OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA
RESEARCH PROJECT = 1100) (BMBRS103)
| FACTORS INFLUENCING EMPLOYEE’S
ORGANIZATIONAL CITIZENSHIP BEHAVIOR] AT HO CHI MINH CITY DEPARTMENT OF
INDUSTRY AND TRADE
Trang 2Advisor’s assessment
Trang 3ACKNOWLEDEGEMENTS:
I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my supervisor Dr Nguyen The Khai for his guidance and insightful comments on this thesis I tried my best to finish this research base on the knowledge about the Business Research Method 1 had
I thankful to all of the participants in my survey who have willingly shared their precious time during the process of this research
Trang 4CONTENTS
L INTRODUCTION 00101577 = 01
1.1 About Ho Chi Minh City Department of Industry and Trade 01
Trang 6FIGURE AND TABLE
Figure 1: Propose research model of employee”s OCB at DOIT - 17 Table 1: Organizational citizenship behavior scale . -ccccserserrrrieee 19 Table 2: Person organization ft scaÌe - - ch HH 20 Table 3: Public service motivation SC «óc 2+ s2 492821812 1 1e, 20 Table 4: Job satisfaction fit sCaÌ€ -¿ - 5S SH H211 8214112 T1 de 21 Table 5: Cronbach’s alpha — internal consisfencY .-cecseseneieieiirre 22 Table 6: Cronbach°s Alpha of Organizational Citizenship Behavior 23 Table 7: Cronbachˆs Alpha of Person Organization FI( -c series 23 Table §: Cronbachˆs Alpha of Public Serlice Motivation «.cceeeeririee 23
Table 9: Cronbach’s Alpha of Job SatisfacHon ccceinhhhieeerrie 24
Table 10: Reliability Statistics 0.0 24 Table 11: Descriptive statistics 2.00 ccccseceeceeeecereerenteeeceeeesenessecsenesenessesenansneetans 24 IV 10-82160100) 25
Table 13: Model sumary of H1, H2, H2 . ccẶ Sằn‡ HH 26
Table 14: Coefficients of H1, H2, H2 - Ăn, 8 xe 26 Table 15: Model sumary oŸ H4 - ch nh HH2 0 re 27 Table 16: Coefficients of H4 Ác 2.2412 H101 1 kg 27 Table 17: Model sumary of HŠ . 5 chờ HH hưng 27
Trang 7ABSTRACT
This study examines a model of the relationship between person organization fit, public service motivation, job satisfaction and organizational citizenship behavior, which is an interesting issue in the context of Ho Chi Minh city Department of Industry and Trade following intergration, started in 2008
Improving public service quality has become a priority of the government to meet
the expectations of the public, as it is generally known that the quality of this service is relatively poor still Therefore, to provide better service, public servants
have to reconsider their basic function
We collected data from 170 employees working at Ho Chi Minh city Department of Industry and Trade We test our hypotheses using structural equation modeling
Our results show that person organization fit has a positive and significant effect on public service motivation and job satisfaction, which means that public servants having higher motivation in providing public service and are more likely to be satisfied with their job Moreover, job satisfaction is found to be related to the organizational citizenship behavior Having higher job satisfaction leads public servants to perform organizational citizenship behavior in a better way Generally, our findings indicate that public servants who have a high motivation in providing public service and high satisfaction with their jobs may also strongly intend to show prosocial behaviors beyond the behaviors that are formally prescribed by the organization
Trang 81 INTRODUCTION
1.1 About Ho Chi Minh City Department of Industry and Trade (DOIT)
Department of Industry and Trade were established on the basis of the
Decision of Ho Chi Minh People’s Committee about the consolidation of Industry
Department and Trade Department into Department of Industry and Trade
Department of Industry and Trade is the specialized organization under the
authority of Ho Chi Minh People’s Committee, having the function of advising and
assisting Ho Chi Minh People’s Committee in performing the state management in industry and trade sector including engineering; metallurgy; electric energy; chemicals; industrial explosives; mining and mineral processing industry; consumer goods industry; food industry; and other processing industries; the circulation of goods; export; import; market management; competition management; trade promotion; monopoly control; anti-dumping; anti-subsidy; consumer protection; e- commerce; trade services; economic integration; industrial clusters management in the local area; industry promotion; and other public services under the jurisdiction of Department of Industry and Trade
Rights and duties
1 Submitting to the city People’s Committee the annual, 5-year or long-term draft plans; the guidelines, policies, programs, measures and regulations on developing the industry and trade sector in the local area; the draft decisions and instructions issued under the authority of Ho Chi Minh People’s Committee in the industry and trade sector; the draft regulation on the functions, rights, duties and organization structure of Market Management Branch in accordance with the regulations of the Government, Ministry of Industry and Trade and other authorized state organizations; the draft regulations on the title standards for the heads and deputy heads of the agencies under the authority of Department of Industry and
(a a
Trang 9Trade; the draft regulations on the title standards for the leaders of Industry and Trade Divisions or Economic Divisions of the District People’s Committees
2 Submitting the draft decisions on the establishment, merger and
dissolution of the agencies under the authority of Industry and Trade Department prescribed by law; the draft decisions and instructions issued under the authority of Chairman of the city People’s Committee in industry and trade sector
3 Guiding and supervising the implementation of legal documents, policies, plannings, projects, programs and regulations on developing the industry and trade sector after they are approved; disseminating, guiding and educating the industry and trade related legislation
