Revision of concrete performance at elevated temperatures: A critical review and initial results

In this paper, some major influencing factors and spalling of concrete at elevated temperatures will be first reviewed. Limitations of current test setups for fire test, with a focus on the questionable reliability of thermal boundary condition and deformation capturing, will then be discussed to highlight the need for improved setups.

ISSN 1859-1531 - TẠP CHÍ KHOA HỌC VÀ CƠNG NGHỆ ĐẠI HỌC ĐÀ NẴNG, SỐ 5(126).2018, Quyển 33 REVISION OF CONCRETE PERFORMANCE AT ELEVATED TEMPERATURES: A CRITICAL REVIEW AND INITIAL RESULTS ĐÁNH GIÁ LẠI SỰ LÀM VIỆC CỦA BÊ TƠNG Ở ĐIỀU KIỆN NHIỆT ĐỘ CAO: PHÂN TÍCH CHUN SÂU VÀ CÁC KẾT QUẢ BAN ĐẦU Quang Xuan Le1,2, Dinh Ba Le1,2, Son Duy Tran1, Vinh The Ngoc Dao1* School of Civil Engineering, The University of Queensland, Australia University of Science and Technology - The University of Danang; quang.le@uq.edu.au; v.dao@uq.edu.au; badinh.le@uq.net.au; duy.tran@uq.net.au Abstract - The performance of concrete at elevated temperatures depends on its mix constituents and proportions as well as their complex physio-chemical transformations during fire exposures In this paper, some major influencing factors and spalling of concrete at elevated temperatures will be first reviewed Limitations of current test setups for fire test, with a focus on the questionable reliability of thermal boundary condition and deformation capturing, will then be discussed to highlight the need for improved setups On that basis, details of a new test setup will be presented It will be shown that the use of radiant burner system and DIC technique with band-pass filter and blue illumination effectively addresses the identified limitations of existing systems: While the radiant burner system allows us to generate known and consistent thermal boundary conditions, the adoption of DIC technique with band-pass filter and blue illumination enables it to reliably capture deformation of concrete surfaces at elevated temperatures in a full-field, non-contact manner With this new test setup established, a comprehensive set of reliable data can now be further collected, forming a solid basis for revising concrete performance in fire, taking into account the effects of temperature and temperature gradients Tóm tắt - Sự làm việc bê tông điều kiện nhiệt độ cao phụ thuộc vào thành phần, hàm lượng cốt liệu cấu thành chuyển hóa phức tạp xảy bê tơng tiếp xúc với lửa Sự bong tróc bề mặt yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến làm việc bê tơng phân tích báo Sau đó, báo nêu bật hạn chế phương pháp thí nghiệm bê tơng nhiệt độ cao bao gồm: độ tin cậy điều kiện biên nhiệt độ, đo đạc biến dạng bê tơng nhiệt độ cao Từ đó, phương pháp thí nghiệm sử dụng hệ thống xạ nhiệt để tạo điều kiện biên nhiệt độ có đồ đồng cao sử dụng hệ thống camera để đo biến dạng bê tông cách không tiếp xúc trình bày Phương pháp thí nghiệm thu thập số liệu đáng tin cậy nhằm đánh giá lại làm việc bê tông nhiệt độ cao có kể đến ảnh hưởng nhiệt độ gradient nhiệt độ Key words - concrete; elevated temperatures; incident heat flux; thermal boundary condition; concrete deformation Từ khóa - bê tơng; nhiệt độ cao; thơng lượng nhiệt; điều kiện biên nhiệt độ; biến dạng bê tông Introduction The outbreak of a fire in buildings and civil engineering structures can lead to severe structural damage, significant loss of content and possible loss of life Adequate design for fire is, therefore, an important and essential requirement in the design process Being the most commonly used construction material, concrete has favorable inherent characteristics with respect to fire: (i) It has low thermal conductivity and high heat capacity; (ii) It is non-combustible; and, (iii) It does not emit smoke or toxic gases High levels of fire resistance for traditional concrete structures can thus generally be achieved by adopting certain member dimensions and cover for reinforcement [1] Nevertheless, concrete also exhibits some less attractive aspects when exposed to elevated temperatures, including degradation of material properties and spalling Consequently, both the load-carrying and separating/ insulating functions of concrete structures could be compromised This paper will first provide an overview of the performance of concrete at elevated temperatures, with a focus on major influencing factors and spalling The paper will then highlight the need to better