COATING INSPECTOR PROGRAM Level Student Manual January 2014 Version1.03 Important Notice: Neither the NACE International, its officers, directors, nor members thereof accept any responsibility for the use of the methods and materials discussed herein No authorization is implied concerning the use of patented or copyrighted material The information is advisory only and the use of the materials and methods is solely at the risk of the user Printed in the United States All rights reserved Reproduction of contents in whole or part or transfer into electronic or photographic storage without permission of copyright owner is expressly forbidden ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level Your CIP Level Instructors are: _ _ _ ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level Acknowledgements The time and expertise of a many members of NACE International have gone into the development of this course Their dedication and efforts are greatly appreciated by the authors and by those who have assisted in making this work possible The scope, desired learning outcomes and performance criteria of this course were developed by the NACE Coating Inspector Program (CIP) Subcommittee under the auspices of the NACE Education Administrative Committee in cooperation with the NACE Certification Administrative Committee On behalf of NACE, we would like to thank the CIP subcommittee for its work Their efforts were extraordinary and their goal was in the best interest of public service — to develop and provide a much needed training program that would help improve corrosion control efforts industry-wide We also wish to thank their employers for being generously supportive of the substantial work and personal time that the members dedicated to this program ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level DAILY SCHEDULE DAY ONE Chapter Introduction Team Formation Lunch Chapter Advanced Corrosion Chapter Environmental Controls Chapter Advanced Environmental Testing Instrumentation Chapter Advanced Environmental Testing Instrumentation Practice Lab DAY TWO Chapter Centrifugal Blast Cleaning Chapter Waterjetting Chapter Interpersonal Relationship Dynamic in the Workplace Lunch Chapter Safety Awareness Chapter 10 Advanced Nondestructive Test Instruments Chapter 11 Advanced Nondestructive Test Instruments - Practice Lab DAY THREE Chapter 12 Linings and Special Coatings Chapter 13 Thick Barrier Linings Chapter 14 Advanced Standards and Resources Lunch Chapter 15 Coating Concrete and Inspection Chapter 16 Test Instruments for Coating Concrete Chapter 17 Test Instruments for Coating Concrete - Practice Lab ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level DAILY SCHEDULE DAY FOUR Chapter 18 Pipeline Mainline and Field Joint Coatings Chapter 19 Destructive Instruments and Tests Lunch Chapter 20 Destructive Instruments and Tests - Practice Lab Chapter 21 Surface Preparation, Coating and Inspection of Special Substrates Chapter 22 Maintenance Coating Operations DAY FIVE Chapter 23 Non Liquid Coatings Chapter 24 Coating Surveys Chapter 25 Specialized Tests and Test Equipment Chapter 26 Coating Types, Failure Modes, and Inspection Criteria Lunch Chapter 27 Peer Review Instrument Review DAY SIX Course Review Course Exam *Schedule may change based on individual instructor and or classroom pace ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level Policy on Use of Laptop Computers and Camera Phones NACE sends a CD-ROM of the student manual to each student when they register for a CIP course This will provide students the opportunity to review and (hopefully) study the manual prior to arriving at the class The CIP Committee made the decision to allow students to use laptops to follow along electronically versus working from their student manual and to also use their laptop to take notes of the class lecture However, the following guidelines must apply: Students are not allowed to be on the internet or connect with the outside world through their computer Students are not allowed to record any portion of the classroom/lab activities (including lectures) All laptops must be kept in “silent” mode so as not to disturb others in the class Laptops cannot be used while quizzes or exams are taking place Laptops cannot be used during the Peer Review In addition, with the use of more and more camera cell phones, students are forbidden to use their cell phone to take pictures while in the class Thank you, NACE CIP Committee ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level Code of Conduct Policy While on site at a NACE course, appropriate behavior towards instructors, NACE/ class location staff, and fellow students is required If appropriate behavior is not maintained, NACE has the authority to take proper action against the student(s) in violation, which could result in revocation of one or more of the following: NACE Certification, Membership, and current/future classroom attendance ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level Instructions for Completing the ParSCORETM Student Enrollment Score Sheet Use a Number (or dark lead) pencil Fill in all of the following information and the corresponding bubbles