4 Assisting the city People’s Committee in the assessment of the basic
design of the investment projects on developing the industry and trade sector in the
local area; the assessment, issuance, amendment, supplementation, extension and
revocation of the licenses under the responsibility of Department of Industry and
Trade in accordance with the regulations of law and the assignment of city People’s
Committee
5 Industry and handicraft:
* Engineering and metallurgy: Implementing the planning, projects and policies on developing the engineering and metallurgy sector, engineering and electro-mechanical products, hi-tech products combining engineering technique,
automation and industrial electronics in the local area
* Electricity and energy: Implementing the projects and plans on developing the electric energy and the application of new energy and renewable energy in the local area; organizing training courses on legal knowledge of electricity activities and electricity use for the electricity organizations in the local area; training the
professional knowledge of the electricity safety for the technical staffs of rural
a
Trang 10electricity management organizations; implementing the electricity pricing plan in the local area after being approved by the competent authorities; coordinating with the competent state organizations in the specialized inspection according to the law
* Chemicals, industrial explosives and machinery or equipment with strict requirements on technical safety: Implementing the policies, projects and plans on developing the sectors of chemicals, industrial explosives and machinery or equipment with strict requirements in the local area; coordinating with local relevant organizations in inspecting and handling the law violations on the management, use, storage and transportation of chemicals, industrial explosives, liquefied petroleum gas and machinery or equipment with strict requirements on technical safety according to the law
* Consumer goods industry, food industry and other processing industries: Implementing the plans and projects on developing these sectors after being approved, including: textile, footwear, paper, porcelain, glass, plastic, beer, wine, beverages, tobacco, candy, milk, vegetable oil, flour and starch; guiding and supervising the application of the standards of quality, environmental and food hygienic safety from production to circulation under the jurisdiction of Department of Industry and Trade
* Industry promotion: Implementing the programs, plans and projects on industry promotion in the local area including activities funded by the national industry promotion funds and the local industry promotion funds; organizing
training courses on capacity building in organizing the industry promotion activities
for staffs working in the industry promotion sector
* Industrial clusters management: Chairing and coordinating with relevant organizations in the implementation of programs, projects, plans, mechanism and policies on developing the small and medium size enterprises, the collective economic organizations in the local area (including rural craft villages, cooperatives
a
Trang 11relating to industry and trade sector); ratifying the regulations of these
organizations; implementing the preferential mechanism and policies on investment
attraction, export and import, tax, finance, labor, infrastructure construction, land
clearance, new industrial clusters construction in the local area after being approved
6 Trade:
* Domestic trade: Implementing the mechanism, plans and policies on developing the wholesale and retail trade infrastructure network, including: markets,
commercial centers, supermarkets, stores, trade cooperatives, trade services;
commercial agencies, franchising network and other types of trade infrastructure; chairing and coordinating with relevant organizations in guiding and implementing the mechanism and policies on encouraging the expansion of the business network,
establishing and developing the stable channels of goods circulation from
production to consumption in the local area; implementing the preferential policies and mechanism in order to encourage and support people in mountainous and remote areas in production and living (such as providing the essential goods, supporting the circulation of trade services and goods, etc); collecting and processing the market information on the total flow of goods, total supply and demand, goods reserves, the fluctuations in price of essential commodities, the policies for people in mountainous and remote areas; proposing the measures for regulating the circulation of commodities in each period to the competent
authorities
* Export and import: Implementing the policies, plans, programs and projects on developing and encouraging commodity export; developing export and import services in the local area; managing the commodity export and import of domestic and FDI enterprises or foreign enterprises which have no representative in
Viet Nam
a a
Trang 12* E-commerce: Chairing and coordinating with relevant organizations in building the infrastructure of e-commerce applications in the local area; implementing the policies, plans and programs to train and develop the human resources for the management of e-commerce activities in the local area
* Trade promotion: Implementing the trade promotion plans, projects and programs in order to encourage the export, support local enterprises in building and developing the Viet Nam commodity brands; executing and supervising the registration of trade fairs and exhibitions organizing and the promotion of goods
