THE MAKING OF PSYCHOTHERAPISTS AN ANTHROPOLOGICAL ANALYSIS JAMES DAVIES First published 2009 by Karnac Books Ltd 118 Finchley Road London NW3 5HT © James Davies The moral right of the author has been asserted All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced or utilised in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without permission in writing from the publisher British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A C.I.P is available for this book from the British Library ISBN-13: 978-1-85575-656-4 www.karnacbooks.com 298 THE MAKING OF PSYCHOTHERAPISTS Kardiner, A (1939) The Individual and His Society: the psychodynamics of primitive social organization / by Abram Kardiner; with a foreword and two ethnological reports by Ralph Linton New York: Columbia University Press Katz, J (1984) The Silent World of Doctor and Patient New York: Free Press Katz, R (1982) Boiling Energy: community healing among the Kalahari Kung Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press Keller, C and Keller, J D (1993) Thinking and Acting with Iron In: Chaiklin, S and Lave, J (eds.) Understanding Practice: perspectives on activity and context Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Kernberg, O (1986) Institutional Problems of Psychoanalytic Education Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, vol 34 (4): 799-834 Kernberg, O (1996) Thirty Methods to Destroy the Creativity of Psychoanalytic Candidates Int J Psycho-Anal, 77: 1031-1040 Kernberg, O (2006) The Coming Changes in Psychoanalytic Education: Part International Journal of Psychoanalysis 87: 1649-73 Kirsner, D (2000) Unfree Associations: inside psychoanalytic institutes London: Process Press Klein, M (1975 [1952]) Envy, Gratitude and Other Works London: Routledge Klienman, A (1980) Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture Berkeley: University of California Press Kleinman, A (1991 [1988]) Rethinking Psychiatry New York: Free Press Klienman, A., Das, V., and Lock, M (eds.) (1998) Social Suffering Oxford: Oxford University Press Laderman, C (1986) The Ambiguity of Symbols in the Structure of Healing Social Science and Medicine, 24 (4): 293-301 La Fontaine, J S (1985) Initiation London: Penguin Books Lambek, M and Antze, P (2004) Illness and Irony: on the ambiguity of suffering in culture Oxford: Berghahn Larson, M S (1977) The Rise of Professionalism: a sociological analysis Berkeley: University of California Press Larson, M S (1990) In the Matter of Experts and Professionals, or how Impossible it is to Leave Nothing Said In: Torstendahl, R BIBLIOGRAPHY 299 and Burrage, M (eds.) The Formation of Professions: knowledge, state, and strategy London: Sage Lasch, C (1979) The Culture of Narcissim American: life in an age of diminishing expectations New York: Warner Books Lave, J and Wenger, E (1991) Situated Learning: legitimate peripheral learning Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Lave, J and Chaiklin, S (1993) Understanding Practice Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Leach, E R (1954) Political Systems of Highland Burma London: Routledge Levine, F J (2003) The Forbidden Quest and the Slippery Slope: roots of authoritarianism in Psychoanalysis International Journal of Psychoanalysis 85: 13-8 Levi-Struass, C (1967) Structural Anthropology London: Basic Books Lewis, G (1980) Day of Shining Red: an essay on understanding ritual Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Lewis, I