Competitor or ally japans role in american educational debates

COMPETITOR OR ALLY? R EF EREN C E BOOKS IN INT ERNATIONAL EDU CATION V OLUME 45 GARLAND R E F E R E N C E LIBRARY OF S O C I A L S CI ENCE VOLUME 140 COMPETITOR OR ALLY? JAPAN'S ROLE IN AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL DEBATES EDITED BY GERALD K I~ ~~ o~~~~n~~~up New York London LETENDRE First published by Falmer Press This edition published 20 II by Routledge: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group 11 Third Avenue New York, NY 10017 Routledge Taylor & Francis Group Park Square, Milton Park Abingdon, Oxon OX 144RN Copyright © 1999 by Gerald K LeTendre All rights reserved Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available at the Library of Congress Competitor or ally? : Japan's role in American educational debates / edited by Gerald K LeTendre Contents Tables and Figures Acknowledgments Introduction Merry White vii ix xi Chapter I: International Achievement Studies and Myths of Japan Gerald K LeTendre Chapter 2: A Look at the Other Side of Japanese Education : Student Responsibility and Learning Ineko Tsuchida and Catherine C Lewis 25 Chapter 3: Coping with Diversity: The Achilles' Heel of Japanese Education? David McConnell 47 Chapter 4: Individuality, Learning, and Achievement: Japanese Perspectives Hidetada Shimizu 65 Chapter 5: Work Roles and Norms for Teachers in Japan and the United States Hua Yang 83 Chapter 6: "The Dark Side of .": Suicide, Violence and Drug Use in Japanese Schools Kangmin Zeng and Gerald LeTendre v 103 vi Conren~ Chapter 7: International Comparisons and Educational Research Policy Gerald LeTendre and David Baker 123 Conclusion : Resilient Myths: Are Our Minds Made Up About Japanese Education? Catherine C Lewis 141 Glossary References List of Contributors Index 149 151 165 169 Tables and Figures Management statements in Japanese and American classes 31 Teacher encourages students to express support, disagree or elaborate on other students' remarks 37 Fig 2-3 Teacher external reward statements 39 Fig 2-4 Teachers' lesson-framing statements 40 Fig 2-1 Fig 2-2 Table 5-1 Weekly Time Allocations of Japanese and U.S Middle School Teachers 88 Table 5-2 Time Distribution for Specific Academic Tasks by Japanese and U.S Middle School Teachers 89 Table 5-3 Time Distribution for Specific Student Guidance/Activity Tasks by Japanese and U.S Middle School Teachers 90 Table 5-4 Staffing Patterns in the U.S and Japanese Middle Schools 97 Table 6-1 Suicide Rates Over Time for Japanese Youth (per 100,000) by Age Ranges 109 Table 6-2 Suicide Rates by Gender in Selective Nations Death by Suicide per 100,000 Population for Youth Aged 15-24 109 Table 6-3 Bullying in Japan 114 vii Acknowledgments The process of developing a book from a set of conference papers can be a long and convoluted one We would like to thank Thomas Rohlen , Harold Stevenson and Nancy Sato for their input in developing this manuscript, and Cindy Fetters and Judy Harper who worked to type parts of the manuscript Marie Ellen Larcada, formerly of Garland Press, provided direction for an early draft of the manuscript And we would especially like to thank Ed Beauchamp for his support and guidance The idea for this book originated in the American Educational Research Association symposium "Comparison or Competition: The Use and Misuse of Japanese Educational Data in the American Context," in which the principle authors of this book took part as presenters and discussants The overall conclusion of the symposium was that to a large degree discussion of Japanese education in the American research context is still belabored by stereotypical notions of the Japanese and Japanese society; is heavily biased in favor of quantitative studies, even those with widely acknowledged methodological flaws such as the SIMS; and is more and more a policy or political issue in which statistics , divorced from the social context, are used as "evidence" in ways that prevent an accurate picture of Japan from emerging ix Introduction Merry White Why so many Americans seem to have something to say about Japanese children? From the National Inquirer-gossipmonger of the supermarket checkout lines-which ran a story about Japanese education moms, to leading political satirist Gary Trudeau, everyone wants to talk about Japanese students But, at the same time that some writers are exalting Japanese educational values, others in the same popular media write lurid stories about bullying, juvenile