characterize concrete performance in fire The limitations of conventional furnace tests, regarding both thermal boundary conditions and deformation capturing at elevated temperatures, will be discussed On that basis, an improved test setup that effectively addresses the identified limitations will be presented, together with evidence giving confidence to the reliability of such a new setup Performance of concrete at elevated temperatures 2.1 Factors influencing the fire performance of concrete Key factors affecting the performance of concrete at elevated temperatures can be divided into material and environmental categories, as summarised in Figure Figure Factors influencing fire performance of concrete 2.1.1 Material factors a Concrete ingredients Concrete is a complex composite made from cementitious materials, water, aggregates, and admixtures These 34 Quang Xuan Le, Dinh Ba Le, Son Duy Tran, Vinh The Ngoc Dao component ingredients interact to form hardened concrete that typically consists of three phases: aggregates, hydrated cement paste and the interfacial transition zone between those two phases The behavior of concrete during both heating and cooling process is therefore dependent not only on the physiochemical changes of each individual phase but also on the complex interaction between these changes [2-4] b Concrete strength The initial strength of concrete plays an important role in concrete structure performance at elevated temperatures The change in mechanical properties of concrete at elevated temperatures may differ significantly between normal strength concrete (NSC) and high strength concrete (HSC): The loss of strength due to exposure to elevated temperatures of HSC is typically significantly higher than that of NSC [5-7] c Moisture content Moisture content has been recognized as one of the most important factors that influence the behavior of concrete at elevated temperatures [3, 6, 8-10] If all else is comparable, test specimens with higher moisture content tend to have an increased propensity for spalling mainly due to the higher pore pressures [3, 6, 10] 2.1.2 Environmental factors a Types of test Many studies [5-7, 9-12] have demonstrated that strength of concrete at elevated temperature is affected by the type of test Three types of tests are typically used; stressed test, unstressed test, and unstressed residual test: - In the unstressed test, the unloaded specimen is heated to the target temperature and then loaded to failure while hot - By contrast, in the stressed test, the concrete specimen is heated to the target temperature while under loading The loading is subsequently increased until specimen failure - In the unstressed residual test, the concrete specimen is heated to the target temperature, then allowed to slowly cool to ambient temperature The concrete specimens are then loaded until failure b Target temperatures The performance of concrete at a given target temperature is influenced by the combined and accumulated effects of physio-chemical changes occurring in the concrete Table summarizes the key physiochemical changes of concrete at elevated temperatures Table Major physio-chemical changes of concrete components at elevated temperatures [9] Temperature (°C) 20-80 100 Major physio-chemical changes of concrete components Increase in hydration, slow capillary water loss and reduction in cohesive forces as water expands Marked increase (of up to hundred-fold) in water permeability 80-200 80-850 150 Increase in the rate of loss of capillary water and then physically-bound water Loss of chemically-bound water Peak for the first stage of decomposition of calcium silicate hydrate (CSH) >300 Marked increase in porosity and micro-cracking 350 Break-up of some river gravel aggregates Critical point of water when no capillary water is possible 374 400-600 573 550-600+ Dissociation of Ca(OH)2 into CaO and water α-β transformation of quartz in aggregates and sands Marked increase in ‘basic’ creep c Heating rate – Temperature gradient Different heating rates undoubtedly lead to different temperature and moisture gradients within concrete test specimens, thereby causing different moisture losses, thermal stresses and pore pressures therein Depending on the actual combined effects of these for specific cases, the mechanical properties of concrete specimens subject to faster heating rates can be higher [13, 14] or lower [15] than those subject to slower heating rates