The study used Structural Equation Modelling (SEM) to test the proposed research hypotheses. It is found that there are four factors influencing customer satisfaction, including Corporate Image, Security, Service Price, Customer Expectations, Empathy.
AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 DETERMINANTS OF CUSTOMER SATISFACTION IN COMMERCIAL BANKS: A CASE STUDY IN QUANG NAM PROVINCE, VIETNAM Huynh Tan Nguyen1, Nguyen Hoang Hung1 Dong Nai Technology University Information: Received: 18/09/2018 Accepted: 29/03/2019 Published: 11/2019 Keywords: Customer Satisfaction, Structural Equation Modelling (SEM), Commercial Banks ABSTRACT Currently, customer satisfaction is often considered as the sustainable and long-term strategy to expand business operations for any banking institutions Hence, the purpose of this article is to explore and measure factors affecting customer satisfaction in commercial banks via both qualitative and quantitative approaches To collect data, the questionnaire was designed to officially survey 500 customers at nine commercial banks in Quang Nam province, Vietnam Next, the study used Structural Equation Modelling (SEM) to test the proposed research hypotheses It is found that there are four factors influencing customer satisfaction, including Corporate Image, Security, Service Price, Customer Expectations, Empathy Based on the findings, the paper proposed some managerial implications to enhance customer satisfaction in the next period Yet, the study had some limitations, so more studies with alternative methods should be conducted to confirm the results of this study for better policies and practices INTRODUCTION al., 2017) However, today's competitive market has forced banks to only focus on reducing operating cost for gaining short-term high profit instead of improving service quality and enhancing customer satisfaction, which is regarded as a long-term business strategy That’s why exploring determinants of customer satisfaction is presently a popular research topic in research as regards human behavior Doing business in the context of such competitive environment nowadays, customer satisfaction is considered as a main factor affecting business operations of any commercial bank (Colm & Parasuraman, 2017), in which the bank retains customer interest and loyalty Doing so will provide opportunities to widen market share, increase profit and develop business operation sustainably (Hennig & Klee, 1997) Thus, the commercial banks are shifting business strategies towards improvement of customer satisfaction (Yang & Peterson, 2004) Many empirical studies have illustrated that profits and business efficiency only come from satisfying customer expectations and demands (Le Thị Thanh Giang, 2016; Lone, Aldawood, & Bhat, 2017; Wolter et The empirical research of Sirdeshmukh, Deepak, Singh, and Sabol (2002) demonstrates that customer satisfaction is significantly different between the state-owned commercial banks and the private commercial banks with higher satisfaction in the private banks The reasons for this phenomenon may stem from deliverability, accessibility as well as transaction convenience, 42 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 which lead to the advancement of customer service capacity This finding is consistent with the study of Janahi and Mubarak (2017) and Sirdeshmukh et al., (2002) 2.2.1 Corporate image Corporate image may be regarded as “the perceptions of an enterprise” that exists lastingly in consumers' memory, and also helps customers to recognize the difference between the product and service of the organization from their competitors as well (Elgin & Nedunchezhian, 2012) In the opinion of Connor and Davidson (1997), an enterprise with a positive corporate image is likely to lead to attraction of new customers and retain existing ones Because of the current competitive nature of the banking sector nowadays, corporate image plays a crucial role in seeking and attracting new customers, owing to the fact that the more reputable banks will be easy to appeal to new customers Various empirical evidence have suggested that corporate image is a vital factor of customer satisfaction (Johnson et al., 2001) Thus, it is hypothesized as follow: There are presently numerous ongoing empirical researches in the context of the Vietnamese banking industry, yet, descriptive statistics of customer