* Market management: Performing the work of market management in the local area according to the regulations of the Government, Ministry of Industry and Trade and other competent state management organizations; guiding and supervising the law enforcement in the industry and trade sector of organizations and individuals doing business in the local area; conducting the specialized inspection under the provisions of law; chairing and coordinating with relevant organizations to fight against smuggling, trafficking of smuggled goods and prohibited goods, production and trafficking of counterfeit goods, poor quality goods, goods violating the regulations on intellectual property; struggling against the acts of speculation, market manipulation and commercial fraud of individuals and organizations doing business in the local area
* Competition, antitrust, antidumping, anti-subsidy and consumer protection: Guiding and implementing the provisions of law on competition, antitrust, anti- dumping, anti-subsidy, consumer protection and ensuring a fair competition
environment in the local area; proposing the amendment of issued regulations and
documents inconsistent with the competition law to the relevant organizations; having the right to request relevant organizations and individuals to provide information and documents necessary for the performance of assigned duties prescribed by law on competition, antitrust, anti-dumping, anti-subsidy and consumer protection; collecting and setting up the database to manage and provide
a
Trang 13the information on enterprises at dominant position in the market, monopoly enterprises, competition rules in the associations and the exemptions
* Economic integration: Implementing the plans, programs and specific measures on economic integration, international trade in the local area after being approved; chairing and coordinating with relevant organizations in disseminating and guiding the implementation of the plans, programs and regulations on economic integration and international trade in the local area
7 Assisting the city People’s Committee in the state management of enterprises and organizations in the collective and private economy sector; guiding and supervising the activities of local associations and non-governmental organizations in the industry and trade sector in accordance with the law
8 Guiding and supervising the application of autonomy and self- responsibility mechanism of professional organizations under the authority of Industry and Trade Department and in accordance with the law
9 Promoting the international cooperation in the field of industry and trade in accordance with the law and the decentralization of the city People’s Committee
10 Giving professional advice and guidance on the field of industry and trade to the Industry and Trade divisions or the Economic divisions of the district people’s committees
11 Implementing the research plans and applying the scientific and technological progress in the field of industry and trade under the jurisdiction of Industry and Trade Department; guiding the application of economic and technical standards, guidelines and norms; setting up the information storage systems and providing data on industry and trade in accordance with the law
a a a
Trang 1412 Doing the administration reform of Industry and Trade Department in accordance with the objectives and contents of the administration reform program of the city People’s Committee
13 Inspecting, testing and handling the violations, settling complaints and denunciation; preventing and struggling against the corruption; doing saving, fighting against waste in the field of industry and trade according to the law and the assignment the city People’s Committee
14 Providing public services in the domain of industry and trade under the jurisdiction of Industry and Trade Department and in accordance with the law
15 Stipulating the functions, rights, duties, organization structure and working relationship of the organizations directly under the authority of Industry and Trade Department; managing the regular staffs, implementing the salary policies, the treatment, training, reward and discipline regime for the officials under the jurisdiction of Industry and Trade Department in accordance with the law and the decentralization of the city People’s Committee
16 Doing the finance and asset management, distributing the budget in accordance with the law and the decentralization of the city People’s Committee
17 Supplying information, doing periodic and extraordinary reports on the implementation of the programs, plans and projects to develop the industry and trade sector in the local area according to the regulations of the city People’s Committee and the Ministry of Industry and Trade
18 Performing other duties assigned by the city People’s Committee and in accordance with the law
Development History of Ho Chi Minh City Industry and Trade Sector In August 2008, implementing the policy of the Government on the
reorganization of the state management units, Ho Chi Minh city Department of
a
Trang 15Industry and Trade was established on the basis of merging Ho Chi Minh city Department of Industry and Department of Trade Following the policy of the Government on the reorganization of the state enterprises, most of the purely business units under the Department were equitized At present, the total number of employees of Ho Chi Minh city Department of Industry and Trade as of October 2016 is about 170 people with 11 divisions (not include 4 dependent units)
1.2 Research problem statement:
Public services worldwide have been subject to reforms and restructures in order to enhance competitiveness and meet social expectation in a dynamically changing global work environment The Vietnam public sector is no exception and reforms in the public’s services have been a priority for every government DOIT is working on a plan in order to increase its effectiveness and efficiency and provide high quality services to citizens and businesses
Nowadays, the success of organization need employees who will do more than their usual job duties that is beyond expectations The main study is to investigate whether the distinct classes of organizational citizenship behavior (OCB) such as altruism and generalized compliance are shown at DOIT, and whether person organization fit, public service motivation and job satisfaction are predictors of OCB at DOIT civil servants