Despite such significant effects of heating rates, currently available constitutive models for concrete have largely been derived from standardized tests where temperature gradients within the concrete test specimens is intentionally minimized [16, 17], with the aim of separating, as far as possible, the “material” effects from the “structural” effects [18] Limitations of these constitutive models include: - Mass transfer processes affected by heat are different from typical real fire situations (with higher temperature gradients) because the very slow heating rates not only allow dissipation of heat through the specimen but also slow dissipation of water vapor with minimal pore pressure increase - Components of the model linked with temperature gradients have not been explicitly addressed, nor have the couplings between different processes linked to temperature gradients (including moisture transport, vapor pressure and thermal gradient induced stresses) It is thus questionable whether such constitutive models developed based on tests under minimized temperature gradients are representative of concrete in structures with substantial temperature gradients, as typically the case for those in fire 2.2 Spalling of concrete in fire Spalling is the violent or non-violent breaking off of layers or pieces of concrete from the surface when it is exposed to high and rapidly rising temperature as experienced in fire [19] Notable features of concrete spalling upon heating are highlighted as follows: • There seems a general consensus that spalling is due ISSN 1859-1531 - TẠP CHÍ KHOA HỌC VÀ CƠNG NGHỆ ĐẠI HỌC ĐÀ NẴNG, SỐ 5(126).2018, Quyển to a combination of thermal stresses, pore pressures, and load-induced stresses (Figure 2), although the relative importance of these contributing mechanisms is still debatable [20-22] • Compared to normal-strength concrete, high-strength concrete is subjected to (i) higher thermal stresses because of its greater rigidity and higher coefficient of expansion; and (ii) higher pore pressures due to its lower degree of porosity and permeability that does not readily allow moisture to escape from the heated concrete Accordingly, despite having higher tensile strength, high-strength concrete appears more susceptible to spalling than normal-strength concrete 35 Limitations of conventional fire testing of concrete material and structures 3.1 Establishing reliable thermal boundary condition The increase in temperature in a test specimen is a function of the incident heat flux on the specimen’s surface In conventional furnace tests, this incident heat flux on the test specimen’s surface results from the combination of the convective and radiative heat flux from the gas phase, the radiative heat flux from the furnace walls and possibly also from the other test specimens (Figure 3) • Pore pressure is influenced by concrete permeability, moisture condition, and heating rate o Polypropylene fibers appear very effective in spalling mitigation due to their melting at about 160 oC providing channels for moisture to escape, especially when the pore pressure mechanism governs o The higher the water saturation level at fire exposure, the higher the risk of spalling: It seems thus desirable to dry the concrete after sufficient initial curing to achieve the required strength Figure Schematic of key heat transfer processes in the conventional furnace [26] Through consideration of energy balance at the surface of specimen, the absorbed heat flux at the specimen surface (𝑞𝑠" ) can be approximated as: qs'' = Fg , s  g  Tg4 + hc (Tg − Ts ) −  s  Ts4 (1) where, Fg,s is view factor of the compartment to specimen surface; εg: thermal emissivity of gases; Tg, Ts: temperature of the gas and of specimen surface, respectively (K); σ: Stefan-Boltzmann constant (5.67x10-8 W/m2K4); hc: average convective heat transfer coefficient by both radiation and convection modes of gas (W/m2K) The evolution of 𝑞𝑠" in time and space is thus highly complex, and accordingly very difficult to be controlled accurately and consistently This inconsistent thermal loading imposed on test specimens has serious implications for the case of concrete, where proper characterization of thermal boundary conditions is required [27, 28] Figure Combination of compressive, thermal stress and pore pressure [21, 25] • Spalling results in loss of material, reduction in section size and early exposure of the reinforcing steel to excessive