for each category: √ ID Number: √ PHONE: Student ID, NACE ID or Temporary ID provided Your phone number The last four digits of this number will be your password for accessing your grades on-line (For Privacy issues, you may choose a different fourdigit number in this space.) √ LAST NAME: Your last name (surname) √ FIRST NAME: Your first name (given name) √ M.I.: Middle initial (if applicable) √ TEST FORM: This is the version of the exam you are taking √ SUBJ SCORE: This is the version of the exam you are taking √ NAME: _ (fill in your entire name) √ SUBJECT: (fill in the type of exam you are taking, e.g., CIP Level 1) √ DATE: _ (date you are taking exam) The next section of the form (1–200) is for the answers to your exam questions TM x All answers MUST be bubbled in on the ParSCORE Score Sheet Answers recorded on the actual exam will NOT be counted TM x If changing an answer on the ParSCORE sheet, be sure to erase completely x Bubble only one answer per question and not fill in more answers than the exam contains ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level Instructions For Accessing Scores On-line It is NACE policy NOT to disclose student grades via the telephone, e-mail or fax Students will receive a grade letter in approximately 6–8 weeks after the completion of the course by US mail or through their company representative However, in most cases, within 7–10 business days of receipt of exams at NACE headquarters, the students may access their grades via the NACE website The following are step-by step instructions for this process Spaces are provided below for you to fill in the information required to access grades Please be sure to have this information filled in before leaving the course location Keep this form with you upon leaving the course You will NOT be able to access your grades without this information Go to the NACE website at www.nace.org Under the Training & Certification tab click on Access Scores Online Then follow the easy steps: Step 1: Find your Course Number in the drop-down list and click on it COURSE NUMBER: The number listed above is your course number You may also find it on your registration confirmation letter If your course number does NOT appear in the drop down list then grades have not yet been posted Step 2: Enter your Student ID number STUDENT ID: This is your 6-digit NACE ID number or membership number (example 123456) This is printed on the roster provided to the instructor as well on your registration confirmation For courses where no roster is provided, the instructor will assign a 10-digit temporary ID number used only for accessing scores on-line Step 3: Enter your Password PASSWORD: _ This should be the last four digits of the telephone number you completed on your ParSCORE exam form You may choose an alternate number but it must be in the last four spaces provided for the telephone number on the Scantron exam form Step 4: Click on SEARCH If you have trouble accessing your grade, please contact NACE International by e-mail at GradeQuestions@nace.org ©NACE International 2011 January 2014 Coating Inspector Program Level Coatings by Industry Summary Some problems of corrosion and methods of corrosion control are common to the water treatment and wastewater treatment systems In both systems, many surfaces are in continuous contact with water High performance coatings must be selected for steel and concrete surfaces and should be properly applied prior to the facilities being placed in service Chemicals used in water and wastewater facilities impact on coating performance, consequently long-term performance of protective coatings may best be obtained by: Proper selection of coatings Adequate surface preparation Proper coating application Inspection by a competent inspector Coating inspection can be a vital component of the coating operation In many cases, inspection is not required on new construction, and the inspector often finds himself inspecting rework or rehabilitation projects In either event, the inspector can provide the valuable service to the client to ensure that the coating specifications are properly enforced Once these facilities commence operation, the owners should establish a timely routine inspection and coating maintenance program in order to prolong the life of the coatings 120 Coatings by Industry CORROSION, COATINGS, AND COATING INSPECTION IN SPECIFIC INDUSTRIES INTRODUCTION MARINE TRANSPORTATION .3 CLASSIFICATION SOCIETIES DRY DOCKING INSPECTION REPORTS 12 REPORT FORMS 17 SCHEMATIC OF SHIP 23 SECTION 1: SHIP CONSTRUCTION .24 SECTION 2: GLOSSARY OF MARINE TECHNOLOGY 36 COMMON FOULING ORGANISMS .47 SECTION - SOFT BODIED ANIMALS .54 SECTION - PLANTS .60 BRIDGES AND FIXED STRUCTURES .64 SHOWN HERE IS AN INSPECTOR PERFORMING A DOLLY PULL-OFF ADHESION TEST ON A COATED SECTION OF A BRIDGE 71 PULP AND PAPER INDUSTRY 72 WOOD CHIPPING .75 PULP MANUFACTURING AREA 75 PULP BLEACH AREA 75 PRIMARY RECOVERY AREA .76 LIME RECOVERY AREA .76 BLOW DOWN AREA 76 PAPER MAKING AREA .76 POWER INDUSTRY .78 NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS 79 OIL- AND COAL-FIRED ELECTRIC POWER PLANTS .86 OIL-FIRED POWER PLANTS 86 COAL-FIRED POWER PLANTS .87 