satisfaction instead of testing the relationship among research constructs is one of the main limitations of these studies Furthermore, the other limitation is that the studies are only conducted at one commercial bank, so the results are generally difficult to apply for overall system of commercial banking in Vietnam Hence, this research aims (1) to explore and measure the factors influencing customer satisfaction in commercial banks in Vietnam; (2) from that, to propose effective recommendations to improve service quality as well as boost customer satisfaction LITERATURE REVIEW RESEARCH MODEL H1: Corporate image has a positive influence on customer satisfaction AND 2.2.2 Security 2.1 Customer Satisfaction Cyberattacks in the financial industry, especially the banking sector, are recently increasing more and more seriously when so many recent attacks have become more complex than before (Amin, 2016) The reason may be explained as the quite rapid increase of the quantity of financial transactions and the continued advancement of new technologies in the banking sector (Fabrigar & Wegener, 2011) Therefore, security is an extremely important factor for financial operations Although there is much technological progress towards security namely cryptography, electronic signatures, as well as multi-factor authentication, consumers are still at risk in monetary transactions, particularly online transactions (Hazen et al., 2017) Consequently, if the security is assured, customer satisfaction may increase Several previous studies in retail banks also demonstrate that security is a significant determinant of customer satisfaction Therefore it is hypothesized that: Oliver (2014) states that satisfaction is the understanding of the consumer comparison between the expectation and performance Kotler et al (2009) postulate that satisfaction is “a person's feelings of pleasure or disappointment that results from comparing a product's perceived performance or outcome with his/her expectations” According to Fečiková (2004), satisfaction is the feeling of customers originated from the procedure of assessing what they obtain and what they expect Abdullah and Rozario (2009) emphasize that customer satisfaction may be affected by several various internal and external elements Hence, it's difficult to determine client satisfaction In the opinion of Veloutsou et al (2005), overall customer satisfaction is a moving process and will change the clients’ experience with the service and products that they purchase 2.2 Development of hypothesis 43 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 H2: Security has a positive influence on customer satisfaction expectations Thus, it is worth mentioning that the commercial banks ought to identify customer expectations and to seek to meet their expectations with the aim of maximizing their satisfaction (Jamal & Naser, 2002) Accordingly, the following hypothesis is proposed as: 2.2.3 Service price For a specific bank, the service price is one of the factors of the marketing strategy The marketing perspectives evaluate the service price in the banking sector, especially, from the customer’s point of view The service price is regarded as what customers actually pay for their transactions including the loan interest, the money transfer cost, the other service fees Many recent researches have shown that service price is one of the significant factors influencing service quality and customer satisfaction in the banking industry (Hazen, Boone, Wang, & Khor, 2017) Hence, with this factor, the hypothesis is posited as: H4: Customer expectations have a positive impact on the customer satisfaction 2.2.5 Empathy Empathy refers to the possibility to understand another person’s feelings and experiences within their frame of reference (Kotler, Kartajaya, & Setiawan, 2018) The different types of empathy rely mainly on the range of emotional states, which result in three types of empathy including emotional empathy, somatic empathy as well as cognitive empathy (Levesque & McDougall, 1996) Some researchers have demonstrated role of empathy as an essential part of service quality in any enterprise, and certainly affecting customer satisfaction Many prior studies have postulated that empathy has a direct and considerable effect on re-purchasing behavior of the clients (Tadic et al., 2018; Yang, 2017) Empathy in the banking sector is also