MOCKOBCKMkl rOCyflAPCTBEHHbll/l COHMA/lbHblM yHl/IBEPCMTET fOpn/ỊMHeCKHti MHCTMryr HAH XAY TXAHb L55ẠG (Ha npMMepe BbeTHaMa) 230002 - rio/iMTHHecKMe MHCTMTyTbi M npoueccbi A M C C E P T A ỊM > H A C O H C K A H H E y i IE H O H C T E ĩlE H M K A H A H A A T A lO P H A M H E C K M X H A Y K H A y q H b i H p y K O B O A H T E J ib M J I b H H lO Ị ị - K A H ^ H A A T lOPHAMHECKMX HAyK, I1P0ECC0PMrcy MocKBa - 1996 oniAiuim Mii C ip BíìlUlLII i I I li U ÌA ỊÌA ỉ IICTOIM I l l UCKH li n PE/ÌcTAIỈJI III 11UI () 111’AIỈOIỈOM r o c y / iA P d iỉ c 1'|U)CC0JI0ỈHMCCKHC KopiỉH n p a iio iio ri) I ocyHiipenia TeopitH pa3jiejicmiM luiacicH B ÌIPIIMCIIIIII ^ K npaiỉOMOMy ro cy^a p cin y O cnom ihic Iip iiim m ih i II cym nocTi npanonoro I I>cy>iapcTiiíầ /M A/ỈA // IKJI>>IA0K o o P M M P o iiA iiim M P A iỉo iỉo ro I OCy/AAPCTIỈA (liPHMOP UbETHAMA) ■ l lponccc UbCTiiaMC O aKTopu, luniM ioim ie na (ị)opMH|K)Híimitì II p ;n iu rr;ic rocynapcTMi II Iipaua UbCTMUMii yaiom iH n IK)3M()>KIIOCTM I locrpoei II m comIÍUIIICHI’ ICCKOIO Iip n n o iu m ) I o cyym p cT iỉii IH) lỉhC TiiiiM C U IAIIA III o t IIO m iM E ẩI AI I PAI3/1 ril I n>l C ĨTOH Ị l:JlbC TIỈA I I' I Ic I < - I c o iu i/v in c T M M iX K o r o IIPAIỈOIỈOK) ro cy/iA i*(T H A IU) m>i: I IIAM 12 3AKJIIOl i m i l l l ĩ J1II I YPA I ' / bbeaehme Hapfltìy c 0ỐH0B/16HH6M 3KOHOMHKH BbeTHaM ÕHOB/1H/1 M OỐHOBJmeT no/inT H M tìC K yio c n c ĩe M y , ro c y A a p C T B ũ n npaBO A /m yK p e ru ie H H H n pa3BHTHa ỖOJlbLUHX AOCTHXeHHÍÍ B Ae^ie SKOHOMHHeCKOI o OỖHOB/ltíHHtt BbeiHBM o c y m e c rtu m /1 n o c y m e c T B iia e T K p y n n b ie n a M e n e n n H C ĩp a n b i, HHTeHCHtìHoe íì0JiniM H e cK 0e o ố H O B iie n n e n p o n c x o A H L M n e tì c u n a j i b H O - K O H O M H H e c K O i7 i >K H H H rp e õ y iO T OT H a c 0ốH 0B JieH H R n p e A C T a B /ie n H M ÌÍ o ro c y A a p c T tìe n npaBe Po/Ib rocy,aapcTBa M npaBa B yc/i0BHMx pbiHOHHOÍi 3KOHOMHKH 0TiinH aeTCfl OT nx p o jin B yc/iO BH flx npe>KHero BbiC 0K0-ueH Tpa/in30B aH H 0í o MexaHH3Ma ruiaHMpoBaHMA KoMMyHHGTnsecKaa Hah riapTHH BbicTynaiOT 3a nocĩenenHoe rocyAapcTBa pa AU HaBCTpesy HOBUM TpeõoBaHHHM XCH3HH, BbeTHaMa n C03AaHne ỗoraTCTBa BbeTHaMCKoe rocyA ap cT B O conna;incTwHecKoro HapoAa, npouBeĩaHHH npaBOuoro CTpaHbi, CTponTejibCTBa cnpaBeAAHBoro n unBn^n3oaaHHoro oõmecTBa Crp0i4Te/ibCTB0 counanncTnsecKoi o npaeoBoro rocy,fl(apcTBa paGCMaTpnBaeTCH K3K nepaocreneHHoe C0Aep>KaHne AS/ia oỗHOBiieHHH n CTponTe/ibCTBa BbeTHaMa Ha C0BpeMGHH0M 3Tane BMecĩe c TeM BbmcHeHne TeopeTnsecKnx n npaK TnsecK nx acneK T O B T o ro Bonpoca CTa/10 H a c y iu H b iM T p e ố o B a H k ie M 0ốH0B/ieHHfl noHHMaHHH M 3amnTbi couna/iM3Ma VII Gbe3A KoMMyHncTMHecKoPi ílapTnn BbeTHaMa HaMeĩn/1 cncĩeM y HaysHO-Ana/ieKivHecKwx AeM O KpaTnn KOHLiBTiLụ/M no/ìHTHHecKí npa B O B O T O r o c y A a p c T B a CHCTeMbi, cũuna/incTHHecKOi/i B n e p e x o A H b iÊ í n e p M O A K c o L * n a jin M y rio/)HTHHecKafl nporpaMMa KoMMyHncTHecKOíí naprnn BbeTHaMa TOA^epKHBaeT: "B c a opraHH3aMHfl n AeaTe/ibHOCTb no/inTMHecKOíí CMCTeMbi HaLiieíí CTpaHbi Ha HOBOM 3Tane HanpaB/ieHbi Ha coạAaHHe n n o cĩe n e H H o e coBepiueHCTBOBaHne c0Mna/iwcTHHecK0Íí AeMOKpaTVK o õ e cn e n e h n e anacĩvi HapOAy ” 1, "CTpOKTe/ibCTBo c o M n a /ỉn c ĩn s e c K o r o ro c y A a p c T B a , ro c y A a p c T B a H apoA a, H3 H apoA a, p a A n H a poA a, n o /iH o e o c ym e cT p /ie H n e AeMOKpaTHHecKMX npaB HapoAa, C ĩp o ro e coxp a H e H H e oốLuecTBeHHOÍi A n c u n n /in H b i, ocym e cT B Jie H n e A H K Taĩypbi tì OThotueHHM K BceM ym eM /ieHHHM nH T epecoB poAHHbi n H a p o A a ” * ' / KoM M yhM CTM HecKaH riapTM H BbeTH aivta n p o rp a M M a C T p o n ĩe /ib C T B a nepexoAHbiíi riepMOA K coana/iM3My " Lilbi TxaT” , Xanoii, 1991, CTp 199 CTpaHbi li ĩe M a HacTOALueíi A n c c e p T a u n n o n p e A e /ie n a M0THB3MH, HGÕblHHOCTbtO H HOBH3HÍ HAí TaKí C T pane, K3K BbeTHaM , CB«3aHHbiMn c B03BeAeHHfl npaBOBO rocyAapcTBa B H M e to iu e íi BeKOByto r o c y A a p c ĩB e H n o c T b H npoH H bie M o p a /ìb h o - H paBcTB6H Hbi6 oÕLuecTBeHHbie TpaAH M nn, n A y m e ìí n o n y ĩn c o u n a n n c T H H e c K o ro npaBO BO M ro c y A a p e T B e pa3BMTMfl B CBoe H 3B ecm o, BpeM H MTO B 3H H K /1M n p e A C T a B /ie n n a B ẼBpone n o CBOHM H yxoAHT B n c ĩo p n t o 3anaAHO ũ K y /Ib iyp b i Ịự i9 i aB Topa HacTOHLu,ei/i KOPHHMH AnccepTaunn BaxeH Bonpoc, B KaKí