Information Management Resource Kit Module on Building Electronic Communities and Networks UNIT OPTIONS, CHOICES, TOOLS AND APPLICATIONS LESSON OVERVIEW OF TECHNICAL OPTIONS NOTE Please note that this PDF version does not have the interactive features offered through the IMARK courseware such as exercises with feedback, pop-ups, animations etc We recommend that you take the lesson using the interactive courseware environment, and use the PDF version for printing the lesson and to use as a reference after you have completed the course © FAO, 2006 Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page Objectives At the end of this lesson, you will be able to: • distinguish the key features and peculiarities of interactive tools suitable for your online community; • identify strengths and limitations of e-mail based and web based tools; • identify strengths and limitations of synchronous and asynchronous tools; and • decide, in broad terms, which groups of tools are likely to be most appropriate for particular contexts Introduction In this lesson we will discuss the importance of assessing the technical options that are available to you for building an online community, and we will have a broad look at online community tools available, which – in order to simplify – we distinguish in two main groups: e-mail based and web based tools; and synchronous and asynchronous tools In this lesson we will iscuss In this if lesson we will home In this lesson we will iscuss Let’s explore key features, strengths and limitations… Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page The importance of technical choices The tools you choose for your online community will have an impact on the effectivness of your community and on the level of member participation The right tools will promote effective community building, the wrong ones can actively hinder it For example, choosing a tool which requires a high-bandwidth Internet connection and extended online time can mean that online interaction would be easier for community members from “resource rich” countries, where such access is more common Similarly, choosing tools which require a high level of skills from users will put the less technically competent members of the community at a disadvantage The importance of technical choices Make sure that your decisions about tools are driven by: • the needs of your target • the needs of your target audience, that is the audience, that is the communication and information communication and information flows your online community is flows your online community is intended to facilitate; intended to facilitate; and the context in which members the context in which members operate, that is the nature of operate, that is the nature of their Internet access, whether all their Internet access, whether all community members have the community members have the same level of access etc same level of access etc Let your audience’s needs and context drive the choice of technology; don’t let the technology drive the shape of the community Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page The importance of technical choices Short Answer In your opinion, what should be the main characteristics of the tools you choose for your online community? Please write your answer in the input box and press “Check Answer” Main groups of online community tools As we said, the main types of online community tools can be described using two main aggregations: • e-mail based vs web based tools; and • synchronous vs asynchronous tools Before we explore these categories in detail, we must say that since technology is constantly evolving, these tools and categories are not static One result of this constant evolution is convergence, the “coming together” of different tools and technologies For example, in the past, mobile phones and personal computers were separate technologies which were used to perform different tasks Now, some mobile phones can be used to access the Internet as well as for making phone calls Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page E-mail based tools vs web based tools They are often called “push” technologies, because they push the content directly to users @ USER in f E-mail based tools Tools such as e-mail itself, listservs, enewsletters and site update alerts deliver information and communications straight to users or m at io n Let’s have a look at the main features of e-mail based and web based tools Web based tools Tools such as portals, online databases, forum and blogs require the user to go to a Web site to look for information, or to perform a specific task USER They are often called “pull” technologies, because you need to pull users to your site in order for them to access the content E-mail based tools vs web based tools E-mail is the best known example of pushing information into the users’ view This application brings the information directly to the users, rather than they having to fetch it themselves Publishing information on a web page is the opposite It is available to the users but it is not delivered to them, and it requires willingness on their part not to ignore it Push and pull technologies are often used to support each other For example, e-mail alerts (push) can drive users to a Web site (pull); mailing lists (push) can be managed via a web interface (pull) Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page E-mail based tools vs web based tools This “push/pull” distinction is not restricted to the world of electronic communications Traditional knowledge communities have always been confronted with the challenge of opting for direct or indirect delivery, or a combination of both The choice of e-mail/web and push/pull technologies will ultimately depend on your audience’s needs and specific context The following sections explore some general points about which tools work well, and which less well, in particular contexts E-mail based tools vs web based tools Example of push/pull technologies in a traditional community • in online communities you can make direct