Some solutions for further attracting foreign direct investments in binh dinh province in the coming time

I UPPSALA t'NIVERSlTV OF ECONOMICS dfe 8USINFSS W i : iUNfVKRSITET ' " ' '^ MASTER THESIS OF MPPM Some solutions for further attracting Foreign Direct Investments in Binh Dinh province in the coming time Auilwrs: - Nguyen Thanh Vinh ' Nguyen Thi Lun Anh - Do Thi Thuy Van Superviors: - Lars Torsten Eriksson^ MSc, PhD - Nguyen Tien Dung« PhD Class: MPPM Intake 2, group 14 Hanoi, September 2011 UPPSALA UNIVERSITET UPPSALA UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OF ECONOMICS & BUSINESS, VNU EP*^ re ã>-ô*'-* MASTER THESIS OF MPPM Some solutions for further attracting Foreign Direct Investments in Binh Dinh province in the coming time Authors: - Nguyen Thanh Vinh - Nguyen Thi Lan Anh - Do Thi Thuy Van Superviors: - Lars Torsten Eriksson, M S c , PhD - Nguyen Tien Dung, PhD Class: MPPM Intake 2, group 14 Hanoi, September 2011 THESIS SUMMARY Title of thesis: "Some Further Solutions for Attracting Foreign Direct Investments (the "FDI") in Binh Dinh Province in the coming time" Academic level: Thesis of Master Program in Public Management Author: Nguyen Thanh Vinh, Nguyen Thi Lan Anh, Do Thi Thuy Van Instructors: Vietnam supervisor: Nguyen Tien Dung, PhD Uppsala supervisor: Lars Torsten Eriksson, MSc, PhD Date of completion: August n Purpose Capital is a very important resource for development, and it is particularly needed in developing countries to tackle the cycle of poverty: low income —*• low accumulation -^ low technology —>• low productivity -^ low income, etc Hence, the fast and efficient attraction of domestic and foreign capital resources, especially the foreign direct investment has significance for the development of a country, particularly developing countries like Vietnam Binh Dinh Province is a potential area in the key economic zone in the Central Part of Vietnam Seeing the importance of the FDI for the development, Binh Dinh has actively attracted the FDI by various measures but the results of attraction are too modest compared to its potentiality; therefore, it is required to find solutions to overcome through research of the situation of FDI attraction and causes of achievements and limitations in attracting the FDI in Binh Dinh Method - Using the model of Nguyen Manh Toan in respect of factors affecting the FDI attraction as a theoretical basis for assessing causes of success and limitations in attracting the FDI in Binh Dinh - Using the method of analysis-synthesis, the method of qualitative and quantitative analysis to analyze and evaluate collected statistics, reports and other data - Using the method of interview of some related objects for gathering more data Results and conclusions Through the thesis analysis we come to a conclusion that the FDI that has increased rapidh in Binh Dinh in recent years compared to previous periods is mainly because of: - Having a favorable geographic location - Having a synchronous infrastructure system - Having advantages of setting up the Nhon Hoi Economic Zone, industrial zones and 37 industrial groups - Having plentiful resources and potentiality - Quite strong development of the provincial economy in recent years with the GDP growth on average of 12% - Issuing many policies with investment incentives, rendering administrative reforms actively; simultaneously paying more attention to investment promotion activities Political security and social order is stable - Enjoying benefits from the results of expanding foreign relations between Vietnam and other countries around the world, as well as increasing improvement of the law system, mechanisms, general policies of Vietnam with respect to encouraging direct foreign investments However, the amount of attracted capital is little, not corresponding with the potentiality of Binh Dinh and not contributing much to the development of the area because of: * Objective reasons - The impact of the global financial crisis and economic slowdown Limited capacity of some investors - The strong competition of some localities with comparative advantages better than those of Binh Dinh * Subjective reasons - Binh Dinh is not really ready for planning and sites for investors - The infrastructure of Binh Dinh is not really convenient to attract investments - Administrative procedures in several areas relating to in\eslment remain cumbersome, troublesome, causing delays and congestions - The location declaration is not clear - The investment promotion is inefficient - The analysis results of the thesis as stated above show why Binh Dinh is a province with potential in attracting the FDI but the attraction results are modest Those are the basis for seeking solutions to o\ercome this situation According to us the two factors namely the unclear location declaration statement and inefficient investment promotion are the two causes of most powerful impacts which need deeper research Recommendations for future study The most fundamental limitation of the thesis is only focusing on the assessment of the FDI in Binh Dinh hardly considering impacts of this capital resource on the economy and society of Binh Dinh, especially negative ones This can affect the firmness of the subject significantly because although the FDI is essential for the development, it is not because of which the attraction is made at all costs regardless of its negative impacts The FDI attraction also requires a selection and prudent strategies to both attract this capital resource quickly and limit its negative impacts 10 Contribution of the thesis - The thesis adds two factors of clear positioning messages and effective investment promotion to improve the theoretical