Mepe õmeMnpoBbie npeACTaBiienna o n p a B O B O M r o c y A a p c T B e M o r y T ố b iT b o c y m e c i B / i e n b i B H e a n a A H b ix C Tpanax, H M e io m n x C B o e o õ p a H b ie TpaAMUHOHHbie C T p yK íypbi Boci ipnnmvian npeACTaB/ieHHH o npaBOBOM rocyAapciBe, BbeInaMCKnn Hapotì BocnpnHHMaeT n PHA HopMaTHBHbix riojiox KeH nn M B ocTO K a, HapoAO B CeBepa n M npa, K D Ha noHBe yHHBepca/ibHbix npnHLinnoB ASMOKpaTHM M npaaa OseBHAHa, XOTA n n/ioxo M3yHeHHbie HHT6rpnpyiOLHMe ộyHKUnM rocyAapcTBa n npaBa npOAB/miOTCH He TO/lbKO B paMKSX OTAe/lbHblX nO/1HTHHeCKHX CHCTeM, HO n AíCTByiOT B MHPOBOM MacLUTãe np n onpeAe/ieHnn npeAMeTa HaciRmí A n cce p u n n aBTop HCXOAHT H3 Toro oốCToaTe/ibCTBa, HTO BbeTHaM, cor/iacHO KoHCĩnTyunn CPB, flB/lfleTCfl COUHanHCTHSeCKHM rOCyAapCTBOM 3A ecb B03HHK36T Bonpoc o COBM6CTHMOCTH n p a e o B o ro ro c y A a p c T B a n c o i4 n a /in M a B coBeTCKOíí /inTepaĩype nepnoAa nepecTpoPíKn Bonpoc 3TOT Craan/ICA HÊOAHOKpaTHO Ha Hero 6bm AâH B ueiiOM yTBepAHTe/ibHbiíí OTBeT no npoố/ieMe npaBoeoro rocyAapcTBa K3K B ncTopnsecKOM acneKTe, T3K M B coBpSM SHHbix yc/iOBHHx B M n p e cym ecT B yeT oốL iin p H a n /ìm e p a T y p a B cooTBeTCTByiOLUHX paốcrrax paccMaĩpnBaioTCH cymHOCTb, npn3HaKn, npnH unribi n OGHOBHbie HanpaB/ieHHA CTpoMTe/ibCTBa npa B ũB oro rocyA ap cT B a OĩAeiibHbie 3jieMeHTbi npaBOBoro rocyA apcrea paccM aĩpnBa/incb B TpyAax Be/IHKHX Mbic/inTeneíí 3HTHMHOCTH, cpeAHeeeKOBbix n HQBoro BpsMeHM Bo Bbem aM e HeKOTOpbie Bonpocbi ciponre/ibC TBa npaBOBoro rocyAapcTBa nocranenbi tì Tpy^ax T3KHX aBiopoB, K3K Mbiotó, fla o Hu Yk, HryeH KyH, Hryen Ban Txao, OaM HroK Kyanr, XoaHr Ban Xao, Ao HryeH ObiOHr, 4an HroK /Ịb iũ H r n AP- B 1993r BbGTHaMCKMíí acnnpaHT Hryen BaH HneH ycneniHO 3am nĩn^ KaHAHAaTCKyK) A n c c e p T a u m o no n p a e y Ha reM y "B b e iH a M B n o n cK a x nyTeM ộ o p M n p o B a n n q rpa>KAaHCKoro oỗuuecTBa n npaBO Boro ro cyA a p cT B a ” M 3TO 6bm nep B bin BO BbeTHaMe eAHHCTBeHHbiPi TpyA, ncc/ieAOBBBLUniTi cp3BHHTSJibH0 cncieMaTHHecKn Boripoc CTponTe/ibCTBa npaBũBoro rocyAapcTBa B b eiH aM a Co BpeM6Hn VII cte3A a KoMMyHncTmecKoPí napTnn BbeTHaMa B riapTHìÍHbix A O K yM em ax, B )KypHa/ia, e T a x n KH nrax K a c a /in c b B o n p o c a C T pom e/ibC T B a n p a e o B o ro BbeTHHMa MacTO ro c y A a p c T B a B o n p o c CTponTe/ibCTBa npaBO Boro rocyA ap cT B a npeACTaB-riHeT COÕOI/I B o n p o c K3K ỗbi npnBbiHHbiíí n BMecTe c T0M BecbM a HOBbii/í n no HeMy cymecTByiOT MHorne pa3Hbie MH6HH8 B yc/iOBMflx KorAa Ae/10 ũÕHOB/ieHnq BO BbeTHaMe HaxGAHTCH Ha Hana/ibHOM 3Tane n CTpaHa n0JiH0CTbi0 eLue ne n3 õ a B /ie H a OT ố eA H o cT n n B MHpe cym ecT B yioT M H o rn e o c/io ^H e H H H , 3TO noncTHHe BecbMa c/io>KHbiPi B onpoc E ro Ba>KH0CTb n rpaHAH03H0CTb 3acny>KHBatOT 6o;iee CHCTeMaTHHecKoro, ỗOiiee no/iHoro TeopeTHecKoro ncc/ieflpBaHHfl n A e i/ in o r o coA epxaH H H /ie e n y õ e A n r e jib H o r o M eTO Aa n c c /ie A O B a n n a TaKOBa uenb, KOTOPOI/I a B ro p HacTOHiuei/i A n c c e p T a u n n cĩp e M H T cn AOCTH‘ib H a c T o a m a a A n c c e p T a u n a C OC TO HT H i p e x B AnccepTaunn Ha ocnoB e r / ia B H b ix s a c T e í í - T p e x r / i a B n c c /ìe A O B a H n n n c ro p n n e c K n x KopH ew n KOHuenunn npaBơBoro rocyAapcTBa, ố o rẻ i/im e ro apceH aJia cooTBercTByiOLunx n A e ií õũC HO BaH B b iB O A 06 y n n B e p c a jib H O M , oõm eM npoaoM n a 4e n n n u e n n o c T e iĩ ripaB O B oro rocyA apG TB a HapHAy c 3THM A a n o o n p e A e /ie n n e npaBoeoro rocyAapcTBa K3K TaKOÊí ộopMbi opraHH3aunw nonnTnsecKoPi B iia c rn , K o io p a a ocHOBbiBaeTCH Ha n p n H n n ria x ro c n o M C iu a n p a a a BO Bcex c tịie p a x oốLueciB eH H O ìí >KH3HH, pa3A e/ieiiM H BJiacTeíí, CBfl3aH H 0C ĩn nx n tìc e ro rocyAapcTBeHHOiTO o c y m e c T B / ie H H A 3aKO H HO CTn, npaB, CBOỐOA, H e c ĩn MexaHH3Ma oốecneM eH H H npaBOM, H a p o A H O Ìí n AOCTOMHCTBa rp a ^ M a n , B6pxoB6HCTBa npaBa, cyB epeH H TeTa, a m n ib i nm epecoB o õ m e cT B a n caMoro rocyMapcTBa C A tíiia H BbitìOA o TOM, HTO npeACTaB/ieHHH o npaBOBOM ro c y A a c ĩB e n p n o õ p e jin ocoốyKD aKTya/ibHOCTb B c ip a H a x õbiBLDero "counanncTHHecKoro iia r e p f l" KâK peaKUM R O Õ L iỊG C T B G H H O C T H 3THX C TpaH Ha T O /IH T a p H M , aAMHHncĩpaTHBHO - KOMaHAHbie MeTOAbi BnacTBOBâHHA, nmopupoBaHne npaB H e j!O B e K a n r p a > K A a H H H a Ha ũCHOBe /ìeHHHCKĩ re