Dđ^ g“_Y UZx ecũú_Y& ộũô_Y ê¿[& UZ[_Z dkUZ Unn ờặ_Y

Một phần của tài liệu Phương pháp phân tích luật viết - Một số vấn đề lý luận cơ bản: Phần 1 (Trang 61 - 74)

D Z“_Y ZũÃU ộ[∑^ UZ[_Z UŒS UkU aZk erUZ ởFZl erUZ UZũS e`l V[

Dđ^ g“_Y UZx ecũú_Y& ộũô_Y ê¿[& UZ[_Z dkUZ Unn ờặ_Y

ê¿[& UZ[_Z dkUZ Unn ờặ_Y

=âẩ^ X]– ỷÁ mv ]Á^ X]Ù c\]ÊV' ajĂi k^–i e]sc sc]

k t i] w X]x ]d s X] Å igâòc\' ỷâẻc\ a~^' X ]zc ] hsX] XÅV † v c \ <Ác\ h c) E j ~c e ] s c izX] a j Ă i k^–i b Á i XsX] ỷ Å c\ ỷsc ' c\â}^ c \ ]^y c Xˆj kt e ]s c izX] X] jn yc

c\] ^◊ e e ]s ^ ộœ_Y g“_Y ecq_ bfS_ ộ[∑^ UZ[_Z eZv_Yg∂ ^´e UZ[_Z 97[" L gd c \ ỷ V h~ igâẻ c\ ]ễe' k^◊X e ] u c g∂ ^´e UZ[_Z 97[" L gd c \ ỷ V h~ igâẻ c\ ]ễe' k^◊X e ] u c izX] aj Ă i k^–i X]Ÿ X]d gV c ]˙ c\ ` – i fj i ] j Ω c iâự `˛ i ] j Ă i' X ]jky c b~c6 hdc\ XĐ c\ X| c ]˙ c \ igâ ò c \ ]ễe XsX `– i fj e ] u c izX] XΩ c ỷâễX ỷ s c ] \^s ẽ \|X ỷÁ X ] zc ] ig€ kt X]^ ỷâễX X ]ê e c ]Ă c b Ái ` ]^ ifl gV e] ầ ]ểe kẩ^ ỷâ}c\ a~a' X] Ù igâòc\' X ]zc ] hsX])))

F|^ X]jc\' ajĂi k^–i aj~c ỷ›c\ a∑^ ẽ bÁi i]}^ ỷ^–b c] êi ỷ€c] #i]}^ ỷ^‘b kvc W c ajĂi ỷâễX i]~c\ fjV$ i]tc ] Xuj X]˜ XÚ i] ‘ kt at h c e]ổb XÙV a€X] h˘) F\âẻ^ c\]^yc Xˆj kt e] uc izX] X]jnyc c\]^◊e' hVj `]^ msX ỷ€c] ỷâễX fjVc ỷ^‘b bt c\âẻ^ Ÿtb aj Ăi Y˚V ktd ỷ‘ mun Y˚c\ fjn i√X k^–i' e] ^ X~ỗ \sc\ e]si ig^‘c XsX e]uc izX] aj Ăi k^–i i]Zd ]âẩc\ W d k◊ fjVc ỷ^‘b ỷ|)

<| igâẻc\ ]ễe Yd hV^ h|i `• i] j Ăi' ajĂ i ig} cyc b uj i] jΩc ' hò ]ẽ ]dÀX `]~c\ ]ễe aự' igs^ X k|^ ự X]z XÙV c\âẻ^ atb ajĂi) C]^ ỷ|' c\â}^ c\]^yc Xˆj ajĂ i X|

igs X ] c] ^◊b 5 ^ƒe ^∞e& Y ˚ V ktd ự X]z ỷzX] i]˚ X XÙ V

c\â}^ atb ajĂi X]Ÿ gV \^ ^ e]se ỷÅc\ ỷ√c c]uói bt c\âẻ^ atb ajĂi X]Ù igâYc\ ỷâV gV' ^ ∞e \ZkU& \|e ự kẩ^ c\â}^ atb ajĂi k“ k^◊X h˘V ỷ‰^ ajĂi) H ]Ωc i] ˆ c ] ê i XÙV X~c\ k^◊X k˜V cyj X| i]‘ ỷâễX i]˚X ]^◊c igdc\ `]j~c `]‰ c\]^yc Xˆj' W^yc hd∑c hsX]' it^ a^◊j i] Vb