1.3 Research objective:
The aim of this research focuses on clearly defining the relationship between person organization fit, public service motivation, job satisfaction and organizational citizenship behavior at DOIT to improve public service quality, provide better service, what factors DOIT should reconsider? To examine how factors have influenced organizational citizenship behavior and give commendation
to DOIT
a
Trang 161.4 Research scope:
This study focuses to issues related to Person Organization Fit, Public Service Motivation and Job Satisfaction of the employees of DOIT base on their current operating mode and working condition The survey is only built to collect feedback form employees who are working at DOIT, not have the dependent unit
The study is divided into four sections The first section is a literature review, which starts by discussing the history and development of the literature on Organization citizenship behavior I provide a brief description of the variables and theories associated with Organization citizenship behavior and a description of a theoretical framework for the study based on Person organization fit The second section comprises the research methodology employed in the study and describes the data and statistical techniques used to test the hypotheses The third section reports the results and findings of the analysis Finally, the study concludes with a discussion of the findings, focusing on the implications for public managers
a
Trang 172 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Organizational Citizenship Behavior
Organ (1997) has defined organizational citizenship behavior (OCB) as a contextual performance The behavior carried out by the individuals does not directly support their job but can support the organization as a whole Further, Organ defines OCB as a discretionary individual behavior which is not rewarded by the formal rewarding system but can support the effectiveness of organizational functions in general OCB tends to take the form of extra-role behavior in organization Extra-role behavior is very important for the effectiveness of the organization, which would impact the survival of the organization in the long term, especially during increasing competition between organizations Dyne, Graham & Dienesch (1994) state that OCB is the behavior of employees willing to work more than what they are required to or to carry out things which are not stipulated in their
job description would be beneficial for the success of the company in the long run
In this concept of OCB from, the dimension of civic virtue is similar to social participation, while sportsmanship has the same meaning as loyalty A rather different dimension from the concept of Dyne, Graham & Dienesch is the dimension of advocacy participation, which includes the behavior directed towards other members of the organization and reflects the intention to be different
2.2 P-O fit
Currently, the P-O fit theory is widely used in motivational research in the public sector and is complementary to the PSM approach [for an extensive review of the relations between PSM and P-O fit, see Kim (2012)] Value congruency (i.e., a high level of P-O fit) is frequently conceptualized as an intermediate variable that comes into play in the relationship between PSM and attitudinal outcomes such as preference for public work (Christensen and Wright, 2011; Steijn, 2008);
performance (Bright, 2007); job satisfaction (Wright and Pandey, 2011); or
ee
Trang 18organizational commitment (Kim, 2012) The general theorization of values- congruency in work settings allows for a more precise analysis of the causal link between HRM practices and preferences, and PSM
P-O fit theory relies on the assumption that the individuals in an organization compare their personal aspirations to their organizational environment in search of congruence The idea that individuals expect to fulfill some of their personal needs through their membership in a professional organization is a well-accepted postulate Diverse needs, motives and values theories focus on the individual (internal) or situational (external) determinants of behavior (Alderfer, 1969;
Herzberg et al., 1959; Maslow, 1954) They all share the claim that motivation
arises when individuals seek optimal satisfaction of certain needs In the wake of this strong claim, it is likely that personal expectations might encounter favorable or unfavorable organizational realities and may thus engender satisfaction or dissatisfaction depending on whether or not those expectations are fulfilled
P-O fit is one of the most popular areas of research in this context According to this perspective, employees are more willing to be committed, to be satisfied, and to remain in place if they feel that there is a good fit between their preferences, whether intrinsic or extrinsic, and their organizational environment Numerous studies have demonstrated the positive effect of a high P-O fit on work outcomes, for instance, on job satisfaction or on turnover intentions (Kristof-Brown et al., 2005; Bretz and Judge, 1994)
2.3 Public Service Motivation
Expectations of the public servants differ from those of the employees in the private sector Profit-seeking firms are likely to be dominated by economic oriented employees, while public-service organizations are likely to be dominated by service- oriented employees (Crewson, 1997) Thus, public servants show concern for the community and a desire to serve the public interest The concept of public
a a
Trang 19service motivation is used to explain the differences between public and private employees
Public service is often used as a synonym for government service This
includes also all the workers in the public sector Public service motivation provides both the analytical framework to determine the nature of public sector incentives
and an evaluative mechanism through which the behaviors of those providing the
