.7817 149.556 48.7817 149.556 48.5033 150.115H41.2305C42.3679 144.046 43.6378 138.009 44.9289 131.972L45.7607 128.066L47.3828 120.467L42.9078 120.187L43.4672 117.67L44.3898 117.587C48.2062 117.212 51.3121 116.202 54.7015 114.423C55.4943 114.034 55.4943 114.034 56.0537 114.034Z' fill='%23FF6D18'/%3E%3Cpath d='M47.8535 168.108C47.1215 168.108 46.5815 167.916 46.2335 167.532C45.8975 167.136 45.7295 166.65 45.7295 166.074C45.7295 165.822 45.7595 165.54 45.8195 165.228C45.8795 164.904 45.9395 164.592 45.9995 164.292C46.0715 163.992 46.1195 163.8 46.1435 163.716C46.2395 163.296 46.3295 162.882 46.4135 162.474C46.4975 162.066 46.5395 161.736 46.5395 161.484C46.5395 160.872 46.3235 160.566 45.8915 160.566C45.5795 160.566 45.3035 160.722 45.0635 161.034C44.8235 161.334 44.6315 161.73 44.4875 162.222L43.2635 168H40.6715L42.5795 159H45.1715L44.9735 159.936C45.5735 159.264 46.2755 158.928 47.0795 158.928C47.6915 158.928 48.1775 159.096 48.5375 159.432C48.8975 159.768 49.0775 160.278 49.0775 160.962C49.0775 161.31 49.0355 161.7 48.9515 162.132C48.8675 162.552 48.7475 163.068 48.5915 163.68C48.4955 164.052 48.4055 164.418 48.3215 164.778C48.2495 165.126 48.2135 165.402 48.2135 165.606C48.2135 165.846 48.2675 166.032 48.3755 166.164C48.4835 166.296 48.6695 166.362 48.9335 166.362C49.2935 166.362 49.5815 166.236 49.7975 165.984C50.0135 165.72 50.2295 165.318 50.4455 164.778H51.2015C50.7575 166.098 50.2415 166.986 49.6535 167.442C49.0775 167.886 48.4775 168.108 47.8535 168.108ZM53.0714 168.072C52.1834 168.072 51.4814 167.844 50.9654 167.388C50.4494 166.932 50.1914 166.212 50.1914 165.228C50.1914 164.4 50.3534 163.494 50.6774 162.51C51.0014 161.514 51.5294 160.656 52.2614 159.936C52.9934 159.204 53.9294 158.838 55.0694 158.838C56.4854 158.838 57.2474 159.648 57.3554 161.268C57.6194 161.208 57.8534 161.064 58.0574 160.836C58.2614 160.596 58.4534 160.326 58.6334 160.026H59.2094C58.8854 160.674 58.5974 161.184 58.3454 161.556C58.0934 161.916 57.7634 162.21 57.3554 162.438C57.2834 163.566 57.0494 164.556 56.6534 165.408C56.2694 166.26 55.7654 166.92 55.1414 167.388C54.5174 167.844 53.8274 168.072 53.0714 168.072ZM53.7914 166.452C54.2354 166.452 54.6494 166.092 55.0334 165.372C55.4174 164.652 55.6814 163.764 55.8254 162.708C55.5374 162.6 55.3934 162.33 55.3934 161.898C55.3934 161.43 55.5614 161.118 55.8974 160.962C55.8734 160.578 55.8074 160.314 55.6994 160.17C55.6034 160.014 55.4414 159.936 55.2134 159.936C54.8174 159.936 54.4394 160.224 54.0794 160.8C53.7194 161.364 53.4254 162.054 53.1974 162.87C52.9814 163.674 52.8734 164.382 52.8734 164.994C52.8734 165.57 52.9394 165.96 53.0714 166.164C53.2034 166.356 53.4434 166.452 53.7914 166.452ZM66.1232 158.028C65.7272 158.028 65.3912 157.89 65.1152 157.614C64.8392 157.338 64.7012 157.002 64.7012 156.606C64.7012 156.21 64.8392 155.874 65.1152 155.598C65.3912 155.31 65.7272 155.166 66.1232 155.166C66.5192 155.166 66.8552 155.31 67.1312 155.598C67.4192 155.874 67.5632 156.21 67.5632 156.606C67.5632 157.002 67.4192 157.338 67.1312 157.614C66.8552 157.89 66.5192 158.028 66.1232 158.028ZM64.8992 168.108C64.3232 168.108 63.8552 167.928 63.4952 167.568C63.1472 167.208 62.9732 166.668 62.9732 165.948C62.9732 165.648 63.0212 165.258 63.1172 164.778L64.3412 