deliver using e-mail, indirect deliver trough web pages, and a combination of both in a mailing list archive on a web page; • in a traditional knowledge community, such as an academic one, you can make direct deliver using correspondence or meetings, indirect deliver trough journals, and a combination of both trough transactions and letter publishing Community Direct delivery (push) Indirect delivery (pull) Combination Online Electronic Mail Web Page Mailing list archive on Web page Academic Correspondence, meetings Journal Transactions, letter publishing Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page E-mail based tools Let’s see in detail the characteristics of most common e-mail based tools Electronic mail was the first practical Internet application, and it is still the most important and widespread An online community may exist and flourish solely on the basis of electronic mail services, isolated from the world of web pages and instant messaging, but no online community could survive in isolation from electronic mail Electronic mail messages are the building blocks of online communities and networks, because they allow and foster interaction in a easy, fast and economic way E-mail based tools The main e-mail based tools are: • e-mail itself, used to communicate one-to-one by community members, or through multiple-address messages, using “carbon copies”, “blind copies” or other multiple addressing features available; • mailing lists, managed with the help of dedicated programs that provide administrative functions as well as message forwarding to all members of the list and archiving; • newsletters, sent to all addresses on a subscriber list, are used to provide information focused on a specific topic and to promote and support content published online; and • automated mail alerts, commonly used to inform the users when web pages are modified or a new page is added to a Web site Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page E-mail based tools STRENGTHS E-mail based tools strengths are the following: • flexibility, since it’s not necessary to be online at the same • flexibility, since it’s not necessary to be online at the same time, users with limited time don’t have to struggle to schedule time, users with limited time don’t have to struggle to schedule times to communicate with other users; times to communicate with other users; • immediacy, near real-time communication is possible if all • immediacy, near real-time communication is possible if all parties are able to be online at the same time; parties are able to be online at the same time; • capability of delivering information automatically to users; • capability of delivering information automatically to users; • cost-effectiveness: users are not required to be connected to • cost-effectiveness: users are not required to be connected to the Internet all the time They can download mail and disconnect the Internet all the time They can download mail and disconnect before reading and composing messages; and before reading and composing messages; and • accessibility, e-mail based tools not require the use of high• accessibility, e-mail based tools not require the use of highend equipment end equipment E-mail based tools In your opinion which are the weak points of e-mail based tools? Connectivity costs Speed and quality of access Need to organize and keep track of messages Security risks Please select the answers of your choice (2 or more) and press Check Answer Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page E-mail based tools WEAKNESSES E-mail based tools weaknesses are the following: • the “push” aspect of e-mail is a strength, but can also be a • the “push” aspect of e-mail is a strength, but can also be a weakness E-mail requires a relatively high level of effort from weakness E-mail requires a relatively high level of effort from users, they need to decide which messages are relevant and users, they need to decide which messages are relevant and manage and organize them Because it is so easy to push manage and organize them Because it is so easy to push messages out, users may be faced with mountains of useless and messages out, users may be faced with mountains of useless and unwanted information, and overlook messages which are both unwanted information, and overlook messages which are both useful and wanted; and useful and wanted; and • e-mail based communication is, in general, quite insecure It is • e-mail based communication is, in general, quite insecure It is possible for messages to be intercepted and read by other parties possible for messages to be intercepted and read by other parties It is possible to encrypt messages, but this poses an additional It is possible to encrypt messages, but this poses an additional burden on the user burden on the user Web based tools Let’s now explore web based tools The Web is very good for storing, finding and delivering information, far better than offline technologies like e-mail Some common web based tools for online communities are: • ordinary web pages; • web based discussion forums; • online directories; • tools which allow the development of Web sites directly from a web browser and with no knowledge of HTML (blogs, wikis, content management systems); • scheduling tools such as calendars; and • online decision support tools And many other tools derived from them Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page Web based tools STRENGTHS Web based tools are good for: • document storage and delivery; • archiving; • collaborative work; • dissemination; • delivering multiple/multimedia formats; and • security See next slides to learn more about these strong points Web based tools Document storage and delivery It would be difficult to build an online community just by publishing static documents on a Web site; the interactivity aspect of communal action and learning would be lacking or poorly served At the same time, communities are likely to produce bodies of knowledge that are best kept in the form of “documents” The Web is