M (1977) Symbols and Sentiments London: Academic Press Liberman, B L (1978b) The Role of Mastery in Psychotherapy: maintenance of improvement and prescriptive change In: Frank, J D et al Effective Ingredients of Successful Psychotherapy New York: Brunner/Mazel Little, M (1950) Countertransference and the Patient’s Response to it Int J Psych-Anal, 32: 32-40 Littlewood, R (1980) Anthropology and Psychiatry: an alternative approach Br J Med Psychology, 53: 213-225 Littlewood, R and Lipsedge, M (1987 [1982]) Aliens and Alienists: economic minorities and psychiatry London: Routledge Littlewood, R and Kareem, J (eds.) (1992) Intercultural Therapy: themes, Interpretations and practice Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications Littlewood, R., Jadhav, S., and Raguram, R (1999) Circles of Desire: a therapeutic narrative from South Asia—translation to creolization In: Holmes, J and Roberts, G (eds.) Healing Stories: narrative in psychiatry and psychotherapy Oxford: Oxford University Press Littlewood, R and Dien, S (2000) Cultural Psychiatry and Medical Anthropology: An introduction and reader London: Athlone Press 300 THE MAKING OF PSYCHOTHERAPISTS Lock, M and Scheper-Hughes, N (1996) A Critical-Interpretive Approach in Medical Anthropology In: Sargent, C F and Johnson, T M (eds.) Handbook of Medical Anthropology: contemporary theory and method London: Greenwood Press Losche, D (2001) What Makes an Anthropologist Laugh? The Abelam, Irony, and Me’ In: Fernandez, J and Huber, M T (eds.) Irony in Action Chicago: University of Chicago Press Lousada, J (2000) The State of Mind We Are In British Journal Psychotherapy, 16 (4): 467-76 Luborsky, L B and Luborsky, S (1975) Comparative Studies of Psychotherapy Archives of General Psychiatry, 32: 995-1008 Lurhmann, T (1989) Persuasions of the Witch s Craft London: Blackwell Luhrmann, T (2001) Of Minds: the growing disorder in American Psychiatry New York: Borzoi Books MacClancy, J (2002) Exotic No More: anthropology on the front lines Chicago University of Chicago Press Macdonald, K M (1995) The Sociology of the Professions London: Sage Mechanic, D (1972) Public Expectations and Health Care: essays on the changing organisation of health services New York: Wiley-interscience MacIntyre, A (2001 [1981]) After Virtue London: Duckworth Malcolm, J (2004 [1983]) Psychoanalysis: the impossible profession London: Picador Malinowski, B (1971 [1926]) Myth in Primitive Psychology Westport: Negro Universities Press Malinowski, B (1927) Sex and Repression in Savage Society London: Kegan Paul Marcuse, H (1966 [1955]) Eros and Civilisation Boston: Beacon Press Marmor, J (1962) Psychoanalytic Therapy as an Educational Process: common Denominations in therapeutic approaches of different therapeutic “schools” In: Masserman, J H (ed.) Psychoanalytic Education London: Grune and Stratton Masson J (1984) Against Therapy London: Fontana Press Mayer, L (2003) Subservient Analysis International Journal of Psychoanalysis 84: 1241-62 BIBLIOGRAPHY 301 McDougall, W (1908) Introduction to Social Psychology London: Methuen Mechanic, D (1972) Social Psychological Factors Affecting the Presentation of Bodily Complaints New England Journal of Medicine, 286, 1132-1139 Meed, M (1943) Coming of Age in Samoa: a study of adolescence and sex in primitive societies Harmonsworth: Penguin Miller, A (1994) The Drama of the Gifted Child New York: BasicBooks Mills, C W (2000 [1959]) The