CASE STUDIES IN PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT phần 7 potx

08_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 134 135 9 WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY WITH ACTIVITY-BASED COSTING INFORMATION Profit in business comes from repeat customers. —W. Edwards Deming FOREWORD Jeff Thomson Intense competition is often an accelerator for innovation. In this case, Wendals Foods (a South African–based subsidiary of Aardvark Indus- tries, Ltd.) turned its innovative spirit in serving customers inside to de- sign and implement innovations in its business management processes. Wendals Foods was facing intense competition in the snack food in- dustry from multinational companies returning to South Africa and from smaller, local niche competitors. It designed and installed an ac- tivity-based costing (ABC) process in conjunction with a customer prof- itability model, which enabled it to make more strategic decisions on pricing, margins (product, customer, distribution channel, and loca- tion) and resource allocation. Wendals describes its implementation approach in the next case, and provides practical lessons learned that are portable to organizations of various size and scope. INTRODUCTION In businesses whose strategic thrust is to be customer focused, the accounting function’s cornerstone for adding value is providing customer profitability infor- mation determined on ABC principles. Customer profitability information helps to decide what to do, with what product, for which customer. It translates strategy into action by answering these types of questions: 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 135 • Do we push for volume or for margin with this customer? • Is there scope to change the way we package, sell, deliver, and so on to im- prove this customer’s profitability? • Does the turnover justify the discount/promotion structure we give this customer? Wendals Foods, a division of Best Brands Ltd., a subsidiary of Aardvark In- dustries Ltd., holds approximately 35% of the South African snack food market. Approximately 90 products are manufactured at two sites and are distributed to more than 24,000 outlets via close to 30 depots across 200 routes. This case de- scribes what Wendals Foods did to provide customer profitability and process cost and performance information to better manage its business. Best Brands is proudly South African. It encourages its staff to take the op- portunity to make a difference for themselves and for the company by working together with honesty, integrity, and trust at all times and by embracing the chal- lenges of change with a will-to-win-attitude. Best Brands is passionate about excellence in satisfying its consumers and customers. Its business perpetually attempts to deliver number-one–rated service and constant innovation, which is strongly supported by good systems and lead- ing conceptual approaches. ORGANIZATIONAL ISSUES The snack food industry is extremely competitive—to the extent that companies have not been able to recover from consumers inflationary cost increases. This position is not likely to change in the foreseeable future. Competition that has resulted in de- clining shelf space for Wendals Foods is coming from the return of multinational companies to South Africa and an increasing number of niche local competitors. To be competitive in the marketplace, Wendals needs to know the source of its profits. The key issue for profitability management is the profitability of brands (prod- ucts) and customers. Wendals’ customers range from large hypermarkets to small cor- ner cafés. Each individual customer affects the profitability of the brand and the market segment due to its purchasing habits, delivery location, and discount/rebate structures. In this environment, managing all elements of customer profitability, not just product cost, is critical. Discounts and promotions represent a substantial part of the margin that must be managed, along with the cost of serving the customer, at the customer level. Most of the data needed to manage the elements of customer profitability is available, but spread across many systems and not readily accessi- ble. Exhibit 9.1 illustrates how Wendals Foods will enable its management to drill 136 WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 136 137 Exhibit 9.1 Wendals Foods “Drill Down” 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 137 down from a nationwide view of the business to the sales of a particular product at a specific outlet and then to query how those costs are built up. CASE STUDY Initial Efforts Porter’s value chain was used as the basis for defining Wendals’ primary and support processes. Each process was then defined in greater detail by identifying up to ten ac- tivities. The processes that constitute the primary (product touching) processes are: • Inbound logistics. The procurement and storage of raw and packaging materials • Operations. The issue of materials into the factory, product manufacture, and packing and sealing of boxes • Marketing. All advertising, marketing, and promotional activities • Outbound logistics. Centralized warehousing, freight to depots, and depot warehousing • Sales and distribution. Taking orders, delivery from depot to customer, invoicing, and collection of payments Inbound logistics, operations, and marketing are product-related costs that vary primarily by the nature of the product and the pack size. Outbound logistics and sales and distribution are customer-related costs that may vary primarily by the location of the customer outlet and the nature of the sales and distribution process. Project Stages The project to develop customer and brand profitability was split into two phases: (1) a pilot project to prove the concept and develop an implementation plan and (2) the actual implementation. Pilot Phase A pilot ABC project initially was implemented to prove the value of the informa- tion and gain executive buy-in. A snapshot of six months of actual data was used 138 WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 138 to illustrate the information that could be produced by an ABC approach to cus- tomer profitability. Six steps were taken to implement the pilot: 1. Value chain processes were identified. 2. Key activities within each process of the chain were defined, including appropriate output measures and performance measures. 3. Five project teams comprised of different functional representatives were established to collect financial and nonfinancial data. 4. The data collected by each team was used in spreadsheets to illustrate and test basic ABC principles for each process. The results of each process were consolidated into a “snapshot” result for a sample of products and customers. 5. Mock-up customer and product profitability statements were developed. 