skkn HOW TO HELP WEAK STUDENTS TO WRITE AN ESSAY EFFECTIVELY IN ENGLISH GRADE 11

SỞ GIÁO DỤC VÀ ĐÀO TẠO ĐỒNG NAI TRƯỜNG THPT NGUYỄN HỮU CẢNH Mã số: Title: HOW TO HELP WEAK STUDENTS TO WRITE AN ESSAY EFFECTIVELY IN ENGLISH GRADE 11 PART A NGHIỆM SÁNG KIẾN KINH REASONS FOR CHOOSING THE RESEARCH HOW TO TOand English in gradeHELP 11 consistsWEAK of reading, STUDENTS speaking, listening, writing WRITE ANskillESSAY EFFECTIVELY IN language focus Writing contains many different types such as writing letters, describing information from a chart, writing biography, writing ENGLISH GRADE 11 an essay and so on When writing an essay with the given topic, our students are nervous because almost of them are weak and their vocabulary, grammar, structures or language knowledge and writing techniques are limited They don’t know how to begin, make an outline, provide evidence to support or develop the point Therefore, they have many difficulties in writing thựcno hiện: THỊ THƠM In order that theNgười students longerNGUYỄN fear and hate writing an essay, have Lĩnh vực nghiên cứu: some techniques for writing and they feel easier to write, I, teacher of English at - Quản lý giáo dục  high school, explain in a clear and direct way to teach, help them identify clearer - Phương pháp dạy học môn: English  aims for writing and develop writing skill effectively at high school In this assignment, I only focus on techniques that help me and other English teachers to teach and our students to learn how to write an essay effectively The Có đính kèm: Các sản phẩm khơng thề in SKKN above lead mePhần to choose the topic to help weak students to write an reasons Mô hình mềm  “How Phim ảnh  Hiện vật khác essay effectively in English grade 11” Năm học: 2011-2012 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 SƠ LƯỢC LÝ LỊCH KHOA HỌC I THÔNG TIN CHUNG VỀ CÁ NHÂN Họ tên: NGUYỄN THỊ THƠM Ngày tháng năm sinh: 12- 09 -1981 Nam, nữ: Nữ Địa chỉ: 962, tổ 29, khu phố 8, phường Long Bình - Biên Hịa - Đồng Nai Điện thoại: 061.3834289 (CQ)/ (NR); ĐTDĐ: 0984705649 E-mail: nguyenthithomav@yahoo.com.vn Chức vụ: Giáo viên Đơn vị công tác: Trường THPT Nguyễn Hữu Cảnh II TRÌNH ĐỘ ĐÀO TẠO - Học vị cao nhất: Đại học - Năm nhận bằng: 2003 - Chuyên ngành đào tạo: Anh Văn III KINH NGHIỆM KHOA HỌC - Lĩnh vực chun mơn có kinh nghiệm: Giảng dạy - Số năm có kinh nghiệm: - Các sáng kiến kinh nghiệm có năm gần đây: How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 Title: HOW TO HELP WEAK STUDENTS TO WRITE AN ESSAY EFFECTIVELY IN ENGLISH GRADE 11 PART A REASONS FOR CHOOSING THE RESEARCH English in grade 11 consists of reading, speaking, listening, writing and language focus Writing skill contains many different types such as writing letters, describing information from a chart, writing biography, writing an essay and so on When writing an essay with the given topic, our students are nervous because almost of them are weak and their vocabulary, grammar, structures or language knowledge and writing techniques are limited They don’t know how to begin, make an outline, provide evidence to support or develop the point Therefore, they have many difficulties in writing In order that the students no longer fear and hate writing an essay, have some techniques for writing and they feel easier to write, I, teacher of English at high school, explain in a clear and direct way to teach, help them identify clearer aims for writing and develop writing skill effectively at high school In this assignment, I only focus on techniques that help me and other English teachers to teach and our students to learn how to write an essay effectively The above reasons lead me to choose the topic “How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11” How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 PART B REAL SITUATION • Advantageous conditions Most of students and their parents comprehend the importance of learning English language at high school Some students are very interested in learning English Furthermore English is one of the subjects, which are compulsory in the final examination at high schools This will promote students to spend much time learning and practicing English • Difficulties Some students are not very interested in learning English; not concentrate on the lessons, especially in writing lesson The first reason is that most of them are lack of basic knowledge, lack of language knowledge as such grammar, vocabulary and structures The other important reason is that they not have writing techniques They don’t know how to begin, make an outline, provide evidence to support or develop the point Therefore, they have many difficulties in writing The students’ above difficulties make teachers lack time to apply different activities in teaching so as to motivate students’ activity and interest PART C WHAT I HAVE CARRIED OUT TO HELP WEAK STUDENTS IN WRITING In writing skill of English grade 11, there are available activities designed for teachers to teach students at high school However, most of my students are average and weak at learning English, especially at writing an essay with the given topic In order that students are well-motivated and have some basic techniques in writing an essay in English grade 11, some necessary ways I carry out in Writing to help students to write an essay effectively How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 To make my students know how to write an essay with the topic given in textbook effectively I adapt textbook to fit students’ low level by using many activities in Writing If we don’t design activities in writing skill, our students will have many difficulties in writing an essay and they will waste their time preparing ideas Especially, textbook adaptation should be applied flexibly in each particular class situation Here are some activities I use in teaching writing so that our students can write an essay effectively such as: At the pre-writing stage To prepare students for writing an essay effectively, I have some activities applied: - In each writing lesson, I tell students the aim of writing and deliver one focused topic based on textbook by writing the thesis statement of the topic on the board This step makes sure that every student knows what they are writing about One line of the thesis statement written on board reminds students that they should focus on this point but not others or can’t go off the topic Therefore, the writing is good - I give them more new structures and vocabulary This activity helps students to have some words, phrases and structures for writing - I give students a model essay From the model essay, I get students to read carefully, analyze it by answering a series of questions and identify the task related to the topic Giving sample writing and some ideas for some topics can enable students to base on to write effectively and remember the way to express language in writing From the model essay, I guide students to identify a thesis statement or introduction, a topic sentence for each paragraph, supporting details for each topic statement, a conclusion, the evidence for the meaning How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 At the while-writing - Making the detailed outline One of the most important activities which help students to write an essay effectively is making an outline under teacher’s control, organization and resource An outline of an essay can be very helpful because it helps make their essay more organized A careful plan will help their body paragraphs stay focused on the ideas in their thesis statement and it saves time for students Preparing an outline can take time, but when they are finished, they will be able to write the rough draft of their essay more quickly than if they didn’t have an outline • I ask students to work in groups or in pairs to give the detailed outline This step encourages students to interact with each other by giving and getting information about the thesis statement This is the best way to collect ideas from students under my control so that the students can’t go off the topic and reduce the stress in the classroom • I call the leader of each group to present their opinions on the thesis statement; I take note on the board in an outline form When I take note on the board, the whole class can keep up with the flow of ideas Besides, students can avoid mispronunciation from the group leaders in speaking Strong, average and weak students can base on the outline and develop the essay It is necessary that before writing, I get students to pay attention to clarity by giving transition words, to punctuation and spelling I remind students to write all the sentences begin with capital letters, punctuation marks such as periods at the end of each sentence Furthermore, I explain to students that an essay is a combination of paragraphs It will be easier to start writing with a paragraph How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 - Writing In this step, I ask them to follow the sample writing, base on some cues to write on demand At the Post-writing - After they have finished their writing, I make students find out mistakes and get the whole class to correct them If they can’t give correct answers, I give suggested answers - If possible, I get students to present their writing in speaking individually, in pairs or in groups PART D SOLVE THE PROBLEM In this part, I give the practice in adapting materials in some units to make writing an essay easier and more suitable for students’ low level at high school I have designed some units of the 11 th form textbook such as unit 1, unit 8, unit 12 and unit 13 Unit 1: FRIENDSHIP D – WRIRING Aim: By the end of the lesson, Ss will be able to write about a friend, real or imaginary, using the words and expressions that they have learned in previous lessons I WARM UP: Expending sentence I write the word “RFIDEN” on the blackboard then I ask students to reorder and expand it by adding at the beginning or the end of what is already written to make a meaningful sentence “FRIEND” I model: “I like a friend.” Then I get some volunteers to expand the sentence in front of the whole class I write on the blackboard The student reads the last sentence is the winner How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 Suggested answer: I like a friend who is friendly I like a friend who is friendly and helpful ………………………………………………… Then I have them guess the topic to write I introduce the topic that they are going to write a friend, real or imaginary II Pre-writing: Activity 1: Comprehension questions I give sample writing and ask students to read the passage describing a person I get students to work in groups of four to analyze the passage by answering some questions *Sample: Of all my classmates, I like Ha the best She is 16 She lives in Binh Son village I met her in a school holiday to Mui Ne when we were in secondary school She is a pretty girl with short hair She is tall She has an oval face Her eyes are black and clear She looks more beautiful in Ao Dai Ha is honest, sincere and helpful I learn honesty and helpfulness from her I like her because she teaches me a lot of things I feel safe to be with her I hope that we will be friends forever I give them some cues Name: What’s her name? Age: How old is she? Home address: Where does she live? Place to meet: When and where did you meet her? Character: How is she? Appearance: What does she look like? What’s she like? What you learn from her: What you learn from her? Reason why you like her: Why you like her? How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 When students work in groups, I go around to help them if necessary Then I check their understanding by asking them to answer the above questions From the sample writing, I get the whole class to recognize the ways of expressing the ideas; three parts of the essay: Introduction, Body and Conclusion; some necessary structures and the tenses III While- writing Activity 1: Making an outline I guide students to identify a thesis statement or introduction, a topic sentence for each paragraph, supporting details for each topic statement, a conclusion, the evidence for the meaning Then I ask them to make an outline by completing the table below introduction body - The topic sentence - name, age, sex: - appearance: - personalities: - Reason why you like her: - writer’s feelings conclusion Suggested answer - The topic sentence: Of all my classmates, I like Ha the best introduction body - name, age, sex: Ha - appearance: tall, short hair, oval face, black and clear eyes - personalities: honest, sincere and helpful - reason why you like her: because she teaches me a lot of things and I feel safe to be with her - writer’s feelings: I hope that we will be friends forever conclusion How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 Activity 2: Writing a description: From the above outline, I can help students to describe a friend, real or imaginary without going off the topic Some cues: *Language: My best friend is She is 16 She lives in I met her in a school holiday to Mui Ne when we were in secondary school / We’ve studied in the same class since secondary school She is a pretty girl She is tall She is honest and helpful I like her because she For good students, they can write themselves about their friends However, for weak students, I take some common images so that they can write in groups of four I move around to control and give help with vocabulary When they have finished, I collect their writing IV Post-writing: peer correction - I exchange their writing with another student for peer correction - I go around and collect mistakes and errors - I collect some writings for quick feedback - I write students’ typical errors on the board and elicit self and peer correction I provide correction only when they are not able to correct the errors - Finally, I provide general comments on the writings After correcting mistakes, if I have the time, I add an activity called: “Listening: describing appearances and characteristics” I give each student a sheet of paper Then I call one student to sit in front of the class This one describes a person and the rest draw the person being described 10 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 -I am always eager to welcome the festival /I don’t like the festival because IV.POST- WRITING -The first finishing groups give their writing on the board -I give corrections and comments -I give some suggestions -Students study the description to report I call on some groups to present their writing A leader tells about a festival they have chosen to write in front of the whole class I remind others to listen to and ask them to put some questions for that group or I ask some other students to answer some questions to check their understanding or concentration Unit 12: THE ASIAN GAMES part D Writing Aims: By the end of the lesson, students will be able to describe the preparations for the coming Asian Games I.WARM UP I ask students to close their book Then I write seven words with jumbled letters on the board and tell them to work in groups in order to reorder to make correct words Liudb, deagrpu, dneiw, quiep, vtiserade, criutre, oldh After they have finished, I give the answers for them to check: Build, Upgrade, Widen, Equip, Advertise, Recruit, Hold I lead in the lesson by asking: “What are these words related to?” and then I say: “we are going to describe the preparations for the Games” II.PRE - WRITING : Activity 1: Pre- teaching Vocabulary: I ask Ss to work in pairs to match a word in A with a line in B to find out the meaning of the new words To upgrade (v) a to advertise sth in order to make it popular To promote (v) b to find new people to join an organization 15 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 To recruit (v) c to change something so that it is of a higher standard Key: 1-c 2- a 3- b Checking vocabulary: I tell them to give Vietnamese equivalents This activity helps students to have some words, phrases and structures related to the topic of the lesson Activity 2: Matching activity I have them work in pairs to match the verbs in column A with the noun phrases in column B A 1.build upgrade 3.widen 4.equip 5.advertise 6.recruit B a the training areas b one more National Stadium c people to serve the Games d the National Sports Centers e hotels with modern facilities f a competition to choose an official song 7.hold g sports – places – dates and time Before doing the task, I get them to guess the meaning of the verbs, then I explain their meaning I let them work in pairs to combine At the same time, I go around to help if necessary After they finish, I check in front of the whole class Suggested answers: –b Build one more National Stadium 2- d Upgrade the National Sports Centers 3- a Widen the training areas 4-e Equip hotels with modern facilities 5-g Advertise sports – places – dates and time 6-c Recruit people to serve the Games 7-f Hold a competition to choose an official song Activity 3: Questions and answers 16 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 I get them to open their book and I give a situation that suppose Vietnam is going to hold the Asian Games What will we have to to prepare for the Games? I give students a series of questions The students answer the questions in full sentences Before answering, I make them look at some cues in the book (page 143) Questions Answers What will you (your company) first? Why will we have to upgrade the National Sports Centres and stadiums? What about the training areas and the roads? What will we have to equip the hotels and guests houses with? What for? Which forms of mass media will be used to advertise all the preparations for the Games? Who will you recruit to serve the games? What competition will we have to hold? Some suggested: We’ll have to build one more National Stadium and some sports buildings and car parks Because they are not in good condition We will widen the training areas the roads and the sports buildings We will have to equip the hotels and guests houses with modern facilities to welcome foreign athletes and visitors The radio and television will be used for advertising We should recruit university teachers and students with good English 17 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 We should hold a competition to choose an official song for welcoming Asian Games III WHILE-WRITING Activity 1: Making the detailed outline From the above answers, I get students to make the detailed outline: I Introduction- Thesis Statement: Vietnam is going to hold the coming Asian Games To meet the need of modern facilities for the Games, we will have a lot of things to II.Body Paragraph - build one more National Stadium and some sports buildings and car parks - upgrade the National Sports Centres and stadiums - widen the training areas the roads and the sports buildings - equip the hotels and guests houses with modern facilities – to welcome foreign athletes and visitors - promote and advertise all the preparations on the radio and television - recruit university teachers and students with good English - hold a competition to choose an official song for welcoming Asian Games III Conclusion: It is hoped that the good preparations will help our country receive good results, good regards from other countries To organize and connect specific evidence, I ask students to use: - some connectors such as First / Firstly / First of all…, And, Then , Finally ,One more important thing is that - conjunctions such as Because, so, Moreover – Further - structures: - need to be + pp = need + V-ing - have to + inf - tenses: future and simple present I get students to pay attention to clarity by giving transition words, to punctuation and spelling, remind them to write all the sentences begin with capital letters and explain to students that an essay is a combination of paragraphs Activity 2: Writing a composition 18 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 Then I ask students to write the essay basing on above cues to describe the preparations for the coming Asian Games in Vietnam Students may begin with: To prepare for the coming Asian Games, we will have a lot of things to First of all, we will build one more National Stadium and ………………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………………… IV POST-WRITING -The first finishing groups give their writing on the board -I give corrections and comments -I give some suggestions -Ss study the description to report In the textbook, unit 13 asks students to write about their collection, real or imaginary with some cues and there aren’t other activities In real situation, this is very difficult for my students to write because their vocabulary grammatical structures are limited Therefore, to help them to feel easier when writing, I have designed and given some activities from easy to difficult based on the previous skills such as reading, speaking and listening lessons English 11, Unit 13 HOBBIES PART D WRITING Aims: By the end of the lesson, students will be able to write about a collection I.WARM UP: I ask Ss to close their book and work in groups to find the words going with pictures: 19 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 I ask: - Do people collect something as a hobby? - Can you tell me something that they often collect? 20 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 10 Suggestion: stickers, animals, bottle caps, pens, toy cars, old money, stamps, pencils, key rings, 10 coins - I introduce the lesson that the students are going to write about their real or imaginary collection II PRE – WRITING * Vocabulary First, I provide them with some new phrases - be crazy about (exp) ~ very interested in - provide S.O with ST( context): Forests provide us with wood - enable S O to ST (exp) : Her good English enabled her to get a good job at a foreign company - feel like doing st~ fancy doing st ( synonym) * Comprehension questions 21 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 I give them a passage as sample writing Then, I ask them to work in pairs to read it and answer some given questions in full sentences Sample writing Minh has a modest stamp collection He buys some from the post office He also asks his friends to give him their discarded envelops Besides, he exchanges stamps with other stamp collectors in his club He classifies the stamps into categories: animals, plants, people, and landscapes He keeps them in a small album He still remembers the day when he first saw a stamp of a landscape That was when he was The stamp was so beautiful that he decided to keep it and collected more He told that to his mother and she helped him with an album, which he is still keeping Keeping and watching the stamps really make him relax after hard work He will continue to make his collection richer and richer, and give it to his children in the future Questions: What is Minh’s hobby? How does he collect his stamps? How does he classify them? When did he start his collection? Where does he keep his stamps? Why does he collect them? What does he plan to next? After that, I check their understanding by calling on some pairs to ask and answer the questions I get the whole class to pay attention to and give feedback Suggested answers: Minh’s hobby is collecting stamps He buys them, asks his friends to give them and exchanges them He classifies the stamps into categories He started his collection when he was 22 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 He keeps in album Because keeping and watching the stamps really make him relax after hard work He continues to collect, and will give his collection to his children in the future III WHILE-WRITING ACTIVITY Write the outline following the guidelines I elicit ideas from students I ask them to divide the class into three groups to make an outline about some collections as directed Hobby Collecting stamps Collecting coins Collecting English songs When to ( last year, years collect ago, long ago ) How to (buy them, ask collect someone to give them, Where to exchange them ) ( in album, on shelves, keep How to in boxes, in a safe ) (into categories, organize countries, ages, Why to colors ) (to relax, to kill time, collect to entertain oneself…) Plan for the (continue to collect ) future After eliciting ideas from students under my control, I get the representative of each group to present their opinions on the thesis statement; I write on the board for cues At the same time, I give the immediate feedback and give mark, which would give students good motivation Suggested answers: 23 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 Collecting Collecting coins Collecting English Hobby When to stamps ( last year, years collect ago, long ago ) How to ( collect someone to give them, antique shop and the Internet buy them, songs ask -Buy exchange them ) from the -Down load from buy when travelling -Buy them from the in foreign countries -Inherit bookstores from -Brother, sister, Where to grandfather ( in album, on shelves, In grass box, bag friends give In disc, tapes, files: keep in boxes, in a safe ) put them into the bookcase categories, Classify coins into Classify them into How to (into organize countries, Why to colors ) or domestic ones,… rap, hip hop… (to relax, to kill time, Know more about Love English songs collect to entertain oneself) ages, old, new, foreign, kinds: pop, rock, the values of Help to learn history, culture of English Plan for the (continue to collect ) future many countries Continue collecting Continue collecting coins English songs ACTIVITY Writing From the ideas mentioned in activity and sample writing, I let students write about a collection Because most of my students are weak, I have them work in groups to write on the poster I go around to offer help I take notes of students’ mistakes for indirect correction IV POST-WRITNG 24 