o p n n peBOiiKDunoHHoro, couna/incTH M ecKoro r o c y A a p c T B a n X O L U H M H H C K O Ê Í n A e n r o c y A a p c T B a n n p a B a , a T3K>K6 n p S K T H K n rocyaapcĩBa APB n CPB B oỗ/iacTH pyKOBOACTBa n ynpae/ieHHH CTpaHOi/1 B TeseH ne ố o jìe e n a r n A e c a r n ;ieT npexcnee rocyAapciBO APB syxợibi counanncTHMecKOMy counaiincvm ecKoro BbemaMCKOMy H HbiHeLMHee íũcyAapcTBO CPB no cyrn ne npaBOBOMy npaBoeoro OTHOCnre/ibHO co-iinAHbiM HapoA y aB Top A n c c e p T a u n n x o n e r AO Ka3arb, HTO rocyA apcTB y rocytìapcTBa õaraxcoM: ueHHePíLuee CTpom e/ibCTBa BbeiHaM npe3HMfciHT Xo HacmeAne tì y>Ke pacnoiiaraer LUn M hh o ỗ /ia c r n ocratìn/i rioHHManna n KOHCTpynpOBannH roeyA apC T B a H B o ro Tnna; OAHHM H3 rip e A B a p n re jib H b ix ycjỉO B n iì A /IÍỈ yrb e p íK A e H n n , HTO B b e m a M p a c n o /ia r a e r yc/i0BMHMn n B03M0>KH0CTflMn fự \ft d p o n T e /ib c rs a n p a a o B o ro ro c y A a p c T B a -a ro pemnMOCTb BcePi n a p ĩn n n B c e ro H a poA a BC6MGPHO ố o p o ĩb C H 3a C T p0H T e;ibcrB AeMOKpaTHHecKoro rocyAapcTBa, 3a H03âBnGHMOCTb, cBQỗoAy n csacTbe HapoAa, 33 CM/ibHyio, M yA pyio rocyA a p cT B e H H yto BJìacTb paA H M c x o rtA y T B e p ^ a e ĩ, H3 T O ÍÍ n o n i4 n n , MTO B b e T H a M nM eeT S B io p y c /io B H H A nccepTaunn n c BQ 3M 0>KH0C TM 1-iapoAa y B e p e n H O C ib tũ ỊW Ĩ\ r io c r p o e n n H couna/incTM secK oro npaBoro ro c y A a p c ĩB a CĩponiejibCTBQ COUHCUIHCI m e c K o ro npatìOBoro rocyAapcTBa ao BbeTHaMe HB/ineTCH peajIU lori ne;iuo, cotìMecrnMoPi c TpaAHUHOHHbiMH nHCTHTyraMH BbeTHaMCKoro o õ iu e c T B a , K o ro p u e ÕecneHMBaiOT OỖLUeCTBeHHblíí KOHTpO;ib M nOpHAOK B3aMMOOTHOWeHHM M e>KAy íltO A b M H , O C H O B â H H b líí na yaa>K eH W H H p a B C T B tìH H b lX H O pM , A O Õ p O > K e /ia T /lb H O C T H M H B C T H O C T H 06HQBJienH6CKan ycTaHOBKa KoMMyHHCTUHecKOỈĩ napĩn n BbBinaMa 3aKiiiosaeTCH B TOM, MTO craỗmibHOdb n pa3BkiTne oÕmecTBa npeAno/iai aioT ero BcecTopoHHee OỐHOB/Ienue, n p n se M A&nbHeỉíiuee HOB/ieHne cocraBHbix s a c ie P i ncmnTHHecKOỈÍ CMCT8Mbi flBJifleTCfl nepBOOHepeAMHM ycnoB H tỉM /VIA npoABH)KeHHfl B rie p e A com -ia/ibHO-aKOHOM HHecKoro pa3BWTHfl CTpaHbi K ílB BbicnynaeT 3a y c n /ie n n e no/inTMHecKoPi c r a ố n /ib H O c rn o õ m e cT B a B nHTepecax co3AaHHH õ/iaronpMHTHOíí cpeAbi CTaồníin3aunn n pa3BHTHH 3KOHOMHKH B eA b C T a ố n /in a u n fl He 03H aH aer n o /iH o ro coxpaneiHHH Toro V C T a p e / io r o , a c T W H r0 , necnocoỗH biM a K O C T e H e / io r o n p n c n o c a ố /in B a T b c a 1103 lO M y VII G b e A KHB B b ic r y n a ^ 3a M exann3M a, K O T O p b iíí K H3M6HHBLL1HMC5R A an^H eP unee O K a b iB a e ĩC f l yCJ10BH«M O Ỗ H O B /Ie nn e H m ghho n o n m nMecKOM cncreM bi, BK/itOHaA pecpopMy rocyAapcTBeHHoro a n n a p a ĩa B HanpaB/iennn CTpome^ibCTBa npaBũBoro rocyAacTBa B 3101/1 CBR3H noBbiLuaeTCA 3HaHHM0CTb n aKiyajibii0CTb nccjieAOBannfl n nonuKa n yĩe íí CTaHOBneHHH counaJincTnsec- Koro npaeoBoro ro c y A a p c ĩB a BO BbeTHaMe nocKonbKy paHee 3T0T Bonpoc, 6CT6CTB6HHO, He 6blJÌ n cc/ie A O B an ca Mcxoaa M3 stoPí yCTaHOBKM KnB Ha OỐHOB/Ienne, TBOpneCKH npMM6HW5H MapKCH3M-/ieHHHH3M n HAePi yHHTbiBaa 0C0ỗeHH0CTn Xo LLIn MnHa o rocyA apcTB e n npaBe M n KOHKpeTHbie yc/ìOBHH BbeTHaMa (TpaA nunn HaunoHavibHyio Ky/ibTypy, oố b N an , oõmecTBeHHyio n c n x o /io rn to HapoAa n T-A-) a K x e oribiT pa3BHTbix rocyAapcTB 3anaAa n BocTũKa, B TOM sn c/ie onbiT rocyAíipcTBa PoecnííCKoro, 8BTOP A n c c e p u n n BbiABnraeT KOHKpeTHbie peKOMeHAauMH MaKpo 1/1 MHKpoypoBHH B nHTepecax nocTpoeHHH K3K coLịna/incTH H ecKoro n p a B o ro rocyA apcTB a BO BbeTHaMe, T3K M BooỗLue nioốoro rocyAapcTBa, npaBOBbiM to ộynuMOHMpoBOHna 3aKOHOAaTenbHbix, ộopMnpoBaHHH K o ĩop oe pecỊ)opMa npaBOBí CT3BHT COỐÍ 0praHH 3aun0HH0íí CMCTGMhi, ncno/iH m e/ibH bix nepeA opraHM3auMfl M cyAeỗHbix rocyAapCTBa couno/incTnsecK í 3aflany daTb CTpyKTypbi n n peopraHH3ai4Hfl opraHũB B HanpaB/ieHHM pecriy6/iwKH BbeTHaM KaK co u n a/incT nsecK oro npaBQBoro rocyAapcTBa i0r0-B0CT0HH0-a3naTCK0r0 Tnna r/IA B A I _ MCTOPMHECKME nP E flC TA B JlE H M fl nPABOBOM rO C yA A P C TB E rHOCEOilOrMHECKME KOPHM nPABOBOTO rocyAAPCTBA OneBHAHO s ro , B COOTBGTCTBOLU,tìM HCTOpnseCKOM TO /lbKO MOXCHO noHHTb CTaHO BJieiine n pa3BHTH6 rocyAapcTBeiiHOCTn, ncĩopnHecKoro rocyM apC TB a nx coAepaonne, M rip a ia n K n CMbic/1 n 3HaneHne noAxotìa He/Ib3fl