Sociological Imagination Oxford: Oxford University Press Morris, B (1996 [1987]) Anthropological Studies of Religion Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Moskowitz, E (1990) In Therapy we Trust: America s obsession with self-fulfilment Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press Needham, R (1983 [1962]) Structure and Sentiment: a test case in social anthropology Chicago: Chicago University Press Nurge, E (1958) Etiology of Illness in Guinhangdan American Anthropologist, 60: 1158-72 Parson, T (1964) Essays in Sociological Theory New York: Free Press Parkin, D (1995) Latticed Knowledge: eradication and dispersal of the unpalatable in Islam, medicine and anthropological theory In: Fardon, R (ed.) Counterworks: managing the diversity of knowledge London: Routledge Parkin, F (1979) Marxism and Class Theory: A Bourgeois Critique New York: Colombia University Press Peck, S (1978) The Road Less Travelled New York: Norton Pedder, J R (1986) Courses in Psychotherapy: evolution and current trends British Journal of Psychotherapy, (2): 203-221 Philips, A (1995) Terrors and Experts Cambridge: Harvard University Press Porter, R and Hinnels, J R (eds.) (1999) Religion, Health, and Suffering London: Kegan Paul International Porter, R (1996) Two Cheers for Psychiatry! The Social History of Mental Disorder in Twentieth Century Britain In: Freeman, H and Berrios, G E (eds.) 150 Years of British Psychiatry Volume II: the aftermath London: Gaskel 302 THE MAKING OF PSYCHOTHERAPISTS Prince, R (1980) Variations in Psychotherapeutic Procedures In: Draguns, H C (ed.) Handbook of Cross-Cultural Psychology: Psychopathology Boston: allyn and Bacon Pulver, S E (1995) The Technique of Psychoanalysis Proper In: Moore, B and Fine, B D (eds) Psychoanalysis: the major concepts New Haven: Yale Uni Press Rapp, D (1988) The Reception of Freud by the British Press: general interest in literary magazines, 1920-1925 Journal of the History of the Behavioural Sciences, xxix: 191-201 Richards, A (1956) Chisungu: a girl s initiation ceremony in Northern Rhodesia London: Faber Rieff, P (1966) The Triumph of the Therapeutic: uses of faith after Freud London: Chatto and Windus Ltd Rivers, W H R (1924) Medicine, Magic and Religion London: Kegan Paul Rivière, P (1984) Individual and Society in Guiana: a comparative study of Amerindian social organisation Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Roberts, J (2003 [1988]) Setting the Frame: definition, functions, and typology of rituals In: Imber-Black, E and Roberts, J (eds.) Rituals and Families in Family Therapy New York: W W Norton and Company Roith, E (1987), The Riddles of Freud: Jewish influences on his theory of female sexuality London: Tavistock Press Rose, N (1990) Governing the Soul: The Shaping of the Private Self London: Routledge Roseman, M (1991) Healing Sounds From the Malaysian Rainforest: Temiar music and medicine Berkeley: University of California Press Roth, A and Fornagy, P (1996) What Works for Whom: a critical review of psychotherapy research London: Gilford Press Rudnytsky, P L (1987) Freud and Oedipus New York: Columbia University Press Ruskin, M (1985) The Social Organisation of Secrets: towards a sociology of psychoanalysis International Review of Psychoanalysis,12: 143-159 Russell, B (1996 [1946]) History of Western Philosophy London: Routledge BIBLIOGRAPHY 303 Russell, D (1986) The Secret Trauma: incest in the lives of girls and women New