reflected through free service capacity, which relates to caring, listening and careful compensation in case of any mistake (Ekiz et al., 2006; Farooq, 2016) Hence, it is hypothesized that: H3: Service price has a positive effect on customer satisfaction 2.2.4 Customer expectations Customer expectations are defined as the perceived value or benefits that the customer perceives before consuming goods or services from providers They may be derived from the “experiencing” process and can also be shaped immediately with even first impressions during purchasing (Cronin Jr et al., 2000; Hult et al., 2017) Once formed, these expectations are hardly to change and are likely to considerably affect clients’ decision-making processes Furthermore, customer expectations might be established from customers' consumption experience in the past and largely depend on the firm's product or service quality as well as promotion strategies and word-of-mouth information (Johnson et al., 2001) Therefore, customers will evaluate the performance efficiency of a bank via their H5: Empathy has a positive impact on customer satisfaction 2.3 Proposed research model Based on the literature review from the previous studies, the proposed theoretical model includes six constructs These are depicted in Fig 2.1 below 44 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Corporate image (F1) (+) Security (F2) (+) Service price (F3) Customer expectations (F4) (+) Customer satisfaction (Y) (+) (+) Empathy (F5) Figure 2.1 Proposed research model in which represented as “strongly disagree” while reflected as “strongly agree” METHODOLOGY 3.1 Measures of the constructs 3.2 Sampling The items used to establish constructs are mainly adapted from prior studies to assure content validity Measures for the independent constructs were taken from Lone et al (2017), Shahin et al (2017), Verhoeven and Sha (2017), Fabrigar and Wegener (2011), Hazen, Boone, Wang, and Khor (2017), Hult et al (2017) Measures of customer satisfaction construct was taken from Fabrigar and Wegener (2011), Lone et al (2017), Verhoeven and Sha (2017), Hazen, Boone, Wang, and Khor (2017) This research used five-point likert scales to collect customer responses for each construct, Hair, Black, Babin, Anderson, and Tatham (2006) suggest that minimum sample size in EFA is 50 observations, and preferably sample size should be 100 or larger and observations/measured variables is 5:1, more acceptable sample size would have a 10:1 ratio From this general rule, this study surveyed 500 customers at 09 commercial banks in Quang Nam province, Vietnam Then, cleaning inappropriate responses, official data was used to analyze as follow: Table The result of survey responses at each bank Valid Frequency Percent Vietcombank 39 8.46 BIDV 34 7.38 MHB 44 9.54 Dong A Bank 37 8.03 45 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Frequency Percent Techcombank 53 11.5 Maritimebank 61 13.23 ACB 73 15.84 VPbank 33 7.16 LienViet Post Bank 87 18.87 461 100 Total 3.3 Data analysis methods After finishing the phase of qualitative research, the official questionnaires are delivered to clients transacting at the commercial banks to collect necessary information for the study Then all data is cleaned missing information, coded, and analyzed through SPSS 22 and AMOS 22 Some techniques are utilized for quantitative research, consisting of: analysis is to explore the most appropriate items from a set of items for a specific construct, in which their internal consistency has been analyzed (Everitt and Dunn, 2001) Everitt and Dunn (2001) and Esbensen et al (2002) state that the standard required in EFA comprising of: (1) Eigenvalue ≥ 1, (2) total variance explained ≥ 50%, (3) Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) ≥ 0.5 and sig coefficient of the KMO test ≤ 5%, (4) factor loadings of observed items ≥ 0.5, (5) difference between the loading of two factors greater than 0.3 Firstly, the study carries out descriptive statistic technique to examine mean, standard deviation, and minimum value and maximum value of observed variables Furthermore, this technique is also exploited to test the difference between controlled variables in proposed research model at a particular significant level Fourthly, the study utilizes Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) to further confirm the unidirectionality, scale reliability, convergence