ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Mục Lục PHỤ LỤC 1: THIẾT KẾ SÀN TẦNG ĐIỂN HÌNH PHỤ LỤC 2: THIẾT KẾ KHUNG TRỤC 53 PHỤ LỤC 3: THIẾT KẾ LÕI CÔNG TRÌNH 119 PHỤ LỤC 4: KẾT QUẢ PHÂN TÍCH DAO ĐỘNG 136 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN -1- SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - PHỤ LỤC 1: THIẾT KẾ SÀN TẦNG ĐIỂN HÌNH 1.1 DỮ LIỆU ĐẦU VÀO 1.1.1 Khai báo vật liệu 1.1.1.1 Bê tông Material Text B40 E N/mm2 25743 U Unitless 0.2 A 1/C 0.0000099 UnitWt kN/m3 25 Fc N/mm2 30 1.1.1.2 Cáp dự ứng lực Material Text A416Gr270 StrandArea mm2 140 E N/mm2 196501 UnitWt kN/m3 76.973 Fy N/mm2 1689.90516 Fu N/mm2 1861.58463 1.1.2 Khai báo tiết diện 1.1.2.1 Frame section SectionName C700X800 C600X700 C500X600 D300X500 Material Text B40 B40 B40 B40 Shape Text Rectangular Rectangular Rectangular Rectangular Depth m 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 WidthTop m 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.3 Area m2 0.56 0.42 0.3 0.15 I33 m4 0.0299 0.0172 0.009 0.0031 I22 m4 0.0229 0.0126 0.0063 0.0011 1.1.2.2 Slap section Section Text S230 S400 Material Text B40 B40 Type Text Shell-Thin Shell-Thin MembThick m 0.23 0.4 BendThick m 0.23 0.4 TotalWt kN/m3 81240.03 30751 1.1.3 Khai báo tải trọng LoadCase Text SW SDL TUONG HT GTX GTY GDX GDY DDX DDY Type Text LinStatic LinStatic LinStatic LinStatic LinStatic LinStatic LinStatic LinStatic LinRespSpec LinRespSpec GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN DesignType Text DEAD SUPER DEAD SUPER DEAD LIVE WIND WIND WIND WIND QUAKE QUAKE -2- SelfWtMult Unitless 0 0 0 0 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 LoadCase Text PT-FINAL PT-TRANSFER PT-FINAL-HP THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Type Text LinStatic LinStatic Hyperstatic DesignType Text PRESTRESS-FINAL PRESTRESS-TRANSFER HYPERSTATIC SelfWtMult Unitless 0 Hình 1.1 – Mặt tải hoàn thiện sàn điển hình Hình 1.2 – Mặt hoạt tải sàn điển hình GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN -3- SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - 1.1.4 Khai báo tổ hợp tải trọng 1.1.4.1 Kiểm tra độ võng Combo Text DFT1 DFT2 DFT2 DFT2 Load Text HT TT PT-FINAL1 HT SF Unitless 2 Type Text Linear Add Linear Add SF Unitless 1 Type Text Linear Add SF Unitless 0.5 1 1 Type Text Linear Add SF Unitless 0.5 1 1.4 1.2 1.6 1.2 1.6 1 1.2 1.6 -1 Type Text Linear Add 1.1.4.2 Giai đoạn truyền ứng lực (Transfer) Combo Text INTIAL INTIAL Load Text SW PT-TRANSFER1 1.1.4.3 Giai đoạn sử dụng (Service) Combo Text SLS1 SLS1 SLS1 SLS2 SLS2 SLS2 Load Text TT HT PT-FINAL1 TT HT PT-FINAL1 Linear Add 1.1.4.4 Giai đoạn cực hạn (Ultimate) Combo Text SLS1 SLS1 SLS1 TT+PTfinal TT+PTfinal ULS1 ULS1 ULS2 ULS2 ULS2 ULS3 ULS3 ULS3 ULS3 ULS4 ULS4 ULS4 ULS4 Load Text TT HT PT-FINAL1 TT PT-FINAL1 TT PT-FINAL1-HP TT HT PT-FINAL1-HP TT HT GIOX PT-FINAL1-HP TT HT GIOX PT-FINAL1-HP GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN -4- Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Combo Text ULS5 ULS5 ULS5 ULS5 ULS6 ULS6 ULS6 ULS6 ULS7 ULS7 ULS7 ULS8 ULS8 ULS8 ULS9 ULS9 ULS9 ULS10 ULS10 ULS10 ULS11 ULS11 ULS11 ULS11 ULS12 ULS12 ULS12 ULS12 ULS13 ULS13 ULS13 ULS13 ULS14 ULS14 ULS14 ULS14 ULS15 ULS15 ULS15 ULS16 ULS16 ULS16 ULS17 ULS17 ULS17 ULS18 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load Text TT HT GIOY PT-FINAL1-HP TT HT GIOY PT-FINAL1-HP TT GIOX PT-FINAL1-HP TT GIOX PT-FINAL1-HP TT GIOY PT-FINAL1-HP TT GIOY PT-FINAL1-HP TT HT DDX PT-FINAL1-HP TT HT DDX PT-FINAL1-HP TT HT DDY PT-FINAL1-HP TT HT DDY PT-FINAL1-HP TT DDX PT-FINAL1-HP TT DDX PT-FINAL1-HP TT DDY PT-FINAL1-HP TT GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN -5- SF Unitless 1.2 1.6 1 1.2 1.6 -1 0.9 1 0.9 -1 0.9 1 0.9 -1 1.2 1.6 1 1.2 1.6 -1 1.2 1.6 1 1.2 1.6 -1 0.9 1 0.9 -1 0.9 1 0.9 Type Text Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add Linear Add SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Combo Text ULS18 ULS18 BAO THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load Text DDY PT-FINAL1-HP ULS – ULS 18 SF Unitless -1 1 Type Text Envelope 1.2 SƠ ĐỒ TÍNH 1.2.1 Mô hình sàn cáp Hình 1.3 – Mô hình sàn cáp dự ứng lực GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN -6- SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - 1.2.2 Tên phần tử dãy Hình 1.4 – Chia dãy theo phương X Hình 1.5 – Chia dãy theo phương Y GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN -7- SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - 1.3 KẾT QUẢ NỘI LỰC 1.3.1 Kết nội lực giai đoạn truyền ứng lực Strip Text CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA1 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 Location Text Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start OutputCase Text INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN AbsMaxP kN -1622.754 -1377.85 -1671.603 -1625.92 -1265.191 -1256.762 -1272.864 -1013.24 -1304.439 -1299.05 -1341.756 -1734.626 -1785.944 -1472.781 -1744.709 -4280.068 -3695.777 -3643.692 -3537.107 -3718.285 -3866.136 -1228.7 -1204.67 -1138.831 -961.495 -1071.194 -977.632 -924.843 -926.483 -930.541 -943.617 -1189.82 -1107.838 -1035.604 -1020.22 -957.225 -1013.724 -970.96 -951.798 -8- AbsMaxV2 kN -179.206 6.47 112.33 -100.319 -8.3 92.915 -65.247 14.042 65.174 -91.913 9.766 99.628 -111.559 -5.303 176.131 -180.97 -24.875 237.043 -171.55 82.881 122.521 2.628 2.628 -1.279 -16.421 -16.421 -23.11 -12.647 -12.647 -38.555 -38.555 -55.817 -55.817 -21.145 -21.145 10.991 22.229 22.229 1.709 MaxM3 kN-m 80.9931 12.0269 64.4647 60.6188 1.5476 73.6969 68.8714 -8.2103 69.9881 77.2185 0.7887 65.98 71.0627 10.5476 89.1783 224.9363 17.3262 200.1792 176.8091 214.818 120.4455 27.117 26.7495 22.2555 12.5562 21.4702 23.3464 20.4789 -1E+30 22.306 7.2258 -1E+30 20.6081 -4.6482 -1E+30 47.5472 39.3937 -1E+30 44.6162 47.2447 39.3335 16.9839 21.8104 MinM3 kN-m 2.3343 -5.2338 -47.0279 -36.2732 -9.2384 -17.3318 -1.1539 -15.2764 -1.642 -12.954 -10.0876 -27.4802 -37.3425 -5.8881 2.4505 -31.2343 -5.3254 -61.0411 37.6188 -81.9683 24.2467 27.117 19.6071 22.2555 12.5562 21.421 23.3464 20.4789 1E+30 22.306 7.2258 1E+30 20.6081 -4.6482 1E+30 47.5472 39.3937 1E+30 44.6162 47.2447 31.7407 16.9839 21.8104 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Strip Text CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA3 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 CSA5 Location Text Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - OutputCase Text INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN AbsMaxP kN -981.825 -1247.065 -1193.313 -1259.991 -1012.942 -1047.26 -986.776 -1069.283 -1085.064 -1170.832 -1252.198 -1000.121 -986.26 -984.759 -982.873 -1034.664 -1128.026 -1019.089 -1196.719 -1265.29 -1291.327 -3962.028 -3821.891 -3659.43 -3776.062 -3818.065 -4407.454 -1622.873 -1369.686 -1659.849 -1613.471 -1245.826 -1265.68 -1283.535 -1026.776 -1316.62 -1309.391 -1322.832 -1722.454 -1774.372 -1464.702 -9- AbsMaxV2 kN 1.709 4.561 6.633 -2.937 -21.161 -9.547 -7.841 20.21 20.21 53.025 53.025 38.277 38.277 12.819 12.819 23.248 16.464 16.464 0.709 -3.21 -3.21 -121.258 -81.619 170.69 -235.902 22.581 177.213 -179.408 6.456 113.254 -101.234 -8.4 92.962 -65.229 14.443 64.998 -91.789 9.928 100.547 -112.479 -5.289 MaxM3 kN-m -1E+30 20.5564 13.8341 13.3318 12.1729 15.2765 34.1972 43.1212 44.3738 -1E+30 39.3389 48.3365 -1E+30 -3.0974 22.4494 -1E+30 8.8743 23.2819 -1E+30 21.4172 24.5047 22.1824 13.024 22.6588 27.5951 28.151 124.0559 222.0908 185.9702 211.3359 13.6097 233.6091 80.6049 12.0975 63.7949 60.0634 1.5015 74.1554 69.771 -8.3055 70.906 77.6948 0.7116 65.457 70.3972 10.6183 MinM3 kN-m 1E+30 20.5564 4.9192 10.3953 2.3957 15.2765 28.5074 43.1212 44.3738 1E+30 39.3389 48.3365 1E+30 -3.0974 22.4494 1E+30 8.8743 23.2819 1E+30 21.4172 24.5047 22.1319 13.024 22.6588 20.1112 28.151 28.8984 -84.7954 47.169 -45.2868 -7.1283 -31.1686 2.2674 -5.0141 -48.2629 -37.3928 -9.0339 -17.0015 -1.105 -15.6039 -1.6241 -12.4897 -9.8814 -28.5749 -38.5649 -5.6676 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Strip Text CSA5 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 CSA6 Location Text End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End Start Middle End THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - OutputCase Text INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL INTIAL AbsMaxP kN -1744.874 -4313.95 -3698.763 -3666.521 -3566.433 -3772.367 -3987.241 -1267.211 -1235.568 -1155.702 -971.433 -1077.09 -959.833 -872.113 -873.5 -868.903 -868.996 -901.482 -831.486 -870.678 -854.325 -826.819 -886.579 -891.346 -920.505 -945.051 -1235.714 -1191.244 -1252.66 -962.018 -935.39 -882.974 -913.696 -922.142 -881.533 -958.813 -924.709 -920.858 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 10 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN AbsMaxV2 kN 176.334 -180.175 -21.463 234.845 -175.703 76.072 130.014 23.491 23.491 14.687 -8.522 -8.522 -21.153 -0.121 -0.121 -17.954 -17.954 -23.836 -23.836 -40.462 -40.462 -2.579 -2.579 2.193 -21.095 -21.095 3.099 6.737 -0.185 -4.246 8.518 5.664 42.043 42.043 20.953 20.953 19.504 19.504 MaxM3 kN-m 88.7905 224.3707 16.4265 200.3041 176.7457 217.281 128.644 34.1475 23.6236 15.4331 15.8208 19.0523 25.1116 22.7793 -1E+30 23.2266 17.9546 -1E+30 25.2604 16.0251 -1E+30 42.4937 32.023 -1E+30 43.1237 39.7821 33.0204 22.4458 18.9733 -1E+30 21.9365 11.2715 10.7874 9.7106 15.945 27.5158 31.3479 42.4374 -1E+30 30.2078 44.0965 -1E+30 16.4228 28.7703 -1E+30 20.3505 MinM3 kN-m 2.3844 -30.9954 -7.8089 -58.2008 37.7786 -78.8006 29.431 34.1475 20.1485 15.4331 15.8208 19.0345 25.1116 22.7793 1E+30 23.2266 17.9546 1E+30 25.2604 16.0251 1E+30 42.4937 32.023 1E+30 43.1237 39.7821 31.0833 22.4458 18.9733 1E+30 21.9365 2.076 7.5816 -0.8448 15.945 25.259 31.3479 42.4374 1E+30 30.2078 44.0965 1E+30 16.4228 28.7703 1E+30 20.3505 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN Loc Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom P -5055.61 -4480.43 -5517.45 -4396.9 -5433.92 -4438.52 -5475.55 -4438.8 -5475.82 -4051.41 -5088.44 -4545.76 -5582.78 -4051.41 -5088.44 -4545.76 -5582.78 -4224.37 -5261.4 -4372.8 -5409.82 -4224.37 -5261.4 -4372.8 -5409.82 -8816.27 -9853.29 -7887.17 -8924.2 -7722.21 -8759.24 -7804.4 -8841.42 -7804.99 -8842.01 -8789.34 -9826.36 -8640.88 -9677.9 -8714.84 -9751.87 -8715.38 -9752.4 -7974.28 -9011.3 -8849 -9886.02 