Financial leverage of companies listed on hose and hastc an analysis across industries, over time and in compaision with other countries

000042409 FINANCIAL LEVERAGE F COMPANIES LISTED ON HOSE AND HASTC A N AN ALYSIS ACROSS INDUSTRIES, OVER TIM E A N D IN COMPARISON W ITH OTHER COUNTRIES m TRUNGTÃM THONGĩ!N TKƯVIẺN m h -w h h ỡ c ::s o i •MTV _ Ạ I ậ O £ - Submitted by NGO THI THANH HUYEN A thesis subm itted as a requirem ent for the degree of Bachelor of Business Adm inistration HANOI UNIVERSITY Faculty o f M an ag em en t a n d T o u ris m Hanoỉ November 2008 F in a n cỉa l leverage o f com pan ies lis te d on HOSE a n d HaSTC CONTENTS A B ST R A C T S T A T E M E N T O F A U T H O R S H IP h CKNOVVLEDGEM ENT LIST F F IR G U R E S LIST F T A B L E S LIST F A P P E N D IC E S LIST F A B R E V IA T IO N S 10 IN TR O D U C T IO N 11 1.1 B ackground o f the s tu d y 11 1.2 Statem ent o f p ro b le m s 12 1.3 R esearch signiíicance 13 1.4 T he research .14 1.4.1 Aims o f research 14 1.4.2 Research C o n trib u tio n s 14 1.4.3 O rganization o f th e re s e a rc h 15 LITER A T U R E REVIEVV 16 2.1 2.2 2.3 D eíínition o f Capital structure and MM proposition m o d e l 16 2.1.1 D eíin itio n o f Capital s tr u c tu r e 16 2.1.2 M odigliani and M iller (M & M ) proposition th e o ry .17 2.1.2.1 N o T a x e s 17 2.1.2.2 With T a x e s 19 C apital structure theories re v ie w 21 2.2.1 Pecking order th e o ry 22 2.2.2 Static T rade-off th e o ry 23 F a c to rs affectin g Capital stru c tu re 26 2.3.1 Firm -specific ĩa c to r s 26 Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 F in a n cĩa l leverage o f com panies lis te d o n HO SE an d HaSTC 1 Firm g ro w th 26 2.3.1.2 T an g ib ility 27 2.3.1.3 B usiness risk 27 2.3.1.4 Proíĩtability 28 2.3.1.5 Firm s iz e 28 2.3.1.6 R elationship with B anks 28 2.3.1.7 N etw orking 29 2.3.2 C ountry-speciíìc facto rs 29 2.3.2.1 Institutional and legal fa c to rs 29 2 Financial m arkets and banking system factors 30 2.3.2.3 M acroeconom ics 30 2.4 Em pirical researches on Capital s tru c tu re 32 2.5 Researches in V ietnam .33 M E T H O D O L O G Y 35 3.1 R esearch questions 35 3.2 R esearch to o ls 35 3.2.1 Industry classiíìcation m e th o d 35 3.2.1.1 Industry classiíication sy stem s 36 3.2.1.2 Industry classiíìcation fo r V ietnam ese listed c o m p an ies .37 3.2.2 R esearch D ata 38 3.2.2.1 D ata collection 38 3.2.2.2 D ata m easurem ent 39 FIN D IN G S A N D D ISC U SSIO N 40 4.1 Capital structure across various industries in V ietnam 40 4.1.1 C apital structure by industries in V ietn am .41 1.2 Short-term debt ratios across Industries 49 4.2 C apital structure across industries through tim e .51 4.2.1 C apital structure o f listed firm s by tim e 52 4.2.2 Short-term debt ratios o f listed íirm s by tim e 53 4.2.3 C apital structure across industries by tim e 53 Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 Fin a n cia l leverage o f com panies lis te d on HO SE a n d HaSTC 4.2.4 4.3 Short-term debt ratios across industries by tim e .56 C apital structure o f industries in Vietnam vs other countries 60 Vietnam vs C h in a 60 4.3.2 Vietnam vs USA and W estem E urope 62 4.4 R esearch lim itations .68 4.4.1 Industry c la ssiíic a tio n 68 4.4.2 D ata d isto rtio n 68 IM PL IC A T IO N S O N F IN D IN G S 70 5.1 Im plications fo r policy m a k e rs 70 5.2 Im plications fo r m anagers .71 C O N C L U S IO N S 73 6.1 S u m m ary 73 6.2 K ey íĩn d in g s .73 6.3 Future research reco m m en d atio n s 74 6.4 C onclusion statem en t 75 A P P E N D IC E S 76 R E FE R E N C E 90 Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 F in a n cia l leverage o f com panies lis te d on HO SE and HaSTC