York: Basic Books Russell, D E H (1983) The Incidence and Prevalence of Intrafamilial and Extrafamilial Sexual Abuse of Female Children, Child Abuse 7: 133-46 Rycroft, C (1995 [1968]) A Critical Dictionary of Psychoanalysis London: Penguin Samuels, A (1989) The Plural Psyche: personality, morality and the father London: Routledge Samuels, A (1993) The Political Psyche London: Routledge Samuels, A (1993) ‘What is Good Training’ British Journal of Psychotherapy 9: Schafer, R (1978) Language and Insight New Haven: Yale University Press Schultz, D P and Schultz, S E (2000) A Modern History of Psychology University of South Florida: Harcourt College Publishers Scheff, T (1979) Catharsis in Healing, Ritual, and Drama Berkeley: University of California Press Seijas, H (1973), ‘El Susto Como Categoría Etiológica’ Acta Cient fica Venezolana, 23: 176-78 Seligman, C G (1924) Anthropology and Psychology: a study of some points of comparison, Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 94: 30-43 Selvini Palazzoli, M., Boscolo, L., Cecchin, G., and Prata, G (1977) The Treatment of Children Through Brief Therapy of Their Parents Family Process, 13 (4): 429-442 Sennett, R (1976) The Fall of Public Man New York: Knopf Seymour-Smith, C (1986) Macmillan Dictionary of Anthropology London: Macmillan Press Sharma, U (1996) Bringing the Body Back into the (Social) Action: techniques of the body and the (cultural) imagination Social Anthropology, (3): 251-263 Sharp, L (1993) The Possessed and Dispossessed: spirits, identity, and power in a Madagascar migrant town Berkeley: University of California Press Shorter, E (1994) (ed.) The Face of Melancholy In: From the Mind into the Body: the cultural origins of psychosomatic symptoms New York: Free Press 304 THE MAKING OF PSYCHOTHERAPISTS Shorter, E (1997) A History of Psychiatry New York: John Wiley and Sons Sinclair, S (1997) Making Doctors: an institutional apprenticeship Oxford: Oxford University Press Skorupski, J (1976) Symbol and Theory Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Smail, M (2001) The Origins of Unhappiness: a new understanding of personal distress London: Robinson Sperber, D (1975) Rethinking Symbolism Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Sperber, D (2005) An Epidemiology of Representations An Interview with John Brockman Available at: www.edge.org/3rd_culture/ sperber05/sperber05_ index.html [Accessed Nov 2005] Spitzer, R L et al (eds.) (1984) International Perspectives on DSM III Washington: American Psychiatric Press Straker, G., Watson, D and Robinson, T (2003) Trauma and Disconnection: a trans-theoretical approach International Journal of Psychotherapy, 7: 145-58 Storr, A (1979) The Art of Psychotherapy London: Heinemann Publishing Storr, A (1989) Freud Oxford: Oxford University Press Szasz, T S (1979) The Myth of Psychotherapy: mental healing as religion, rhetoric and repression Oxford: Oxford University Press Torrey, E F (1986) Witchdoctors and Psychiatrists: the common roots of psychotherapy and its future New York: Harper and Row Turner, V (1967) The Forest of Symbols London: Cornell University Press Tyler, S A (1969) Cognitive Anthropology London: Holt, Rinehart and Winston Valentine, M (1996) The Abuse of Power in the Analytical Setting British Journal of Psychotherapy, 19 (2): 174-181 Van de Hart, O (1993) Rituals in Psychotherapy New York: Harper Collins Wallace, A (1961) Culture and Personality New York: Random