noHKTt n cõciBeH H oro B H a n p a B /ie H n n HayMHO HHC TO - rip a B tì0 i/i Be3 n y ĩn npaBoooro nocTpoenna O ỗ p a m e n n e K UCTOPHH npaBOBOíí TO/ibKO ĩe o p n n KOHT6KCT0 TaKoro Jitoỗoro ro c y A a p c T B a ro c y A a p c ĩB e n H O C T n nM eeT, KOHtìSHO, He n o a H a e a re iib H o e 3H aseH ne " H c ĩo p n a , -K3K cnpaBeA^inBO cKa3ano - 3TO BcerAa BejiMKH!4 yHMTtìiib, n p ocB e rm e /ib, M BO cnM TaTe/ib” H paB O B oe Teopna, ro c y A a p c T B O a a ĩe M KaK caMOCTOHTe;ibHaH n npaKTHKa MMeeT A O /iry io n T a nax pa3BH Tn« H a s a /in (ịio p M n p o B a T b C H y>Ke n a p a n n n x H eiiO BesecKO íí B3ÊÌHMOCBH38ÍÍ, BaanMOAePicTBHH GBH3biBcuincb npaBa noncKn oÕmecTBeiinoiií )KH3HH Q ỗm eM pycne n u n B n /in a u n n y>Ke B a n M a B n c n M c re ti BJiacTw ỗonee n c ĩo p n t o ocyiuecrtìJifliomeÉ'i CBOIO tì HasnnatOTCA noHCKH npnHunnoB, cịiopM M KOHCĩpyKunM HaA.ne>KaLMnx K O H u enun a, r io y 'im e ;ib H y io nptíACĩaB/ieHHA o rocyAapcTBe KSK opraHH3aunn, A eare/ibH O C T b Ha 0C H0Be 3aKOHa, HAGH, c n A e e íi coBepuienhbix ycTaHOBiieHHA n c o m a c o B a H M Q ro n p a B O B o ro M ApeBHOCTM ro c y A a p c T B a cnpaBeA^iMBbix cpopM H3BecTHbiíí yHenuiíi Hepcecanq, B.c OTMenan, HĨO ” B ym yõ /iH B L D n xcn n p e A C T aB n eH H Ìĩ AOBOJibHO paHO c c f)o p M n p o B a /ia c b n A e a o n p a tìe n p n n a n n io ro c y A a p c T B tì o pa3yM H O C Tn w cíipaBtìA^inbOCTn o p n n a u n n TaKÍ ncuinTHHecKOỈÍ 4>opMbi oồm ecTBeHHí K ũ T o p o ũ rip a e o , ỗ /ia r o A a p a n >KH3HH nioMei/1, n p n n DOAaep>KKe B Jiacĩn , cianoBHTCA B/iacĩH O Ìí c n /io ìi ( T e o6m eo6fl3aTejibH biM 33KOHOM), a nyỗJinMHO-BJiacmafl c n /ia (c ee B03M0>KH0CTflMn nacmiHH H T A-) npn3naiom a« rip a a o , ynopíHAOHeiinaH n, c/ìeAOBaĩeiibHO, orpaHHHeHHaA n onpaBAaHHaa aAHOBpeMeHHO, cnpaB e/ụinB O ÌĨ ( ĩ.e cooTBeTCTByKDLuí npaBy) ro c y A a p c T -B e iiH O ií B / ia c ĩb io ’’2 '/ ŨHụ/iaiIHCIVMtìCKoe I ipattotioe rocy^vafxmỉo: KOtinauiyiH HIlyrn 2/ U ht p a õ , c M., 1990 c TaKoe riOHHManne rocyAapGTBa KcỉK npaBOtìoPí o p n n a n n n n y õ n m n o B/iacTHOÍĩ cnJibi HB.riHeTCfl o ch o b h o P i n A e e íí npaBOBOíí rocyAapcTBeHHOCTH B r e o p e T i/ H e c K n pa3BH TO M ro c y A a p c rB e ố b u in n p a B e p n y ĩO M o c |) o p M J ie H b i ro p a A O BM Ae no3>Ke yneH H íH - B o rip a B O B O M y c /iO B H A x ốopbõbi npoTHB cịíe o A a n b H o ro n p H B /ia n aốGO/itOTncTCKoro A ecnoTH 3M a, B a n o x y y p > K y a H b ix p e B o / iio u n i/ H y T B e p > K A e H H fl H o a o r o C T pO H O y p x < y a H b ie yH eH H H o K0HCTHTyuM0Ha/in3Me, AÊM O KpaTnn, npaBax n h h , K3K n BOOÕLMe p e c n y ố /in K a H C K O M CBoốoAax He/ioBeKa, C Tpoe, Hap0AH0M cyBepeH H Tere, rocnoA C TB e npaB a, BepxơBeHCTBe 3aKOHa n P3B6HCTB6 Bcex n e p e A HUM , p a A e /i6 H H n B /ia c T e i/i, H a B n c M M O C T n c y A a n T A -, n n T a /iM C b BO M H O rO M a H T H H H b lM H M CTO HHHK3M H, nx TeO peTH H eC K H M H n O /lO X e H M H M H n npaK TH M ecK H M n ố p a u a M M V HCTOKOB npaBOBoro rocyAapcĩBa CTOHT ApeBHníí 0ốpa3 ỗornnM npaeocyAHH paBeH C TBo - ộeMHAbi, 0Jim46TB0pflKDin6Ì/í B c e x /ìK D A e íí n e p e A 33KO HO M eAHHeHne to t oõpa3, no cn/ibi n npaca, n p e A C T a B /ie H M io ApeBHnx, Bbipa>KaeT He TO/IỊKO cnMB0/inKy cnpaBeinBoro cyAa, HO n nAeto cnpaeeA-nnBO M rocyAapcTBeHHO G TM BOoỗLMe ílp a B O c y A n e - 3TO c y ^ e H M e , ocHoeaHHoe Ha npaBe, npm eM Hê TO/ibKO no ocoõbiM cnopaM B cyAe, HO n no uceM Ae/iaM r0cyAapcTBeHH0-0praHH30BaHH0fí >KH3HH.1 C yA fle c b B b icT yna eT He K3K O TAe/ibnan sacT b ro c y A a p c T B a , a K3K tìb ip a x e H n e n noATBep>KAeHne rocyAapcTBeH HO Éí opraH M 3ai4M n n c T o p n s e c K n íí c yA b npa603amnTH0íí He3aBHCHMblM npaBoeyAHO CTn npncym uM cỆỉyHKLineíí, CTâTyCOM, M c n p a B e A -n n B o c ĩn oõm ecTB eH H O íí SMy co se T a H n e M npaBOBOíí >KH3HH Tatoxe H np a B a n c n /ib i, c e ro oprann3aunePi HeíĨTpa/lbHOCTbK), B cí H npoueAypaMn, ÕeKTHBHOCTbKD H T A- BbicrynaeT K3K nepBHHHbiií aTOM, npaõpa3, oỗpa3ei4 H MOfle/ib npaBOBí rocyAapcTBeHHOCTM, npaBOBĩ ộopMbi opraHH3ai4nn n 0yHKUMOHHpOBaHHfl nO/lMTHHeCKÍ )KH3HH H a en eAHHeHHH c n /ib i n npaea B o p H H a u n n AHHCKoro rocyAapcTBa Ha AeMOKpaTHHecKnx Hasajiax c03HaTe/ibH0 npoBũAH-n B CBOHX peộopM ax rp e se cK n x yxe B VI MyApeuoB B AO H CyTb CBOHX C o / io h , OAHH M3 H a M e H H T b ix pecị)opM OH Bbipa3HJi