Handbook of Psychotherapy Integration, Second Edition Part 5 pps

Cognitive Analytic Therapy 209 overactivity in therapists and passive resistance ently. She described her father as very stern and cried when describing how critical he was but in patients. added, “It was for my own good.” Later, she ver- bally attacked the psychotherapist for “making Maintenance her say bad things about him,” adding that he and Relapse Prevention was a perfect parent who, had he not died a few The maintenance and continuation of change years back, would have been very upset by the after a 16- or 24-week therapy depend on the mess her life was now in. She described how her internalization of the therapist as a corrective mother, with whom she currently shared a house, voice and on the continuing use of the tools had never sided with her against the father and develop ed in the thera py. Fo llo w-up at 3 months had never trusted her to manage anything in the usually shows that more has been retained than home. Neither parent had expressed any pleasure appeared likely during the ambivalent phase of when she graduated from college. termination. This experience of coping alone Kate “fell desperately in love” at the age of 20. is a positive one for most patients. Nonetheless, Despite episodes of mutual physical violence, she a proportion of patients, especially those with lived with the man and became pregnant by personality disorders, may need further help. choice when aged 27. No sooner was her daugh- This may take the form of further spaced ter Lily born than the couple separated, Kate be- follow-up sessions or a short spell of “top up” ing given custody. At 29, she met and married a sessions designed to reinforce what was “well-off and good looking” businessman and learned. In other cases, long-term “dilute” sup- had her second daughter, Tina. Soon after the portive therapy informed by the understanding birth, she requested a legal separation and the of the reciprocal role patterns may be appro- husband was granted custody of the child. She was priate. Patients needing a continuation of ac- currently trying to incre ase her access to Tina but tive therapy may be referred to group therapy, did not wish to take over full-time parenting and, therapeutic community, or day hospital pro- in any case, Social Services were conce rned about grams, preferably to receive various inputs her inc onsi sten t behavior toward the children. (such as other group activities, psychodrama, Kate herself described her attitude to her or art therapy) coordinated by CAT-informed daughters in strongly contrasting terms. Some- management. There may be a place for a sec- times she would be overwhelmed with longing ond CAT after a gap of a year or more, for and sadness for Tina and would describe Lily as example, with patients who, building on a first an unmanageable monster; at other times, she therapy, risk greater involvement with others would reject Tina and praise Lily. and encounter new forms of difficulty. Kate was given the Psychotherapy File. She checked traps concerned with the fear of hurting others, depressed thinking, and social isolation. She identified the following self-management di- CASE EXAMPLE lemmas: either I try to be perfect or I feel guilty, Kate, aged 33, consulted with the aim of obtain- and either I keep things and feelings in perfect order or I fear a terrible mess. Relationship dilem-ing psychiatric support for her request to be al- lowed more access to her 3-year-old daughter mas identified were: either I am involved and likely to get hurt or uninvolved, in charge butwho was in the custody of her husband, from whom she had separate d shortly after the birth of lonely; either I stick up for myself and am disliked or I give in, get put upon and feel cross and hurt;the child. She did not want psychotherapy, but agreed to attend for four asses sme nt sessions. A t and when involved with someone either I or they have to give in. Her score on the PSQ was 37.the end of this ti me, she accepted a further 20 ses - sions. Kate missed her third session, explaining at the next meeting that she had felt too upset. The ther-Kate was an intelligent and attractive woman who told her story histrionically and incoher- apist suggested that this might reflect the self- 210 Integrative Psychotherapy Models continue to work together to make sense of management dilemma of “either I keep things what, at present, is so often bewildering. and feelings in perfect order or I fear a terrible mess” and the relationship dilemma of “either I am involved and likely to get hurt or uninvolved, Kate was moved by the reformulation letter and brought it to the next