House Webb, J., Schirato, T and Danaher, G (2002) Understanding Bourdieu London: Sage Weber, M (1947 [1922]) The Theory of Social and Economic Organisation New York: Oxford University Press BIBLIOGRAPHY 305 Webster, R (1995) Why Freud Was Wrong London: Harper Collins Wienmann, J (1981) An Outline of Psychology as Applied to Medicine Bristol: Wright Whan, M (1999) Registering Psychotherapy as an Institutional Neurosis: or, Compounding the Estrangement Between Soul and World The European Journal of Psychotherapy and Counselling Vol (3) Whiting, B (1950) Paiute Sorcery New York: Viking Bond Whiting, R A (2003 [1988]) Guidelines to Designing Therapeutic Rituals In: Black, I and Roberts, J (eds.) Rituals in Families and Family Therapy New York: W W Norton and Company Whitehouse, H (1995) Inside the Cult: religious innovation and transmission in Papa New Guinea Oxford: Clarendon Press Winnicott, D W (1947) Hate in the Countertransference Int J Psycho-Anal, 30: 69-74 Wittgenstein, L (1946-7) Lectures of the Philosophy of Psychology (Notes taken by Geach, P T.) Oxford: Oxford University Press Yalom, I D (2001) The Gift of Therapy London: Piatkus Books Young, A (1983) The Relevance of Traditional Medical Cultures to Modern Primary Health Care Social Science and Medicine, 17: 1205-11 Young, R (1996a) The Culture of British Psychoanalysis Available from: http://human-nature.com/culture/paper5h.html [accessed Dec 2004] Young, R (1996b) The Psychodynamics of Psychoanalytic Organisations Presented at the conference for the International Society for the Psychoanalytic Study of Organisations in New York City, 15 June 1996 Available at: http://www.sba.oakland.edu/ ispso/html/young.html [accessed Dec 2004] Zatzick, D F and Johnson, F A (1997) Alternative Psychotherapeutic Practice Among Middle Class Americans: some conceptual comparisons Culture, Medicine, and Society, 21: 213-246 111 10 711 20 511 311 911 REFERENCES 111 711 10 211 30 911 307 INDEX Abram, J., 57, 63, 278, 283, 290 abuse, 138, 149, 160, 164, 189 child, 48, 69, 149–150, 169, 283 sexual, 48, 149–150, 152, 160, 283 aetiology, 13, 32, 146–148, 151, 153–154, 166, 170, 173–175, 177–178, 180–181, 200, 219, 238, 252, 284–285 ambivalence, 66, 86–87, 155, 162 American Psychiatric Association, 45 Anderson, B G., 175–176, 293 anger, 69, 87, 157–159, 178 Antze, P., 84–85, 275, 298 Ashurst P., 189, 290 Association of Child Psychotherapists, 27 Association of Psychotherapists, 27, 270 Auchincloss, E L., 16, 290 Auden, W H., 29, 290 Bandura, A., 194, 199, 290 Barth, F., 106, 290 Bass, A., 277, 290 Bateson, G., 3, 290 Bayer, R., 50, 290 Becker, H S., 11, 16–17, 185, 255, 266, 291 Benedict, R., 3, 29, 282, 291 Berger, P L., 26, 243–244, 246–247, 267, 291 Berman, E., 16, 291 Blaxter, M., 176, 283, 291 Bleger, J., 276, 291 Bloch, M., 3, 291 Boscolo, L., 88, 303 Bourdieu, P., 7, 9, 11, 255, 267, 285, 291 Breuer, J., 277, 294 British Association of Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP), 37, 269–270 British Association of Psychotherapists (BAP), 36, 40, 103, 144, 254, 261, 265, 270, 278, 281–282 307 308 111 10 711 20 511 311 911 INDEX British Confederation of Psychotherapists (BCP) see British Psychoanalytic Council (BPC) British Psychoanalytic Council (BPC), 17, 20, 22, 34, 37, 39–43, 49, 56, 127, 144, 258, 263, 270–271, 280, 286 British Psychoanalytic Society, 21, 27, 141, 261 see also: Institute of Psychoanalysis Brown, B S., 45, 291 Bruzzone, M., 15, 267, 291 