Mối quan hệ giữa trí tuệ cảm xúc phong cách lãnh đạo và hiệu suất làm việc của nhân viên

Southern Luzon State University Thai Nguyen University Republic of Philippines Socialist Republic of Vietnam THE DISERTATION OF DBA THE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE, LEADERSHIP STYLES AND PERFORMANCE OF EMPLOYYEES IN ENTERPRISES IN HANOI, VIETNAM Name of Student : Nguyen Thi Thu Huong English Name : Alice Date of Birth i : 13/02/1977 Course : SLSU-DBA1 2012 ABSTRACT This study aims to determine the effect of leadership styles and emotional intelligence on employee performance The subjects of this study include 375 leaders and 730 subordinates in enterprises in Hanoi, Vietnam The questionnaire has two parallel forms, one for the leaders to rate themselves and another in which subordinates can rate owns performance and leadership styles, emotional intelligence of their leaders Leadership styles and emotional intelligence were identified as the independent variables and employee performance as the dependent variable Data obtained from each of the research instruments was then statistically analysed Through linear regression analysis it was concluded that there is a significant relationship between leadership styles and employee performance, However, only three leadership styles: the transactional leadership, the transformational leadership and the charismatic leadership was seen to have a positive effect on the significant subscales of employee performance and a visionary leadership has no significant effect on employee performance Simple correlation analysis showed that there is a positive significant linear relationship between emotional intelligence and employee performance Moreover, this results showed that a combination of the various leadership styles and emotional intelligence of the leader will bring more effective and enhance employee performance However, out of four leadership styles, the visionary leadership combine leader’ emotional intelligence has negative effect on employee Finally, although emotional intelligence and leadership styles had a significant effect on employee performance, the emotional intelligence, charismatic leadership were affected more ii than others This research therefore adds a new dimension to employee performance, leadership styles and emotional intelligence, since no similar study has been conducted As this research takes place in the Vietnam context, the findings of this study were expected to provide references to a corporate body in operating the human resource management strategy and developing the leadership style iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Firstly, I am deeply indebted to Dr Adwin Bernal and sincerely grateful for your infinite patience, direction, support, wisdom, and guidance throughout the research Additionally, I would like to thank the following individuals for their contributions and cooperation throughout the research: • All the leaders and employees who took the time to complete the questionnaires • Dr Nguyen Thanh Hai and Trinh Thi Hieu, from the International training center of Thai nguyen University, for their help and assistance with the research • My colleagues in The University of Labour and Social Affair, for their continuous encouragement and support through the good and bad times, and also for helping with the proofreading of the document Finally, Many thanks and much appreciation to my family members and friends who both supported and encouraged me throughout this process iv Contents ABSTRACT ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS iv LIST OF TABLES vii CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION 1 Background of the study Statement of Objectives Statement of the Problem 4 Hypotheses 5 Significance of the study Scope and Limitations of the Study CHAPTER II: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES 2.1.Leadership 2.2 Emotional intelligence 18 2.3.Employee performance 23 2.4 Relationship between employee performance, leadership and emotional intelligent 30 CHAPTER III: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 36 3.1 Research design 