session. She said it wasin charge but lonely.” At the next meeting, the provisional reformulation letter was read. perfect and needed no revision, adding that no- body had ever understood her before. Work onAfter recording how, as a child, she had had to work hard to avoid father’s criticism and how the diagram was started, but when a draft was of- fered at session 6, she said it made no sense atmother had never trusted her to be capable, the reformulation letter continued: all and tore it up. The final version (Figure 9.2), which encapsulates her borderline features, was It seems to me that, although your parents agreed on two sessions later. gave you a lot, they did not give you any se- Kate became far more aware of her idealiza- cure sense of your own worth. You experi- tion, of her slavish striving for praise, and of her enced your father as particularly rejecting switches into destructiv e anger. At session 11, she when you became adolescent, mocking your reported how she had prepared for a meetings with appearance and your normal interest in boys, and you felt too anxious to risk getting close her husband and social worker a bou t Tin a with the to people of your own age. The one way you aid of the diagra m and how this had enabled her could feel good about yourself was through to be calm and coh eren t for the firs t time. your achievement at school. It seems that it is Kate stopped her therapy after 15 sessions, still very important for you to win admiration saying it was too demanding to go on and that and praise but you still have no close friends she felt less distressed and more controlled than and often feel lonely and empty. With both the before. She had achieved more independence important men in your life you seem to have from her mother and was looking for separate ac- started by expecting too much and then, as commodation. The therapist wrote a brief good- things became difficult, you alternated be- bye letter, noting the changes that had been tween desperately striving to please them and achieved and the residual instability of mood and angry, sometimes violent, dis app oint ment . Sim- ilar switches affect how you are with your chil- emphasizing the need to continue self-reflection dren. It seems to me at this point that with Lily with the help of the diagram. At follow-up meet- you are sometimes harsh like your father was ings at 3 and 6 months, Kate reported that she to you and at other times you try to make it up now had a clearer understanding of her child- to her and be a perfectly caring parent. With hood and of how it had affected her attitude to- Tina you are facing the consequences of hand- ward her children. She also reported that her ing her over to her father; as we discussed, I mood and behavior were more even and con- wonder if this was your way of protecting her trolled. from what you feel is bad in you. Now, though Two main problems had faced the therapist in you miss her desperately, you feel unable to this case. The first stemmed from the fact that the take full care of her and can become very im- patient came seeking support for her wish for patient when she is with you, as a result of which your ex-husband and Social Services more access to Tina, rather than for help with her are only allowing you restricted access. personal difficulties. The experience of the first It seems that you can be angry, loving, de- assessment meetings was distressing, and she structive, and unhappy in extreme ways and missed the next appointment. (Normally patients that deep down you feel irrationally bad. Our lose any sessions missed without notification, but first important task will be to continue to work during assessment this rule is relaxed.) However, on the map we started as a way of understand- after completing the assessment process and re- ing the switches between these different states. ceiving the reformulation letter, she was able to It is probable that we will experience these commit herself to therapy, although she did fail states, for working at therapy may make you to attend on one subsequent occasion. The pre- feel exposed or angry or well cared for or dis- liminary understandings of the role procedures appointed at different times; our job will be to recognize and manage these changes and to derived from the history and the Psychotherapy Cognitive Analytic Therapy 211 Critical Rejecting Kate to daughters Kate to parents Rejected Guilty Deprived Placate Seek admiration perfectionist Resentful Ideally cared for Idealized care Fall in love Feel wonderful Disappointed FIGURE 9.2 Diagram of Kate. The number s in brack- ets indicate individuals with whom the procedures are clearly