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 122 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 1430.08 1702.23 1702.23 1739.24 1739.24 1717.83 1717.83 1723.64 1723.64 2273.33 2330.38 972.22 915.17 2273.33 2330.38 972.22 915.17 1818.76 1835.82 1426.79 1409.73 1818.76 1835.82 1426.79 1409.73 1818.41 1818.41 1298.68 1298.68 1597.6 1597.6 1442.79 1442.79 1453.49 1453.49 1646.87 1646.87 1915.9 1915.9 1776.57 1776.57 1786.2 1786.2 3084.96 3131.08 255.64 209.52 M2 2480.481 -634.66 3539.699 -1580.59 2720.977 -1115.49 3113.786 -1099.76 3146.89 1567.282 5366.619 -3694.55 448.559 1567.282 5366.619 -3694.55 448.559 -272.987 3650.507 -1854.28 2164.67 -272.987 3650.507 -1854.28 2164.67 -975.866 2707.025 327.933 2631.622 -1671.94 1560.477 -689.953 2062.109 -654.055 2129.99 -45.537 3127.943 -1845.42 2163.912 -961.634 2615.38 -929.326 2676.474 3990.055 7106.401 -5698.7 -2181.13 M3 280.631 -457.484 281.805 -558.52 63.107 -714.481 65.589 -301.523 279.323 969.514 2684.605 -1964.22 -2346.74 969.514 2684.605 -1964.22 -2346.74 456.714 2465.913 -1451.42 -2128.05 456.714 2465.913 -1451.42 -2128.05 -878.507 217.431 -685.806 360.631 -916.016 22.339 -1184.56 463.888 -417.263 -80.918 -767.152 367.068 -974.341 62.606 -1216.03 459.999 -525.464 -30.326 1758.913 3699.65 -3453.85 -3285.55 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 13 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 12 TANG 11 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 Loc Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top P -7974.28 -9011.3 -8849 -9886.02 -8280.32 -9317.35 -8542.95 -9579.98 -8280.32 -9317.35 -8542.95 -9579.98 -13098.4 -14135.4 -11669.7 -12706.7 -11432.1 -12469.1 -11550.4 -12587.5 -11551.3 -12588.3 -13050.6 -14087.6 -12836.7 -13873.8 -12943.3 -13980.3 -12944 -13981.1 -11850.7 -12887.7 -13108.1 -14145.1 -11850.7 -12887.7 -13108.1 -14145.1 -12290.6 -13327.7 -12668.2 -13705.2 -12290.6 -13327.7 -12668.2 -13705.2 -17342.7 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 123 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 3084.96 3131.08 255.64 209.52 2095.82 2109.64 1244.79 1230.97 2095.82 2109.64 1244.79 1230.97 1801.51 1801.51 1183.18 1183.18 1673.64 1673.64 1422 1422 1434.82 1434.82 1543.5 1543.5 1984.91 1984.91 1758.44 1758.44 1769.97 1769.97 3565.47 3598.27 -260.93 -293.72 3565.47 3598.27 -260.93 -293.72 2227.48 2237.31 1077.07 1067.23 2227.48 2237.31 1077.07 1067.23 1724.25 M2 3990.055 7106.401 -5698.7 -2181.13 602.321 3865.701 -2310.96 1059.568 602.321 3865.701 -2310.96 1059.568 -378.244 2424.337 1005.399 2229.786 -1198.44 1543.36 -130.183 1833.771 -62.857 1939.375 641.655 2679.452 -1341.8 2061.669 -380.368 2323.039 -319.775 2418.082 5782.856 9638.913 -6313.96 -5220.45 5782.856 9638.913 -6313.96 -5220.45 1557.056 4453.413 -2088.16 -34.95 1557.056 4453.413 -2088.16 -34.95 368.747 M3 1758.913 3699.65 -3453.85 -3285.55 1565.22 6114.223 -3260.16 -5700.12 1565.22 6114.223 -3260.16 -5700.12 -1279.16 281.558 -1000.7 444.944 -1319.46 38.467 -1152.58 1303.835 -1167.58 -820.424 -1123.81 460.487 -1410.7 94.659 -1260.5 1233.489 -1274.01 -678.343 2287.743 4931.444 -4750.8 -4400.21 2287.743 4931.444 -4750.8 -4400.21 4228.231 11373.52 -6691.29 -10842.3 4228.231 11373.52 -6691.29 -10842.3 -1653.59 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 11 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 Loc Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom P -18379.7 -15419.4 -16456.4 -15110.4 -16147.5 -15264.4 -16301.4 -15265.5 -16302.5 -17273.9 -18310.9 -16995.8 -18032.9 -17134.4 -18171.4 -17135.4 -18172.4 -15695.7 -16732.7 -17327.4 -18364.5 -15695.7 -16732.7 -17327.4 -18364.5 -16266.6 -17303.6 -16756.5 -17793.5 -16266.6 -17303.6 -16756.5 -17793.5 -21529.1 -22566.1 -19119.2 -20156.2 -18740.8 -19777.8 -18929.3 -19966.3 -18930.6 -19967.7 -21439.5 -22476.5 -21098.9 -22135.9 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 124 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 1724.25 1019.76 1019.76 1699.36 1699.36 1351.95 1351.95 1367.17 1367.17 1381.96 1381.96 1993.6 1993.6 1680.93 1680.93 1694.63 1694.63 3863.17 3887.34 -706.42 -730.59 3863.17 3887.34 -706.42 -730.59 2265.23 2272.49 891.51 884.26 2265.23 2272.49 891.51 884.26 1625.06 1625.06 847.53 847.53 1703.43 1703.43 1266.64 1266.64 1284.32 1284.32 1204.95 1204.95 1975.25 1975.25 M2 2117.258 1523.744 1531.421 -345.734 1760.597 536.452 1570.732 641.557 1721.285 1232.038 1967.004 -450.493 2173.262 343.476 2002.384 438.07 2137.882 8108.048 12682.5 -7194.35 -8824.98 8108.048 12682.5 -7194.35 -8824.98 2767.026 5176.1 -1853.33 -1318.58 2767.026 5176.1 -1853.33 -1318.58 1194.965 1834.855 1831.645 605.84 830.76 2245.943 1256.135 1324.428 1406.27 1527.354 1658.987 1055.912 758.19 2532.005 M3 313.993 -1303.34 486.116 -1683.62 34.685 -699.824 2510.099 -2287.14 -1989.3 -1466.46 511.778 -1808.71 105.49 -923.288 2333.363 -2351.88 -1716.1 3023.201 6456.297 -6202.3 -5871.19 3023.201 6456.297 -6202.3 -5871.19 8835.384 17690.53 -12014.5 -17105.4 8835.384 17690.53 -12014.5 -17105.4 -2049.35 -767.813 -1639.45 -596.718 -2058.35 -1073.12 130.47 2978.939 -3828.27 -4648.77 -1840.8 -560.145 -2217.81 -988.902 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG 10 TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX Loc Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top P -21268.6 -22305.6 -21269.8 -22306.8 -19492.2 -20529.2 -21486.7 -22523.7 -19492.2 -20529.2 -21486.7 -22523.7 -20190 -21227 -20788.9 -21825.9 -20190 -21227 -20788.9 -21825.9 -25632.9 -26670 -22747.9 -23784.9 -22302 -23339 -22524.1 -23561.2 -22525.7 -23562.7 -25522.8 -26559.8 -25121.5 -26158.5 -25321.4 -26358.4 -25322.9 -26359.9 -23217.4 -24254.4 -25562.1 -26599.1 -23217.4 -24254.4 -25562.1 -26599.1 -24037.7 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 125 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 1582.15 1582.15 1598.06 1598.06 4056.61 4076.92 -1086.15 -1106.47 4056.61 4076.92 -1086.15 -1106.47 2258.26 2264.35 712.2 706.1 2258.26 2264.35 712.2 706.1 1515.86 1515.86 669.27 669.27 1697.14 1697.14 1173.12 1173.12 1193.29 1193.29 1020.05 1020.05 1945.13 1945.13 1473.52 1473.52 1491.67 1491.67 4231.65 4251.25 -1466.06 -1485.66 4231.65 4251.25 -1466.06 -1485.66 2239.26 M2 1141.028 1702.642 1276.149 1885.275 11204.78 16124.93 -8705.86 -12782.4 11204.78 16124.93 -8705.86 -12782.4 4258.457 6035.326 -1759.54 -2692.79 4258.457 6035.326 -1759.54 -2692.79 2152.06 1669.264 1995.406 -468.2 2370.253 3076.631 2081.515 1172.803 2284.144 1435.629 1986.456 37.585 2323.818 3227.933 2063.954 1514.487 2246.32 1751.031 15046.01 20075.56 -10717.3 -17029.1 15046.01 20075.56 -10717.3 -17029.1 6059.288 M3 -247.876 2657.947 -3810.74 -4206.99 4068.195 7164.962 -8006.54 -8754.27 4068.195 7164.962 -8006.54 -8754.27 14617.64 23639 -18556 -25228.3 14617.64 23639 -18556 -25228.3 -3554.76 -1884.56 -3096.02 -1723.6 -3533.82 -2205.95 228.797 3778.054 -6858.64 -7707.6 -3333.76 -1675.52 -3727.78 -2109.64 -341.425 3275.968 -6720.12 -7061.12 4316.776 8100.634 -11234.4 -11933.9 4316.776 8100.634 -11234.4 -11933.9 20085.59 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 Loc Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom P -25074.8 -24741.7 -25778.8 -24037.7 -25074.8 -24741.7 -25778.8 -29695.6 -30732.6 -26338.3 -27375.3 -25832.7 -26869.7 -26084.6 -27121.6 -26086.4 -27123.4 -29562.1 -30599.1 -29107 -30144 -29333.7 -30370.8 -29335.4 -30372.4 -26925 -27962 -29578.1 -30615.1 -26925 -27962 -29578.1 -30615.1 -27853.2 -28890.3 -28649.8 -29686.8 -27853.2 -28890.3 -28649.8 -29686.8 -33712 -34749 -29886.7 -30923.7 -29327.8 -30364.8 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 126 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 2245.15 526.33 520.45 2239.26 2245.15 526.33 520.45 1417.13 1417.13 519.7 519.7 1682.11 1682.11 1089.82 1089.82 1111.99 1111.99 862.42 862.42 1908.59 1908.59 1375.53 1375.53 1395.48 1395.48 4347.93 4367.92 -1766.66 -1786.64 4347.93 4367.92 -1766.66 -1786.64 2209.79 2215.78 371.49 365.49 2209.79 2215.78 371.49 365.49 1293.77 1293.77 341.25 341.25 1654.72 1654.72 M2 7124.39 -1730.55 -4077.9 6059.288 7124.39 -1730.55 -4077.9 3013.488 1447.418 1832.233 -1775.68 4066.515 4043.785 2818.109 969.713 3080.639 1298.39 2001.65 -1202.68 4012.503 4034.842 2888.938 1268.177 3125.215 1563.986 19362.42 24296.27 -13386.7 -21652.1 19362.42 24296.27 -13386.7 -21652.1 7939.072 8257.816 -1963.39 -5613.67 7939.072 8257.816 -1963.39 -5613.67 3813.106 1098.842 1416.051 -3414.68 5910.869 5128.815 M3 30175.84 -27003.2 -34009.1 20085.59 30175.84 -27003.2 -34009.1 -5093 -2983.35 -4595.17 -2841.03 -5033.3 -3312.52 658.775 4921.743 -10287.2 -11075.3 -4867.96 -2780.52 -5262.28 -3204.86 -139.41 4205.973 -9990.83 -10191.4 4805.46 9286.299 -14768.4 -15327.7 4805.46 9286.299 -14768.4 -15327.7 26168.33 37261.5 -36131.3 -43302.9 26168.33 37261.5 -36131.3 -43302.9 -6611.02 -4090.02 -6083.15 -3978.37 -6505.32 -4414.48 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX Loc Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top P -29606.2 -30643.2 -29608.3 -30645.3 -33553 -34590 -33050 -34087 -33300.5 -34337.6 -33302.4 -34339.5 -30607 -31644 -33533.2 -34570.2 -30607 -31644 -33533.2 -34570.2 -31630.8 -32667.8 -32509.4 -33546.4 -31630.8 -32667.8 -32509.4 -33546.4 -37629.3 -38666.3 -33348.6 -34385.6 -32740.9 -33778 -33043.6 -34080.6 -33045.9 -34082.9 -37444.3 -38481.3 -36897.4 -37934.4 -37169.8 -38206.8 -37171.9 -38208.9 -34207.7 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 127 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 986.02 986.02 1009.95 1009.95 673.13 673.13 1855.25 1855.25 1253.42 1253.42 1274.96 1274.96 4528.32 4548.98 -2177.41 -2198.06 4528.32 4548.98 -2177.41 -2198.06 2183.38 2189.58 167.53 161.33 2183.38 2189.58 167.53 161.33 1138.94 1138.94 145.84 145.84 1592.08 1592.08 856.38 856.38 881.54 881.54 461.14 461.14 1762.75 1762.75 1100.62 1100.62 1123.26 1123.26 4668.87 M2 3499.245 657.164 3827.676 1056.976 1775.473 -2769.91 5820.809 4919.236 3650.347 894.75 3945.935 1254.581 24148.61 29098.17 -16642.1 -27093.9 24148.61 29098.17 -16642.1 -27093.9 9919.297 9482.431 -2412.8 -7478.16 9919.297 9482.431 -2412.8 -7478.16 4744.287 806.598 871.188 -5216.46 8114.309 6483.095 4292.91 395.976 4692.588 870.659 1459.729 -4475.53 7978.538 6054.07 4539.279 575.663 4898.989 1002.878 29948.34 M3 1440.804 6387.44 -14029.3 -14780.3 -6389.37 -3904.41 -6769.32 -4296.91 382.19 5424.82 -13540.9 -13626.1 5562.573 10743.23 -18531.2 -19008.4 5562.573 10743.23 -18531.2 -19008.4 32840.68 45038 -45809.3 -53303.2 32840.68 45038 -45809.3 -53303.2 -8131.02 -5212.05 -7586.29 -5146.24 -7968.33 -5516.08 2555.54 8149.919 -18110.2 -18812.2 -7923.73 -5057.53 -8267.56 -5390.39 1203.923 6909.012 -17395.2 -17356.9 6609.928 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX Loc Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom P -35244.7 -37383.3 -38420.3 -34207.7 -35244.7 -37383.3 -38420.3 -35318.7 -36355.8 -36272.2 -37309.2 -35318.7 -36355.8 -36272.2 -37309.2 -41435.1 -42472.1 -36712.7 -37749.8 -36062.1 -37099.1 -36386.1 -37423.1 -36388.7 -37425.7 -41223.1 -42260.1 -40637.6 -41674.6 -40929.2 -41966.2 -40931.5 -41968.5 -37718.8 -38755.8 -41113.3 -42150.3 -37718.8 -38755.8 -41113.3 -42150.3 -38906.4 -39943.5 -39925.6 -40962.6 -38906.4 -39943.5 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 128 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 4690.35 -2606.97 -2628.45 4668.87 4690.35 -2606.97 -2628.45 2124.42 2130.86 -62.52 -68.96 2124.42 2130.86 -62.52 -68.96 974.06 974.06 -54.17 -54.17 1518.96 1518.96 719.45 719.45 745.34 745.34 241.99 241.99 1657.8 1657.8 938.24 938.24 961.55 961.55 4829.87 4851.6 -3075.08 -3096.82 4829.87 4851.6 -3075.08 -3096.82 2065.2 2071.72 -310.41 -316.93 2065.2 2071.72 M2 34852.28 -20661 -33377.7 29948.34 34852.28 -20661 -33377.7 12290.61 11030.7 -3003.27 -9556.13 12290.61 11030.7 -3003.27 -9556.13 5771.15 601.496 182.78 -7156.67 10633.35 8139.331 5170.739 215.417 5645.394 767.241 1032.084 -6292.72 10437.6 7473.681 5521.247 342.158 5948.436 838.8 36895.52 41834.07 -25643.7 -40719.2 36895.52 41834.07 -25643.7 -40719.2 15069.48 13005.77 -3817.64 -11890.9 15069.48 13005.77 M3 12509.58 -22589 -23029 6609.928 12509.58 -22589 -23029 40243.82 53597.24 -56222.9 -64116.6 40243.82 53597.24 -56222.9 -64116.6 -9657.4 -6362.72 -9112.6 -6362.24 -9423.76 -6625.76 3979.195 10178.11 -22515.6 -23166.1 -9478.45 -6257.26 -9758.49 -6494.43 2304.166 8629.054 -21541.1 -21380.7 7986.211 14648.7 -26989.6 -27479.2 7986.211 14648.7 -26989.6 -27479.2 48466.78 63066.69 -67470.2 -75897.2 48466.78 63066.69 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 Loc Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top P -39925.6 -40962.6 -45139.5 -46176.5 -39986.3 -41023.3 -39301.9 -40338.9 -39642.7 -40679.7 -39645.5 -40682.5 -44897.9 -45934.9 -44282 -45319 -44588.7 -45625.7 -44591.2 -45628.3 -41157.9 -42194.9 -44724.8 -45761.8 -41157.9 -42194.9 -44724.8 -45761.8 -42405.8 -43442.9 -43476.8 -44513.8 -42405.8 -43442.9 -43476.8 -44513.8 -48751.8 -49788.8 -43177.9 -44214.9 -42468.3 -43505.3 -42821.5 -43858.6 -42824.6 -43861.6 -48478.2 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 129 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 -310.41 -316.93 823.38 823.38 -229.96 -229.96 1451.09 1451.09 597.49 597.49 623.64 623.64 45.63 45.63 1558.56 1558.56 790.33 790.33 813.86 813.86 4980.98 5001.05 -3504.48 -3524.55 4980.98 5001.05 -3504.48 -3524.55 2013.07 2019.08 -536.56 -542.58 2013.07 2019.08 -536.56 -542.58 684.05 684.05 -383.92 -383.92 1384.07 1384.07 488.23 488.23 511.91 511.91 -129.95 M2 -3817.64 -11890.9 6841.613 502.22 -693.076 -9194.09 13427.51 10102.21 6091.292 139.18 6643.139 768.939 439.911 -8185.93 13148.44 9180.737 6545.843 214.013 7042.504 780.795 45159.52 50128.72 -31855.8 -49162.8 45159.52 50128.72 -31855.8 -49162.8 18272.72 15447.4 -4969.01 -14481.5 18272.72 15447.4 -4969.01 -14481.5 7796.926 339.703 -1885.23 -11466.5 16359.56 12219.76 6922.25 26.508 7552.079 726.784 -469.202 M3 -67470.2 -75897.2 -11203.9 -7550.35 -10680 -7640.14 -10880.4 -7748.53 5681.001 12448.01 -27241.4 -27836.7 -11071.3 -7515.98 -11251.7 -7613.53 3653.613 10563.36 -25976.6 -25692.9 9754.214 17244.72 -31823 -32460.6 9754.214 17244.72 -31823 -32460.6 57635.88 73543.55 -79704.7 -88759.4 57635.88 73543.55 -79704.7 -88759.4 -12779.4 -8796.43 -12302.8 -9013.63 -12344.1 -8888.19 7635.949 14943.24 -32282.8 -32845.1 -12715.3 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX Loc Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom P -49515.3 -47839.6 -48876.6 -48157.6 -49194.6 -48160.3 -49197.3 -44532 -45569 -48228.7 -49265.7 -44532 -45569 -48228.7 -49265.7 -45825.3 -46862.4 -46935.3 -47972.3 -45825.3 -46862.4 -46935.3 -47972.3 -52230 -53670 -46249.7 -47689.7 -45523.2 -46963.2 -45884.8 -47324.8 -45888.1 -47328.1 -51922.6 -53362.5 -51268.8 -52708.7 -51594.2 -53034.1 -51597.2 -53037.1 -47799.6 -49239.6 -51585.6 -53025.5 -47799.6 -49239.6 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 130 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 -129.95 1461.25 1461.25 654.99 654.99 676.31 676.31 5093.32 5108.74 -3872.4 -3887.82 5093.32 5108.74 -3872.4 -3887.82 1957.07 1961.69 -736.15 -740.77 1957.07 1961.69 -736.15 -740.77 441.49 441.49 -632.77 -632.77 1251.24 1251.24 282.62 282.62 335.85 335.85 -419.54 -419.54 1276.06 1276.06 404.31 404.31 452.22 452.22 5091.68 5102.73 -4314.51 -4325.56 5091.68 5102.73 M2 -10315.4 15951.1 11002.2 7457.527 28.273 8024.373 658.522 54698.91 59620.6 -39552.9 -58911.6 54698.91 59620.6 -39552.9 -58911.6 21784.01 