model of Nguyen Manh Toan in respect of factors affecting the FDI In our opinion, in a current globalization age with increasingly fierce competition, these two factors are important in fast FDI attraction of a region, a nation - The thesis has raised some measures to promote the FDI attraction as a basis for policy-makers in Binh Dinh to refer in the course of making their decisions TABLE OF CONTENT L Introduction 1.1 Aim of study 1.2 Method of study ^ 1.3 Scope and demacrations o Theory 2.L Some basic concepts o o 2.1.1 The concept of Investment 2.1.2 The concept of foreign investment 10 2.1.3 The concept of foreign direct investment ]0 2.2 The role of foreign direct investment capital to Vietnam's economy 11 2.3 Main factors help attracting foreign investment 13 2.3.1 Economic motivation group 13 2.3.2 Resources motivation Group 14 2.3.3 Infrastructure motivation Group 15 2.3.4 Mechanisms and policies motivation Group 16 Analysis 17 3.1 Overview of Binh Dinh 17 3.2 Reality in attracting foreign direct investment of Binh Dinh in the period 2006 - 2010 17 3.2.1 The number and scale of projects 17 3.2.2 Investment Structure 18 3.2.3 Investment Partners 19 3.2.4 Form of Investment 20 3.2.5 Overall Assessment 21 3.3 The cause of the achievements and limitations in attracting FDI in Binh Dinh in the past time 24 3.3.1 I he cause of the achievements 24 3.3.2 The cause of the limitation 26 3.4 Some recommendations on resolutions to boost attracting FDI in Binh Dinh in the coming time Conclusion 36 References 39 Introduction For any nation to have rapid economic growth and development, that nation must have various resources such as labour, natural resources, land, science, technology, capital In these resources, capiuil is a quite important resource for developmem, and it is particularly needed in developing countries to tackle the vicious cycle of poverty: low income — low accumulation -^ low technological level -> low productivity -^ low income ' Therefore attracting both domestic and foreign investments, especially foreign direct investments (FDI) quickly and effectively is important for national development, especially for developing countries This can be seen in the achievements of Vietnam's socio-economic development since its renovation started in 1986: those achievements were significantly contributed by FDI and the foreign-invested economic sector In fact, FDI has become an important source of capital for investment and development that promotes the shift of economic structure towards industrialization and modernization; introduction of many new industries and products; improved management capacity and technology; more employment: expansion of the export market; and, development of Vietnam's external economic relations with the rest of the world The highly-growing foreign-invested economic sector has become part of the economy, has increasingly closer tics with the other economic sectors, and makes increasing contribution to the Gross Domestic Product Because it is legalized and encouraged to develop by the state, the Party and the State's guideline states that ^Uo facilitate the foreign-invested economic sector in its development, exportorientation, construction of socio-economic infrastructure, attraction of modern technology, and more employment The legal and economic environments should be improved to attract foreign investments strongly"" Realising the importance of FDI to its development in the context that its internal capital accumulation remains limited, Binh Dinh, a province in the economic focal area in Central Vietnam (which includes the provinces of Da Nang, Hue, Quang Nam, Quang Ngai, Binh Dinh), has been very actively attracting and using FDI in many ways However, FDI attracted by Binh Dinh over the recent years remains fairly modest, mainly in the form of small projects, which are inadequate to its potentials As a result, the positive sides of FDI have not been seen clearly, and their contribution to the provincial socio-economic development is less than expected This situation attracts much attention from researchers, the provincial leaders and its people, who all wonder why the province, with its potentials, can not attract as much FDI as expected Therefore, how to provide effective solutions to further attract FDI has become an urucnt issue in Binh Dinh especially in the context ot ' David licgg, 1992, p 403-404 ' Vietnam C'ommunisl Party 2001, p 99 increasingly serious competition for FDI in the country, the region and the world and while the demands for investments in socio-economic development still largely depends on external sources Based on this practice, we choose the thesis theme, ''Some Solutions for Further Attracting Foreign Direct Investments in Binh Dinh Province in the Coming Time", to study and propose effective solutions for further attracting FDI in Binh Dinh for its socio-economic development in the coming years The thesis comprises three main parts Part I shall mention theories on FDI as the fundamental knowledge and discuss the role of FDI in national development Based on the data collected through an analysis of the reality of FDI attraction in Binh Dinh (reports, statistics, inteniew^s, etc), Part II will figure out the causes and limitations of the activity In the final part of the thesis, we shall propose feasible solutions for further FDI attraction in Binh Dinh, based on the analysis and evaluation of the achievements and limitations of its FDI attraction we have conducted in Part II 1.1 Aim of study This thesis is aimed to find out feasible solutions for further FDI attraction for Binh Dinh Province, based on an analysis of the achievements and limitations of the province's