value and distinctive value; next the Structural Modelling Equation (SEM) is use to test research hypothesis According to Hair Jr et al (2016) and Everitt and Dunn (2001), a model is considered consistent with market data if satisfying some criterion, including: (1) significance value of Chisquare test is less than 5%, (2) CMIN/df ≤ (if CMIN/df ≤ is demonstrated best), (3) GFI, CFI, TLI ≥ 0.9 Furthermore, some scholars illustrate that RMSEA ≤ 0.08, GFI should be greater than 0.8, composite reliability (CR) ≥ 0.6 and the average variance extracted (AVE) ≥ 0.5 (Esbensen et al., 2002, Ho, 2006) Additionally, to further confirm the exactness of estimated results, the study utilizes the boostrap technique, which is suggested by Yung and Bentler (1996) Secondly, the reliability of overall measurement scale is tested by Cronbach's alpha, which is a statistical test used to estimate the reliability or internal consistency of a composite scale, originates from the paradigm of (Cronbach, 1951) According to Nunnally and Bernstein (1994) and Hair Jr et al (2016), a scale is considered reliable if Cronbach's Alpha coefficient greater than 0.7 and observed variables have corrected item-total correlation greater than 0.3 Thirdly, exploratory factor analysis (EFA) is carried out to identify trends in the sample data and reduce a set of observed variables by grouping them together (Ho, 2006, Hair et al., 2015) In addition, the aim of applying factor 46 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 RESULTS and the corrected item-total correlations are greater than 0.3 Hence, six constructs and relevant items (exempt from "BM_3", which corrected item-total correlations are smaller than 0.3) are accepted and included in the next analysis 4.1 Scale reliability tests Table 4.1 briefly summarizes the results of scale reliability tests through Cronbach’s Alpha coefficients The overall Cronbach’s Alpha coefficients of all constructs are greater than 0.7 Table 4.1 Scale reliability tests Construct Cronbach's Alpha Corporate image 0.815 Security 0.880 Service price 0.810 Customer expectations 0.786 Empathy 0.871 Customer satisfaction 0.862 4.2 Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) value of 0.000; meaning that, EFA is used appropriately in this study Additionally, the factor loadings are greater than 0.5 and the weight differences among the loadings are greater than 0.3, demonstrating that these observed variables are acceptable for further analysis (exempt from “VC_7”) 4.2.1 EFA for independent constructs Table 4.2 shows that the items of independent constructs are converged on original five constructs with the total variance explained of 61.05%; KMO = 0.946 with the significance Table 4.2 Exploratory factor analysis Independent Constructs Observed variables Corporate image DA_2 0.758 DA_1 0.749 DA_4 0.694 DA_3 0.693 DA_5 0.616 DA_6 0.575 Security VC_1 0.701 VC_2 0.636 VC_4 0.611 VC_3 0.608 47 Service price Customer expectations Empathy AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Independent Constructs Observed variables Corporate image Security VC_5 0.575 VC_6 0.519 Service price Customer expectations Empathy VC_7 TL_1 0.694 TL_2 0.685 TL_3 0.679 TL_4 0.631 TL_6 0.592 TL_5 0.578 GDV_1 0.799 GDV_2 0.698 GDV_3 0.670 GDV_4 0.534 BM_4 0.737 BM_1 0.654 BM_2 0.552 BM_5 0.535 Eigenvalues 11.156 1.7071 1.488 1.1142 1.0194 % of variance 41.317 6.3227 5.5114 4.1267 3.7754 Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity 946 Approx Chi-Square 6434.638 df 351 Sig .000 4.2.2 EFA for “Customer Satisfaction” As shown in Table 4.3, the results of EFA for the scale “Customer Satisfaction” with items illustrates that using EFA in the scale is also appropriate and the items can be used for the next analysis 48 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Table 4.3 EFA for construct “Customer Satisfaction” Customer Satisfaction SHL_3 0.847 SHL_4 0.809 SHL_2 0.798 SHL_5 0.786 SHL_1 0.77 Eigenvalue 3.221 Total variance 64.442 KMOs 0.859 Approx Chi-Square 982.507 df 10 Sig 0.000 4.3 Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) Specifically, Chi-square = 927.132 with 332 degree of freedom; p = 0,000; CMIN/df = 2,793; GFI = 0,875, TLI = 0,9; CFI = 0,912; RMSEA = 0,062 The results from CFA model is assessed via three criteria including unidirectionality, convergence values, composite reliability (CR) and average variance extracted (AVE) Convergence values: Figure 4.1 also shows that the weights of CFA meet required standards that is greater than 0.5 Unidirectionality: Figure 4.1 illustrates that CFA model is suitable with the market data Table 4.4 Confirmatory factor analysis Scale Notation Numbers of items CR AVE Conclusion Corporate image F1 0.865543 0.518827 Accepted Security F2 0.849550 0.531231 Accepted Service price F3 0.816107 0.525269 Accepted Customer expectations F4 0.797496 0.496602 Accepted Empathy F5 0.785127 0.528049 Accepted Customer satisfaction Y 0.817978 0.500277 Accepted 49 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Composite Reliability and Average Variance Extracted: The calculation of CR and AVE in the Table 4.4 indicates that the scales meet criteria in terms of Composite Reliability and Variance Extracted Figure The CFA results of the saturated model 4.4 Analysis of Structural Equation Modelling The results of SEM in Figure 4.2 show that the proposed research model is consistent with the market data Particularly, Chi-square = 845.819; df = 306; p = 0,000; CMIN/df = 2.764; GFI = 0.881; TLI = 0.904; CFI = 0.916; RMSEA = 0.062 50 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Figure Standardized SEM Model The results of hypothesis testing shown in Table 4.5 clearly illustrate that out of research hypotheses are accepted with significant of 5% apart from the third hypothesis Moreover, Boostrap testing with N=1000 also indicates the appropriateness of the results from SEM (Table 4.6) 51 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Table 4.5 Coefficients from SEM Relationship Coefficient S.E C.R P Conclusion Y < - F1 0.172 0.056 3.056 0.002 H1 supported Y < - F2 0.282 0.115 2.461 0.014 H2 supported Y < - F3 0.074 0.089 0.828 0.408 H3 rejected Y < - F4 0.388 0.102 3.81 *** H4 supported Y < - F5 0.305 0.114 2.679 0.007 H5 supported Table 4.6 Boostrap testing with N=1000 Relationship SE SE-SE Mean Bias SE-Bias Y< -F1 0.073 0.002 0.167 -0.005 0.002 Y< -F2 0.168 0.004 0.269 -0.013 0.005 Y< -F3 0.128 0.003 0.067 -0.006 0.004 Y< -F4 0.134 0.003 0.395 0.008 0.004 Y< -F5 0.191 0.004 0.329 0.024 0.006 CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS MANAGERIAL exploratory factor analysis, confirmatory factor analysis, structural equations modelling (5) Bootstrap testing with the help of SPSS 16 and Amos 22 It is found that there are four factors significantly affecting customer satisfaction, consisting of “Corporate Image”, “Security”, “Customer Expectations”, “Empathy” Service Price failed to have a positive impact on customer satisfaction 5.1 Conclusion To improve the competitive capacity in the context of the extremely challenging business environment, the only way for any organization to so especially the commercial banks, is to satisfy customer’s expectations and demands via effective marketing strategies Therefore, this research aims (1) to explore and measure the factors influencing customer satisfaction in commercial banks in Vietnam; (2) from that, to propose effective recommendations to improve service quality as well as boost customer satisfaction To obtain the objectives, research procedure was proposed including (1) propose the theoretical model based on the literature review; (2) apply a qualitative approach to perfect the scale measurement of the constructs and to establish the official questionnaire; (3) survey 500 customers at 09 commercial banks in Quang Nam province of Vietnam; (4) perform data analysis through four techniques referenced from Hair et al., (2006) namely Cronbach's Alpha testing, 5.2 Managerial Implications This research yields several practical implications for the banking sector, policy-makers as well as practitioners Findings from this study posit that Vietnamese commercial banks should focus on the service-oriented strategy for improving customer satisfaction Considering the context of the somewhat rapid growth of banking services in Vietnam, findings of this research are likely to be actually useful for policy-makers and practitioners for better understanding regarding dimensions of the independent constructs In addition, commercial banks ought to educate and train their staff to provide better services with higher empathy, which is illustrated to be of greater 52 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 importance on banking customers The banks need to represent a personal