ABSTRACT The 8-year deveìopment ofVietnam Capital market since 2000 has provided fim is usẹỷủỉ tooỉs in raising and mobilizing their sources o f funds Hovvever, Vietnam Capital markeís stiỉl show evidence o f the weaknesses in credit systems, organìiation and alỉocation o f sources o f funcỉs amongỷirms Therefore, the issues on effective Capital strucíure become essential and headache decisions for firm s ’ managers in order to best ilize thr Capital sỉructure fo r fu tu re developments For thai reasorì, this research ìs conducted to investigate the current situation o f Capital strucíure o f alỉ ỉisted Jìrm s across Industries in Vietnam Data used in this research are secondary informaiỉon taken from offìcỉal websites o f ÍM'Ũ stock exchanges in Vietnam, HOSE and HASTC The sample invesiiged ìndudesỉ-year fìnancial data o f totơl 295 ỉisted companies in Vietnam The fìndings show that ỉisted companies in Vỉnam generally use more ciebí compared to equiíy in íheir Capital strucíure (D/E = 1.33) in which aboui 68 per cent o f toíaỉ debís employed are short-term maturity Capital structures vaty across nine iììdustries in Vietnam O f alì, fìrm s in Financiaỉs industry utilize highesí debt to equiíy ratios (D/E = 2.0) w hile/inns in Healthcare industry employ the least level o f debí in iheir capitưỉ structure (D/E = 0.37) Capital structures aỉso vary across countries Lisíed companỉes in Vietnam employ lower leveỉ o f debt compared ío lisíedfìrm s in developed markets (D/E = 1.33; 2.86 and 4.04 in Vietnam, USA and Westem Europe, respecíively) In addiỉion, ỉisted companies in Vietnam and China reìy more on shorí-term debt compared to those in USA and Wesíern Europe Imptìcations f o r poìicy makers and managers to improve the situations as weỉỉ as future research recommendations are also mentioned This íhesis consists o f about 17,170 Mords and 74 pages, excluding appendices Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 F in a n ã a l leverage o f com panies lis te d on HO SE and HaSTC STATEMENT 0F AUTHORSHIP "Except w h ere reíerence is m ade in the text o f the thesis, this thesis contains no material published elsew here o r extracted in vvhole o r in part from a thesis o r any o th er degree or diploma N o other person's w ork has been used w ithout due acknow ledgm ent in th e main text o f the thesis This thesis has not been subm itted for th e aw ard o f any degree o r dipỉom a in any other tertiary institution” Student signature Ngo T h i Thanh Huyen Date: * N ovem ber 2008 Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 F in a n cia l leverage o f com panies lis te d on HO SE a n d HaSTC ACKNOVVLEDGEMENT This thesis vvould not have been com pleted vvithout the enthusiasm , valuable guidance, and vvillingness to answ er all the questions o f m y supervisor, Mrs N guyen H oai Phuong I would like to give m y greatest thanks to her for alw ays giving me supports, m otivations and useíùl inform ation during th esis' com pletion progress It is her to discuss w ith m e for ideas generations, helping me to get back to the right track w henever I got lost It is m y honor to send a warm gratitude to all o f m y teachers in th e Faculty o f M anagem ent and Tourism w ho have been w ith m e for m ore than four years, teaching me to becom e not only a successĩul but also a kind-hearted person I want to express my love to my classm ates in BA 3-04 w ho alw ays care fo r me, encouraging me during my hard time Especially, I am indebted to m y friend, Ms Tran M inh N guyet vvho has helped me a lot with iníịrm ation searching as well as listening to m y troubles when I w as extrem ely worried AI so, m y great appreciation sent to m y colleagues w