operating: 1 = Lily; 2 = Tina; 3 = first husband; and 4 = second husband File had helped the therapist to contain the dys- EMPIRICAL RESEARCH functional procedures that threatened therapy from the beginning. As explained above, many CAT features were originally developed in the context of research The second problem stemmed from the pa- tient’s “narrative incompetence” (Holmes, 1998). (Ryle, 1980), and smal l explorato ry studies have continu ed to i nfluenc e d eve lopments. The rap id Kate’s account of her life was full of the illogical jumps, obvious contradictions, and violent mood expansi on of CAT train ing , the fact that it takes place in a large number of center s, and the ex- swings typical of patients with borderline person- ality features. The idea that these could reflect al- treme shor tag e of rese arc h funding during the past two de cad es hav e l imi te d large-scale studies, ternating states of mind, which could be under- stood and connected, was put to Kate at the but some are now being undert ake n. The fol- lowing are the main published studies . second session. The process of identifying and describing her different states was initiated by a detailed consideration of her replies on the PSQ. Controlled Outcome Studies The development of the diagram supported the therapist in making sense of the patient’s various and at times extreme attitudes. Although Kate 1. A small, randomized comparison of CAT with focused dynamic therapy carried failed to carry out agreed self-monitoring based out by the same therapists and using on it, her use of it to prepare for her meeting with both nomothetic and ideographic (grid- her ex-husband and social worker demonstrated derived) measures showed a significantly that she had achieved more understanding and larger effect for CAT on the latter. The control through the use of it. Kate did not com- results indicated more change in the pa- plete the 24 sessions offered, and this doubtless tients’ dysfunctional self-attitudes and in reflected a persistent uncertainty about self-expo- associations between caring, depending, sure. However, her attendance for follow-up and controlling, and submitting (Brockman, her reports of continued change suggested that Poynton, Ryle, & Watson, 1987). she had achieved significant changes in personal- 2. Insulin-dependent diabetic patients with ity functioning. poor diabetic control despite nurse edu- 212 Integrative Psychotherapy Models cation were randomized between CAT Naturalistic Outcome Studies with Measured Outcomesand an equivalent number of sessions with a diabetic specialist nurse offering intensive education. The procedures as- 1. Mitzman and Duignan (1993; Duignan & Mitzman, 1994) described a CATsociated with poor self-management in- cluded depressive self-neglect (sometimes therapy group in which the patients’ re- formulation letters and diagrams, con-amounting to slow suicide), passive resis- tance to the clinic staff, and personality structed in four individual sessions, were shared in the subsequent 12 meetings offragmentation. The CAT focus on high- level procedures seemed particularly rel- the group. Five of the eight group mem- bers had Axis II diagnoses. One patientevant for such problems. HbA1 levels, in- dicating the average level of diabetic dropped out after two meetings. Mean changes in questionnaire scores and grid-control, fell in both groups at the end of 16 sessions, but this was not maintained derived measures in the remaining 7 cases were similar to those achieved inin the nurse education group, whereas in the CAT group further reductions oc- 16 sessions of individual CAT. 2. Garyfallos and colleagues (1998) as-curred. Measures of interpersonal diffi- culties improved significantly in the CAT sessed the effect of CAT in a large series of outpatient s in Greece using the MMPI.group only. 3. In a similar randomized controlled trial, They concluded that CAT offered a satis- factory approach in this setting.Cluely (perso na l communica tio n, March 2001) reported a significant effect of 3. Kerr (2001) described the use of CAT in post–acute manic psychosis and alsoCAT on increasing the quality of life and improving treatment adherence in pa- CAT treatment of a case of schizoaffec- tive disorder (Ryle & Kerr, 2002, pp.tients with poorly controlled asthma. 4. There have been two unsatisfactory ran- 167–172). 