159H66.9332L65.6372 165.12C65.5892 165.3 65.5652 165.492 65.5652 165.696C65.5652 165.936 65.6192 166.11 65.7272 166.218C65.8472 166.314 66.0392 166.362 66.3032 166.362C66.6512 166.362 66.9752 166.218 67.2752 165.93C67.5752 165.63 67.7912 165.246 67.9232 164.778H68.6792C68.2352 166.074 67.6652 166.956 66.9692 167.424C66.2732 167.88 65.5832 168.108 64.8992 168.108ZM78.86 168.108C78.128 168.108 77.588 167.916 77.24 167.532C76.904 167.136 76.736 166.65 76.736 166.074C76.736 165.822 76.766 165.54 76.826 165.228C76.886 164.904 76.946 164.592 77.006 164.292C77.078 163.992 77.126 163.8 77.15 163.716C77.246 163.296 77.336 162.882 77.42 162.474C77.504 162.066 77.546 161.736 77.546 161.484C77.546 160.872 77.33 160.566 76.898 160.566C76.586 160.566 76.31 160.722 76.07 161.034C75.83 161.334 75.638 161.73 75.494 162.222L74.27 168H71.678L72.992 161.79C73.028 161.646 73.046 161.496 73.046 161.34C73.046 160.812 72.866 160.548 72.506 160.548C72.17 160.548 71.876 160.704 71.624 161.016C71.384 161.316 71.192 161.718 71.048 162.222L69.824 168H67.232L69.14 159H71.732L71.534 159.936C72.146 159.252 72.878 158.91 73.73 158.91C74.786 158.91 75.404 159.426 75.584 160.458C76.244 159.438 77.078 158.928 78.086 158.928C78.698 158.928 79.184 159.096 79.544 159.432C79.904 159.768 80.084 160.278 80.084 160.962C80.084 161.31 80.042 161.7 79.958 162.132C79.874 162.552 79.754 163.068 79.598 163.68C79.502 164.052 79.412 164.418 79.328 164.778C79.256 165.126 79.22 165.402 79.22 165.606C79.22 165.846 79.274 166.032 79.382 166.164C79.49 166.296 79.676 166.362 79.94 166.362C80.3 166.362 80.588 166.236 80.804 165.984C81.02 165.72 81.236 165.318 81.452 164.778H82.208C81.764 166.098 81.248 166.986 80.66 167.442C80.084 167.886 79.484 168.108 78.86 168.108ZM83.6112 168.108C82.9272 168.108 82.3572 167.874 81.9012 167.406C81.4452 166.938 81.2172 166.206 81.2172 165.21C81.2172 164.322 81.3912 163.392 81.7392 162.42C82.0992 161.436 82.6272 160.608 83.3232 159.936C84.0312 159.252 84.8712 158.91 85.8432 158.91C86.3352 158.91 86.7012 158.994 86.9412 159.162C87.1812 159.33 87.3012 159.552 87.3012 159.828V159.954L87.4992 159H90.0912L88.7952 165.12C88.7472 165.3 88.7232 165.492 88.7232 165.696C88.7232 166.212 88.9692 166.47 89.4612 166.47C89.7972 166.47 90.0852 166.314 90.3252 166.002C90.5772 165.69 90.7752 165.282 90.9192 164.778H91.6752C91.2312 166.074 90.6792 166.956 90.0192 167.424C89.3712 167.88 88.7172 168.108 88.0572 168.108C87.5532 168.108 87.1452 167.97 86.8332 167.694C86.5332 167.406 86.3532 166.992 86.2932 166.452C85.9452 166.944 85.5552 167.346 85.1232 167.658C84.7032 167.958 84.1992 168.108 83.6112 168.108ZM84.7812 166.362C85.0812 166.362 85.3752 166.224 85.6632 165.948C85.9632 165.66 86.1672 165.27 86.2752 164.778L87.1392 160.71C87.1392 160.554 87.0792 160.404 86.9592 160.26C86.8392 160.104 86.6532 160.026 86.4012 160.026C85.9212 160.026 85.4892 160.308 85.1052 160.872C84.7212 161.424 84.4212 162.096 84.2052 162.888C83.9892 163.668 83.8812 164.358 83.8812 164.958C83.8812 165.558 83.9652 165.942 84.1332 166.11C84.3132 166.278 84.5292 166.362 84.7812 166.362ZM94.1118 172.5C93.5358 172.5 93.0558 172.35 92.6718 172.05C92.2878 171.75 92.0958 171.318 92.0958 170.754C92.0958 170.07 92.3718 169.518 92.9238 169.098C93.4758 168.69 94.1778 