18208.42 -6637.97 -17499.5 21784.01 18208.42 -6637.97 -17499.5 9006.341 677.367 -3052.81 -14735 19766.71 16138.04 8006.961 240.038 8706.941 1162.962 -1327.38 -13213.1 19210.19 14572.67 8626.411 264.465 9256.393 1095.096 65926.64 76262.71 -48433.5 -74888.7 65926.64 76262.71 M3 -8868.33 -12752.4 -8755.43 5229.606 12692.85 -30697.3 -30316.6 11998.02 20411.47 -37192.1 -38127.9 11998.02 20411.47 -37192.1 -38127.9 67848.34 85165.26 -93042.4 -102882 67848.34 85165.26 -93042.4 -102882 -14404.3 -10470.9 -14014.4 -10895.1 -13817 -10383.5 9834.67 18817.44 -37666.1 -40096.1 -14444.2 -10718 -14266.6 -10257.5 7019.964 16023.33 -35730.8 -36998.8 14840.34 25409.6 -43258 -46486.1 14840.34 25409.6 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 Story TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET TANG TRET THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Load COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN COMB1 COMB1 COMB2 COMB2 COMB3 COMB3 COMB4 COMB4 COMB5 COMB5 COMB6 COMB6 COMB7 COMB7 COMB8 COMB8 COMB9 COMB9 COMB10 MAX COMB10 MAX COMB10 MIN COMB10 MIN COMB11 MAX COMB11 MAX COMB11 MIN COMB11 MIN COMB12 MAX COMB12 MAX COMB12 MIN COMB12 MIN COMB13 MAX COMB13 MAX COMB13 MIN COMB13 MIN Loc Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom P -51585.6 -53025.5 -49124.2 -50564.2 -50261 -51700.9 -49124.2 -50564.2 -50261 -51700.9 -56124.8 -57161.8 -49357.8 -50394.8 -48622.3 -49659.3 -48988.5 -50025.5 -48991.6 -50028.6 -55742.3 -56779.3 -55080.4 -56117.4 -55409.9 -56447 -55412.7 -56449.7 -51354.7 -52391.7 -55187.1 -56224.1 -51354.7 -52391.7 -55187.1 -56224.1 -52695.5 -53732.6 -53846.2 -54883.3 -52695.5 -53732.6 -53846.2 -54883.3 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 131 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V3 -4314.51 -4325.56 1804.1 1807.4 -1026.92 -1030.23 1804.1 1807.4 -1026.92 -1030.23 439.58 439.58 658.78 658.78 24.89 24.89 345.65 345.65 338.02 338.02 715.06 715.06 144.55 144.55 433.24 433.24 426.37 426.37 1993.98 1993.99 -1193.02 -1193.03 1993.98 1993.99 -1193.02 -1193.03 879.27 879.27 -78.31 -78.31 879.27 879.27 -78.31 -78.31 M2 -48433.5 -74888.7 25976.37 23452.72 -8483.2 -22078.7 25976.37 23452.72 -8483.2 -22078.7 10303.51 684.452 -5846.65 -13497.1 24563.09 15153.49 8895.799 377.546 9820.641 1278.885 -3475.4 -12193.9 23893.37 13591.58 9792.804 293.226 10625.16 1104.431 84382.15 70879.3 -64531.4 -69395.4 84382.15 70879.3 -64531.4 -69395.4 32356.58 21877.32 -12505.8 -20393.4 32356.58 21877.32 -12505.8 -20393.4 M3 -43258 -46486.1 79259.16 102721 -107677 -123798 79259.16 102721 -107677 -123798 -16503.1 -10655 -16251 -11077.2 -15666.7 -10587.1 13423.84 19076.13 -45341.6 -40740.4 -16711.6 -10893.2 -16185.8 -10452.2 9995.733 16244.74 -42893.1 -37590.2 19533.27 25302.1 -52104.1 -46753.8 19533.27 25302.1 -52104.1 -46753.8 96690.9 103500.8 -129262 -124953 96690.9 103500.8 -129262 -124953 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - 3.2.2 Phần tử Spandrel Story Spandrel Load Loc MAI S1 BAO MAX Left MAI S1 BAO MAX Right MAI S1 BAO MIN Left MAI S1 BAO MIN Right ST S1 BAO MAX Left ST S1 BAO MAX Right ST S1 BAO MIN Left ST S1 BAO MIN Right TANG 13 S1 BAO MAX Left TANG 13 S1 BAO MAX Right TANG 13 S1 BAO MIN Left TANG 13 S1 BAO MIN Right TANG 12 S1 BAO MAX Left TANG 12 S1 BAO MAX Right TANG 12 S1 BAO MIN Left TANG 12 S1 BAO MIN Right TANG 11 S1 BAO MAX Left TANG 11 S1 BAO MAX Right TANG 11 S1 BAO MIN Left TANG 11 S1 BAO MIN Right TANG 10 S1 BAO MAX Left TANG 10 S1 BAO MAX Right TANG 10 S1 BAO MIN Left TANG 10 S1 BAO MIN Right TANG S1 BAO MAX Left TANG S1 BAO MAX Right TANG S1 BAO MIN Left TANG S1 BAO MIN Right TANG S1 BAO MAX Left TANG S1 BAO MAX Right TANG S1 BAO MIN Left TANG S1 BAO MIN Right TANG S1 BAO MAX Left TANG S1 BAO MAX Right TANG S1 BAO MIN Left TANG S1 BAO MIN Right TANG S1 BAO MAX Left TANG S1 BAO MAX Right TANG S1 BAO MIN Left TANG S1 BAO MIN Right TANG S1 BAO MAX Left TANG S1 BAO MAX Right TANG S1 BAO MIN Left TANG S1 BAO MIN Right TANG S1 BAO MAX Left TANG S1 BAO MAX Right P 116.85 116.85 92.21 92.21 -34.36 -34.36 -61.6 -61.6 -44.67 -44.67 -87.19 -87.19 -52.77 -52.77 -102.65 -102.65 -56.47 -56.47 -119.94 -119.94 -65.21 -65.21 -145.19 -145.19 -68.17 -68.17 -165.18 -165.18 -70.41 -70.41 -183.99 -183.99 -73.57 -73.57 -205.62 -205.62 -74.02 -74.02 -226.02 -226.02 -72.29 -72.29 -245.99 -245.99 -70.5 -70.5 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 132 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V2 160.66 173.67 127.91 140.63 135.27 120.38 66.06 52.59 200.16 179.35 61.55 47.93 247.81 224.98 41.08 27.33 277.43 254.29 21.53 8.68 275.35 251.78 -21.42 -33.67 287.4 263.61 -46.86 -59.92 300.71 282.05 -66.26 -80.43 313.12 296.15 -91.02 -103.34 324.12 306.99 -114.03 -126.87 332.12 314.99 -136.43 -149.85 336.04 319.1 V3 -2.76 -2.76 -3.86 -3.86 4.45 4.45 3.07 3.07 5.25 5.25 3.39 3.39 5.16 5.16 3.25 3.25 5.19 5.19 3.15 3.15 5.19 5.19 3.03 3.03 4.89 4.89 2.73 2.73 4.82 4.82 2.49 2.49 4.89 4.89 2.42 2.42 4.67 4.67 2.19 2.19 4.36 4.36 1.9 1.9 3.97 3.97 M2 -1.695 1.436 -2.429 1.065 15.587 11.163 11.127 8.026 17.343 12.115 11.51 8.096 16.893 11.773 10.897 7.617 16.653 11.506 10.378 7.184 16.178 11.039 9.693 6.615 15.22 10.387 