orking in C B V R esearch Team They gave me assistance in data collection and helped m e to balance the w ork-thesis tim e All o f my stresses w ere rem oved as w e talked and laughed It is im possible for m e to com plete the thesis w ithout supports from m y fam ily and close íriends w ho have given me best regards and been w iíh m e in the m ost nervous m om ents I truly w ant to send them a vvarm hug for their appearance in m y life Pinally, I w ould like to send the m ost faithful and special thanks to my room m ates - m y little sister and a close íriend They have put up w ith me during diữ ìcult tim e w ithout any com plain M oreover they supported m e w ith the best condition to keep going on vvith m y thesis as well as helped me to balance m y life Thanks for alw ays sym pathizing and forgiving m e w hen ỉ w as not being w ith you when you were in need Thank you very much w ith all o f my s\veetest love! Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 ••• F in a n cia l leverag e o f com panies lis te d o n H O SE an d HaSTC Lisr 0F FIRGURES Figuc 1: M &M Proposition II (W ith T ax ) 20 Figuc : Static T rad e-o ff theory: C ost o f Capital vs Capital stru ctu re 24 Figuc 3: Capital structure o f íĩrm s in nine Industries - 0 46 Figuc : Ranking o f Capital structures across industries in V ietnam - 0 .47 Figue 5: Segm ents o f Pharm aceutical Production Lines - 0 48 Figuc 6: Ranking o f short-term debt ratios by Industries in V ietnam , 0 .49 Figuc 7: Capital structure o f listed íirm s through y e a rs 52 Figuc 8: Short-term d eb t ratios o f listed firm s through years 53 Figuc 9: Trends o f Capital structure across industries through tim e 54 FigUE 10: Inílation rates o f V ietnam , 0 55 Figuc 1: T rends o f short-term debt ratios across Industries through tim e 57 Figuc 12: Short-term debt ratios - N ine industries in V ietnam 59 F iguc 13: R anking o f Capital structure across industries, 2008: Vietnam vs C h in a 61 FiguE 14: C apital structure across industries: V ietnam vs C h in a 62 Figuc 15: R anking o f Capital structure across industries: Vietnam vs USA and Western Europe 63 F iguc 16: C apital structure across industries: V ietnam vs U SA and \V estem E urope .64 F iguc 17: Structure o f V ietnam Listed Bond m arket throughout y e a r s 65 F iguc 18: Bond vs Equity m arket in V ietnam , 0 66 FiguE 19: T u m o v er ratios o f B ond m arkets across em erging countries, 0 66 Figui3 20: Long-term D /E ratios across industries: Vietnam - C hina - U SA - W estem Europe 67 Gradiation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 ôằã F in a n c ia l leverage o f com panies lĩs te d on HO SE a n d HaSTC LIST 0F TABLES Table 1: Sum m ary o f Capital structure th e o rie s 24 Table 2: Impact o f C ountry-speciíĩc Factors in Capital S tructure 31 Table 3: Sum m ary o f Industries in V ietn am 38 Table 4: Capital structure ratios fo r nine industries in V ietnam , 0 .41 Table 5: Standard deviation and V ariance coeffĩcient for nine industries 46 Table 6: Capital structure across industries through tim e 51 Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 H ro ơv m Õ o co ơ' Õ co Ó co ư> õ to o> Õ ơ> Õ1 õ ÍN cn ó co r** ị co os õ IN 00 ơ> ựỵ õ V Ỡ1 Ị rw ó vo lẠ d co H Ọ c* rN K rH r-« m ơỊ «-1 fTỈ H r-i rH Ọ ri 00 •í Õ o s r*j «-* r*Ị rj PM CỌ r>ĩ T-i n> t/> rò tH cn õ ÍY1 o Õ rv r* Õ rt o Õ ơì o Ị o o s Ị r»■< ỏ fN o Ó co ơ' Õ oo 00 õ < to ơ» õ ƠI o% Õ 0 rơ> Ị s rv ơ» Ĩ rg Õ m 03 Õ 03 0> Ơ ví> «> Ị T-i ưì r* Õ < z < < z < z ơ> ưì ó < z < < < z z z z r i pv ' ũ ãôằ PO co •H fN fN rn ơí ro < z Ưì < z < z < z rỡ\ < z < z »-* H d ơ> cn õ < z Ỡ1 ó ơì cn ó < m vọ \Ĩ T -i r•N Õ ơt õ ro K Õ K Ĩ ẵ Ị r** ơ» ó vo ơ> Ó < z ' < z* r i < UD rv Ô rK õ $ d < < z z o ỈN ŨS 'T 00 ro •H m r-* rã 'T CT> -í fn s Ưì m ri < z < z UI rò »T m < z < < z z ' K Õ ơ« * Ị ưì r ' ó < z r* o fN CO < < z ơ> oi Õ ưi co ó T-« ơ' Õ r -í ư> õ m ơ< õ Ơ 00 •í ó H cn ó < z co rj ó cn ữi õ r* ơ\ ó 00 O) rH •H ro ri rfN Õ r* T* Õ < cn ot T -i Ch •N Ị o r t Õ ưì ro f*i < z m ƠI rị CO Ưì rvj Ĩ s Ĩ D r* rj z g r -i s Ĩ Ĩ 'í GO Ĩ T -i s Ơ •H H m io rr> CO r -i rì í fN < s vo ôN CO UI Đ rằj Q < z < «x m - ro Ọ H ư> Õ co c* Ú 00 rH < r>in ỏ n rs õ fx »-« ri r» *-* ị r ' T-H ơ> r>j ưi < z < z í r-v T* ị •I ÍNI Õ < o Ò d g *H o Õ õ H o Õ ó K ị Ĩ ró N rM Ề cr IU 1** ♦» rx b s co fN r*4 ơ< vo Ĩ Õ • f-t 00 Õ 8 Ị c í ÍN m s H Ị ro (£> o o Ó ô Õ Ỏ g d ■ ■ Ơ ct 2Ì ị /ì ã D -« Ọ r-í r* d I /Í *3 rH m r>j r>i N m fơ ow Ị r-1 r í lO N r4 03 H < z 00 ro r i < C7> (M fN < < z ơ» K »ỹ < Ưì Ỡị ưi rf ) CỌ rM m Ị r«< lO d vo 'í o H o Ò Ò Õ ni < H ĨÕ Ỏ iX> Ĩ s Ĩ < < z < o "«r rH H CO < < < z 2 < z VD ơ> ri m oỊ ưÃ ro Õ m 8 Si UI u i ló ư> fị N ib •H s ẳ < z o Ưì o «£> o «H r- IN r*» ro r- s tr> r- ư> r« t I z Ễ a> o 4-1 í B X H •< X a u ẫ z Q ỉ Q- £ c c c» ỉ a Ô z a p K í ư> QX CL t1 X o u -O c z I I z I f» ơ' r-~ o 00 " •5 > o z I "D c a> ■5 oc c s "D £ ÙC c >< _ưj re ■Ú ts -o c t" 1 •< o ọ £ »- t>> T3 c ẫ "ồ — n w s LO ro u —1 ỉ 00 c > b ÍN s o z z ll> X z z u> o Q- X a ẽ Q- d s o Q u LU b —J y> ro *c (0 w f = a o Q o ễ £ i c co ro -tr —i r í tu o (/) a — 10 *s> n *o c TJ c t! T? c R> •Ễ M *o _c *o c z X z X X z I z I ro CO 00 ư\ CO 00 15 ■o c íí *D c z I z X rH 00 rM 00 b h- *0 £ JS o a rc K o z o X z tt K o > ■< o z o X Q o X CL ầ I ỉ ủ a o t— u o a Q tu ĩc ►ịy X H ■< > »1 z b HQ u £ c z c oc c ■o Ễ ■4Đ > oc c >• E c> ưi N ? o o z a u ế u a u £ s ễ a rv r-t Ư) Ưì ãÊ> m UJ ô Q- vừ •< Õ o z o ửl Q- ĩỏ * Ọ o o z o e> z í JC z § ọ § Q- ã z ệ o s s u Đ u s in ã-< ằ ui Q u o o z § z < >< 01 u Ê E K i£> o> l/i ơv ăi CL X z X z X z I fN a> ro ƠI 'T ơ> in ƠI ơ> r*~ cn eo ƠI ơ\ ă' rH o »-t «N o M ro o H ■s ~ĩõ ■o _c *c «/» ■D c c ■D c ễ z I I X z X co co O' ă) — ơ' «A u X ã t- o j£ (« *c ựl T3 o z T-i •H èo Ò ID Õ H ơ> Õ rsj èo Ó o ró ư> d fƠI õ < z r*» ư> Ĩ s Ĩ 00 CO Õ ưì r-Õ •» võ Ò d s õ < ọ H o ro Ỡ) ri ro rt T-i r«i ró o ÍN r>i £ Ọ fõ co m 00 «x> ẹ ri ÍM Ọ m rv rN rsj r* m ri ơ> ưS H H T VÕ K ưì rơ Q ọ ró r- ơ' ó eo Ĩ ơ< õ vo 00 Ị 5? ó »H ? r-i õ < z ư\ s õ o ơ» Õ § ỉ Ọ K m ri s VÔ IN < r~ 00 yỏ g Ô r-' m ưi < < > cn f*ỡ 00 ãN K ể T ô ơ> Ó < Sỉ ơ> ỡl ỏ < z < z r-i s Ó vo ớ) Õ < z < z H GO Õ VÕ Ó < ơ\ r> õ < KỊ rj rt rrj m Q T-ỡ ôN rv H ã- < z kO LÕ rv (Ti r> »ỹ H ưi ri < r>ưì T-i < z 3 LT> m yỏ < z •H < rj Õ fM õ co Õ Ch ỡí Ĩ ư> õ rỉ o 00 Õ ■ < H Ó ơ> ĩo ó < rtì r* Õ o m Õ Ò trt & Ó < < z O' ơ) õ < m 00 Ĩ ro 00 Ị fNJ ơ> Õ rơ> d < < Z < < 03 ƠI Õ m co Õ § t-i § Ĩ rv K ơ> ãã T-í fO H rv (N Ơ ơ> GO Õ m í*ị 'T CO Õ V D T-i H õ co 00 õ 'í 0.66 co ỡ» õ 0.97 o ư> d 1.00 Oi v£) Õ 1.00 o ơ> Õ 1.00 < •H ã» ó 96 rg K d 2008 H r** io Ó 660 CNI J5 Õ 860 Q £ V o cn ã> õ fõ < z 1/1 fM ó c* r» m Ĩ co J Õ •H Ò Sỉ Ò Ò < < z «D r rằi H H H ãN ri rô4 K rã ĩ; N có 8 o PM 8 rõ o •-* m N K »-< r-' H rt u-í m s Ị N r-« ơĩ f»ỉ Ĩ ưi eo H Õ p» H Ỏ rv N Ó Ó £ õ Q < z rs «N Õ r* Õ ĩ? Õ D d Si Õ < z < rƠI ó s Ò i ỉ 8 ưi õi s rH ế Ị Ưì r* *-í •N IN ư> ỹỏ 00 s rt i N D N rs CÒ ư\ Ĩ s H r-ớ 03 ôr lớ -ã H s Ĩ »N Õ «o rs N Mi cọ rõ 00 H ỏ Ọ «-i 'í T-< cã m rõ lÃ s oi r*> ơ> d < z m ư> õ o •H Ĩ o fM Õ CO rọ l>i rg ÍN õ r>i r>i ơ» Cd oi < z < T-ỉ < < < z ro »r r>i < H Ưì 1Ã < z < z < z < z IA cn ó o r» ó »-* o OJ Õ Tí ữ> H • í? T-i o r-j ưi 00 Ó Ò ro Ò Õ s Ò < ư> õ Ị rH Ị *-• o Ĩ co H Ĩ I-I o Ơ o Õ rS 03 Õ ô g Ó s Õ r-ị o Õ < z < rs o d < H Ó s r-ì Ọ rị •í fN Õ m wi ri rs H Õ < z < z < z < z fN o Ỏ g H Ĩ cg K 8 8 8 < s Ó < < z Õ Ò Ó co fn ri < z ir» í»i Õ < z < < rg < 8 ó ưi »-* oò 8 8 8 ID m Ổ o s p' vò ro ắ CM N s? s V H < < s s rsi co ữ) s Ò ẩ IX) H 1/1 Ò r-* o Õ v£> 00 Ó c> Ô ơ' s Ó CO Õ m cõ T-i ơ> r-l Ổ 00 rí ưi *» »n < z < z N in fn ■ o m r»‘ ữĩ Ỡ1 •H *H fr> r-»' ĨH 1-4 Õ s ỮS r-" K fN rv rC K r«í ư» r*> 00 F> tH o co rôr-i ể H ỡ r>- 5* ãH IN i c i f>í I s ro fM ữS ưỉ »£> m 00 ưi »-< ò fM Ỗ 00 o rrt r-T Ổ ■ H H ẫ T-» > ! • tn -< ã o z m s Q ị o z •8 Ọụ o u ư> -< a z a u £ ơ* >< o ưì Qu o o z E 03 o b s «/ì j£ (D ■c !