168.348 95.0298 168.072L95.2458 167.118C94.6338 167.778 93.9138 168.108 93.0858 168.108C92.4018 168.108 91.8318 167.874 91.3758 167.406C90.9198 166.938 90.6918 166.206 90.6918 165.21C90.6918 164.322 90.8658 163.392 91.2138 162.42C91.5738 161.436 92.1018 160.608 92.7978 159.936C93.5058 159.252 94.3458 158.91 95.3178 158.91C95.8098 158.91 96.1758 158.994 96.4158 159.162C96.6558 159.33 96.7758 159.552 96.7758 159.828V159.936L96.9738 159H99.5658L97.7838 167.352C98.3598 167.16 98.8218 166.872 99.1698 166.488C99.5178 166.104 99.8118 165.534 100.052 164.778H100.808C100.484 165.846 100.046 166.632 99.4938 167.136C98.9418 167.628 98.3178 167.964 97.6218 168.144L97.3518 169.44C97.1118 170.604 96.6978 171.402 96.1098 171.834C95.5218 172.278 94.8558 172.5 94.1118 172.5ZM94.2558 166.362C94.5318 166.362 94.8138 166.236 95.1018 165.984C95.3898 165.732 95.5878 165.39 95.6958 164.958L96.6138 160.692C96.6138 160.548 96.5538 160.404 96.4338 160.26C96.3138 160.104 96.1278 160.026 95.8758 160.026C95.3958 160.026 94.9638 160.308 94.5798 160.872C94.1958 161.424 93.8958 162.096 93.6798 162.888C93.4638 163.668 93.3558 164.358 93.3558 164.958C93.3558 165.558 93.4398 165.942 93.6078 166.11C93.7878 166.278 94.0038 166.362 94.2558 166.362ZM93.6978 171.096C93.9018 171.096 94.0998 170.958 94.2918 170.682C94.4838 170.406 94.6338 170.01 94.7418 169.494L94.8498 168.972C93.6738 169.404 93.0858 169.914 93.0858 170.502C93.0858 170.658 93.1398 170.796 93.2478 170.916C93.3558 171.036 93.5058 171.096 93.6978 171.096ZM102.587 168.108C101.711 168.108 101.027 167.88 100.535 167.424C100.043 166.956 99.7968 166.23 99.7968 165.246C99.7968 164.418 99.9588 163.506 100.283 162.51C100.607 161.514 101.135 160.656 101.867 159.936C102.599 159.204 103.529 158.838 104.657 158.838C105.977 158.838 106.637 159.414 106.637 160.566C106.637 161.238 106.445 161.856 106.061 162.42C105.677 162.984 105.167 163.44 104.531 163.788C103.895 164.124 103.217 164.316 102.497 164.364C102.473 164.628 102.461 164.808 102.461 164.904C102.461 165.9 102.833 166.398 103.577 166.398C103.913 166.398 104.273 166.308 104.657 166.128C105.041 165.948 105.389 165.72 105.701 165.444C105.377 167.22 104.339 168.108 102.587 168.108ZM102.623 163.5C103.079 163.488 103.505 163.338 103.901 163.05C104.309 162.762 104.633 162.396 104.873 161.952C105.125 161.496 105.251 161.022 105.251 160.53C105.251 160.038 105.101 159.792 104.801 159.792C104.381 159.792 103.961 160.176 103.541 160.944C103.133 161.7 102.827 162.552 102.623 163.5ZM112.703 168.108C112.019 168.108 111.449 167.874 110.993 167.406C110.537 166.938 110.309 166.206 110.309 165.21C110.309 164.322 110.483 163.392 110.831 162.42C111.191 161.436 111.719 160.608 112.415 159.936C113.123 159.252 113.963 158.91 114.935 158.91C115.427 158.91 115.793 158.994 116.033 159.162C116.273 159.33 116.393 159.552 116.393 159.828V159.9L117.275 155.76L119.939 155.4L117.869 165.12C117.821 165.3 117.797 165.492 117.797 165.696C117.797 165.936 117.851 166.11 117.959 166.218C118.079 166.314 118.271 166.362 118.535 166.362C118.871 166.362 119.159 166.218 119.399 165.93C119.651 165.642 119.849 165.258 119.993 164.778H120.749C120.017 166.926 118.811 168 117.131 168C116.639 168 116.237 167.868 115.925 167.604C115.625 167.34 115.439 166.956 