temperatures The reduced performance of a concrete structure due to spalling can render fire design calculations inaccurate and result in significantly reduced levels of fire safety Unfortunately, our current understanding of spalling remains inadequate mainly due to the highly complex nature of the phenomenon [16, 23, 24] and the lack of appropriate test methods to reliably quantify and separate the effects of influencing factors, as discussed further in the next sections Poor definition of 𝑞𝑠" makes it challenging to achieve reliable control of the temperature evolution as well as temperature gradients in test specimens in conventional furnace tests This has contributed to the significant variation in test results regarding both strength deterioration and spalling of concrete upon heating [16, 18] 3.2 Deformation capturing of concrete at elevated temperatures Reliable deformation measurement is required for proper quantification of fire performance of concrete structures Predictive capability of models for many critical properties, including Young’s moduli, stress-strain relationships and load-induced thermal strains, is first and foremost dependent on such reliable deformation capturing 36 Quang Xuan Le, Dinh Ba Le, Son Duy Tran, Vinh The Ngoc Dao However, conventional fire testing generally does not allow reliable direct measurement of deformation and strain of high-temperature concrete It has been shown that measurement of structural displacements and strains has been mostly performed outside the heated zone in previous fire tests of concrete [29] As a result, the validity of models for many critical properties, including Young’s moduli, stress-strain relationships and load-induced thermal strains, remains questionable A major research program is thus ongoing at the University of Queensland to address the above-discussed limitations in testing of concrete at elevated temperatures, thereby allowing collecting reliable data for revision of concrete performance in fire taking on account of the effects of temperature and temperature gradients New test setup with improved thermal boundary conditions and reliable deformation capturing of concrete at elevated temperatures 4.1 Reliable thermal boundary condition A novel test method, by using high-performance radiant burners as shown in Figure 4, has been proposed to establish known and consistent thermal boundary condition on test specimens [30, 31] The radiant burners can be arranged to create a known incident heat flux on different types and sizes of sample surfaces Besides, the intensity of incident heat flux can be adjusted by changing the distance between the radiant burners to sample surfaces This test setup also enables the simultaneous application of thermal loading and other types of loadings, allowing us to test specimens under various stresstemperature paths generate well-defined, homogeneous and reproducible heating regimes on concrete cylinder specimens (Figure 5), enabling us to re-examine the effects of temperature and temperature gradient on mechanical properties and spalling of concrete [32, 33] The good repeatability, consistency, and uniformity of the thermal boundary conditions on test cylinder specimens have been clearly demonstrated [32, 33] 4.2 Deformation capturing of concrete at elevated temperatures A review of major relevant existing methods has shown that the Digital Image Correlation (DIC) technique is one of the most promising techniques for deformation capturing of concrete surfaces at elevated temperatures [34] The question then is how the remaining technical challenges can be adequately addressed to enable such reliable deformation capturing using DIC technique The new setup with radiant burner system allows test specimens to be heated with virtually no smoke, flame or soot particles produced, which greatly facilitates the application of optical measuring techniques In addition, the available open space enables the adoption of noncontact measuring equipment outside the hot environment to capture the deformation of hot areas on sample surfaces Radiant panels Actuator Concrete cylinder Camera with blue filter Blue LED light Camera with blue filter Figure Radiant burners array Figure Test setup for deformation capturing of concrete at elevated temperatures Figure Thermal boundary condition on the cylindrical specimen By adopting this novel testing method, the setup of using four radiant burners has been successfully