/» "O c ) n JS n ôA ãa " O c "ĩi s I z X z I s ir> â ằ-4 r 1/1 ế ô/> ô > i a Ũ g a u £ m < l Q >• ■ fC X ư» N -< o z o •H -< Ị o z c § a u £ § a Q 01 un s co b - CL ► — vrt o s u § Qp § a u a u Ê £ g p u u UJ ũì 75 13 z < cc l/> CD o: i/> — « -o ẽ tn o T5 c ữí T5 _c t" •D c T X X z z I r> ôã- 00 T-i rH ơ> H o rg rH H XJ c -c z X X z I 2 rH UI *-< lO IH »-< X p z •< h~ UJ I u a » — o ĩz *- >A J2 ro ‘rõ "ĩõ ■Ổ •c \A ự* tõ 3 3 •o ■ Õ ■o ■a T3 _c c c c c *o c í z z> > I o o a tố T3 c ts TJ c o o z § o ã o o t/t Q- "55 ễ g võ < tẽ < v/í a fD c t" ■c c I p < z h* iu > o Õ CL yị s a u £ X Q »- •c •p _c 15 z < X •9 < X ► — a u > z t> o >- í ỉ CL d tj rM u > ư\ u > p tõ I (TJ c > Ol -ô Ê a ão u r0 1/ằ e> z •3 a ễ iO s ư> JA X 08 V LU £ « X O' o u «£) rx o z s Q > c •0» o oc ỉ ■Ề o u & u ĩ> ơì cc LL > u > > ơ' tH Ố cc *z ẩ < z > z o ổ > z i/> < õ Q ■ẽ o o Q ti d o > t/1 "O c * •c l/l VI 3 ■ o ■o _c c IA _JA — < T> "rê m JP •c ũí t« 3 3 ■ O ■ D D T3 •0 c c ■ _c c _c 4S tĩí ■ o c IS •c »0 X z I z X X X X z X z X I X X X X f*í T-« *» rSi r-i in P«J •-< vo rs *-« r» ÍN r-i 00 ơ» r»i H s •H r-i rt •H rsi m ro •H 'ĩ m •H ro z Q § ■s -o >■ •ni X a u LU g *u z> r>ì rn \ữ rỉ z I z X I ư> rm rH 00 m ri ỉ o ri f>J Csl y~* r-t ro r-* •H ưì o ó o ưì ó H r i ơ» ọ o ƠI cri •» Ĩ Ĩ •H ị Õ ri ưì rH Ị 'í võ Ĩ f -ỉ •H co » Ĩ vf> r* Õ r-i § rH Ĩ »D r» ó ro 1-1 Ỏ < z r-i § ri »T ro rv j rH eo m *-< lA K ri s Ị fN ưì Ị < z Ị Õ Ĩ ó Õ eo r** ỏ o ÍS N • pg rH Ị Ĩ Ĩ o rõ Õ 00 Ó N rộ ri ơ» •H Ó ư> õ < z 8 ơ\ ăó Ị Ĩ T-i ò < H ò a> ở' õ õ cn õ < ro vo Ó m Ó < wi Ọ T-t ọ> r» ọ m r*' co eo ô rvi rn o ú rú ã ể Ò rì H Õ õ Õ ri H ư> cọ 1—1 Ỡị r>ì cn T-ỉ ư> co Ọ rõ o r*- rv à\ ó ư> o õ ư> ữì ri ro K o rH Ĩ r** o ị ó Õ g õ co ■—< o ro « < z < ID o T-< •H ưS rí < o õ IN Õ Ô m o Õ ƠI o Ĩ ó m o m Ũ5 o Ĩ ị d ó o • Õ s Õ •H Õ ó ọ ó Õ • d ỏ rv o d 8 T-i co oS Ò r** C71 t4 Ưì ũi Ĩ 4 oo co Ó ro ix» Õ m ơ» Ó ơt Ởi Ó co ơ> Ó r» ơ> õ r' 00 ó ơì ó Ò < ro fõ Ó ơ' ƠI Õ eo cn Õ < VD m ÍN r* r-i •-* ri 0 ơ» rõ Õ 9 Ưì 00 0 o> 00 Ó co r* ó 9 rỉ CTl fO Ị 2008 s Ị õ Ĩ Ị Q H s «N ĩ < z rõ &> *-• ù> Õ ỈÃ ư> 8 N CO N LU r»* Q r*t < < 2 Ol ư> Ơ* o o m f>j »15 VO oo co ưi Ó fM èọ r4 < z rõ < z < z Ị m CN Ĩ tn ưi Ị ơl H Õ < z < < z o Õ s Õ ó fO Cb 8 B eo ro VD ro rsi o Vũ o r*« H ơì Ĩ ị ưi co ế *-* ằ-ô 1Ê> ro > ^ Đ m o ể r-ớ s ế fừ m ã-ô m ú Ề y£> n in io ó r- o r>j Õ ƠI s Õ Õ ó ị o m K H © Õ ó ro o Õ o Ò < z < z ro •N lõ o% to •4 Ó CO ọ Ỏ Õ Ó 8 8 8 8 rC o •H ế ư? ơì ưS V r-‘ s ơ> rỉ H Ớ» Ỏ n r-> n rọ ri rá o Õ õ ó m z õ o < z r* j < z tn ằ-ớ ô- ãH o ãH Ò ri ÍN ơ' Ò H o Õ TH o ó < z rt Ọ H V rH Ó o Õ s Õ < z ưì F» õ 8 8 I r-• H o r-t ưì õó r> í vo ã & nẻ t: Õ sê ầ r*l o« 00 ơ> en s Ò o m Ỡi ƠI Sò »n s s r-í Õ «-* Õ r-T 00 « ÍN H m co *H H ưi r-t ư> F*H Ẹp ể N ro rõ co g r-ĩ fM o in ỮS È ả fN Ị fị ÍN ầ s ị r-< Q z j ? I r« «3 Ị ro I oĩ CO H fS f r- ã-ô ỡn 4n ư\ r< r -t s m 12 o t§ Ị ưĩ 9? z I r*í r**' PVI f*| •H ơ> I ị ÍN r«T rị fN BÕ r* í o CO ƠI rH H ưn ưĩ eo in s ư> m o in m s £ Ị < 2* < z PM K *-• CN o ỉ N o D s a Ọ CO -t »-í in Si r ì 1-4 < U3 1/1 o ro iĨ cn r-H z •< X ■? b *- í z ỉ c M c ÍS o x: -* ro > oc c rõ E 1 o z *< X b t- u 5 s u i X u m >- o ị o o J£> X Ợ' r~i *o c z I Ọ z ễ ị < > X u Q | X UJ k— u X 1 í 1 > z < o X ac o u