36 3.2 Population and Sample 37 3.3 Measuring Instruments Used 37 3.5 Data gathering procedure 39 v 3.6 Statistical Analysis 40 CHAPTER IV: RESULTS AND DISCIUSSIONS 45 4.1 The Survey Respondents 45 4.2 Relationship Between Leadership Styles and Employee Performance 46 4.3 Relationship Between Employee Performance and Leaders’ Emotional 49 4.4 Relationships among Emotional Intelligence, Leadership Styles and 53 4.5 Most Effective Leadership Style in Vietnamese Companies 54 CHAPTER 5: SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMADATIONS 56 5.1 Summary of Findings 56 5.2 Conclusion 58 5.3 Recommendations 59 5.3.1.Recommendations for the leaders 59 5.3.2.Recommendations for the enterprises 60 5.3.3.Recommendations for future researchers 61 APPENDIXES 62 Appendix G: 78 Appendix H: 79 Appendix I: 80 Appendix K: Covariance Matrix 87 List of References 90 vi LIST OF TABLES Table 4.1: Sample and Response Rates…………………………………………………45 Table 4.2 The Distribution of the Participants in Terms of Gender…………………… 46 Table 4.3 Leadership Style Survey – Item Descriptions…………………………………47 Table 4.4: Means and standard deviations of leadership style……………………………48 Table 4.5 Emotional intelligence Survey – Item Descriptions……………………………50 Table 4.7: Means and standard deviations of employee performance……………………52 Table 4.12 Correlations between Emotional Intelligence and Employee performance….55 vii CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION Background of the study In the global competitive market of today, Human Resources are playing a vital role in almost all aspects of life and in organizational development As more and more organizations are making progress, by making the use of human resources, they need some means to increase the performance in human resource by increasing the efficiency of leaders and their followers Emotional Intelligence is playing the vital role in the performance of the leaders T.Quang & N.T.Vuong (2002) state that management styles are profoundly influenced by the social cultures in which organisations operate It is important to identify the most suitable style of management to the specific operating circumstances of an organisation This research investigates the relationships among employee performance, leadership styles and emotional intelligence in enterprises in Hanoi, Vietnam To understand clearly that relationships, there is a need to consider some features of the Vietnamese culture Vietnam has a deep cultural heritage, which was developed over 4,000 years However, Vietnam’s history is characterized by turbulence due to centuries of foreign invasions and occupations The northern part of Vietnam was strongly influenced by the Chinese culture due to 1,000 years of dominance of the Chinese feudalism In general, the Vietnamese people are hospitable and industrious The history and geographic vicinity meant that Vietnamese people share many of the cultural and business practices of their Chinese neighbours In the words of Hofstede (1980), the Vietnamese culture can be described as high power distance, high collectivism, moderate uncertainty avoidance, and high context (Swierczek, 1994, Quang, 1997; Ralston et al., 1999) The high power distance characteristic is present in the daily life of Vietnamese as well as in business In the family, sons and daughters have to obey parents’ orders In organisations, there is a clear subordinate-superior relationship Titles, status, and formality are very important in Vietnamese society Collectivism has existed for a very long time in Vietnam It is characterised by tight social frameworks and self-functioning communities People expect ‘in groups’ to look after their members to protect them, and provide them with security in return for their loyalty Vietnamese people place importance on fitting in harmoniously and avoiding losing the other’s face In conflicts, they prefer to come out with a win-win situation Vietnamese culture displays moderate uncertainty avoidance People in society feel threatened by ambiguous situations and try to avoid these situations by providing greater job stability, establishing more formal