Calestro, K., 63, 194, 203–204, 286, 291 Campbell, J., 277, 291 Casaula, E., 15, 267, 291 case study Arya, 13, 154–172, 180, 283 Casement, P., 239, 276, 291 Cassel Hospital, 28 Cassell, J., 183, 195, 266, 285, 291 Cecchin, G., 88, 303 Chaiklin, A., 266–267, 291 Chaiklin, S., 266–267, 291, 299 Charny, I W., 189, 192–193, 292 cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), 31, 49, 62, 144, 155, 166, 270, 272, 275 Collingwood, R G., 147, 292 Comaroff, J., 180, 284, 292 conscious(ness), 19, 70, 77–79, 85–87, 90–92, 94, 101, 142, 162, 169, 199, 209, 212, 218–219, 235, 275–276, 286 see also: unconscious(ness) Counselling, Advice, Mediation, Psychotherapy, Advocacy Guidance (CAMP), 31 countertransference, 76–77, 80, 118–119, 151, 169, 276 see also: transference Crapanzano, V., 84, 292 Cremerius, J., 14–15, 59–60, 272, 292 Crichton-Brown, Sir J., 268, 292 Cross-National Collaborative Group, 270, 292 Csordas, T J., 79, 225, 292 Danaher, G., 267, 304 Das, V., 180, 298 De Martino, R., 79, 85, 277, 294 Deleuze, G., 287, 292 Deluz, A., 280, 296 Desjarlais, R R., 273–274, 292 Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM), 45–46, 50–51, 284 disposition(s), 4–10, 54, 60–61, 64, 68, 100, 102, 113, 116, 126, 139, 146–147, 154, 173–174, 184–185, 188, 199–200, 202, 236, 240–241, 252, 254, 256 Dougherty, J W D., 3, 292 Dow, J., 203, 273, 292 Durkheim, E., 81, 226–227, 292 ego, 19, 70, 86, 88–93, 209, 257, 277, 286 super, 209, 286 Ehernwald, J., 194, 292 Ellenberger, H., 28, 293 Evans-Pritchard, E P., 79, 86, 127, 147, 176, 226–227, 278, 284, 286, 293 Ewart, E., 73, 293 Eysenck, H J., 47, 50, 293 Falzeder, E., 272, 293 fantasy, 68, 70, 75, 97, 117, 149, 151, 165, 170, 187, 189–190, 192–194, 218, 233 Fernandez, J., 84, 293 Ferris, P., 277, 283, 293 Fiedler, F., 47, 293 Figlio, K., 15, 267, 293 Fornagy, P., 272, 302 Forrester, J., 28, 117, 269, 293 Foster, G M., 175–176, 293 Foucault, M., 51, 117, 293 Fox, R., 182–184, 266, 294 Frank, D., 189, 199, 294 INDEX 111 711 10 211 30 911 Frank, J B., 189, 199, 294 Frattoroli, J., 15, 294 Freud, A., 213 Freud, S., 13, 15, 18–19, 26–28, 33, 36, 40, 44, 48, 50–51, 57–58, 70, 74, 84, 86, 88–91, 94–95, 104–105, 112–113, 122, 134, 140–143, 147–151, 154, 204–205, 207–210, 215–220, 233–235, 238, 257–258, 264–265, 271, 276–277, 279, 281–283, 286–287, 294 Fromm, E., 32, 79, 85, 140–141, 148, 207, 215–219, 277, 283, 286, 294 Frosh, S., 280, 295 Furedi, F., 10, 26, 30–32, 244–245, 269, 289, 295 Gabbard, G O., 28, 295 Gabbard, K., 28, 295 Gallop, J., 283, 295 Gardner, F., 120, 295 Garza-Guerrero, C., 15–16, 295 Geer, B., 11, 16–17, 185, 255, 266, 291 Gellner, E., 9–10, 21, 26, 48, 81, 215–216, 218, 242–244, 268, 295 Giddens, A., 246, 295 Gluckman, M., 81, 280, 295 Goffman, E., 3, 5, 56, 106, 295 Goody, J R., 81–82, 295 Gorer, G., 115–116, 280, 295 Gray, A., 275, 295 Grunbaum, A., 31, 48, 296 Guattari, F., 287, 292 Gusterson, H., 3, 6, 12, 185, 285, 296 habitus, 7–8, 14, 54, 146, 252 Halmos, P., 31, 216, 248, 296 Haynal, A., 88, 296 Heald, S., 29, 280, 296 Heelas, P., 3, 10, 185, 225, 243–244, 296 Heimann, P., 59, 77, 296 Helman, C., 98, 296 Herdt, G., 185, 199, 296 Hillman, J., 100, 280, 296 Hinnels, J R., 278, 301 309 Hinshelwood, R D., 125, 128–129, 267, 296 Hinton, L., 274, 296 Hobart, M., 147, 296 Holmes, J., 27, 100, 269, 280, 296 Horney, K., 18, 32, 140, 215, 296 Horton, R., 178, 296 Hoshmand, L T., 273, 297 Houseman, M and Severi, C., 82–83, 194, 297 Hsu, E., 102, 109–112, 