4. Ryle and Golynkina (2000) described thedomized controlled trials (RCTs) of CAT in anorexia nervosa. Treasure et al. outpatient treatment of a series of pa- tients with borderline personality disor-(1995) compared CAT with educational behavior therapy, and Dare, Eisler, Rus- der with up to 24 sessions of CAT, in most cases by trainees. Of the 31 patientssell, Treasure, & Dodge (2001) com- pared CAT with routine care, a psycho- starting treatment, 4 dropped out. The remaining 27 patients were all assesseddynamic in ter ve nti on, and family therapy. It is hard to draw conclusions from these at a 6-month follow-up, and 18 attended at 18 months posttherapy. At 6 months,studies for, though CAT was reasonably effective and patients were positive about mean psychometric scores were signifi- cantly lower, and half the sample nothe approach, in neither case were the CAT therapists trained. Further, in the longer met Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders IV (DSM-latter study, the effect of a 7-month CAT was compared to 12-months of the other IV) criteria for BPD; these were catego- rized as improved. The pretherapy assess-interventions. 5. Pollock (personal communication, Octo- ments showed that the unimproved pa- tients were less likely to have been inber 2002) compared 16 sessions of CAT with a waiting list control condition in employment or in any ongoing relation- ship and were more likely to have a his-female survivors of childhood sexual abuse. CAT showed clinically and statistically tory of self-harm, violence, and alcohol abuse than were the improved group.significant treatment effects. 6. Controlled trials are currently in process Follow-up at 18 months showed further reductions in psychometric scores inwith personality-disordered patients and with seriously disturbed adolescents. both groups. Cognitive Analytic Therapy 213 clinical disorders. The approach will doubt- Studies of Phenomenology less continue to be modified and will need and Change evaluation in these various applications. It is likely to be applied more frequently to workClarke and Llewelyn (1994; Clarke & Pearson, 2000) reported studies of adult abuse survivors. with couples and families, where it is compati- ble with systems theory approaches, and toRyle and Marlowe (1995) described the clini- cal and research uses of the self-states sequen- group therapy. In the care and management of personalitytial diagram. Golynkina and Ryle (1999) used repertory grids to identify the characteristics of disorders and major mental illnesses, CAT has, I believe, an important contribution to make.the partially dissociated states of a series of bor- derline patients, and Ryle (1995) linked state It provides, in accessible language, descriptions of interactions that can be shared by patientsdiagrams t o me as ure me nts of variatio ns in trans- ference and countertransference during the and staff. The more technical contributions of CAT, notably the value of written and dia-therapies of two borderline patients. Pollock (1996) reported repertory grid studies of a group grammatic reformulation, have two parts to play: one in extending patients’ capacity forof sexually abused women who had committed violence against their partners, demonstrating self-reflection, and the other in supporting clinical workers in the creation and mainte-how it was necessary for the therapist to ac- knowledge the patients’ self-perceptions as guilty nance of a working alliance that can guard against inadvertent collusion and allow an au-abusers before the guilt irrationally associated with the victim role could be reconsidered. thentic human interchange. CAT continues to aim for integration at theSheard et al. (2000) described a CAT-derived three-session intervention for patients present- level of theory and practice, being committed to the creation of a conceptual base that ising to emergency departments with repeated deliberate self-harm. compatible with what is reliably known about human development, personality, and therapy. Such a base supports the critical evaluation Measures of Model Adherence and continuing selective assimilation of ideas and Process from other models. This should generate a continuing debate,Bennett and Parry (1998), using reliable alter- native analyses of the therapy dialogue, demon- but so far this has not been forthcoming. Expo- sitions of the differences between the idea ofstrated the accuracy of the CAT joint reformu- lation of a borderline patient. Methods for the the schema and the procedure and of the na- ture of sign-mediated internalization as op-microanalysis of audiotapes or transcripts of therapy sessions were developed (the Therapist posed to representation have not been dis- cussed; the radical critiques made of selectedIntervention Coding) with the aim of identify- ing how threats to the therapeutic alliance psychoanalytic ideas and practices have re- mained uncommented upon. The CAT dia-were managed (Bennett, 1998; Bennett & Parry, 