rules, and rejecting deviant ideas and behaviour One of the distinctive features in the Vietnamese society is indirect speech, resulting from the importance of saving face In compensation, the Vietnamese have a very good sense of humour that surfaces often in every opportunity and conversation In economy, Vietnam is a nation in transition and a country full of opportunities It has a large, young, dynamic and highly literate population that has potential to be developed as a resource to attain high levels of sustained economic growth (Quang, 2006) Before 1986, Vietnam was a command economy dominated by large bureaucratic state-owned enterprises (SOEs), an inefficient agricultural base and small family businesses Vietnam started a profound economic reform in 1986 that aimed to transform the country from a command economy into market oriented economy called Doi moi As a consequence, Vietnam has substantially elevated its economy and the living standards of Vietnamese people The country reaped average economic growth rate (GDP) of over 7% during the 1990s and early 2000s, especially more than 8% in 2006, which made it one of the highest growing economies in the World (World Bank, 2006) Excessive reliance on factor accumulation to support rapid growth is bound to be unsustainable There is a limit to how fast factors can grow to support a rapidly growing economy Although Vietnam has a large population base, people with necessary education and skill to work in industry and services are getting increasingly scarce This has led the SEDP to identify skills and human capital as one of the breakthroughs for the next five years At the same time, rapid growth in credit, which is the basis for brisk growth in capital accumulation, has led to macroeconomic instability, forcing the government to pursue a tighter monetary policy in recent year Another sign of weakness in Vietnam’s economy is its persistent macroeconomic instability For four years in a row, Vietnam has had one of the highest inflation rates in Asia, averaging nearly 16 percent a year between 2008 and 2011 Along with high inflation, Vietnam has also been coping with persistent pressure on its currency, falling levels of foreign exchange reserves, an underperforming stock market, high sovereign spreads and domestic capital flight It has thus become an exception to the broader trend of the rest of the emerging markets in Asia, which are dealing with appreciating currencies, rising foreign exchange reserves, and increasing capital inflow.WEF showed more pessimistic view of Vietnam's twodigit surging inflation situation currently In addition, high state budget deficit ratio (6 per cent in 2010) and substandard infrastructure continue to be the major concerns of experts to Vietnam (road infrastructure ranked at No 123 and port at No 111) The quality of education, despite gaining significant progresses from last year, was still ranked in the low average group 86 Appendix K: Covariance Matrix Coefficient Correlationsa Model Correlations Charismati cs Transformati Visionary Leadershi onal Emotional Transactional Leadership p Leadership intelligence Leadership Visionary Leadership 1.000 -.554 -.260 -.674 -.532 Charismatics -.554 1.000 -.092 626 329 -.260 -.092 1.000 020 -.391 Emotional intelligence -.674 626 020 1.000 058 Transactional -.532 329 -.391 058 1.000 1.042E-6 -2.591E-7 -1.869E-7 -6.842E-7 -4.067E-7 -2.591E-7 2.096E-7 -2.967E-8 2.848E-7 1.126E-7 -1.869E-7 -2.967E-8 4.963E-7 1.375E-8 -2.060E-7 Emotional intelligence -6.842E-7 2.848E-7 1.375E-8 9.886E-7 4.315E-8 Transactional -4.067E-7 1.126E-7 -2.060E-7 4.315E-8 5.603E-7 Leadership Transformational Leadership Leadership Covariances Visionary Leadership Charismatics Leadership Transformational Leadership Leadership a Dependent Variable: Employee performance 87 Appendix L: The results of Linear regressions Summary of the Linear Regression Model for Hypothesis One Model Summary Adjusted R R R Square Square Std Error of the Estimate 950 903 902 12596 Model a Predictors: (Constant), Transformational leadership, Transactional leadership, Visionary leadership, Charismatics leadership b ANOVA