recent FDI attraction (since 2006) and the causes of those achievements and limitations The thesis is also aimed to emphasize the role and position of FDI attraction for the development of a region or a nation It shall not develop more theories on FDI but further confirm the need to attract FDI for development; and, it will provide some basis for the policy-makers and governments in Binh Dinh to make feasible policies for quickly attracting this important source of capital As a result, the main aim of this thesis is to answer the question, What solutions should be carried out lo further FDI attraction in Binh Dinh Province? It will not be easy to answer this question if there is no basis Therefore, the thesis will answer the question through raising and answering two other equally important questions: - What is the reality (achievements and limitations) of FDI attraction by Binh Dinh over the recent years? - What are the causes of the achievements and limitations of FDI attraction by Binh Dinh? The two questions are perhaps the most central in the discussion of FDI attraction in Binh Dinh and to answer the main question mentioned above The validity of the thesis is largely dependent on answering the two questions because the two answers will be found through the FDI reports and statistics prepared by the authorities and frequently imprecise, comments of some experts It is important that the information is analysed and evaluated to serve as an objective basis for providing feasible solutions that help readers see an overall picture of the FDI attraction in Binh Dinh and that can be applied to further the FDI attraction in Binh Dinh in the coming time 1.2 Method of study To answer questions raised in this thesis, a variety of documents were used For the theory, in order to discuss and provide basic knowledge to help readers comprehensively understand about foreign direct investment and its importance in developing countries, a number of textbooks and books are used to clarify such as ^^Vietnam external economic curriculum'" of Nguyen Anh Tuan, "Vietnam external economic curriculum" of Nguyen Van Trinh, "Foreign Direct Investment in Vietnam current situation and solutions" of Tran Xuan Tung And then, the book named "Factors affecting the attraction of FDI into a locality" of Nguyen Manh Toan will help provide a theoretical model as a basis for evaluating the reasons of achievements and limitation in attracting FDI in Binh Dinh Relating to analyzing of FDI in Binh Dinh, data, reports collected by Binh Dinh Department of Planning and Investment, PMU of Economic Zone, Center for Investment Promotion and the book named "Binh Dinh lO-year socio-economic development" of Binh Dinh Statistical Office are especially the key sources Finally, the articles such as "Approach to Marketing in FDI attraction" by Mai The Cuong and interviews conducted with a number of FDI entrepreneurs, officials working in this field in Binh Dinh is a tool help us evaluate the reasons for achievements and limitations in attracting FDI in Binh Dinh and give out solutions The most important question of the thesis is what are the causes of the achievements and limitations of attracting FDI in Binh Dinh? To answer this question, we used theoretical model of Nguyen Manh Toan and research of Tran Xuan Tung It means we highly consider factors that Nguyen Manh Toan and Tran Xuan fung mentioned in their theory as crucial factors and concentratively use them to answer the causes of achievements and limitations of a nation or a region However, preliminary analysis of the thesis shows that there are still other very important factors besides the factors mentioned above Therefore, we will add the latter to partly complete this model To find out solutions to strengthen FDI attraction by Binh Dinh First, sufficient information on IDI such as the total attracted FDI amount and number of projects, the capital structure, the investment partners, the provincial policy, etc should be collected to analyse and evaluate the FDI development realitv in the province We have selected the information through the statistics and reports ot the provincial authorities such as the Department of Statistics, Department of Planning and Investment, Centre for Investment Promotion, PMU of Economic Zones The collected infonnation is generally fairly reliable and refiects the IT)I reality in Binh Dinh In the next step to figure out the answer to the thesis question, we shall analyse and evaluate the causes of the recent achievements and limitations of FDI attraction through the evaluation reports of the provincial investment promofion authorities, articles collected from the investment webpage and the Department of Planning and Investment webpage of the province The data collected in this step is less reliable because they are based on subjective judgments of the authors The data of this kind have not been much collected perhaps because there are certain difficukies in accessing information (e.g getting access to evaluation reports of the authorities in Binh Dinh) To overcome this, we plan to conduct some interviews of some provincial leaders, investment promotion agencies and FDI businesses of the province In our opinion, the interviews will be very important for collecting data and answering the thesis question; they will provide the most authentic picture of FDI attraction in Binh Dinh, and they will be a useful information channel for figuring out the causes of the recent FDI situation in the province Moreover, consulting the intended interviewees of possible solutions for further FDI attraction in the province will lay the foundation for the final solutions that we will provide in this thesis