services can be examined (Jacobson, 2011) According to Perry & Wise (1990), public service motivation may be understood as an individual’s predisposition to respond to motives grounded primarily or uniquely in public institutions and organization These motives can be classified in to three analytically distinct categories: rational, norm-based and affective Perry & Wise (1990) explained that rational motives involve actions grounded in individual utility maximization; and norm-based motives refer to actions generated by efforts to confirm to norms, while affective motives refer to triggers of behavior that are grounded in emotional responses to various social contexts
Perry (1996) has developed a measurement scale for public service motivation Four dimensions of attraction to public policy making, commitment to the public interest and civic duty, compassion, and self-sacrifice-are empirically associated with the construct Attraction to public policy making refers to the opportunity to participate in the formulation of public policy According to Perry
(1996), this dimension is closely related to rationale motives Another dimension,
commitment to the public interest, is one of the most commonly identified
normative foundations for public service and reflects the desire to serve the public interest Perry explained that this desire is only one value included in the construct of public service motivation Following Buchanan, Perry noted that the public service ethics involve a unique sense of civic duty According to Buchanan, this norm derives from the state’s sovereign power and the role of public employees as nonelected trustees of parts of this power
ng
Trang 20Perry (1996) defined compassion as a “patriotism of benevolence”, which reflects an extensive love of all people within our political boundaries and the imperative that they must be protected in all of the basic rights granted to them by the enabling documents
The last dimension of public service motivation, self-sacrifice, is defined by Perry (1996) as the willingness to substitute service to others for tangible personal
rewards
The construct of public service motivation is new, and has not been discussed yet in the literature on public administration (Perry, 1997) Perry’s study (1997) identified potential antecedents of public service motivation He found that an individual’s public service motivation develops from exposure to a variety of experiences, some associated with childhood, some associated with religion and some associated with professional life
Camilleri (2007) investigated the antecedents of public service motivation and found that role states, employee-leader relations, job characteristics, and employee perceptions of the organization have a significant correlation between public service motivation and the antecedents
Several authors developed the hypothesis that motivation differs across different sectors This hypothesis gained continuous attention and was affirmed by empirical support (Jacobson, 2011) Further, researchers’ efforts to understand the behavioral impact of public service motivation have found it to be correlated with
pro-social behavior and positive organizational outcomes
2.4, Job Satisfaction
Job satisfaction refers to the general attitude of an individual towards his or her work A person with high satisfaction would have a positive attitude towards the job while a dissatisfied person would express a negative attitude towards the job
a
Trang 21(Robbins, 2005) Individual attitude towards the job is, according to Gibson,
Ivancevich & Donnelly (1996) a result of the individual perception of their work and work environment, such as supervisor style, policies and procedures, affiliation with their department, work condition and benefits According to Mathis & Jackson (2001) , job satisfaction is a positive emotional condition resulting from the evaluation of one’s work experience comparing to their individual expectations Job dissatisfaction would emerge when expectations of the employee are not met
Job satisfaction plays an important role for an employee Employees who are not satisfied with their job would become frustrated Dessler (2005) adds that employees with job satisfaction usually have good records for attendance, a lower rate of turnover and better job performance than employees with job dissatisfaction
Mathis & Jackson (2001) state that job satisfaction has many dimensions In general, the focus of research are the dimensions of the satisfaction with the job itself, satisfaction with payment, recognition, relation between superior and subordinate, and with opportunities for advancement Each dimension would result in a feeling of satisfaction with the job itself, while different people have their own perception about job satisfaction
Basically, there is no simple way to estimate employee satisfaction Mathis & Jackson (2001) suggest that the critical factor here is the difference between what is expected from the employees and what they receive from their work
2.5 Previous Studies Camilleri (2007)
This research tests the relation between public service motivation and several antecedents, such as personal attributes (education, family life- cycle, tenure, gender, age and pay), job role, perception of employees on their organization, relation between supervisor and subordinate, and job characteristics Tests were
a
Trang 22carried out on the following four dimensions of public service motivation: policy making, public interest, compassion and self-sacrifice The results show that all dimensions of public service motivation, except policy making, are related to personal attributes All dimensions of the public service motivation are also found
to be related to the ambiguity of job role, but job role conflict is not related to public