warmth, customized touch in their financial service provision Therefore, the banks should focus on advancing the quality of corporate image along with security Additionally, we highly recommend that commercial banks should ensure the safety of online monetary transfer services, expand their forms of customer service and further upgrade technical maintenance in order to build image of a reliable and safe business unit in the eyes of the customers Journal of Security and Sustainability Issues doi: https://doi.org/10.9770/jssi.2016.5.3(9) Colm & Parasuraman (2017) When Service Customers Do Not Consume in Isolation: A Typology of Customer Copresence Influence Modes (CCIMs) Journal of Service Research, 20(3), 223-239 doi: https://doi.org/ 10.1177%2F1094670517690025 Fabrigar, L R., & Wegener, D T (2011) Exploratory factor analysis: Oxford University Press ISBN: 01-99-81-35-15 Ha Thi Thanh Hai (2016) Improve customer service quality satisfaction at Saigon Commercial Joint Stock Bank - Phu Dong Branch Finance-Banking University of Economics Ho Chi Minh City Retrieved from http://digital.lib.ueh.edu.vn/handle/UEH/4878 5.3 Limitations And Further Research Although this study sheds light on a number of important issues in the banking sector of Vietnam, but some limitations should be considered carefully for further research Firstly, all constructs as well as observed variable were mainly adapted from the prior studies in both Vietnam and worldwide Secondly, owing to limitation of resources and time, this study only employed a convenience sampling technique that regards for slightly biased results (Tadic et al., 2018; Verhoeven & Sha, 2017); thus, future researchers should avoid this limitation by utilizing other sampling methods for better results (e.i Cluster Sampling, Systematic Sampling, Stratified Random Sampling) Finally, sample size of this research was fairly small as compared to the population of the commercial banking industry Hair, J F., Black, W C., Babin, B J., Anderson, R E., & Tatham, R L (2006) Multivariate data analysis (Vol 6): Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall Hazen, B T., Boone, C A., Wang, Y., & Khor, K S (2017) Perceived quality of remanufactured products: construct and measure development Journal of Cleaner Production, 142, 716-726 doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.05.099 Hennig‐Thurau, T., & Klee, A (1997) The impact of customer satisfaction and relationship quality on customer retention: A critical reassessment and model development Psychology & Marketing, 14(8), 737-764 https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)15206793(199712)14:8%3C737::AIDMAR2%3E3.0.CO;2-F REFERENCES Amin, M (2016) Internet banking service quality and its implication on e-customer satisfaction and e-customer loyalty International Journal of Bank Marketing, 34(3), 280-306 doi: https://doi.org/10.1108/IJBM-10-2014-0139 Hill, N., & Brierley, J (2017) How to measure customer satisfaction: Routledge Bachelet, D (1995) Customer satisfaction research Measuring Satisfaction, or the Chain, the Tree and the Nest Hult, G T M., Morgeson, F V., Morgan, N A., Mithas, S., & Fornell, C (2017) Do managers know what their customers think and why? Belás, J., Korauš, M., Kombo, F., & Korauš, A (2016) Electronic banking security and customer satisfaction in commercial banks 53 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 45(1), 37-54 Shahin, A., Mohammadi, S., Harsij, H., & Rahbar Qazi, M R (2017) Revising satisfaction and dissatisfaction indexes of the Kano model by reclassifying indifference requirements: A case study of the presidential elections The TQM Journal, 29(1), 37-54 doi: https://doi.org/10.1108/TQM-05-2015-0059 Jamal & Naser (2002) Customer satisfaction and retail banking: an assessment of some of the key antecedents of customer satisfaction in retail banking International Journal of Bank Marketing, 20(4), 146-160 doi: https://doi.org/10.1108/02652320210432936 Singhal, N., Bala, K., & Sarawgi, S (2018) An empirical study of employee engagement and customer satisfaction in banking sector Journal of Business Thought, 8, 24-41 Janahi, M A., & Al Mubarak, M M S (2017) The impact of customer service quality on customer satisfaction in Islamic banking Journal of Islamic Marketing, 8(4), 595-604 doi: https://doi.org/10.1108/JIMA-07-20150049 Sirdeshmukh, D., Singh, J., & Sabol, B (2002) Consumer