... September2009becauseofthelaborrequired to collect,sort, and processtherecyclables.30Recycling,reuse,deconstruction, and remanufacturingshiftthevalueaddedintheeconomyfromhighlymechanized,environmentallyharmfulextractionindustries, to labor‐intensive,localindustries.31,32 Land management options to reduce emissions alsohavemanyco‐benefits.Anumberofstudieshaveshownsubstantialbeneficialeffectsofbrownfieldsredevelopmentforlocalcommunities,includingjobcreation,increasedpropertyvalues,taxrevenuesforlocalgovernments,preservationofgreenspace, and socialbenefits.33,34Otherresearchhasshownthatbrownfieldsredevelopment,asacomponentofurbanredevelopment,reduceslocalvehiclemilestraveled and isassociatedwithlowerbuildingenergyuse,35bothofwhichlead to improvementsinurbanairqualityinaddition to GHGreductions.Theco‐benefits to communitiesof materials and land management strategiesmakethemattractiveasGHGreductionoptions.UnlikemanyGHGmitigationoptions,theyarealsolargelyunderstate and localinfluence.States and communitiescanusethesetools to reduce theircarbonfootprints and meetstateorlocalGHGreductiontargets.Thepurposeofthisdocument, Opportunities to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions through Materials and Land Management Practices, is to increasetheunderstandingofhow materials and land management practices relate to GHG emissions and showanewwayofthinkingabout materials and land management aspartofthesolution to theclimatechange.ThisdocumentpresentsEPA’sresearch to date.Aswedevelopprograms and policieswithourpartners,moredetailedstudiesthataccountforeconomic,technical, and institutionallimitations and opportunities willbeneeded.Inaddition,wewillshareinformationonthemitigationimpactsofcurrent materials and land management programsonGHG emissions and ultimatelydevelopmorespecificapproaches to implement materials and land management activitiesthatcouldachieveGHGemissionreductions.Theremainderofthisdocumentisorganizedintothefollowingsections.Section2presentsannualGHG emissions intheUnitedStatesusingtwoapproaches.Thesector‐basedapproachallocates emissions to economicorend‐usesectorsincludingtheelectricpowerindustry,transportation,industry,agriculture,commercial, and residentialsectors.Thesystems‐basedapproachreliesonthesamedata,butapportions emissions to materials management, land management, and othersystems to demonstratethepotentialimpact materials and land management haveontotalU.S. emissions. Section3presentsresearchintothepotentialGHGreductionsthatcouldbeachieved through anumberof materials and land management approaches.Section4summarizesthereport and describesthedirectionthatfutureresearchmaytake.Finally,thedocumentappendix(TechnicalSupportfor Opportunities to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions through Materials and Land Management Practices) presentsthedatasources and methodologyused to developthisreport. ... U.S.EPA.2003.BeyondRCRA:Waste and Materials Management intheYear2020.Availableat:http://www.epa.gov/epaoswer/osw/vision.pdf.“Sustainable Materials Management: TheRoadAhead”buildsonthisreport and isscheduled to bepublishedinFall2009 7 Opportunities to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions through Materials and Land Management Practices September2009Using materials management approaches to help reduce oravoidGHG emissions isconsistentwithEPA’svision and manyofthestrategies to increasetheefficient and sustainableuseofresources and reduce wastegenerationaredescribedinBeyondRCRA:Waste and Materials Management intheYear2020.Someofthestrategiesincludereducingtheamountof materials used to makeproductsorperformservices and influencingproductdesign,use, and reusecapabilities to minimizerawmaterialinputs,extendproductlifespans, and maximizetheease and frequencyofsubsequentproductdisassembly,recycling, and/ ortransformationforfurtherproductiveuse.27Inaddition to increasingmaterialefficiency and reducingwaste, materials management activitieshavethepotential to significantly reduce GHG emissions, asdescribedinthefollowingsections. Land