2003). The use of an early version of this logical understanding of early development, self-processes, and therapeutic change impliesin the supervision of CAT therapists is de- scribed in Ryle (1997a). Bennett and Parry (in a challenge to common philosophical assump- tions about how humans should be thoughtpress) have also developed a method of mea- suring competence in delivering CAT. about and will, I suspect, be widely misunder- stood but I hope will eventually be construc- tively debated. Differences in language and un- derlying paradigms, even though they oftenFUTURE DIRECTIONS conceal considerable areas of agreement, make much debate as constructive as conversationsThe development of CAT is not over. As a framework for individual therapy, it is being in the Tower of Babel. However, the difficul- ties cannot be resolved by adherence to parishapplied in different contexts and to different 214 Integrative Psychotherapy Models loyalties or by bland assertions that we are all Bennett, D. & Parry, G. (in press). A measure of psychotherapeutic competence derived from doing the same thing really. In both theory and in values, CAT is insis- cognitive analytic therapy (CAT). Psychother- apy Research. tent on the need for psychotherapists to work from an understanding of the whole person. Bennett, D., Pollock, P., & Ryle, A. (in press). The States Description Procedure: The use ofReductive models of human functioning, whether by overemphasizing the role of genes, guided self-reflection in the case formulation of patients with borderline personality disorder. behaviors, cognitions, or unconscious forces, have damaging ethical implications. In its em- Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy. Brockman, B., Poynton, A., Ryle, A., & Watson, J. phasis on the profound and subtle influence of human culture on individual personal develop- P. (1987). Effectiveness of time-limited therapy carried out by trainees: A comparison of two ment, CAT does not deny these factors. But nor should psychotherapists deny that we and methods. British Journal of Psychiatry, 151, 602–609. our patients live in, and internalize much of a world where increasing wealth is linked with Clarke, S., & Llewelyn, S. (1994). Personal con- structs of survivors of childhood sexual abuse persistent gross inequalities, increasing loneli- ness, depression, passivity, and powerlessness. receiving cognitive analytic therapy. British Jour- nal of Medical Psychology, 67, 273–289. These forces effectively diminish the individu- al’s sense of self and connection with others; Clarke, S., & Pearson, C. (2002). Personal con- structs of male survivors. Unpublished manu- we need to bear witness to this. In our relation- ships with our patients, we need to challenge, script. Coleman, P. (1999). Identity management in later not reinforce, the internalized social sources of psychological damage. life. In R. T. Woods (Ed.), Psychological prob- lems of ageing: Assessment, treatment and care (pp. 49–72). Chichester: Wiley. References Dare, C., Eisler, I., Russell, G., Treasure, J., & Dodge, L. (2001). Psychological therapies forBeck, A. T. (1976). Cognitive therapy and the emo- tional disorders. New York: International Uni- adults with anorexia nervosa. British Journal of Psychiatry, 178, 216–221.versities Press. Bell, L. (1999). The spectrum of psychological dis- Dunn, M., & Parry, G. (1997). A formulated care plan approach to caring for borderline person-orders in people with eating disorders. An anal- ysis of 30 eating disordered patients treated ality disorder in a community mental health setting. Clinical Psychology Forum, 104, 19–22.with Cognitive Analytic Therapy. Clinical Psy- chology and Psychotherapy, 6, 29–38. Duignan, I., & Mitzman, S. (1994). Change in pa- tients receiving time-limited cognitive analyticBennett, D. (1998). Deriving a model of therapist competence from good and poor outcome cases group therapy. International Journal of Short- Term Psychotherapy, 9, 1151–1160.in the psychotherapy of borderline personality disorder. Unpublished doctoral thesis. Univer- Fosbury, J. A., Bosley, C. M., Ryle, A., Sonksen, P. H., & Judd, S. L. (1997). A trial of cognitivesity of Sheffield. Bennett, D., & Pa rry, G. (1998). The accuracy of re- analytic therapy in poorly controlled type 1 pa- tients. Diabetes Care, 20, 959–964.formulatio n in c ogni tive analytic therapy: A vali- dation study. Psychotherapy Research, 8, 84–103. Frank, J. D. (1961). Persuasion and healing. Balti- more: Johns Hopkins University Press.Bennett, D., & Parry, G. (2003). Maintaining the therapeutic alliance: resolving alliance-threat- Frank, J. D., & Frank, J. B. (1991). Persuasion