TaK; " OCBOÕOAH/1 A T o ro AOCTHr B /ia c ĩb to 3aKOHa, Bcex » c u /iy c npaBOM coMeTaB1'2 c C o n o n a , n o A LiepKH Ba/i A p n c T o r e /ib , B Acị)HHax H aH a/iacb AtìMOKpaTna, ' / L ịu r p a õ , c 2/ A pncroie/Ib AộnHCKaH no/iMTHH, M 1937, c 21 ceM n 10 /ự m ue/ieP i H a cT flL iie r0 ncc/ieA O B aH U A rocyAapcTBeH H O 0AH03HaHH0 - npaBOBaR n A e fl A p e B H n x H a npaB /iena npoTHB Ba>KHO 0TM6TnTb, o eA H H eH nn c n /ib i B y/ib rap H bix, paHHBLunxca coộncTHH ecKM x npeACTaB/ieHni/i o HTO 3Ta a 3aTeM TOM, ỗ y / u o n n npa B a pacnpocT- cnna poxA aei npaBo: cn/ibhbiM BcerAa npaB M T fl ripaBAa, cnpaBeA/inBocĩb, npaBo u 33KOH TpaAHUHOHHO CHHTaJlHCb Ố0>KeCTB6HHblMH yCTaHOB/16HHflMH, HeoỗxoflHMbiMn aTpnỗyĩaMn KOCMnsecKnx n 3eMHbix DOPHAKOB, aHTnnoAaMi/1 n a c n /in a , np0H 3B 0/ia ApeBHHX, nx n xa o ca n, r0 B p fl ceroA H R BblCOKOM nOMHTQHHH 3aKOHa n o 3aK0H0ri0CJiyujH0CTM 33KOHHOCTM, He CJieAye I 3aỗbiBaTL>, MTO noHnreuincb cBameHHbie TpaAnunn, Hcựvie>KaLne ycraHaB/inBaeMbiu pa3yMHbie cnpaBeA/inBbie 3aKOHbi, a He np0H380JibHbm AHKTaT CM/Ibi TaKoe oTH0LLI6HH6 K 3aKOHy c o A e p x n T c a , H a n p H M e p , B rpa>KAaHCKOM n p n c a re , KũTopyio >Km e/in n p n n o c n /in coBGpLUGHHO/ieTHR;’1 MOiiOAbie H ồyAy Acf)HH c /iy iu a ĩb c fl npn AOCTH>KeHnn B^acTeií, ÍIOCTÌHHO cym ecĩByiO LHM x, w noBHHOBaTbCH ycTaHOB/ieHHbiM aaKOHaM, a TaioKe T6M HOBbiM, Koĩopbie ycTaHOBMTb cor/iaceH HapoA M éc/IM KTO - HnỗyAb ỗyAer oTMeHATb 3aKOHbi H/IH He noBHHOBaĩbCH UM, ne A O iiym y a ro ro , He ỗ y A y a m n iu a T b n x n OAHH, H BMeCTG c o BCeMH1’ nosieHMeM HM0HHO K Õ0)KecTBeHH0 cnpaBefl/!HBOMy n pa3yMHOMy 3aKOHy npoAHKTOtìa/1 M õeceMepTHbiíí a(|)opn3M re pa K /im a H3 3(Ị>eca (540480 AO H.3): "HapOA AO/i>KeH c p a x a T b 3a 33KOH, K3K 3a CBOH CTeHbi” HecoM HehHO, STO A e cb p e s b HAST o B oííH e a rip a B o H npaBO Bbie y c ĩo n ro c y A a p c e H H O Íi >KM3HM, a He o a m m e B e n e H n íí B /ia cT B yio m n x y C oK paTa (4 -3 9 AO H 3.) Mbi BCTpewaeM Cfl nonbiTKOíí K/iaccncpnKaM Hu cpopM ro c y tìa p c T B a ũC H O B H b ie r o c y M a p c T B e H H b ie n/iyTOKpaTHH n ộ o p M b i: A eM O K parna CoKpar M O H apxH H , n p a B U Jib H O Íĩ'M T3K)K8 c nep B Q íi H a3b(Baer TaKne TnpaH na, apncTO KpaTH H , npaBCTBtìHHơPi OH GHHTaei ĩcuibKO apucTOKparnK), Koĩopyto xapaKĩepn3yer K3K B/iacTb HeÕQ/ibiuoro K0J1HHGCTBa 0Ốpa30BaHHb|X H HpâBC I B6IIHblX JIIOAei4 V seH ne C ũKpaTa HCXOAHT H3 T o ro HVO c n p a B e A -n n B o c ĩb COCTOHT B noAHHHennn cymecTBytOLUMM p a c c M a T p n B a iO T c n C oKpaTO M 3aKOH3M KâK OAHO CGố/itOAenMH 33KOHOB HtìMbic/iHM bi HU C npaBeA-HH Boe M TO *e no e ro n 3aK0HH0e M H e H n to , 6e3 rc>cy,4apcTBO, HU npaUOriOpHAOK ysei-me CoKpara o rocyAapcTBe yTBep>KAajio, HTO ” /Ìtoốbie aaKOHbi, KaKOBbi ỗbi Itn ỗ b u in HX HeAOCTaTKH, c n a c n r e íib n e e õe33aKOMHH n (Ip o n tìo iia E c ìih rp a xA B H e cõJìioAaK3T 3aKOHbi, TO ro c y A a p c T B a , B K o ro p b ix ripo>KHtíaior, CTaHOUHTCH CHiibHbiMH H n p o u tí e ia io iu n M u " '/ Apncioitíiib, HMI paồ., c 217 2/ MavepnaJincibt APtìBiieií Tpeuun M., 1955 c 15 3/ KcmaJieHKO A n npaBOBOtí rocyAapcruo: Konnermnn Mpeajibiiocib M.,1993 C.62 OIIH 195 Kax^oro KOJi/ieKTHBa n Bcero oÕLuecTBa H3 HHX n m epecbi HHAHBHAOB HtìmuoTCH nenocpeACTBeHHOỹi Aun>KymeM CHiií C/itìMìT ycĩpaHHTb raKoe rio/io^eHHH, KCHAa 3aKOHOAaTejibHbie aKĩbi HenocpeACTBtìHHyto ABHxymyto CH/iy, M BM0 CT6 c I ipeneốpe^ennA oÕLMecTBeHHbiMn /lHMHblX HHTepeCOB 3tO H ÌIHKBHAH-Pytoi reM ỗopoTbCA npOTHB KO/iiieKTHBHbiMn nHiepecaMn paAn 3K0H0MHH6CK06 3aKOHOA3TeJlbCTBO n AB/meTCH KOpHAOpOM CBOỐOAbl X03flííCTB0BaHHfl n aộộeKTMBHÍ oxpahbl 3aKOHHOPÌ COỐCTBGHHOCTH BM eC Te c n TeM C peAC TBO M AOXOAOB OHO AO/l>KHO OỐHOB/ieHHA ynpaB/ieiHHH CyÕbeKTOB n Õ blTb Bcex 3K0H0MHHeCKHX A eM C TB eH H blM COBepLUeHCTBOBaiHHA OốecneHHTb TecHyio B3anMOCBH3b, n yKiiaflOB 3C Ệ)(t)eKTH B-HblM H H C TpyM 6H T0B M aK pO - B3aM M 0A0n0JiHeHHfi n KOopAHHaunio Me>Kfly OTpac/iHMH npaBa B npaBOBOíí CMCTeMe CTpaHbi, yHac/ieAOBaTb OAHO H3 n BbiốopoHHO OCHOBHUX BocnpnHHMarb HanpaB/ieHníí M e x A yH a p o A H o e coBep-LueHCTBOBaHHH npaBO - npaBOBOi/i cucĩe M bi BbeTHaMa B HacTOHinee BpeMR M B ỗyAymeM HapHAy c OÕLMMMH 3aAasaMM VII cbe 3A KĨIB HaMeTn/1 TaioKe P«A KOHKpeTHblX Hanpae/ieHMÍÍ COBepiUeHCTBOBaHHH M OỐHOB/ieHHA CMCT6 Mbi 3KOHQMMH6CKOrO 3aKOHOflaTe/1bCTBa B HaCTHOCTH, C/ieAyeT MMeĩb 3aKOHbi, KOHKpeTHO