used to However, a key factor affecting the performance of DIC when using radiant burner system is thermal radiation To overcome this issue, a Midopt BP470 filter is employed to minimise the effect of thermal radiation, together with an EFFI-Lase-Power-CM-C02-465 blue light to enhance the lighting condition (Figure 6) Such use of band-pass filter and blue illumination has proved to be very effective in stabilizing the lighting condition during the whole testing time Initial results demonstrate a good agreement between DIC measurement and data collected from the loading machine, at both ambient and elevated temperatures Figure and show a good agreement between load-displacement curves, deformations captured ISSN 1859-1531 - TẠP CHÍ KHOA HỌC VÀ CÔNG NGHỆ ĐẠI HỌC ĐÀ NẴNG, SỐ 5(126).2018, Quyển by DIC and actuator of three heated concrete cylinders, giving confidence to the reliability of this measuring technique Additional tests will be conducted for further verification Figure Good agreement between load-displacement curves captured by DIC and actuator Figure Good agreement between deformations captured by DIC and actuator Summary and conclusion When subjected to fire condition, concrete undergoes various complex physio-chemical changes Some major influencing factors and spalling of concrete at elevated temperatures are reviewed in this paper Limitations of current test setups for fire testing are then discussed, highlighting the need for new setups with improved thermal boundary condition and deformation capturing of concrete at elevated temperatures On that basis, a new test setup that effectively addresses the identified limitations is briefed: The use of radiant burner system and DIC technique with band-pass filter and blue illumination has allowed us to (i) create known and consistent thermal boundary conditions and (ii) reliably capture deformation of concrete surfaces at elevated temperatures in a full-field, non-contact manner Further work is ongoing to utilize this new test setup to generate a comprehensive set of reliable data, allowing us to revise concrete performance in fire taking on account of the effects of temperature and temperature gradients 37 REFERENCES [1] Australian Standard, AS 3600-2009 Concrete structures 2009, SAI Global Limited: Standards Australia Limited [2] Savva, A., P Manita, and K.K Sideris, Influence of elevated temperatures on the mechanical properties of blended cement concretes prepared with limestone and siliceous aggregates Cement and Concrete Composites, 2005 27(2): p 239-248 [3] Hertz, K.D., Concrete strength for fire safety design Magazine of Concrete Research, 2005 57(8): p 445-453 [4] Sakr, K and E El-Hakim, Effect of high temperature or fire on heavy weight concrete properties Cement and Concrete Research, 2005 35(3): p 590-596 [5] Knaack, A.M., Y.C Kurama, and D.J Kirkner, Compressive strength relationships for concrete under elevated temperatures ACI Materials Journal, 2010 107(2): p 164-175 [6] Kodur, V.K.R and L.T Phan, Critical factors governing the fire performance of high strength concrete systems Fire Safety Journal, 2007 42(6-7): p 482-488 [7] Phan, L.T., Fire performance of high-strength concrete: A report of the state-of-the-art The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), 1996: p 118 [8] Castillo, C and A.J Durrani, Effect of transient high temperature on high-strength concrete Materials Journal, 1990 87(1): p 47-53 [9] Khoury, G.A., Effect of fire on concrete and concrete structures Progress In Structural Engineering And Materials, 2000 2(4): p 429-447 [10] Kodur, V.K.R and R McGrath, Fire endurance of high strength concrete columns Fire Technology, 2003 39: p 73-87 [11] Schneider, U., et al., Recommendation of RILEM TC 200-HTC: Mechanical concrete properties at high temperatures-modelling and applications: Part 2: stress-strain relation Materials and Structures, 2007 40(9): p 855-864 [12] Schneider, U., et al., Recommendation of RILEM TC 200-HTC: Mechanical concrete properties at high temperatures-modelling and applications: Part 1: General presentation Materials And Structures, 2007 40(9): p 841-853 [13] Khoury, G.A., Compressive strength of concrete at hightemperatures - a reassessment Magazine of Concrete Research, 1992 44(161): p 291-309 [14] Sarshar, R and G.A Khoury, Material and environmental-factors influencing the compressive strength of unsealed cement paste and concrete at high-temperatures Magazine of Concrete Research, 1993 45(162): p 51-61 [15] Mohamedbhai, G.T.G., Effect of exposure time and rates of heating and cooling on residual strength of heated concrete Magazine of Concrete Research, 1986 38(136): p 151-158 [16] Phan, L.T., Fire performance of high-strength concrete: A report of the state-of-the-art 1996, The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) p 118 [17] Cheng, F.