z ■O o 3 UJ T5 c ■o c í s V X I z z ỗ X ĩ X u ÕT y Q 1_» on cL »n ư% ựt /» ro 1/1 (0 ịf> ẽõ V) ĩo ty n> -o c -o c ÍC ■D c ro •o c »0 l/l •o c ■o c 1/1 -n in Õ Õ Õ o u X u I o X u X rH rN m Ư-l ự? r" •H T-* »-* n z K ơ> r-*' ÍN oi s? fN r» H z trt tfỹ H z 13 z •o u ĩ ỗ I § z X 4Í D 1 ĩc X ■s z o £ u z I < z Q o u n> o a tUJ o > o cữ ỉ z u TJ c lũ iu Q> 00 Q > Õ n X Ề V— & ■D c i o X a X t— Cj Õ I ứ z ỉ z ĩ z z —í z Q> r> < õ z •3 X u ĨS ■o c « £ w o z '5 m c o K y u ■o c o H < z r-* ĩ «/» g ã ■t X Ui o m ể § s < cu CD « ■o o u > m ÍM ÍN § s H r*ĩ X I < z ư» < UJ o u < > o z s o >•< X < z < ỉ ò I z ■< z 03 •< *< Ị X z •< > óa ỉ í o u to CL ?n T5 c > Q- c ưi Q l/ì > ĩ t < ĩ o o u> z o z >>■ oB •< *< cõ z o * z •5 z o LU X ta I u * (T> s QC< c 3 E X ỈC a V •5 Q *- z X õ X a u t a u c d £ X o 1/1 d t— u h- < z 1- z < z •< Q ã K s i u Q o •< > c w V5 X < 1/1 i -1 n UJ CL > Q w s Õ I < o z -< ò X HU K u o D < z »✓» ỗ z in D rv rH T-» u I I X § Õ < §fN r** fN < rôJ o Đ p 1N fM 8M < z Ị Ị Õ "§ Õ ọ õ < z Ọ o s £ I I s ío_ z íI ỊU X o o o < z ỊỊ1 ■ẵ o > ■s t o VJ £ o ữĩ (ũ 1/1 a» 0J U ụ)I c M !! I * 5* » õ VD eo Ĩ £ ó 00 ĩ** Õ ro K õ s õ fN r< ó < rK ò co Õ ơ> » Õ < < o» r~ õ K> Õ r* oii Ĩ vị Ĩ < 2T om õ fn s Ĩ «8N < z r* ơ> ỏ CO Õ a» ó 'ĩ Õ õọ» Ĩ < z co ơì Õ ơ» Fó < z < o ơ> õ co 00 Õ < z < z < z < z rv> ó < z < rx c\ K ó CO o» õ orw õ 00 o Ò ờ) Õ o» fN Õ fS IN ơ> oj u> Tí o> rí õ *í fN H 't> vi CN h < Õ H ro õ fN ií •H rã lA OỊ ri H ao Õ »} õ co ư> ò ưi O) ri m võ r*j U p»3í ri rv 8r>J < z 00 rM Õ H Õ IN f>l Ò ư> oa Ĩ ÍN m «-i o f*ì rv C4 ni co ÍM õ < z 00 v£ Ĩ ư> õ m ưi Ĩ < < rg •H r* èõ Ĩ •n ị *T ưi õ < *y •H fN ƠI in ri < ư> trt Õ ofN Õ co rr> Ị ÍS Ĩ r-' Ọ r4 < z eo õn «N W D ỏ < < z N rõ Ị ư> ÍM r4 < z < z* < < N Õ < z' < rsj d V r* rõ r-1 o õ «oH Õ IM o Ị ■ Ĩ r** ói d co vo d Ưì rỉ U rHI Õ Õ fM ro Õ ro o Ò Õ ro o Ó rH u> d *5 (N d ro N Õ in Ó Ó d H Õ fõ rS ư> < z H o Ĩ rv o Ị • o Ơ fNI Õ s Ò a> N T-i C oO Ó < ưt - u a y B u o Q s m Q z X e *3>v JbZ ~ 'O £ Ò 5ữi z •< Ổ z ap n ► — zÚI k w a> 0) 1c T> c ^ i -s 10 »8 u o & uĩX c ũ Đ ô-i co ế oo oS Õ «Cr> O Õ ỡ' ị s ó *CN Ị Õ o< ơ vơ'o Õ ã> co ao ó < z < < z ơ> r> Ò eo UD Ò 8 CO õ o 00 Õ < z < < ơ> Õ § 1-i < m d < z H K Ó cn ở' õ ơ« d < z < ưì 00 ỡ> H CỌ o rt o tn o ro ?! © co 00 t-1 eo Ị Ị m ó u> ri * rõ ơ>s í* ri r* rH r-i K> «■ ÍN õ »ĩ Õ < z < z < z VD ri ro ri ■-tJ O Ĩ rl T-* Õ r-< ÍN •H P KO Ó < < < z ro ữí Ỏ § ri < z r> * ÍN Õ < z cn u> •Ỡ * -* r-i rg < z < r-i tH i-i N ư> Ò rÕ V HO Ĩ s Õ Ị r> H d ro o d g Ò d rH fM Ị 8 ị o d s Õ d m •H Õ r* •H Ị g m o> Õ m0 Ó s Ó < T> trt Õ o © H H Ĩ f» oJ Ó co o Ó rH o Õ oM Õ fN Õ IN Õ g Ò Õ s o < < z' < rŨS o u ■«r ó 8 8 ưã fN fM o? fõ fS l r-* r>j co CN Ui rQ* s ễ ơ3 Ui r*» ÍN ã § 1/1 00 § ĩ = rs Q s Ọ Ỉ2 oõ N» o> Õ Ỏ rỉ «* iK rt IN ơĩ F- £ H sm ? < z < z < s o zH< IT o X toB D t- u V ■ < o Q ur;o e> z K c 0) 06 « c o CL ũ > z s < X Q = > X ta u £ e> z oz ■< É D u5 o > ể z »/1 z & d u £ z z zo C O ro rN ơ> PM o r*j rM •N rg d ó d Ị 2 § Õ Õ g Õ ú ã ã r-ô rN ế ỡ ể < z < z < z r**N » ó H o Õ < z X z co D u Q u Ê oC£ X ÍN Ưi § i- iư> t< Q < Ò I z ỗ o o < »o ẫ1 o2 0tẽ oơ> ũ> uS ri oX u K < > 0u > a u ẵ ọ ì s I oT-* 00 « K < z oz oo z o u z o rí M n o «5/> < 0z 51 *bH1a puu u Iui fị < < z Ìz o oX K D «/» su ao tu u z h~ X z z D J/Í u a U tu ucc h- m ƯI ưt *A t/l ự» J2 ts u !Ì o J o ụ w u u u a u J u u « u !