115.367 166.452C115.055 166.932 114.677 167.328 114.233 167.64C113.801 167.952 113.291 168.108 112.703 168.108ZM113.873 166.362C114.161 166.362 114.449 166.23 114.737 165.966C115.037 165.702 115.241 165.336 115.349 164.868V164.778L116.231 160.656C116.123 160.236 115.877 160.026 115.493 160.026C115.013 160.026 114.581 160.308 114.197 160.872C113.813 161.424 113.513 162.096 113.297 162.888C113.081 163.668 112.973 164.358 112.973 164.958C112.973 165.558 113.057 165.942 113.225 166.11C113.405 166.278 113.621 166.362 113.873 166.362ZM123.006 158.028C122.61 158.028 122.274 157.89 121.998 157.614C121.722 157.338 121.584 157.002 121.584 156.606C121.584 156.21 121.722 155.874 121.998 155.598C122.274 155.31 122.61 155.166 123.006 155.166C123.402 155.166 123.738 155.31 124.014 155.598C124.302 155.874 124.446 156.21 124.446 156.606C124.446 157.002 124.302 157.338 124.014 157.614C123.738 157.89 123.402 158.028 123.006 158.028ZM121.782 168.108C121.206 168.108 120.738 167.928 120.378 167.568C120.03 167.208 119.856 166.668 119.856 165.948C119.856 165.648 119.904 165.258 120 164.778L121.224 159H123.816L122.52 165.12C122.472 165.3 122.448 165.492 122.448 165.696C122.448 165.936 122.502 166.11 122.61 166.218C122.73 166.314 122.922 166.362 123.186 166.362C123.534 166.362 123.858 166.218 124.158 165.93C124.458 165.63 124.674 165.246 124.806 164.778H125.562C125.118 166.074 124.548 166.956 123.852 167.424C123.156 167.88 122.466 168.108 121.782 168.108ZM126.851 168.108C126.275 168.108 125.789 168 125.393 167.784C124.997 167.556 124.703 167.268 124.511 166.92C124.319 166.56 124.223 166.188 124.223 165.804C124.223 165.408 124.319 165.066 124.511 164.778C124.691 164.478 124.913 164.262 125.177 164.13C125.645 163.29 126.053 162.444 126.401 161.592C126.749 160.728 127.079 159.798 127.391 158.802L130.055 158.442C130.115 159.978 130.217 161.64 130.361 163.428C130.421 164.148 130.451 164.67 130.451 164.994C130.451 165.27 130.427 165.498 130.379 165.678C130.943 165.354 131.375 165.054 131.675 164.778H132.431C131.663 165.666 130.745 166.416 129.677 167.028C129.329 167.4 128.897 167.676 128.381 167.856C127.877 168.024 127.367 168.108 126.851 168.108ZM126.275 166.686C126.719 166.686 127.091 166.554 127.391 166.29C127.691 166.026 127.841 165.6 127.841 165.012C127.841 164.652 127.805 164.148 127.733 163.5C127.613 162.132 127.535 161.214 127.499 160.746C127.211 161.694 126.725 162.828 126.041 164.148C126.317 164.292 126.455 164.502 126.455 164.778C126.455 165.006 126.377 165.21 126.221 165.39C126.077 165.57 125.891 165.66 125.663 165.66C125.411 165.66 125.249 165.582 125.177 165.426C125.177 165.858 125.261 166.176 125.429 166.38C125.609 166.584 125.891 166.686 126.275 166.686ZM133.04 158.334H135.632L135.344 159.684C135.944 159.168 136.646 158.91 137.45 158.91C138.122 158.91 138.656 159.132 139.052 159.576C139.448 160.02 139.646 160.746 139.646 161.754C139.646 162.702 139.508 163.662 139.232 164.634C138.956 165.594 138.488 166.416 137.828 167.1C137.168 167.772 136.298 168.108 135.218 168.108C134.45 168.108 133.94 167.892 133.688 167.46L132.752 171.852L130.034 172.5L133.04 158.334ZM134.66 166.542C135.236 166.542 135.71 166.272 136.082 165.732C136.466 165.192 136.742 164.55 136.91 163.806C137.09 163.05 137.18 162.348 