HYDROELECTRIC PLANTS 90 GEOTHERMAL PLANTS 91 CHEMICAL AND PETROCHEMICAL INDUSTRY .92 CHEMICAL INDUSTRY 93 Salt from Mines 93 Salt from Brine Wells 93 Salt from the Sea 93 PETROCHEMICAL INDUSTRY 98 THE FERTILIZER INDUSTRY 108 PHOSPHORIC ACID AND PHOSPHATES 108 AMMONIA FERTILIZERS 109 SULFURIC ACID .109 WATER AND WASTEWATER (SEWAGE) TREATMENT PLANTS 111 WATER SYSTEM-OVERVIEW 111 BASIC CORROSION CONCERNS 112 CORROSION CONTROL IN SYSTEM COMPONENTS .112 WATER STORAGE FACILITIES 113 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM 116 SEWAGE TREATMENT FACILITIES 116 SUMMARY .120 121 Coatings by Industry 122 Coating Types and Inspection Criteria The following tables are examples of problems that inspectors may encounter on projects using the various generic types of coatings It is the inspector's responsibility to become knowledgeable about the specified coatings Coating Types and Inspection Criteria Chlorinated Rubber and Vinyl Inspection Criteria What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? Dry spray, cob webbing, poor appearance Insufficient or wrong thinner Application at high ambient temperature What should the inspector do? Request proper thinner in correct amount Seek guidance from coating manufacturer or postpone coating application Film softens and/or disintegrates upon short term exposure Film applied to surfaces exposed to strong solvents Suggest owner use more solvent resistant coatings or eliminate exposure to solvents Film deteriorates when placed in service Application to surfaces exposed to temperatures above 175F (80C) Measure temperature and report Inspection Criteria of Coatings That Cure by Oxidative Polymerization What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What should the inspector do? Softened coating, with loss of adhesion at coating/substrate interface Application over alkaline surfaces such as, concrete, galvanizing, inorganic zinc Ensure coating applied to nonalkaline substrate, or use proper tie-coat Wrinkling, sagging, coating not cured, or cure very slow, spot rusting Material past shelf life, failure to mix in pigment Report use of old coating Slow drying, runs, sags, wrinkling, outer surface harder than body of coating Application in excessively thick coats Ensure application in thinner wet coats to allow proper cure before next coat Early failure, coating resin disintegrates, loss of adhesion Application to surfaces exposed to strong solvents, mineral acids, alkalis, water immersion, or high temperature Report; suggest client confine coatings to moderate exposure Application to solvent evaporation type primer Ensure use of proper primer or tie coat Peeling or alligatoring, and /or cracking, poor adhesion, poor longtime performance ©NACE International 2011 January 2013 Observe and ensure proper mixing Do not apply to high temperature surfaces Coating Inspector Program Level Coating Types and Inspection Criteria Inspection Criteria for Oil Modified Phenolic Coatings What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Lifting of the coating, peeling from substrate Recoat time too short Observe required recoat interval Allow coating to dry/cure properly before recoating Poor intercoat adhesion, delamination Recoat time too long Observe proper recoat time Apply overcoating before surface hardens too much Inspection Criteria for Coal Tar Epoxy What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Amine blush, an ambercolored, oily film bloom on surface Application and cure during cool, damp conditions Ensure application at proper temperature and humidity Ensure blush is removed before overcoating Delamination between coats Recoat interval exceeded Monitor recoat interval Scarify surface by sweep blast before overcoating Inspection Criteria for Zinc-Rich Epoxy What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Delamination of coating from substrate Application to inadequately cleaned surface and/or surface with inadequate anchor pattern Ensure surface preparation and surface/profile are as specified Loss of film properties (hardness), sagging, not providing galvanic protection when cured Failure to use agitated spray systems required to keep zinc uniformly dispersed in coating Monitor application and ensure agitator in constant use to keep zinc properly dispersed Uncoated peaks showing rust, rust bleed-through Application over unusually deep surface profile, or DFT less than recommended Ensure proper surface profile and adequate application May need to rework zinc application Rust bleed-through; mudcracking; some coating peeling Application thickness below or above that specified Ensure proper application thickness ©NACE International 2011 January 2013 Coating Inspector Program Level Coating Types and Inspection Criteria Inspection Criteria for Polyester/Vinyl Ester What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Material lumpy or gelled in container Material has exceeded shelf life or has been subjected to hot storage conditions Check shelf life of material and determine its usability Ensure proper material storage Applied coating has very brittle film High catalyst level shortens pot life, gives brittle film Applied coating has slow and/or