suicide, robotized minds and stifled imaginations American and Japanese writers over the past 25 years have offered models, mirrors and cautionary tales of Japanese childhood and schooling The Japanese classroom has been a focus, even an obsession of commentators associating education with national security This obsession has equally affected cartoonists, supermarket tabloids and, more recently it appears, some leading educational research journals in which, for example, the results of the Third International Math-Science Study are debated using reference to U.S and Japanese cultural parameters The contradictory and inflammatory views that typify coverage of Japanese students or schools reflect American divisions and confusion over educational priorities and goals These views also demonstrate how research data can be (and often has been) used and misused in the discourses on both Japanese and American education to promote a range of reform agendas American attention to Japan has reflected our international and domestic concerns about global competition and the frustrations of a generation of young workers who will not better than their parents But these concerns were sometimes buried under an overarching feverish attention to the success of xi xii Introduction children in a country that is just about as far away from the United States (culturally and geographically) as you can get Of course, these cycles of attention and concern have not always been characterized by distortion, projection or denial of appropriate priorities There are certain giveaways which can cue the reader to the presence of biased reporting: the use of absolutes such as "all Japanese children," unsubstantiated claims or correlations such as "examination pressure has caused a rise in juvenile suicides," references to a mythical ideal or archetypal norm in one society that is contrasted with down-toearth realities in the other In each of the three waves of engagement I will discuss below, there have also been clear, well-researched pieces on Japanese realities which critically assess the constructions which American researchers and policy makers tend to place on Japanese schools and students With proper acknowledgment of the complexity and contradictions that any serious treatment will generate, let us call these three types or stages of reaction to Japanese education the "wow!", "uh-oh" and as Joseph Tobin notes, "yes, but " reactions "Wow" refers to the gape-mouthed amazement with which stories of exceIIence in test results, classroom management, and family-school cooperation were received in the United States in the 1970s when Japan's economic "miracle" first came to center stage in the international media "Uh-oh" describes the reaction of those concerned with American competitiveness in the face of apparent Japanese superiority Finally, "yes, but " allows for the positive aspects, putting them in context as weII as noting downsides-an admiring but qualified response These three periods roughly correspond to the three decades in which Japanese education has developed a high profile in America, in the seventies, eighties and nineties Japanese education has stimulated envy, fear and pity in Americans for some time: wartime propaganda tended to focus on fear (Japanese adolescents training to be kamikaze pilots) and postwar reports often focused on pity (children packed 50 to a classroom in half-bombed buildings) Since the take-off of the Japanese economy in the 1970s, envy appeared in the "wow!" stories of Japanese school success These tended to focus positively on classroom order, high test scores and on the moral value and political priority given to education in Japanese society Openly curious, the writers of these stories asked if this centrality could be attributed to the traditional Confucian equation of 156 References Lee, V., Croninger, R., Linn, E and Chen, X (1996) "The Culture of Sexual Harassment in Secondary Schools." American Educational Research Journal, 33 (2), 383-418 LeTendre, G (1994) Willpower and willfulness: Adolescence in the U.S and Japan Unpublished doctoral dissertation School of Education Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.s LeTendre, G (1995) "Disruption and reconnection : Counseling young adolescents in Japanese schools " Educational Policy, (2), 169-184 LeTendre, G (1996) "The evolution of research on educational attainment and social status in Japan " Research in Sociology of Education and Socialization, J, 203-232 LeTendre, G and Baker, D (1998) "International Competitiveness in Science." Education Week, June 17,46 LeTendre, G., Rohlen, T P and Zeng, K "Merit or Family Background? Problems in Research Policy Initiatives in Japan " Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, in press Lester, D (1991) "Suicide across the life span: A look at international trends Life span perspectives of suicide." In Leenars, A (ed ) Life span perspectives of suicide : Time-lines in the suicide process New York : Plenum Press, 71-80 Lewis, C (1995) Educating hearts and mind: Reflections on Japanese preschool and elementary education Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Lewis, C and Tsuchida., I (1997) "Planned educational change in Japan : The case of elementary science instruction " Journal of Educational Policy, 12, 5: 313-331 Lewis, C and Tsuchida, I (1998) "The basics in Japan : The three C's" Educational Leadership, March, 32-37 Lincicome, M (1995) Principles, praxis, and the politics of educational Reform in Meiji Japan Honolulu : University of Hawai'i Press Loupe, D and Shepard, G (1993) "Guns at school: A common sight for students." The Atlanta Constitution, April 13: I Lynn, R (1988) Educational achievement in Japan: Lessons for the West Armonk, New York: M.E Sharpe Macl.eod, J (1987) Ain 't no makin ' it Boulder, Westview Press Marcus, G E., and Fischer, M M J (1986) Anthropology as cultural critique Chicago : University of Chicago Press McClelland, D C (1961) The achieving society Princeton: Van Nostrand References 157 McClelland, D C., Atkinson , J W., Clark, R A., and Lowell , E L (1953) The achievement motive New York: Appleton -Century-Crofts McPartland, J (1990) "Staffing decisions in the middle grades: Balancing quality instruction and teacher student relations," Phi Delta Kappan, 71, (6),465-469 McCartney, J (1971) Pp 383-397 in The phenomenon of sociology : A reader in the sociology of sociology E Tiryakian (ed.) New York : AppletonCrofts Meyer, J., and Baker, D (1996) "Forming American educational policy with international data : Lessons from the sociology of education." Sociology of Education, Extra, 123-30 Meyer, J and Rowen, B (1977) "Institutionalized organizations: formal structure as myth and ceremony," American Journal ofSociology ,83 Meyer, J., Scott, W R and Deal, E (1983) "Institutional and technical sources of organizational structure: Explaining the structure of educational organizations," in J Meyer and W R.Scott (eds.) Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Miller, R A.(l982) Japan 's modern myth: The languag e and beyond New York: Weatherhill Miyagi, K (1988) "The high school selection process in middle schools." Issues in Modem Japanese Sociology, March, 29-47 Monbusho (1990) Nihon KyOiku Nenkan (Statistical Yearbook of Education) Tokyo: Gyosei Nagoya, S (1996, July 15-21) "Gov't promoting policies to attract foreign students " The Japan Times Weekly International Edition, 10 National Center for Education Statistics (1992) Digest of Educational Statistics Washington, DC: U.S Government Printing Office National Edu cational Goals Panel (1995) Data Volume for the national educational goals report Washington, DC: U.S Government Printing Office Nitobe, I (1923) "The teaching and use of foreign languages in Japan." Sewanee Review, 31, 338-39 Noblit, G and Hare, R D (1988) Meta-ethnography: synthesizing qualitative studies Newbury Park : Sage Publications Ohanian, S (1987) "Notes on Japan from an American schoolteacher." Phi Delta Kappan, 68 (5), 360-367 Okamoto, Y., Calfee, R., Varghese, S., and Chambliss, M (1991) "A cross cultural comparison of textbook designs." Paper presented at the Annual 158 References Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Washington, D.C Okano, K (1993) School to work transition in Japan Philadelphia: Multilingual Matters Ltd Okano, K (1995) "Rational decision making and school-based job referrals for high school students in Japan." Sociology ofEducation, 68 (1), 31-47 Pasin, H (1965) Society and education in Japan New York: Teachers College Press Peak, L (1989) "Learning to become part of the group: The Japanese child's transition to preschool life." Journal ofJapanese Studies 15 (1),93-124 Peak, L (1991) Learning to go to school in Japan: The transition from home to preschool life Berkeley: University of California Press Peck, D and Warner, K (1995) "Accident or suicide? Single-vehicle car accidents and the intent hypothesis," Adolescence, 30 (118), 463-472 Ramirez, R and Meyer, J (1981) "Comparative