EấL K‡ N∫F †— Dỳ DM¿F N— <ở< H@đảF? H@ởH H@ốF Lớ<@ DM¿L NAœL

! -FE 1, !9) 3- FE1, 3 - .3 1,- .<1 )T6 7: 3-;1 5>)- /6 L5 7.P5A

` ] s d k– ajĂi5 e ] Ω c i] ˘ ] V^ X ÙV X~c\ k^◊X k˜V cy j X| i ] – ỷâểX i]˚X ] ^◊c i∑ ^ XsX ]Á^ i]s d `] dV ]›X ]dÀX ig y c W s d X]z)

A[qZ eZœU a Z v eZv_Y gl \[à_ eZœU UZfiq_ ^ v_

N‘ b Ài aự i]jk–i' Wêi `˝ c\â}^ ctd XĐc\ X| i]‘ c\]^yc Xˆj kt e ]u c izX] ajĂi k^–i) Kdc\' bj∙c i]˚X ] ^◊c X~c\ k^◊X X| ]^◊j fjs) c\â}^ c\ ]^yc X˘j kt e]sc izX] XΩc X| `^–c i]ˆX e]~ i]~c\ i∙^ i]^‘j kt `^–c i]ˆX X]j kwc b~c k“ ajĂi) C^–c i]ˆX Xtc\ gÁc\ kt huj' i]{ ] d ∑i ỷÁc\ c\]^yc Xˆj kt e] uc izX] Xtc\ \^tj izc] h s c \ i∑d kt hsX Wwc)

Nz YÚ' eZS` ờ[∂f .0, 9ƒ êf´e Vk_ d” _ố^,**/& g[ U ^fS Tk_ Ut eZ∂ộũÀU hkU ]´a \p^ ,**/& g[ U ^fS Tk_ Ut eZ∂ộũÀU hkU ]´a \p^ eZW` ộ[∂f \[ _ eZW` ột _Yũô[ Tk_ Ut eZ∑ UZfƒU eĐ[ el[ dl_ Zk_ ?c`_Y ^ƒe eZô[ ZĐ_(

Nẩ^ `^–c i]ˆX e]‰ i]~c\ kt `^–c i]ÅX X]jkyc b~c c ] êi ỷ€c]' c\â}z c\]^yc Xˆj kt e] tc izX] X]jnyc c\]^◊e c ]Ă c ỷ€c] g≈c\' fjn‘c X]jÁX a∑^ at bÁi fjn‘c X| \^s ig€ it^ h c kt igdc\ ỷ^‘j `^◊c `]~c\ X| fjn ỷ€c] ] ∑c X]– gt c ] b∑X] XÙV aj Ăi k^–i' at bÁi fjn“c X| i]‘ X]jn‘c \^Vd ỷâễX i]Zd ]ễe ỷ‚c\ ]dÀX Wtc\ Xdc ỷâẻc\ i]˜V `–) L˜ c ] Ă c ỷ€c] ỷ|' c\âẻ^ c\]^yc Xˆj kt e ]u c izX] X]jnyc c\]^◊e ỷ À i XsX \^s i]^–i5 c\â}^ X]jÁX a∑^ bdc\ bj∙] ọ1 s c ó fjn“c X]jÁX a∑^ X]d bÁi c\â}^ `]sX6 c\â}^ X]jÁX a∑^ X]–i kt c\â}^ i]˜V `y bdc\ bj∙c i]˚X ]^◊c fjn‘c X]jÁX a∑^5 c\â}^ X]jÁX a∑^ X]–i' ỷ‘ a∑^ c]^“j c\âẻ^ i] ˜V `–' kt c\â}^ b jV ỷˆc\ igâẩX c]^“j c\âẻ^ b j~c X]jÁX a∑^ it^ h c bt `]~c\ W^–i e] ^ ỷse ˆc\ nyj XΩj XÙV ]› c ]â i] – ctd X]d ỷÅc\ ajĂi6))) :l_Y Zs_Z V f _ Y ộũÃU _Z[∂f Y[• eZ[àe& _Yũô[ _YZ[q_ Uœf gl a Zm _ erUZ UZfiq_ _YZ[ a Ul_Y hkU ộ Ω_ Z ộũÃU _Z[∂f UkUZ e[àa U´_& ^ ơ h≥ gố_ T•_(