8.665 5.877 14.816 10.054 7.984 5.434 14.456 9.626 7.467 4.986 13.273 8.663 6.486 4.238 11.888 7.589 5.4 3.439 10.474 6.554 M3 108.219 -49.652 86.85 -63.341 57.929 -44.361 19.193 -76.477 91.56 -42.691 18.034 -108.558 117.635 -33.252 5.608 -132.121 133.975 -24.33 -5.536 -146.806 132.853 -4.506 -29.607 -146.511 139.217 8.502 -44.294 -151.829 146.893 19.251 -54.588 -160.861 153.272 30.871 -67.622 -168.105 159.445 42.987 -80.18 -173.802 165.156 55.179 -93.173 -177.969 168.807 67.325 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Story Spandrel Load Loc TANG S1 BAO MIN Left TANG S1 BAO MIN Right TANG S1 BAO MAX Left TANG S1 BAO MAX Right TANG S1 BAO MIN Left TANG S1 BAO MIN Right TANG S1 BAO MAX Left TANG S1 BAO MAX Right TANG S1 BAO MIN Left TANG S1 BAO MIN Right TRET S1 BAO MAX Left TRET S1 BAO MAX Right TRET S1 BAO MIN Left TRET S1 BAO MIN Right MAI S2 BAO MAX Left MAI S2 BAO MAX Right MAI S2 BAO MIN Left MAI S2 BAO MIN Right ST S2 BAO MAX Left ST S2 BAO MAX Right ST S2 BAO MIN Left ST S2 BAO MIN Right TANG 13 S2 BAO MAX Left TANG 13 S2 BAO MAX Right TANG 13 S2 BAO MIN Left TANG 13 S2 BAO MIN Right TANG 12 S2 BAO MAX Left TANG 12 S2 BAO MAX Right TANG 12 S2 BAO MIN Left TANG 12 S2 BAO MIN Right TANG 11 S2 BAO MAX Left TANG 11 S2 BAO MAX Right TANG 11 S2 BAO MIN Left TANG 11 S2 BAO MIN Right TANG 10 S2 BAO MAX Left TANG 10 S2 BAO MAX Right TANG 10 S2 BAO MIN Left TANG 10 S2 BAO MIN Right TANG S2 BAO MAX Left TANG S2 BAO MAX Right TANG S2 BAO MIN Left TANG S2 BAO MIN Right TANG S2 BAO MAX Left TANG S2 BAO MAX Right TANG S2 BAO MIN Left TANG S2 BAO MIN Right TANG S2 BAO MAX Left P -266.93 -266.93 -66.54 -66.54 -285.14 -285.14 -68.67 -68.67 -350.69 -350.69 -93.73 -93.73 -411.56 -411.56 -36.54 -36.54 -45.03 -45.03 -54.82 -54.82 -73.99 -73.99 -71.08 -71.08 -110.78 -110.78 -81.04 -81.04 -137.68 -137.68 -87.37 -87.37 -167.2 -167.2 -80.99 -80.99 -187.04 -187.04 -80.4 -80.4 -214.02 -214.02 -80.69 -80.69 -242.12 -242.12 -79.61 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 133 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V2 -159.59 -172.51 344.46 325.3 -193.49 -198.22 294.99 273.04 -216.86 -222.45 63.96 61.84 -88.22 -83.08 37.53 51.13 10.05 23.7 41.43 116.19 -32.69 44.76 81.72 165.98 -87.51 -7.12 131.38 213.71 -127.63 -50.73 169.75 250.92 -155.83 -81.55 173.91 252.46 -206.93 -136.65 194.29 270 -237.57 -171.5 218.81 293.69 -257.89 -194.14 243.68 V3 1.47 1.47 3.79 3.79 1.39 1.39 4.15 4.15 1.57 1.57 4.12 4.12 2.08 2.08 2.97 2.97 2.06 2.06 -0.96 -0.96 -1.64 -1.64 -0.99 -0.99 -1.88 -1.88 -0.92 -0.92 -1.69 -1.69 -0.93 -0.93 -1.7 -1.7 -0.88 -0.88 -1.7 -1.7 -0.67 -0.67 -1.53 -1.53 -0.59 -0.59 -1.51 -1.51 -0.62 M2 4.296 2.77 9.448 5.701 3.936 2.502 8.364 4.284 3.465 1.826 8.429 4.32 2.777 0.688 1.097 -1.244 0.805 -1.882 10.206 11.666 7.293 8.432 11.066 12.872 7.307 8.373 10.7 12.282 6.835 7.866 10.418 11.959 6.397 7.481 9.95 11.444 5.814 6.903 9.33 10.586 5.099 6.04 8.997 10.199 4.643 5.542 8.592 M3 -106.701 -180.256 174.525 81.417 -123.751 -182.031 149.71 82.096 -144.997 -151.759 19.466 22.84 -80.838 -64.712 14.139 -16.965 1.414 -31.878 26.88 -11.557 -8.931 -49.989 42.868 14.937 -37.058 -78.22 64.905 36.822 -58.635 -105.955 81.41 52.01 -74.236 -127.635 82.541 80.64 -99.834 -129.709 90.266 98.404 -116.691 -140.347 100.789 109.722 -128.046 -154.097 111.348 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Story Spandrel Load TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MAX TANG S2 BAO MIN TANG S2 BAO MIN TRET S2 BAO MAX TRET S2 BAO MAX TRET S2 BAO MIN TRET S2 BAO MIN MAI S3 BAO MAX MAI S3 BAO MAX MAI S3 BAO MIN MAI S3 BAO MIN ST S3 BAO MAX ST S3 BAO MAX ST S3 BAO MIN ST S3 BAO MIN TANG 13 S3 BAO MAX TANG 13 S3 BAO MAX TANG 13 S3 BAO MIN TANG 13 S3 BAO MIN TANG 12 S3 BAO MAX TANG 12 S3 BAO MAX TANG 12 S3 BAO MIN TANG 12 S3 BAO MIN TANG 11 S3 BAO MAX TANG 11 S3 BAO MAX TANG 11 S3 BAO MIN TANG 11 S3 BAO MIN Loc Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right Left Right P -79.61 -270.6 -270.6 -74.91 -74.91 -299.15 -299.15 -66.72 -66.72 -328.75 -328.75 -54.4 -54.4 -360.11 -360.11 -41.17 -41.17 -394.33 -394.33 7.26 7.26 -465.25 -465.25 -9.05 -9.05 -429.73 -429.73 54.18 54.18 37.58 37.58 -222.15 -222.15 -285.41 -285.41 -258.72 -258.72 -342.11 -342.11 -261.46 -261.46 -360 -360 -261.8 -261.8 -370.17 -370.17 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 134 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V2 317.6 -280.85 -219.61 269.09 339.91 -303.7 -246.97 294.16 361.68 -326.56 -274.65 316.6 381.25 -347.45 -299.97 337.68 401.52 -370.72 -325.51 361.5 421.42 -397.61 -358.71 118.55 178.3 -125.02 -72.28 -160.13 -145.14 -208.04 -192.55 -99.02 -75.14 -183.3 -152.07 -105.2 -78.05 -231.66 -196.55 -99.61 -73.58 -267.44 -236.54 -84.77 -61.01 -289.4 -259.29 V3 -0.62 -1.61 -1.61 -0.52 -0.52 -1.55 -1.55 -0.39 -0.39 -1.45 -1.45 -0.18 -0.18 -1.26 -1.26 -0.25 -0.25 -1.36 -1.36 -0.77 -0.77 -2.04 -2.04 0.33 0.33 -4.39 -4.39 -5.63 -5.63 -7.01 -7.01 -2.08 -2.08 -2.91 -2.91 -1.28 -1.28 -2.86 -2.86 -0.93 -0.93 -3.15 -3.15 -0.42 -0.42 -3.18 -3.18 M2 9.894 4.182 5.112 7.692 8.916 3.442 4.285 6.695 7.822 2.652 3.37 5.746 6.712 1.968 2.436 5.007 6.088 1.639 2.177 3.276 5.202 0.976 