poor cure Insufficient catalyst extends pot life, gives slow and poor cure In all cases shown, monitor mixing and application to ensure catalyst level is in accordance with the material requirements and the specification Material set up in pot, lines, and/or gun Excessive catalyst, curing too rapid, unable to apply before cure No cure response; film if formed will have poor integrity Catalyst is old, and past useful life Ensure catalyst material within stated useful shelf life Coating does not cure or has a poor cure Coating applied when substrate and ambient temperature too low Ensure that substrate and ambient temperatures are within the ranges required by the material manufacturer and the specification Generally, these materials can be applied as low as 60°F (15°C), but temperature must reach 70°F (21°C) within 24 hours after application for cure reactions to proceed properly Low cure response, and coating does not cure well into a hard film Application of film less than 10 mils (250 µm) Since polyesters need mass to cure properly and require a profile higher than for most coatings, inspector must ensure correct profile, and proper WFT applied to obtain correct DFT Coating does not cover peaks of profile; rusting visible Application of film less than actual profile Poor film build and inferior cure Use of incorrect thinner Ensure only correct thinner used Cure not proceeding Poor ventilation or air movement across coated surface Provide adequate ventilation or air movement to remove solvent atmosphere from wet coated surface ©NACE International 2011 January 2013 Coating Inspector Program Level Coating Types and Inspection Criteria Inspection Criteria for Moisture-Cured Urethane What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Coating gels in container; bubbles and pinholes are visible in coating film Aged coating exhibits excess thickness or has absorbed moisture before application Ensure coating is within useful shelf life and has not prematurely absorbed moisture Poor intercoat adhesion Over coating aged film without abrading surface Abrade or scarify surface before over coating Inspection Criteria for Two Component Polyurethanes What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Very short pot life; film cheesyfull of bubbles and pinholes; poor gloss Moisture in lines or equipment Monitor equipment to ensure no moisture enters application equipment Poor adhesion of fresh coat to aged coat Application to aged coat without proper surface preparation Prepare surface (usually by scarifying) for over coating Inspection Criteria for Vinyl (Polyvinyl/Butyral) Wash Primer What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Film dries, but no wash primer mechanism seems to occur Failure to add converter to base before application Ensure applicator adds the converter to base before application Poor spray characteristics— will not displace moisture on damp surface Material may agglomerate Incorrect or no thinner used Ensure correct thinner (if required) is used Cohesive failure Coating much thicker than the 0.5 mil (12.5 µm) maximum required Monitor application; ensure correct DFT of wash primer Material gels immediately; gelled coating cannot be applied to surface Catalyst added to base rapidly without stirring Observe mixing; ensure catalyst added slowly to base with proper agitation Delamination of topcoat from aged primer Wash primer exposed to atmosphere longer than recommended Ensure topcoat is applied within the required overcoat interval ©NACE International 2011 January 2013 Coating Inspector Program Level Coating Types and Inspection Criteria Inspection Criteria for Epoxy-Modified Phenolic Coatings What might the inspector see? Blistering ranging from very small, 10 to 15 mil (250 to 375 µm) to very large, 500 mil (12.5 mm) What is the probable cause? Cross-linking not completed; coating placed in service (immersion) before sufficient cure What can the inspector do? Observe curing; ensure coating cured before placing in service Inspection Criteria for Epoxy-Phenolic (Heat Converting) Systems What might the inspection see? Cross-linking reaction starts in container, increasing viscosity and stickiness Excessive thinner required for smooth film; severe pinholes during application What is the probable cause? Improper and/or lengthy storage The phenolic component is heat reactive, and may gel in to months even at ambient temperatures Inspect very carefully to ensure material has not begun to gel in the container Surface may not be clean and dry Observe surface preparation to ensure required cleanliness and surface profile are achieved Difficult to achieve required DFT Coating does not wet substrate, and crawls during set-up and/or final bake Coating has blisters, holidays Film cracks and delaminates Unable to attain holiday free film What can the inspector do? Inadequate surface profile Monitor storage, suggest storing under refrigeration until needed for application These materials require a profile sufficient to prevent disbonding during final bake Excessive film thickness Monitor application, and ensure coating applied to proper DFT Coating sags easily, with solvent left in film Blisters develop