EấL K‡ N∫F †— Dỳ DM¿F N” <ở< H@đảF? H@ởH H@∏F Lớ<@ DM¿L NAœL

<| ]^‘j W^–i i~"i k“ aj Ăi XÙV XsX câẩX `]sX' c]t X]jnyc b~c hŒ X| ỷ^“j `^◊c gxc ajn◊c `˛ cỹc \ c\]^yc

Xˆj kt e]sc izX] `]sX] fjVc5 i]dsi gV `]fl^ ]◊ i]Ä]\ iâ Yjn e]se aự b t igdc\ ỷ| b{c] ỷâễX ỷtd i∑d' c] t X]jkyc b~c ỷˆc\ fl k€ igz XÅV bÁi X]jnyc \^V câflX c\dt^ ỷ‘ i{b ]^‘j' mZb mwi aj Ăi XÙV câẩX b{c] kt e]si ]^◊c c]˙c\ Y€ W^◊a6 hVj ỷ|' ỷˆc\ } k€ igz c\âò^ i] ˆ WV hd kẩ^ X ]V^ ]◊ i]~c\ aj Ăi ỷVc\ ỷâễX hd hsc ] ỷy hjn c\ ứb kt msX Y€c] c\jnyc c] uc XÙV c]˙c\ Y€ W^◊i ên6 c–j X| i]‘' X]Ÿ gV c]˙c\ âj ỷ^–b kt c]âễX ỷ^‘b XÙV bÂ^ ]◊ i]~c\' XĐc\ c]â Xuc c]√X k“ c]˙c\ W^◊c e]se `]s i]^ c]≈b ]dtc i]^◊c ]◊ i]~c\ ajĂi XÙV câ|X b{c])

L [ Vế& eZW` ờ [∂f .. 0 9 ƒ ] f ´ e V k _ d ” _ ố^

+33/ "& ec`_Y ecũô_Y ZÀa _Zl ằ UZ` eZfq ộũÃUTk_& eZ[ _Yũô[ eZfq \Z[ ộố eZ”U Z[ _ ộâi ộŒ Tk_& eZ[ _Yũô[ eZfq \Z[ ộố eZ”U Z[ _ ộâi ộŒ UkU _YZỡS gế UŒS _Yũô[ eZfq _Zl gl \Zv_Y Ut UZ√ ằ eZ[ Ut bfi∂_ ũf e[q_ ^fS(

<| i]‘ ỷ’ Ytc\ c] Ăc i]un gtc\' ]ểe ỷ‚c\ b jV W sc bt X]Ù c ]t X]d i] j y Y˚ ỷ€c] \^Vd `–i kẩ^ c\â}^ i] ˆ WV) i]Zd \^ i] ^–i XÙV ỷ^“j ajĂi' X| ỷ‚^ iâểc\ at c ] t ỷVc\ X]d i]j y kt \^s W sc ỷâễX i]flV i] j Ăc hŒ at

< ]âò c \ AA) <sX e ]âòc\ e ]s e c\] ^yc X˘j kt e] uc izX] ajui k^–i

Ijn i X ctk `]~c\ YâễX YâV ktd igdc\ ;Á ajĂi Yuc h˚ c tb -++0)