and healing (3rd ed.). Baltimore: Johns Hopkinsening interactions related to the transference. In D. Charman (Ed.), Core processes in brief University Press. Garyfallos, G., Adamopolou, A., Karastergiou, A.,psychodynamic therapy: Advancing effective prac- tice (pp. 251–27 2). M ahwa h, NJ : Lawren ce Erl- Voikli, M., Zlatanos, D., & Tsifida, S. (1998). Evaluation of cognitive analytic therapy (CAT)baum. Cognitive Analytic Therapy 215 outcome in Greek psychiatric outpatients. The disorder: The model and the method (pp. 128– 145). Chichester: Wiley.European Journal of Psychiatry, 12, 167–179. Golynkina, K., & Ryle, A. (1999). The identification Leiman, M. (1992). The concept of sign in the work of Vygotsky, Winnicott, and Bakhtin: Furtherand characteristics of the partially dissociated states of patients with borderline personality integration of object relations theory and activ- ity theory. British Journal of Medical Psychol-disorder. British Journal of Medical Psychology, 72, 429–445. ogy, 65, 209–221. Leiman, M. (1994). Projective identification as earlyHepple, J. (2002). Cognitive analytic therapy. In J. Hepple, J. Pearce, & P. Wilkinson (Eds.), Psy- joint action sequences: A Vygotskian adden- dum to the procedural sequence object rela-chological therapies with older people. Develop- ing treatments for effective practice (pp. 128– tions model. British Journal of Medical Psychol- ogy, 67, 97–106.160). Hove: Brunner-Routledge. Hepple, J. (2004). Ageism in therapy and beyond. Leiman, M. (1997). Procedures as dialogical se- quences. A revised version of the fundamentalIn J. Hepple & L. Sutton (Eds.), Cognitive ana- lytic therapy and later life. A new perspective on concept in cognitive analytic therapy. British Journal of Medical Psychology, 70, 193–207.old age (p. 4). Hove: Brunner-Routledge. Hepple, J., & Sutton, L. (in press). Cognitive ana- Mann, J. (1973). Time-limited psychotherapy. Cam- bridge, MA: Harvard University Press.lytic therapy in later life. A new perspective on old age. Hove: Brunner-Routledge. Miller, G. A., Galanter, E., & Pribram, F. H. (1960). Plans and the structure of behavior.Holmes, J. (1998). Narrative in psychotherapy. In C. Mace (Ed.), Heart and soul. London: New York: Holt. Mitzman, S., & Duignan, I. (1993). One man’sRoutledge. Kelly, G. A. (1955). The psychology of personal con- group: Brief CAT group therapy and the use of SDR. Counselling Psychology Quarterly, 6,structs. New York: Norton. Kerr, I. B. (1999). Cognitive analytic therapy for 183–192. Neisser, U. (1967). Cognitive psychology. New York:borderline personality in the context of a com- munity mental health team: Individual and or- Appleton. Pollock, P. H. (1996). Clinical issues in the cogni-ganisational psychodynamic implications. Brit- ish Journal of Psychotherapy, 15, 425–438. tive analytic therapy of sexually abused women who commit violent offences against their part-Kerr, I. B. (2000). Vygotsky, activity theory, and the therapeutic community: A further paradigm? ners. British Journal of Medical Psychology, 69, 117–127.Therapeutic Communities, 21, 151–164. Kerr, I. B. (2001). Brief cognitive analytic therapy Pollock, P. H. (Ed.). (2001). Cognitive analytic ther- apy for survivors of childhood abuse. Chiches-for post-acute manic psychosis on a psychiatric intensive care unit. Clinical Psychology and ter: Wiley. Pollock, P. H., & Belshaw, T. (1998). Cognitive an-Psychotherapy, 8, 117–129. Kerr, I. B., Birkett, P. B. L., & Chanen, A. (2003). alytic therapy for offenders. The Journal of Fo- rensic Psychiatry, 9, 629–642.Clinical and service implications of a cognitive analytic therapy (CAT) model of psychosis. Pollock, P. H., Broadbent, M., Clarke, S., Dorrian, A. J., & Ryle, A. (2001). The personality struc-Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychi- atry, 37, 515–523. ture questionaire (PSQ): A measure of the mul- tiple self-states model of identity disturbance inKernberg, O. F. (1989). In O. F. Kernberg, M. A. Selzer, H. W. Koenigsberg, A. C. Carr, & cognitive analytic therapy. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, 8, 59–67.A. H. Applebaum, (Eds.), Psychodynamic psy- chotherapy of borderline patients (p. 18). New Robbins, I., & Sutton, L. (in press). A coming to- gether of CBT and CAT. Sequential diagram-York: Basic Books. Leighton, T. (1997). Borderline personality and sub- matic reformulation of the long term effects of complex and distant trauma. In J. Hepple & L.stance abuse problems. In A. Ryle (Ed.), Cogni- tive analytic therapy and borderline personality Sutton (Eds.), Cognitive analytic therapy and 216 Integrative Psychotherapy Models later life. A new perspective on old age (pp. 146– theory and practice. British Journal of Psycho- therapy, 12, 60–66.176). Hove: Brunner-Routledge. Ryle, A. (1967). Neurosis in the ordinary family. Ryle, A. (1996). Ogden’s autistic-contiguous posi- tion and the role of interpretation in psychoan-London: Tavistock Publications. Ryle, A. (1975). Frames and cages. London: Sussex alytic theory building. British Journal of Medi- cal Psychology, 69, 129–138.University Press. Ryle, A. (1978). A common language for the psycho- Ryle, A. (1997a). Cognitive analytic therapy and bor- derline personality disorder: The model and thetherapies. British Journal of Psychiatry, 132, 585–594. method. Chichester: Wiley. Ryle, A. (1997b). The structure and development ofRyle, A. (1979a). The focus in brief interpretative psychotherapy: Dilemmas, traps, and snags as borderline personality disorder: A proposed model. British Journal of Psychiatry, 170, 82–target problems. British Journal of Psychiatry, 134, 46–54. 87. Ryle, A. (1998). Transferences and countertransfer-Ryle, A. (1979b). Defining goals and assessing change in brief psychotherapy: A pilot study us- ences: The cognitive analytic therapy perspec- tive. British Journal of Psychotherapy, 14, 303–ing target ratings and the dyad grid. British Journal of Medical Psychology, 52, 223–233. 309. Ryle, A. (2001). Constructivism and Cognitive Ana-Ryle, A. (1980). Some measures of goal attainment in focused, integrated, active psychotherapy: A lytic Therapy (CAT). Constructivism in the Hu- man Sciences, 6, 51–58.study of fifteen cases. British Journal of Psychia- try, 137, 475–486. Ryle, A. (2003). Something more than the “some- thing more than interpretation” is needed. ARyle, A. (1982). Psychotherapy: A cognitive integra- tion of theory and practice. London: Academic comment on t he paper by the process of change study group. International Journal of Psycho-Press. Ryle, A. (1984). How can we compare different psy- analysis, 84, 109–118. Ryle, A., & Beard, H. (1993). The integrative effectchotherapies? Why are they all effective? Brit- ish Journal of Medical Psychology, 57, 261– of reformulation: Cognitive analytic therapy with a patient with borderline personality disor-264. Ryle, A. (1985). Cognitive theory, object relations, der. British Journal of Medical Psychology, 66, 249–258.and the self. British Journal of Medical Psychol- ogy, 58, 1–7. Ryle, A, & Golynkina, K. (2000). Effectiveness of time-limited cognitive analytic therapy of bor-Ryle, A. (1990). Cognitive analytic therapy: Active participation in change. Chichester: Wiley. derline personality disorder: Factors associated with outcome. British Journal of Medical Psy-Ryle, A. (1991). Object relations theory and activity theory: A proposed link by way of the proce- chology, 73, 197–210. Ryle, A., & Kerr, I. B. (2002). Introducing cognitivedural sequence model. British Journal of Medi- cal Psychology, 64, 307–316. analytic therapy: Principles and practice. Chi- chester: Wiley.Ryle, A. (1992). Critique of a Kleinian case presen- tation. British Journal of Medical Psychology, Ryle, A., & Marlowe, M. (1995). Cognitive analytic therapy of borderline personality disorder: The-65, 309–317. Ryle, A. (1993). Addiction to the death instinct? A ory and practice and the clinical and research uses of the self states sequential diagram. Inter-critical review of Joseph’s paper “Addiction to near death.” British Journal of Psychotherapy, national Journal of Short-term Psychotherapy, 10, 21–34.10, 88–92. Ryle, A. (1994). Projective identification: A particu- Sheard, T., Evans, J., Cash, D., Hicks, J., King, A., Morgan, N., et al. (2000). A CAT-derived onelar form of reciprocal role procedure. British Journal of Medical Psychology, 67, 107–114. to three session intervention for repeated delib- erate self harm: A description of the model andRyle, A. (1995). Defensive organisations or collusive interpretations? A further critique of Kleinian initial experience of trainee psychiatrists in us- Cognitive Analytic Therapy 217 ing it. British Journal of Medical Psychology, Treasure, J., Todd, G., Brolly, M., Tiller, G., Nehmed, A., & Denman, F. (1995). A pilot73, 179–196. Sutton, L. (2002). Introduction: Contemporary study of a randomised trial of cognitive analytic therapy vs. educational behaviour therapy forviews-a duel with the past. In J. Hepple, J. Pearce, & P. Wilkinson (Eds.), Psychological adult anorexia nervosa. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 33, 363–367.therapies with older people (pp. 1–20). Hove: Brunner-Routledge. [...]