service motivation Employee perception on the organization is found to be related to most of the dimensions of public service motivation, except compassion The relation between supervisor and subordinate is also found to be related to all dimensions of public service motivation Job characteristics are also related to most dimensions of public service motivation, except compassion
Liu, Tang & Zhu (2008)
This research examines the construct of public service motivation consisting of the four dimensions policy making, public interest, self-sacrifice and compassion in the context of government employees in China A second focus of research is the impact of public service motivation on job satisfaction among the employees Exploratory testing has shown that the generalizability of the concept of public service motivation is limited to the dimensions of policy making, public interest and self- sacrifice The dimension of compassion is found to be lacking evidence in the studies in public sector in China Liu, Tang & Zhu also show that there is a significant impact of public service motivation on job satisfaction
Kim (2006)
This study has examined the role of public service motivation, job satisfaction and organizational commitment as predictors of organizational citizenship behavior (OCB) The result of this research suggests that there is a significant relation between public service motivation and OCB and between organizational commitment and OCB, while job satisfaction is not found to be
related to OCB
Pl
Trang 23Gonzales & Garazo (2006)
The paper of Gonzales & Garazo (2006) examined the structural relation between organizational service orientation, job satisfaction and organizational citizenship behavior (OCB) The result of this research shows that organizational service orientation has a significant impact on job satisfaction Job satisfaction is
also found to have a positive impact on OCB Employees more satisfied with their work would be more likely to practice OCB
(a ea
Trang 243 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 3.1 Hypothesis:
Hypothesis 1: Person organization fit (P-O Fit) will have positive association with Organizational citizenship behavior (OCB)
Hypothesis 2: Person organization fit will have an indirect impact on Organizational citizenship behavior through Public service motivation
Hypothesis 3: Person organization fit will have an indirect impact on Organizational citizenship behavior through Job satisfaction
Hypothesis 4: Person organization fit will have a positive association with Public service motivation (PSM)
Trang 25Dependent Variable: - Person organization fit - Public service motivation - Job satisfaction
3.3 Data collection
This study was carried out to investigate the interrelationships among person organization fit , public service motivation, job satisfaction and organizational citizenship behavior The five hypotheses proposed in this study were tested with a sample of 170 employees who work at DOIT Organizational Citizenship Behavior Scale of Podsakoff and et al., (1990), Person Organization Fit Scale of Bretz and Jude (1994), Public Service Motivation Scale of Perry (1996), and Job Satisfaction Scale of Brayfield and Rothe (1951) were used as the measurement instruments All five hypotheses were fully supported The purpose of this study was to find out the effect of person organization fit on organizational citizenship behavior through the mediations of job satisfaction, and public service motivation
Organizational Citizenship Behavior
Trang 26honest day’s pay Always focuses on what’s wrong, rather than the positive side Is mindful of how his/her behavior affects other people’s jobs Attends functions that are not required, but help the organization image
(Table 1: Organizational citizenship behavior scale) Person Organization Fit
Trang 27Statement 1 2 3 4 5 on individual performance
(Table 2: Person organization fit scale)
Public Service Motivation
(Responses for items | to 4 are obtained on a 5-point Likert-type subscale where 1 = strongly disagree and 5 = strongly agree) Statement 1 2 3 4 5 I like to discuss political subjects with others 1 1213141“ It is important for me to contribute to the common good I consider public service my civic duty 1 2/3/41] 5
I’m often reminded by daily events tow dependent we are on one another
I think people should give back to society more | 1 213 141» than they get from it
(Table 3: Public service motivation scale)
Job Satisfaction
Trang 28
I am often bored with my job 112 31414
'1eel fairly well satisfied with my present job 1 2 |3 1415
I am satisfied with my job for the time being 1 J2 |3 14 15 Most days I am enthusiastic about my work 1 |2 |3 1415 I like my job better than the average worker does 1 12 |3 14 5 I find real enjoyment in my work 1 |2 |3 14315
(Table 4: Job satisfaction fit scale) 4 FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS
4.1, Data analysis
Data collected was analyzed by using SPSS software by testing the
relationship between independent variables and dependent variable
In this study, some questions had a lot of items Therefore, we deleted bad items that are not good discriminators by using factor analysis and arrange these items into group
Reliability statistics
Trang 29Cronbach’s alpha Internal consistency a>0.9 Excellent 0.8<a<0.9 Good 0.7<a<0.8 Acceptable 0.6<a<0.7 Questionable 0.5<a<0.6 Poor a<0.5 Unacceptable
(Table 5: Cronbach’s alpha — internal consistency)
If Cronbach’s alpha reliability of all variable are more than 0.8 which show that the scale has good reliability in order to conduct further research
Descriptive statistics
Descriptive statistics refers to the transformation of the raw data into a form that will make them easy to understand and interpret
Correlation among variables
In order to determine whether there are significant relationship among
independent variables and dependent variables, Person Correlation Coefficient
analysis will be conducted The scale model suggested by Davies (1971) is shown as below: 0.7 and above: very strong relationship 0.5 to 0.69: strong relationship 0.3 to 0.49: moderate relationship 0.1 to 0.29: low relationship 0.01 to 0.09: very low relationship Testing hypotheses