\^s iâòc\ ˆc\ kẩ^ i{c] ig∑c \ ỷVc\ ỷâễX X]d i]j y XÅV ỷ∙{ iâễc\ b j V Wsc' c\]ÊV at i] êe ]òc \^s XÙV X]zc] Xỹc c]t ỷ| igdc\ igâẻc\ ]ễe ỷâễX ỷ‘ ig∙c\) Lgdc\ ỷ^‘j `^◊c c\â}^ X]d i] jy `]~c\ X| fjn“c ỷ“ c\]€ kfl^ c\â}^ i]j y bÁi \^s W sc `]sX kẩ^ \^s i]d i] j Ă c k∙^ c\â}^ i] ˆ WV' X| i]‘ ]{c ] Yjc \ `] cỹc \ i]Zd ỷ|' c\âẻ^ i]jy h˘ YÚc\ fjn“c âj i^yc b j V ỷ‘ b jV a∑^ it^ h c' hVj ỷ| W sc a∑^ X]d c\âẻ^ `]sX i]Zd \^s iâ5Bc\ ˆc\ k|^ c]t ỷâễX ỷ‘ ig~c\) LV c] Ăc i]uN c\Vn g≈c\' c\âẻ^ i]jy igdc\ \^s i]^– i igyc hŒ ỷâễX ]âflc\ aễ^ i˜ `]d c X]yc] a◊X] \^˙V ]V^ \^s Wsc kt k^◊X ]âflc\ aễ^ ỷ| ]dtc idtc `]~c\ X]zc] ỷsc\) C]~c\ i]‘ c|^ gtc\ ỷd at \^ ^ e]se e ]ầ ]ễe kẩ^ ự X]z XÙV c\â}^ atb ajĂi6 hdc\' X| aŒ `]^ mun Y˚c\ ỷ^“j ajĂi' c\âẻ^ hd∑c i] d ỷỹ `]~c\ ]{c] Yjc\ ỷâễX bÁi XsX] ]dtc ] d XsX] i]ˆX se YÚc\ ỷ^–j aj Ăi ỷ| igdc\ i]˚X i^’c)

Lgdc\ ajĂi XÙV c]^‘j câẩX' c–j c\âẻ^ X]d i]jy W s c c]t igdc\ aÅX ]ễe ỷ‚c\ i] jy X}c ]^◊j ^˚X' i]{ c\â}^ i]jy' igyc c\jnyc i√X' `]~c\ X| fjn‘c âj i^yc bjV) Ijn“c ctn X]Ÿ e ] s i h^c] igdc\ igâẻc\ ]ễe ]ễe ỷ‚c\ X]d i]jy ỷv ] –i ]∑c kt c\â}^ X]d i]jy `]~c\ bj∙] i^–e iÚX X]d i] jy bt bj~N^ aên a∑^ c ] t ỷy Wsc) ?^ ^ e]se ctn X]d e]we c \ỹc X]Àc `] cỹc\ c\âẻ^

EấL K‡ N∫F †— Dỳ DM¿F N” <ở< H@đảF? H@ởH H@ốF Lớ<@ DM¿L NAœL

i] j y h˘ YÚc\ fjn“c âj i^yc b jV ỷ‘ igÚX aễ^) D^◊j ỷ|

X Đ c \ X ] ^c ] at \^ ^ e ] s e b t c\âẻ^ at b a j Ă i N ^◊i F Vb b dc \ b j ~c `]^ m n Y ˚ c \ † ^“j //1 ;Á a j Ă i Y u c h˚ c ỹ b ,440 ]Vn `]~c\9

< ]â ò c\ AA) <sX e] âò c\ e ]s e c\] ^yc XÙ j k e] c izX] ajĂi k^–i N ~c h~c \ X| i] ‘ ỷâễX ] ^‘ j c ] â at i Ă e ]ểe XsX ` ^c ] c \ ]^◊ b ỷâễX ỷÅX ` – i i˜ fj s i g{ c ] hflN^\ XÙV W c i] u c c ] t X ] j nyc b~c' i ˜ c ] Ù c \ `– i f j s i^ c ] i ] Ω c ỷ ∑ i ỷâễX ig dc \ f j s i g {c ] i ] V b \^V XsX f j V c ] ◊ m v ]Á^' i g d c \ ] d ∑ i ỷÁc\ c\ ] y c \ ]^◊e kt igd c\ h ^c ] ] d ∑ i ] t c\ c \ tn ) I j V c ]◊ Xt c \ c ] ^“ j kt ỷV Y∑c\ ' i] { X t c \ X| ỷ ^‘ j `^◊c izX] aj ˛ k∙c h∙c\) Kdc\' b j∙c X| c ] ^ “ j k~N^ h~c\' i] { igâ|X ] – i e ] ^ izX ] X˚X' X]Ù ỷÁc\ i g d c \ ]d∑ i ỷ Á c \ c \ ]“ c \] ^◊e k t ig dc \ \^Vd i^–e e ]‰ i]~c \) ;ẽ^ kĂn' X| c] Đ c \ c\â}^ X ] âV ỷ–c -+ ij‰^ ỷv X| k ∙ c h~c\ ỷ s c \ `‘' igd c\ ` ]^ X| c\â}^ ỷv ]òc 2+ ij‰^ k ứ c X]Ÿ X| b Á i ] t c ] ig V c \ h~c\ c \] xd ctc) Nẩ^ k∙c h∙ c\ e ]d c\ e ] Å) c ] t X] j n y c b ~ c mun Y ˚c \ ỷâểX b~^ a^yc ] ◊ \^˙V a j Ă i kfl^ i]˚X i^’c' ] ^c ] Y j c \ ỷâễX ` ] cỹ c \ kt XsX] i ] ầ X se Y Úc \ a jĂ i ig dc \ c ] ˙ c \ igâẻ c \ ]ễe ỷ ^y c ]{c] ) 14