6. The full-scale implementation approach and project plan were developed. Pilot Project Output The pilot project highlighted several issues for the business. Previously, a key measure was the “cost per case,” where various summary costs were divided by the number of cases produced. The ABC model proved that this was a gross sim- plification of the business and was more likely to mislead than to provide insight. Because high labor and capital costs were incurred in establishing a three-shift manufacturing environment, nonworking time in operations had a significant ef- fect on product cost. The sample ABC customer profitability information clearly demonstrated that outlet profitability would allow Wendals to reengineer its trading relation- ships with its customers to manage profitability. However, because of the cyclical nature of the business, the snapshot data were not good enough to illustrate the dy- namics of the customer relationship; monthly information was necessary. Sum- marizing activity-level ABC costs up to their processes also helped to identify the future directions for ABC development. It was obvious that although the inbound logistics and the marketing processes managed large cash outflows, their process costs were insignificant relative to the potential costs if their activities were performed ineffectively. Consequently Wen- dals decided to focus its process management efforts on process effectiveness and control the costs using good old-fashioned budgets. WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY 139 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 139 As far as the Operations process was concerned, the key issue was line utiliza- tion. The capacity for each machine in the line was determined, and the bottleneck machine that was the throughput constraint was identified. However, for the initial implementation, it was decided to split each production line only into processing and packaging because their different cost drivers (kilograms and packs per case, re- spectively) yielded good insights into cost behavior in the different parts of the man- ufacturing process. At a later stage the process costs would be broken down into greater detail for better management and improvement of the individual operations. The outbound logistics ABC analysis led to a questioning of the extent to which cost savings would be achieved by moving to “roll-on, roll-off” technology. This process was simplified for the initial implementation by calculating an average cost to move a case to a depot. The ABC analysis of the sales and distribution process highlighted the cost differentials between “preselling” and “knock and drop” routes and the dynamics of route profitability. Wendals is in the process of implementing hand-held computer technology for route accounting. The detailed data recorded by route accounting provide the ideal input into a route ABC system. That data will allow Wendals to identify each call that is made, how long the call took, and the product quantity sold. A key factor influencing route profitability is the number of calls that do not yield reasonable sales levels. However, for the initial implementa- tion, this process was simplified by averaging the route costs per client on the route. The rationale behind simplifying the data in the ABC implementation is to en- sure that a successful implementation can be made in a 3-month window. It is better to have information of reasonable quality quickly than to wait 18 months for perfec- tion with a high risk of project failure. After the initial implementation, the model can be extended down into the detail in a controlled fashion—also in 3-month windows. Focusing on key result areas using the information developed by the pilot has already identified an annual savings in excess of R6 million to the division— many times the total cost of the pilot project. The output from the pilot was suffi- cient for the executive to give the go-ahead to a full-production monthly customer profitability measurement and reporting system using process-level costs. Implementation Phase The objective of the implementation project was to deliver monthly, actual, process-based information that could be summarized into product and customer profitability. The information is used by: • Sales management to improve the profitability of trading relationships with customers 140 WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 140 • Marketing management to determine product pricing • General management to improve overall profitability using an activity- based management (ABM) approach to monitor cost and performance The full implementation enabled the reevaluation of outputs required from the system and the approach to be used. Due to the seasonal nature of the business, Wendals decided to calculate customer profitability on a monthly basis. Wendals determined that rather than developing a model at an activity level of detail, it would be quicker, more certain of success, and cheaper to develop the ABC model at the process level. A process could be broken down to the activity level of detail later, when the need arose. The spreadsheet software used for the pilot was not suitable for an ongoing production system. Oros (now SAS Activity-Based Man- agement) software was purchased to handle the ABC calculations. To achieve product, brand, market, and customer profitability, a two-stage ap- proach was required: 1. Use the ABC system to cost the products (including marketing cost) up to the end of the Marketing process in the value chain, thus producing a cost per case of each product and pack size variant. In addition, use ABC to pro- vide the outbound logistics and sales and distribution costs to get a case of product to the customer’s outlet and to collect payment for the sale. 2. Use a data warehouse to combine the rates per unit of output measure for each process from the ABC system. Use the distribution and sales data from the operating systems to calculate the required profitability state- ments based on actual customer sales for the period. A custom database was designed and built to handle the calculations needed to produce cus- tomer profitability data. An Executive Information System (EIS) tool and Excel were used to display the information and provide “slice-and- dice” and “what-if” capabilities. (The top-level information model design for the data warehouse is shown in Exhibit 9.2.) Implementation Steps The five steps in the full project implementation were: 1. Identify the source of all the data required for the ABC/warehouse sys- tems. Develop download formats and procedures to dump data monthly into a designated directory on the file server. A reliable, flexible, and WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY 141 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 141 automated tool set is required to handle the collection of data, the calcu- lations, and the export of the data to the data warehouse. 