127, 179, 273–274, 279, 283–285, 297 Huber, M T., 84, 293 Hubert, H., 12, 297 Hughes, E C., 11, 16–17, 185, 255, 266, 291 Hutton, R., 225, 297 id, 70, 91, 209, 287 imagination cultural, 32 psychoanalytic, 13, 85, 124, 213 psychodynamic, 100, 102, 118, 120, 181, 202, 247 therapeutic, 64, 139, 200, 281 Institute of Psychoanalysis, 18, 20–21, 27, 36–37, 39–40, 43, 49, 56, 104, 136, 143–144, 154, 213, 261, 270–271, 286 see also: British Psychoanalytic Society Institute of Psychoanalysts, 18, 20–21, 27, 36–37, 39–40, 43, 49, 56, 104, 136, 143–144, 154, 213, 261, 270–271, 286 International Psychoanalytic Association (IPA), 20, 26, 36, 38, 60, 140, 143, 214–215, 272, 281 Jacobs, M., 27, 31, 232–240, 269, 288, 297 Jadhav, S., 165, 299 Jenkins, R., 7, 297 Jimenez, J P., 15, 267, 291 Johnson, F A., 273, 305 Johnson, S M., 283, 297 310 111 10 711 20 511 311 911 INDEX Jones, E., 19, 27, 140–143, 214–215, 217–218, 257, 277, 297 Jordan, J F., 15, 267, 291 Jung, C G., 18, 26, 40, 43–44, 58, 73, 89–90, 140, 144, 230, 233, 239, 264–265, 268, 282–283 Kapferer, B., 12, 297 Kardiner, A., 3, 29, 282, 298 Kareem, J., 153, 299 Katz, J., 183–184, 266, 298 Katz, R., 274, 298 Kernberg, O., 15–16, 59, 113, 116, 279, 298 Kirsner, D., 21, 279, 298 Klein, M., 18, 77–78, 104, 141, 151, 213, 230, 264–265, 276–277, 298 Kleinian therapy, 19–20, 118, 133–134, 230, 263–265, 267, 271, 287, Kleinman, A., 15, 48, 62–63, 98, 153, 180, 194, 203, 273–274, 279, 284–285, 296, 298 Laderman, C., 99, 275, 278, 298 La Fontaine, J S., 199, 298 Lambek, M., 84–85, 275, 298 Larson, M S., 225, 298–299 Lasch, C., 26, 216, 247, 299 Lave, J., 8, 266–267, 291, 299 Leach, E R., 273, 280, 299 Levine, F J., 16, 299 Levi-Strauss, C., 282, 299 Lewis, G., 275, 299 Liberman, B L., 194, 299 Lincoln Centre, 20, 103, 261, 263, 265, 270–271, 281, 289 Lipsedge, M., 32, 224, 253, 299 Little, M., 77, 222, 299 Littlewood, R., 32, 48, 88, 153, 165, 224, 242, 253, 273, 277, 280, 288–289, 299–300 Lock, M., 180, 284, 298, 300 Losche, D., 84, 300 Lousada, J., 15, 30, 45, 51–53, 300 Luborsky, L B., 47, 272, 300 Luborsky, S., 47, 272, 300 Lurhmann, T., 79, 96, 300 MacClancy, J., 14, 300 MacIntyre, A., 206, 300 Malcolm, J., 112, 279, 281, 300 Malinowski, B., 205, 300 Marcuse, H., 215, 218, 300 Marmor, J., 207, 273, 300 Masson J., 48, 149, 216, 300 Maudsley Hospital, 47, 50 Mauss, M., 12, 297 Mayer, L., 16, 300 McDougall, W., 268, 301 Mead, M., 3, 29, 290, 301 Mechanic, D., 99, 300–301 Michels, R., 16, 290 Miller, A., 219–220, 301 Mills, C W., 241, 301 Morgan-Jones, R., 57, 63, 278, 283, 290 Morris, B., 278, 301 Moskowitz, E., 29, 301 myth(s), 14, 51, 62–64, 85, 98, 203–206, 210–211, 213, 224–225, 230–232, 240, 244–245, 249, 251–256, 272, 278, 286 National Health Service (NHS), 22, 49, 51–52, 131, 181–182, 223 National Institute of Mental Health, 45 Needham, R., 14, 108, 278, 301 Nurge, E., 175–176, 301 object relations, 19, 144, 151–152, 216, 257–258, 264–265 Parkin, D., 11, 29, 288, 301 Peck, S., 32, 301 phantasy, 148, 150, 220, 238 Philips, A., 91, 301 Porter, R., 31–32, 50, 269–270, 278, 301 Portman Clinic, 27 Prata, G., 82, 303 INDEX 111 711 10 211 30 911 pre-training therapy, 13, 54, 56–61, 100, 118, 120, 126, 131, 133, 202, 252, 272 priest, 105, 140, 143, 236–237, 240, 278 Prince, R., 63, 302 projective identification, 78, 276 prophet, 105, 140, 240, 278 Pulver, S E., 285, 302 Raguram, R., 165, 299 Rapp, D., 28, 302 regression, 15, 107, 193, 207, 209, 267 repression, 15, 