ycTaHaB/inBaiomne yHac/ieAOBaHne n nepeAany npaBa Ha ncn0íib30BaHne 3eMJin, KOMn/ieKTOBanne 33KOHOB o Ha/iorax K3K pbinara, CTHMyiinpyiomero n HanpaB/iAKDmero np0H3B0ACTBeHH0 - xo3flíícTBeHHyio AeHTe/lbHOCTb, HHTeHCHBHO pa3paốO Taĩb n M3A3Tb 33KOH oố oxpaHe OKpyaotomeíí cpeAbi, rpa>KAaHCKníí KOfleKC, TpyAOBoe 3aKOHO- AaTe/ibCTBO, õecneHHBaiom ee BC6 M /1K)A«M ripaBO ỗbiTb X03HI/IH0M CBoí p a õ o se ìí cn /lb l B OTHOLU6 HMH COBepLUeHCTBOBBHHH n OỐHOB/ieHHH nO/lHTHHeCKÍ CHCTeMbi VII cbe3A noAHepKHy/1 po/ib AeMOKpaTnn KQK yc/ioBHfl n ue/in H0 B;ieHsecK r f\ena AeMOKpaTHR - coaoKynHoe 3aBoeBaHMe Ae/ia ÕH0 BJieHHfl t o 3aB0eBaHne A J1>KH0 /iera/in3oaaTbc« B BHAe 3aKOHa - 3TO topHAMsecKoe npaeo n 0ốfl3aHH0CTn HeiioBeKa K3K rpa)KAaHHHa n jih s h o c th ri03T0My ro c y A a p C T B AO/i>KHO ycTaH O B H Tb c n c ĩe M y npaB w o5fl3aiiHOCTeỉí rp a*A a H , a TaK>KG npaB Me/ioBeKa, npaB, HeoTAe/inMbix o r 0ốfl3aiiH0CTeíí n OTBeTCTBeHHOCTU 196 HapAAy c oÕHOB/ienneM n coBepLueHGiBOBanneM SKơHOMHMecKOi o 3aKOHOAaTejibCTBa c/ieAyer npo,40 /]>tKeHHbie B AOKyMeHTax VII ct>e3Aa K n B BecbMa ốoraTbi n r/iyốOKH npoBe,qeHne nx B >KH3HL> rtB/ineTCfl OAHÍ H3 r a p a m n n y c n e L U H o r o C T p o u r e /ib C T B a npaBOBOTO r o c y A ầ p c ĩ a BO B b e T H a M e / 197 3AKÌ1IOHEHM E B HTO xoAe npaBO BQ e A n c c e p T a i^ n o H H o ro ro c y A a p c T B O - n c c iie A O B a h H H eAH HC TBeHH O Mbi B e p H b iíí r ip n u m n nyTb K K B b iB O A y , n o c ĩp o e H H io i4HBn/!H3 Ban-H0 r AeM0KpaTMHecK0r oõmecTBa Booốiue n BO BbeTHaMe, B MacTHOCTn CTpome/ibCTBO couna/iMcrnHecKoro npaBũBoro rocyAapcTBa npeACTaBnReT c o õ o íí nepB CTeneHH e GOAep>KaHne Ae/ia oốHũB/ieHHH H C T p o n T e /ib C T B a B b e T H a M a Ha C O BP6M 0H H O M T a n e HacTOHLuee MCC/ieAOBaHMe flBJifleTCfl nonbiTKoíí npoaHa/inanpoBaib ncTopnsecK ne, npaBOBOi TeopeTnsecKne n npaKTMHecKne acneKTbi (|)0pMnpQBaHH9 rocyAapC TBa, A3Tb xapaKTepncTMKy rip o u e c c a ộ o p M n p o B a n n H n noarariH oro paaBHTHH rocyAapcTBa n ripaBa K3K BOoỗLue, TâK BO BbeTHaMe, BbiHBHTb maBHbie ro c y A a p c T B a n 4>aKT0pbi, npaBa B/iMflK)mne Ha ộopM npoeaH ne n pa3Bm ne H c c /ie A O B a H M e n p n B e /10 H a c K n o H H M a H H K ) TOI O ,HTO HMe»OTCfl yc/ioBHA 1/1 B03M0>KH0CTH nocTpoeHHH y>Ke Ha CBP M6 HHOM 3Tane couna/incTM secKoro npaBOBO rocyAapcTBa BO BbeTHaMe B npouecce HariMcaHHH A n c c e p ĩa u n n CTa /10 B03M0>KHbiM cộop- My/inpoBarb c/ieAy»omne BbiBOAbi M npeA-no>KeHHfl: npaeoBoe rocyAapcTBO K3K caMOCTOHTe/ibHaq KOHuenuna MMeeT CBOK) A^inTe/ibHyto MCTopmo n npaKTMHecKoe B o n /io iu e H n e ncT0pniiecKMx acneKTOB Teopnn npaBOBoro rocyAapcTBa MM66T BaxHoe 3H aseH ne, n CK0 /ibKy c o A e p x m õ o T b iíí a p c e H a /1 Htìí, 6e3 3HaHHfl K0 T0 pbix H6B03M0)KHa myốOKaa npopaõũTKa H pea/inaunfl KOHuenunn coBp6M6HHoro npaBOBoro rocyAacTBa npaB0B0e rocyAapcTBo npeACTaB/iaeT coốoỉí cpopMy opraHH3a- UMH no/inTnsecKoíí B/iacTn, rocnoACTBa BO npaBa Bcex 0CH0BbiBaK)ineíícfl cộepax Ha npm-mnnax oốLuecTBeHHOÊí XH3HH, pa3Ae/ieHHfl B/iacTePi, CBH33HH0CTH nx n B cero rocyAapCTBenHoro MexaHH3Ma npaBOM, BepxoBeHCTBo 33KOHOB, ocymecTB/ieHHR 3aKOHHOCTn, oốecneHeHHR HapoAHoro cyBepehniera, rapamnpoBaiiHOCTH 3aiMHTbi npaB, CBOỖOA, n e c ĩn n A CT0 HHCTBa rpa>KAaH, nHTepecoB oỗmecTBa n caMoro rocyAapcTBa, y s e ĩa oỗmeMe/ioBesecKnx ueHHOCTeií n MHPOBÍ npaKTHKn 198 B C0BpGM6HHbix yc/iOBMflx npeAciatìJiennH o ripaBOBOM rocytìapcitie npnoỗpeiiM ocoồyio aKTya/ibHOCTb tì crpanax ốbiBiuero "counanncTHH6 CK o narepa” KâK peaKMHA Ha T0iajiurapn3M; aAMHHMCĩpaTHBHo KOMaHAHbie MeTGAbl UJiaCTBOBaHHfl, HMtìBliiee M e c io n rn o p n p o B a n n e npaB senoBeKa n rpa>KflaHMHa cpopMnpoBaHne n pa3Bnrne rocyAapcTBa n npaBa BO BbeĩHaMe npeACTae/iaeT co ỗ o iĩ ncTopMHecKnti n p o u e cc MHoroTbic«sejifc I- Hí ốopbõbi 3a c03AaHne n coxpanenne roeyAapCTBa AOBaHne ncTopun M cc;ie- cỊ>0 pMMp0 BaHMH n pa3BHTi/in rocyAapcTBa n npaBa BbeTHaMa MMeeT ncK/ìt0HMTejibH0 6o/ibiuoe 3HaseHne onpeAe/ieH H A BbeTH aM e npaBHJibHoro n y rn c o u n a /in c T H H e c K o r o CTponTe/ibCTBa n p a B o e o ro BO ro c y A a p c rB a B C T H H r0 T n n a ro c y A a p c T B O CPB n A e ííc T B y » O L u a fl- a K O H O fla re /ib H a a c n c ĩe M a BbeTHaMa HB/IHIOTCH npoAyKTOM ncropnHecKOi o npouecca /ựinTe/ibHoro H AHa/ieKTmecKoro pa3BMTMfl Pa3HOOõpa3ne n cne unộ nK a npnpoAbi n /ìtOAei/i n03B0Jin/in co3AaTb rocyAapcTao