To carry out the study, we shall analyse, summarize, with a fiexible combination of quantitative and qualitative analysis to answer the question The collected data shall be thoroughly analysed and then summarized to find out the answer Through quantitative analysis, we shall find out the answer through the figures of FDI gained by Binh Dinh such as the number of projects, the total amount, the IDI structure, etc and how they contribute to the provincial socio-economic development Qualitative analysis shall be very useful in evaluating collected reports and personal views on i 1)1 attraction in the province When starting analyzing the thesis contents and collecting data, we considered using some other methods, one of which is survey through questionnaires, which can help collect reliable and objective data However, we believed that conducting such a kind of survey requires certain knowledge of developing a questionnaire that we are short of Moreover, every step from developing the questionnaire, identifying the objects, means; material, human and time resources takes so much time and effort that they may slow dowTi the progress of the thesis while the results may be low due to some reasons mentioned above As a result, we replaced it with direct inter\ievvs of some stakeholders, which is less objective and restricted in number of interviewees due to the time limit of the thesis but easier to implement Moreover, interviewing those directlv m charge of FDI attraction and investors will help go straight to the question of the thesis bao chi nude, qua eae cudc tilp khach, hdi nghi, hdi thao ddu tu, qua xudt ban dn pham, bang dTa va gui tai lieu quang ba d nude ngoai, nhung hinh anh ddu tu eua Binh Dinh cdn chua rd rang, chua cd du lugng thdng tin ma ddi tac cdn cd Viec tuyan truyln cdn nang vl "td hdng" va gidi thieu nhirng uu dilm, chua phan tich ranh mach dugc limg Igi tha so sanh, ddng thdi cung chua nau dugc nhirng bdt Igi, nhimg thach thirc ddi vdi cac nha ddu tu nude ngoai vao lam an tai linh" Ldy vi du diln hinh mot cdng viec tdn nhiau cdng sire, thdi gian ciia bg phan van ddng ddu tu la cap nhat danh muc du an khuyin khich ddu tu Thdng tin dugc thiat kl tuang ddi dep mdt bang tiing Viet, tiing Anh tran td rai va dTa CD de cung cap cho cac nha dau tu nuoc ngoai tidm nang, nhung thuc chdt no khong hicu qua vi danh muc chi dua tren mong mu6n cua nguai lam chinh sach chu chua dugc xay dung tren ca sa dap ung nhu cau thong tin cua nha dku tu Mot vi du khac la tai cac cugc hoi thao, hoi ngbj xiic tien dau tu a nuac va nuac ngoai, thidu thong tin v^ nha dku tu, Binh Djnh thuang co xu huang trinh bay nhieu thong tin khong hiju ich va cung ckp it cac thong tin thuc su co ich cho nha dau lu Chang ban mot bai trinh bay keu goi dku tu dien hinh thuang bao gom cac so lieu ve kinh te, cac thong ke ve FDI, ODA, thuang mai du lich; cac thong tin ve hinh thuc dau tu, so lugng du an dau tu so lugng vice lam tao tu cac du an dau tu giija Binh Dinh va cac quoc gia dang ghe tham; Cac thong tin cung can thiet cho nha dau tu theo each hay each khac song cac nha dau tu can cac thong tin dac thii ban nhu hg co th^ bat dku cong vice kinh doanh nhu the nao, khuyen khich cu the nao ho se nhan dugc, chinh quy^n se giiip da hg nhu the nao de giai quyet cac kho khan phat sinh Igi tha so sanh giira Binh Djnh va cac dja phuang khac Neu Binh Dinh chi trinh bay ve dja phuang, chinh sach va tiam nang ciia minh, dieu vua qua nhieu va cung \ ira qua it Ly cua boat dgng xiic tian dku tu a Binh Djnh thai gian qua chua dat yau cau bat nguon lu chinh luyen b6 dinh vi ciia Tinh khong dugc xac dinh ro rang; mat khac la doi ngu can bg lam cong tac xiic liCm dAu tu vua it \'ira thieu kinh nghiem; nhung quan han la kinh phi danh cho boat dgng qua it khong tha ma rgng cac chuang trinh cac ky thuat xiic tian dciu lu da quang ba rgng rai hinh anh ciia Binh Dinh dan cac d6i tac nuac ngoai '•Hgnh Nguyen, 2011 35 3.4 M9t s6 kiln nghj v^ giai phap dSy manh thu hut v6n FDI d Binh Dinh trona thoi gian den Phdn tran chiing tdi da phan tich thuc trang thu hut vdn FDI d Binh Dinh va danh gia nhirng nguyan nhan chu ylu ddn din thuc trang Phdn tilp theo tren ca sd cac nguyan nhan cdng, han chi da phan tich d tran, mdt sd giai phap theo chiing tdi la ca ban va quan trgng nhdt se dugc dl xudt nham muc dich gdp phdn cai thien nhimg tdn tai tran 3.4.1.Giai phap ve quy hoach Day nhanh tian xay dung va pha duyet cac quy hoach cdn thilu gom ca cac quy hoach tdng tha, quy hoach nganh, quy hoach xay dung, quy hoach sir dung ddt, cu ihl la Quy hoach cac khu cdng nghiep, cum cdng nghiep (bo sung), Quy hoach tuyin du lich \en biln Quy Nhan - Sdng Cau (dilu chinh), luyin du lich Dl Gi - Tam Quan (lap mdi), Quy hoach khu dd thj mdi Nhon Binh - Nhom Phii (lap mdi) ; soat dl dinh ky bd sung, dilu chinh cac quy hoach da lac hau nham tao diau kien thuan Igi cho nha ddu tu vice xac dinh va xay dung du an Quan trial va thue hian thdne nhat cac quv dinh mdi ciia Luat Dau tu ironu cdnu lac quv hoach, dam bao vice xay dung cac quy hoach nganh ITnh vuc, san pham phii hgp vdi cac cam kat qudc te Hoan chinh quy hoach sir dung dat, cdng bd rdng rai quy hoach, tao diau kien da day nhanh lian giai phdng mat bang cho cac du an dau tu 3.4.2.Giai phap ve cai thien cff so tang Tilp tue khdn truang nang cdp xay dung mdi he thdng giao thdng \ an tai ndi bd cac khu cdng nghiep he ihdng giao thdng kit ndi giua cac khu cdng nghiep vdi nhau, khu cdng nghiep vdi cac ducrng qudc Id Phat triln nhanh he thdng dien nude, thdng tin lian lac cap thoat nude, Cu thi trudc mdt Tinh cdn ddy nhanh tiln xay dung tang Khu kinh te Nhan llgi va cac khu cum cdng nghiep- ddng thdi quan tam ddu tu cac cdng trinh tang thilt ylu ca kinh tl