Model Sum of Squares Regression Mean Square F 54.564 13.641 5.870 370 016 60.435 374 Residual Total df Sig 859.761 000 a a Predictors: (Constant), Transformational leadership, Transactional leadership, Visionary leadership, Charismatics leadership b Dependent Variable: Employee performance Coefficients a Model Standardiz ed Unstandardized Coefficients Coefficients B Std Error (Constant) 905 064 Transactional leadership 040 012 Charismatics leadership 303 Visionary leadership Transformational Beta t Sig 14.088 000 065 3.383 001 030 625 10.139 000 048 027 095 1.803 072 156 022 266 6.966 000 leadership a Dependent Variable: Employee performance 88 Summary of Hypothesis Three Results Table 4.14: Summary of Hypothesis Three Results Model Summary Model Adjusted R R a .999 R Square a Square 998 Std Error of the Estimate 998 01694 Predictors: (Constant), Transformational leadership, Transactional leadership, Emotional intelligence, Charismatics leadership, Visionary leadership b ANOVA Model Sum of Squares Regression Residual Total df Mean Square 60.329 106 369 60.435 374 F Sig 12.066 42029.489 000 a 000 a Predictors: (Constant), Transformational leadership, Transactional leadership, Emotional intelligence, Charismatics leadership, Visionary leadership b Dependent Variable: Employee performance Coefficients Model Unstandardized Standardized Coefficients Coefficients B (Constant) Std Error -.794 015 Emotional intelligence 584 004 Transactional leadership 226 Charismatics leadership Visionary leadership Transformational leadership a a Beta t Sig -53.737 000 865 141.704 000 002 367 109.750 000 410 004 847 100.387 000 -.413 005 -.813 -85.327 000 134 003 228 44.312 000 Dependent Variable: Employee performance 89 List of References ACKERMAN, C.P., SCHEEPERS, J.M., LESSING, B.C and DANNHAUSER, Z 2000 “Die Faktorstruktuur van Bass se Veelfaktor Leierskapvraelys in die Suid- Afrikaanse Konteks”, Journal of Industrial Psychology, 26(2): 58-65 ADAM, C., CAVENDISH, W and MISTRY, P 1992 Adjusting Privatisation London: Heinemann AMOS, T.L., RISTOW, A and RISTOW, L 2004 Human Resource Management (2ndEdition) Lansdowne: Juta and Co Ltd ARMSTRONG, M and BARON, A 1998 Performance Management – The New Realities.London: IPD ARNOLD, K.A., BARLING, J and KELLOWAY, E.K 2001 "Transformational Leadership or the Iron Cage: What Predicts Trust, Commitment and Team Efficacy", Leadership and Organization Development Journal, 22(7): 315-320 AUNTRY, I 1995 “Love and profit – finding the balance”, Quality Process, 29(1): 477 AVOLIO, B 1996 “Leadership most critical issue in business today”, Human ResourceManagement, Yearbook: 10-14 AVOLIO, B.J., WALDMAN, D.A and YAMMARINO, F.J 1991 "Leading in the 1990's: The Four I's of Transformational Leadership", Journal of European Industrial Training, 15:1-8 BABBIE, E and MOUTON, J 2001 The Practice of Social Research Oxford: Oxford University Press 90 10 BAGSHAW, M 2000 “Emotional Intelligence – training people to be affective so they can be effective”, Industrial and Commercial Training, 32(2): 61-65 11 BAIRD, L 1986 Managing Performance New York: John Wiley 12 BARLING, J., FULLAGAR, C and BLUEN, S 1983 Behaviour in Organisation: South African Perspective (2nd Edition) Johannesburg: McGraw-Hill Book Company 13 BARLING, J., SALTER, F., and KELLOWAY, E.K 2000 "Transformational leadership and EI: an exploratory study", Learnership & Organizational Development Journal, 21(3): 157-161 14 BAR-ON, R 1996 The Emotional Quotient Inventory (EQ-i): A Test of Emotional Intelligence Toronto: Multi-Health Systems 15 BAR-ON, R 1997 Bar-On Emotional Quotient Inventory Technical Manual New York: Multi-Health Systems 16 BAR-ON, R 2000 “Emotional and Social Intelligence” In Bar-On, R and Parker, J.D.A (eds) The Handbook of Emotional Intelligence San Francisco: Jossey-Bass 17 BARRY, J.M 1997 “Performance Management: A Case Study”, Journal of Environmental Health, 60(4):12-38 18 BARTLETT, C.A and GHOSHAL, S 1995 “Changing the Role of Top Management: Beyond Systems to People”, Harvard Business Review, 73(3): 132-142 19 BASS, B.M 1985 Leadership and Performance Beyond Expectations New York: Free Press 