To test the hypotheses, the multiple regression analysis was used to find out
the impact of person organization fit, public service motivation, job satisfaction on
a
Trang 30organization citizenship behavior of DOIT 4.2 Result Cronbach’s Alpha Alpha OCB — Organizational Citizenship Behavior Reliability Statistics Cronbach's N of Items Alpha 844 5
(Table 6: Cronbach’s Alpha of Organizational Citizenship Behavior) The Cronbach’s Alpha of Organizational Citizenship Behavior is 844, it is a reliable to continue researching
Alpha POF-— Person Organization Fit Reliability Statistics Cronbach's N of Items Alpha .838 5
(Table 7: Cronbach’s Alpha of Person Organization Fit)
The Cronbach’s Alpha of Person Organization Fit 838, it is a reliable to continue researching Alpha PSM — Public Serice Motivation Reliability Statistics Cronbach's N of Items Alpha 864 5
(Table 8: Cronbach's Alpha of Public Serice Motivation)
The Cronbach’s Alpha of Public Serice Motivation is 864, it is a reliable to continue researching
rr
Trang 31Alpha JS — Job Satisfaction Reliability Statistics Cronbach's N of Items Alpha 874 6
(Table 9: Cronbach’s Alpha of Job Satisfaction)
The Cronbach’s Alpha of Job Satisfaction is 874, it is a reliable to continue researching Reliability Statistics Cronbach’s | No of Variable Consider Alpha items
Organizational Citizenship Behavior | OCB 844 5 Good Person Organization Fit POF 838 5 Good Public Service Motivation PSM 874 5 Good Job Satisfaction JS 864 6 Good (Table 10: Reliability Statistics) Statistics information Descriptive statistics
Trang 32Correlation statistics
The correlation coefficient was computed for determining relationship between independent variable (Person Organization Fit, Public Service Motivation, Job Satisfaction) with dependent variable (Organizational Citizenship Behavior) sustainability The scale model suggested by Davies (1971), are as shown below: 0.7 And above — very strong relationship 0.5 to 0.69 — strong relationships 0.3 to 0.49 — moderate relationship To 0.29 — low relationship To 0.09 — very low relationship Correlations OCB POF PSM JS OCB Pearson Correlation 1 583" 616 665" Sig (2-tailed) ,000 ,000 ,000 N 170 170 170 170 POF Pearson Correlation 583 1 557" 618" Sig (2-tailed) ,000 ,000 ,000 N 170 170 170 170 PSM_ Pearson Correlation 616” 557” 1 ,739” Sig (2-tailed) ,000 ,000 ,000 N 170 170 170 170 JS — Pearson Correlation 665 ”|_ ,618” 739” 1 Sig (2-tailed) ,000 ,000 ,000 N 170 170 170 170
** Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed) (Table 12: Correlations statistics)
4.3 Hypotheses testing
We have the relationship of five (05) hypotheses have positive relationships with the dependent hypothesis Overall Job Satisfaction According the theory of hypotheses which are supported, they have to meet all three (03) requirements
below:
a
Trang 33R square is value: greater than 0
Unstandardized coefficients beta: the same sign with hypothesis P value (Sig) is value: less than 0.05
H1: Person organization fit (P-O Fit) will have positive association with Organizational citizenship behavior (OCB)
H2: Person organization fit will have an indirect impact on Organizational citizenship behavior through Public service motivation
H3: Person organization fit will have an indirect impact on Organizational citizenship behavior through Job satisfaction Model Summary” Adjusted R Durbin- Model R R Square Square Std Error of the Estimate | Watson 1 ,71%° 11 „302 ,48152 2,215 a Predictors: (Constant), JS, POF, PSM
b Dependent Variable: OCB
(Table 13: Model sumary of H1, H2, H3) Coefficients” Unstandardized Standardized Coefficients Coefficients Model B Std Error Beta t Sig 1 (Constant) „686 ,234 2,929 ,004 POF „256 ,074 242 3,447 ,001 PSM 5232 ,086 221 2,697 ,008 JS 360 ,089 352 4,057 ,000 a Dependent Variable: OCB (Table 14: Coefficients of H1, H2, H3) R square is 511: greater than 0
Unstandardized coefficients beta is 256; 232; 360: the same sign with hypothesis
P value (Sig) is 004; 001; 008; 000: less than 0.05 We can assess that the hypothesis H1, H2, H3 is supported
Trang 34Model Summary
Mode R Adjusted R | Std Error of l R Square Square _| the Estimate 1 557° 310 306 54340 a Predictors: (Constant), POF
(Table 15: Model sumary of H4) Coefficients* Standardize Unstandardized d Coefficients Coefficients Model B Std Error Beta t Sig 1 (Constan) 1,649 5228 7,226 ,000 POF 562 ,065 557| 8,685 ,000 a Dependent Variable: PSM (Table 16: Coefficients of H4) R square is 310: greater than 0
Unstandardized coefficients beta is 562: different sign with hypothesis P value (Sig) is 000: less than 0.05
We can assess that the hypothesis H4 is supported
HS: Person organization fit will have a positive association with Job satisfaction (JS) Model Summary
Mode R Adjusted R | Std Error of
1 R Square Square _| the Estimate
l 618° ,382 ,378 52624
a Predictors: (Constant), POF
Trang 35R square is 382: greater than 0
Unstandardized coefficients beta is 638: the same sign with hypothesis P value (Sig) is 000: less than 0.05
We can assess that the hypothesis H5 is supported
Trang 365 CONCLUSION 5.1 Discussion:
This study aims to analyze the influence of factors on organizational citizenship behavior The results show that person organization fit, public service motivation and job satisfaction is found to have positive impacts on OCB
Based on the result of this research, DOIT should improve the motivation of
their employees in providing public services to strengthen their role as state
employees and civil servants
DOIT should create and maintain employees’ job satisfaction at an optimum level so the employees can perform extra role behaviors in conducting their jobs 5.2 Limitation and recomendation for future research:
This resarch have several limitations The most important one of is that only
responses to the questionaire were collected since the conditions in the field did not
allow for depth interviews with the respondents Time for research is too short that I just conduct only 170 questionnaires The unqualified responses cannot use for
future research
Because the object of this study is a particular organization in a specific setting, we suggest the necessity to replicate the study in other settings to gain more generalizable results Additionally, all data is derived from questionnaires, which may be biased if individuals rate themselves high Therefore, it appears worthy to make in depth interviews with respondents to get more information
The research just discuss about factors that have positive effects to organizational citizenship behavior Future research should examine more factors that affect to organizational commitment positively and negatively to help the DOIT have an overall sight
aa a
Trang 37References
Alderfer, C (1969) ‘An empirical test of a new theory of human needs’,
Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, Vol 4, No 2, pp.142-175
Anderfuhren-Biget, S (2012) ‘Profiles of public service motivated civil servants:
evidence from a multicultural country’, International Journal of Public
Administration, Vol 35, No 1, pp.5-18
Anderfuhren-Biget, S., Varone, F and Giauque, D (2013) ‘Policy environment and public service motivation’, Public Administration [online] http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/padm.12026 (accessed 13 October 2014)
Baron, R and Kenny, D (1986) ‘The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol 51, No 6, pp.1173-1182
Bretz, R.D and Judge, T.A (1994) ‘Person-organization fit and the theory of work
adjustment: implications for satisfaction, tenure, and career success’, Journal of Vocational Behavior, Vol 44, No 1, pp.32—54
Brewer, G.A and Walker, R.M (2010) ‘Explaining variation in perceptions of red
tape: a professionalism-marketization model’, Public Administration, Vol 88,
No 2, pp.418-438
Bright, L (2005) ‘Public employees with high levels of public service motivation Who are they, where are they, and what do they want?’, Review of Public
Personnel Administration, Vol 25, No 2, pp.138-154
nn
Trang 38Bright, L (2007) ‘Does person-organization fit mediate the relationship between public service motivation and the job performance of public employees?’, Review of Public Personnel Administration, Vol 27, No 4, pp.361-379,
doi:10.1177/0734371X07307149
Bright, L (2008) ‘Does public service motivation really make a difference on the
job satisfaction and turnover intentions of public employees?’, The American
Review of Public Administration, Vol 38, No 2, pp.149-166
Bright, L (2009) ‘Why do public employees desire intrinsic nonmonetary opportunities?’, Public Personnel Management, Vol 38, No 3, pp.15—37
Cable, D.M and DeRue, D.S (2002) ‘The convergent and discriminant validity of subjective fit perceptions’, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol 87, No 5,
pp.875-884
Camilleri, E (2007) ‘Antecedents affecting public service motivation’, Personnel Review, Vol 36, No 3, pp.356—377
Christensen, R.K and Wright, B.E (2011) ‘The effects of public service motivation on job choice decisions: disentangling the contributions of person-organization fit and person-job fit’,
Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, Vol 21, No 4, pp.723—
743, doi:10.1093/jopart/muq085
Coursey, D.H and Pandey, S.K (2007) ‘Content domain, measurement, and validity of the red tape concept: a second-order confirmatory factor analysis’, The American Review of Public Administration, Vol 37 No 3, pp.342-361
a
Trang 39Daley, D.M and Vasu, M.L (2005) ‘Supervisory perceptions of the impact of public sector personnel practices on the achievement of multiple goals Putting the strategic into human resource management’, American Review of Public Administration, Vol 35, No 2, pp.157-167
Deci, E.L and Ryan, R.M (1985) Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in
Human Behavior, Plenum Press, New York
Judge, T A., C J Thoresen, J E Bono, and G K Patton 2001b The job
satisfaction-job per-formance relationship: A qualitative and quantitative review Psychological Bulletin 127 (3): 376-407
Koys, D J 2001 The effects of employee satisfaction, organizational citizenship
behavior, and turnover on organizational effectiveness: A unit-level,
longitudinal study Personnel Psychology 54 (1): 101-14
Kreitner, R., and A Kinicki 2001 Organizational behavior 5th ed Boston, MA:
McGraw-Hill.260 Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory
Larson, E W., and C V Fukami 1984 Relationships between worker behavior and commitment to the organization and union Academy of Management Proceedings 34:222—26
Liou, K., and R C Nyhan 1994 Dimensions of organizational commitment in the
public sector: An empirical assessment Public Administration Quarterly 18:99-
118
ee
Trang 40Locke, E A 1976 The nature and cause of job satisfaction In Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology, ed M D Dunnette, 1297~1343 Chicago: Rand McNally
Van Dyne, L., Kamdar, D., & Joireman, J (2008) In-role perceptions buffer the negative impact of low LMX on helping and enhance the positive impact of high LMxX on voice Journal of Applied Psychology, 93(6), 1195-1207
Walumbwa, F O., Hartnell, C A., & Oke, A (2010) Servant leadership,
procedural justice cli-mate, service climate, employee attitudes, and organizational citizenship behavior: A cross-level investigation Journal of Applied Psychology, 95(3), 517-529
Wang, H., Law, K S., Hackett, R D., Wang, D., & Chen, Z X (2005) Leader-
member exchange as a mediator of the relationship between transformational
leadership and followers’ performance and organizational citizenship behavior Academy of Management Journal, 48 (3), 420-432
Williams, L J & Anderson, S E (1991) Job satisfaction and organizational commitment as predictors of organizational citizenship and in-role behaviors Journal of Management, 17(3), 601-617
Yukl, G., Mahsud, R., Hassan, S., & Prussia, G E (2013) An improved measure of
ethical lead-ership Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 20(1), 38— 48
a