... (Eds.), Comprehensive handbook of psychotherapy integration (pp 87–100) New York: Plenum Shapiro, D., & Firth, J (1987) Prescriptive vs exploratory psychotherapy: Outcomes of the Sheffield Psychotherapy Project British Journal of Psychiatry, 151 , 790–799 Shapiro, D., & Firth-Cozens, J (1990) Two year follow-up of the Sheffield Psychotherapy Project British Journal of Psychotherapy, 151 , 790– 799 Silberschatz,... that will be of use with the next patient References Alexander, F (1963) The dynamics of psychotherapy in the light of learning theory American Journal of Psychiatry, 120, 440–448 Alexander, F., & French, T (1946) Psychoanalytic therapy New York: Ronald Press Allen, D M (1993) Unified psychotherapy In G Stricker & J R Gold (Eds.), Comprehensive handbook of psychotherapy integration (pp 1 25 138) New... Annual Conference of the Society for the Exporation of Psychotherapy Integration, New York City Singer, E (19 65) Key concepts in psychotherapy New York: Basic Books Stricker, G., & Gold, J (1988) A psychodynamic approach to the personality disorders Journal of Personality Disorders, 2, 350 – 359 Stricker, G., & Gold, J (1996) An assimilative model for psychodynamically oriented integrative psychotherapy. .. Practice, 3, 47 58 Stricker, G., & Gold, J (2002) An assimilative ap- proach to integrative psychodynamic psychotherapy In J Lebow (Ed.), Comprehensive handbook of psychotherapy, Vol 4: Integrative/ Eclectic (pp 2 95 316) New York: Wiley Stricker, G., & Trierweiler, S J (19 95) The local clinical scientist: A bridge between science and practice American Psychologist, 50 , 9 95 1002 Strupp, H H (1993) Psychotherapy. .. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 10, 207–220 Gold, J (May, 2003) A comment on Control-Mastery Theory Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference of the Society for the Exporation of Psychotherapy Integration, New York City Gold, J R., & Stricker, G (1993) Psychotherapy integration with personality disorders In G Stricker & J R Gold (Eds.), Comprehensive handbook of psychotherapy integration... Plenum Gold, J., & Stricker, G (2001) Relational psychoanalysis as a foundation for assimilative integration Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 11, 47–63 239 Goldfried, M (1999) A participant-observer’s perspective on psychotherapy integration Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 9, 2 35 242 Greenberg, J., & Mitchell, S (1983) Object relations theories in psychoanalysis Cambridge, MA: Harvard Greenberg,... sense is a central mechanism of change We believe that an enhanced and expanded awareness of the warded off, unconscious meanings of one’s life experience, of the effects of intrapsychic conflict, and of an appreciation for the ways in which we unwittingly repeat our histories and find our parents and significant others in current relationships, often leads to a greater sense of psychological freedom, to... Miller, N E (1 950 ) Personality and psychotherapy New York: McGraw-Hill Feather, B W., & Rhodes, J W (1973) Psychodynamic behavior therapy I: Theory and rationale Archives of General Psychiatry, 26, 496– 50 2 Fensterheim, H (1993) Behavioral psychotherapy In G Stricker & J R Gold (Eds.), Comprehensive handbook of psychotherapy integration (pp 73–86) New York: Plenum Frank, K (1999) Psychoanalytic participation... work of Pavlov American Journal of Psychiatry, 89, 11 65 1203 Freud, S (1912) Recommendations to physicians practicing psychoanalysis Standard Edition 1 958 ;12:111–120 London: Hogarth Press Gold, J (1980) A retrospective study of the behavior therapy experience Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Adelphi University, Garden City, NY Gold, J (2000) The psychodynamics of the patient’s activity Journal of Psychotherapy. .. process This is inherent in an exploratory, psychodynamically informed psychotherapy, wherein a central goal of the treatment is the progres- 224 Integrative Psychotherapy Models sive expansion of our understanding of the patient and of her or his self-knowledge We do not separate the treatment into phases of formal assessment and psychotherapy, but as new material and understanding progressively emerges, . personality struc-Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychi- atry, 37, 51 5 52 3. ture questionaire (PSQ): A measure of the mul- tiple self-states model of identity disturbance inKernberg, O. F. (1989) British Journal of Psychiatry, 132, 58 5 59 4. method. Chichester: Wiley. Ryle, A. (1997b). The structure and development ofRyle, A. (1979a). The focus in brief interpretative psychotherapy: Dilemmas,. 6, 51 58 .study of fifteen cases. British Journal of Psychia- try, 137, 4 75 486. Ryle, A. (2003). Something more than the “some- thing more than interpretation” is needed. ARyle, A. (1982). Psychotherapy: