The Refutation of the Proponents of Perception 175 Therefore, this text does not teach that the eighteen elements in dreams equally exist, [not] even conventionally Rather, it teaches that the eighteen elements of waking and not waking not differ with regard to the abiding of objects—[some] true, [the others] false—for they are equally and only false When one awakens from the small sleep, the three of dreams not exist Similarly, when the element of qualitiesa becomes manifest due to an awakening from the great sleep of ignorant bewilderment, these three not polluted by superficial causes of errorb resemble those three of dreams in not existing Therefore, it is not reasonable [to assert] consciousness lacking an object.13 a chos kyi dbyings, dharmadh›tu b ’phral gyi ‘khrul rgyu 176 The Moon of Wisdom ,$*A?-0-=, $$-0-.%R?-.%-, J:A-*J?-%R%-$A-=/-.$$-0-$*A?, %-0R-=, ;=->J?-2.J/-m/-35%?-0-.%-, J-v