very effective for storing, ordering, indexing and delivering documents, and can be an essential support asset for mature online communities, even those based primarily on electronic mail tools Archiving The Web’s capacity to interact with other programs makes it a very effective way to maintain archives, in particular electronic mail archives Again, the Web offers an important support asset for e-mail-based communities, adding value to the exchanges that took place in the past by making them accessible today Mail archives can constitute important bodies of knowledge As in the case of documentation, the Web provides us with the tools to index, search and order archive items in useful ways (for example, by threading discussions, making them easy to follow later) Collaborative work A Web site is like a meeting point which users come to in their own time, and are met by a familiar environment which they share in common Because of the Web’s ability to deliver practically any computer functionality to remote users, it is a very effective tool for collaborative work Users may be presented with tools that allow them to modify a database, react to existing items of information, edit documents already in storage, and so on Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page 10 Web based tools Dissemination The Internet is still not quite as universal as television, but it is a much more flexible and powerful tool for delivering specific information to diverse audiences In addition, it can accommodate a much wider variety of delivery formats Delivering multiple/multimedia formats Although e-mail can transport anything that can be contained in a computer file, it cannot compete with the ability of the Web to deliver non-textual information The modern web browser is not only very good at displaying richly formatted text, it is just as good at displaying pictures, playing videos and music, and running programs that interact with the user to generate complex objects in any format If there is a consistent need to share or deliver non-textual information, it can only be properly addressed by a Web site Security The Web provides very robust data security and protection, without the need for user intervention Using a technology called SSL (Secure Sockets Layer), data can be encrypted before being sent through the internet A Web site that can be made secure without burdening the user has a definite advantage over regular e-mail Web based tools WEAKNESSES The weak points of these kind of tools are: • connectivity costs: working with content stored in a Web site requires that users remain online for the entire time Where connectivity costs are high, heavy use of web based tools is not appropriate; and • speed and quality of access: even if cost is not a major issue, web based tools may be extremely slow and cumbersome to use if users are dependent on poor quality or slow connections In both cases, making extensive use of web based tools may foster inequalities across your online community by giving advantage to members with high-level access, and placing obstacles in the face of members from resource poor contexts Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page 11 Convergence While the broad aggregations of tool previously described are useful to have an idea of what is available, you should always take into account the phenomenon of convergence, which has resulted in an increasing number of tools being available via a web interface E-mail is the most notable example: while it remains an independent service that can exist separately from the Web, the fact is that today most e-mail is read through the Web Web mail has opened the world of e-mail to millions of users, many of whom are in developing countries and rely on Internet cafés for access Convergence Accessing Market Information by Mobile Phone Convergence is an important concept for those working in agriculture and rural development As you will see in the following examples, the compatibility between different ICTs (such as e-mail and mobile phones) offers possibilities for bridging the ‘communication gap’ in areas where telecommunications infrastructure is weak Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page 12 Convergence Accessing Market Information by Mobile Phone The Kenya Agricultural Commodity Exchange (KACE) Limited has developed a Market Information System designed to help farmers, especially smallholder poor farmers in remote rural areas, to access better markets and prices for their produce As part of this, KACE has partnered with a mobile phone company to provide a service where people can access market information like commodity prices in different markets, who is buying or selling what commodity, at what prices, where and when, as well as access extension messages, using mobile phones and Short Messaging Service (SMS) This information service is made possible by combining several ICTs: computer databases, the Internet, and mobile phones A similar service exists in Uganda In 1999, the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) established a National Market Information Service in Uganda This service collects market data on 19 different agricultural commodities from 19 market centres across the country on a weekly basis, and from the country’s main wholesale markets on a daily basis The information is processed, compiled in databases, and disseminated through various radio stations, national newspapers and by e-mail and fax to major trading companies, government departments, agricultural development agencies and famine early warning agencies Since 2003, the National Agricultural Advisory Services in Uganda has established localised market information services in a pilot project These services are designed to meet the information needs of grassroots agricultural actors, especially local farmers and small-scale traders Data on prices, traded volumes, market flow, growing conditions and other relevant information is collected from villages and market centres in several districts and, together with relevant national and regional information, is disseminated in local languages by local FM radio stations The projects can receive and disseminate instant reports through SMS on changing market prices Find out more: http://www.foodnet.cgiar.org Synchronous vs Asynchronous tools Let’s now have a look at the other group of technical options, exploring the main features of synchronous and asynchronous tools Synchronous tools Tools such as instant messengers, Internet Relay Chat (IRC), and virtual whiteboards require the parties who are communicating to be online at the same time, just as both parties to a telephone call Asynchronous tools Tools such as e-mail and web based discussion forums not require people who are communicating to be connected at the same time This kind of communication, just as postal letters do, allow a “conversation” to be spread out across time Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page 13 Asynchronous tools The most common asynchronous tools are: • e-mail based tools; and • web based tools, such as web based discussion forums and bulletin boards These tools and their main strengths and limitations are outlined next Synchronous tools Common synchronous tools for online communities are: • instant messengers and IRC, tools which allow people to have text-based conversations online in real time (some tools also allow the exchange of documents and graphics, and even the holding of “voice” conversations); • virtual conferencing programs, which include tools such as whiteboards and other shared applications, allow all participants in the online conference to see the same screen live at the same time; and • online video conferencing tools, which use the Internet to translate live sound and images Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page 14 Synchronous tools STRENGTHS The most obvious advantage of synchronous communications is immediacy and the ability to sustain interpersonal and group “conversations” It is the closest approximation to meeting someone or a group of people face-to-face Tools with voice services are in this respect even better, and cheaper, than the telephone Furthermore, this kind of tool is particularly good for: • quick consultations and decisions; and • providing a useful supplement to asynchronous tools (for example, documents can be distributed to a group by e-mail – and quick consultations on changes done using synchronous tools) Synchronous tools WEAKNESSES • The fact that these tools require users to be simultaneously connected is a weakness in terms of costs (because online time is costly) and fruition (because participants are spread out across time zones) • tools which rely on the use of graphics or video may be inaccessible to users with poor bandwidth; • text-based tools can place non-native speakers and people who type slowly at a disadvantage; • our availability status needs to be advertised for colleagues to contact us, resulting in a trade-off against our privacy (this means for example, that we are granting others the ability to keep track of our working or waking hours, and of how often we are at our desk) • synchronous tools allow little time for reflection and for editing of what is written (unlike e-mail messages which we can write, edit, and think about before sending) Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page 15 Synchronous tools These pairs of statements relate to the strengths and weaknesses of types of tool Match each statement on the left with a statement on the right a Problematic for users with poor or limited connectivity A strength of e-mail based tools Generally less secure than web based tools A limitation of synchronous tools Good for quick consultations and decision making A limitation of e-mail based tools Allow users to reflect on and edit messages before sending them A strength of synchronous tools Click on each option, drag it and drop it in the corresponding box When you have finished, click on the Check Answer button Change is the only constant Technological changes cannot be predicted, but we can prepare for them by adopting tools that will not tie us too tightly to any particular tool, technology or standard Even if we cannot predict exactly what new technologies will be developed and how existing tools will evolve, there are certain broad trends which we can bear in mind in our planning One trend, previously mentioned, is that Internet tools are tending to evolve towards convergence Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page 16 Summary The tools you choose for your online community can actively help or hinder your community interaction Make sure that your community’s needs drive your choice of tools – not the other way round Tools can generally be grouped into e-mail based (“push” technologies) and web based (“pull” technologies) tools, and into synchronous and asynchronous tools If you want to learn more… Synchronous vs Asynchronous Interaction http://www.webcrossing.com/WebX?50@209.KKfVaUbGsAZ.3@.f6ede4f Synchronous-Asynchronous http://mitpress2.mit.edu/e-books/City_of_Bits/Electronic_Agoras/SynchronousAsynchronous.html Synchronous and Asynchronous Communication Tools http://www.centeronline.org/knowledge/article.cfm?ID=2587 Electronic Agoras http://mitpress2.mit.edu/e-books/City_of_Bits/Electronic_Agoras/index.html What types of virtual communities can I build and what tools are available? http://www.fullcirc.com/community/communitytypes.htm Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page 17 ... tools such as calendars; and • online decision support tools And many other tools derived from them Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page Web based tools. .. audience’s needs and context drive the choice of technology; don’t let the technology drive the shape of the community Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options... and limitations… Options, Choices, Tools and Applications - Overview of technical options - page The importance of technical choices The tools you choose for your online community will have an