f j V ỷ|' \|e e ] Ω c i ỹ c \ Xâ}c \ izc ] ] Đ j ]^◊j X ÙV aj Ăi)

L [ Vế & eZW` \ Z ` • _ , ờ [∂f 10 B f ´ e Zv_ _ Z l _ gl Y [S ộ s_ Z _ ố ^ ,***& g[ U _f v[ U`_ _ f v [ U Z ả ^ V œ e ec` _Y ecũ ô_ Y Zà a U`_ _ fv [ TΩ \ à e k _ g∂ ^ ƒ e ec` _Y UkU eƒ[ h m ^ a Z Đ ^ e[_ Z ^ Đ _ Y & dœU \ZứW& _ Z m _ a Z â ^ & V S _ Z V ” UŒ S UZS& ^ ≤ _fv[5 _ YũÃU ộ l [& Z l _ Z Z Đ UZS& ^ ≤ _f v[ Z` ∞ U Ut Z l _ Z g [ a Z k ek_ el[ d•_ UŒS UZS& ^ ≤ _fv[(

E Áa c\â}^ X| k∙ c h∙c\ Y‚^ Y td X| i] ‘ \]^ c ] Ă c g t c \ igdc\ i]˚ X i–' X| ig âẻ c\ ]ễ e Xdc cj~^ m u b e ] ∑ b izc ] b ∑c \' h˘X `] flZ X Ù V X ] V cj~^ ỷ‘ W d k◊ b à cj~^ X]~c\ a∑^ h˚ ] t c ] ]∑' c\˚ễX ỷ v ^ X Ù V X]V cj~^) D^◊j ` ] d c - † ^“j 21 XÙc \ ỷâễX se Y Ú c \ igd c \ igâ ẻ c\ ]ễe ỷ|9 F – j X u j i g a}^ at X|' i] { k^◊X X ] ê b Y ˆ i f j V c ]◊ cj ~^ Xdc cj~^ i gd c \ igâ ẻ c\ ]ễe c t n X| ]^◊ j a˚X Xs ỷ~{ kẩ^ fj V c ] ◊ X ] V ẫ Xdc' b à ẫ Xdc ] V k X]Ÿ ỷ‰^ k}^ f j V c ] ◊ X ] V ẫ Xdc9 F –j X]d g ≈ c \ f j V c ] ◊ cj~^ Xdc cj~^ e] ^ X ]ê b Y ˆ i ỷ‰{ kẩ^ X X ]V k t b à cj~^ igd c \ ig â } c\ ]ễe ccn' i]{ gÄ g t c \ f j V c ] ◊ b à c j~^ ( Xdc c j ~^ W€ X si ỷˆi b Ái XsX] d V c j‰c\5 X}c c – j X]d g≈ c \ X]Ÿ X| f j V c ]◊ X] V °Xdc X ] ê b Y˘i' i]{ c\â}^ Xdc cj~ ^ hŒ ig } i ] t c ]

EấL K‡ N∫F †— Dỳ DM¿F N— <ở< H@đảF? H@ởH H@ốF Lớ<@ DM¿L kỡœL

Xdc cj~^ g^y c\ X Ù V kễ XÙV c\âẻ^ X] V cj~^ igâẩX ỷu n kt ỷ| at i{c ] ] j ~c \ `]} c\ ỷâểX c\â}^ atb aj Ă i Y˚ `^–c)