20 BASS, B.M 1990 Bass and Stogdill’s handbook Research and Managerial applications New York: Free Press 91 of leadership: Theory, 21 BASS, B.M 1994 “Transformational leadership critical for South Africa”, Human Resource Management, (2): 10-13 22 BASS, B.M 1997 “Concepts of Leadership” In Vecchio, R.P (ed) Leadership: Understanding the Dynamics of Power and Influence in Organizations Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press 23 BASS, B.M 1998 Transformational Leadership: Industrial, Military, and Educational Impact Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum and Associates 24 BASS, B.M and AVOLIO, B.J 1990a "Developing Transformational Leadership: 1992 and Beyond", Journal of European Industrial Training, 14(5): 21-27 25 BASS, B.M and AVOLIO, B.J 1990b Transformational Leadership Development: Manual for MLQ Palo Alto: Consulting Psychologist Press 26 BASS, B.M and AVOLIO, B.J 1994 Improving Organizational Effectiveness: Through Transformational Leadership Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications Inc 27 BASS, B.M and AVOLIO, B.J 1997 Full Range Leadership Development: Manual for the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire Redwood City: Mind Garden Inc 28 BASS, B.M and AVOLIO, B.J 2000 Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire Redwood City: Mind Garden Inc 29 BASS, B.M., AVOLIO, B.J and GOODHEIM, L 1987 “Biography and the Assessment of Transformational Leadership at a World Class Level”, Journal of Management, 13(2): 7-19 30 BAXTER, J 2004 Personal Communication Statistics Department Rhodes University, Grahamstown November –December 92 Lecturer, Statistics 31 BEHLING, O and MCFILLEN, J 1996 “A syncretical model charismatic/transformational leadership”, Group and Organisation Management, 21(2): 120160 32 BENNIS, W and NANUS, B 1985 Leaders: The Strategy for Taking Charge New York: Harper and Row Publishers 33 BERNARD, L.L 1926 Introduction to Social Psychology New York: Holt 34 BLESS, C AND HIGSON-SMITH, C 2000 Fundamentals of Social Research Methods: An African Perspective (3rd Edition) Lusaka: Juta Education (Pty) Ltd 35 BOOTH, W.C 1995 The craft of research Chicago: University of Chicago Publishers 36 BOTHA, J 2001 The Relationship between Leadership, Internal Quality, and Customer Satisfaction Levels of Dealerships in a South African Motor Vehicle Organisation Unpublished Masters Thesis Grahamstown: Rhodes University 37 BRAND, C., HEYL, G and MARITZ, D 2000 “Leadership” In Meyer, M and Botha, E (eds) Organisational Development and Transformation in South Africa Durban: Butterworths 38 BREWSTER, C., CAREY, L., DOWLING, P., GROBLER, P., HOLLAND, P and WÄRNICH, S 2003 Contemporary Issues in Human Resource Management Cape Town: Clyson Printers 39 BURNS, J.M 1978 Leadership New York: Harper and Row Publishers 40 BYCIO, P., HACKETT, R.D and ALLEN, J 1995 “Further Assessment of Bass’s (1985) Conceptualisation of Transactional and Transformational Leadership”, Journal of 93 Applied Psychology, 80(4): 468-478 41 BYRKIT, D.R 1987 Statistics Today: A Comprehensive Introduction New York: Cummings Publishing Company 42 CACIOPPE, R 1997 “Leadership Moment by Moment”, Leadership and Organisational Development Journal, 18(7): 335-345 43 CAMPBELL, J., McCLOY, R., OPPLER, S and SAGER, C 1993 The Theory of Performance New York: Jossey-Bass 44 CARKHUFF, R.R 1988 Empowering the Creative Leader in the New Age of Capitalism Amherst: Human Resource Development Press 45 CARLTON, G 1993 Leadership: The Human Race (2nd Edition) Kenwyn: Juta & Co 46 CARRELL, M.R., ELBERT, N.F., HATFIELD, R.D., GROBLER, P.A., MARX, M and VAN DER SCHYF, S 1998 Human Resource Management in South Africa Cape Town: Prentice-Hall 47 CHARLTON, G 2000 Human Habits of Highly Effective Organisations Pretoria: Van Schaik Publishers 48 CHERRINGTON, D.J 1994 Organisational Behavior Boston: Allyn and Bacon 49 COAKES, S.J and STEED, L.G 1997 SPSS: Analysis Without Anguish: Version 6.1 Brisbane: John Wiley & Son 50 COETZEE, M 2005 Organisational report: 360-Degree Emotional Competency Profiler Results Unpublished report Pretoria: University of South Africa 51 