education: Synthesis and agenda." In Short, J (ed.) The State of Sociology: Problems and Prospects Beverly Hills CA: Sage, 215-238 Ravitch, D (1986) "Japan's smart schools." The New Republic, 194,13-15 Reischauer, E (1988) The Japanese today: Change and continuity Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press Roden , D (1980) Schooldays in imperial Japan Berkeley: University of California Press Rohlen, T P (1976) "Violence at Yoka High SchooL" Asian Survey, 16 (7) , 682-699 Rohlen, T.P (1977) "Is Japanese Education becoming Less Egalitarian?" Journal ofJapanese Studies Winter, 37-70 Rohlen, T P (1983) Japan's high schools Berkeley: University of California Press Rohlen, T., and LeTendre, G (1996) Teaching and learning in Japan New York: Cambridge University Press Rotberg, I (1990) "I never promised you first place." Phi Delta Kappan, December, 296-303 Russell, J (1992) "Race and reflexivity: The black other in contemporary Japanese mass culture." In Marcus, G (ed ), Rereading cultural anthropology Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 296-318 Sanger, D (1993) "Student's killing displays dark side of Japan schools." New York Times, April 3, A-I Sarason, S (1982) The culture of the school and the problem of change Boston: Allyn and Bacon References 159 Sato, N (1991) Ethnography of Japanese elementary schools: Quest for equality Unpublished doctoral dissertation School of Education Stanford: Stanford University Press Sato, N (1996) "Honoring the Individual." In Rohlen, T and LeTendre G Teaching and Learning in Japan New York, Cambridge University Press, 119-153 Sato, N., and McLaughlin, M (1992) "Context matters: Teaching in Japan and in the United States." Phi Delta Kappan, 73 (5), 359-366 Sato, S (1987) Causal attributions by Japanese and Japanese-American mothers and children about school performance Unpublished doctoral dissertation School of Education, Stanford University Schaub, M and Baker, M (1991) "Solving the math problem : Exploring mathematics achievement in Japanese and American middle grades " American Journal ofEducation, 99 (4), 623-642 Schoolland, K (1990) Shogun's ghost: The dark side of Japanese education New York: Bergin and Garvey Schoppa, L J (1991) Education reform in Japan: A case of immobilist politics New York: Routledge Scott, W R.(1987) "The adolescence of institutional theory," Administrative Science Quarterly 32,493-511 Shirnahara, N (1984) "Towards the equality of a Japanese minority: The case of Burakumin." Comparative Education, 20 (3), 339-53 Shimahara, N and Sakai, A (1995) Learning to teach in two cultures New York: Garland Shimizu , H (1986) Hito no tsunagari (Interpersonal communication as Japanese children's cultural context for learning and achievement motivation ) Unpublished qualifying paper Harvard University Graduate School of Education Cambridge, MA Shimizu, H (1993) Adolescents in a Japanese school: An ethnographic approach to achievement, morality and behavioral inhibition Unpublished doctoral dissertation Harvard University Graduate School of Education Cambridge, MA Shimizu, H (1996) "Individual differences in the Japanese school system." In The educational system in Japan: Case study findings Unpublished manuscript Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Center for Human Growth and Development Shoji, M (1966) "Frobelians in Japan." Education in Japan, 1,54-65 Simons, C (1987) "Kyoiku Mama: Secret of Japan's schools." Readers Digest, July, 117-119 160 References Singleton, J (1967) Nichu: A Japanese school New York : Holt, Rinehart, & Winston Singleton, (1989) "Gambaru: A Japanese cultural theory of learning." In Shields, J (ed.) Japanese Schooling University Park : Pennsylvania State University Press, 8-15 Singleton, J (1989) "Japanse folkcraft pottery apprenticeship: Cultural patterns of an educational institution apprenticeship" in Coy, M (ed.) From theory to method and back again Albany, New York : State University of New York Press , 13-30 Smith, R (1992) "The cultural context of Japan's political economy," In Kumon, S and Rosovsky, H (eds ), The political economy of Japan Volume 3: Cultural and social dynamics Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press, 13-3 I) Sonmucho Seishonen Taisaku Honbu (1990) Seishonen Hakusho; Tokyo : Government Print ing Office Sonrnucho Seishonen Taisaku Honbu (1993) Se i shone Hakush o ; Tokyo : Government Printing Office Sonmucho Seishonen Taisaku Honbu (1997) S e i shone Hakusho ; Tokyo : Government Printing Office Stack, S (1996) "The Effect of the medi a on suicide: Evidence from Japan, 1955-1985," Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, 26 (2), 132-142 Statistics Bureau (1996) Japan statistical yearbook Tokyo: Management and Coordination Agency Stedman, L (1994) "Incomplete explanations: The case of U.S performance in the international assessments of education," Educational Researcher, 22 (7),24-32 Stevenson, D., and Baker, D (1992) "Shadow education and allocation in formal schooling: Transition to university in Japan " American Journal of Sociology, 97 (6),1639-1657 Stevenson, H and Stigler, J W (1992) The learning gap: why our schools are failing and what we can learn from Japanese and Chinese education New York : Summit Books Stigler, J W., and Perry, M (1988) " Mathematic s learning in Japanese, Chinese, and American classrooms." In Saxe, G and Gearhart, M (eds ), Children 's mathematics San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Stigler, J and H Stevenson (1991) "How Asian teachers polish each lesson to perfection," American Educator, Spring : 12-47 Stigler, J., et al (1996) "Cultures of mathematics instruction in Japanese and American elementary classrooms," In Rohlen, T P and Le'Tendre, G References 161 (eds) Teaching and learning in Japan New York, Cambridge University Press : 213-247 Stigler, J and Hiebert, J (1997) "Understanding and improving mathematics instruction: An overview of the TIMSS video study." Phi Delta Kappan, 79, 1: 14-21 Strauss, V and Brown, D (1995) Washington Post Washington, D.C.: AI Tobin, J., Wu, D Y., and Davidson, D H (1989) Preschools in three cultures: Japan, China and the United States New Haven, CT: Yale University Press Torney -Purta, J (1986) "Civic values learned in school: Policy and practice in industrialized nations." Comparative Education Review, 30 (1), 30-49 Trelfa, D (1994) Educating the Working-Class: Perceptions of Relevance of Schooling among Japanese Vocational High School Students Unpublished doctoral dissertation Department of Sociology, University of Michigan Tsuchimochi, G (1993) Education reform in postwar Japan, the 1945 U.S Education Mission Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press Tsuchida, I (1993) Teachers ' motivational and instructional strategies: a study offourth grade U.S and Japnese classrooms Unpublished doctoral dissertation University of California, Berkeley Graduate School of Education Tsuchida, I and Lewis , C (1996) "Responsibility and learning: Some preliminary hypotheses about Japanese elementary classrorns." In T Rohlen, T and Le'Tendre, G (eds.), Teaching and learning in Japan New York: Cambridge University Press, 190-212 Tsukada, M (1991) Yobiko life: A study of legitimat ion process of social stratification in Japan Berkeley: Institute of East Asian Studies Tyack , D and Cuban, L (1995) Tinkering toward Utopia: A century ofpublic school reform Cambridge: Harvard University Press Umakoshi , T (1991) " The role of education in preserving the ethnic identity of Korean residents in Japan " In Beauchamp, E (ed.) Windows on Japanese Education New York: Greenwood Press: 281-290 U.S Department of Education (1983) A nation at risk: The imperative for educational reform Washington, D.C.: Superintendent of Documents U.S Department of Education (1987) Japanese education today Washington, D.C.: Superintendent of Documents Vogel, E (1979) Japan as Number One Cambridge , MA: Harvard University Press 162 References Wagatsuma, H., and DeVos, G (1984) Heritage ofendurance: Family patterns and delinquency formation in urban Japan Berkeley: University of California Press Weisman , S (1991) "Deaths at School in Japan put focus on Rules" New York Times, August 4, 13 Westbury, I (1992) "Comparing American and Japanese achievement: Is the United States really a low achiever." Educational Researcher, 21 (5), 1824 Westbury, I (1993) "American and Japanese achievement Again : A response to Baker" Educational Researcher, 22 (3), 18-20 White, M (1987) The Japanese educational challenge: A commitment to children New York: The Free Press White , M (1988) The Japanese overseas : Can they go home again? New York: The Free Press White, M (1993) The material child New York: Free Press Whiting, B., & Whiting, J (Eds.) (1975) Children of six cultures: A psycho cultural analysis Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press Whiting , R (1990) You gotta have wa New York: Vintage Books Wolcott, H (1967) A Kwakiutl village and school Prospect Heights,IL: Wavel and Press, Inc