1.863 3.969 8.353 0.27 -0.061 -2.559 3.718 -3.308 3.033 14.499 17.121 10.444 12.806 16.292 18.363 11.005 13.079 15.831 17.943 10.535 12.505 15.586 17.55 10.199 11.839 M3 122.598 -140.561 -167.906 122.099 136.28 -153.166 -181.074 132.788 150.187 -165.674 -193.894 142.523 163.067 -177.094 -205.297 152.534 175.513 -190.368 -216.068 151.246 203.394 -194.211 -239.541 49.992 47.93 -69.772 -95.098 -66.053 111.279 -91.242 88.249 -109.301 13.374 -163.145 -16.542 -119.435 28.941 -196.792 -20.392 -111.246 46.665 -219.973 -20.584 -100.519 57.471 -232.052 -25.261 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - Story Spandrel Load Loc TANG 10 S3 BAO MAX Left TANG 10 S3 BAO MAX Right TANG 10 S3 BAO MIN Left TANG 10 S3 BAO MIN Right TANG S3 BAO MAX Left TANG S3 BAO MAX Right TANG S3 BAO MIN Left TANG S3 BAO MIN Right TANG S3 BAO MAX Left TANG S3 BAO MAX Right TANG S3 BAO MIN Left TANG S3 BAO MIN Right TANG S3 BAO MAX Left TANG S3 BAO MAX Right TANG S3 BAO MIN Left TANG S3 BAO MIN Right TANG S3 BAO MAX Left TANG S3 BAO MAX Right TANG S3 BAO MIN Left TANG S3 BAO MIN Right TANG S3 BAO MAX Left TANG S3 BAO MAX Right TANG S3 BAO MIN Left TANG S3 BAO MIN Right TANG S3 BAO MAX Left TANG S3 BAO MAX Right TANG S3 BAO MIN Left TANG S3 BAO MIN Right TANG S3 BAO MAX Left TANG S3 BAO MAX Right TANG S3 BAO MIN Left TANG S3 BAO MIN Right TANG S3 BAO MAX Left TANG S3 BAO MAX Right TANG S3 BAO MIN Left TANG S3 BAO MIN Right TRET S3 BAO MAX Left TRET S3 BAO MAX Right TRET S3 BAO MIN Left TRET S3 BAO MIN Right P -272.97 -272.97 -386.7 -386.7 -271.27 -271.27 -388.46 -388.46 -271.07 -271.07 -388.35 -388.35 -271.98 -271.98 -389.23 -389.23 -265.99 -265.99 -387.93 -387.93 -254.48 -254.48 -386.29 -386.29 -240.6 -240.6 -386.83 -386.83 -216.16 -216.16 -384.39 -384.39 -225.22 -225.22 -454.65 -454.65 -180.14 -180.14 -452.54 -452.54 GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 135 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN V2 -93.05 -72.61 -325.87 -297.68 -83.82 -67.16 -341.72 -316.12 -71.78 -56.05 -349.56 -323.7 -58.31 -42.85 -357.52 -332.85 -42.69 -31.23 -362.18 -341.8 -25.9 -19.42 -364.94 -348.58 -6.78 -4.34 -363.11 -350.16 13.31 13.55 -367.76 -354.42 92.16 83.69 -339.69 -328.89 41.14 44.39 -122.31 -125.37 V3 -0.11 -0.11 -3.33 -3.33 0.23 0.23 -3.48 -3.48 0.68 0.68 -3.42 -3.42 1.26 1.26 -3.26 -3.26 1.75 1.75 -3.23 -3.23 2.21 2.21 -3.23 -3.23 2.69 2.69 -3.22 -3.22 3.31 3.31 -3.21 -3.21 6.38 6.38 -1.04 -1.04 6.88 6.88 1.14 1.14 M2 15.027 17.011 9.61 11.066 14.099 16.132 8.771 9.994 13.7 15.595 8.292 9.139 13.323 14.945 7.941 8.32 12.149 13.644 7.139 7.125 10.768 12.189 6.237 5.839 9.375 10.702 5.362 4.562 8.335 9.525 5.108 3.821 7.709 6.23 4.987 1.129 9.272 2.709 2.621 1.164 M3 -103.26 75.699 -252.481 -20.671 -95.72 86.453 -260.612 -22.327 -86.179 92.692 -263.37 -26.928 -76.249 98.238 -266.389 -31.782 -64.725 104.007 -267.145 -35.55 -52.124 109.196 -266.317 -38.89 -38.478 111.924 -262.965 -43.796 -22.892 118.059 -260.314 -48.053 25.382 85.303 -266.027 -78.048 -26.298 0.363 -115.407 -71.497 SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4 ĐH KIẾN TRÚC TP.HCM 2014 THUYẾT MINH ĐỒ ÁN TỐT NGHIỆP KSXD KHÓA 2009 - PHỤ LỤC 4: KẾT QUẢ PHÂN TÍCH DAO ĐỘNG 4.1 TỌA ĐỘ TÂM CỨNG, TÂM HÌNH HỌC VÀ TÂM KHỐI LƯỢNG Story MAI SAN THUONG TANG 13 TANG 12 TANG 11 TANG 10 TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TANG TRET MassX 228.1716 2483.218 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3055.849 3096.968 2636.48 MassY XCM YCM XCCM YCCM XCR YCR 228.1716 24 14.406 24 14.406 24 13.604 2483.218 24 14.265 24 14.277 24 13.591 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.269 24 13.564 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.267 24 13.536 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.265 24 13.509 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.265 24 13.483 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.264 24 13.46 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.264 24 13.438 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.264 24 13.419 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.263 24 13.403 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.263 24 13.388 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.263 24 13.376 3055.849 24 14.262 24 14.263 24 13.363 3096.968 24 14.264 24 14.263 24 13.345 2636.48 24 14.265 24 14.263 24 14.143 4.2 MODE DAO ĐỘNG Chu kỳ Tần số UX UY RZ SumUX SumUY SumRZ (s) (Hz) % % % % % % 1.30 0.768 64.715 0.000 4.646 64.715 0.000 4.646 1.27 0.787 4.367 0.000 71.966 69.082 0.000 76.611 1.25 0.801 0.000 67.124 0.000 69.082 67.124 76.611 0.45 2.213 0.180 0.000 9.601 69.262 67.124 86.212 0.33 3.054 15.972 0.000 0.173 85.234 67.124 86.386 0.28 3.633 0.000 18.975 0.000 85.234 86.099 86.386 0.25 3.982 0.042 0.000 3.123 85.277 86.099 89.509 0.17 5.873 0.001 0.000 1.293 85.277 86.099 90.801 0.15 6.575 4.720 0.000 0.017 89.998 86.099 90.818 10 0.13 7.814 0.000 0.000 0.614 89.998 86.099 91.432 11 0.13 7.940 0.000 4.975 0.000 89.998 91.074 91.432 12 0.10 9.786 0.007 0.000 0.322 90.005 91.074 91.755 Mode GVHDKC: Thầy VŨ TÂN VĂN - 136 GVHDTC: Thầy PHẠM KHẮC XUÂN SVTH: NGUYỄN ĐÀO ĐĂNG KHOA MSSV: 09510300648_LỚP: XD09-A4