trust, value, and loyalty in relational exchanges Journal of marketing, 66(1), 15-37 doi: https://doi.org/10.1509/jmkg.66.1.15.18449 Kotler, P., & Gertner, D (2002) Country as brand, product, and beyond: A place marketing and brand management perspective Journal of brand management, 9(4), 249-261 https://doi.org/10.1057/palgrave.bm.2540076 Stein, C., Morris, N., & Nock, N (2012) Structural equation modeling Statistical Human Genetics (pp 495-512) Berlin (pp 495-512): Springer Le Thi Thanh Giang (2016) Factors affecting customer satisfaction about the quality of personal credit services at Techcombank Can Tho Tay Do University Retrieved from http://115.74.210.103:81/tailieuso/handle/1234 56789/185 Le Tabachnick, B G., & Fidell, L S (2007) Using multivariate statistics (5th ed) Boston, MA, : Allyn & Bacon/Pearson Education Tadic, D., Aleksic, A., Mimovic, P., Puskaric, H., & Misita, M (2018) A model for evaluation of customer satisfaction with banking service quality in an uncertain environment Total Quality Management & Business Excellence, 29(11-12), 1342-1361 doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/14783363.2016.12579 05 Van Hai (2016) Improve customer satisfaction on service quality of Big C-Thanh Hoa supermarket Hue University of economics Retrieved from http://thuvien.hce.edu.vn:8080/dspace/handle/ DHKTHue_123456789/4352 Levesque, T., & McDougall, G H (1996) Determinants of customer satisfaction in retail banking International Journal of Bank Marketing, 14(7), 12-20 doi: https://doi.org/10.1108/02652329610151340 Tran Duc Thuc & Pham Thi Lan Huong (2017) Factors affecting customer satisfaction with ATM card services at Vietnam Joint Stock Commercial Bank for Foreign Trade of Vietnam Vung Tau branch Ba Ria-Vung Tau University Retrieved from http://lib.bvu.edu.vn/handle/TVDHBRVT/162 06 Lone, F A., Aldawood, E., & Bhat, U (2017) Comparative Analysis of Customer Satisfaction towards Islamic and Conventional Banking: An Empirical Study from Saudi Arabia 7(1), 273-280 Retrieved from https://ssrn.com/abstract=2918680 Tran Trong Khue & Le Thuy Kieu (2017) Factors affecting customer satisfaction on retail banking service quality at the Bank for 54 AGU International Journal of Sciences – 2019, Vol (2), 42 – 55 Investment and Development of Vietnam Phu My Branch Ba Ria-Vung Tau University Retrieved from http://thuvienso.bvu.edu.vn/handle/TVDHBR VT/16208 http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/download?doi=10.1 2.563.85678&rep=rep1&type=pdf Wolter, J S., Bock, D., Smith, J S., & Cronin Jr, J J (2017) Creating ultimate customer loyalty through loyalty conviction and customercompany identification Journal of Retailing, 93(4), 458-476 doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jretai.2017.08.004 Ullman, J B., & Bentler, P M (2012) Structural equation modeling Handbook of Psychology, Second Edition, https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118133880.hop20 2023 Yang, Z., & Peterson, R T (2004) Customer perceived value, satisfaction, and loyalty: The role of switching costs Psychology & Marketing, 21(10), 799-822 doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/mar.20030 Verhoeven, P., & Sha, N (2017) A study based on Kano model to improve satisfaction of students at university libraries in Sweden Retrieved from http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:hh:div a-33534 Youssef, M A., Youssef, E M., Anadol, Y., & Zahrani, A A (2017) Modelling customer's intention to use e-banking in Saudi Arabia: an empirical study International Journal of Business Innovation and Research, 14(2), 239258 Webb, I P., & Martin, H D (2017) The effect of banking and insurance on the growth of capital and output (Doctoral dissertation, Georgia State University) Retrieved from 55 ... https://doi.org/10.1108/TQM-05-2015-0059 Jamal & Naser (2002) Customer satisfaction and retail banking: an assessment of some of the key antecedents of customer satisfaction in retail banking International Journal of Bank Marketing,... 09 commercial banks in Quang Nam province, Vietnam Then, cleaning inappropriate responses, official data was used to analyze as follow: Table The result of survey responses at each bank Valid... Singhal, N., Bala, K., & Sarawgi, S (2018) An empirical study of employee engagement and customer satisfaction in banking sector Journal of Business Thought, 8, 24-41 Janahi, M A. , & Al Mubarak,