Wolferen, K V (1989) The enigma ofJapanese power London: Macmillan Woronoff, J (1991) Japan as anything but number one Armonk, NY: M.E Sharpe Wray, H (1991) "Change and continuity in modern Japanese educational history : Allied occupational reforms forty years later." Comparative Education Review, 35, (3), 447-475 Wysocki, B., Jr (1986) "Despite global role, many Japanese try to avoid foreigners." Wall Street Journal, November 13, I Yamazumi, M (1989) "State control and the evolution of ultranationalistic textbooks." In J J Shields, Jr , Japanese schooling: Patterns of socialization University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press Yang, H (1993) The teacher 'sjob: A comparison of U.S and Japanese middle school teachers Stanford University: School of Education Yoshirnatsu, K (1992) "Suicidal Behavior in Japan Suicidal Behaviour in the Asia-Pacific Region." In Peng, K.L and Tseng, W S (eds.) Suicide in the Pacific Region Singapore: National University of Singapore Press Young, M (1993) "The dark underside of Japanese education." Phi Delta Kappan , October, 130-132 References 163 Zeng, K (1996) "Prayer, luck, and spiritual strength: The Desecularization of entrance examination systems in East Asia." Comparative Education Review, 40 (3), 264-279 Zeng, K and LeTendre, G (1998) "Adolescent suicide and academic pressure in East Asia." Comparative Education Review, 42, 4:513-528 Zimmerman, M (1985) Dealing with the Japanese Boston, MA: George Allen and Unwin List of Contributors David Baker David Baker is Professor of Education Policy Studies at the Penn State University, and received his Ph.D from Johns Hopkins University He is the author of many works on comparative and international education and is a leading authority on the analysis of international test score data He is Principal Investigator on 1.8 million dollar grant from the National Science Foundation and Fund for the Improvement of Education Grant to re-analyze the TIMSS data Recent publications include Baker, D (1994) "In comparative isolation: Why comparative research has so little influence on American sociology of education." Research in Sociology ofEducation and Socialization 10, 53-70 Baker, D (1997) "Good news, bad news, and international comparisons: Comment on Bracey" Educational Researcher, 26 (3), 16-18 Baker, D (1998) "Surviving TIMSS Or, everything you blissfully forgot about international comparisons " Phi Delta Kappan, December, 295-300 Gerald K LeTendre Gerald LeTendre, Assistant Professor of Education Policy Studies at the Penn State University, received his bachelors' degree from Harvard University, and his M.A and Ph.D from Stanford University In addition to his own ethnographic studies of U.S and Japanese schools, Dr LeTendre worked for three years in California classrooms conducting teacher and student observations using structured observation instruments He has also worked on both the TIMSS Case Study Project (as a primary field researcher) and the lEA Civic 165 166 List of Contributors Education Case Study Project Recent publications include LeTendre , G., Rohlen, T., and Zeng, K (1998) "Merit or family background? Problems in research policy initiatives in Japan." Educational Evolution and Policy Analysis 20(4): 285-297 Catherine C Lewis Catherine C Lewis, a developmental psychologist, is a senior researcher and formative research director at the Developmental Studies Center in Oakland, California She has conducted both ethnographic and intervention research in a variety of institutional settings, including schools, hospitals, and child care centers; her studies focus on the ways institutions promote (or fail to promote) children 's social and intellectual development She speaks and reads Japanese ; her book Educating Hearts and Minds: Reflections on Japanese Preschool and Early Elementary Education (Cambridge University Press, 1995) was named an outstanding academic book of 1995 by the American Library Association's Choice Currently she directs a study of the shift from transmission-focused to student-centered science education in Japanese elementary schools ("Innovations in Science Education: Learning from Case Studies" NSF grant REC-9355857) and directs formative research on the Child Development Project, a multi-district U.S school reform project designed to help schools promote children's fulllest intellectual, social and ethical development David McConnell David McConnell, Associate Professor of Sociology and Anthropology at the College of Wooster, is