toro-BOCTOHHO - a3naTCKoro THna c ocoỗbiM CTH/ieM n CBOeOỐpa3HblMH TpaAHUH«MH T a ic n e aKTOpbi, KaK ce/ibCKaR K yn b íy p a , T paA nun oH H aq Õm,H0CTb, KOHCịiyUHâHCTBO, BÍHbl, MHOCipaHHbie 3aKOHOAaTe/lbHbie CHCTeMbl ocTaen/in oTneHaTKM Ha Bceií õmecTBeHHí >KH3HH BbeTHaMa n OKa3a/]n cn/ibHo B/inflHne Ha CTaHOBíienne H pa3Bnrne rocyAap- CTBa n npaea BbernaMa B HacTOHLuee BpeMA BO BbeTHaMe c 03AaJincb yc/iOBMfl H B03M0>iKHee l ocyAapcreo APB n HbiHeiiiHetí rocyAapcTBo CPB no npaBOBOMy rocyAapcTBy cyrn He ny>KtìL'i conna/incinMecKOMy I9a CrponTe/ibCTBO couna/incTHHecKoro BbemaMe TpeốyeT n p a B O B o ro n c x o A H T b H3 K J ia c c B i/i BO ro c y A a p c T B a cymHOCTn ro c y A a p c T B a C P B , H3 ycTaHOBKH KriB Ha oÕHOtì/ienne, TBopMecKoe npnMeneHne MapKCH3Ma - /16H H H H 3M n H AÊH X o l i l n M n n a o ro c y A a p C T B e n npaBe n TpeõyeT yMHTbiBaĩb 0C0ốeHH0CTn n KOHKpembie yc/iOBHH BbeTHaMa (TpaAnunn, Ky;ibTypHbiíí ypoBeHb oốmecTBeHHyio 3KOHOMHHeCKOrO oốbHan HapoAa HaunoHa/ibHyK) n ncnxo/iornK) H a p o A a pa3BHTHfl Cĩpanbl) ypoBeHb n ypoBenb ĩa Ky/ibTypy, AeMOKpaTnn, couna/ibHO CyiMHOCTb n - 3TH 0C06 eHH0 CTn 0ỗycjì0B/inBaK3T MOAe/ib n nHCĩnTyĩbi npaBũBoro rocyAapcTBa BO BbeTHaMe a A a s a CTâH0B/i6HHfl couna/incrnM ecKoro npaBOBoro rocyAapGTBa BbeTH aM a TpẽyeT (Ệ)yHKUM0 H np BaHMH pe4>opM bi 0praHH3amn0HH0íí npaBOBí CMCTeMbi, c ĩp y K T y p b i o p H H a u n n n n peopraHH3ai4nn 3aKOHOAaTe/ibHbix, ncno/iHnre/ibHbix M cyAeÕHbix QpraHOB 200 CriMCOK HCnQJIb30BAHH0fl JIMTEPATyPbl I OcHQBHbiQ HayqHhie paỔOTM MapKc K , 3HT6Jibc T 3, c HeM6iựcaj! HfleoJiorHH// Coq 2-e H3A., -5 4 MapKC K , 3Hrejibc MaHH$QCT KoMMyHMCTHqecKoA napTHn// Coq 2-e H 3fl., T 4, MapKc G 419-459 K , 3Hrejibc í PeBOJiDLựífl B McnaHHn//Cotỉ 2-e H fl., T 12, c 44-49 MapKC K , dHranbc Cọ* - H3A*» T , 19, c Mapnc K ,, 3HTôJibc T 13, Mapxc K ,, dHT&nbc - H8 f l , T , K KpHTHKỠ nOJIHTHqeCKOft 3R0H0IAỈXM// 23, c c I-I6 - KpHTHKa roTCKoK nporp&MMU.// Co^ -3 ripoiỊecc OỔM6H& //C o tỊ 2-e H 3fl., -1 Mapicc K , 3HT8JĩbC $ TeopHH npHỔaBOqHOH CTOHMOCTH*// Coq 2-e H 3fl,, T 26, q I Mapxc K , 3HT6JJbc $ IlepenHCKa M&tpỵ K.MapncOM H í.3 h t0 JI COM BManqecTep Jl0 Hfl0 H, ceHTHƠpn 1852 r / / M3 A , T 28, c Coq 2-e -1 M&pitc K , dHT6Jibc ĩlMCbMa K.MapKca H $.3Hre.Bbca K P&3- HUM jfMiỊBLM 3HT9jibc - ABrycTy BeổejHQ, 18-28 MapTa I8 r./ Coq 2-0 H3f l , T 34, c 99-106 20 dH T JIbC $ IlpOHCXO*fleHHfl CƠMbH, íiaCTHOA COỐCTBƠHHOCTM H r o c n o ,n c T B a // MapKC K , ÔHrenbc ỉ T 3, c, 1 -3 M aổp.npoH B0flôHHH 201 1 H re jib c $ ĩlpMHHnnbi K0 MMyHH3M a./ / MapKC K , n re jib c Com - e H A , T 4, c 2 -3 12 JlôHHH B M iụiKTaType n p o jie T a p H E T a / / r io jiH c o d p c o q T 39, c 259-268 13 JỈ6 HMH B M MejiK ố y p K y a Hbỉỉí H npojieTapGKMỈi c o ụ n a jiH M / / n o jiH c o đ p c o q T 12, c -4 14 JIeHHH B H OcTanbHHe nojiHTH*i6 CKM6 Bonpocbi, M M3 BpameHHwe n K H e B C K H M / / ì1ojih c o ố p cow c 15 16 T 30, II6 -I2 JỈ6 HMH B H T aTpoHyTbie 33, c JỈ6 HHH B H P c y fla p c T B H peBOJl(OiụiK.// nOJIH.CO'Jp c o n I-I3 V B y p iy a H a H M n p o j! T a p c K a H fl M0 K p a T M fl./ / ỉloj!Ha c o đ p cou Tt , c -2 17 JỈ6 HHH B H T Iô 37, c JIỡHHH B M 06 " fl MQKpaTHM" H A H K T a ry p ẹ // Il JIH.C0 ổp.C t| 8 -3 Eme paa o n p o ặ c o Đ s a X ) TexyiqeM M0 M6 HT M omHỔKax T T Tpoiụtoro H B yxa p H H a // IloJiH.cođp.cotỉ T 42, c 264-296 19 JIghhh B.M rocyflapcTBe JIeKiflifĩ B CBep,iựĩOBCKOM yHMBepcK Tere I I 20 1919 r / / n o jiH co p c o ti T 39 JỈ6 HMH B M A e T C K a a Ổ0Jie3Hb "JleBM3HU" B KOMMyHM3 M0 / / rỈ0JiH* coổp C(m, T 41, c 77 21 CtễUIMH H Oổ 0CH0B8X H0HMHH3M&Ĩ JJ9 KIJHH, tníTaHHbie B CBep,IỤ!OBCKO«ắ yH H BơpCH TCTo// Il0 CJieCJI0 BHe H.CHMOHOBa M : Teppa, 1991 - 142 c 22 Xo iŨH Mhh XaHott: HsỔpaHHblỡ nOJIHU6 COHHH0 HHH lỉỉbi T x a r 1995 (H a B b ỡ T H •) • 10 TO MOBa - 23 Xo 111m Mhh c o iạ ia jiH Ma co iạ i& n n cT H iie cK ott peBC)jiioi],wn H CTpoHTejibCTBe Xaỉỉott; lllu T x a T , “ 236 c ( h a B b e T H H ) 24 Xo UỈH Mmh JÌ6HMH6 H ÌĨSHMHH3M6 XaHOÍị: liiu Txa-r 1977 - 119 c (Ha Bb6TH.H3 ) 25 Jíe 3yaH MađpaHHHe CTâTLM H penH I965-Ĩ970 r r - M : rio^MTH3flaT, 1971, - 359 c 26 JIe 3yan W3 ỔpaHHue cTaTbH M peqn 1970-1975 r r - M : riojiM TM 3A aT , 27 1975 - 374 c Jie 3yan ComiajiwcTHtiecKaH peBOjjK)ụwfl BO BbeTHaMe - T - XaH0 W: lilbi TxaT, 1976.- 743 c (na BL«TH.H3.) 2tì Jle 3yaii ComifiưjHCTHtiecKafl peB0.n»HHH BO BbeTHaMỡ T.2 -• XaHí: Diu TxaT, 1976.