idn xa hoi, dd la giao thdng, thuy Igi, giao due y tl va chinh trang dd thi dl lao thi sdn sang cho cac du an ddu tu chudn hi lien ich cho nha ddu ur dan dau tu va kinh doanh lai linh Ddi vdi cac cdng trinh, du an Trung ucmg quan ly nhu nang cap cang 36 biln Quy Nhon, ga hang khdng va thilt bi san bay Phu Cat tinh cdn chii ddng phdi hgp vdi cac Bd, nganh va de dat lan Chinh phu cd giai phap phii hgp Viec tao lap mot he thdng co sd tdng ddng bd va hien dai khdng phai dilu dl dang, ddi hdi phai can cd rat nhilu vdn Do dd, Binh Dinh cdn da dang hda cac ngudn vdn ddu tu, bao gdm ca ngudn vdn ngan sach, vdn vien trg ODA, vdn tu nhan va ngoai nude Md rdng cac hinh thirc thu hiit vdn tu nhan nhu BOT, BTO, lian doanh phat hanh trai philu tren thi trudng chirng khoan Xac dinh mire uu tian cho cac du an ea sd tdng theo mire dg hieu qua de tap trung dau tu, tranh lang phi, ihdt thoat vdn" 3.4.3 Giai phap ve cai each thii tue hanh chinh Tiap tue cai tien manh me thu tue hanh chinh lian quan dan cac boat dgng dku tu true tiep nuac ngoai theo huang don gian hoa ban niia cac hinh thuc va thii luc cap phep dau tu va theo nguyan tac boat dgng dau lu thugc quyan ciia cac doanh nghiep, ca quan nha nucVc co nhiem vu tao dieu kien thuan Igi cho vice thuc hien cac du an dau tu Vice tham dinh du an nan dugc cai tian theo huang ma rgng dien dang ky cap phep dau iir bo bat noi dung yau cku chu dau lu phai cung cap thong tin khong can thiat nil ngan thai gian iham dinh, lung buac chuyan tu tian kiem sang hau kiam' Thuc hien t6l viec phan eSp quan ly nha nuac gan vai viec tang cuang hgp lac, ho trg, phoi hgp d6i vai dku tu nuac ngoai, dac biet viec phc du\ ci cap Giay chirng nhan dau tu Quy djnh ro rang, cong khai cac thu tue hanh chinh tran ca sa da dan gian boa va giam bat cac Ihu luc khong ckn thiCn Tilp tue hoan thien ca cha quan ly "mot cua" viec giai quyat thii tue dku tu, d6ng thai xu ly dut diam, kip thai cac \kn da vuang mac qua trinh ckp phep, dilu chinh Gidy chirng nhan dku lu Kian quylt xir ly nghiem khac cac trucmg hgp sach nhilu cua quyln tiau cue, v6 trach nhiem cua can bg co lian quan dan boat dgng dku tu Xoa bo linh trang "phep x ua thua le lang" dang tin tai lau a nhilu cap quan lyThuc hien nghiam tue Chi thi s6 OT/CT-UBND ban hanh 25/6/2011 cua chu uch linh Binh Dinh vl mgi so giai phap chu ylu chi dao, dilu hanh thuc hien nang cao Chi s6 Nang *' Nguyen Anh Tuan, 2005, trang 261 " Nguyen Anh Tu.4n, 2005 trang 262 37 Wc canh tranh cap tinh (PCI) nam 2011" Viec thuc hien tdt cac giai phap trone Chi thi theo Chung tdi se giup cac nha ddu tu giam thilu cac chi phi ddu tu; lam cho mdi trudne ddu tu, kinh doanh ciia Binh Dinh se trd nan thdng thoang edi md, minh bach han va dav^cung se la ca sd dl cac nha ddu tu nude ngoai tin tudng ddu tu va Idi keo cac nha ddu tu khac dau tu lau dai vao Binh Dinh 3.4.4 Giai phap ve tuyen bd dinh vi Nhu da dl cap d phdn Iran, Binh Djnh hien tai chua djnh vj rd rang thu hut FDI vi vay, quylt dinh vl dinh vj cdn thuc hien cang sdm cang idt Djnh vj cdn thi hien rd dilu Binh Dinh mudn cac nha dau tu nude ngoai cd ddu nghT din viec ddu tu vao Binh Djnh Theo chimg tdi, dl viec dinh vi dugc hieu qua, Binh Dinh cdn hilu rd linh hinh ndi tai cua dja phuang cung nhu tinh hinh ban ngoai dd, chinh quyln tinh nan thuc hien phan tich SWOT (dilm manh, diam yau, co hdi, thach Ihirc) thuc trang phat triln kinh tl - xa hgi cua Tinh so vdi cac dia phuang khac dl xac djnh Igi thi so sanh cua minh ddng thdi cung can phan tich xu hudng FDI chinh sach cua cac dja phuang khac, tim hilu nhung danh gia cua nha dau tu nuac ngoai vc moi truang dau tu ciia Binh Dinh tu quyet dinh mot duang thuc le hay noi each khac la dua mot thong diep dinh vi ro rang da cai thien hinh anh dau tu ciia Binh Dinh suy nghi ciia cac nha dau lu nuac ngoai, lam cho hg nghi dan Binh Dinh la nghT dan Igi tha riang co ciia linh da quyat dinh dau tu va co the loi keo tham cac nha dau lu khac tham gia dau lu Mot ggi y ciia ong To Tu Thanh, nguyan Bi thu linh liy Binh Dinh mot bai phong \'an ma chiing toi neu lan sau da\ co the la nguin tham khao t6l cho Binh Djnh xac dinh thong diep dinh vi: "Phai thdy duac edi dac thii thS manh rieng cua Binh Dinh de cd su keu goi ddu tu dung ddi tuang cu the Theo toi ''qua ddm" dy phdi Id cdng nghiep hdu loc ddu Tue la cdng nghiep hod ddu, nhua duang, polyme sai tdng hop, hod chdt chi biin sdn phdm tic phu phdm cua hod ddu Dung Qudt Ta cd diiu kien vi ca sa Igi gdn vai khu loc ddu Dung Qudt Xac dinh truac de cd chudn hi vi nguai di tun nhd dau tu cu thi, chuyen mdn hod, cd nang luc tren llnh vuc md dat vdn di goi ddu tu trirc tiip vai ho Khdng thi goi chung chung den tin den, '' Chi thi s6 07/CT-UBND nham khac phuc nhirng han cha, tri v^ nang cao Chi s6 PCI nam 201 '/^^3j;"^^*"J; Djnh irjinh s^r t^il h^u so v6i c^c tinh vung va anh hucmg khong tot den moi imcmg dau tu kmh doanh cua tmh theo ngi dung chi s6 th^nh phan ciia PCI Xem c^c giai phap chi tiet tai Chi th) 38 vay thi khd Idm, vi ta khdng cd tru thi nhu Binh Duang Ddng Nai TP HCM Bd Ria Vun^ Tdu /''\ ^ Co thi khang dinh xac dinh mot thong diep dinh vj dii vai Binh Djnh khong phai la viec dl dang Ben canh viec xac djnh diing thi djnh vi phai phii hgp "dinh vi phu hgp" co y nghla quan trgng ban la ^djnh vj cao" Thilt lap cac muc tiau qua tham vong se lam giam tinh kha thi thuc hien va tinh tin cay mSt cac nha dSu tu tim nang 3.4.5 Giai phap ve xuc tien dau tu* Nang cao chat lugng cong lac xiic tiln dku tu c6 y nghTa quan trgng dky manh thu hut FDI a Binh Djnh De cai thien cong tac xiic tiln dku tu, Binh Djnh ckn tap trung vao cac van dl sau: * Xay dimg chien lirac xuc tiin dau tie co diem Da cong tac xuc tian dau tu c6 hieu qua, Binh Djnh ckn c6 chiln luge tap trung