COLLIS, D.J and MONTGOMERY, C.A 1995 “Competing on Resources”, Harvard Business Review, 73(4): 118-128 94 52 COOPER, R.K 1997 “Applying emotional intelligence in the workplace”, Training and Development, 51(12): 31-38 53 COOPER, R.K and SAWAF, A 1997 Executive EQ: Emotional Intelligence in Leadership and Organisations New York: Putnam 54 CORVELLEC, H 1995 Stories of Achievement: Narrative Features of Organisational Performance Sweden: Lund University Press 55 CULLEN, K., GILMOUR, L and HOLMES, A 2005 Collins Dictionary and Thesaurus London: Harper Collins 56 CUMMINGS, L.L and SCHWAB, D.P 1973 Performance in Organisations: determinants and appraisal Glenview: Scott, Foresman and Company 57 DAMASIO, A 1994 Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason and the Human Brain NewYork: Putnam 58 DE VELLIS, R.F 1991 Scale Development: Theory and Applications Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications 59 DIMMA, W.A 1989 “Leadership”, Business Quarterly, 23(2): 20-41 60 DOWNING, S.J 1997 “Learning the plot: emotional momentum in search of dramatic logic”, Management Learning, 28(1): 27-44 61 DRAFT, R.L 1999 Leadership Theory and Practice Fort Worth: The Drydon Press 62 DULEWICZ, V and HIGGS, M 2000 “Emotional Intelligence – A review and evaluation study”, Journal of Managerial Psychology, 15(4): 341-372 63 FIEDLER, F.E and HOUSE, R.J 1988 “Leadership Theory and Research: A Report of Progress”, International Review of Industrial and Organisational Psychology, 95 19(88): 73-91 64 FOOT, M and HOOK, C 1999 Introducing Human Resources Management London: Longman 65 GARDENER, L and STOUGH, C 2002 “Examining the relationship between leadership and emotional Leadership intelligence in senior level managers”, andOrganisation Development Journal, 23(2): 68-78 66 GARDNER, H 1983 Frames of Mind New York: Bantam 67 GARDNER, H and HATCH, T 1989 “Multiple Intelligences Go to School”, Educational Researcher, 18(8): 8-14 68 GEORGE, J.M 2000 “Emotions & leadership: the role of EI”, Human Relations, 53(12: 1027-1041 69 GERBER, P.D., NEL, P.S and VAN DYK, P.S 1996 Human Resource Management, Johannesburg: International Thompson Publishing 70 GOLEMAN, D 1995 Emotional Intelligence New York: Bantam 71 GOLEMAN, D 1996 Emotional Intelligence London: Bloomsbury 72 GOLEMAN, D 1997 Beyond IQ: Developing the leadership competencies of emotional intelligence London: Bloomsbury 73 GOLEMAN, D 1998 Working with Emotional Intelligence New York: Bantam 74 GROBLER, P.A., WÄRNICH, S., CARRELL, M.R., ELBERT, N.F and HATFIELD, R.D 2002 Human Resource Management in South Africa London: Thompson Learning 75 HALL, J 1996 The Competence Connection: A blueprint for excellence Woodlands: Woodstead Press 76 HARRISON, R 1997 “Why your firm needs emotional intelligence”, People 96 Management,3(1): 41 77 HATER, J.J and BASS, B.M 1988 “Superiors evaluations and subordinates perceptions of transformational and transactional leadership” Journal of Applied Psychology, 20(1): 695-702 78 HAYWARD, B.A., DAVIDSON, A.J., PASCOE, J.B., TASKER, M.L, AMOS, T.L and PEARSE, N.J 2003 The Relationship between Leadership and Employee Performance in a South African Pharmaceutical Company Paper presented at the Society for Industrial and Organisational Psychology 6th Annual Conference, 25-27 June 2003, Sandton, Johannesburg 79 HELLRIEGEL, D., JACKSON, S E., SLOCUM, J.W., STAUDE, G., AMOS, T., KLOPPER, H.B., LOUW, L and OOSTHUIZEN, T 2004 Management: Second South African Edition Cape Town: Oxford University Press Southern Africa 80 HELLRIEGEL, D., JACKSON, S.E and SLOCUM, J.W 1999 Management Cincinnati: South-Western College Publishing 81 HELLRIEGEL, D and SLOCUM, J 1996 Management (7th Edition) Cincinnati: South- Western College Publishing 82 HENDREY, C 1995 Human Resource Management: A Strategic Approach to Employment Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann 83 HERSEY, P and BLANCHARD, K.H 1988 Management of Organizational Behavior: Utilizing Human Resources (5th Edition) Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall 84 HOLLOWAY, J., FRANCIS, G and HINTON, M 1999 “A vehicle for change? A case study of