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 After they finish writing, I call on two groups to stick their poster on the blackboard I get the whole class to find out the mistakes and correct them I give feedback on Ss' work I point out some common mistakes made by students when doing this writing task Then I remind them to write corrected writing on their notebooks - I get students to present their writing in speaking in groups so that they can feel more self-confident in daily communication ************ To show textbook adaptation for fitting to fit my aims, my setting and most of all my students, I have made some changes by adding some activities, making small changes to the existing material in the textbook, removing a textbook from the lesson, replacing one activity with another related one which is more suitable to fit teaching and learning situation 25 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 PART E RESEARCH RESULT After applying above training method, I have students write some given topic based on the textbook and I get below result The first test Class 11A3 Quantity 44 11A5 46 The third test Class 11A3 11A5 Quantity 44 46 Good students (4%) Average 22 students (50%) Weak (bad) 20 students(46% ) students(5% ) 23 students (50%) 21students (45%) Good Average students (15%) 27 students (62%) students(20%) 31 students(66%) Weak (bad) 11 students (23%) students(14%) PART F CONCLUSION Teaching writing is a very important part of second language learning The ability to write in a second language clearly and efficiently contributes to the success of the learner in school and success later in every phase of life Therefore, it is essential that language teachers pay great attention to teaching writing With this aim, various writing activities such as those listed above can contribute a great deal to students in developing basic interactive skills necessary for life These activities make students more active in the learning process and at the same time make their learning more meaningful and fun for them In order to make the writing learning and teaching process a more motivating experience, instructors need to think carefully about a developing program, which mixes good teaching procedures with motivation from learners Bien Hoa City, May 25th, 2012 Teacher NGUYEN THI THOM REFERENCES 26 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 In Vietnamese Canh, Le Van 2004 Understanding Foreign language teaching method: NXB Dai Hoc Quoc Gia Chau, Nguyen Hai 2007 Giới thiệu giáo án Tiếng Anh 11 – Nhà xuất Hà Nội Hien, Nguyen Thi Thu 1999 Rhetorical patterns in English and Vietnamese essays written by Vietnamese students: a comparative study: Unpublished MA Dissertation CFL-VNU Nhung, Nguyen Thi Mai 2003 Motivation and factors affecting motivation in learning English writing of the freshmen at the department of English and Anglo-American Culture: Unpublished MA Dissertation CFL-VNU Tan, Hoang Van Sách giáo viên Tiếng Anh 11 – Nhà xuất Giáo Dục Thanh, Tran Thi Ai.Thiết kế giảng Tiếng Anh 11 – Nhà xuất Đại Học Quốc Gia Hà Nội In English Anita, P 1992 Writing in English, Book 1,2,3: Macmillan Publisher Byrne, D 1990 Teaching writing skills, Longman handbooks for language teacher: Longman group, ltd Gabi, D 1995 Essay writing for English Tests: Academic English Press Grabe, W & Kaplan, R 1998 Theory and practice of Writing: London and New York, Longman Heaton, J B.1989 Writing English test, Longman handbooks for language teacher: Longman group, ltd Leki, I 1976 Academic writing, techniques and task: New York, ST Martin’s press Ronal, V White 1989 Teaching Written English, Practical language teaching: Heinemann Tribble, C 1996 Writing Oxford: Oxford University Press 27 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 CỘNG HOÀ XÃ HỘI CHỦ NGHĨA VIỆT NAM SỞ GD&ĐT ĐỒNG NAI Độc lập - Tự - Hạnh phúc Trường THPT Nguyễn Hữu Cảnh Biên Hòa, ngày 25 tháng 05 năm 2012 PHIẾU NHẬN XÉT, ĐÁNH GIÁ SÁNG KIẾN KINH NGHIỆM Năm học: 2011-2012 ––––––––––––––––– Tên sáng kiến kinh nghiệm HOW TO HELP WEAK STUDENTS TO WRITE AN ESSAY EFFECTIVELY IN ENGLISH GRADE 11 Họ tên tác giả: NGUYỄN THỊ THƠM Chức vụ: Giáo viên Đơn vị (Tổ): Anh Văn Lĩnh vực: (Đánh dấu X vào ô tương ứng, ghi rõ tên môn lĩnh vực khác) - Quản lý giáo dục  - Phương pháp dạy học môn:  - Phương pháp giáo dục  - Lĩnh vực khác:  Sáng kiến kinh nghiệm triển khai áp dụng: Tại đơn vị  Trong Ngành  Tính - Có giải pháp hồn tồn - Có giải pháp cải tiến, đổi từ giải pháp có   Hiệu - Hoàn toàn triển khai áp dụng tồn ngành có hiệu cao  - Có tính cải tiến đổi từ giải pháp có triển khai áp dụng tồn ngành có hiệu cao  - Hồn toàn triển khai áp dụng đơn vị có hiệu cao  - Có tính cải tiến đổi từ giải pháp có triển khai áp dụng đơn vị có hiệu  Khả áp dụng - Cung cấp luận khoa học cho việc hoạch định đường lối, sách: Tốt  Khá  Đạt  - Đưa giải pháp khuyến nghị có khả ứng dụng thực tiễn, dễ thực dễ vào sống: Tốt  Khá  Đạt  - Đã áp dụng thực tế đạt hiệu có khả áp dụng đạt hiệu phạm vi rộng: Tốt  Khá  Đạt  28 How to help weak students to write an essay effectively in English grade 11 School year 2011 – 2012 XÁC NHẬN CỦA TỔ CHUYÊN MÔN THỦ TRƯỞNG ĐƠN VỊ LÝ THỊ THANH TÂM PHAN QUANG VINH 29