ban, xiic tian vao viec thu hiil mot dong FDI nhat dinh da xac dinh truac han la dong FDI noi chung Su can thiat eiia chian luge lap trung la bai: xiic lian dau tu co trgng diem c6 the giiip Binh Djnh dat dugc nhung muc tieu chian luge lian quan tai nhung khia canh nhu nhan sir, chuyan giao cong nghe , xuat khau va cac ITnh vuc khac chian luge phat trian chung Han nija, no giiip nang cao hieu qua chi phi, cac boat dgng lao dung hinh anh chung va van dong dku lu chung chung se khong dem lai hicu qua tru chiing dugc thuc hien vai mot chian luge xac dinh nham thu hiit mot dong FDI cu tha Mot chiln luge xiic tiln dciu lu trgng dilm bao gim \iac xac dinh nganh nao se la nganh mui nhgn Irong ngfm ban va trung ban? c^n tap trung chinh vao khu vuc dia ly nao? nhung hinh thuc xiic tiln nao co thi dugc lira chgn dl Ihu hut cac cong ly? Do do, vice xay dung chiln luge xiic tiln ddu tu trgng dilm cua Binh Djnh cdn co sir trg giiip cua thong diep dinh vj Dilu CO nghTa la Iran ca so tuyan bd dinh vi da dugc xac djnh truac, chian luge xuc tiln ciia Tinh sc co can cu xac djnh nhung nganh nghi nao dia ban nao, quoc gia nao, cong ty nao cdn tap trung \'dn dgng ddu lu * Ciii thien ky thuat xuc tiin ddu tu tren ca sa sir dung ddng bg cac dang ky thuat vd xay dung chifong trinh hanh dgng cu the "* Hoang Lan 2006 39 Nhu da dl cap a p h k tren, cac ky thuat xuc tiln ddu tu cua Binh Dinh da sir dung vlu va chua ding bg Chinh vi vay, ben canh sii dung ddy du va ding bg ba dang ky^huat xiic tiln ddu tu^^; phai su dung thudn thue, chuyan nghiep cac ky thuat nay, dac b^et la ky thuat xay dung hinh anh Mat khac, cung cdn phai xay dung dugc cac chuang trinh hanh dong xuc tiln ddu tu Cac noi dung cua chuang trinh cdn ro rang, cu the chu dgng va chi tilt tu viec xay dung din thuc thi kl hoach Mot chuang trinh hanh dong phai chi ro cac nhiem vu cdn thuc hien, la nguai chiu trach nhiem cho tirng cong viec Mot kl hoach thuc tl la mot kl hoach CO tha thuc thi chu khong phai mot kl hoach chi dl vilt va cdt vao tu dung hi sa Noi dung ciia chuang trinh hanh dgng c6 thi dugc trinh bay nhu bang sau: Bang 6: Noi dung cua chuang trinh hanh dgng xiic tiln ddu tu Phan 1: Muc tieu thu hut dau tu* Mong muon ve hinh anh dau tu Muc tieu dinh tinh Mong muon ve moi quan h^ giira doanh nghigp hai nuac So lugng doanh nghiC'p thu hut; So lugng von dau tu thu hiit; So Myc tieu djnh lirgng lugng doanh nghiep hai nuac tiep xiic vai Phan Cac bien phap thuc hien ke hoach Nhom cac bien phap xay Cac bien phap tu den tai trang 34: dung hinh anh ve moi truang Ngan sach phan bo ca quan thuc hien ca quan phoi liap thai dau tu Nhom cac bien phap tao nguon dau tu gian thuc hien, mau danh gia kcl qua thuc hi^^n Cac bien phap tir den tai trang 34: Ngan sach phan bo, ca quan thuc hien ca quan phoi hgp, thai gian tlurc hien, mau danh gia ket qua Cac bi^n phap tu 10 den 12 tai trang 34: Nhom cac bien pliap dich v^i dau tu Dac biet chii trpng cac nha dAu tu da co mat tai Binh Dinh: toa dam chinh sach, trao doi thong tin hai chieu giua cac nha quan ly va doanh nghiep X Phan Phoi hop va hyp tac Cac ca quan thuang irii nuac ngoai Cac ca quan Vict Nam tai nuac n)^oai 67 len ca quan chirc nang, trucrng dai dien nguai true tiep lam vifc vai pho, phii hgp hien tai, de xuat phoi hgp Ten ca quan, chirc nang tnrong dai di^Mi, nguai true tiep lam viC^c vai pho, phii hgp hign tai, de xuat phoi hgp Da neu trang 34 cua luan van 40 Phan Danh gia djnh ky viec thu-c hien ke hoach xuc tien dau tir Nhom bi^n phap: tir d^n 12 tai trang 34: Danh gia theo nhom bien phap thuc hien Tieu chi danh gia, k^t qua thuc hien, nguyen nhan cong va that bai, ti^p tue hay khong ti^p tue thuc hien, cac y^u x6 moi xuat hien, cac dieu kien va ho trg thai gian tiep theo Cac ca quan true thupc UBND tinh, ph6 va Sa Ke hoach va Dau tu; don vj ben ngoai dugc giao thuc hien mot s6 bien Danh gia theo ca quan thuc hien bien phap phap; ca quan phoi hgp ben ngoai: Tieu chi danh gia ket qua thuc hien, nguyen nhan cong va that bai, tiep tgc hay khong tiep tue hgp tac, cac yeu t6 mai xuat hi?n, hinh thuc giao viec thai gian tai, dieu kien th^c hi?n Ngudn: Mai The Cuang, 2005, trang 22-23 Mot nh&ng ly chinh can tra viec thuc hien mot chian luge xiic tiln ddu tu hicu qua la ban cha wc kinh phi va ddy dang la vdn da chung ciia hdu hat cac ca quan xiic tian dau tu a cac dia phuang khac, khong riang gi a Binh Djnh Tuy nhian nau thiau nguon tai chinh dam bao thi cong cua chuong trinh rat kho dat dugc nen van de cai tao ngan quy cho hoat dong xuc tiln dau tu can dugc chinli quyen Binh Djnh quan tam hon nijra qua trinh lap du loan su dung ngan sach hang nam tranh ihu nguon ho irg cua Trung ucmg Dong thai cac ca quan xuc tiln dau tu cung phai lu no lire han nua viec tim kiem cac nguon tai trg dl b6 sung cho ngan quy hoal dgng cua minh Ket luan Muc tieu chinh cua dl tai la tren ca sa phan tich thuc trang thu hut \ on FDI a Binh F)inh di tim mot s6 giai phap kha dung dl thu hut manh han nua ngudn vdn na> tuOTg lai Qua phan tich cac s6 lieu vl tinh hinh thu hut v6n FDI a Binh Dinh co the kit luan rang nguon v6n da tang kha nhanh nhung nam ghn day tii>- nhien sir tang chua tuang xung vai tilm nang cua Binh Dinh s6 lugng v6n thu hiit it va do chua dong gop nhilu den sir phat triln cua dja phuong Mac du vay van dl hu> dgng N a su dung co hieu qua v6n FDI kinh tl a Binh Djnh noi rieng va Vicl t6ng thi chiln luge phat triln va tang truang nhirns chiln luge trgng yeu mot Nam noi chung giai doan hien \an la mot goc nao do^ co thi noi rang viec thuc hien muc tieu tang truang nhanh lau ben ma Binh Dinh dang theo dudi phu thugc rat nhilu vao nang lire giai quylt nhiem x u noi tren 41 De phan tich, danh gia nhung nguyen nhan cong va han chi cua viec thu hut v6n FDI cr Binh