management isatermused to describeseparateorintegratedstrategiesthatinfluencehowwemanage and use land to provideopenspace and habitat,food,naturalresources, and placesforpeople to live,work, and recreate.Forexample, land management includesthe practices ofdeveloping land and managing land foragricultural and forestrypurposes.Thewaywemanageour land directlyinfluencesGHG emissions related to agriculture,thebuiltenvironment(e.g.,residential and commercial emissions) ,electricityuse, and transportation.Theconceptof land management linksdirectly to EPA’svisionofpreventing land contamination,inpart,byencouragingsmartgrowth,28improvingchemical and waste management to preventcontamination,restoringcontaminated and potentiallycontaminated land forreusebysociety, and encouragingthesustainablereuseofproperty.Some land management approachescanalsoyieldGHGemissionreductionsorcanprotectthecarbonsinkprovidedbyU.S. land, whichisfurtherdescribedinSection2.Bytakingadvantageof opportunities presentedby materials and land management, EPA and itspartnerscancontribute to areductionoravoidanceofGHG emissions aswellasimprovement to publichealth and theenvironment.LeveragingOSWERprograms to achievemeasurableclimatechangebenefitsinnowayreplacesorsupersedesotherOSWERprogramgoals.Rather,thisdocumentpromotestherecognitionthat materials and land management programshavesignificantclimatebenefitswhileyieldingpositiveenvironmental,economic, and societalco‐benefitsincommunitiesacrossthecountry.Inthecaseof materials management, themajorityofGHGreductionbenefitsfromrecyclingorwastepreventioncomefromtheenergysavingsfromavoidedresourceextraction and materials processing.29Thisenergysavingscarriesco‐benefitsofimprovementsinlocalairquality.Similarly,theconservationofrawmaterialreducesenvironmentaldegradation and waterpollutionfrommining,logging, and oilextraction. ... SeeAppendixAformoredetailonhowtheestimateofGHG emissions frominfrastructuredevelopment to newlydevelopedgreenfieldwasderived.49Ewing,R.,Bartholomew,K.,Winkelman,S.,Walters,J., and Chen,D.2008.GrowingCooler:TheEvidenceonUrbanDevelopment and ClimateChange.Urban Land Institute.Washington,D.C. 15 Opportunities to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions through Materials and Land Management Practices September2009extracting and processingfuelsusedforlocalpassengertransport.Theslicerepresents1,019MMTCO2E,or15%of2006U.S. emissions. 50Thefinal land management elementofFigure4istheadditionalsliceoutsidethepiechartrepresentingGreenfieldDevelopment.Eachyear,millionsofacresofpreviouslyundevelopedoragricultural land (“greenfields”)aredeveloped,51resultinginGHG emissions fromthecarbonsinkprovidedbyU.S. land and vegetation.However,theGHG emissions associatedwithgreenfielddevelopmentarenotcurrentlycalculatedintheInventoryofU.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks.Becausethese emissions arerelateddirectly to land cleanup,revitalization and reuse,aroughestimatewaspreparedforthisreport.Thisestimateaccountsforforest,grassland, and agricultural land convertedforanurbanuse and mayincludesomeoverlapwiththeexisting land sinkvalue.These emissions areshownasanadditionalsliceoutsidethepiechartinFigure4becauseitrepresentsaninitialestimatethatisnotincludedintheInventoryofU.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks and, ascalculated,wouldbeinaddition to the emissions shownintherestofthepiechart.52Themethodologyused to developthisestimateisdescribedinAppendixA.Thepreliminaryestimateindicates emissions associatedwiththedevelopmentofgreenfieldsareontheorderof314MMTCO2E,orapproximately4%,of2006U.S.GHG emissions. 53OtherTherearethreeadditionalsystemsthatwehavegroupedunder“Other”(seeFigure5).ThiscategoryincludestheUseofAppliances and Devices(8%),BuildingHVAC and Lighting(25%) and OtherPassengerTransport(9%).Whileitcanbearguedthateachoftheseslicesareinfluencedby materials or land management, manyoftheassociatedmitigationapproacheshavebeenwidelyexploredinotherstudies and arenotthefocusofthisreport.Theseslicesarebrieflydescribedbelow....