2. Design the resource, activity, cost object structure in an ABC package to calculate product and customer costs. Develop the import file structures to be able to import financial and nonfinancial data. 3. Develop a data model and build a data warehouse to process the sales and ABC data. Two key features of the warehouse are: (1) the ability to re- verse out erroneous data and reimport the correct data and (2) the ability to give each data set a name and to mix and match the data sets across the value chain. This gives the capability, for example, to assess the impact of a price increase for potatoes on June actual sales. 4. Design custom reports for users based on their requirements using an EIS tool or Excel. This step was crucial for gaining buyer buy-in; giving the managers the opportunity to specify exactly what they wanted ensured their commitment. 5. Provide “goal seek” and “what-if” capability for scenario planning. This gave the user the ability to flex the profitability calculations based on changes in volumes, costs, and pricing, for example: What if we de- creased the price by 10% and got a 5% increase in volume across the board? How would this affect the brand profitability? 142 WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY Depot Route Outlet Discount Factory Product Materials Customer Region Is Delivered to Makes Comprises Has Consumes Receives Has OwnsIs Sold at Receives Exhibit 9.2 Wendals Information Model 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 142 Initial Benefits/Outputs In a typical profitability statement from the data warehouse, the source of the data is shown for each element. The EIS has a drill-down capability that provides the details behind each element on the statement (see Exhibit 9.3). The building block for this statement is the cost of manufacturing each product and the cost of getting it to the customer’s outlet. The profitability can be viewed along any of the di- mensions shown in Exhibit 9.3. Initial Lessons Learned Most times when people say they have implemented ABC, they are referring to a snapshot analysis. Although a snapshot ABC project has its challenges, these are minor in comparison to the effort required to install a monthly running ABC pro- gram. A key success factor is ensuring the company has at least one person dedi- cated to the project—ideally the person who will take ownership of the system when the consultants leave. The speed with which the implementation of a WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY 143 Exhibit 9.3 Wendals Outlet Profitability Statement Support Detail 09_4611.qxp 1/23/06 12:53 PM Page 143 [...]... on the definition and promise of Business Intelligence 11 ABC AIRWAYS: IMPLEMENTATION LANDS MILLIONS IN PROCESS IMPROVEMENT SAVINGS Kaizen: gradual unending improvement by doing little things better, by setting and achieving increasingly higher standards —Masaaki Imai FOREWORD Ed Blocher This case is an excellent illustration of how activity-based costing /management (ABC/M) can provide new insights... heart of any strategic costing approach Treating all costs as entirely fixed or entirely variable is not likely to be appropriate at the activity, resource, process, or product levels The lack of a robust method for determining fixed versus variable costs could result in inappropriate marginal pricing and “smearing” of costs across product lines (resulting in inaccurate investment and resource allocation... change the paradigm in the culture of information management, in its control as well as in its application, in order to generate a common language for division wide understanding 2 To establish a communication platform for setting and monitoring financial objectives 3 To develop tools that support operational and strategic decision making, measure performance, and support forecasts In order to achieve... of the data warehouse With cost information needs in mind, its management met and compared the available alternatives in the market to choose the most appropriate option for what it was pursuing with IFMS in the ABC area The task was to find an integrated information system that normalized its measurements and that could give meaning to the information After evaluating several alternatives, it was... is to be commended for turning its passion for customer innovations inward to focus on improving key business processes, in this case the strategic costing process Making the 146 WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY “best” choices around customers, products, distribution channels, and resources was critical for Wendals to improve its market position in an increasingly competitive market It... improvement UNDERSTANDING THE BUSINESS NEEDS ABC Airways needed detailed cost information with particular focus on engine overhaul costs The lack of detailed operational and financial information did not allow management to fully understand the costs associated with producing or overhauling an engine and, to a lesser extent, the costs of each of the modules making up an engine This fact led management to ask... channels, services) Why Things Have Cost Better Decision Making Exhibit 10.2 Veri Glass Activity-Based Management Model Using the CAM-I Cross Derived from the Consortium of Advanced Management International (CAM-I) Veri Group is currently evaluating the suitability of employing outsourcing services In summer 2005 it will start an ABC benchmarking project with companies of the same international character... opportunities in local markets, it continues to further expand its business and introduce its brands into more international markets With its consumer, customer, and shopper always first in mind, Best Brands will continue to offer affordable South African brands with great taste, consistent quality, and a focus on health and well-being to discerning consumers around the world Armed with solid information... study of performance improvement initiatives Sometimes, though, you can learn as much from what is not said as what is Although it does not state it explicitly, this case illustrates the rarely understood symbiotic relationship between activity-based costing (ABC) and Business Intelligence (BI) Business Intelligence can be loosely defined as a group of technologies that assist in the gathering, storing,... determine the business solution needed to provide this information Some of the key questions included: • What are ABC Airways’ critical business issues? (See Exhibit 11.1.) • What industry trends are driving these issues? • What is the strategy to meet the needs of the changing business environment? • What operational and financial information would provide decision support to meet these business needs? . robust method for determining fixed versus vari- able costs could result in inappropriate marginal pricing and “smearing” of costs across product lines (resulting in inaccurate investment and resource. commended for turning its passion for cus- tomer innovations inward to focus on improving key business processes, in this case the strategic costing process. Making the WENDALS FOODS: MANAGING CUSTOMER. cost the products (including marketing cost) up to the end of the Marketing process in the value chain, thus producing a cost per case of each product and pack size variant. In addition, use ABC