Dinh, chung toi da su dung mo hinh ly thuylt ciia Nguyln Manh Toan vl cac nhan t6 anh huomg din thu hut FDI lam ca sa nghien cuu Qua danh gia nhung nguyen nhan anh huang din thuc trang thu hut v6n FDI cua Binh Dinh bang cac du lieu, cac cong cu phan tich va nhilu kenh thong tin khac cua dja phuang nay, chiing toi khang dinh rang, cac nhan tl anh huang din thu hut FDI ma Nguyln Manh Toan da dl cap anh huang rat lan din kit qua Ihu hut FDI ciia mot dia phuang, la ca sa chii ylu dl cac nha dau tu nuac ngoai lira chon dau tu Tuy nhien, chiing toi cung nhan thay ring, thai dai toan cau hoa hien canh tranh thu hiit FDI cang gay gat han, su co san cung nhu su tao dung ncn nhung nhan to la chua du de dem lai cong thu hiit manh me \on FDI ciia mgi dia phuang, mot quoc gia neu nhu dia phuang quoc gia chua xac djnh dugc thong diep djnh vj, chua co nhCrng boat dgng xiic tian ddu lu hieu qua loi keo cac nha ddu lu nuac ngoai dan voi minh Hai yau to theo danh gia ciia chiing loi cang tra nen quan trgng va khong tha thiau dugc doi vai chian luge thu bin IT^I diau kien canh tranh gay gat Tat nhian sir quan trgng ciia chimg khong the loai trir cac nhdn to ma Nguyen Manh Toan da chi ra, diau co nghTa la cac nhdn lo mo hinh ciia Nguyan Manh Toan chi that sir phat huy lac dung co su gop mai cua ca thong diep djnh vi ro rang va xiic tian ddu tu hieu qua Chinh vi vay, su bl sung hai ylu to la cdn thiat da hoan thien mo hinh ly thuyat noi Iran 42 Bieu 3: Mo hinh cua Nguyen Manh Toan co su b6 »• — • • sung Thi trucmg licm nang Kinh tc ' » Lai the ve chi phi Nguon nhan luc NhOng nhin l6 anh hu6ng den thu hut dau lu nuac ngoai • nguyen — • Tai nguyen thicn nhicn Th6ng diCp dmh VI rO rang Vi tri dia l> 1—^ • Co so tang k> thuat Co su tang w • — • Xuc licn diu tu hi^u qua Chinh sach Co sa lang xa hyi n d ! n h chinh in kinh ic ' Nhihig uu dai h6 Ug / Mot nhirng diem han che can ban nhat cua luan van la chi tap trung danh gia vice thu hilt von FDI vao Binh Dinh, hau nhu chua xcm xet nhung tac dgng cua ngudn v6n den kinh te, xa hgi cua Binh Dinh, nhal la nhung tac dgng tieu cue Dieu co thi sC anh hmrng khong nho den tinh vtrng chac ciia de tai, bai vi mac dii von FDI la rat can thiet cho phat trien nhirng khong phai vi the ma Ihu hiil bang mgi gia, bat chap nhirng tac dgng lieu cue ciia no Viec thu hiit von FDI cung can co su chgn Igc va co nhti-ng chien luge khon ngoan de vira Ihu hiit nhanh nguon von quan trgng vira han che nhirng tac dgng tieu cue cua no Khi tiln hanh phan tich nhirng nguyen nhan cong va han che cua qua trinh thu hiit FDI a Binh Djnh, dilu chiing toi tam dac nhat la thdy dugc tam quan trgng cua hai yeu to: xac dinh thong diep djnh vj va chat lugng cong tac xiic tien dau lu Chimg loi iha\ rang hai ylu to anh huang rc4t lan din lugng v6n FDI ihu bin dugc \ iec phan tich thau dao chiing se la CO sa giiip hoach dinh nhung chinh sach ihu bin IDl hieu qua Do chung loi hi \ gng se CO dip nghicMi ciru rieng vl chimg thcTi gian den Tom lai mac dii thu bin v6n FDI dai kei qua ihap Binh Dinh theo danh gia cua chung toi la mot dia phuang rSt tilm nang de ihu hiil manh ngudn vdn NIU nhu co nhung giai phap diing, kit qua ihu bin FDI ciia Binh Djnh se dugc cai thien nhilu thd, gian tdi Do do, chuno tdi ciing hi vong rang nhirng giai phap chiing tdi dl xuat luan v^.n se la mdt trone nhimg can cir giiip cac nha hoach dinh chinh sach Binh D.nh nghien cuu nhirng 43 giai phap kha dung dl thu hut nhanh vdn FDI, gdp phan dua Binh Dinh trd mdt tinh manh ca nude, xirng dang la mdt tinh ciia Viing kinh tl trgng dilm miln Truns./ 44 TAI LIEU THAM KHAO Sach - Cue thdng ke Binh Dinh 2010 Binh Djnh 10 nam phat triln kinh tl - xa hdi (2001 2010) Nha xuat ban thdng ke Ha Ndi - Dang cdng san Viet Nam 2001 Van kien Dai hdi Dang toan qudc lan thir IX Nha xuit ban Chinh tri qudc gia Ha Ndi - David Begg, et al 1992 Kinh tl hgc (tap 2) Nha xuat ban Giao due Ha Ndi - Hgc vien Chinh tri qudc gia Hd Chi Minh 2004 Kinh tl chinh tri Mac-Lenin va mdt sd van de vl td chirc, quan ly kinh tl d Vict Nam Nha xuat ban Ly luan chinh in Ha Ndi - Mai Thi Cudmg 2005 Cach tilp can Marketing thu hiil Dl Nha xual ban Giao due Ha Ndi - Nguyen Anh Tuan, et al 2005 Giao trinh kinh tl ddi ngoai Viet Nam Nha \uk ban Chinh trj qudc gia Ha Ndi - Nguyen Thj Tue Anh, et al 2006 Tac ddng ciia dau tu true tiep nude ngoai den tang trudng kinh te ciia Viet Nam Nha xual ban Chinh tri qudc gia Ha Ndi - Nguyen Van Trinh (chii bien) 2006 Kinh te ddi ngoai Viet Nam Nha xuat ban Dai hgc qudc gia, Hd Chi Minh - Phdng Thuang mai va cdng nghiep Viet Nam 2010 Chi sd nang lire canh tranh cap linh cua Viet Nam nam 2010: Thiic day dilu hanh kinh tl va dau tu bC-n \ung Nha xuat ban Lao ddng Ha Ndi - Qudc hgi nude cdng hda xa hdi chu nghia Viet Nam 2003 Luat dau tu nude ngoai tai Viet Nam Nha xuat ban Chinh trj qudc gia Ha Ndi - Qudc hgi nude cdng hda xa hdi chu nghTa Viet Nam 2006 Luat dau lu Nha xuat ban Chinh trj qudc gia Ha Ndi - -Fran Xuan Tiing 2005 Dau tu true tilp nude ngoai d Viet Nam - thuc trang vi^ giai phap Nha xuiil ban Chinh tri qudc gia Ha Ndi Cac tap chi va bao cao 45 - Nguyln Manh Toan 2010 "Cac nhan td tac ddng din viec thu hiit vdn diu tu true tilp nude ngoai vao mdt dja phuang cua Viet Nam" Tap chi Khoa hoc vd cdng nghe Dai hoc Dd Ndng 5(40): 270-280 - Nguyln Thi Kim Nha 2001 "Cac ddng lire va nhan td chu ylu tac ddng din thu hiit FDI" Tap chi hoat ddng khoa lioc 20-24 - Phan Hiru Thang 2008 'Tdng kit 20 nam Luat dau tu nude ngoai tai Viet Nam" Tap chi kinh te vd du bdo 1(417): 17-21 - Sd K I hoach va dau tu Binh Dinh 2006, 2007, 2008 2009 2010 "Sd lieu bao cao tong hgp FDI tai Binh Dinh" 3, Internet - Binh Dinh dung sau tinh, tlidnh cua viing duyen hdi mien trung PCI 2010 19/3/2011, CO san vao 