- 754 c (Ha Bb6TH.H3.) , 29 Jle 3yaH, CoiỤ!ajiHCTimecKaH peBOJi»ụH/r BO BbeTHaMe T.3 Xajiofi: lHhi 'íbcaT, 1900- I721 c, ( he BbôTK H ) 30 Jiữ 3yaH C o m ia j!rH c w iẹ c K a fl peBOJ!»ụKH BO B b e T iỉa n e T XaHOtl: Diu T)C&T, 1984 - 654 c (Ha BbdTH.H3 ) 31 HuOHP lílH b MapKCH3M M Bb THGLMCK&ff Ity/IETypa JlM TepaTypa Ha HHocTpaHMi.Dc H3UK&X, X âH 0fl.H 3A 1979 32 Muonr TtoHb HeKOTOpue Bonpocu o rocy^apcTBe CPB XanoH: U!u T k e t , 33 1965 H uohp TVlHb (Ha B b O T H H ) B L THEMCK fl peBOJIK)ựMH //ỉịOKyMeHTbl n b e - ĩlapTHH XaHOtt: liỉu T xa ĩ, 1965 - 201 c (na BbâTH.H3.) 34 H uohp 'RiHb BbeTHaMCKan HanKOHanbHaH HHp0 flH “ ^GMOKpaTH— tỉecKOH p©bojibiẹĩHc XaH0 ỉ lliu TxaT, 1976 T ĩ , - 203 c ( n a B b ỡ T H H ) 35 HuoiíP TYĩHb Bnepe,n no/* 3HaMflHeM napTHH XaH0 fl: lliu TxaT, 1963, c 92-94 («a BL0TH.H3 ) 203 HryeH BaH JỈMHb BaacHHỈí aiar no nyTM ỐH0 BJieHHH./ / rip o ố n e u tí MHpa M comíaưiH3Ma, 37 Ao MbioH 1987, N“ , c -1 CoBepmeHCTBOBaHHe rocyflapcTBeHHoro annapa- Ta M OỐHOBJI8HH6 napTHỈíHoro pyKOBOACTBa r0cyflapcTB0M// 1992, ỉf> I , c 10 n iịoK.VMQHTbi KilB H BbeTHaMCKoro r o c y Ạ iip o Í-Béx 38 MaTapnaưibi lil 0be3fla ĩlapTHH TpyAHíiìMxcH BbeTHaMa - M : noJiMTi!3,i\aT, I9 Ịr-304 c V 39 C*be3fl KoM^yHHCTH^iecKoỉí napTHM BbeTHEMa; ll0JJHTH3flaT, 1977, - 516 c I 40 y b K o M H y H H C T H q e cK O Ỉ! napTMH BbeTHSLMa: ĩloj!HTH3)n a ĩ , 1983 - 208 c 41 MaTepH&nu y i Ci>03A& KT1B - Xanott: lilbi TxaT, 1987 248 c (Ha BbOTH'H3♦ ) 42 AoKyMeiiTH BbeTHaMCKOtt napTHRHott KOHỘepỡHiỊHM yn coaHBa XaHoỉt: UIh Txet , 1994 (Ha 8b6TH*H3 ) 43 AoKyMeHTH yn 0B63A6 KT1B XaHOtt: illhi TxaT, 1991 ( he BbơTH H3 ) •’ 44 UeHTpeưibHUlí KoMHTeT IlapTHM TpyAHiiỊnxcíi BbeTHaMa PeBOIIDLẸIA HneHyMa HTpaHbHoro KoMHT0Ta napTHH A a - qax BbỡTHÊLMCKOVl pỡBOJIK>pHH Ha HOBOM 3Tanô X&HOft: Ulu TxaT, 1975 75 c (Ha BbCTH.H3 ) 45 KoHCTHTyiẸiH ,IỊPB 1946 r XaHoỉt: nojMTH3flaT ( he BbeTH H3 • ) * 204 46 KoHCTHTyựMH APB 1959 r XaHoỉí: ỈIojiHTH3AaT (Ha Bb6TH H3 ) 47 KỊHCTHTymiH CPB 1990 r XaHl: HojiHTM3^aT (Ha Bb6TH fl[3ô) ã 48 KoHCTMTyiớH CPB 1992 r XaHoi: riojiHTW3flaT ( he BbôTH H3 ) 49 LịeHTpajIbHafl KOMMCCHH no HCCJieAOBaHMK) MCTOpHH napTHH 50-jieTHHH AeHTajibH0 CTb KTIB XaH0 ft: liibi TxaT, 1974 (Ha BÒ6TH.H3 ) 50 no AaHHbiM rocyflapcTBeHHoro eựỤiíHHMCTpaTHBHoro HHCTHTyTa o "peộopMe rocyAapcTBeHHoro annapaTa EựỊMHHHCTpaTHBHo- ro ynpaBJieHHfl H OTpHAe rocyaapcTBeHHHX 8flMHHHCTpaTHBHhDC cjiyjKaiqHx" XaHOtt: ỉỉỉbi T xet, 1991 51 riflTbflecHT H8T fleflTanbH0 CTH KT1B XaHott: lllbi TxaT, 1979,334 c DI CneipĩeuibHne HayxĩHue paỔQTU 52 AsapKHH H H , JleBqeHKO B H , MapTHUiHH A B McTopHH noJiHTHnecKHX yqeHHtt BbmycK I K)pHCT, M , 1994 53 Ạ jie K c e e B c c ripaBOBoe ro c y ^ a p c T B O - c y A b Ố a copnanM 3M a M , 1966 54 /tao 3yỉl ẢHb BbeTHaM qepe3 n0 K0 Ji6HHH XaHOỈi, 1964 ( he BbeTH.H3 ) 55 ApHCTOTejib AỘHHCKaa nojiHTMfl M , 1937 56 ApHCTOT0 JIb ílOJJHTMKa M , I I I HryeH ^UK BMHb HaụHOHa/ibHaH HeaaBHCHMOCTb H co iụ ia jiH 3M- Henoổe;ụiMoe 3HOMH BbeTHaMCKOỈí peBOJi»ựHM// " Kommỵhm ct" , 1977, J#> I 205 58 BopoHHH A c BbeTHaM cero^HH M , 1979 59 By ĩb™ $yHT McTopHH rocyaapcTBa H npaBa BbeTHaMa XanoK: ỉỉỉbi TxaT, 1993 (Ha BbSTH H ) 60 By Kk)ỈỈHb, Kbey $y CTpaHHbie HCTOPHH ilHHbHEMa H3fl HKyjibTypa" XaH0fl: 1960 ( he BbỡTH H 3.) 61 rerejib $HJIOCOỘHH npaBa M ,JI., 1934 62 Tođốc T JIeBHaộaH M., 1936 63 Jỉe Kyỉi ^OH CounHeHHíĩ, T 111 H3fl "oốmecTBeHHboc HayKn XaHOỈÍ, 1977 (Ha ĐbỡTH.H3.) 64 HaH Htok /UdOHr H Ịị,0 HryeH $bi0 Hr Co3flaHHe coLẠiajiHCTHiiecKOỈÍ AeMOKpaTHH w npaBOBoro rocy,napcTBa XaH0 ft: lUbỉ TxaT, 992 65 (Ha B b O T Ị ỉ'jỊ t) ' Hòuihhck r 66 Oổiqee yxieHHe ro c y fla p c T B e Cnố, A.A yqeỔHHK rocyflapcTB6HHoro npaBa: 1908 (nocoỐHe K KIỤỈhm) • IỉeTporpaA' 1916 67 SypHan "CoBôTcicoe rocỵAapcTBO H npaao" 1988, 60 KypHỄUi "HCTOPHVỊOCKHỠ HccjjeflOBaHHHn I 1967 (Ha Bb6TH' H3 ) 69 SypH & n ” HCTOPMW0CKH6 HCCJieflOBSLHHflM, 1992 Jf> (H a BbBTH H ) 70 KypHan "Mejiụ^HapoflHHtt", 1993 I (Ha Bb@TH.H3 ) 71 HryeH 3yw 3a Xo IDh Mhh - c03flaT8Jib rocyAapcTBa HOBoro THna Hhh3&h # If 8.I995r 72 HaH BaH 3jin HeKOTopne MH8HHH TH0 CMT6JibH0 AparoựeHHHx ỐaMổyKOBbDC AOQỊỡtỉỡK KopoJiH Ah 3feiOHra H npoỔJi6MU Kopojifl TxyK AH3W0Hra H3fl "•HHTepaTypa", 1957 (Ha Bb6TH.H3.) • 206 73 Xo UỈH MHHa rocyAapcTBe H npaBe XaHoữ: riojiHTM3AaT 1993 (H a Đ b T H H3 ) 74 MepMHr p LỊejib B npaBe C nố., 1961 75 RnbHH Đ A JleKLỌ!M no Me»AyHap0flH0My nyỐJiH