the leading expert on internationalization in Japanese education He received his B.A from Earlham College and his M.A and Ph.D from Stanford University He has published numerous works on English teaching efforts in Japan His book on Japan's internationalization efforts, Importing Diversity, is due to be published this summer by the University of California Press Hidetada Shimizu Hidetada Shimizu, Assistant Professor of Educational Psychology at Northern Illinois University, is a cultural psychologist trained in comparative human development at the Harvard Graduate School of List of Contributors 167 Education His research interests are in the acculturation of individuals, sociocultural influences on individual development, learning processes, and schooling experience He is also interested in cultural conceptions of and strategies for dealing with students' ability differences His professional mission is to examine critically the reductionistuniversalistic assumptions inherent in Western academic psychology, and recast them from the perspective of Japanese and Western individuals' real-life experience Currently he teaches a course in qualitative research methods (i.e., ethnography) His recent publications include : Shimizu, H (1998) Individual differences and the Japanese education system In The educational system in Japan: Case study findings Office of Educational Research and Improvement U.S Department of Education Ineko Tsuchida After being educated through university in Japan, Ineko Tsuchida earned a doctorate in education from the University of California, Berkeley Since 1990, she has conducted research in Japanese and U.S elementary schools She is the author or co-author of articles on Japanese elementary education, and has translated, edited and produced videotapes of Japanese lessons and elementary classroom life for use by American educators Recent works include Tsuchida, I and Lewis, C (1996) "Responsibility and learning : Some preliminary hypotheses about Japanese elementary classrooms," in Rohlen, T and LeTendre, G Teaching and learning in Japan New York: Cambridge University Merry Isaacs White Merry I White is professor of anthropology and sociology at Boston University, and associate in research at Harvard University's Edwin O Reischauer Institute of Japanese Studies A graduate of Harvard College (in anthropology), she received a master 's degree in comparative literature and a doctorate in sociology from Harvard University She has served as administrator of the East Asian Studies program at Harvard, as director of international education at Harvard 's Graduate School of Education, and has consulted with a wide range of educational and corporate institutions, as well as to the United States Congress Her research and publications have focused on Japanese education, family and social issues in Japan, adolescence and popular 168 List of Contributors culture, internationalization and population change Her current work is on changing families in Japan, and on food and social change in Asia Her recent publications include: White, M 1., & Barnet, S (1995) Comparing cultures Bedford Books White, M (1993) The material child: Coming ofage in Japan and America Free Press Una Yang Hua Yang received her B.S from Beijing Normal University and her Ph.D from Stanford University She has conducted extensive research on teachers' lives and work roles in U.S and Japanese schools She is currently Principal Evaluator for the Dallas Public Schools ' Division of Research Kangmin Zeng Kangmin Zeng received his B.A from Tianjin Finance and Economics University and his Ph.D from Stanford University He served in the Chinese foreign service before entering academics He has written several works on entrance examination, including his book The Dragon Gate His recent publications include "Prayer, Luck and Spiritual Strength: The Desecularization of Entrance Exam Systems in East Asia." Comparative Education Review, August, 1996 Index ALT See Japanese Exchange and Teaching Program ability, xvii, 18-19,78 academic achievement, xix, 4, 18-19,65-81, 83, 142 competition, 12,48,80, 123, 143 access to education, 11 adolescence, 11,20,68,72-73, 106 adolescent health, 15, 20, 22, 106 arts, 12 Behavioralism, 44 Better Homes and Gardens, bullying, xxi, 14,71-72,79, 113-117, 142 burakumin, xix, 22, 48-49 child mental development of, 26, 43-45 , 77 social development of, 10,28,34, 36,38,74,76,145 rearing, 18, 142 class size, 94-95 time, 29, 87-88,92 classroom instruction, 11, 18-19,20,41, 