during final bake; film has holidays, and coating is peeled Improper set-up bake Observe/monitor set-up and final bake procedures to ensure they are proper and as specified Coating is light colored Insufficient final bake Coating is very dark colored, film looks chalky, has blisters and is cracking Final bake is excessive Carefully observe baking procedure and schedule to ensure they are as specified Blistering during set-up and/or final bake; some cracking of blisters Semi-circular cracking during final bake no apparent blisters Film has poor adhesion Blistering and bubbling ©NACE International 2011 January 2013 Inadequate drying time before baking, solvents not completely evaporated Allow adequate drying time before baking (flash time) Coating Inspector Program Level Coating Types and Inspection Criteria Inspection Criteria for Silicone Coatings What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Pop-ups in coating, film has poor integrity, and coating appears to be disintegrating Poor application resulting in a heavy uneven coat Ensure application is as required Blistering and bubbling in service Wrong heat (bake) schedule Ensure proper heat schedule is followed Aluminum pigment has dull, non-uniform, mottled appearance Over agitation or mechanical mixing Ensure mixing is done as required Inspection Criteria for Inorganic Zinc—Post-Cure Water-Soluble What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Coating does not cure or does not cure uniformly; coating still water-soluble, in streaks or totally Failure to apply curing agent (wash coat) or curing agent not applied uniformly Monitor application to ensure curing agent uniformly applied Non-uniform cure; mudcracking; coating flaking in heavy areas; rust-bleed in thin areas DFT above or below that specified Monitor application to ensure DFT is as specified Spot rusting, sagging, greater tendency to mud crack Failure to use all of zinc powder or powder not uniformly blended in vehicle Monitor mixing to ensure proper amount of zinc powder is added and properly blended Coating peeling, crawling, or fish eyeing Contaminants on surface Ensure surface cleanliness before coating Peeling or loss of adhesion of intermediate or finish coats Failure to remove curing agent before top coating Monitor application to ensure wash coat adequately removed Loss of film properties (hardness); sagging; some mud cracking Failure to use agitated spray containers Ensure agitation is used for mixing coatings throughout application Rain on applied primer before application of wash coat Coating softens; may completely wash off Try to ensure primer is not applied when rain appears imminent Coating softens; may wash off completely Rain on applied coating before application of wash coat Ensure coating applied under proper ambient conditions ©NACE International 2011 January 2013 Coating Inspector Program Level Coating Types and Inspection Criteria Inspection Criteria for Inorganic Zinc—Self-Cure, Water-Reducible What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Poor adhesion to surface; coating easily removed Surface not properly cleaned; contamination not totally removed Observe surface preparation; ensure contamination is removed Film will not cure; may become friable and/or powdery Application when humidity is below required level Ensure application only under required ambient conditions Coating blistering, bubbling; film is very porous, and has poor integrity Application to hot surfaces Ensure substrate temperature within application limits of specified coating Rust bleed-through, poor film integrity Topcoats may not adhere Not enough powder mixed or not mixed properly Ensure proper amount of powder and proper mixing Inspection Criteria for Inorganic Zinc—Self-Cure, Solvent Reducible What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Film not cured, is friable and powdery Application when relative humidity is low Ensure application when humidity level is adequate Poor film formation and poor adhesion Application over condensation on surface or under very warm, dry conditions Ensure no condensation and ambient conditions proper for application Product gels in pail, pressure pot, or lines Premature cure because moisture enters equipment before application Observe equipment; keep moisture out until material applied Film is powdery and dry Application in warm area with considerable air movement Apply when ambient conditions are proper ©NACE International 2011 January 2013 Coating Inspector Program Level Coating Types and Inspection Criteria Inspection Criteria for Waterborne Coatings What might the inspector see? What is the probable cause? What can the inspector do? Coating gelled or separated completely; suspension is destroyed Coating exposed to freezing temperatures Ensure gelled coating not used Ensure material is not allowed to freeze Coating sags or crawls; slow to dry; film not properly formed Application at low temperatures (below 50ºF [10ºC]) Ensure application at warmer temperatures (above 50ºF [10ºC]) Coating smells bad; may contain gel-like particles; coating skins over Liquid paint past shelf life; bacteria may have attacked antisag polymer Ensure material