< ]âò c \ AA) <sX e]âòc \ e] se c\ ]^yc Xˆj k e] u c izX] ajô# k^–i

†∑d aự at bÁi igdc\ c]˙c\ ỷ^“j `^◊c W d ỷ b ự i]ˆX e]se ajĂi) †∑d aự X| i]‘ ỷâễX ]^‘j c]â at h˚ X b

c ] Ă c ]dÀX h˚ ự i]Å X k“ c ] ˙ c\ nyj X Ωj X ÙV Xdc c\â}^ ỷ‚{ k|^ Xdc c\âẻ^ a^yc f jV c ỷ–c k^◊X msX ỷ €c ] i] s ^ ỷÁ m˘ h˚ i gd c \ c ]˙ c \ igâẻ c\ ]ểe c]t"i ỷ €c ] ' c ] ˙ c \ nyj XΩj ] {c ] i ] t c ] ig y c XY hfl ỷ∑d ỷˆX' aâòc\ ig^' aŒ e] ^'

aŒ X}c\ W≈c\) †∑d aự `]~c\ ỷâễX izX] iÚ igdc\ Xdc

c\â}^ i]Zd Xầ c\ b Á i XsX] c ] â ]›X i ] j Ă i ]V n k~c h~c\ b t ỷâểX X]^yb c\] ^◊b kt i ] u b c ] j Ω c i gd c \ f js

ig{c] h∙c\) L]ub c ] j Ωc ỷ∑d aự) c ]t X]jnyc b~c X|

i] ‘ atb gÄ \^s ig€ ỷ∑d ỷÅX XÙ V aj Ăi' i ỹ c \ Xâ}c\ izc] i] j n– i e] Ú X X ÙV aj Ă i' f jV ỷ| i] Å X ỷV k h ˚ e ] s i i g^ ‘ c ự i]ˆX i˚ \^sX i] ˚X ] ^◊c e ] s e ajĂi)

Nz Vế & eZW` V [p ^ V \ Z ` • _ "s ờ [∑f 0 .- ;Á

]f ´ e V m _ d ” _ k ^ ,**/ ( _Yũô[ Ut Z l _ Z g[ ]–S Vw[& Uũ…_Y oa Z` ∞U _Y ố_ U•_ _Yũô[ ộ q ]Đ[ V [ dk _ ec` _ Y g[ U ]´ a V [ UZxU& d— S UZ “ S V [ UZxU&

Z f ’ V [ UZ xU _ Z ≠ ^ Z ũ ằ_ Y ^ ƒ e a Z k _ Z`∞U e`l _ Tƒ V [ d k _ eck [ g∆[ ◊ U Z [ UxS _Yũô[ ộo ]Đ [ V [ d• _ dp \ Z v _ Y Ut b f i∂ _ Zũ ằ _ Y V[ dl_(

L]˚X gV' c\â}^ i] ˜V ` – X]Ÿ ỷ sc\ W€ ig˜ c\ e] ∑ i igdc\ igâ}c\ ]ểe ự X]z `]~ c\ ỷâễX i~c ig›c \ ` ]~c\ X]Ÿ at ự X]z i]˚X' X]√X X] √c b t X}c e] ^ at ự X]z ]ểe ỷ∑d a _ ) <| i]y ] {c] Yj c \ igâẻc\ ]ểe c ] â hVj5 c\â}^ X]‚c\ aĂe Y^ X]ÅX \^Vd id tc WÁ it^ KŸ^c X]d c ] s c i{c ]' c\â}^ kY \^Ăc Y˙ mw Wfl Y^ X]ÅX6 c\â}^ X]‚c\ X]–i ỷ‘ a∑^ kể kt bÁi Xdc X]âV