-P., V.K.R Kodur, and T.-C Wang, Stress-strain curves for high strength concrete at elevated temperatures Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, 2004 16(1): p 84-90 [18] Khoury, G.A., P.J.E Sullivan, and B.N Grainger, Radial temperature distributions within solid concrete cylinders under transient thermal states Magazine of Concrete Research, 1984 36(128): p 146-156 [19] Fédération Internationale du Béton, Fire design of concrete structures: Materials, structures and modelling, in fib Bulletin 38 2008 p 77-90 [20] Bažant, Z.P., Analysis of pore pressure, thermal stress and fracture in rapidly heated concrete, in International Workshop on Fire Performance of High Strength Concrete, NIST SP 919, Gaithersburg, MD 1997 p 155-164 [21] Khoury, G.A., Passive fire protection of concrete structures Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers: Structures and Buildings, 2008 161(3): p 135-145 [22] Hertz, K.D., Limits of spalling of fire-exposed concrete Fire Safety Journal, 2003 38(2): p 103-116 [23] Sanjayan, G and L.J Stocks, Spalling of high-strength silica fume concrete in fire ACI Materials Journal, 1993 90(2): p 170-173 [24] Kalifa, P., F.-D Menneteau, and D Quenard, Spalling and pore pressure in HPC at high temperatures Cement and Concrete 38 [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] Quang Xuan Le, Dinh Ba Le, Son Duy Tran, Vinh The Ngoc Dao Research, 2000 30(12): p 1915-1927 Zhukov, V., Explosive failure of concrete during a fire Joint Fire Research Organisation, 1975 Translation No DT 2124 Yabuki Y., Harada K., and Terai T., Heat transfer in fire resistance test furnace with particular references to gas radiation Proceedings of the 2nd Asia - Oceanian Conference on Fire Science and Technology, 1995: p 262-273 Torero, J., Assessing the performance of concrete structures in fires Concrete in Australia - Special Issue on "Concrete Performance in Fire", 2014 40(3): p 44-49 Bisby, L., J Gales, and C Maluk, A contemporary review of largescale non-standard structural fire testing Fire Science Reviews, 2013 2(1): p 27 McAllister, T., et al., Measurement of temperature, displacement, and strain in structural components subject to fire effects: Concept and candidature approaches, in NIST Technical Note 1768, P.D Gallagher, Editor 2012, Department of Commerce - USA: National Institute of Standards and Technology p 73 [30] Maluk, C., et al., A heat-transfer rate inducing system (H-TRIS) test method Fire Safety Journal, 2016 [31] Le, Q.X., et al., Effects of temperature and temperature gradient on concrete performance at elevated temperatures Advances in Structural Engineering, 2017 Accepted on 03-11-2017 [32] Le, Q.X., A study of temperature gradient effects on mechanical properties of concrete at elevated temperatures, in School of Civil Engineering 2016, MPhil Thesis, The University of Queensland: Brisbane, Australia [33] Maluk, C., Development and application of a novel test method for studying the fire behaviour of CFRP prestressed concrete structural elements 2014, PhD Thesis, University of Edinburgh, UK [34] Le, B.-D., et al., Deformation capturing of concrete structures at elevated temperatures, in Proceedings of the 6th International Workshop on Performance, Protection & Strengthening of Structures under Extreme Loading, PROTECT2017, 11-12 December 2017 2017: Guangzhou (Canton), China (The Board of Editors received the paper on 25/11/2017, its review was completed on 14/12/2017) ... α-β transformation of quartz in aggregates and sands Marked increase in ‘basic’ creep c Heating rate – Temperature gradient Different heating rates undoubtedly lead to different temperature and. .. the rate of loss of capillary water and then physically-bound water Loss of chemically-bound water Peak for the first stage of decomposition of calcium silicate hydrate (CSH) >300 Marked increase... Australian Standard, AS 3600-2009 Concrete structures 2009, SAI Global Limited: Standards Australia Limited [2] Savva, A. , P Manita, and K.K Sideris, Influence of elevated temperatures on the mechanical