is well with the stated shelf life Do not allow paint past shelf life to be used Cracking, shrinkage Excessive thickness may cause shrinkage and cracking Ensure coating applied at recommended thickness Liquid coating gels or kicks out Addition of organic thinner such as xylol Allow only recommended thinners be used Coating streaking, running, or washing off substrate Exposure to moisture (dew, rain, spray, etc.) before fully cured Ensure coating not exposed to rain, spray, or dew ©NACE International 2011 January 2013 Coating Inspector Program Level NACE International Evaluation Survey NACE International takes the quality of instruction offered by its instructors seriously NACE has a policy that requires that all instructors and courses be evaluated by their students, and that the evaluations be considered by the NACE Instructor/Peer and Course Quality Committee The results of these evaluations are important to provide feedback to instructors on how their performance can be improved and to provide NACE with information to advance and revise its training programs Course Number: Course Date: / / (MM/DD/YYYY) I found the course to be generally interesting and informative Attending this course has improved my knowledge and understanding of the subject matter of this course I would recommend this course to others interested in improving their knowledge and understanding of the subject matter This course was what I expected from its description in NACE Literature Materials Evaluation I was completely satisfied with the COURSE MANUAL and REFERENCE MATERIALS (books, standards) used in this class I was completely satisfied with the GROUP EXERCISES used in this class I was completely satisfied with the DAILY QUIZZES used in this class I was completely satisfied with the SLIDES/VIDEOS used in this class I was completely satisfied with the CASE STUDIES used in this class I was completely satisfied with the CLASS DISCUSSION encountered in this class Did your employer sponsor your attendance at this course? Check “Yes” if self-employed Yes No Will you pursue additional training and/or certifications with NACE International? Yes No ~MORE OVER~ ONLY COURSE ORGANIZERS AT NACE HEADQUARTERS SEE COMPLETED EVALUATION FORMS 2005-01-1 Agree (5) (4) (3) (2) Disagree (1) Course Evaluation My Company or division can best be described as: (Please choose one of the following) Aerospace Original Equipment Manufacturer Bridges & Highways Oil & Gas Pipelines/Storage Tanks Chemical Processing/Process Industries Plastics/Nonmetals Coating & Lining Application Power Plant/Electric Utility Coating & Lining Mfg/Distributor Pulp & Paper Construction Railcar/Tank Trucks Engineering/Architecture/Consulting Firms Refining Industrial Water Treatment Research Services Measuring, Analyzing & Controlling Ships/Marine Structures/Offshore Platforms Metals/Mining Testing Services Municipal Water Distribution/Treatment Other What is your job function? (Please choose one of the following) Applicator Manager Chemist Owner/Pres/VP Consultant Planner Contractor Sales/Marketing Designer Scientist/Researcher Engineer Supervisor Foreman Technician/Technologist Inspector Other Comments: 2005-02-1 NACE International Instructor Evaluation Survey NACE International takes the quality of instruction offered by its instructors seriously NACE has a policy that requires that all instructors and courses be evaluated by their students, and that the evaluations be considered by the NACE Instructor/Peer and Course Quality Committee The results of these evaluations are important to provide feedback to instructors on how their performance can be improved and to provide NACE with information to advance and revise its training programs Course Number: Course Date: / (MM/DD/YYYY) Instructor Evaluation The instructor demonstrated a thorough understanding of the subject matter and showed enthusiasm for the subject matter The instructor presented the material according to the course outline The instructor came to class well prepared and organized The instructor is a positive representative for NACE INTERNATIONAL The instructor generally was available to consult with and assist students The instructor encouraged student participation The instructor answered my questions to my satisfaction The instructor's presentation was interesting and kept my attention The instructor spoke audibly and clearly The instructor should continue to teach this course for NACE Comments: ONLY COURSE ORGANIZERS AT NACE HEADQUARTERS SEE COMPLETED EVALUATION FORMS 2006-01-1 Agree (5) (4) (3) (2) Disagree (1) Instructor: / ... International 20 11 January 20 14 Coating Inspector Program Level Your CIP Level Instructors are: _ _ _ ©NACE International 20 11 January 20 14 Coating Inspector Program Level. .. International Coating Inspector Program are as follows: Highest Level Successfully Completed Category Title CIP Level NACE Coating Inspector Level 1—Certified CIP Level (must also have CIP Level 1) NACE Coating. .. permitted to use the term NACE Coating Inspector Level 1—Certified, NACE Coating Inspector Level 2? ??Certified, or NACE Certified Coating Inspector? ? ?Level (whichever level of certification is attained),