i]tc] c^yc) ?^s h˘ i]yb g≈c\' Y^ X]ÅX ỷâễX Y˚c\ a∑^ ỷΩn

ỷÙ) F –j Y^ X]ÅX ` ]~ c\ W€ mw Wfl' i]{ s e YÚ c \ †^“j ?14 ;Á aj Ă i Y uc h˚ cỹ b -++0) id t c WÁ Y^ h c hŒ ỷâễX igVd X]d c ] u c i{c ] XÙV c\âẻ^ X]– i kt c\âẻ^ c t n X| igsX] c]^◊b X]jnyc \^Vd ] V^ e] Ω c Y^ h c ỷâểX ]âXz^^\ `]~c\ e ]Ú i]jÁX cÁ^ Y j c \ Y^ X]ÅX X]d kể kt Xdc X] â V i ]t c ] c^yc XÙV c\â}^ X]–i' bÂ^ e ] Ω c W ≈ c \ -*. hju"i i] ˜ V `Œ i]Zd e] s e aj Ăi XÙ V bÂ^ c\â}^) F V n Yd c\âẻ^ kY X| ] t c] k^ ]Ùn Y^ X]ÅX' se ỷ Úc\ ỷ^‘b Y `] d c , † ^“j 1/. ;Á ajĂ i Yuc h˚ cỹ b -++0' c ] u c i{c ] XÙV c\âẻ^ ỷy a∑^ Y^ h c X]Ÿ e] ^ \^Vd bÁi e ] Ω c Y^ h c ỷâễX ]âò c\ ` ]~c\ e ] Ú i]jÁX cÁ^ Yj c\ Y^ X]ÅX X]d c\âẻ^ Xdc X] âV i] t c ] c^yc' X}c c\âẻ^ kễ `] ~c\ X| fjn“c ]âẽc\ Y^ h s c kt e ] Ω c i]˜ V `Œ `]~c\ e ] Ú i]jÁX cÁ^ Y j c \ Y^ X]ÅX XÙV c T } ^ ctn W€ ]j• W}) EấL K‡ N∫F †” Dỳ DM¿F

N— <ở< H@đảF? H@ởH H@ốF Lớ<@ DM¿L kỡ”L

C ]}c\ X]√X Y| at \^t^ e] se b t c\âẻ^ atb a j Ă i b dc\

bj~c' Wẻ^ ] tc ] k^ ]jự Y^ X]ÅX igdc\ \^ i]^–i gÄ gtc\ ỷâễX i]˚X ]^◊c igdc\ ỷ^“j `^◊c c\â}^ X| ]tc] k^ ên W€ `zX] ỷÁc\ Wò^ ]t c ] k^ e]^ ỷ∑d ỷ˘X XÙV c\âẻ^ aĂe Y^ X]ÅX)))

AA) <ở< H @ đ ả F ? H @ ở H F ? @ A ờ F <ủOB Nà H @ ở F L ớ < @ < @ Û PœM

N^◊X e ]u c izX] XsX fjn iêX k^–i X| i] ‘ ỷâễX i]˚X ]^◊c W t c \ c] ^‘j e] âỷc \ e]se) Lgdc\ ` ] j~ c `]~ ] ∑ c ] Ã e XÙV XjÄ ] hs X] ctn) X]Å c \ iV ỷÀX W^◊i fj V c iu b ỷ–c c ] ˙c \ e]âẻc \ e] s e ỷâễX h˘ YÚ c \ e] ‰ W^–c' i]âẻ c\ mj ny c kt X| ] ^◊j fj s c] êi5 e ] u c izX] Xuj X]˜ ]dÀX X] Å \^ ^' e]u c izX] a€X] hÙ kt e ] u c izX] e ] s i ig^‘c) F\dt^ gV' X| igâẻc\

]ểe #`]~c\ i]âẻc\ \Àe c]âc\ a∑^ gê i i– c]€$ igdc\ ỷ|

\^˙V XsX ỷ^‘j aj Ă i k^–i X| h ˚ b u j i ]j ứ c ' k^◊X c\ ]^yc Xˆj kt e ] s c izX] aj Ă i ỷ}^ ]fl^ b Ái e]âòc\ e] s e g^yc\)

,) H ] â ò c \ e ] s e i g j n “ c i ] ~ c \ 5 e ] u c i z X ] X u j X ] ˙ ] d À X X ] Å \ ^ ^ ồ%

H ]u c izX] Xuj X]ầ ]dĂX X]Å \^ ^ #hVj ỷun \›^ at

< ] âò c \ a z ) <vX e ] âò c \ e ] s e c\ ]^yc Xˆj kt e ] u c azX] ajui k^–i

N‘ bÁi e] sc izX] X]^ i^ya' mZb5 ;dccZXVhZ' ũ o U` ]W VW

]"<hoYpX[W W_ Vc`[e U[f[]& H Vg^h' ,4-",)

e ] u c izX] X uj X]˙$ ` ] ~ c \ i] ‘ ỷâễX ] ^ ‘ j i] Z d c \ ]ÊV ỷZc' iˆX at e ] u c izX ] i ˜ c \ Xsj' i˜ c \ X ]˙ Y˚ V i] Z d ự c\ ]ÊV X Ù V i ˜ c \ Ù ỷâễX \]^ c ] Ă c igd c \ i ˜ ỷ^‘c ]dÀX igd c \ i Ă e f j sc ) F \ ] ^y c X ˆj kt e ] u c izX ] a j Ă i k ^– i Y ˚ V ktd e]âò c \ e ] s e e ] s c izX] X u j X]ầ ]l ZTĐe ộƒ_Y ec[ ef UŒS _Zl UZfiq_ ^v_ "%ộ[ hfiq_ bfS gố_ T•_ bfi aZĐ^ aZka ]f´e ộ ∑ _ả^ Tăe ỗ UZr ộrUZ eZ”U UŒS _Yũô[ ]l^ ]f´e( E ÚX ỷzX] X Ù V k^◊X i]˚ X ] t c ] e ] â ỷ c \ e ] s e e ] s c izX] X u j X ]˙ at e ] s i ] ^◊ c ự X ] z X Ù V c\âẻ^ at b ajĂ i' e ] s i ] ^◊ c XsX fj n e ] ∑ b e ] s e a j Ă i b t c\âẻ^ at b a j Ă i b j∙c mun Y˚ c \ k t ỷâễX i] ‘ ] ^◊ c igd c \ k v c W c' N∙^ e] âò c\ e ] s e e ] u c izX] Xuj X]˙' c \â }^ c \] ^y c Xˆj e ] s i ] ^◊c aj Ă i X ]ˆ ` ] ~ c \ i∑d g V ajĂi %) F|^ XsX] `]s X' igd c\ f j V c c^◊b aự iâẽ c\ X Ù V c\â}^ e ] u c izX] X uj X]˙' aj Ă i kt aj Ă i k^– i ] d t c i d t c ỷ‚ c\ c ] s i k∙^ c ] V j EấL K‡ N∫F †” Dỳ DM¿F

N” <ở< H@đảF? H@ởH H@ºF Lớ<@ DM¿L kỡœL

"OZb5 =ZbdadbWZ' : `fcd VW : `VW D Sa`]o`_& L) ,' h∙ ,,05 ọN“ e]âòc\ Y ^◊c $ự i] jn – i' Y^’c Y€X] X| c\ ]ÊV at \^ ^ i]zX]6 Y^’c Y€X] at atb hs c \ i} ˛ c\ ] ÊV ỷÅ c\ kt ỷzX] i] ˚X X ầ V aj Ă i k^–i) =| `]~c \ e] ^ at i] V n ỷ‰^' hÙV ỷ‰^' atb bẩ^6 ỷ| at ij ny c W~' at i] ˜ V c ] Ăc ) N^◊X Y^’c Y€X] Xfl i]‘ `]wd awd ]dÀX i^c ] i–6 X| A]‘ Y ức ỷ–c k^◊X \sc X]d c\Tz}^ at b aj Ă i c] ˜ c\ ự ỷ‚ b t i]˚X gV c\â}^ atic aj Ăi `]~ c\ X|) c ] Ù c \ ự ỷ‚ X| i] ‘ i∙i ]òc ]dÀX mêj ]òc6 c ]â c\ Y ^’c Y€X] `] ~ c\ X| isX YÚ c \ i∑d gV fjn isX bẩ^6 c–j `]~c\' ^]{ `] ~ c\ X}c Ÿt Y^’c Y€X] c˙V )

! - FE 1 , "" !9) 3-FE1, 3-93 1, -.=1 )U6 7K 3-;1 5>)- /6L5 7.P5

k t k^◊X s e YÚ c\ e ] s e aj Ă i igâẩX ] – i at k^◊X mun Y ˚c\ b Á i i V b ỷd∑c aj Ă c ỷòc \^s c #hnaad\^hb Z h^beaZ$" 6 ộĐ[ ộ∂ at f j n i√X i] zX] ˆ c\ XÙV a j Ă i k^–i6 e[∑f ộà at e] Ω c \]^ c ] Ă c k^◊X X| ỷ Ù ỷ ^‘j ` ^◊c ỷŒ s e Y Ú c \ f j n isX igdc \ igâ ẻ c \ ]ểe ỷV c\ m Zb mwi6 kt \àe ]f´_ at e ] Ω c `] ô c\

Một phần của tài liệu Phương pháp phân tích luật viết - Một số vấn đề lý luận cơ bản: Phần 1 (Trang 61 - 74)