78, 89, 92-93 management, 11,44 routines, 27-28, 30-31, 41-44 comparative education, 119, 120-131, 133-135 Confucian influence, xii, xv, 12 Constructivism, 44 cooperation, 26, 34-36, 67 cram school See juku creativity, xv, 10-12, 120 curriculum, 30-36, 92-94 Democracy and Education, 125 dowa education, xix drug abuse, 117-119 Education Week, 12 educational criticism, 19-21 goals , 20 myth , 7,141 -148 policy, 20, 53, 60-64, 134-136 reform, xi, 12,53-56 , 100, 128-129, 144,147 stereotypes, xiv, 13 values, xxi, 11, 43-45, 54, 75-77, 84, 125-127,133, 137, 143, 145 Educational Researcher, 6-7 effort, xix, 18-19 economic competition, xi, xii, xxi, 3, 130-31 elementary schools, 11, 17,26-27, 115 EFL (English as a Foreign Language), 169 170 49-52 ,93 enrollment rates, entrance exams , 9, 11, 12 ethnocentrism, 13,62-63 ethnography, 7, 15,63,80-81, 136 exam hell, 12,23, 120 extracurricular activities , 90, 93-94 family relations , 19 FIMS (First International Math Study), Fourth -grade achievement, 6, 20 gangs, 116 gender differences, 34, 57, 70-71, 115 German schools , 124-126 GOALS 2000, groupwork, 27-28, 36, 42 hansei ,42, 143, 146 high school, higher-order thinking, 34, 36, 40 human capital, xi, 3-5 human relations, 43-45, 70, 76-79 identity development, 15,67-73 individualism, xiv, 35, 66, 69, 84 intelligence, xiii, 18-19, 136 international test scores, 3, 5-8, 9, 119120,135 accuracy of, 5-6, 21 political uses of, 6-8 internationalization, 49, 52, 55 Japan, Inc., 15 The Japanese Educational Challenge, xiii Japanese Exchange and Teaching Program, 53-64 Japanese society images of, xii, x v, 141-148 changes in, 67, 106 role of school in, 120-121, 142 Japanese Teacher's Union, 111 JET See Japanese Exchange and Teaching Program JTU See Japanese Teacher's Union juku , xix, 9, 11,26,50,98-99 Index juvenile delinquency, xiv, 16,71 Koreans, 48-49 learning rote, xiv theories of, 66-67, 73-79, 80, 84 The Learning Gap, 5, 16 lesson plans, 29-30 The Manufactured Crisis, 12, 49, 103 maternalism, 14 Marshall Plan, 128 math achievement, 20 education, 10, 145 media images of Japan, 13, 16, 110-111, 116,132 reports on school problems, 13,27, 79,112-113,116, 147 meritocracy, 10, 17 Mexican schools , 131 middle schools , 8,19,84-101 Ministry of Education, 11, 52-53 minorities, xx, 15,22,48-49,55 Mombusho See Ministry of Education modernization, xvi, 66 moral education, 76-77, 89, 94 mother-child relationship, 18 motivation, 38, 43, 66-67 A Nation at Risk, xiv national curriculum See national standards National Enquirer, xi national standards, 6, 12, 31-33, 95-96, 126,144 nihonjinron, xvi, 49 peer pressure, 70, 115 Phi Delta Kappa, political competition, 131-134 preschool, 74, 76, 126, 146 problem solving, 10 psychological theories, 19, 65-67 171 Index PTA (Parent-Teacher Association), 59, 138 recess, 29 reflection See hansei responsibility, xviii, 29, 33, 38, 43 returnees , 13, 48 school advancement, 8, 11,48 failure, 25, 133 hierarchy, xix, 10 organization, 8-9, 14 refusal, 146 rules, xix, 11,67 social class differences and, 11, 1617 violence, 18, 108-110, 112-113 school-to-work transition , 9, 17 science education , 27-28, 32-33, 130, 133, 144 self, 70, 73 self-esteem, 67-72 Shogun's Ghost, 13, 110 Sputnik, xv, 129-130, 133 standardization, student responsibility, 27 substance abuse See drug abuse suicide, 15, 105-108, 120, 141, 146 teachers, 11, 13,36-41,84-101 lives, 14,78-79,92 working conditions, 87-91, 97 workload, 89,91-92 teacher training schools, II textbooks, 32, 98 TIMSS See Third International MathScience Study Tinkering Toward Utopia, 147 Third International Math-Science Study, xi, analysis of, 4, 135 case study project, 21, 138 critiques, 137 video study, 138 tracking, 9, 78 unemployment, 21 universities, xv, 124, 126 and feeder school, U.S Educational Mission to Japan, 138 U.S educational policy, 133-136 weapons, 115 whole-class instruction, 42 World War II, 127-128, 132 .. .COMPETITOR OR ALLY? R EF EREN C E BOOKS IN INT ERNATIONAL EDU CATION V OLUME 45 GARLAND R E F E R E N C E LIBRARY OF S O C I A L S CI ENCE VOLUME 140 COMPETITOR OR ALLY? JAPAN''S ROLE IN AMERICAN. .. emanating from reform committees and councils are noted by their vague good intentions, "giving top priority to instilling respect for children''s individuality" and "increasing opportunities for... either nonverbally (e.g., by waiting for students to look at them or by pointing at a student) or verbally (e.g., by stating what students were expected to or by counting while waiting for students