137.18 161.7C137.18 160.704 136.88 160.206 136.28 160.206C136.064 160.206 135.842 160.284 135.614 160.44C135.398 160.596 135.206 160.812 135.038 161.088L133.976 166.128C134.072 166.404 134.3 166.542 134.66 166.542ZM141.874 168.108C141.298 168.108 140.83 167.928 140.47 167.568C140.122 167.208 139.948 166.668 139.948 165.948C139.948 165.648 139.996 165.258 140.092 164.778L142.018 155.76L144.682 155.4L142.612 165.12C142.564 165.3 142.54 165.492 142.54 165.696C142.54 165.936 142.594 166.11 142.702 166.218C142.822 166.314 143.014 166.362 143.278 166.362C143.626 166.362 143.95 166.218 144.25 165.93C144.55 165.63 144.766 165.246 144.898 164.778H145.654C145.21 166.074 144.64 166.956 143.944 167.424C143.248 167.88 142.558 168.108 141.874 168.108ZM147.051 168.108C146.367 168.108 145.797 167.874 145.341 167.406C144.885 166.938 144.657 166.206 144.657 165.21C144.657 164.322 144.831 163.392 145.179 162.42C145.539 161.436 146.067 160.608 146.763 159.936C147.471 159.252 148.311 158.91 149.283 158.91C149.775 158.91 150.141 158.994 150.381 159.162C150.621 159.33 150.741 159.552 150.741 159.828V159.954L150.939 159H153.531L152.235 165.12C152.187 165.3 152.163 165.492 152.163 165.696C152.163 166.212 152.409 166.47 152.901 166.47C153.237 166.47 153.525 166.314 153.765 166.002C154.017 165.69 154.215 165.282 154.359 164.778H155.115C154.671 166.074 154.119 166.956 153.459 167.424C152.811 167.88 152.157 168.108 151.497 168.108C150.993 168.108 150.585 167.97 150.273 167.694C149.973 167.406 149.793 166.992 149.733 166.452C149.385 166.944 148.995 167.346 148.563 167.658C148.143 167.958 147.639 168.108 147.051 168.108ZM148.221 166.362C148.521 166.362 148.815 166.224 149.103 165.948C149.403 165.66 149.607 165.27 149.715 164.778L150.579 160.71C150.579 160.554 150.519 160.404 150.399 160.26C150.279 160.104 150.093 160.026 149.841 160.026C149.361 160.026 148.929 160.308 148.545 160.872C148.161 161.424 147.861 162.096 147.645 162.888C147.429 163.668 147.321 164.358 147.321 164.958C147.321 165.558 147.405 165.942 147.573 166.11C147.753 166.278 147.969 166.362 148.221 166.362ZM157.173 172.5C156.609 172.5 156.111 172.314 155.679 171.942C155.259 171.582 155.049 171.12 155.049 170.556C155.049 170.028 155.181 169.596 155.445 169.26C155.709 168.924 156.051 168.66 156.471 168.468C156.891 168.276 157.455 168.072 158.163 167.856L158.343 167.064C157.731 167.76 156.999 168.108 156.147 168.108C155.571 168.108 155.103 167.928 154.743 167.568C154.395 167.208 154.221 166.668 154.221 165.948C154.221 165.648 154.269 165.258 154.365 164.778L155.589 159H158.181L156.885 165.12C156.849 165.264 156.831 165.414 156.831 165.57C156.831 166.098 157.011 166.362 157.371 166.362C157.707 166.362 157.995 166.224 158.235 165.948C158.475 165.66 158.667 165.27 158.811 164.778L160.035 159H162.645L160.449 169.44C160.209 170.592 159.783 171.39 159.171 171.834C158.571 172.278 157.905 172.5 157.173 172.5ZM156.759 170.898C156.975 170.898 157.179 170.784 157.371 170.556C157.563 170.34 157.713 169.986 157.821 169.494L158.037 168.432C157.401 168.648 156.909 168.9 156.561 169.188C156.213 169.476 156.039 169.848 156.039 170.304C156.039 170.448 156.111 170.58 156.255 170.7C156.399 170.832 156.567 170.898 156.759 170.898Z' fill='%23AAAAAA'/%3E%3C/svg%3E%0A)