ắ ^ " »•= s 5 I X X ơ> ÍNI o •H fN fN 2 2 I IM rM ro IM rsi ưi r\i vo 5 X I r* fN co fN ơ> fN ÍT> K Ĩ < < z < z 00 m ơì co ư> ó 0*1 r< K vo Õ ro vc rH Ó < < o * § o rn Õ «-H ơ* O' ro Õ ưi ữỊ 00 r-i Õ fM 00 Ó rg ưS Õ ơ> o Õ co eo Ó H H m vo Ô 0 < < m ^ Õ 0 H kT) r*H fN VÍ5 Õ H m ó ư> ỡi ó < *-ì < z < 1 •H ưí ó 0 •-H V£> Ĩ ư> H 0 < Ui fN ơ* Ó Đ â ế 001 cn K ể trỡ 860 H r** 1001 o 00 Õ rv 860 ư> I-* õ cc Q r' ẳ IN & < z ■9 ơ' ó *-* ơ» Õ H co 01 Ó s H < z < < < < < < 2 ơ> Ơ a\ ó Ị VA õ < m CO rsi /E r*> ÍN cọ Õ 1S1 ró < «-1 co o ưi Ĩ ■ã eo ưi rõ ấn õ CO *-< Ĩ s Ơ r-í ƠI T“i Ĩ in rõ < z rí fM Ĩ rv H Õ ư> H o T-* 00 00 Ọ ri ri r~ võ Ĩ § 'i m co ưì ư» ũậ í*i CO N ri co ri H VỊ Ĩ < < z < z s H rv < s rH o rưi < ó ơ» rH Ĩ co eo Ĩ «S| r*j *-» o Õ H o Q Õ § IN • r-t Õ Õ < rH o Õ fM o Ị Ĩ VO < Ĩ § r-i < rH o Ĩ • < < z 8 U3 o ư> m 00 LÕ rH ã »ri cị •H s s rH < CO ní £■ er UI r** H r*» m õ < Õ < co Ịạ r*i r-i IM m ri Õ »N m õ r» ƠI ưi fN < ^ ộ T-i ỉ o ®ì ri fM o Ị ỉ s ri s d m -n Õ o H Ò s < < z rs • • ■ < z < z < z • < < z < z 8 ơ* m Ĩ »H < z o < o z l£ Irt Ị § 1-i èo ơ» ír ó ưì tj ị vo m r4 rN rN Õ ơ> H Õ ơ' H m H BO CJ> m "1 Ĩ f>í fN Ĩ Õ < z < H Õ < ó 00 ọ ĨT ư> õ o Ị < z rv M D 00 r-( Ơ «N H Ị n H rí < z H < z Đ *? o H < r Q pôỡ eo m rõ s lò y-i o X H z 91 n c ĩ o o z z »< t— >k Um o o © z cu > V T3 I fQ u u t/» K Q > ưì In d u s tr y co o € Q u t— o > is y - £ - 5 ỉ 5 u I z I srs *-t to r»J ÍN VỊ 04 m vo r»j s < ĩ u ỉ «5 •a V? *< o X àí u> X o ■> X o z o X z o u s ẵ (X> « có ~ẵ s w > z o < m a u o o K "2 ‘ũ c rg c ĨZ 'rê c fD c il «« ũ c IT» c iZ X 5 u X 1 z 3C o •5 X V a p u ư* ro ằ s Ị < r-i trì •b O •< X z z o r-* o I-* rs co fN co rM rsí ■í Ư1 K K MI n> Õ c »0 c iZ rỉ o § — ữ) o 'í ưì »í r-~ s *o »o & u X a Q u s ÌZ ị Ổ X c re c iT z H co >A o s CÕ ồro o o Qo s í z Q ụ> X Õ n n' ỉ o V3 z < z -ĩti % ■= Ẵ «> n E X CL u £ Cl Ỡ u á co rsj c ÍZ X co co rvj ơ» ó õ (Ti Ó < < z < z rM VÕ Ị f*> Ĩ 2ơ> Õ o m ri 00 Ưì r>i 'I Õ 00 rri Ĩ H c* ri ơ' m ri «rj ơ' ro rõ T-* iH ri 'D < ưi < z < z < z Ợ) Ị fõ r*> ư% ri s < z co o cr> N 3/0 r*- CM PVJ Ề z o Õ • 1D r- Q r>ỉ ơí rH r-i Ị eo ri 2o> Õ 2008 0 ƠI r** õ fO K Ó o > -O Q1 Q fr •H co C7» Ĩ ơt ơ> ó ơ» ị ưì *-• Ỏ "í s r-i õ Ị Ĩ m c* K ị o cọ •-i Õ m d o Õ Ĩ H o ó ó cr Ui l'* r>í Ơ Õ Ọ H ư> r-' vo r*ớ fN in ô r rừ ãH H ãớ ỡ N ô-ô N rĩ u> rVĩ rí Õ ► — JĐ N ô- \ >' rN~ cũ rM m 00 rõ (N 8 § Õ m r-t 00 Q I i c r* a o wH ưt *-ì H cH o r>í I00 y •2 JS u u c c ÍC ro ĨT ỈT < s 00 cn ữ» < z Ưì o co fx rí CO r-t < z o z o -< o Ò o z o => ẫ X u H- *- CTCP PHAT TRIEN NHA B A RIA VUNG TAU 3S o u fõ ’ũ c "rô 'ũ c m il r** o z s o X z < X a *> D < ỉ ac ■Ui \D z < =) Qj fp u -C c 0) nu £ V to o £1 ÍT ĩx LL (U 01 X I 0* z I X u X u X TO V ac i e ãt IM Jẻ u I z X u I z X o z rr> rg 00 1^ s P*J H ư» g j Q UI 00 o X ÍT> in ơ» Ỡ* ơ> 04 rM fN F in a n cia l leverage o f com panies lis te d on HOSE an d HaSTC REFERENCE A dham C hehab, 1995, Essay on determ inants o f C ap ita l structure, D octor o f Philosophy dissertation, U niversity o f N ew Orleans CBV , 2008, ìndiistry cỉassiýìcation, Equity G roup, Financial D atabase o f Bien Viet Securities Joint-stock com pany M ost updated 30 Septem ber 2008 Financial term , Industry classiỳìcation G ICS, [online] A vailable at URL: at URL: http://w w w investopedia.eom /term s/g/gics.asp (A ssessed 10 O ctober 2008) Financial term , Industry classị/ìcation lC B , [online] A vailable http://A vw w investopedia.eom /tenns/i/industrv-classification-benchm ark.asp (A ssessed 10 O ctober 2008) Financial term s, 2008, C apital in Finance, [online] A vailable at URL: http://w w w invcstopedia.eom /tcrm s/c/capital.asp (A ssessed O ctober 2008) H A STC , 2008, OffìciaI vvebsite, [online] A vailable at U R L: http://hastc.org.vn/ (A ssessed 30 Septem ber 2008) H O SE, 2008, O íĩĩcial w ebsite, [online] A vailable at URL: http://w w w hsx.vn/ (Assessed 30 S eptem ber 2008) H ung Son Tran, 2006, Các tá c nh â n tác độ n g đến c cẩu vốn cù a công ty niêm y ế t thị Irư ng chứng khoáng Việt Nam , [online] A vailable http://w w w saga.vn/T aichinh/C autracvon/C