02/6/2011 lai website: http://www.binhdinhinvcst.gov.vn/Tinchitict.php?idTin=970&idLoaitin=7 - cat Hiing va Thanh Hai, 2011, Tao dot phd tliu hut vdn ddu tu d Binh Dinli cd san vao 13/7/2011 tai website: http://cafef.vn/20110421081052865CA33/tao-dol-nha-trong-thu-hul-dau-tu-o-hinh-inh.chn - Hanh Nguyen, 2011 Trung tdm xiic tidn ddu tu Binh Dinh pluin ddu time hi^n tdt cdng tdc tlidng tin ddi ngoai, 26/5/2011 cd san vao 12/6/2011 tai website: http://www.binhdinhinvest.gov.vn/rinchilicl.php?idTin=1022&idLoailin=7 - Hoang Lan 2006 Xay dung ket cdu lig tdng Khu kinh ti Mian Hdi phai hien dai tlieo cong nghe tien tiin, cd san vao 3/7/2011 tai website: hllp://www.doslbinhdinh.org.vn/MagazineNew-sPage.asp':>TinTS 1D-700&TS lD-64 - Hoang Thiiy, 2010, Binh Dinh hm chon cac nhd ddu tu tiim ndng 12/01/2010, cd san vao 22/7/2011 tai website: http-//w>xvw.tinkinhie com/tai-chinh-dnu-tu tin-dau-iu-viet- nam/binb-dinh-hia-chon-cac-nhaHlaudMHmhl^^ - Hd Qudc Dung 2010 Quy Iwach vd ddu tu tdng ky- thuat cua Trung uang ddi vdi Binh Dinh - cue phdt triin phia Nam cua Viing kinh ti diim miin Trung ed san ^ao 11/7/2011 lai website: 46 - Thu hut ddu tu vao Binh Dinh nam 2010: Quyet tdm tao birdc dot phd mai, 4/01/2010 CO sin vao 13/7/2011 tai website: http://www.binhdinhinvest.gov.vn/TinSukienChitiet.php?idTin="559 - Tinh Binh Dinh mai goi hap tdc ddu tu, co sSn vao 29/4/2011 tai website: http://www.binhdinhinvest.gov.vn/Lvdodautu,php - Tdng quan kinh te - xa hoi tinh Binh Dinh, c6 sin vao 15/6/20!) tai website: http://skhdt.binhdinh,Rov,vn/content.php?id=62&pr^55 - Viet Hien, 2010, Binh Dinh cdn tiep tue ddy manh thu hut ddu tu nuac 9/11/2010, CO sEn vao 13/7/2011 tai website: http://www.baobinhdinh.com.vn/kinhte-phattrien/2010/ll/100530/ - Ly thuyet, tin tire, xa luan, an pham ciia chinh quyen Tinh khac 47 PHU L y e - cau hdi phong van Cau hoi d6i voi d6i tu-oTig la lanh dao cac co quan Nha Nude lien quan true tilp hoac gian tiep den cong tac xiic tiln dau tu - Ong (ba) hay cho bilt viec thu hut vdn FDI d Tinh Binh Dinh hien cd cAn thilt hay ko? Vi sao? - Ong (ba) hay cho mot cai nhin tong quan vg cai tinh hinh thu hut FDI a Tinh Binh Djnh nhiJng nam gan day? - Theo ong (ba), FDI co tac dong nhu thi nao (ca tich cue va tieu cue) din su kinh ii xa hoi a Tinh Binh Dinh? - Theo ong (ba) nhung tuu va nhung han chi thu hut FDI cua Tinh Binh Dmh hien la gi? Nguyen nhan cua no la dau? - La mot ngudi lam cong tac thu hut FDI cho tinh Binh Dinh ong (ba) co thi cho mot su so sanh gi&a thu hiit FDI cua tinh Binh Djnh vai mot so dja phuang khac ca nuac? (Diem manh, diem yeu ciia Binh Djnh so vai cac dia phuang khac.) - Theo ong (ba), bai hoc kinh nghiem nil qua trinh ihu hut ID! cua uiii Hinh Dinh la ui? - Theo dng (ba), Finh Binh Dinh cAn phai ihuc hien nhung giai phap gi de day manh ihu hilt vdn FDI thdi gian din? Va giai phap nao la kha ihi nhat? Doi vol ddi tuong la cac nha quan ly ciia mot so Doanh nghiep FDI o Tmh Binh Dinh - Ong (ba) hay cho bilt ly nao Doanh nghiep cua dng (ba) dau tu vao Tinh Binh Dinh'^ - Ong (ba) hay cho bilt nhimg ihiian Igi x a kho khan ciia Doanh nghiep minh dau tu vao Tinh Binh Dinh? - Nlu cd Ihl dng (ba) hay cho biet linh hinh san xuat kinh doanh cua Doanh nghiep cua ong (ba) sau dAu lu vao Binh Djnh nd cd khd khan N a thuan Igi gi'' - Ong (ba) danh g.a nhu ihc nao vc chmh sach thu hut FDI cua Tmh Binh Dmh^ So sanh no vdi mdt sd Finh ciia Viet Nam'.' - Vdi tu each la Doanh nghiep Dl a Binh Dinh theo dng (ba) Tinh Binh Dmh can pha, lam gi de ihu Iuit manh hon nua cac Doanh nghiep 1- DI x ao dau tu? 48 PHU L i i r -, Th Ji ^"^ " ^ ° ^ ^"'^ *'^"** *''""'' ""^^ ""*' ^***^ '^ " ' " "'"•' "'"'• "*'" ^"'" eo PCI 2010 Phong Thuomg mai va Cong nghiep ViCn Nam (VCCI) vira cftng bA Binh Dinh da tyt 13 bac tir thir (narr 2009) xudng thir xlp thir 20 nhung vSn cdn gift duoc nhom tot Day la thu hang thSp nhat qua ikn xlp hang, ISn d§u tien la nam 2005 Theo tieu chi danh gia, chi c6 tieu chi Dich vu h6 trg doanh nghiep va Dao tao lao dong la CO tang diem nhe, lai tieu chi ThiSt chg phap ly, Tilp can dk dai, Gia nhap thi iofomg, Tinh minh bach, Chi phi thai gian, Chi phi khong chinh thuc, Tinh nang dong va tien phong giai quyet cac van de ciia doanh nghiep ciia lanh dao tinh dilu giam dilm Bang 7: Cac tieu chi xep hang PCI ciia Binh Djnh nam 2010 so sanh vai nam 2009 theo each tinh ciia Phong thuang mai va cong nghiep Viet Nam Tinh minh bach Chi phi thdi gian Chi phi khdng chinh thirc Tinh nang dong 7,17 6,67 7,99 6,79 6,91 7.77 6,26 6,18 6,42 6,36 -0,72 -0,91 -0,49 -1,57 -0,43 Gia nhap thi trudng Tiep can Diem nam 2009 8,49 Diem nam 2010 So sanh diem nam 2010 vdi nam 2009 dat dai Dich vu Dao tao lao ddng Thilt che phap ly 4,23 5,10 5,15 5.32 5.54 5.29 4,9 -1,59 1,31 0.19 -0,25 hS trg DN Ngudn.- Phdng Tlnrang mgi vd cdng nghiep Viet Nam 2010 Xet 12 tinh phd viing duyen hai Miln Trung Binh Djnh dirng sau tinh, phd la Da Nfmg (vj thir 1, rk tdt) Quang Tri (16, tdt) Thira Thien Hui (18, tdt): cdn lai cac linh thugc nhdm Trung binh la Quang Nam (26), Phii Yen (31) Ha Tmh (37) Khanh Hoa (40), Thanh Hoa (44), Quang Binh (46), Nghe An (54) Quang Ngai (55) 49 ... Direct Investments in Binh Dinh Province in the Coming Time" , to study and propose effective solutions for further attracting FDI in Binh Dinh for its socio-economic development in the coming years... MPPM Intake 2, group 14 Hanoi, September 2011 THESIS SUMMARY Title of thesis: "Some Further Solutions for Attracting Foreign Direct Investments (the "FDI") in Binh Dinh Province in the coming time" ... & BUSINESS, VNU EP*^ re ã>-ô*'-* MASTER THESIS OF MPPM Some solutions for further attracting Foreign Direct Investments in Binh Dinh province in the coming time Authors: - Nguyen Thanh Vinh -