19, 94, 149, 151, 159, 197, 207, 209, 218–219, 234–235, 286 Richards, A., 185, 199, 302 Rieff, P., 34, 116, 302 ritual(s), 13, 62, 73, 81–83, 98, 104, 115, 127, 184, 205, 227, 245, 249, 252, 255, 273–275, 277, 284 secular, 81–82 Rivers, W H R., 29, 174, 269, 283, 302 Rivière, P., 73, 302 Roberts, G., 100, 296 Roberts, J., 81, 277, 302 Rose, N., 29, 302 Roth, A., 272, 302 Rudnytsky, P L., 277, 302 Russell, B., 29, 86, 302 Russell, D E H., 283, 303 Rustin, M., 6, 112, 117, 302 Rycroft, C., 94, 275–276, 303 Samuels, A., 16–17, 117, 152, 194–195, 216, 303 Schafer, R., 100, 303 Scheff, T., 82, 303 Scheper-Hughes, N., 284, 300 Schirato, T., 267, 304 Schultz, D P., 88, 303 Schultz, S E., 88, 303 Seijas, H., 175–176, 303 Selvini Palazzoli, M., 88, 303 311 Sennett, R., 10, 26, 216, 244, 289, 303 Sharma, U., 99–100, 275, 303 Sharp, L., 180, 284, 303 Shorter, E., 32–33, 46, 50–51, 270, 272, 303–304 Sinclair, S., 3–5, 9, 11, 17, 183, 185, 225, 254–255, 304 Skodol, A E., 47, 304 Skorupski, J., 82, 304 Smail, M., 247, 304 socialisation medical, 5, 182–183 professional, 2–4, 14, 61, 102, 124, 200, 202, 251, 254–255 psychoanalytic, 3, 7, 13, 146, 201, 252 Society for Analytical Psychology, 27, 40 Sperber, D., 232, 304 spiritual, 48, 178, 246, 274, 289 Spitzer, R L., 47, 50–51, 290, 304 Storr, A., 66, 68, 70–71, 150, 208, 225, 275–276, 286, 304 Strauss, A L., 11, 16–17, 185, 255, 266, 291 Suzuki, D T., 79, 85, 277, 294 Szasz, T S., 48, 304 talking cure, 27, 29, 30, 33, 268 Tavistock Clinic, 27–28, 40, 51, 53, 141, 236, 261 Torrey, E F., 194, 273, 304 traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), 109, 111, 279, 283 transference, 58, 68, 70–73, 75, 77, 80, 92, 117–118, 125–126, 131, 137, 151, 169, 211, 220, 258, 276, 278 see also: countertransference Turner, V., 73, 81–82, 199, 273–274, 283–284, 304 Tyler, S A., 3, 304 unconscious(ness), 19, 70, 74, 78, 80, 82, 85, 87–88, 91–92, 108, 110, 114, 117, 124–125, 137, 142, 159, 312 111 10 711 20 511 311 911 INDEX 169, 171, 188, 190, 196, 210–212, 217, 219–220, 235, 245, 247, 257–258, 264, 267, 275, 277, 286–287 see also: conscious(ness) United Kingdom Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP), 17–18, 22, 31, 34, 37, 39–41, 43, 56, 127, 135, 137, 258, 261–262, 269–271, 280–281 Valentine, M., 117, 133, 135, 281, 304 Van de Hart, O., 82, 304 Wallace, A., 184, 304 Webb, J., 267, 304 Weber, M., 43, 105, 240, 244, 275, 279, 289, 304 Webster, R., 48, 283, 305 Wenger, E., 8, 266, 299 Whan, M., 16, 305 Whiting, B., 177, 305 Whiting, R A., 82, 277, 305 Wienmann, J., 93, 305 Williams, J B W., 47, 304 Winnicott, D W., 18, 20–21, 77, 104, 151, 213, 264–265, 277, 305 witchcraft, 79, 127, 175–177, 179, 225, 284, 286, 288 Wittgenstein, L., 48, 305 Yalom, I D., 276, 305 Young, A., 174, 176–179, 305 Young, R., 41, 126–127, 129, 135, 215, 281, 305 Zatzick, D F., 273, 305 .. .THE MAKING OF PSYCHOTHERAPISTS AN ANTHROPOLOGICAL ANALYSIS JAMES DAVIES First published 2009 by Karnac Books Ltd 118 Finchley Road London NW3 5HT © James Davies The moral right of the author... instinct theory—e.g Freud, Ernest Jones, K Abraham), and the interpersonal psychotherapists (including the ‘Kleinians’ and the ‘Independents’ otherwise known as the ‘object relations’ ther- 20 THE MAKING. .. biography—hence the psychoanalytic mantra the child is the father of the man’ That these strivings are largely repressed does not mean that they cease to exist Rather they retain their dynamism and if not