autrucvonl/8938-saga at URL: (A ssessed 12 N ovem ber 2008) Jensen, M and M eckling w , “Theory o f th e firm : M anagerial behavior, agency costs, and Capital structure" Journal o f F inancial E conom ics (O ctober 1976): 305-60 Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 « * 90 • F in a n cia l leverage o f com panies lis te d on HO SE an d HaSTC 10 Joshua A bor, 2007, ‘in d u stry classiíìcation and the C ap ital s tr u c tu r e o f G hanaian SM Es” , U niversity o f G hana Business School, Legon, G hana 11 Kim Lien, 2008, N gành dược Việt N am trước thềm ỈVTO, [online] A vailable at URL: http://w w w sggp.org.vn/vtesuckhoe/2006/10/67973/ (A ssessed 31 O ctorber 2008) 12 M arsh, p., “T he choice betvveen equity and debt: An em pirical study” Journal o f Fm ance (M arch 1982): 121-44 13 M T, 2007, N ă m 2007: N gành ngân hàng thắng lớn, [online] A vailable at ULR: http://dantri.com vn/kinhdoanh/am -2007-ganh-ngan-hang-thang-lon/2006/12/160094.viD (A ssessed N ovem ber 2008) 14 M yers, s c and N M ajluf., “C orporate íinancing and investm ent decisions when firm s have iníịrm ation that investors not have” J o u m a l o f F inancial E conom ics 13 (June 1984): 187-221 15 M yers, s c , "D eterm inants o f corporate borrovving” Journal o f F inancial Econom ics (N ovem ber 1977): 147-76 ] M yers, s c , “T he Capital structure puzzle” Journal o f Finance 39 (July 1984): 575-92 17 Petersen, M A and R G Rajan, “T he beneíits o f ỉending relationships: Evidence from small business data” Jo u rn a l o f Finance 49 (M arch 1994): 3-37 18 Phuoc H a, 2008, 20% doanh nghiệp đ ứ ng trước nguy c p h ả sàn, [online] Available at URL: http://w w w vnn.vn/kinhte/2008/10/806847/ (A ssessed N ovem ber 2008) 19 R obert A K orajczyk and A m non Levy, 2001, “ Capital structure choice: m acroeconom ic conditions and íìnancial constraints'’, K ellogg School o f M anagem ent, Northvvestem U niversity, Evanston, IL 60208-2001, USA Graduation Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 F in a n cia l leverage o f com panies lis te d on HOSE an d HaSTC 20 R oss, A.s and Thom pson s , 2004, “Leverage and C a p ita l structure policy” F undam ental o f corporate f'trtance, rd edn, p.702-703 Mc G raw -H ill, A ustralia 21 Saga, 2008, s ố liệu tình hình lạm p h t Việt Nam, Ịonline] A vailable at URL: http://w w w saga.vn/V andecuaban/14209.saga (A ssessed N ovem ber 2008) 22 San, N H , 2002, “D eterm inants o f C a p ita l structure for tourism com panies in Thue Thien H ue Province”, Da N ang University, Da Nang 23 Schvveser, 2008, “Capital Structure theory” CFA L eveỉ 2: Study Guide, p 68 24 Sum itra Das, 2003, “ Inter-Industry differences in Capital structure: The Evidence from India” , Jadavpur University, India 25 V iet bao, 2007, 10 kiện kinh tế nỗi bật năm 2007, [online] A vailable at URL: http://vietbao.vn/K inh-te/10-su-kien-kinh-te-noi-bat-nam -2007/70108289/87/ (Assessed N ovem ber 2008) 26 W ikipedia, Capital structure, 2008, [online] A vailable http://en.w ikipedia.org/w iki/C apital_structure (A ssessed O ctober 2008) Graduatiion Thesis _ Ngo Thi Thanh Huyen BA3 04 at URL: .. .FINANCIAL LEVERAGE F COMPANIES LISTED ON HOSE AND HASTC A N AN ALYSIS ACROSS INDUSTRIES, OVER TIM E A N D IN COMPARISON W ITH OTHER COUNTRIES m TRUNGTÃM THONGĩ!N TKƯVIẺN m h... In addiỉion, ỉisted companies in Vietnam and China ry more on shorí-term debt compared to those in USA and Wesíern Europe Imptìcations f o r poìicy makers and managers to improve the situations... bank loans and other short-term liabilities, such as trade credits, tax payables and other account ■ L ong-term liabilities include loans from banks, bonds and other Iiabilities vvith more than