performance improvement in the “new” public sector”, The International 97 Journal of Public Sector Management, 12(4): 351-365 85 HOWELL, J.M and AVOLIO, B.J 1993 “Transformational Leadership, Transactional Leadership Locus of Control and Support for Innovation: Key Predictors of Consolidated Bossiness Performance”, Journal of Applied Psychology, 78(1): 891-902 86 HUGHES, R., GINNETT, A and CURPHY, G 1994 Leadership: Enhancing the Lessons of Experiences New York: The Free Press 87 HUSSEY, J and HUSSEY, R 1997 Business Research: A Practical Guide for Undergraduate and Postgraduate Studies London: MacMillan Business 88 JOHNSON, M 1995 Managing in the Next Millennium Oxford: ButterworthHeinemann 89 JONES, G.R and GEORGE, J.M 2000 Essentials of Managing Organisational Behavior Upper Saddle River: Prentice-Hall 90 KAPLAN, R.S and NORTON, D.P 1996 The Balance Scorecard Boston: The Harvard Business School Press 91 KELLER, G and WARRACK, B 1999 Statistics for Management and Economics (4thEdition) Pacific Grove: Brooks-Cole Publishing Company 92 KELLEY, R and CAPLAN, J 1993 “How Bell Labs creates star performers”, Harvard Business Review, 3(2):100-103 93 KENT, A and CHELLADURAI, P 2001 "Perceived Transformational Leadership, Organizational Commitment, and Citizenship Behavior: A Case Study in Intercollegiate Athletics", The Journal of Sport Management, 15: 135-159 94 KILBOURNE, C.E 1935 “The Elements of Leadership”, Coats Artillary Journal, 11(1):437-439 98 95 KLAUSNER, H 1997 Review of Raising your Emotional Intelligence by Jeanne Segal [On-line] Available: http://www.emotionalintelligence.org[accessed 12/04/2005] 96 KOTTER, J.P 1988 The Leadership Factor New York: The Free Press 97 LAGOMARSINO, R and CARDONA, P 2003 Relationships among Leadership, Organizational Commitment and OCB in Uruguayan Health Institutions Unpublished Report for the IESE Business School Madrid: University of Nevarra 98 LANGLEY, A 2000 “Emotional Intelligence – A new evaluation for management development?”, Career Development International, 5(3): 177-183 99 LEEDY, P.D 1993 Practical research planning and design Englewood Cliffs: Prentice- Hall 100 LOWE, Transformational K.B and KROECK, K 1996 “Effectiveness Correlates of and Transactional Leadership: A Meta-analytic Review of the MLQ Literature”, Leadership Quarterly,7(3): 385-426 101 MARITZ, D 1995 “Leadership and mobilising potential”, Human Resource Management,10(1): 8-16 102 MARTINEZ, M.N 1997 “The smarts that count”, HR Magazine, 42(11): 72-78 103 MARTINEZ-PONS, M 1997 “The relation of emotional intelligence with selecte areas of personal functioning”, Imagination, Cognition and Personality, 17: 313 104 MAUDE, B 1978 Leadership in Management London: Business Books 105 MAYER, J.D., CARUSO, D and SALOVEY, P 1998 “Competing models of emotional intelligence” In Steinberg, R.J (ed) Handbook of Human Intelligence (2nd Edition) New York: Cambridge University Press 99 106 MAYER, J.D and SALOVEY, P 1997 “What is Emotional Intelligence?” In Salovey, P and Sluyter, D (eds) Emotional Development, Emotional Literacy, and Emotional Intelligence New York: Basic Books 107 MAYER, J.D., SALOVEY, P and CARUSO, D 2000 “Emotional Intelligence meets traditional standards for an intelligence”, Intelligence, 27(4): 267-298 108 MESTER, C., VISSER, D and ROODT, G 2003 "Leadership Style and its Relation to Employee Attitudes and Behaviour", SA Journal of Industrial Psychology, 29(2): 72-80 109 MEYER, M and BOTHA, E 2000 Organisation Transformation inSouth Africa Durban: Butterworths 100 Development and ... followers Emotional Intelligence is playing the vital role in the performance of the leaders T.Quang & N.T.Vuong (2002) state that management styles are profoundly influenced by the social cultures... distance, high collectivism, moderate uncertainty avoidance, and high context (Swierczek, 1994, Quang, 1997; Ralston et al., 1999) The high power distance characteristic is present in the daily... has potential to be developed as a resource to attain high levels of sustained economic growth (Quang, 2006) Before 1986, Vietnam was a command economy dominated by large bureaucratic state-owned